1 Samuel Chapter 29 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 29:3–5
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
3Then the commanders of the Philistines asked, “What about these Hebrews?” Achish replied, “Is this not David, the servant of King Saul of Israel? He has been with me all these days, even years, and from the day he defected until today I have found no fault in him.” 4But the commanders of the Philistines were angry with Achish and told him, “Send that man back and let him return to the place you assigned him. He must not go down with us into battle only to become our adversary during the war. What better way for him to regain the favor of his master than with the heads of our men? 5Is this not the David about whom they sing in their dances: ‘Saul has slain his thousands, and David his tens of thousands’?”
What the first hearers heard
Israelite hearers would have taken this scene as a tense, ironic moment in David's story, and partly as a defence of him:
- David was not at Gilboa. Saul died fighting the Philistines, and David had been in Philistine service. Someone could easily accuse him of helping kill the Lord's anointed. Here the narrative shows the Philistine commanders themselves refusing to let him fight. David's hands stay clean, and verse 4 adds that the Philistines expected him to turn on them if he did fight.
- The fool's testimonial. Achish's 'I have found nothing in him' is sincere and wrong. Hearers who knew chapter 27 would enjoy the irony: the enemy king calls David blameless (and in v. 9 'as good as an angel of God') precisely because David has deceived him so well. The Philistine generals, who lump David in with 'these Hebrews', see the danger more clearly.
- Divine timing without a miracle. God is not named in the verse, but the story is arranged so that David escapes an impossible choice, between betraying his overlord and fighting his own people, through the ordinary suspicions of soldiers. Next he returns to find Ziklag raided (ch. 30). Hearers would see this as God guiding David's path through events.
- Identity under pressure. To the Philistines David is a 'Hebrew', an outsider who may have a price. To Achish he is a useful 'servant of Saul' turned loyal. The narrative has already told its hearers who he really is: the one God has chosen to be king over Israel.
From the study of 1 Samuel 29:3.
Verse by verse
-
3Then the commanders of the Philistines asked, “What about these Hebrews?” Achish replied, “Is this not David, the servant of King Saul of Israel? He has been with me all these days, even years, and from the day he defected until today I have found no fault in him.”
Full study →The Philistine army is on the march, unit by unit, and at the very back come David and his men alongside King Achish of Gath. The Philistine war-chiefs see them and fire off a curt, suspicious question: "What are these Hebrews doing here?" By "Hebrews" they mean these foreigners, these Israelite hired soldiers, the kind who have changed sides in battle before.
Achish answers as if the name should settle it: "Surely this is David, don't you know? Saul's own officer, a high official of the king of Israel. He has been with me for a good while now, days, no, years. And from the day he defected and came over to me until this very day, I have not found a single thing against him."
The irony is heavy. Achish offers "servant of Saul" as proof that David is a valuable defector. The commanders hear "Saul's man" and wonder how he might buy his way back to his old master (v. 4). Achish rounds up the time ("years", when it was really about sixteen months, 27:7). He swears David is spotless, yet the reader knows David has been lying to him all along (27:8–12). The words "Is this not David?" are the same ones Achish's courtiers spoke when David first came to Gath (21:11), and they bring back the song about David killing tens of thousands of Philistines (v. 5). Achish's trust is total and misplaced. The commanders' suspicion is crude but well-founded, and it is what gets David sent home before the battle in which Saul dies.
-
4But the commanders of the Philistines were angry with Achish and told him, “Send that man back and let him return to the place you assigned him. He must not go down with us into battle only to become our adversary during the war. What better way for him to regain the favor of his master than with the heads of our men?
Full study →The Philistine commanders flared up in anger at their own king, Achish, and the narrator repeats who is speaking ("the commanders of the Philistines said to him") to make clear that the whole officer corps is standing against him. Their demand is blunt and turns on the word "return": Send the man back, and let him go back to the post you gave him, the frontier town of Ziklag that Achish had granted David. They will not even use his name. He is "the man," "this fellow."
