2 Esdras Chapter 10 Read as one passage
2 Esdras 10:40–57
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
40This therefore is the meaning of the vision. 41The woman who appeared to you a little while ago, whom you saw mourning, and began to comfort her, 42but now you no longer see the likeness of the woman, but a city under construction appeared to you, 43and she told you of the death of her son, this is the interpretation: 44This woman, whom you saw, is Zion, whom you now see as a city being built. 45She told you that she had been barren for thirty years because there were three thousand years in the world in which there was no offering as yet offered in her. 46And it came to pass after three thousand years that Solomon built the city and offered offerings. It was then that the barren bore a son. 47She told you that she nourished him with great care. That was the dwelling in Jerusalem. 48When she said to you, ‘My son died when he entered into his marriage chamber, and that misfortune befell her,’ this was the destruction that came to Jerusalem. 49Behold, you saw her likeness, how she mourned for her son, and you began to comfort her for what has happened to her. These were the things to be opened to you. 50For now the Most High, seeing that you are sincerely grieved and suffer from your whole heart for her, has shown you the brightness of her glory and the attractiveness of her beauty. 51Therefore I asked you to remain in the field where no house was built, 52for I knew that the Most High would show this to you. 53Therefore I commanded you to come into the field, where no foundation of any building was. 54For no human construction could stand in the place in which the city of the Most High was to be shown. 55Therefore don’t be afraid nor let your heart be terrified, but go your way in and see the beauty and greatness of the building, as much as your eyes are able to see. 56Then will you hear as much as your ears may comprehend. 57For you are more blessed than many, and are called by name to be with the Most High, like only a few.
What the first hearers heard
For Jews around AD 100 the Temple was in ruins, and hopes of rebuilding it soon had faded or, for some, were growing dangerous. This verse said something precise to them. The Zion God would restore did not depend on clearing rubble or relaying old stones. God's city already existed. It would be shown, and it would rest on God's own foundations. That is why it appeared in a place where nobody had ever built.
The verse also tells readers to look back and see that Ezra's strange instructions had a purpose: leaving the town, the diet of flowers, the empty field. To a reader who had lived through the loss of Jerusalem, this was comfort with a specific shape. It did not deny the grief. In this vision the mourning woman is Zion, and her grief is real. But it moved the hope from human rebuilding to God revealing his city. Within the book, Ezra's own turn happens here: until now he has accused and argued, and from here on he receives revelation and is consoled.
From the study of 2 Esdras 10:53.
Verse by verse
-
40This therefore is the meaning of the vision.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
41The woman who appeared to you a little while ago, whom you saw mourning, and began to comfort her,
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
42but now you no longer see the likeness of the woman, but a city under construction appeared to you,
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
43and she told you of the death of her son, this is the interpretation:
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
44This woman, whom you saw, is Zion, whom you now see as a city being built.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
45She told you that she had been barren for thirty years because there were three thousand years in the world in which there was no offering as yet offered in her.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
46And it came to pass after three thousand years that Solomon built the city and offered offerings. It was then that the barren bore a son.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
47She told you that she nourished him with great care. That was the dwelling in Jerusalem.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
48When she said to you, ‘My son died when he entered into his marriage chamber, and that misfortune befell her,’ this was the destruction that came to Jerusalem.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
49Behold, you saw her likeness, how she mourned for her son, and you began to comfort her for what has happened to her. These were the things to be opened to you.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
50For now the Most High, seeing that you are sincerely grieved and suffer from your whole heart for her, has shown you the brightness of her glory and the attractiveness of her beauty.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
51Therefore I asked you to remain in the field where no house was built,
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
52for I knew that the Most High would show this to you.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
53Therefore I commanded you to come into the field, where no foundation of any building was.
Full study →The angel Uriel is explaining what Ezra has just seen. Ezra had found a woman mourning her son, who died on his wedding day. As Ezra watched, she was suddenly transformed into a city, and a place with enormous foundations appeared (10:25–27). Now the angel tells him why the vision happened where it did:
"This is the reason I told you to come out into the open country, to a place where there is no foundation of any building at all."
The "field" is the open, flowering land Ezra was sent to back in 9:24–26. It had no houses and no stonework, nothing people had ever built. That emptiness was the point. The city Ezra saw is the Zion of the Most High, and it rests on foundations God laid, not on any human groundwork. Verse 54 completes the thought: no human construction could stand on the spot where God's city was to be shown. Ezra was not sent to the ruins of the old city, nor to a place where people might rebuild. He was sent to untouched ground, so that what appeared there would plainly be God's work and nothing else.
