Amos Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Amos 5:21–24

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

21“I hate, I despise your feasts! I cannot stand the stench of your solemn assemblies. 22Even though you offer Me burnt offerings and grain offerings, I will not accept them; for your peace offerings of fattened cattle I will have no regard. 23Take away from Me the noise of your songs! I will not listen to the music of your harps. 24But let justice roll on like a river, and righteousness like an ever-flowing stream.

What the first hearers heard

To worshippers at Bethel or Gilgal this was shocking, possibly blasphemous. Festivals were where Israel was surest of God's favour. People sacrificed generously, sang and feasted, and believed God was pleased and on their side. Amos speaks in God's own voice and says the opposite: I hate it. I refuse it. I will not take it in.

Three things would have hit home:

  • This was their own worship, as commanded. Amos is not attacking Baal worship. He is attacking the festivals of Israel's God, held with all the proper sacrifices (5:22 lists burnt offerings, grain offerings and fattened peace offerings).
  • The covenant curse was in force. 'I will not smell' quoted the curse list Israel knew (Lev 26:31), whose next lines threaten ruined cities and exile. That is where Amos ends up: "I will send you into exile beyond Damascus" (5:27).
  • The cause was injustice, not bad ritual. The surrounding verses make the link explicit. Those who crush the poor, take bribes and push aside the needy in the gate (5:11–12) cannot buy God's favour on holy days. God wants justice flowing like a river that never dries up (5:24). The festival and the courtroom were not separate areas of life. A people who corrupted the gate had emptied the altar of meaning.

For a covenant people this was a warning, not a lecture on spirituality. The relationship that the festivals were meant to celebrate had been broken by how Israel treated its own members, and the worship could not hide that.

From the study of Amos 5:21.

Verse by verse

  1. 21“I hate, I despise your feasts! I cannot stand the stench of your solemn assemblies.

    "I have come to hate them, I reject them: your pilgrim festivals! And I will not breathe in the smoke of your offerings or take any pleasure in your holy days of assembly."

    God speaks here in the first person, and he starts with two blunt verbs and no 'and' between them: I hate, I reject. The perfect tense marks a settled verdict, not a passing mood. What he rejects is not foreign worship or a party. It is the great pilgrimage festivals of Israel's own calendar. The crowds came up to the sanctuaries at Bethel, Gilgal and Beersheba with animals for sacrifice, wine and music. There was the closing 'assembly', a holy day when work stopped and the whole people stood before God. Twice God says 'your': your feasts, your assemblies. The law had called them the LORD's appointed times, and here they are handed back to their owners.

    The second line uses the oldest picture of sacrifice. The smoke of the altar rises, and God 'smells the pleasing aroma' and accepts it. God now says he will not smell it. The smoke may be as fragrant as ever, but he refuses to breathe it in. The words come straight from the covenant curse in Leviticus 26:31 ("I will not smell your pleasing aromas"). Anyone who knew that text would hear that the curse has started.

    The verse also carries a hard play on words. Israel has 'hated' the one who speaks up for justice in the town gate (5:10), when it was told to 'hate evil' (5:15). So God now hates the one thing they love most, their worship. What he wants in its place comes three verses later: "let justice roll down like waters" (5:24).

    Full study →
  2. 22Even though you offer Me burnt offerings and grain offerings, I will not accept them; for your peace offerings of fattened cattle I will have no regard.

    "For even if you send up to Me your whole burnt offerings, the ones that rise entirely in smoke, and your gifts of tribute, the grain offerings, I will not accept them as pleasing; I will not credit them to you. And the feast-offering of your stall-fattened animals, the celebration meal of well-being, I will not so much as look at."