They give two reasons. First: he must not march down with us into the battle, because once the lines are engaged he could become our adversary. The Hebrew word is satan, here simply the ordinary word for an opponent, a man who turns his weapons on his own side from within the ranks. Second, a scornful rhetorical question: How else could this fellow make himself acceptable to his lord again? The verb is the one used for an offering that a god "accepts." A deserter wanting to come home to Saul would need a gift to win back favor, and the commanders know what gift this particular Hebrew is famous for: heads. David first won Saul's favor by bringing him a Philistine head (Goliath's). Achish has just made David "keeper of my head" (28:2). The officers fear this bodyguard will instead carry home "the heads of those men." "Those men" is very likely a deliberate way of avoiding saying "our heads" out loud, though it could also point to the troops around them.
In short, these hard-headed officers see David more accurately than his patron does. To them he is still Saul's man, and a Hebrew in a Philistine line on the day of battle against Israel is a betrayal waiting to happen.
-
5Is this not the David about whom they sing in their dances: ‘Saul has slain his thousands, and David his tens of thousands’?”
Full study →"Come on, isn't this David, the very man they still sing about at their victory dances? The women circle with their drums and trade the refrain back and forth: 'Saul has struck down his thousands, and David his ten thousands!'"
The Philistine commanders are not asking a real question. They are reminding King Achish of something everyone knows, and there is contempt in "this one" (the same word they used a sentence earlier for "this fellow"). The song they quote was a public chant, sung back and forth by groups of Israelite women in ring dances to welcome warriors home. The verb's form means the singing goes on: the refrain is still alive years later. In the song, "struck down" means killed and defeated in battle, and the people struck down were Philistines. "Thousands… ten thousands" is a standard step up in Hebrew poetry meaning "a great many… a vast number". Still, the bigger number goes to David. So the argument is: the most celebrated killer of Philistines in Israel should not march with Philistines against Saul, because he could win back his old master's favor with Philistine heads (v. 4).
Where the English drifted
-
in v3, v4
princes (KJV, WEB)
śārîm
- What we hear
- Sons or heirs of a royal family.
- What they heard
- Military commanders or officers. The word is about rank and authority, not birth.
-
in v3
since he fell [unto me] / since he fell away (KJV, WEB)
nāplô
- What we hear
- A moral or spiritual fall, 'falling away' from faith.
- What they heard
- His defection: the day he went over from Saul's side to Achish's.
-
in v3
Hebrews
ʿibrîm
- What we hear
- A neutral or respectful name for the Israelite or Jewish people.
- What they heard
- An outsider's label for Israelites. In Philistine mouths in 1 Samuel it is dismissive and may carry the sense of a band of hired soldiers of doubtful loyalty.
-
in v3
servant of Saul
ʿebed šāʾûl
- What we hear
- A household attendant or menial.
- What they heard
- A royal officer or courtier. David had been one of Saul's top men.
-
in v4
reconcile himself (KJV, WEB, YLT)
yitraṣṣeh
- What we hear
- Two estranged parties make peace with each other.
- What they heard
- A one-sided act of winning a superior's favor by offering him something acceptable, with the same root used for offerings that God accepts.
-
in v5
in their dances
bammeḥolot
- What we hear
- Social or recreational dancing, a party.
- What they heard
- The ring dances that women performed with drums to publicly welcome warriors home after a victory. It was a civic and religious celebration of a military triumph.
-
in v5
his tens of thousands
rivevotav
- What we hear
- An exact tally: David killed ten times as many as Saul.
- What they heard
- The conventional larger number in a fixed poetic pair ('thousand… ten thousand'), meaning 'a vast number'. It still gives David the bigger figure, which is how Saul and the Philistines heard it.
Every word
-
וַיֹּאמְרוּ
wayyōʾmərû · H0559
and they said · v3, v4, v5
Opens the commanders' challenge. The narrative form moves the story forward: the army is on the march and the objection comes in the middle of it.
