Deuteronomy Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Deuteronomy 5:22–26
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
22The LORD spoke these commandments in a loud voice to your whole assembly out of the fire, the cloud, and the deep darkness on the mountain; He added nothing more. And He wrote them on two tablets of stone and gave them to me. 23And when you heard the voice out of the darkness while the mountain was blazing with fire, all the heads of your tribes and your elders approached me, 24and you said, “Behold, the LORD our God has shown us His glory and greatness, and we have heard His voice out of the fire. Today we have seen that a man can live even if God speaks with him. 25But now, why should we die? For this great fire will consume us, and we will die, if we hear the voice of the LORD our God any longer. 26For who of all flesh has heard the voice of the living God speaking out of the fire, as we have, and survived?
What the first hearers heard
For Israel on the plains of Moab, the verse did several things:
- It made them witnesses. 'Your assembly' puts the new generation at Horeb. The covenant is not their parents' agreement but their own (5:2–3). Nobody could say they had not heard, because God spoke to all.
- It set the Ten Words apart. God spoke only these directly, wrote only these himself, and 'added no more'. They are the core of everything else. The many laws in Deuteronomy 12–26 are taught by Moses as working out what these words mean in practice.
- It established Moses' role. The tablets were handed 'to me'. The next verses explain that the people themselves asked for a go-between. Moses' teaching therefore carries the authority of the God who spoke from the fire, but it is not the same thing as the direct voice. Deuteronomy carefully keeps that difference.
- It shaped how they worshipped. Fire, cloud and darkness without any visible form reinforced the ban on images. God's presence was known by his voice and his written words, kept in the ark, not by a statue.
- It warned them to take it seriously. A voice like that was terrifying (5:24–26). Hearing it and living was a privilege, and it bound them to obey.
From the study of Deuteronomy 5:22.
Verse by verse
-
22The LORD spoke these commandments in a loud voice to your whole assembly out of the fire, the cloud, and the deep darkness on the mountain; He added nothing more. And He wrote them on two tablets of stone and gave them to me.
Full study →These words, exactly these and no others, Yahweh himself spoke out loud to the whole gathered people of Israel at the mountain. His voice came out of the middle of a blazing fire, a cloud, and a black storm-darkness, so that they heard him clearly but saw no shape. It was a huge voice, loud enough for a whole nation, overwhelming and frightening. Then he spoke no more. The Ten Words were the complete set of what God said directly to everyone. Nothing was added to them then, and nothing is to be added to them (compare 4:2). And he wrote them himself on two slabs of stone, a permanent written copy of what had been spoken, and handed them to me, Moses, the go-between who would look after them.
Moses is saying this decades later to the next generation, and he says 'your assembly' as though they had stood at Horeb themselves. The verse rounds off the Ten Words in three steps: they were spoken by God to all, they are complete, and they were written and handed over. It also prepares for what comes next, when the terrified people beg Moses to listen to God for them (5:23–27).
-
23And when you heard the voice out of the darkness while the mountain was blazing with fire, all the heads of your tribes and your elders approached me,
Full study →"Then this is what happened. While you were hearing that voice, speaking out of the heart of the black cloud while the whole mountain went on blazing with fire, you came up to me. All the heads of your tribes and your elders came."
Moses is speaking to Israel on the plains of Moab, forty years after Horeb, and he says "you heard". Most of his listeners were children or not yet born at the mountain, but Deuteronomy treats every generation as having stood there (5:3: "not with our fathers… but with us, all of us here alive today").
The scene is a deliberate paradox. The voice comes from darkness, the cloud that hides God, while the mountain burns with fire, the sign that he is present and dangerous. These are the same words used of the bush at this mountain in Exodus 3:2, "burning with fire". Now the whole mountain is the bush, and the whole nation is watching. Israel heard words spoken to it directly, not just thunder, and saw no form (4:12).
Then the people "drew near". That verb usually describes approaching God in worship, but here the nation's recognised representatives (tribal heads and clan elders) come near to Moses, because they dare not come near the fire. Their speech follows in verses 24–27: we have heard God and lived, but if we keep listening we will die, so you go near and tell us what he says. With this verse the request for a human go-between begins, and God will approve it (5:28).
-
24and you said, “Behold, the LORD our God has shown us His glory and greatness, and we have heard His voice out of the fire. Today we have seen that a man can live even if God speaks with him.
