1 Samuel Chapter 28 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 28:11–14
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
11“Whom shall I bring up for you?” the woman asked. “Bring up Samuel,” he replied. 12But when the woman saw Samuel, she cried out in a loud voice and said to Saul, “Why have you deceived me? You are Saul!” 13“Do not be afraid,” the king replied. “What do you see?” “I see a god coming up out of the earth,” the woman answered. 14“What does he look like?” asked Saul. “An old man is coming up,” she replied. “And he is wearing a robe.” So Saul knew that it was Samuel, and he bowed facedown in reverence.
What the first hearers heard
To Israelite hearers this short exchange was the moment the scene turned. Everyone knew that consulting the dead was forbidden and was the mark of the nations Israel was meant to be different from. Hearing the king himself say "Bring up Samuel for me" showed how far Saul had fallen. He had once enforced the ban (v.3). Now, cut off from every legitimate way of hearing from God, he reached for the illegitimate one, and the person he named was the LORD's own prophet.
The verb "bring up" fit what they already believed: the dead are below, and a necromancer raises them. The story does not deny that the rite can work. Samuel does come up (vv.12–14). But the outcome is the opposite of what Saul wanted. The "Samuel" who rises only repeats God's verdict and adds that Saul and his sons will be dead the next day (vv.16–19). The later writer of Chronicles states the lesson outright: Saul died "because he consulted an 'ov, seeking guidance, and did not seek the LORD" (1 Chr 10:13–14). The scene taught that the LORD's silence cannot be gone around, and that forbidden means only confirm the judgment they were meant to escape.
From the study of 1 Samuel 28:11.
Verse by verse
-
11“Whom shall I bring up for you?” the woman asked. “Bring up Samuel,” he replied.
Full study →The woman, a practitioner who called up the dead (v.7), now has Saul's oath that she is safe (v.10), and she gets straight to work with the question her trade requires: "Whom shall I make come up for you?" Her verb is the standard term for raising a ghost. It assumes the dead lie below, under the earth in Sheol, the shadowy place of the dead, and that her rite can make one of them rise into the world of the living. "For you" marks Saul as the client the ritual is done for.
Saul, still in disguise, answers by putting the name first: "Samuel! Bring him up for me." He asks for the very prophet who had anointed him king and later told him the LORD had rejected him. Samuel is now dead and buried at Ramah. Saul repeats her technical word back to her as a command, and the closing "for me" shows how personal and desperate the request is.
The irony is heavy. Saul had driven such practitioners out of the land (v.3), and the law forbade consulting them (Lev 19:31; Deut 18:11). The LORD had refused to answer him through dreams, through the priestly lots called Urim, or through prophets (v.6). So the king who would not listen to Samuel alive now tries to get Samuel up from the ground.
-
12But when the woman saw Samuel, she cried out in a loud voice and said to Saul, “Why have you deceived me? You are Saul!”
Full study →The moment the woman saw Samuel, the old prophet rising at her summons, she let out a shriek of terror and rounded on the disguised man who had hired her: "Why have you tricked me? You set me up. You are Saul!"
Several things are packed into the Hebrew:
- She alone sees. The apparition is visible only to her. Saul has to ask what she sees (vv. 13–14).
- Her cry is a scream. The verb is the cry of people in danger.
- Her accusation stings. "Why have you deceived me?" is the betrayed person's protest, the same words Jacob threw at Laban (Gen 29:25). Saul himself once hurled almost exactly this line at his daughter Michal (1 Sam 19:17). Now the deceiver is the king, and the victim is a woman whose life he could take. Only minutes before, an anonymous client had sworn by the LORD that she would not be punished. She now discovers that the oath-swearer is the very king who had purged mediums from the land.
- The last words are a bare exposure: "and you, Saul!" There is no verb. In the unpointed Hebrew, "Saul" is spelled with the same letters as "Sheol", the realm of the dead. The king named "asked-for" has come asking of the underworld, where, Samuel will tell him, he will be tomorrow (v. 19).