-
שָׂרֵי
śārê · H8269
commanders of, officers of · v3, v4
The Philistine military chiefs. The word means an officer or official with authority, not a royal 'prince' in the modern sense. Here it alternates with the special Philistine title 'lords' (seranim) used in verse 2.
-
פְלִשְׁתִּים
fəlištîm · H6430G
Philistines · v3, v4
The coastal people of the five cities (Gaza, Ashkelon, Ashdod, Ekron, Gath), Israel's main rival in Saul's day.
-
מָה
māh · H4100
what? · v3, v4
A short, sharp question with no verb: 'What are these Hebrews?' In effect, 'What are these Hebrews doing here?' It carries surprise and suspicion.
-
הָעִבְרִים
hāʿibrîm · H5680
the Hebrews · v3
The label outsiders use for Israelites in Samuel. On Philistine lips it marks David's men as foreigners and possibly as a doubtful band of hangers-on, not as allies.
-
הָאֵלֶּה
hāʾēlleh · H0428
these · v3
'These Hebrews': the commanders can see them marching in the rear with Achish (v. 2). It has a pointing, dismissive edge.
-
אָכִישׁ
ʾākîš · H0397
Achish · v3
King of Gath (27:2), David's overlord, who had given him the town of Ziklag.
-
אֶל־
ʾel- · H0413
to · v3, v4
He answers the commanders directly.
-
הֲלוֹא־
hălôʾ- · H3808
is not...? · v3, v4, v5
A question expecting 'yes': 'Surely this is David, isn't it?' Achish thinks David's name settles the matter.
-
זֶה
zeh · H2088
-
דָוִד
dāwid · H1732
David · v3, v5
Named in full, as a well-known figure.
-
עֶבֶד
ʿebed · H5650
servant, official · v3
Here a royal officer or courtier of Saul, not a menial slave. Achish means it as a credential, but it reminds the commanders whose man David used to be.
-
שָׁאוּל
šāʾûl · H7586G
Saul · v3, v5
The Israelite king the Philistines are about to fight at Gilboa.
-
מֶלֶךְ־
melek- · H4428G
king of · v3
Achish names Saul's full title, which makes the point that David was a high-ranking defector from the enemy court.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵל
yiśrāʾēl · H3478
Israel · v3
The enemy people. Note that Achish says 'Israel' while the commanders say 'Hebrews'.
-
אֲשֶׁר
ʾăšer · H0834A
who · v3, v4, v5
Links David to Achish's record of his loyalty.
-
הָיָה
hāyâ · H1961
has been · v3, v4
A completed, lasting state: he has been and still is with me.
-
אִתִּי
ʾittî · H0854
with me · v3
In my company and service, as my retainer.
-
יָמִים
yāmîm · H3117G
days · v3
In Hebrew 'days' can mean a good stretch of time, sometimes a full year (compare 27:7).
-
אוֹ־
ʾô- · H0176A
or · v3
'Or rather': Achish raises the figure as he speaks, 'days, no, years'.
-
שָׁנִים
šānîm · H8141
years · v3
An overstatement or loose figure. The narrator gives the real time as a year and four months (27:7).
-
מָצָאתִי
māṣāʾtî · H4672
I have found · v3
'I have found nothing in him': the language of looking into a man's record. The reader knows Achish has been deceived (27:8–12).
-
בוֹ
bô · H9033
in him · v3, v4, v5
In him, that is, in his conduct.
-
מְאוּמָה
məʾûmâ · H3972
anything · v3
'Not anything': not the slightest thing. The word 'fault' in English translations is added from context, rightly.
-
נָפְלוֹ
noflô · H5307H
his falling, his defecting · v3
'His falling (over to me)': the ordinary Hebrew way of saying someone deserted to the other side. It is not a moral 'fall'.
-
עַד־
ʿad- · H5704
until · v3
Covers the whole period up to now.
-
וַיִּקְצְפוּ
wayyiqṣəpû · H7107
be angry · v4
'And they flared up in anger.' A word for hot, sudden anger, often of a superior; here, unusually, officers are furious with their own king.