Full study →Look! Yahweh, our own God, has made us see his glory: the crushing, blazing weight of his presence. He has made us see how vast he is. And his voice, the voice itself, we heard, coming from the very middle of the fire, at once thunder and words. This very day we have found out something no one would have expected: God can speak directly with a mortal human being, and that human stays alive.
The sentence is built to end on its last word. In Hebrew, and lives comes last, and it is the point. Everyone assumed that coming this close to God would kill you, and the same two closing words appear in Exodus 33:20, where God says no human can see his face "and live." So this is the awed, shaken report of survivors. It is not a calm statement that God likes to converse with people. The very next verse shows how the discovery landed: they do not ask for more. They say, in effect, "We got through it once. Why risk dying?"
-
25But now, why should we die? For this great fire will consume us, and we will die, if we hear the voice of the LORD our God any longer.
Full study →"So then, why should we die? This great fire will devour us. If we go on hearing the voice of Yahweh our God any more, we will die."
The people have just said something astonishing (v.24). They saw God's glory, they heard his voice out of the fire, and they are still alive. Verse 25 is the conclusion they draw. Surviving once was a gift, not a sign that they can bear it again. Why should we die? is less a question than a plea not to push past a gift.
The fire does not simply "burn". In Hebrew it eats. The verb comes first, so the threat is heard before the fire is named: it will devour us, this great fire right here. Their hearers would remember that this same God is called "a devouring fire" (4:24) and that holy fire had "eaten" people who came near the wrong way (Lev 10:2).
The condition is worded with care: if we keep adding to our hearing. They are not complaining about what God said. They are saying that continued direct exposure to that voice, which carried words and sounded like thunder, is more than flesh can take (v.26: "who of all flesh…?"). The added "we" is stressed: we, mere mortals. And they still call him our God.
The verse starts and ends with die. That frame carries the terror. It also carries the request that follows (v.27): Moses should go near and hear, and then tell them. God answers that they have "done well in all they have spoken" (v.28).
-
26For who of all flesh has heard the voice of the living God speaking out of the fire, as we have, and survived?
Full study →"Because who in the whole race of mortal, perishable creatures has ever heard the actual voice of the God who is life itself (the thunder-voice, speaking real words from inside the blazing fire on the mountain) the way we just did, and come out of it alive?"
The question expects the answer no one. The verse is built on life and death. On one side is "all flesh," the human race seen as fragile bodies that die. On the other is the "living God," who has life in himself and in whose presence a creature should be overwhelmed. Between them comes the event: God speaking words, out of the midst of fire. The last word, "and lived," picks up "living" from earlier in the verse. The Living One spoke, and against every expectation mortals stayed alive.
The verse is not a cheerful boast. It is the reason ("for…") behind the people's plea in verse 25: "Why should we die? This great fire will consume us." They have survived once and see it as a wonder (v. 24). They do not think they can survive it again. So in verse 27 they ask Moses to go near, listen, and bring God's words back to them, and they promise to "hear and do." The privilege of hearing God directly and the terror of it are held together. Moses is retelling it decades later, and his "like us" draws the listening generation into that same moment at the mountain.
Where the English drifted
-
in v22
commandments (BSB, NIV)
devarim
- What we hear
- A list of rules or orders, the 'Ten Commandments' as a moral code.
- What they heard
- 'Words': spoken speech from God. The set opens with a statement of who he is and what he did (5:6) before any command, and Scripture's own label for the set is 'the ten words'.
-
in v22
tables of stone (KJV)
luchot 'avanim
- What we hear
- Stone tables (furniture).
- What they heard
- Flat stone writing slabs, tablets.
-
in v23
elders
zeqenim (zaqen)
- What we hear
- Either elderly people in general, or members of a church leadership board.
- What they heard
- The senior heads of households and clans who acted as the recognised representatives and judges of their kin-groups. It was a civic and tribal position, not just a matter of age.
-
in v24
glory
kavod
- What we hear
- Praise, fame, or a soft heavenly radiance; something people give to God in worship.
- What they heard
- God's overwhelming weight and importance made perceptible, here in the fire and darkness on the mountain. Something that could be stood before, and that might kill you.
