2 Esdras Chapter 14 Read as one passage
2 Esdras 14:37–48
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
37So I took the five men, as he commanded me, and we went out into the field, and remained there. 38It came to pass on the next day that, behold, a voice called me, saying, “Esdras, open your mouth, and drink what I give you to drink.” 39Then opened I my mouth, and behold, a full cup was handed to me. It was full of something like water, but its color was like fire. 40I took it, and drank. When I had drunk it, my heart uttered understanding, and wisdom grew in my chest, for my spirit retained its memory. 41My mouth was opened, and shut no more. 42The Most High gave understanding to the five men, and they wrote by course the things that were told them, in characters which they didn’t know, and they sat forty days. Now they wrote in the day-time, and at night they ate bread. 43As for me, I spoke in the day, and by night I didn’t hold my tongue. 44So in forty days, ninety-four books were written. 45It came to pass, when the forty days were fulfilled, that the Most High spoke to me, saying, “The first books that you have written, publish openly, and let the worthy and unworthy read them; 46but keep the last seventy, that you may deliver them to those who are wise among your people; 47for in them is the spring of understanding, the fountain of wisdom, and the stream of knowledge.” 48I did so.
What the first hearers heard
For Jewish readers around AD 100, the Temple was gone, Jerusalem was in ruins, and their whole way of life with God seemed in danger. This story told them that God's word cannot be destroyed. Even if every copy of the Law burned, God could and would give it again through an inspired scribe, just as he first gave it through Moses.
The number 94 did two things:
- It confirmed the public scriptures. The 24 books known in the synagogue were presented as a complete and authoritative set, restored by inspiration and meant for all Israel, "the worthy and the unworthy" (14:45).
- It gave authority to a hidden layer of revelation. The 70 reserved books placed apocalyptic writings, 4 Ezra included, within the same Sinai-like act of revelation. For readers in apocalyptic circles, this explained why such books were not read publicly yet carried the deepest wisdom: they were meant only for "the wise among your people" (14:46).
The forty days and the Moses echoes would have been obvious to them. Ezra is the new Moses, and the community gathered around the restored scriptures after the catastrophe is a renewed Sinai people.
From the study of 2 Esdras 14:44.
Verse by verse
-
37So I took the five men, as he commanded me, and we went out into the field, and remained there.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
38It came to pass on the next day that, behold, a voice called me, saying, “Esdras, open your mouth, and drink what I give you to drink.”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
39Then opened I my mouth, and behold, a full cup was handed to me. It was full of something like water, but its color was like fire.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
40I took it, and drank. When I had drunk it, my heart uttered understanding, and wisdom grew in my chest, for my spirit retained its memory.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
41My mouth was opened, and shut no more.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
42The Most High gave understanding to the five men, and they wrote by course the things that were told them, in characters which they didn’t know, and they sat forty days. Now they wrote in the day-time, and at night they ate bread.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
43As for me, I spoke in the day, and by night I didn’t hold my tongue.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
44So in forty days, ninety-four books were written.
Full study →Over forty days, as Moses once spent on Sinai, ninety-four written works came into being again. They were dictated by Ezra under the Spirit's inspiration and taken down by five scribes in a script they did not know.
The number matters. In the next verses God orders twenty-four of them to be published for everyone, worthy and unworthy alike. That is the familiar count of Israel's scriptures as Jews numbered them. The other seventy are to be held back and passed only to the wise, because they contain "the spring of understanding, the fountain of wisdom, and the river of knowledge" (14:47).
So the verse is not just a production total. It describes the Law, which had been burned (14:21), being fully restored after disaster, and it claims that alongside the public scriptures God gave a larger, hidden library of revelation of the kind this book itself belongs to.
-
45It came to pass, when the forty days were fulfilled, that the Most High spoke to me, saying, “The first books that you have written, publish openly, and let the worthy and unworthy read them;
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
46but keep the last seventy, that you may deliver them to those who are wise among your people;
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
47for in them is the spring of understanding, the fountain of wisdom, and the stream of knowledge.”
Full study →"For inside these hidden books runs the underground vein that feeds understanding, the spring from which wisdom rises, and the river in which knowledge flows."
God is explaining to Ezra why seventy of the books he has just dictated must be kept back and given only to "the wise among your people" (v. 46). The reason is not that they are minor or dangerous. It is that they are the source. The three water images move in order: a hidden vein under the ground, a spring where the water comes up, and a full river. The three things the water carries, understanding, wisdom and knowledge, are the classic trio Israel's wisdom tradition used for the complete God-given ability to know God's ways. The picture also looks back a few verses: Ezra received these books by drinking a cup of something "like water, but its colour was like fire" (14:39–40), after which understanding poured out of his heart. So the water of the books is the same divine water Ezra drank. In a land where springs meant life, calling these books the spring of wisdom was the highest praise the writer could give them.