-
עָלָיו
ʿālāyw · H5921A
upon, against · v4
'Against him,' meaning Achish, king of Gath, who had brought David along. The anger is aimed at the king's judgment, not only at David.
-
הָשֵׁב
hāšēb · H7725G
return; send back · v4
'Make (him) go back!' A blunt command from the verb 'return.' It begins a play on the same verb in the next word.
-
אֶת־
ʾet- · H0853
(object marker) · v4
An untranslated marker showing that 'the man' is the object of 'send back.'
-
הָאִישׁ
hāʾîš · H0376G
man · v4
'The man.' The commanders pointedly avoid David's name, which comes out in verse 5, and treat him as a suspect outsider.
-
מְקוֹמוֹ
məqômô · H4725
place · v4
'His place,' meaning Ziklag, the town Achish had granted David (27:6). The commanders want him confined to his post on the frontier.
-
הִפְקַדְתּוֹ
hipqadtô · H6485J
appoint, assign · v4
'You assigned him / put him in charge.' This is the language of a ruler stationing a subordinate, and it reminds Achish that David is his appointee and his responsibility.
-
שָׁם
šām · H8033G
there · v4
'There.' Completes 'where you assigned him.'
-
יֵרֵד
yērēd · H3381
go down · v4
'He shall go down.' The usual verb for marching out to battle, which here meant down from Aphek toward the Jezreel valley.
-
עִמָּנוּ
ʿimmānû · H5973A
with · v4
'With us.' The problem is not David existing but David fighting in their ranks.
-
בַּמִּלְחָמָה
bammilḥāmâ · H4421
battle, war · v4
'Into the battle,' meaning the coming clash with Saul's army.
-
לָּנוּ
lānû · H9035
to us · v4
'To us / against us.' Literally 'become to us as…'.
-
לְשָׂטָן
ləśāṭān · H7854
adversary · v4
'As an adversary.' The ordinary Hebrew word for an opponent. Here it is a human soldier who turns on his own side mid-battle. It is not a name for the devil.
-
יִתְרַצֶּה
yitraṣṣeh · H7521
be pleased with; accept · v4
'Make himself acceptable / win himself favor.' The root is used of offerings a god accepts. The picture is of David bringing a gift that would buy his way back into Saul's good graces.
-
אֲדֹנָיו
ʾădōnāyw · H0113
lord, master · v4
'His lord,' meaning Saul. Hebrew often uses a plural-looking form for a single superior as a mark of rank. The commanders assume David still belongs to Saul at heart.
-
בְּרָאשֵׁי
bərāʾšê · H7218A
head · v4
'With the heads of.' Most naturally read as literal severed heads, the battlefield trophies a deserter could carry back to his king. 'Head' can also mean 'chief,' so a hint at 'the leaders' is possible.
-
הָאֲנָשִׁים
hāʾănāšîm · H0582
men · v4
'The men.' Philistine soldiers.
-
הָהֵם
hāhēm · H1992
those · v4
'Those.' Most likely an evasive way of saying 'our' heads, so that the speakers do not say aloud an ill-omened phrase about themselves. It may also simply point to the troops standing nearby.
-
יַעֲנוּ־
ya'anu · H6030C
to sing (responsively) · v5
'They sing', probably in the call-and-answer style of Israelite victory songs, where one group sings a line and another answers it. The verb form describes ongoing or habitual action, so the song is still going round years later, which is what makes it dangerous.
-
בַּמְּחֹל֖וֹת
bammeḥolot · H4246
dances, circle-dances · v5
'In the dances': the round dances, with drums, that women performed to welcome warriors home after a victory (compare 1 Sam 18:6). The song was a public celebration, not a private remark.
-
הִכָּ֤ה
hikkah · H5221
struck, struck down, defeated, killed · v5
'Has struck down': killed or beaten enemies in battle. One verb serves both halves of the song: Saul struck down, and David (struck down).