-
in v24
man / a man (KJV, WEB, BSB)
ha'adam
- What we hear
- A male, or one particular individual such as Moses.
- What they heard
- A human being as such, any mortal, set in contrast with God. The elders are speaking about themselves and about humanity in general.
-
in v24
talk (KJV)
dibber
- What we hear
- Friendly, relaxed conversation, the sort of relationship in which God and a person chat.
- What they heard
- Direct divine speech heard from a burning mountain by frightened listeners. Only God speaks in this scene.
-
in v24
liveth / lives
vachai
- What we hear
- Is given life or has spiritual life through God's word.
- What they heard
- Stays alive, is not killed. The same form is used of the accidental killer who reaches a city of refuge and escapes death (Deuteronomy 19:5).
-
in v25
the LORD
YHWH (Yahweh)
- What we hear
- A title, 'the Lord', meaning master or ruler, as if 'the LORD our God' meant 'our master and God'.
- What they heard
- God's personal name. Ten verses earlier God introduces himself by it (5:6, 'I am Yahweh your God'). The people speak of a named God with a known history with them, not of a generic sovereign.
-
in v26
all flesh
kol basar
- What we hear
- Human beings in their sinful, carnal nature ("the flesh" as the part of us that pulls toward sin).
- What they heard
- Every mortal creature, humanity as frail, perishable bodies. The contrast is with the *living* God, not with holiness or the Spirit in a moral sense.
-
in v26
the living God
elohim chayyim
- What we hear
- God who exists or is "alive" rather than dead; sometimes a soft, comforting phrase.
- What they heard
- The God who acts with real power, has life in himself and gives or takes it (Deut 32:39), set against mortal flesh and powerless idols (Jer 10:10). Here that fullness of life is exactly what makes contact with him seem deadly.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v25
God called Israel's fear at Sinai 'well spoken', not a failure
- What's often taught
- At Sinai, Israel drew back from God out of fear and chose a go-between instead of hearing him directly. On this reading, the plea in Deut 5:25 is a failure of faith, a refusal of closeness that believers should not repeat.
- What the text supports
The people's words in 5:24–27 get a direct verdict from God in the next verse: "They have done well in all that they have spoken" (5:28, hêṭîbû). God then wishes they would keep that heart, "to fear me and keep all my commandments always" (5:29). He agrees to the arrangement they asked for: Moses stands near and passes on the law (5:31).
Deuteronomy 18:16–18 builds Israel's line of prophets on this very request: "this is what you asked at Horeb… 'Let me not hear again the voice of Yahweh my God… lest I die.'"
What the common reading gets right: 5:29 does contain a worry. God wishes their reverence would last, and the rest of Israel's story shows it often didn't. Exod 20:20 likewise tells them not to fear in one sense (not to panic) so that the fear of God may stay with them. The text treats lasting awe, not the request for a mediator, as the open question. The plea itself is approved.
- Where the English feeds it
- Not much. The English is clear. The misreading usually comes from reading the scene without v.28, or through Heb 12:18–21, which contrasts Sinai with Zion but does not condemn the people's request.
Every word
-
אֶֽת־
'et · H0853
[object marker] · v22, v23, v24, v25
Not translated. It marks 'these words' as the object of the verb. Because the object comes before the verb, the sentence opens with emphasis: *these* words, and no others, are the ones God spoke.
-
הַדְּבָרִ֣ים
ha-devarim · H1697
-
הָאֵ֡לֶּה
ha-'elleh · H0428
these · v22
Points back to the exact words just quoted and draws a line around them: this set, and only this set, came straight from God's mouth to the whole people.
-
דִּבֶּר֩
dibber · H1696
he spoke · v22, v24, v26
The verb 'speak' shares a root with the noun 'words' (devarim): 'the words that he worded'. The repeated root stresses that this was real, articulate speech, not only thunder.
-
יְהוָ֨ה
YHWH · H3068
Yahweh (the LORD) · v22, v24, v25
Israel's God, named personally. English versions write it 'the LORD' in capitals. The speaker is God himself, not Moses.
-
אֶל־
'el · H0413
to · v22, v23
Names who received the speech: it was aimed at the people directly.
-
כָּל־
kol · H3605
all, whole · v22, v23, v26
The entire gathering heard it, not just the leaders. Everyone was a witness, and that is the point being made.