-
54For no human construction could stand in the place in which the city of the Most High was to be shown.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
55Therefore don’t be afraid nor let your heart be terrified, but go your way in and see the beauty and greatness of the building, as much as your eyes are able to see.
Full study →"So you, Ezra, do not be afraid, and do not let your heart, your whole inner self, be seized with panic. Instead, go in and see for yourself the shining glory and the overwhelming size of this city God has built, as much of it as your eyes are capable of taking in."
The verse is the angel Uriel's answer to Ezra's collapse. Moments before, Ezra had been comforting a weeping woman whose only son died on his wedding night. Suddenly she blazed with light, gave a terrible cry, and was gone. In her place stood a city with great foundations. Ezra fell down "as one dead". The angel has now explained it: the woman is Zion, her son is the temple Solomon built, and his death is Jerusalem's destruction. The city is what God will show her instead. It appeared in an open field where no human had ever laid a foundation, because no human work could stand where the city of the Most High was to be revealed (verses 53–54).
"Therefore" ties the comfort to that explanation. What frightened Ezra is the answer to his mourning. He is told not only to look but to go in, and to see its splendour, a word for radiance and glory rather than mere prettiness, and its greatness, both its vast size and its majesty. The closing limit, "as much as your eyes are able", is not a door half-shut. It is the book's steady point that a human being is a small vessel. Ezra may take in as much as a human can hold, and the next verse adds hearing "as much as your ears may comprehend". The narrative never tells us what he saw inside.
-
56Then will you hear as much as your ears may comprehend.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
57For you are more blessed than many, and are called by name to be with the Most High, like only a few.
Full study →The angel Uriel has just told Ezra to go into the shining city that had appeared where the mourning woman stood, and to see and hear as much as a human can take in (10:55–56). Now he gives the reason: “For you, you yourself, are favoured by God beyond most people, and you have been called and named in the presence of the Most High, as only a few ever are.”
“Blessed” here is a verdict. God has looked at Ezra and approved him. It is not a remark about good fortune. The book has already given a reason (10:50): Ezra grieved sincerely for Zion and set aside his own sorrow. “Called with the Most High” means that Ezra already has a name and a standing in God’s heavenly court. The wording also points ahead to the end of the book (ch. 14), where Ezra is told he will be taken up from among humans to be with God, as Enoch and Elijah were. The contrast between “many” and “few” recalls the book’s hardest question: why so many are lost and only a few saved (8:1–3). Without answering that question, the angel tells Ezra that he is among the few. This is why he, a living man, may see the heavenly Jerusalem and will be shown the coming visions (10:58–59).
Where the English drifted
-
in v53
the field
ager (Latin; probably Hebrew sadeh behind it)
- What we hear
- A farmer's cultivated field or a meadow next to a town.
- What they heard
- Open, unworked country with no houses: the 'field of flowers where no house has been built' (9:24). It is defined by having no human building on it.
-
in v55
the beauty ... of the building
splendorem ... aedificii
- What we hear
- How good a single structure looks, its attractiveness.
- What they heard
- The shining radiance (splendor) of the whole city God has built (aedificium), which includes the temple. It is glory-language, not a building's appearance.
-
in v57
called
vocatus (probably Hebrew qara’ / Greek kaleō behind it)
- What we hear
- A vocation, a call to ministry, or a conversion experience (“God called me”).
- What they heard
- Named, honoured, or summoned into God’s presence: a standing before the heavenly court, probably pointing toward Ezra being taken up to God (14:9).
-
in v57
blessed
beatus (probably Hebrew ’ashrê / Greek makarios)
- What we hear
- Lucky, prosperous, happy.
- What they heard
- Judged and approved by God, and so in a favoured position, here with access to heavenly secrets.
Every word
-
Propterea
propterea
therefore, for this reason · v53
This word links back to verse 52, where the angel says he knew the Most High would show Ezra the vision. Because the city was going to be revealed, Ezra had to be sent to a particular kind of place.
-
dixi
dixi
I said, I told · v53
The speaker is the angel Uriel, recalling his instruction in 9:23–25. Literally it is 'I said', but an angel's word to a seer carries authority, so 'I commanded' (KJV, WEB) is a fair rendering.
-
tibi
tibi
to you · v53
Addressed to Ezra, the seer, who has just been shaken by watching the mourning woman turn into a city.