The narrator states plainly that what she saw was Samuel. The text does not explain how seeing Samuel revealed Saul's identity, and interpreters have filled that gap in different ways (see Debates).
-
13“Do not be afraid,” the king replied. “What do you see?” “I see a god coming up out of the earth,” the woman answered.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
14“What does he look like?” asked Saul. “An old man is coming up,” she replied. “And he is wearing a robe.” So Saul knew that it was Samuel, and he bowed facedown in reverence.
Full study →Saul cannot see anything. Only the woman sees the figure, so he presses her: "What is his form? What shape is he?" She describes the figure as she watches it rise: "An old man is coming up out of the ground, and he is wrapped up in a robe."
Those two details settle it. Samuel had been "old and gray" for as long as Saul had known him, and the long robe of rank was Samuel's mark from his boyhood at Shiloh, when his mother made him one every year. It was also the robe whose hem tore in Saul's hand on the day Samuel told him God had torn the kingdom from him. Saul understands from her words, not from his own eyes, that this is Samuel.
The king, in disguise in a medium's house at night, then does what a subject does before a superior. He bends his head, presses his nose to the earth the prophet has just risen from, and lies flat before him. Saul ordered the dead man brought up, and now he is the one lying face down.
Where the English drifted
-
in v12
cried (KJV, WEB: “she cried with a loud voice”)
zāʿaq
- What we hear
- Wept, burst into tears.
- What they heard
- Screamed or shrieked in alarm: the outcry of someone in sudden danger.
-
in v14
mantle (KJV)
me'il
- What we hear
- In much church language a 'mantle' is a spiritual anointing or office that passes from one leader to the next, as in 'taking up the mantle'. A reader may assume Samuel appears with some kind of prophetic anointing.
- What they heard
- An ordinary, if high-status, outer robe. Here it is Samuel's own recognizable garment, the one Hannah made for him as a boy and the one Saul tore. It identifies him and recalls the tearing away of Saul's kingdom. It does not carry the idea of a transferable anointing.
Every word
-
וַתֹּ֙אמֶר֙
vattomer · H0559
and she said · v11, v12, v14
The usual verb that moves a Hebrew story forward. The scene shifts at once from Saul's oath (v.10) to the woman getting down to business.
-
הָֽאִשָּׁ֔ה
ha'ishshah · H0802
the woman · v11, v12
The woman already introduced in v.7 as a ba'alat 'ov, 'a woman who controls an 'ov', that is, someone who calls up the dead. The narrator never names her and never calls her a 'witch'. In this chapter she is simply 'the woman'.
-
אֶת־
'et- · H0853
[direct-object marker] · v11, v12
A small word with no English equivalent that marks what follows as the object of the verb. Here it sits in front of 'who', so it means 'whom'.
-
מִ֖י
mi · H4310
who? · v11
Asks about a person. It is a practical question in her line of work: she has to know which dead person to call.
-
אַֽעֲלֶה־
'a'aleh · H5927
I will bring up, cause to go up · v11, v14
'Shall I make [someone] come up?' The verb assumes the dead are below, under the earth in Sheol, and that a necromancer's job is to raise a ghost up from there (compare v.13, 'coming up out of the earth').
-
לָּ֑ךְ
lakh
for you · v11
'For you', meaning for your benefit or on your behalf. This is the form 'for you (man)' takes at the end of a phrase, so it is addressed to Saul even though it looks like the feminine form. The client is the one who gets the answer.
-
שְׁמוּאֵ֖ל
shemu'el · H8050
-
לִֽי׃
li
for me · v11
'For me.' It echoes v.8 ('bring up for me the one I name to you') and shows how personal and desperate the request is: Saul wants an answer for himself after God has refused to give one (v.6).
-
וַתֵּרֶא
wattēreʾ · H7200
-
וַתִּזְעַק
wattizʿaq · H2199
and she cried out · v12
A shriek of alarm. The verb is used for the cry of people in danger or distress, not for a calm announcement and not for weeping.