    The verse goes through the three main kinds of sacrifice Israel knew: the offering wholly given to God (the burnt offering), the tribute of grain, and the shared feast in which the worshipper ate with God. For each one God refuses the response the ritual was designed to get. "Accept" is the priests' own formal word for an offering that counts, and God withholds it. "Look" is about God's face: he will not even turn toward the feast. The offerings are lavish (fattened animals), they are offered correctly, and they are offered "to Me", to Israel's own God. The verse does not say why they are refused. The surrounding chapter does: in 5:7 and 10–12 these same worshippers turn justice into bitterness, take grain levies from the poor, take bribes and push the needy aside in the town gate. Verse 24 then names what God actually wants: "let justice roll on like waters." Read with verses 21 and 23, God is shutting every sense: no smelling (v. 21), no accepting or looking (v. 22), no hearing (v. 23).

    Full study →
  3. 23Take away from Me the noise of your songs! I will not listen to the music of your harps.

    "Get it off me — that roar of your songs! The praise-music of your harps I will not hear."

    God speaks in his own voice, and he speaks to Israel as one person: "you" is singular here, after the plural "you" of verses 21–22. The first word is a blunt command: remove it, take it away. "From upon me" adds the sense of something pressing on God that he wants lifted off, the way Pharaoh once begged for a plague to be taken "from upon me."

    What is to be removed is Israel's festival singing. God does not call it "song". He calls it hāmôn, a word for the roar of a crowd, the din of an army camp, the crash of the sea. The careful, joyful music of the pilgrim feasts at Bethel and Gilgal is, to him, just crowd-noise.

    The second line repeats the point with the instruments. The zimrâ, the praising music the psalms call for ("raise a song, sound the timbrel, the sweet lyre with the harp", Ps 81:2), played on many hand-held stringed instruments, gets no hearing. "I will not hear" means "I will not receive it": in Israel's worship, for God to "hear" was for him to accept and answer.

    This is the last in a series of refusals that runs through the senses. God will not smell the festivals (v.21), will not accept or even look at the offerings (v.22), and will not hear the songs (v.23). Every way into his presence is closed. The next line gives the reason and the alternative. Instead of this torrent of music, "let justice roll on like waters, and righteousness like a stream that never dries up" (v.24).

    Full study →
  4. 24But let justice roll on like a river, and righteousness like an ever-flowing stream.

    "Instead, let justice come rolling like the waters, and right-dealing like a wadi that never runs dry."

    The verse is God speaking, in the first person, to worshippers at Israel's busy shrines. Just before it he has said: I hate your feasts, I will not accept your offerings, take away the noise of your songs, I will not listen to your harps (vv. 21–23). Verse 24 says what he wants in their place.

    • "Let it roll" pictures water surging along a channel: abundant, moving, impossible to hold back. The "and" ties it to the command before it: remove the noise of your hymns, and let this flow instead. The Hebrew can be heard as a wish ("let it roll") or as a purpose ("so that it may roll").
    • Justice (mishpat) is not an abstract ideal. It means honest verdicts in the court held at the town gate, people's legal rights upheld, and the poor not crushed by bribes and debt. This is exactly what Amos accuses Israel of corrupting (5:7, 10–12, 15).
    • Righteousness (tsedaqah) means doing right by the people you are bound to: fair dealing, keeping faith, protecting the vulnerable. Together the two words name one thing, a society set right.
    • The wadi (nachal) is the key image. Most streambeds in Israel run hard in the winter rains and lie dry all summer. Eitan means "enduring, unfailing." A nachal eitan is the rare wadi that keeps flowing through the dry season.