-
ut
ut
that, so that · v53
Introduces what Ezra was told to do. Together, 'I said that you should' amounts to an instruction.
-
venires
venires
you should come · v53
'Come', not 'go'. The angel speaks as if from the place where the revelation happens, so the field is where God meets the seer. WEB's 'come' follows the Latin. KJV's 'go' is looser.
-
in
in
into · v53
With the accusative case, which marks motion: Ezra was to go out into the field, away from the town.
-
agrum
agrum
field, open country · v53
This is the 'field of flowers' of 9:24–26, named Ardat in 9:26: open land with no houses, where Ezra lived on flowers for seven days. It is the scene of the fourth vision.
-
ubi
ubi
where · v53
Introduces what defines the field: what is not there.
-
non est
non est
there is not · v53
The Latin is in the present tense ('where there is no foundation'). English versions put it in the past ('was'), which reads naturally in narrative. The point is that the ground is untouched.
-
fundamentum
fundamentum
foundation · v53
The key word. In the vision a city appeared with 'great foundations' (10:27). The field had to have no human foundation in it, so that the only foundation there would be the one God revealed.
-
aedificii
aedificii
of a building · v53, v55
'Building', meaning a human construction. Verse 54 spells it out: 'no work of human building' could stand where the city of the Most High was to be shown.
-
tu
tu
you · v55
Emphatic 'you'. The angel turns from explaining the vision to speaking to Ezra himself: this is meant for you.
-
ergo
ergo
therefore · v55
Links back to verses 53–54. The ground is untouched by human building because God's city was to be shown there, so Ezra has no reason to fear.
-
noli
noli
do not (be unwilling) · v55
With an infinitive, this is the standard Latin way of saying 'don't'. It is a gentle but firm command.
-
timere
timere
to fear · v55
Together with noli it makes 'do not fear'. This is the classic reassurance heavenly messengers give to people overwhelmed by a vision (compare Daniel 10:12, 19).
-
neque
neque
nor · v55
Adds a second, stronger clause to the reassurance.
-
expavescat
expavescat
be terrified, panic · v55
A stronger word than timere. It means to be struck with dread or panic. It fits the moment: Ezra cried out and fell down 'as one dead' when the woman turned into a city (10:25–30).
-
cor
cor
heart · v55
In the Semitic idiom behind the Latin, the heart is the centre of thought, will and feeling, not just emotion. The angel speaks to Ezra's whole inner self.
-
tuum
tuum
your · v55
Keeps the address personal.
-
sed
sed
but · v55
Turns from what Ezra should stop doing (fearing) to what he should do (enter and look).
-
ingredere
ingredere
go in, enter · v55
A command to enter. Ezra is not only to look at the city from outside. He is invited inside it, like Ezekiel touring the visionary temple.
-
et
et
and · v55, v57
Joins entering and seeing as one act.
-
vide
vide
see! · v55
A command to see. In apocalyptic writing, being 'shown' and 'seeing' is how hidden heavenly realities are revealed to the seer.
-
splendorem
splendorem
brilliance, splendour · v55
Radiance or shining glory, which the KJV and WEB render 'beauty'. It suggests the light-filled glory of God's city, not only that it looks attractive.
-
vel
vel
or / and · v55
In later Latin, vel often simply joins two items, so 'splendour and greatness' (KJV, WEB) is a fair rendering.
-
magnitudinem
magnitudinem
greatness, vastness · v55
Both physical size and grandeur. The city is too large for a human to take in, which sets up the final clause.
-
quantum
quantum
as much as · v55
Introduces the limit. Ezra may see as much as he can, not everything.
-
capax est
capax est
is able to hold / take in · v55
Capax means 'able to contain'. Human sight is pictured as a vessel with a fixed capacity, which echoes the book's repeated point that a human 'vessel' cannot hold the ways of the Most High (4:10–11).
-
visus
visus
sight, power of seeing · v55
The faculty of sight itself. Ezra's eyesight, not the size of the city, sets the limit.
-
oculorum tuorum
oculorum tuorum
of your eyes · v55
Pairs with 'your ears' in the next verse. Ezekiel 40:4 has the same pairing: 'see with your eyes and hear with your ears'.
-
videre
videre
to see · v55
Repeats the verb from the command 'see!', closing the verse on the act of seeing.
-
Tu
tu
you (singular) · v57
Emphatic: the angel Uriel speaks directly to Ezra as one person. In Latin the pronoun is not needed, so using it singles him out.