-
בְּקוֹל
bəqôl · H6963
with a voice · v12
'With a voice': the means of the cry, which strengthens the verb.
-
גָּדוֹל
gādôl · H1419
great, loud · v12
'A great voice' is the Hebrew idiom for 'a loud voice'. Her cry is a scream, not a murmur.
-
אֶל־
ʾel- · H413
to, toward · v12
She addresses Saul directly. The narrator calls him 'Saul', though until now she has not known who he was.
-
שָׁאוּל
šāʾûl · H7586
-
לָמָּה
lāmmâ · H4100
why? · v12, v14
'Why?' here is an accusation more than a request for information: 'What have you done to me?'
-
רִמִּיתָנִי
rimmîtānî · H7411
you have deceived me · v12
'You tricked me' or 'you set me up'. It is the word for a betrayal that leaves the victim exposed. The verb form presents the deception as already done and complete. Her life is now in danger.
-
וְאַתָּה
wəʾattâ · H859
and you · v12
The 'and' gives the reason for the charge: 'when you are Saul', 'seeing you are Saul'. The pronoun is stressed: 'you, of all people'.
-
לָהּ֙
lah · H9034
to her · v14
Addressed to the woman of Endor, the medium. Everything Saul learns about the figure in this verse comes through her.
-
תָּאֳר֔וֹ
to'oro · H8389
his form, figure, appearance · v14
Literally 'his form': the outline and visible build of a person. Saul is asking 'What shape is he? What does he look like?' so that he can identify him.
-
אִ֤ישׁ
ish · H0376G
man · v14
A human figure. This narrows down her startling word 'elohim', 'a god' or 'divine being', from v.13. What is rising looks like a person.
-
זָקֵן֙
zaqen · H2205H
-
וְה֥וּא
vehu · H1931
and he · v14
Starts a second detail about the figure, about how he is dressed.
-
עֹטֶ֖ה
oteh · H5844A
wrapping, enveloping oneself · v14
Wrapped up or enveloped in his garment. The word suggests a garment drawn around the whole body, not just worn loosely.
-
מְעִ֑יל
me'il · H4598
-
וַיֵּ֤דַע
vayyeda · H3045
and he knew · v14
Saul realized or became sure. He knows from her description, not from seeing for himself.
-
כִּֽי־
ki · H3588A
that · v14
Introduces what Saul realized.
-
וַיִּקֹּ֥ד
vayyiqqod · H6915
and he bowed (the head) · v14
Saul bowed his head and upper body. In the Bible this verb always comes just before the fuller verb of lying face down, as the first move in a formal act of respect.
-
אַפַּ֛יִם
appayim · H0639I
nostrils, face · v14
Literally 'nostrils' (the word is a pair form of 'nose'), meaning the face. The picture is of Saul's nose pressed to the ground.
-
אַ֖רְצָה
artsah · H0776H
to the ground · v14
'Groundward.' The same word 'earth' that the figure is rising out of in v.13. The king goes down toward the earth as the prophet comes up out of it.
-
וַיִּשְׁתָּֽחוּ׃
vayyishtachu · H7812
and he prostrated himself, did obeisance · v14
Saul lay flat in full prostration, the gesture made before kings, superiors and God. Here it honors Samuel as a superior. It does not mean Saul worships him as a god.
The world behind it
The crisis. The Philistines have camped at Shunem, and Saul's army is on Mount Gilboa across the valley (28:4). Saul is terrified. He "inquired of the LORD", but God answered him by none of the approved channels: dreams, the Urim (lots kept by the priest), or prophets (v.6). Samuel, the prophet who used to speak for God to him, is dead (25:1; 28:3).