-
בַּֽאֲלָפָ֔יו
ba'alafav · H0505G
thousand(s) · v5
Literally 'among/by his thousands': Saul's tally of slain enemies is counted in thousands. The preposition b- is unusual here. It may mean 'by the thousands' or 'among his thousands'.
-
בְּרִבְבֹתָֽיו׃
berivevotav · H7233
myriad, ten thousand · v5
'Among/by his myriads': a ten-thousand count, the conventional larger number paired with 'thousand' in Hebrew poetry. To the Philistine ear it means David has killed more of them than anyone. The ס after the verse is a scribal paragraph marker, not a word.
The world behind it
The eve of Gilboa. The Philistines have gathered their forces at Aphek, at the head of the Yarkon river on the coastal plain, to march north against Saul, who is camped by the spring in the Jezreel Valley (29:1; 28:4). This is the campaign in which Saul and his sons will die (ch. 31).
David as a Philistine vassal. Running from Saul, David had taken 600 men and entered the service of Achish, king of Gath (probably Tell es-Safi), who gave him the town of Ziklag (27:1–7). A vassal of this kind owed his overlord military service. Achish had even named David his permanent bodyguard (28:2), which explains why David's troop marches in the rear with Achish himself (29:2). Meanwhile David had been raiding non-Israelite peoples in the south and telling Achish he was raiding Judah, leaving no survivors to contradict him (27:8–12). So Achish believes David has made himself 'odious to his own people' (27:12).
A coalition, not one king. The Philistines were ruled by the lords of five cities, who went to war together. Achish could not overrule the other commanders, and in verses 6–7 he has to tell David that 'the lords do not approve of you'.
The name Achish. A seventh-century BC royal inscription from Ekron names a king ʾkyš (Achish), and the same name appears in Assyrian records as Ikausu. This shows the name was really used among Philistine kings, possibly with roots outside the Semitic languages. The Ekron Achish is a different, later man.
Why the story matters to the narrator. Many scholars read 1 Samuel 16–2 Samuel 5 as written partly to defend David. One charge that could be brought against him was that he marched with the enemy against Saul. This scene answers it: David was there, but the Philistines themselves sent him home, so he had no part in Saul's death.
From the study of 1 Samuel 29:3.
Where scholars differ
in v3
Are the 'commanders' (śārîm) of v. 3 the same people as the 'lords' (seranim) of vv. 2, 6–7?
-
Two different groups: the field officers raise the objection and the city-lords back it.
Different titles are used. Śar is the ordinary Hebrew word for an officer, while seren is a special Philistine title for the five rulers (Josh 13:3; Judg 3:3; 1 Sam 6).
-
The same council, under two names.
In the chapter the titles alternate with no visible change in who is speaking. Achish reports the commanders' objection as the decision of 'the lords' (v. 6–7), and the commanders speak again in v. 9.
in v3
Does 'Hebrews' here carry the sense of the ḫabiru/ʿapiru, a social class of uprooted soldiers-for-hire?
-
Yes, at least as an echo: in Philistine mouths it marks David's band as mercenary outsiders.
1 Sam 13–14 seems to separate 'Hebrews' from 'Israel' and describes 'Hebrews who had been with the Philistines' switching sides (14:21). David's band (22:2) looks like ʿapiru groups in the Amarna letters.
-
No: it is simply an ethnic name for Israelites, used by foreigners.
The link between ʿibrî and ʿapiru is disputed on linguistic grounds. In most of the Hebrew Bible ʿibrî is just a name for the people (Gen 40:15; Exod 1–3; Jonah 1:9).
in v3
How long had David been with Achish?
-
About a year and four months; Achish is exaggerating.
1 Sam 27:7 says 'days and four months', with 'days' meaning a year as in 1 Sam 1:21.
-
The original text may have said 'two years'.
The Septuagint's 'this second year' could point to a different Hebrew wording.
in v4
Who are 'those men' whose heads David would bring to Saul?