-
קְהַלְכֶ֜ם
qehalkhem · H6951
your assembly · v22
The people called together as a body. 'Your' is plural and is said to the next generation on the plains of Moab, as if they had stood there themselves (compare 5:3).
-
בָּהָ֗ר
ba-har · H2022
at the mountain · v22, v23
Horeb, Deuteronomy's usual name for Sinai. 'The mountain' needs no name here because everyone knew which one was meant.
-
מִתּ֤וֹךְ
mi-tokh · H8432
-
הָאֵשׁ֙
ha-'esh · H0784
-
הֶֽעָנָ֣ן
he-'anan · H6051
the cloud · v22
The cloud that both reveals and hides God's presence, the same cloud that led Israel in the wilderness. There is no 'and' before it in Hebrew, so the three nouns pile up one after another.
-
וְהָֽעֲרָפֶ֔ל
ve-ha-'arafel · H6205
and the thick darkness · v22
Dense, black storm-cloud. It is a regular word for the darkness around God himself (Exod 20:21; 1 Kgs 8:12; Ps 97:2). This is not ordinary night-time dark.
-
ק֥וֹל
qol · H6963
voice, sound · v22, v23, v24, v25, v26
A voice, though the same word also means 'thunder' (Exod 19:16). Here it is a voice speaking words. Grammatically it describes how God spoke: 'with a great voice'.
-
גָּד֖וֹל
gadol · H1419
great, loud · v22, v25
Loud enough for a whole people to hear, and also grand and overwhelming. The response in 5:24–26 shows it was terrifying.
-
וְלֹ֣א
ve-lo · H3808
and not · v22
Negates the verb that follows.
-
יָסָ֑ף
yasaf · H3254
he added · v22, v25
'He did not add': God spoke these Ten Words to everyone directly and then said nothing more to the whole people. Everything else came through Moses (5:31). An old Jewish reading takes it as 'and it did not stop' (see debates).
-
וַֽיִּכְתְּבֵ֗ם
va-yikhtevem · H3789
and he wrote them · v22
God himself is the one who writes, 'with the finger of God' (9:10). Writing them down fixes the spoken words as a permanent document.
-
עַל־
'al · H5921
upon · v22
The surface the words were written on.
-
שְׁנֵי֙
shenei · H8147
two · v22
Two tablets. Why there were two is debated: either the text was split between them, or each was a full copy (see debates).
-
לֻחֹ֣ת
luchot · H3871
tablets · v22
Flat slabs for writing on. They were small enough for Moses to carry and to fit in the ark (10:1–5).
-
אֲבָנִ֔ים
'avanim · H0068
stones · v22
'Tablets of stones', meaning stone tablets. Stone suggests something permanent that cannot be changed, the standard material for monuments meant to last.
-
וַֽיִּתְּנֵ֖ם
va-yittenem · H5414
and he gave them · v22
Handed them over to someone's keeping. The same verb is used for God 'giving' the land, so this is an act of granting something.
-
וַיְהִ֗י
vayhi · H1961
and it was / and it came to pass · v23
The standard storytelling opener that sets a past scene. It means little alone; it marks the start of a remembered episode, much like 'Now it happened that…'.
-
כְּשָׁמְעֲכֶ֤ם
keshom'akhem · H8085
when you heard · v23, v24, v25, v26
Literally 'as your hearing'. The 'you' is plural and is aimed at the generation listening to Moses in Moab, as if they had stood at the mountain themselves. In Hebrew, shama' also leans toward heeding, and that is where the passage goes next (vv. 27–29).
-
הַחֹ֔שֶׁךְ
hachoshekh · H2822
-
בֹּעֵ֣ר
bo'er · H1197
burning · v23
A participle, meaning the action was ongoing: the mountain was burning the whole time the voice spoke. These are the same words Exodus 3:2 uses for the bush 'burning with fire' on this same mountain.
-
וַתִּקְרְב֣וּן
vattiqrevun · H7126
and you drew near · v23
'And you came near'. The verb ends with an extra -n, a fuller and possibly older-sounding form that may add weight. Qarav is also the word for approaching God in worship and for bringing offerings, so there is irony here: Israel draws near to Moses because it dares not draw near to the fire.