-
enim
enim
for, because · v57
Gives the reason for 10:55–56: Ezra is allowed to enter and see the heavenly city because of the status described here.
-
beatus
beatus
blessed, fortunate, favoured · v57
Probably stands for Greek makarios and Hebrew ’ashrê. It names a state of being favoured by God, not a feeling of happiness.
-
es
es
you are · v57
Present tense. This is Ezra’s standing now, not a hope for later.
-
prae
prae
beyond, more than, ahead of · v57
Comparison: Ezra’s favour is greater than other people’s. It probably reflects the Semitic comparative min (“more than”).
-
multis
multis
many · v57
“The many” is a loaded word in 4 Ezra. It usually means the mass of humanity, most of whom the book expects to be lost (8:1–3).
-
vocatus
vocatus
called, named, summoned · v57
It could mean “named” (honoured, given a name or reputation before God) or “summoned” into God’s company. This is not a calling to a job or a ministry.
-
apud
apud
with, in the presence of, before · v57
“At the side of” or “in the presence of” God. It may translate a Semitic “before” (lifnê) or “with” (‘im). It locates Ezra’s honour in the heavenly court.
-
Altissimum
Altissimum
the Most High · v57
The usual name for God in 4 Ezra. It reflects Hebrew ‘Elyon and Greek Hypsistos, and pictures God as exalted above the world and its history.
-
sicut
sicut
as, just as · v57
Puts Ezra in a class: he belongs with a small group.
-
pauci
pauci
The world behind it
The book and its moment. Chapters 3–14 of 2 Esdras, usually called 4 Ezra, were written around AD 100. That was about a generation after the Romans destroyed Jerusalem and its Temple in AD 70. The author writes under the name of Ezra and sets the story "in the thirtieth year after the destruction of our city", meaning the Babylonian destruction of 587 BC (3:1). That earlier disaster serves as a stand-in for the recent one. The book is a series of seven visions in which Ezra argues with the angel Uriel about how God could let Zion fall.
The fourth vision (9:38–10:59). This is the turning point of the book. Ezra, staying in the field of Ardat (9:26), meets a weeping woman. She was barren for thirty years, then bore a son, and the son died when he entered his wedding chamber. Ezra rebukes her: Zion's grief is greater than hers. Then she cries out, her face shines, and she disappears. In her place is a city being built, with huge foundations (10:25–27). Ezra is terrified. Uriel explains: the woman is Zion. Her thirty barren years are the time before the first Temple. The son's birth is the building of Solomon's Temple, and his death is Jerusalem's destruction. The city Ezra now sees is the glory of Zion that God is showing him (10:40–50).
Why an empty field? Verses 53–54 explain the earlier instruction of 9:24. Ezra was to go to a field of flowers "where no house has been built", eat only flowers, and drink no wine. The place had to be empty of human building. A Jewish reader might also have thought of the old rule that God's altar must be made of uncut stones that no tool had touched (Exod 20:25; Deut 27:5–6). The text does not make that link itself, so it is only a possible echo. The clearer background is the late Second Temple belief that a heavenly Jerusalem already exists with God and will be revealed. 4 Ezra itself says "the city that now is not seen shall appear" (7:26) and speaks of Zion "prepared and built … carved out without hands" (13:36). The same belief appears in 2 Baruch 4:2–7, Galatians 4:26, Hebrews 11:10; 12:22, and Revelation 21:2.
From the study of 2 Esdras 10:53.
Where scholars differ
in v53
Does the vision picture the heavenly Zion replacing the earthly Jerusalem, or the earthly city restored in glory?
-
It is a heavenly, pre-existing city revealed from God's side, discontinuous with human Jerusalem.
The insistence that no human building could stand there (10:54), 'the city that now is not seen shall appear' (7:26), and Zion 'carved out without hands' (13:36). Parallel to 2 Baruch 4:2–7, where the true building is kept with God.
-
It is the glory of Zion itself, the same mother-city restored and transfigured. The book stresses continuity with the mourning woman, not replacement.
The woman who *is* Zion turns into the city (10:27, 44). Uriel says Ezra is shown 'the brightness of her glory' (10:50). Ezra is told to go in and see the splendour of the building (10:55), which ties it to the Zion he mourns.
in v53
Is the unbuilt field meant to recall the rule of uncut altar stones?
-
Possibly. The requirement of ground untouched by human work matches the logic of Exodus 20:25 and Deuteronomy 27:5–6, where human tooling profanes what belongs to God.