    So the image is not mainly about power ("a mighty stream"). It is about constancy. Israel's devotion surged like a wadi in flood at festival time and dried up in the marketplace and the courtroom. God asks for justice that keeps flowing in every season, every day.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v21

    feasts / feast days

    ḥag

    What we hear
    Lavish meals or celebrations, perhaps worldly partying.
    What they heard
    The pilgrimage festivals required by the Torah (Unleavened Bread, Weeks, Booths), the central acts of Israel's public worship.
  • in v21

    solemn assemblies

    ʿăṣārâ

    What we hear
    A grave, sombre or mournful meeting.
    What they heard
    A holy day of 'restraint' when work stopped and the people gathered for worship, often the joyful closing day of a festival.
  • in v21

    I cannot stand the stench (BSB); a stench to me (NIV)

    wəlōʾ ʾārîaḥ

    What we hear
    Israel's worship literally stinks to God; he is disgusted by the smell.
    What they heard
    'I will not smell': God refuses to breathe in, and so to accept, the 'pleasing aroma' of the offerings. The picture is acceptance withheld, not a bad smell.
  • in v22

    meat offerings (KJV)

    minḥah

    What we hear
    An offering of animal flesh.
    What they heard
    A gift or tribute, here almost certainly the grain offering of flour, oil and incense, which contained no meat at all.
  • in v22

    peace offerings

    shelem

    What we hear
    A sacrifice offered to make peace with, or win reconciliation from, an offended God.
    What they heard
    A 'well-being' or communion offering: a festive shared meal before God, expressing an already-good relationship (thanksgiving, a vow fulfilled, freewill joy). In Leviticus atonement belongs mainly to other offerings.
  • in v23

    viols (KJV)

    nəbālîm

    What we hear
    Violins or bowed string instruments like those in an orchestra.
    What they heard
    Hand-held plucked stringed instruments (a harp or large lyre) of the ancient Near East. Bowed instruments did not exist in Amos's world.
  • in v23

    noise

    hămôn

    What we hear
    Unpleasant or badly performed sound, as if God objected to the style, volume or quality of the music.
    What they heard
    The roar or din of a crowd, army or sea. God takes music that was probably excellent and calls it mere crowd-roar because of the injustice of the people singing it (vv. 11–12, 24). It is a moral judgment, not an aesthetic one.
  • in v24

    judgment (KJV)

    mishpat

    What we hear
    Condemnation or punishment, God's verdict against sinners.
    What they heard
    Justice in practice: fair verdicts, people's legal rights, and right order in the community, especially for the weak.
  • in v24

    righteousness

    tsedaqah

    What we hear
    Personal moral purity, religious devotion, or a person's standing before God.
    What they heard
    Right conduct within relationships: honest dealing, generosity, protecting the vulnerable. Paired with mishpat, it means social justice.
  • in v24

    mighty stream (KJV, WEB)

    nachal eitan

    What we hear
    A powerful, rushing torrent: the stress falls on force and volume.
    What they heard
    A wadi that never runs dry: the stress falls on lasting, unfailing flow, in contrast to the usual seasonal streambed.
  • in v24

    stream / river

    nachal

    What we hear
    A watercourse that naturally always has water in it.
    What they heard
    A wadi, a streambed that normally floods in winter and dries in summer. That is what makes "ever-flowing" a surprise.
Every word
  1. שָׂנֵ֥אתִי

    śānēʾtî · H8130

    I hate · v21

    A settled stance, not a passing mood: 'I have come to hate, I hate.' It is the first word of God's speech, with no softening before it. It also picks up 5:10 and 5:15: Israel hates the man who speaks up for justice in the town gate, when it was told to 'hate evil.' So now God hates their festivals.

  2. מָאַ֖סְתִּי

    māʾastî · H3988

    I reject, refuse · v21

    It comes right after 'I hate' with no 'and' between them, so the two verbs hit like two blows. Māʾas means to throw something out as unacceptable. It is covenant language: Judah 'rejected the law of the LORD' (Amos 2:4), and now the LORD rejects Israel's worship.

  3. חַגֵּיכֶ֑ם

    ḥaggêkem · H2282

    your feasts, pilgrimage festivals · v21

    The great pilgrimage festivals, when crowds travelled to a sanctuary to celebrate the harvest with sacrifice, eating, music and procession. The word 'your' matters. The Torah calls these 'the LORD's appointed times' (Lev 23:2), but here God calls them yours.