(Note: the original Hebrew or Aramaic is lost. This reading rests mainly on the Latin translation, checked against what is known of the Syriac and other eastern versions.)
-
48I did so.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v44
books
libri (Latin; Hebrew/Aramaic original lost, probably sefarim)
- What we hear
- Bound volumes, and in a Bible context the separately numbered books of the modern Old Testament (39 in Protestant Bibles).
- What they heard
- Scrolls or separate written works, counted the way Jewish tradition grouped them. So the '24' public books here hold the same material as the 39 Protestant Old Testament books, grouped differently (the Twelve Minor Prophets as one, Samuel, Kings and Chronicles each as one, and so on).
-
in v47
fountain
fons (Latin; Semitic original lost, perhaps maqor or maʿyan)
- What we hear
- An ornamental, man-made water feature in a park or square.
- What they heard
- A natural spring where living water rises from the ground: the origin and life-source of water in a dry land.
Every word
-
Scripti
scripti
written · v44
Perfect passive participle ('having been written'), placed first for emphasis. The stress falls on the finished act of writing: what had been lost (14:21) now exists in writing again.
-
sunt
sunt
are / were · v44
Joins the participle to make the passive 'were written'. The sentence names no writer. Context (14:37–43) makes clear that Ezra dictated by inspiration and five men wrote it down.
-
autem
autem
and, now, moreover · v44
A light connective that moves the story from the process (Ezra speaking day and night, 14:43) to its result. WEB renders it 'So'.
-
in
in
in, within · v44, v47
Gives the time span inside which the work was completed.
-
quadraginta
quadraginta
forty · v44
Picks up the forty days set in 14:23 and echoes Moses' forty days on Sinai, when the Law was first given (Exodus 24:18; 34:28).
-
diebus
diebus
days · v44
Ablative of time. Verse 43 has already said the work went on by day and by night, so the forty days are continuous, like Moses' stay on the mountain.
-
libri
libri
books, written works · v44
In the first century these were scrolls or separate written works, not bound volumes. The count follows how Jewish tradition grouped its scriptures, not modern book divisions.
-
nonaginta
nonaginta
ninety · v44
The best-supported reading. With 'four' it makes 94, which the next two verses split into 24 public books and 70 reserved for the wise.
-
quattuor
quattuor
four · v44
Completes the total of 94 (24 + 70). The Latin variants keep 'four' but change the hundreds or tens, a common kind of copying error with numbers.
-
his
his
-
enim
enim
for, because · v47
Gives the reason for the command in 14:46. The seventy are held back not because they are worth less but because they hold the source itself.
-
est
est
is · v47
A singular verb with three subjects after it. Spring, fountain and river are treated as one flowing reality seen three ways.
-
vena
vena
vein; water-channel; spring · v47
Literally a 'vein': in Latin also the hidden underground channel that feeds a spring, or a seam of ore in rock. The picture is of the hidden source, which fits books that are kept hidden.
-
intellectus
intellectus
understanding, discernment · v47
The ability to see into things and tell them apart. In the Latin Bible this word often stands for Hebrew binah ('discernment'). Here it is the insight the hidden books give.
-
et
et
and · v47
Links the first image to the second.
-
sapientiae
sapientiae
of wisdom · v47
Stands for Hebrew-style 'wisdom' (ḥokhmah): skill in living rightly that comes from God, which in Ezra's day was closely tied to the Law and to God's revealed secrets.
-
fons
fons
spring, fountain · v47
A natural spring where water comes up out of the ground: the point where the water first appears. It is not a decorative fountain.
-
scientiae
scientiae
of knowledge · v47
Knowledge in the biblical sense (Hebrew daʿat): knowing God's ways and purposes, here especially the hidden plan for the ages. It does not mean 'science' or neutral facts.
-
flumen
flumen
river, stream, flowing water · v47
A full, flowing river, the last stage of the water image. The trickle in the hidden channel becomes a spring and then a river.
The world behind it
After the Temple fell. Chapters 3–14 of 2 Esdras, also called 4 Ezra, were written by a Jewish author around AD 100, about thirty years after Rome destroyed Jerusalem and the Temple in AD 70. The author sets the story in the time after Babylon destroyed Jerusalem in 586 BC and uses the scribe Ezra as his hero. The real subject is his own generation's crisis.
The lost Law. In chapter 14 Ezra complains that "your law has been burned, and so no one knows the things that have been done or will be done by you" (14:21). He asks God for the Holy Spirit so that he can write it all again. God tells him to prepare many writing tablets and take five fast scribes (Sarea, Dabria, Selemia, Ethanus, Asiel). He then gives Ezra a cup "full of something like water, but its colour was like fire" (14:39). Ezra's understanding is opened, he dictates for forty days and nights, and the scribes write.