Necromancy in Israel and its world. People across the ancient Near East thought the dead lived on beneath the earth and could know things the living did not. Mesopotamian texts describe specialists who "make a ghost come up". Greek epic has Odysseus calling up the shades of the dead at a pit filled with blood (Odyssey 11). Israel's law singled out the 'ov and the yidde'oni (spirits of the dead and those who consult them, or the people who handle them) as forbidden. Anyone who used them was "defiled" (Lev 19:31) and to be cut off or put to death (Lev 20:6, 27). Deuteronomy groups "one who inquires of the dead" with divination and sorcery as practices of the nations that Israel must not copy (Deut 18:10–12). Isaiah mocks people who consult "the dead on behalf of the living" (Isa 8:19).
The scene. Saul had removed these practitioners from the land (v.3), yet his servants know straight away where one lives, at Endor near the Philistine camp (v.7). Saul goes at night in disguise and swears an oath to her "by the LORD" that she will not be punished (v.10), using the LORD's name to protect a practice the LORD forbade. The question in v.11 is how a session began: the medium needs to know which dead person to call. Only when Samuel actually appears (v.12) does she realise who her client is.
From the study of 1 Samuel 28:11.
Where scholars differ
in v11
Did Samuel really appear, or was it something else?
-
It was really Samuel, permitted by God.
The narrator says without qualification that 'the woman saw Samuel' (v.12) and that 'Samuel said' (vv.15–16). His message repeats 15:28 and comes true. Sirach 46:20 says Samuel 'prophesied after his death'. The Greek of 1 Chr 10:13 adds 'and Samuel the prophet answered him'. Josephus (*Antiquities* 6.327–342) treats the appearance as real. Origen argued for this reading in his homily on the passage.
-
It was a deceiving spirit or demon impersonating Samuel.
Some early Christian writers, notably Tertullian (*De anima* 57) and Eustathius of Antioch, who wrote against Origen, along with many later Protestant interpreters, reasoned that God would not let a forbidden rite command a righteous prophet. They point to the law's ban (Deut 18:10–12). The text itself never hints that the figure is false.
-
The woman was faking it.
Mainly a rationalist reading from early modern times onward. It notes that only she claims to see anything (v.13–14) and that Saul only hears. The Greek term 'belly-speaker' has been taken to suggest ventriloquism. Against this, the narrator reports Samuel's words directly, and her own shock (v.12) suggests the result was not what she expected.
in v11
What is the 'ov that the woman 'masters' (v.7), which lies behind her 'bringing up'?
-
A ritual pit through which the dead were reached.
H. A. Hoffner (JBL 1967) compared Hittite *a-a-bi*, Akkadian *apu* and Ugaritic *ib*, all words for a pit or hole used in rites of the underworld. That fits 'up from the earth' (v.13) and the 'voice from the ground' (Isa 29:4).
-
The ghost or spirit of the dead itself.
In Isa 29:4 and Lev 20:27 the *'ov* seems to speak or to be 'in' a person, and in v.8 Saul says 'divine for me by the *'ov*'. HALOT lists 'spirit of the dead' among its senses.
-
An ancestral spirit (connected with *'av*, 'father').
Proposed on the basis of the word's sound and ancient ancestor cults. The derivation is uncertain, and specialists such as B. Schmidt and J. Tropper weigh the options without agreeing.
in v12
How did seeing Samuel reveal to the woman that her client was Saul?
-
The apparition itself made it obvious. Only the king, the man Samuel anointed and rejected, would summon Samuel at such a time, and the unexpected reality of the appearance shocked her into the connection.
The narrative sequence: she sees Samuel, then immediately names Saul. Samuel's role in Saul's life was so central that his appearance pointed to the king. The text gives no further mechanism.
-
Samuel (or a supernatural insight) disclosed Saul's identity to her.
Josephus's retelling (Antiquities 6.14.2) says she recognised the king because Samuel had made known who he was. This is an interpretive expansion, not in the Hebrew.
-
Something about the manner of Samuel's rising showed that a king had summoned him.
One rabbinic explanation (e.g. Leviticus Rabbah 26:7) holds that the dead rise differently when called up for a king than for a commoner. This is later tradition, not drawn from the text.
-
The text originally read that she 'saw Saul', i.e. recognised him.