  4. וְלֹ֥א

    wəlōʾ · H3808

    and not · v21, v22, v23

    A flat negative that governs the next verb: 'and I will not…'

  5. אָרִ֖יחַ

    ʾārîaḥ · H7306

    I will smell, take in the scent · v21

    Sacrifice was pictured as smoke rising to God as a 'pleasing aroma' that he breathed in and accepted (Gen 8:21; Lev 1:9). To say 'I will not smell' means 'I will not accept it, it gives me no pleasure.' The wording repeats the covenant curse of Lev 26:31 exactly: 'I will not smell your pleasing aromas.'

  6. בְּעַצְּרֹֽתֵיכֶֽם׃

    bəʿaṣṣərōtêkem · H6116

    in your solemn assemblies · v21

    'Smell in' is a Hebrew idiom meaning 'take delight in' (compare Isa 11:3). The ʿăṣārâ was a holy day on which all work stopped and the people gathered for worship, such as the closing day of a festival. Once again God calls them 'yours.'

  7. כִּ֣י

    ki · H3588

    for, indeed, that · v22

    Joined to the next word, it opens the clause with force: 'For even if…' / 'Yes, though…'. It ties this verse to the 'I hate, I despise' of verse 21, so it carries on the same speech.

  8. אִם־

    ʾim · H518

    if · v22

    'If' / 'even if'. With כִּי it makes a concession: whatever you offer, the verdict stays the same. The common meaning of the pair, 'but rather / except', does not fit here.

  9. תַּעֲלוּ־

    taʿalu · H5927

    go up; (causative) offer up · v22

    'You make go up', the standard verb for sending an offering up as smoke from the altar. The tense points to an ongoing practice: whenever you offer. It shares its root with the next noun, so the line reads 'you send up your sendings-up'.

  10. לִ֥י

    li

    to me · v22

    The offerings really are addressed to Israel's God. That is the sting: God is refusing worship directed at himself.

  11. עֹל֛וֹת

    ʿolot · H5930

    burnt offering (lit. 'that which goes up') · v22

    The whole burnt offering. The entire animal (except the hide) was burned so that it all 'went up' to God, which made it the costliest kind of animal offering and the one most fully given to God.

  12. וּמִנְחֹתֵיכֶ֖ם

    u-minḥoteikhem · H4503

    gift, tribute; grain offering · v22

    'And your gift-offerings'. Here it probably means the grain offering of flour, oil and incense that went with animal sacrifices, but the word still carries its basic sense of tribute brought to a superior. 'Your' marks these as their offerings, not God's.

  13. אֶרְצֶ֑ה

    ʾertseh · H7521

    accept with favour, be pleased with · v22

    'I will not accept.' This is the technical temple word for an offering being formally received and credited to the worshipper (Lev 1:4; 22:21–27). God refuses the very verdict the ritual was meant to secure.

  14. וְשֶׁ֥לֶם

    ve-shelem · H8002

    well-being / peace / fellowship offering · v22

    'And the well-being offering of…'. This is the sacrifice most of which the worshipper ate at a festive meal with family and guests. It is the only place in the Hebrew Bible where the word appears in the singular; everywhere else it is plural (shelamim).

  15. מְרִיאֵיכֶ֖ם

    meriʾeikhem · H4806

    fatling, fattened animal · v22

    'Your fatlings': animals kept and fed up specially for slaughter, a luxury product. The word points to the wealth of the people offering them (compare Amos 6:4, 'calves from the stall').

  16. אַבִּֽיט׃

    ʾabbit · H5027

    look, regard, pay attention to · v22

    'I will not look.' God will not even turn his eyes toward the feast. After smell in verse 21 and before hearing in verse 23, this is the sense of sight being shut.

  17. הָסֵ֥ר

    hāsēr · H5493

    remove, take away, turn aside · v23

    A command addressed to one person ("you" singular): "Take it away! Get it out of here!" The same verb is used for putting away foreign gods and removing cult objects, and Pharaoh uses it with the next word when he begs Moses to remove a plague (Exod 10:17).

