Ecclesiastes Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Ecclesiastes 5:13–14
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
13There is a grievous evil I have seen under the sun: wealth hoarded to the harm of its owner, 14or wealth lost in a failed venture, so when that man has a son there is nothing to pass on.
What the first hearers heard
To its first hearers, students of wisdom in a Judean community living with an unstable money economy, this verse opened a short, pointed case study (vv.13-17). It belongs with the sayings around it: whoever loves money is never satisfied with it (v.10), more goods means more people consuming them (v.11), and the laborer sleeps sweetly while the rich man's surplus keeps him awake (v.12).
Qoheleth's point was not that wealth is wicked. Elsewhere he calls the ability to enjoy wealth "the gift of God" (5:19 Eng). His point was that wealth cannot deliver the security people guard it for. Anxiously held riches can turn against their owner and leave him sleepless, then penniless, and finally dead as naked as he was born. The verse would have pushed hearers toward the conclusion Qoheleth draws in verses 18-20: eat, drink and enjoy the portion God gives in the days you have, rather than spending your life standing guard over something that may become your harm.
From the study of Ecclesiastes 5:13.
Verse by verse
-
13There is a grievous evil I have seen under the sun: wealth hoarded to the harm of its owner,
Full study →"There is a sick kind of misfortune I have watched happen in this world: wealth that its owner guards carefully, and that turns out to be his own harm."
Qoheleth (the Hebrew name of the speaker, "the Gatherer" or "the Teacher") is reporting a case he has observed. The verse starts and ends on the same Hebrew word, ra'ah: "evil" at the start and "harm" at the end. The bad thing he sees is the bad thing that falls on the owner. He calls it a "sick evil," a misfortune like a disease that eats away at a person. This is not a lecture on sin. It is a diagnosis of something sickening.
The wealth is described as "kept" or "guarded," with the same verb used for guarding a flock or holding valuables in safekeeping. The owner holds onto it and protects it, presumably so that it will protect him. The irony is that the guarded wealth "guards" him toward misfortune. The surrounding verses show what that looks like: the rich man cannot sleep for his abundance (v.12), and then the whole fortune disappears in one bad venture, so that when his son is born there is nothing in his hand to give (v.14). He came into the world naked and will leave the same way (v.15). The harm may be the anxiety of guarding, the crash of losing, or both. In either case the wealth meant for security became the source of his trouble.
-
14or wealth lost in a failed venture, so when that man has a son there is nothing to pass on.
Full study →"And that very wealth — the hoard he guarded so carefully — vanished in some venture that went bad. By now he had become father to a son, and there was not a thing left in his hand."
This verse is the second half of a scene that starts in verse 13. Qoheleth (the "Teacher" of Ecclesiastes) has seen "a sickening evil under the sun": a man hoards his wealth, and the hoarding harms him. Verse 14 tells how. The money he clung to is simply lost. The verb is the everyday word for something that goes missing. It is lost in an inyan, an "affair" or "undertaking," the same word the book uses for all the restless busyness of human life. The undertaking was ra', "bad." The word means it went wrong. It does not say the man was wicked.
The sting comes in the second half. He has a son. In ancient Israel the reason to build and keep wealth was to pass an estate on to your children and keep the family name and land alive. Now his hand, meaning his possession and his power to give, holds "not a thing." The son inherits nothing, and the father has nothing to give him.
The phrase "nothing… in his hand" sets up the next verse. There, every person leaves this life the way they entered it, naked, carrying "nothing (me'umah) in his hand." The failed investment is a small rehearsal of death. Wealth guarded with worry can disappear in a single bad deal, and death will take it in any case.
Where the English drifted
-
in v13
evil ("a grievous evil")
ra'ah
- What we hear
- Moral wickedness, something sinister or demonic, a sin that someone commits.
- What they heard
- A bad thing, a misfortune, something wrong with how life turns out. Here it is a painful irony of experience, not a wicked act. The same word at the end of the verse is translated "harm."
-
in v13
sore (KJV: "a sore evil")
cholah
- What we hear
- Aching or tender, as in a sore muscle. Or, colloquially, upset ("sore about it").
- What they heard
- "Sick, ailing," and so grievous or severe. In 17th-century English "sore" meant "severe, grievous" and also suggested pain, which was a reasonable match.