A modern conjecture that would make the logic simpler. It is not supported by the Hebrew, Greek or Latin witnesses.
in v12, v14
Was the figure really Samuel?
-
Yes. The text presents a genuine appearance of Samuel, permitted by God.
The narrator calls him 'Samuel' without qualification (vv. 12, 14, 15, 16). His words accurately repeat his earlier verdict (15:28) and correctly predict Saul's death (v. 19; ch. 31). Sirach 46:20 says Samuel 'prophesied after his death'. Origen argued this in his homily on the passage. The woman's terror suggests this was not her usual routine.
-
No. It was a demonic or deceptive spirit impersonating Samuel.
A long line of interpreters (e.g. Eustathius of Antioch's treatise against Origen, Tertullian, De anima 57, and some Reformation-era readers) reasoned that God would not allow a true prophet to be summoned by forbidden arts. They took the narrator to be describing what the woman perceived. This rests on theological inference, not on wording in the text.
-
The medium staged the event or projected it.
Based on the Septuagint label 'belly-talker' and the fact that only she sees the figure. Against this: her genuine terror and the accuracy of the prophecy as the story tells it.
in v14
What does Saul's prostration mean?
-
Honor paid to Samuel as a superior and as the prophet of the LORD.
The verb pair qadad + hishtachavah is commonly used toward kings and superiors (1 Kings 1:16, 31). Saul is addressing a figure he identifies as a man (ish), Samuel. The narrator does not condemn the bow.
-
Reverence for a supernatural being, since the woman called it 'elohim' ('a god', v.13).
The dead could be called 'elohim', meaning beings beyond ordinary human life (compare Isaiah 8:19). Saul's bow may carry some of that awe. Even so, the Hebrew verb itself does not require worship in the sense of honor due only to God.
Sources
- BDB s.v. עָלָה
- HALOT s.v. עלה; s.v. אוֹב
- H. A. Hoffner, 'Second Millennium Antecedents to the Hebrew 'ôḇ', JBL 86 (1967)
- I. L. Finkel, 'Necromancy in Ancient Mesopotamia', Archiv für Orientforschung 29/30 (1983–84)
- J. Tropper, Nekromantie: Totenbefragung im Alten Orient und im Alten Testament (1989)
- B. B. Schmidt, Israel's Beneficent Dead (1994)
- Josephus, Antiquities 6.327–342
- Sirach 46:20
- 1 Chronicles 10:13–14 (MT and LXX)
- Tertullian, De anima 57; Origen and Eustathius of Antioch on 1 Kingdoms 28
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 28
- Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew (fronting for emphasis; pausal forms)
- BDB s.v. רָמָה II (Piel 'beguile, deal treacherously with')
- HALOT s.v. רמה II; s.v. זעק; s.v. אוֹב
- Gen 29:25; Josh 9:22; 1 Sam 19:17; 2 Sam 19:26 (parallel uses of רִמָּה)
- Lev 19:31; 20:6, 27; Deut 18:10–11; Isa 8:19; 1 Chr 10:13–14; Sirach 46:20
- Septuagint 1 Kingdoms 28 (παραλογίζομαι, ἐγγαστρίμυθος)
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 6.14.2 (6.327–336)
- Leviticus Rabbah 26:7
- Origen, Homily on 1 Kingdoms 28; Eustathius of Antioch, De engastrimytho; Tertullian, De anima 57
- H. A. Hoffner, 'Second Millennium Antecedents to the Hebrew ʾôb', JBL 86 (1967)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
- BDB s.v. מְעִיל, תֹּאַר, קָדַד, שָׁחָה
- HALOT s.v. מְעִיל; חוה (hishtaphel); עטה
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 28:14
- Vulgate, 1 Samuel (1 Kings) 28:14
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 6.14.2
- Origen, Homily on 1 Kingdoms 28 (The Witch of Endor); Eustathius of Antioch, On the Belly-Myther
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 28:3–25
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Homer, Odyssey book 11 (calling up the dead through a pit), as comparative background
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.