Galatians Chapter 4 Read as one passage
Galatians 4:19–20
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
19My children, for whom I am again in the pains of childbirth until Christ is formed in you, 20how I wish I could be with you now and change my tone, because I am perplexed about you.
What the first hearers heard
The Galatians would have heard this as the emotional turning point of Paul's argument. After long scriptural reasoning (chapters 3–4), he suddenly speaks as a parent:
- A claim of relationship. They are his children. The rival teachers who 'court' them (4:17) did not give them birth. Paul did, at the cost of his own suffering, and he does so again.
- An alarm. 'Again' tells them that their turn toward circumcision is not a step forward into maturity. In Paul's eyes it is as if they were never fully born. Their new life in Christ is at risk.
- A redefinition of the goal. The finished 'shape' of God's people is Christ, not circumcision or calendar-keeping. This matches the letter's summary: 'neither circumcision nor uncircumcision, but a new creation' (6:15).
- A scriptural frame. Those who knew Isaiah would hear Zion's labor and the birth of the children of promise, which Paul makes explicit in 4:26–27 with 'the Jerusalem above… is our mother'.
The next verse (4:20) shows what kind of speech this is: Paul wishes he were there in person to 'change his tone', because he is at a loss about them. The verse is an anguished appeal, not doctrine laid out calmly.
From the study of Galatians 4:19.
Verse by verse
-
19My children, for whom I am again in the pains of childbirth until Christ is formed in you,
Full study →"My children, you whom I am having to go through labor for all over again, in pain, until Christ himself has taken shape among you."
Paul speaks as a mother in childbirth. He is not saying he is 'working hard'. He is saying he feels the pain of labor, the most intense and dangerous suffering his world knew. He already gave birth to these Galatian believers once, when he first preached Christ to them. Now that they are being drawn toward circumcision and the law as the mark of belonging to God's people, he feels he has to give birth to them a second time, which is as painful and unnatural as it sounds.
The picture then shifts in a way that is both odd and telling. The labor will last until Christ is formed, until Christ takes definite shape like a child in the womb, in and among them ('you' is plural). The verb is passive, so Paul is not claiming to do the shaping himself. God forms Christ in them. The goal is not converts loyal to Paul, and not a community marked by circumcision. The goal is a community whose very shape is Christ.
For hearers who knew the Scriptures, 'labor pains' also called up the prophets' image of Zion giving birth to her children and the painful birth of God's new age. Paul draws on that image a few verses later when he quotes Isaiah 54:1.
-
20how I wish I could be with you now and change my tone, because I am perplexed about you.
Full study →"I could wish, and I know I can't, to be there with you right now, at this very moment, and to change my voice. A letter can only speak in one fixed tone, and it has had to be a stern one. In person I could speak gently and adjust to what I saw in your faces. I wish that because I have run out of ways to reach you. I am at a loss about you."
The verse finishes the tender outburst of verse 19 ("my children, for whom I am again in labour pains until Christ is formed in you"). The wish is grammatically framed as one Paul knows he cannot fulfil, so it carries a wistful ache. "Right now" stresses the urgency of the crisis. "Change my voice" works on two levels. First, the harsh voice this letter has been forced to use ("You foolish Galatians!" 3:1) is not the one he would choose. Second, a letter read aloud by someone else is a poor substitute for his own living voice. The final word, "at a loss" (literally "without a way through"), is not suspicion or distrust. It is the honest bewilderment of a parent-teacher who has argued for two chapters and still does not know what will bring them back.
Where the English drifted
-
in v19
travail (KJV, WEB, YLT)
ōdinō
- What we hear
- Toil, hard work, a long ordeal.
- What they heard
- Specifically the pains of a woman in labor giving birth.
-
in v19
formed (heard as 'spiritual formation')
morphoō
- What we hear
- A gradual programme of personal character-building and spiritual disciplines in the individual believer.
- What they heard
- Christ taking definite shape, like an embryo in the womb, in and among the community, as God's work. It is set against the 'shape' of law-observance the rival teachers were offering.
-
in v20
I stand in doubt of you (KJV); I am in doubt about you (YLT)
aporoumai en humin
- What we hear
- I distrust you; I'm suspicious of you; I don't believe in you.
- What they heard
- I am at a loss about you. I don't know what to do or how to get through to you. It describes Paul's bewilderment, not a verdict on their trustworthiness.
Every word
-
τέκνα
tekna · G5043
child · v19
"Children" as in offspring, the ones one has given birth to. It is a word of origin and belonging, not of age. It sets up the birth image that follows: Paul is addressing people he himself brought into being.