Why 24 and 70. By the late first century Jews counted their scriptures as 24 books (for example, the Twelve Minor Prophets counted as one book, and Samuel, Kings, Chronicles and Ezra–Nehemiah each counted as one). Josephus, writing at the same time, gives 22, probably by joining Ruth to Judges and Lamentations to Jeremiah. This verse, read with 14:45, is the earliest surviving witness to the 24-book count. The 70 hidden books stand for the wider body of apocalyptic and wisdom writings, revelatory books such as those attributed to Enoch and to Ezra himself, which their circles believed were meant only for the initiated.
Connections. The New Testament does not quote this passage. The idea of Ezra as restorer of the scriptures does appear in later Jewish tradition (b. Sanhedrin 21b–22a; b. Sukkah 20a: "when the Torah was forgotten, Ezra came up from Babylon and re-established it") and in early Christian writers (Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.21.2). These clearly share the tradition, though they may not depend directly on 4 Ezra.
From the study of 2 Esdras 14:44.
Where scholars differ
in v44
Does the '24' show that the Hebrew canon (the agreed list of scriptures) was already closed by about AD 100?
-
Yes. It shows a fixed, widely known 24-book collection.
The author can use '24' without explaining it. Josephus at about the same time speaks of a fixed number (22) that no one has dared to add to or take from (Against Apion 1.42). The rabbinic list in b. Bava Batra 14b fits.
-
It shows a dominant count, not a formally closed list.
Rabbinic debates over Ecclesiastes and the Song of Songs went on into the 2nd century (m. Yadayim 3:5). In the same breath 4 Ezra gives 70 more books high authority, which suggests the boundaries of authoritative writing were still disputed in some circles.
in v44
What are the 70 hidden books?
-
Apocalyptic and esoteric writings like 4 Ezra itself, 1 Enoch and similar works.
14:46–47 describe them as reserved for the wise and full of understanding and knowledge. 4 Ezra elsewhere presents itself as secret revelation (12:37–38). Most commentators (e.g. Stone, Metzger) take this view.
-
A symbolic number for the whole body of hidden wisdom, not a real list.
Seventy is a traditional number of completeness (the 70 nations, the 70 elders). The author probably had no catalogue of exactly 70 titles in mind.
in v47
What are the seventy hidden books?
-
Apocalyptic and esoteric revelation literature, including 4 Ezra itself.
4 Ezra's visions are themselves presented as hidden revelation for the wise (compare 12:37–38, where Ezra is told to write his visions in a book and teach them to the wise). The 'Moses was told to keep some things secret' pattern (14:5–6) matches books like 1 Enoch and Jubilees, which claim hidden revelation going back to ancient figures.
-
A symbolic number for the whole body of hidden tradition, not a literal list of books.
Seventy is a stock number for completeness (nations, elders). The text names no titles. Some compare it to the later rabbinic idea that Moses received an 'oral Torah' alongside the written one, though 4 Ezra speaks of written books.
in v47
Does the verse rank the hidden books above the public Scriptures?
-
Yes: the seventy are the deeper source and the twenty-four are the outer layer for everyone.
Only the seventy are called the spring, fountain and river. The twenty-four are for 'worthy and unworthy', the seventy only for the wise (M. E. Stone and others read the passage as giving esoteric books the highest place).
-
It is about access more than rank: both layers come from the same inspiration.
All 94 books come out of the same forty days of dictation after the same fiery drink (14:38–44). The difference in v. 45–46 is about who reads them, and the 24 are Ezra's restoration of the burned Law, the main problem chapter 14 sets out to solve (14:21–22).
Sources
- Bensly, R. L. and M. R. James, The Fourth Book of Ezra: The Latin Version (1895)
- Violet, B., Die Esra-Apokalypse (IV. Esra) (GCS, 1910)
- Stone, M. E., Fourth Ezra (Hermeneia, 1990), on 14:37–48
- Metzger, B. M., 'The Fourth Book of Ezra', in Charlesworth (ed.), Old Testament Pseudepigrapha vol. 1 (1983)
- Josephus, Against Apion 1.37–43
- Babylonian Talmud, Bava Batra 14b–15a; Sanhedrin 21b–22a; Sukkah 20a
- Mishnah Yadayim 3:5
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.21.2
- Jubilees 1
- Latin Vulgate (Weber–Gryson), Liber Ezrae IIII 14:47
- M. E. Stone, Fourth Ezra (Hermeneia, 1990), commentary on 14:37–48
- B. M. Metzger, "The Fourth Book of Ezra," in J. H. Charlesworth (ed.), The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, vol. 1
- Lewis & Short, A Latin Dictionary, s.v. vena, fons, flumen
- Proverbs 3:19–20; 18:4; Sirach 24:23–31; Baruch 3:12; 1 Enoch 48:1; 49:1
- Dead Sea Scrolls: Community Rule (1QS) 10.12; 11.3; Damascus Document (CD) 6.3–9
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
10 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.