There is a shared idea that human labour must not mix with God's own holy structure. 4 Ezra's 'without hands' language (13:36) points the same way.
-
No direct allusion is needed. The motif is simply apocalyptic: revelation in open country, away from the city, with the emptiness making clear the city is God's work.
The text itself gives only the reason in 10:54, that no human building could stand there. It never cites altar law.
in v55
Is the city Ezra sees a heavenly Jerusalem that already exists, or the future Jerusalem of the end times?
-
A city that already exists with God and is now shown ahead of time.
Verse 54 speaks of the place where the city 'was to be shown'. 2 Baruch 4:2–6 describes a building 'prepared beforehand' and shown to Adam, Abraham and Moses. 2 Esdras 7:26 speaks of 'the city which now is not seen'.
-
The future, end-time Zion, revealed in advance in a vision.
2 Esdras 7:26 and 13:36 place the city's appearing in the future ('shall appear', 'will come and be made manifest to all'). The vision answers the community's hope for restoration.
-
Both: a city prepared now in God's presence and to be revealed publicly at the end.
Many commentators (e.g. M. E. Stone, Hermeneia) read the book's 'hidden now, revealed later' language as joining the two ideas, not choosing between them.
in v55
What does this vision do to Ezra's earlier complaints?
-
It marks Ezra's real change of heart, from grief and protest to consolation, through religious experience rather than argument.
Stone and others point to the shift in Ezra's role (he now comforts the mourner), his collapse and restoration, and the fact that the later visions contain no more debate.
-
The vision mainly confirms the angel's position against Ezra's, so the author speaks through Uriel and corrects Ezra's views.
Some earlier German scholarship (e.g. W. Harnisch) read the dialogues as the author refuting a sceptical position voiced by Ezra. On that reading the city vision is the reward for Ezra accepting correction.
in v57
What does “called with/before the Most High” mean?
-
Named or honoured before God: Ezra has a name and reputation in the heavenly court.
Semitic idiom of “being called/named before” someone; Latin “apud”; parallels such as Isaiah 43:1. It fits the present-tense verdict “you are blessed.”
-
Summoned to be with God, pointing toward Ezra being taken up into heaven.
2 Esdras 14:9 (“you shall be taken up from among men… with those like you”), and the report in 14:49 in several versions that he was taken up. The models of Enoch and Elijah. NRSV adopts this reading.
in v57
Why is Ezra counted among the few?
-
His lifelong righteousness and devotion to the Law.
-
Specifically his change in this vision, from complaining about the many to mourning for Zion.
10:50 says the Most High showed him the city because he “sincerely grieved” for Zion. 10:57 follows as the conclusion of that same explanation.
Sources
- Bensly–James, The Fourth Book of Ezra: The Latin Version (1895)
- M. E. Stone, Fourth Ezra (Hermeneia, 1990), commentary on 9:38–10:59
- B. M. Metzger, '4 Ezra', in J. H. Charlesworth (ed.), The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha vol. 1
- Lewis & Short, A Latin Dictionary, s.v. ager, fundamentum, aedificium
- BDB s.v. שָׂדֶה
- M. E. Stone, Fourth Ezra (Hermeneia; Fortress, 1990), commentary on 9:26–10:59
- B. M. Metzger, 'The Fourth Book of Ezra', in J. H. Charlesworth (ed.), The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, vol. 1 (1983)
- R. L. Bensly and M. R. James, The Fourth Book of Ezra: The Latin Version (Cambridge, 1895)
- Biblia Sacra iuxta Vulgatam Versionem (Weber–Gryson), appendix: Liber Ezrae IIII
- Lewis & Short, A Latin Dictionary, s.v. splendor, aedificium, capax, expavesco, vel
- 2 Baruch 4:2–6 (Syriac Apocalypse of Baruch)
- Ezekiel 40:4; Daniel 10:12, 19; Revelation 21:2, 10–11; Hebrews 11:10
- Michael E. Stone, Fourth Ezra (Hermeneia, 1990), commentary on 2 Esdras 9:26–10:59
- B. M. Metzger, “The Fourth Book of Ezra,” in Charlesworth (ed.), Old Testament Pseudepigrapha vol. 1
- R. L. Bensly, The Fourth Book of Ezra: The Latin Version (1895)
- B. Violet, Die Esra-Apokalypse (GCS)
- G. H. Box, “4 Ezra,” in Charles (ed.), APOT vol. 2
- Lewis & Short, Latin Dictionary s.v. voco, apud, beatus
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
15 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.