  18. מֵעָלַ֖י

    mēʿālay · H5921

    from upon me, off me, away from me · v23

    Literally "from upon me". The phrase is used when something weighs on someone or presses on them, and here it adds a sense of "get this off me". The songs are treated as a burden God wants lifted off, not as a gift he enjoys.

  19. הֲמ֣וֹן

    hămôn · H1995

    din, roar, tumult; crowd, multitude · v23

    A word for the roar of a crowd, an army camp or the sea. Calling festival singing hāmôn shrinks carefully made liturgy down to crowd-noise, a racket.

  20. שִׁרֶ֑יךָ

    šîreykā · H7892

    song · v23

    "Your songs", plural. The sung part of the festival worship at shrines such as Bethel and Gilgal. Amos elsewhere calls them "the songs of the temple" (8:3) and says they will be turned into lament (8:10).

  21. וְזִמְרַ֥ת

    wəzimrat · H2172

    melody, music, playing (in praise) · v23

    "And the music of…". This is a word from worship language for festive, praising music, often played on instruments. The second line is set beside "the din of your songs" and makes the same point again: the voices and the instruments are both rejected.

  22. נְבָלֶ֖יךָ

    nəbāleykā · H5035

    harp / large lyre (a stringed instrument) · v23

    "Your harps", plural. The nēbel was a hand-held stringed instrument used both in worship and at elite banquets. In 6:5 Amos mocks the rich who "improvise to the sound of the nēbel" while the nation falls apart.

  23. אֶשְׁמָֽע׃

    ʾešmāʿ · H8085

    hear, listen, heed · v23

    "I will not hear". In worship language, God "hearing" means receiving and answering favorably. Refusing to hear means refusing to accept the worship at all. This is a refusal, not a matter of not noticing the music.

  24. וְיִגַּ֥ל

    veyiggal · H1556

    and let it roll · v24

    The verb means "to roll" (used of stones and of rolling water). Here the form is passive-reflexive, "roll along, come rolling", the picture of water surging down a channel. The "and" joins it to v. 23's command ("Take away… the noise of your songs"), so it works as the alternative: get rid of that, and let this roll instead. The Hebrew form can be a wish ("let it roll") or a purpose ("so that it may roll"). It probably echoes Amos's earlier pun on Gilgal, the shrine that "will surely go into exile" (5:5, using a similar-sounding verb).

  25. כַּמַּ֖יִם

    kammayim · H4325G

    like the waters · v24

    "Like (the) water". The vowels show the definite article ("the waters"), meaning water in general. In a land that depended on seasonal rain, water flowing freely meant life and plenty.

  26. מִשְׁפָּ֑ט

    mishpat · H4941H

    justice · v24

    Justice in the concrete sense of fair verdicts, people's legal rights, and the proper ordering of community life. In Amos it centres on the court held at the town gate (5:10, 12, 15), where the poor were being denied their rights through bribery. The noun is placed at the end of its clause, after the image, so the line builds to it.

  27. וּצְדָקָ֖ה

    utsedaqah · H6666

    and righteousness · v24

    Right conduct toward others: doing what your relationships and your community require of you, especially toward people who are vulnerable. Paired with mishpat, it names one combined ideal, roughly "social justice" or a right social order, not private piety.

  28. כְּנַ֥חַל

    kenachal · H5158A

    like a wadi · v24

    A nachal is a wadi, a valley streambed that runs with water in the rainy season and usually lies dry in summer. That ordinary fact sets up the surprise of the next word.

  29. אֵיתָֽן׃

    eitan · H0386

    perennial, enduring · v24

    "Enduring, constant, permanent." A "nachal eitan" is a wadi that does not dry up (the same phrase appears in Deut 21:4). The point is that it never fails, not just that it is strong: a justice that keeps flowing through the dry season, unlike Israel's festival enthusiasm.