-
רָאשֵׁ֥י
rashei · H7218
heads of · v23
'Heads': leading men of the tribal and clan structure, the kind of officers described in Deuteronomy 1:13–15.
-
שִׁבְטֵיכֶ֖ם
shivteikhem · H7626
your tribes · v23
'Your tribes'. Shevet literally means rod or staff, the leader's mark of authority, and from there it came to mean the kin-group that leader heads.
-
וְזִקְנֵיכֶֽם׃
veziqneikhem · H2205
and your elders · v23
'And your elders': senior men who headed households and clans and spoke for them in public matters. It was a recognised position of authority, not just a word for old people.
-
וַתֹּאמְר֗וּ
vattomeru · H0559
to say · v24
'And you said.' Moses is speaking to the assembly on the plains of Moab and attributes to them, as a single people, what their tribal heads and elders said at Horeb decades earlier.
-
הֵ֣ן
hen · H2005
look! · v24
An attention-grabbing 'Look!' that points at something undeniable. It opens the elders' speech with the sound of people still taking in what has just happened.
-
הֶרְאָ֜נוּ
her'anu · H7200G
see; (this form) cause to see · v24
'He has made us see.' The verb form makes God the one who causes the seeing: they did not get a look at him by their own effort, he put this in front of them.
-
אֱלֹהֵ֙ינוּ֙
eloheinu · H0430G
God · v24, v25, v26
'Our God.' The possessive marks the bond between this people and this God, and it makes a contrast with the plain, general 'God' later in the verse.
-
כְּבֹד֣וֹ
kevodo · H3519
glory, honor, weightiness · v24
'His glory': God's overwhelming importance made perceptible. Here that means the fire, darkness and blazing mountain they have just witnessed, not fame or praise.
-
גָּדְל֔וֹ
godlo · H1433
-
הַיּ֤וֹם
hayyom · H3117L
day; with the article, today · v24
'The day.' With the next word it fixes the discovery to one particular day.
-
הַזֶּה֙
hazzeh · H2088
this · v24
'This very day.' The emphatic phrasing gives the sense of people reporting something that has only just become true for them.
-
כִּֽי־
ki · H3588A
that, for · v24, v25, v26
'That.' It introduces the content of what they found out.
-
אֶת־
et · H0854
with · v24
Spelled like the object marker earlier in the verse, but this is a different word meaning 'with'. God speaks with a human being, in that human's presence, though only God is speaking here.
-
הָֽאָדָ֖ם
ha'adam · H0120G
human being, humankind · v24
'The human': a person as a member of the human race, not a male as opposed to a female. It sets the mortal creature directly across from God.
-
וָחָֽי׃
vachai · H2421
to live, stay alive · v24, v26
'And lives,' meaning survives, is not killed. The last word of the verse is the astonishing part, and the same word pair closes Exodus 33:20, where no human can see God's face 'and live.'
-
וְעַתָּה֙
wəʿattāh · H6258
and now · v25
Moves from what has happened (v.24, 'we have seen that a man can live') to what follows from it. It works like 'so then': the people are drawing a conclusion, not marking a clock time.
-
לָ֣מָּה
lāmmāh · H4100
why? · v25
Literally 'for what?'. A question that isn't really asking anything: 'what would be the point of dying?' They survived once, so why push their luck.
-
נָמ֔וּת
nāmût · H4191
we will die / should we die · v25
An open-ended verb form that here carries the sense 'should we die'. The first of two 'die' verbs that bracket the whole verse.
-
תֹֽאכְלֵ֔נוּ
tōʾkəlēnû · H398
it will eat us · v25
The ordinary verb for eating. Fire 'eats' in Hebrew. The verb comes before its subject, so the threat lands first: 'it will devour us, this great fire'.
-
הַזֹּ֑את
hazzōʾt · H2063
this · v25
Points at it: 'this fire right here', still burning in front of them.
-
אִם־
ʾim · H518
if · v25
Opens the condition. The people put the danger in terms of what they do next, not as fate.
-
אֲנַ֗חְנוּ
ʾănaḥnû · H587
we · v25
A separate pronoun the verb doesn't need, so it adds stress: 'we, mere flesh' (compare 'all flesh' in v.26).
-
ע֖וֹד
ʿôd · H5750
again, still, any more · v25
Repeats the idea of 'adding'. Doubling it ('add to hear… again') stresses that one hearing was all they could survive.