-
in v14
evil travail (KJV) / evil business (YLT)
inyan ra'
- What we hear
- A wicked or sinful deal, or painful suffering ('travail' as agony or labour pains).
- What they heard
- An undertaking or affair that turned out badly: a failed venture, a misfortune. Nothing in the phrase points to moral wrongdoing.
Every word
-
יֵ֚שׁ
yesh · H3426
there is, existence · v13
Simply asserts that something exists: "there is." It opens Qoheleth's report the way an observer opens a case file: here is something real that happens.
-
רָעָ֣ה
ra'ah · H7451
evil, bad thing, misfortune · v13, v14
A bad thing, a misfortune, something wrong with how life goes. It is not mainly moral wickedness. The same word comes back at the end of the verse, so the verse opens and closes on "evil/harm."
-
חוֹלָ֔ה
cholah · H2470
be sick, be weak; grievous · v13
A participle (a verb used as a describing word) from "to be sick": literally "a sick evil," meaning a sickening, painful misfortune. The picture is of an ailment, not only of something serious.
-
רָאִ֖יתִי
ra'iti · H7200
see · v13
"I have seen." This is Qoheleth's usual way of working. He bases his claim on what he has watched happen, not on tradition or revelation.
-
תַּ֣חַת
tachat · H8478
under, beneath · v13
"Under," the first word of Qoheleth's signature phrase "under the sun."
-
הַשָּׁ֑מֶשׁ
hashshamesh · H8121
sun · v13
"The sun." Together with "under," it means "in the world of the living, in ordinary human life." It does not mean "without God."
-
עֹ֛שֶׁר
'osher · H6239
wealth, riches · v13, v14
Wealth or riches in general, meaning accumulated possessions. In the verses around it, this is the money that keeps the rich man awake (v.12) and that is lost in a bad venture (v.14).
-
שָׁמ֥וּר
shamur · H8104
keep, guard, watch over · v13
"Kept, guarded." It is a passive form of the verb used for guarding a flock, a city or a treasure. It shows wealth held onto and protected. "Hoarded" is a fair reading in this context, but the word itself is broader.
-
לִבְעָלָ֖יו
liv'alav · H1167
owner, master, lord · v13
"By (or for) its owner." The Hebrew form is plural ("its owners"), which is a normal Hebrew way of saying "owner" when talking about possessions. The little prefix l- can mean "by" (the owner does the keeping) or "for" (the wealth is kept for his benefit).
-
וְאָבַ֛ד
ve'avad · H0006
to perish, be lost · v14
'And it was lost / it vanished.' The ordinary verb for something that perishes or goes missing (used of lost donkeys in 1 Samuel 9:3). It carries on from verse 13: the wealth the owner guarded so carefully simply disappears.
-
הַה֖וּא
hahu · H1931
that · v14
'That (wealth).' Used here as a pointing word, it ties the loss tightly to the hoarded wealth just described.
-
בְּעִנְיַ֣ן
be'inyan · H6045
business, occupation, affair · v14
'In a business / an undertaking.' A word found only in Ecclesiastes for the activities people are taken up with. Here it means a commercial affair or venture that the money went into.
-
וְהוֹלִ֣יד
veholid · H3205
to father, beget · v14
'And he has fathered.' This is the causative form of 'give birth', used of a man becoming a father. It probably works as a circumstance: he has a son by now, which makes the loss worse.
-
בֵּ֔ן
ben · H1121A
son · v14
'A son.' In Israel the son was the one who received the family estate and carried on the father's name. That is the point of mentioning him.
-
וְאֵ֥ין
ve'ein · H0369
there is not · v14
'And there is not.' The usual Hebrew way of saying something is missing. It sets the son's existence against the empty hand.
-
בְּיָד֖וֹ
beyado · H3027G
in his hand · v14
'In his hand,' meaning in his possession or at his disposal. 'His' most naturally means the father, who has nothing left to hand on. Some readers take it as the son, who receives nothing. Either way, the inheritance is gone.
-
מְאֽוּמָה׃
me'umah · H3972
anything, nothing (with a negative) · v14
'Anything at all.' With the negative it means 'not a thing.' The same word comes back in verse 15 ('he takes nothing'), linking the empty-handed father here with the naked man at death.
The world behind it
Ecclesiastes is generally dated to the Persian or early Hellenistic period (roughly 5th to 3rd century BC). The date is debated. One widely discussed argument, made especially by C.-L. Seow, points to the book's commercial vocabulary (money, profit, "business/venture," grants of property) as signs of the busy money economy of the Persian period. In that world, ordinary people could suddenly make or lose fortunes through trade, loans and investments.