The world behind it

When and where. Amos was a herdsman from Tekoa in Judah. He preached in the northern kingdom of Israel under Jeroboam II, around 760–750 BC. It was a time of military success and wealth: houses decorated with ivory (3:15), feasting on lambs and calves, wine drunk by the bowlful (6:4–6). It was also a time of land-grabbing, bribery in the courts held at the town gate, and debt-slavery of the poor (2:6–8; 5:10–12).

The sanctuaries. Worship was thriving. Bethel was "the king's sanctuary and a temple of the kingdom" (7:13). Gilgal and Beersheba drew pilgrims too (4:4–5; 5:5). Jeroboam I had set up Bethel's own festival calendar as a rival to Jerusalem (1 Kgs 12:32–33). The festivals were happy occasions: harvest celebrations with many animals sacrificed, communal meals from the sacrifices, songs and harps (5:23).

What sacrifice meant. The burnt offering went up in smoke, and Israel's texts describe God smelling its 'pleasing aroma' and so accepting the worshipper (Gen 8:21; Lev 1:9). An offering God 'would not smell' had failed, and the relationship it was meant to keep up had broken down.

The Day of the LORD. Just before this (5:18–20), Amos turns upside down the popular hope that God's great 'Day' would be light and victory for Israel. People probably linked that hope with festival celebration. Amos says the Day will be darkness. Verse 21 then explains why God's coming will not be good news: the worship meant to make him favourable is the very thing he rejects.

From the study of Amos 5:21.

Where scholars differ

in v21

Does Amos reject sacrificial worship as such, or only worship cut off from justice?

  • Conditional rejection: God rejects this worship because it goes together with injustice, not because ritual is wrong in itself.

    The verse says 'your' feasts, and the chapter ties the rejection to the injustice of 5:10–12 and the call in 5:24. 'I will not smell' echoes a covenant curse (Lev 26:31), which assumes offerings normally please God. Parallel prophets (Isa 1:13, 'iniquity with sacred assembly'; Hos 6:6; Mic 6:8) set priorities rather than abolishing ritual. Hebrew rhetoric often says 'not A but B' when it means 'B rather than A' or 'B before A'.

  • Radical rejection: Amos condemns the sacrificial cult itself, at least as practised in the northern kingdom.

    The language is absolute (hate, reject, will not smell, will not accept, will not look). Amos 5:25 asks, apparently expecting the answer no, whether Israel brought sacrifices in the wilderness, which some read as denying that sacrifice was ever basic to Israel's religion. Amos 4:4–5 mocks the act of going to Bethel to sacrifice. Some scholars of the 19th and 20th centuries saw the prophets as opposing the priestly cult.

  • A rejection aimed at the northern sanctuaries in particular.

    Amos was a Judean, and his targets are Bethel, Gilgal and Beersheba (5:5). Jeroboam I's festival at Bethel was a rival foundation (1 Kgs 12:32–33). Even so, Amos never names the location as the reason. His stated charge is injustice, so most commentators treat this as at most a secondary factor.

in v21

Is the first-person 'I hate, I reject' a covenant/legal formula or simply emotional speech?

  • Covenant language of repudiation.

    Śānēʾ and māʾas both appear in covenant and treaty contexts meaning to disown or break off a relationship (Lev 26:15, 43–44; Hos 4:6; 9:15, 17). The Lev 26 echoes in this verse support a covenant-lawsuit setting.

  • Intense personal outburst, without a technical formula.

    The two verbs piled up without 'and' and the vivid smell image read as emotional speech. The prophets often spoke of God's feelings directly. Both readings can be true together: the vocabulary is covenantal and the tone is emotional.

in v22

Did Amos reject sacrifice altogether, or only sacrifice offered alongside injustice?

  • Amos opposed the sacrificial system itself; true worship for him was ethical, not ritual.