-
מִ֣י
mi · H4310
who? · v26
A rhetorical question that expects the answer "no one." It works as a strong denial: nobody else has ever had this happen and come out alive.
-
בָּשָׂ֡ר
basar · H1320
flesh, body, mortal being · v26
Humanity seen as perishable bodies. It is set against the "living God" who comes next: fragile, dying creatures beside the source of life itself. No moral sense of 'sinful nature' here.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
asher · H0834A
who, which, that · v26
Introduces the description: "who has heard."
-
חַיִּ֜ים
chayyim · H2416A
living, alive · v26
"Living" agrees in the plural with elohim. It marks God as the active, powerful One who has life in himself and gives it. That stands against "all flesh," which dies, and against lifeless idols.
-
כָּמֹ֖נוּ
kamonu · H3644G
like, as (+ us) · v26
"Like us" / "as we have." It sets this people apart as the only ones it has happened to. Moses retells the words to a new generation, and the "us" pulls them into the event too.
The world behind it
Where this sits. Deuteronomy is presented as Moses' farewell speeches on the plains of Moab, just before Israel enters Canaan. The generation that stood at Horeb (Sinai) has mostly died in the wilderness. Moses has just repeated the Ten Words (5:6–21) and now recalls how they were given. Then he explains why every other law came through him: the people could not bear God's voice (5:23–31).
Treaty background. Treaties between kings and their vassals in the ancient Near East were written documents. They set out the great king's identity and his past good deeds, then the vassal's obligations. Copies were placed in the temples of each party and read aloud at set times. The Ten Words follow the same pattern: who God is and what he did ('I am Yahweh your God who brought you out...'), then the demands. Stone tablets kept in the ark (10:1–5) and regular public readings (31:9–13) fit that world.
Theophany. When God appeared in power, the Bible describes it with storm imagery: fire, cloud, thunder, darkness. Israel's neighbours told similar stories about storm-gods. Deuteronomy uses the imagery but insists on one difference: Israel heard a voice and saw no form (4:12, 15). The darkness hides God, and that hiddenness is the basis for the ban on images.
From the study of Deuteronomy 5:22.
Where scholars differ
in v22
Does 've-lo yasaf' mean 'he added no more' or 'it did not stop'?
-
'He added no more': God spoke the Ten Words directly and then nothing further to the whole people.
This is the normal sense of *yasaf* with 'not' (e.g. Gen 38:26; Deut 4:2; 13:1). It fits the context, where the people ask Moses to listen for them (5:23–27). The Septuagint and Vulgate take it this way, and so do nearly all modern versions and commentaries.
-
'And it did not cease': God's great voice goes on sounding, and revelation keeps coming.
Targum Onkelos (*ve-la pesaq*) and later rabbinic interpretation, recorded by Rashi. Rabbinic tradition built on it the idea that the Sinai voice keeps speaking through later teaching. It is a very old reading, though less natural in the Hebrew.
in v22
Why two tablets?
-
The Ten Words were divided between them, for example duties to God and duties to neighbour.
Traditional Jewish and Christian view, found as early as Philo and Josephus. It fits the two-part content of the Ten Words, though the Bible never says how they were split.
-
Each tablet held a complete copy, one for each party, like duplicate treaty documents.
Proposed from ancient Near Eastern treaty practice, where copies were placed in the sanctuaries of both parties (associated with M. G. Kline and others). Both copies would be kept in the ark, God's sanctuary in Israel's midst. It is suggestive, but it is a comparison and not stated in the text.
in v22
How does 'these words' relate to the differences between Exodus 20 and Deuteronomy 5?
-
Deuteronomy is Moses' preached retelling. The wording was shaped for the new generation, and the substance is what God wrote.
Common in critical and many evangelical commentaries. Moses says God wrote 'these words', but the speech context allows faithful restatement.
-
Both forms were spoken at once by divine power.
Rabbinic tradition ('remember' and 'observe' were spoken in a single utterance), found in the Mekhilta and the Talmud. This is a theological harmonisation rather than a reading drawn from the text itself.
in v23
Did the whole people hear God's articulate words, or only a great sound that Moses then interpreted?
-
The whole assembly heard all the Ten Words directly from God.