-
An avoiding way of saying 'our men' / 'our heads,' so the commanders do not speak an ill-omened statement about themselves.
Hebrew narrative elsewhere shifts curses and threats onto a third party to avoid saying them directly (e.g., 1 Sam 25:22; 2 Sam 12:14). Followed by BSB and NIV ('our men') and many commentators.
-
A literal pointing reference to the Philistine troops present, 'those men there,' the soldiers in the ranks around them.
'Those' (hāhēm) can simply point to people under discussion. The commanders may mean the rank-and-file soldiers rather than themselves. Followed by the more literal renderings (YLT 'those men').
in v4
Are the 'heads' literal trophies or the Philistine 'chiefs'?
-
Literal severed heads presented as trophies.
The pattern in Samuel: Goliath's head brought to Saul (17:54, 57), Saul's head taken by the Philistines (31:9), Ishbosheth's head brought to David (2 Sam 4:8). Head-counting is also attested in ancient Near Eastern art and texts.
-
A double meaning that includes 'the chiefs,' meaning the Philistine leaders themselves.
rōʾš regularly means 'chief, leader,' and the speakers are leaders. It also connects with 'keeper of my head' (28:2). Most see this as wordplay layered on the literal sense rather than a replacement for it.
in v5
Was the song meant to rank David above Saul, or was it standard poetic praise of both?
-
Standard poetry: 'thousand // ten thousand' is a fixed word pair, and the singers meant to honor both men.
The same rising pair appears in Deut 32:30, Ps 91:7 and Mic 6:7, and as alp // rbt in Ugaritic poetry, with no comparison intended. S. Gevirtz and others argue that Saul misheard a normal poetic form.
-
A real comparison: the narrator presents the song as exalting David over Saul.
Saul's reaction, 'They have given David ten thousands, and me only thousands' (18:8), is reported without correction. The story keeps coming back to the song as a sign that David is rising. Here the Philistines also treat it as proof that David is the greater danger.
-
Both: the form is conventional, but in the story it works as a ranking.
Whatever the singers intended, every hearer in 1 Samuel (Saul, the men of Gath, the Philistine commanders) takes the bigger number as belonging to David.
in v5
Does the verb mean 'sing' or 'answer (responsively)'?
-
A separate verb meaning 'sing'.
BDB and HALOT list 'nh, 'sing', for passages like Exod 32:18, Num 21:17 and Ps 147:7, where no answering is in view.
-
The ordinary verb 'answer', used of responsive singing.
Exod 15:21 ('Miriam answered them') and the call-and-answer form of victory songs. KJV and YLT follow this sense. In practice the two senses overlap here, and the scene described is antiphonal (sung in alternating parts) either way.
Sources
- BDB s.v. שַׂר, סֶרֶן, עִבְרִי, נָפַל, מְאוּמָה
- HALOT s.v. נפל (qal 'desert, go over to')
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 27:7; 29:1–11
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary), on ch. 29
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 29:3
- Ekron Royal Dedicatory Inscription (Gitin, Dothan & Naveh, IEJ 47, 1997)
- Amarna letters on the ḫabiru/ʿapiru (Moran, The Amarna Letters)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, 1 Samuel 27–29
- BDB s.v. שָׂטָן, רָצָה, קָצַף, שַׂר
- HALOT s.v. שָׂטָן; s.v. רצה (hitpael)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 29:1–11
- Robert Alter, The David Story, notes on 1 Sam 28:2; 29:4
- Peggy L. Day, An Adversary in Heaven: śāṭān in the Hebrew Bible
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 29:4 (Rahlfs)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 29
- BDB s.v. עָנָה (IV, 'sing')
- HALOT s.v. ענה IV
- HALOT s.v. מְחוֹלָה
- BDB s.v. רְבָבָה
- HALOT s.v. אֶלֶף
- S. Gevirtz, Patterns in the Early Poetry of Israel (on the fixed pair 'thousand // ten thousand')
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 18:6–7 and 29
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 29:5; 18:7
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).