    The refusal here is total and unconditional. Amos 5:25 ('Did you bring me sacrifices… forty years in the wilderness?') seems to imply sacrifice was not part of Israel's founding relationship with God (compare Jer 7:22). This was the classic view of 19th–early 20th century critical scholarship.

  • Amos rejects sacrifice as practised by people who commit injustice; the negation is rhetorical ('not this, but this').

    Hebrew often uses absolute 'not A but B' to mean 'B far more than A' (compare Hos 6:6, which spells out the comparison: 'rather than'). The speech climaxes in v. 24 with justice, not a reform of ritual. Elsewhere the same prophets assume a legitimate temple. Most current commentators (e.g., Paul, Jeremias) hold some form of this view.

  • Amos targets the specific northern shrines (Bethel, Gilgal) and their royal cult.

    Amos 4:4–5 and 5:4–6 mock pilgrimage to these sites specifically; 7:10–17 shows conflict with Bethel's priest; the book's frame (1:2) has YHWH roaring from Zion. Some see this as a contributing factor rather than the whole explanation, since 5:21–24 itself names injustice, not location.

in v22

What does 'shelem/shelamim' mean, and how should it be translated?

  • 'Peace/well-being offering', from shalom (wholeness, welfare).

    Septuagint σωτήριον ('for welfare/deliverance'); the joyful, communal character of the meal in Lev 3 and 7.

  • 'Fellowship/communion offering', stressing the shared meal between God, priest and worshipper.

    The division of portions in Lev 7:11–36; Deut 12:7 ('eat before the LORD your God and rejoice'). This is the NIV's choice.

  • 'Concluding' or 'payment/completion' offering, from shillem ('pay, complete').

    Some scholars (e.g., Levine) note its frequent place at the end of a ceremony and its link to vow-payment (Prov 7:14). This is a minority view, but it has a philological basis.

in v23

Does Amos reject worship and sacrifice as such, or only worship offered by people who practice injustice?

  • Amos rejects the sacrificial system itself. Israel's true relationship with God never required it.

    The very next verses ask, "Did you bring me sacrifices and offerings for forty years in the wilderness?" (5:25), which some read as expecting "no". Amos mocks pilgrimage outright ("Come to Bethel and transgress", 4:4–5), and the rejection in vv. 21–23 is total, with no conditions stated. This view was influential in 19th- and early 20th-century scholarship.

  • Amos rejects worship cut off from justice. The "not this but that" form is a strong way of saying "that matters far more than this", not a call to abolish worship.

    Isa 1:15 rejects even prayer in the same terms, yet no one thinks Isaiah meant to abolish prayer. Amos himself prays (7:2, 5). Hos 6:6 ("steadfast love and not sacrifice") is paired with "knowledge of God more than burnt offerings", which shows the form compares rather than abolishes. Verse 24 gives the condition, and verse 23 rejects the music, which is not something the law commanded at all. Most recent commentators (e.g. Paul, Jeremias, Andersen & Freedman) lean this way, while stressing how radical the rejection is for that time.

in v23

What instrument was the nēbel?

  • An angular or arched harp.

    Traditional rendering. Harps are well attested in Egypt and Mesopotamia. Josephus distinguishes the nabla (twelve strings, played with the fingers) from the kinnyra (ten strings, played with a plectrum, a small pick).

  • A larger, lower-pitched lyre (a cousin of the kinnôr).

    Iron Age images from Israel and the Levant show many lyres and almost no harps. The constant pairing with kinnôr suggests two members of the same family, the way a violin and a cello belong together.

  • A lute-like instrument or other form with a rounded resonating body.

    Proposed from the identical word nēbel, "jar / skin bottle", possibly naming a bulging sound-box. This is suggestive but speculative.

in v24

Is v. 24 a demand on Israel (practise justice) or an announcement of God's judgment coming like a flood?

  • A demand. God wants human justice and right dealing instead of empty worship. This is the majority view (e.g. Wolff, Paul, Andersen & Freedman).