Deuteronomy 5:4 ('face to face YHWH spoke with you'), 5:22 ('YHWH spoke these words to all your assembly… with a great voice'), 4:12 ('you heard the sound of words'), 4:33, and v. 24 ('we have heard his voice').
-
The people heard only part directly, or heard a voice without making out words, and Moses relayed the content.
Exodus 19:19 and 20:19 suggest Moses' role as go-between even at the mountain. Deuteronomy 5:5 has Moses 'standing between YHWH and you… for you were afraid'. Rabbinic tradition (b. Makkot 24a) held that Israel heard only the first two commandments from God himself, and medieval interpreters such as Maimonides argued the people heard a sound but grasped the words through Moses. Many modern commentators (e.g. Tigay, Weinfeld) see tension within ch. 5 between verse 5 and verses 4 and 22.
in v23
Who 'drew near' to Moses: the whole people or only its leaders?
-
The leaders acted as representatives, and the 'you' is the people acting through them.
The Hebrew says 'you drew near' and then explains it: 'all the heads of your tribes and your elders'. Representative leadership is a theme in Deuteronomy (1:13–15).
-
The whole people approached, and Deuteronomy highlights the leaders as its spokesmen.
Exodus 20:18–19 speaks of 'all the people'. In Deuteronomy 5:24–27 the speech uses 'we' for the nation, and in 5:28 God responds to 'the words of this people'.
in v24
Is the last clause a general truth, or a report of what just happened?
-
It is a general discovery: God can speak with humans and they can survive.
The verb form (Hebrew imperfect) often expresses what can or does happen, and the switch to generic 'God' and 'the human' suggests a wider statement. BSB and NIV read it this way, and KJV and WEB imply it.
-
It is mainly a statement of the astonishing thing just experienced, not a rule.
'This very day we have seen' ties it to one event. Verse 25 shows the speakers do not trust it as a rule, since they fear they will die if it happens again. Verse 26 treats their survival as without precedent.
in v24
What did they actually 'see' at Horeb, given that Deuteronomy says they saw no form?
-
Deuteronomy deliberately plays down any visible divine presence: God is in heaven and only his voice comes to earth. 'Glory' here is at most the visible effects.
Deuteronomy 4:12, 15 says 'you saw no form', and 4:36 says the voice came 'from heaven'. The noun kavod is otherwise missing from Deuteronomy's vocabulary for God's presence, which von Rad and Weinfeld connect with a move away from older presence language.
-
Deuteronomy keeps a real divine presence on the mountain; it only denies that any shape could be copied as an idol.
This verse says Yahweh 'made us see his glory', 5:4 says 'face to face', and the refrain 'from the middle of the fire' places the voice on the mountain. Ian Wilson (*Out of the Midst of the Fire*) argues for this, and 4:15-19 links 'no form' specifically to the ban on images.
in v25
How does v.25 ('why should we die?') fit with v.24 ('a man can live even if God speaks with him')?
-
Survival as a one-time exception: they lived once, so going on would be presumption.
The 'add… again' wording (yāsap̄ + ʿôd) stresses repetition. Deut 4:33 and 5:26 present the survival as something that had never happened before, and v.26 begins with 'for', giving the reason for the fear.
-
Verse 24 is amazement at what happened, not a general rule, so there is no real contradiction. The people move from wonder to terror as they realise how close they came.
Verse 24 opens with 'behold' (hēn), a word of exclamation. Verse 26's 'who of all flesh…' treats survival as a marvel, not something to expect.
in v25
Did the people hear all Ten Commandments directly before making this plea?
-
Yes. The plea comes after the full Ten Words.
Deut 5:22: 'These words Yahweh spoke to all your assembly… and he added no more.' The request (vv.23–27) is placed after that.
-
Rabbinic tradition: the people heard only the first two commandments directly ('I am Yahweh…' and 'You shall have no other gods'), then asked Moses to mediate.
b. Makkot 24a. Its reasoning is that the first two speak of God as 'I' while the rest speak of him as 'Yahweh'. Deut 5:5 ('I stood between Yahweh and you at that time… for you were afraid') is sometimes cited for an early mediation.
in v26
Why is "living" plural (elohim chayyim) when it describes the one God of Israel?
-
Grammatical agreement: the adjective matches the plural form of *elohim*. That form expresses majesty or fullness, not more than one being.