This background helps explain the verse. There were no insured banks. Wealth was kept as silver, goods, land or loans, and it had to be physically guarded. It could vanish through a failed venture (the very next verse speaks of wealth lost be'inyan ra', "in a bad business"), through seizure by officials, or through theft. Qoheleth's "case" was familiar: the man who spends his life guarding his fortune and ends up with nothing to pass to his son. In an Israelite setting that was a serious loss, because handing on an inheritance was central to a family's continuity and honor.
From the study of Ecclesiastes 5:13.
Where scholars differ
in v13
Does the wealth get kept "by" its owner or "for" its owner?
-
"By its owner": the owner himself does the guarding, which harms him (WEB, ESV, NASB; Fox, Seow).
Hebrew sometimes uses l- with a passive form to mark who does the action (e.g. Gen 14:19, "blessed by God Most High," barukh ... le'El). The point of the verse is the owner's own anxious guarding, which connects with his sleeplessness in v.12.
-
"For its owner": the wealth is stored up for his benefit, yet it turns out to his harm (KJV, YLT; some older commentators).
The most common meaning of l- is "for, to." This reading also produces a sharp irony: kept for him, to his harm. Using l- to mark the doer is relatively rare.
in v13
What exactly is the "harm"?
-
The loss narrated in v.14: the guarded wealth is wiped out in a bad venture, leaving nothing for the heir.
Verse 14 begins with "and" and refers back to "that wealth" (ha'osher hahu), which ties it closely to v.13. Most modern commentators read vv.13-17 as one case.
-
The burden of possession itself: anxiety, sleeplessness, people who prey on wealth, and a life spent guarding it.
Verse 12 has just said that the rich man's surplus does not let him sleep. Verse 17 describes him eating in darkness with much vexation, sickness and anger.
-
Both: the guarding wears him down, and then the loss proves the guarding was useless.
Qoheleth's cases often pile ironies on top of each other. The "sick" vocabulary appears both here and in v.17, which joins the two.
in v14
Whose hand is empty: the father's or the son's?
-
The father's. He has nothing left to give his son.
The father is the subject of the nearest verb ('he fathered'), so 'his hand' most naturally means him. Verse 15 then goes on with the same man leaving life naked and empty-handed, using the same words (me'umah, beyado). Many commentators (e.g., Fox, Longman) read it this way.
-
The son's. He is born into poverty and inherits nothing.
The son is the last person named before 'his hand.' The Vulgate and some modern versions (NASB 'nothing to support him') take it this way. Some also read verse 15's 'as he came from his mother's womb' as playing on the newborn son.
-
The wording is deliberately open and works both ways.
The loss of the inheritance leaves both men empty-handed. Some scholars (e.g., Seow) note how well verses 14–15 hold the son's birth and the father's death side by side.
in v14
How should 'and he fathered a son' relate to the loss?
-
As a circumstance: 'and (by then / if) he has a son…'
Hebrew often states a background condition with 'and' plus a perfect verb. WEB ('if') and BSB ('when') read it this way, and it makes the best sense of why the son is mentioned.
-
As the next event: 'and (afterwards) he fathered a son.'
The literal sequence in KJV and YLT. On this reading the son is born after the ruin and so is born into nothing.
Sources
- BDB s.v. רַע / רָעָה, חָלָה, שָׁמַר, בַּעַל
- HALOT s.v. חלה I, שׁמר
- C.-L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Bible 18C), on 5:12-16 (Heb)
- C.-L. Seow, "Linguistic Evidence and the Dating of Qohelet," JBL 115 (1996)
- Michael V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up: A Rereading of Ecclesiastes
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Ecclesiastes 5:12
- Vulgate, Ecclesiastes 5:12
- Phoenician inscriptions of Tabnit and Eshmunazar (KAI 13-14), "under the sun"
- BDB s.v. עִנְיָן; s.v. רַע; s.v. אָבַד
- HALOT s.v. עִנְיָן
- C. L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Bible 18C)
- Tremper Longman III, The Book of Ecclesiastes (NICOT)
- Thomas Krüger, Qoheleth (Hermeneia)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Ecclesiastes 5:13
- Vulgate, Ecclesiastes 5:13
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).