    Everywhere else in Amos, mishpat and tsedaqah are things people do or pervert (5:7, 15; 6:12). The verse answers the imperative in v. 23 ("take away"), and the contrast between worship and justice is the point of vv. 21–24. Compare Isa 1:10–17, Hos 6:6, Mic 6:6–8.

  • A threat. Since Israel refuses justice, God's own judgment and vindication will sweep over them like a torrent (argued notably by J. P. Hyatt, 1956).

    The Hebrew verb form can be read as a plain future, and the Septuagint and Vulgate both translate it as one. Overwhelming water is a common image of divine judgment, and Amos speaks of God pouring out the waters of the sea (5:8; 9:6). The surrounding verses (5:18–20, 27) announce judgment.

in v24

Does Amos reject sacrificial worship altogether, or only worship cut off from justice?

  • Only worship without justice. The problem is the combination of piety and oppression.

    The complaint is aimed at "your" feasts and "your" songs, the offerings of these people. The prophets elsewhere assume the temple and its worship continue. Similar sayings (Hos 6:6; Ps 51:16–19) contrast priorities rather than abolishing sacrifice.

  • A more radical rejection of the sacrificial system as such.

    V. 25 asks whether Israel brought sacrifices in the forty wilderness years, apparently expecting the answer "no." That would suggest sacrifice was never what God's relationship with Israel was built on (compare Jer 7:22).

Sources
  • BDB s.v. שָׂנֵא, מָאַס, חַג, רוּחַ/רִיחַ (Hiphil), עֲצָרָה
  • HALOT s.v. עֲצָרָה; s.v. ריח hif.
  • H. W. Wolff, Joel and Amos (Hermeneia)
  • S. M. Paul, Amos (Hermeneia)
  • F. I. Andersen & D. N. Freedman, Amos (Anchor Bible)
  • J. Milgrom, Leviticus 23–27 (Anchor Bible), on Lev 26:31
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs/Göttingen) Amos 5:21; Vulgate Amos 5:21
  • Leviticus 23; 26:31; Deuteronomy 16; 1 Kings 12:32–33; Isaiah 1:11–15
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. רָצָה, מִנְחָה, שֶׁלֶם, מְרִיא, נָבַט
  • Shalom M. Paul, Amos (Hermeneia, 1991)
  • Hans Walter Wolff, Joel and Amos (Hermeneia, 1977)
  • Francis I. Andersen & David Noel Freedman, Amos (Anchor Bible, 1989)
  • Jörg Jeremias, The Book of Amos (OTL, 1998)
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible, 1991), on ʿolah, minḥah, shelamim and ratson
  • Gary A. Anderson, 'Sacrifice and Sacrificial Offerings (OT)', Anchor Bible Dictionary
  • Baruch Levine, In the Presence of the Lord (1974), on shelamim
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Amos 5:22
  • Vulgate (Weber-Gryson), Amos 5:22
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Amos 5:21–24
  • BDB s.v. הָמוֹן, זִמְרָה, נֵבֶל, סוּר, שָׁמַע
  • HALOT s.v. הָמוֹן; זִמְרָה I; נֵבֶל II
  • Francis I. Andersen & David Noel Freedman, Amos (Anchor Yale Bible, 1989)
  • Joachim Braun, Music in Ancient Israel/Palestine (2002)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 7.306 (nabla and kinyra)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Amos 5:23
  • Vulgate, Amos 5:23
  • STEPBible / supplied morphological data (TAHOT)
  • BDB s.v. גָּלַל, מִשְׁפָּט, צְדָקָה, נַחַל, אֵיתָן
  • HALOT s.v. אֵיתָן; נַחַל; גלל
  • J. P. Hyatt, "The Translation and Meaning of Amos 5:23-24," ZAW 68 (1956)
  • M. Weinfeld, Social Justice in Ancient Israel and in the Ancient Near East (1995)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Amos 5:24
  • Vulgate, Amos 5:24
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Amos 5

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).