Standard Hebrew grammars (Gesenius–Kautzsch §132h; Waltke–O'Connor) list it with other cases where plural modifiers go with *elohim* meaning God. The same writer can use singular verbs with *elohim* nearby (5:24, "God speaks"). Singular forms (*el chay*, *elohim chay*) express the identical idea elsewhere, so no theological contrast is intended.
-
Some Christian interpreters, from the church fathers through later apologetics, have read plural grammar with *elohim* as a hint of plurality within God.
Points to the plural forms here and in Gen 1:26; 3:22; 11:7. Most Hebrew grammarians, including many Christian scholars, regard this as reading a later doctrine into ordinary agreement, since Israelite writers mixed plural and singular forms freely in the same meaning.
in v26
Is the people's fear in vv. 25–27 a right response or a failure of faith?
-
Right and approved: their fear is proper awe, and asking for a mediator is wise.
God's direct verdict in 5:28 ("they are right in all that they have spoken") and 5:29 ("oh that they had such a heart… to fear me"); Deut 18:16–18 bases the prophetic office on this request.
-
Partly a pulling back: the people avoid direct closeness to God, and Exodus presents fear as something to be turned the right way.
Exod 20:20 has Moses say "Do not fear" while also saying "that the fear of him may be before you," which suggests their terror needed reshaping. Later readers (e.g. Heb 12) contrast Sinai's terror with a new kind of approach. In Deuteronomy itself, though, God's approval is explicit.
Sources
- BDB s.v. דָּבָר, יָסַף, עֲרָפֶל, קָהָל, לוּחַ
- HALOT s.v. עֲרָפֶל; יסף
- Septuagint (Rahlfs-Hanhart), Deuteronomy 5:22
- Targum Onkelos on Deut 5:19 (Hebrew numbering)
- Rashi on Deuteronomy 5:19
- Vulgate, Deuteronomy 5:22
- J. H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996)
- M. G. Kline, Treaty of the Great King (1963)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Deut 5
- Philo, De Decalogo
- BDB and HALOT s.v. קוֹל, חֹשֶׁךְ, בָּעַר, קָרַב, זָקֵן
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §47m (verb forms with an added final nun)
- J. H. Tigay, Deuteronomy (JPS Torah Commentary), on 5:20–24
- M. Weinfeld, Deuteronomy 1–11 (Anchor Bible), on 5:19–30
- J. W. Wevers, Notes on the Greek Text of Deuteronomy, on 5:23
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Deut 5 and Exod 19–20
- Babylonian Talmud, Makkot 24a
- BDB s.v. כָּבוֹד, גֹּדֶל, קוֹל, אָדָם, חָיָה
- HALOT s.v. כָּבוֹד, קוֹל
- M. Weinfeld, 'kabod', Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament
- M. Weinfeld, Deuteronomy 1-11 (Anchor Bible)
- S. R. Driver, Deuteronomy (International Critical Commentary)
- G. von Rad, Studies in Deuteronomy
- I. Wilson, Out of the Midst of the Fire: Divine Presence in Deuteronomy
- Ugaritic Baal Cycle, KTU 1.4 vii (Baal's 'holy voice')
- Septuagint and Vulgate at Deuteronomy 5:24 (cited from memory, not verified against critical editions)
- BDB s.v. אָכַל, יָסַף, קוֹל
- HALOT s.v. אכל, יסף, קוֹל
- Jeffrey H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996), on 5:20–27 / 5:23–30
- Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy 1–11 (Anchor Bible, 1991)
- J. G. McConville, Deuteronomy (Apollos OT Commentary, 2002)
- 4QTestimonia (4Q175)
- Samaritan Pentateuch, Exodus 20
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Deuteronomy 5
- BDB s.v. בָּשָׂר, חַי, קוֹל, תָּוֶךְ
- HALOT s.v. בָּשָׂר, חַי, חָיָה
- Gesenius–Kautzsch, Hebrew Grammar §132h (plural attributes with אֱלֹהִים)
- Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax (plural of majesty)
- Jeffrey H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996), on 5:20–30 (Heb.) / 5:23–33 (Eng.)
- Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy 1–11 (Anchor Bible), on 4:32–36 and 5:23–28
- Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Deut 5:26
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Deut 4–5
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).