-
μου
mou · G3165
my, of me · v19, v20
"Mine." Paul claims them as his own. Rival teachers are courting the Galatians (4:17), and Paul answers by stating his parental bond with them.
-
οὓς
hous · G3739
whom · v19
"Whom." It is masculine although "children" is a neuter noun in Greek. The grammar follows the people meant rather than the form of the word, so Paul is thinking of real persons and not a grammatical abstraction. It is the object of the labor: these are the ones he is giving birth to.
-
πάλιν
palin · G3825
again · v19
"A second time." Paul already 'gave birth' to them when he first preached in Galatia (4:13–15). Their turn toward circumcision and law-observance (4:9–11; 5:2–4) means he has to go through the labor all over again. The word carries the pain and absurdity of a birth having to be repeated.
-
ὠδίνω
ōdinō · G5605
suffer birth pangs, be in labor · v19
"I am in labor." It means the physical pains of childbirth, not hard work in general. The present tense shows the pain is going on now. A man using a mother's image is striking, and the word also recalls the prophets' 'birth pangs' of Zion and of the coming age.
-
μέχρις
mechris · G3360
until · v19
"Until." It sets a goal for the labor: it goes on as long as the outcome has not arrived.
-
μορφωθῇ
morphōthē · G3445
be formed, take shape · v19
"Has taken shape." The verb is passive and aorist, which looks at the outcome as a finished event: the point when Christ has actually taken form. The word was used of a fetus taking shape in the womb, so it continues the pregnancy image. Paul does not say who does the forming, but the passive points to God's own work and not to Paul's or the Galatians' effort.
-
Χριστὸς
Christos · G5547
Christ, Anointed One · v19
The Messiah himself, not 'Christ-like behavior' in the abstract. What has to take shape among them is Christ, not the identity markers of the law (circumcision, calendar observance) that the rival teachers are pressing.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in, among · v19, v20
"In" or "among." With a plural pronoun it can mean inside each person or in the midst of the community. Both may be meant.
-
ὑμῖν
hymin · G4771
you (plural) · v19, v20
"You all." The plural means the Galatian congregations together. The image is of Christ taking shape in the whole body of believers as well as in each one, compare 2:20 'Christ lives in me'.
-
ἤθελον
ēthelon · G2309
to will, wish, want · v20
Past-tense form used the way Greek speakers voiced a wish they know cannot come true right now: "I could wish," "how I wish." It is wistful, not a report of what Paul wanted at some earlier time.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and, now · v20
A light link to verse 19. After the image of a mother in labour, Paul turns to what he cannot do: be there in person. It carries a slight contrast, roughly "but".
-
παρεῖναι
pareinai · G3918
to be present, be here · v20
To be physically there. This verb family (its noun is parousia, 'presence') was the standard way to talk about being present in person as opposed to being absent and writing a letter.
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
to, toward, with · v20
With 'be present' it means 'with you, there among you,' face to face.
-
ἄρτι
arti · G737
now, just now, at this moment · v20
Right now, at this critical moment, while the crisis over circumcision and the Law is live. It stresses urgency: later will be too late.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v20
Joins the two parts of the wish: to be there, and, being there, to change his voice. The second depends on the first.
-
ἀλλάξαι
allaxai · G236
to change, alter, exchange · v20
To alter or swap. The verb can mean 'change' (make different) or 'exchange' (trade one thing for another), and both senses are possible here: soften the harsh tone, or trade the written letter for his own living voice.
-
τὴν
tēn · G3588
the · v20
The article together with 'my' marks this as Paul's own particular voice, the one the Galatians know.
-
φωνήν
phōnēn · G5456
voice, sound, tone · v20
Literally 'voice,' the sound of a person speaking. Here it means the manner of his speaking: its pitch, warmth or severity. A letter has no voice, and that is exactly what Paul is lamenting.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
because, that · v20
'Because.' It gives the reason for the whole wish: his perplexity is why he longs to be there.
-
ἀποροῦμαι
aporoumai · G639
to be at a loss, perplexed · v20
Literally 'to be without a way through' (a-, 'no' + poros, 'passage, way'). Paul does not know which way to turn with them or what will work. It is bewilderment and helplessness, not suspicion.
The world behind it
The crisis in Galatia. Paul had founded these mostly Gentile congregations in central Asia Minor (4:13–15). After he left, other teachers came, probably Jewish followers of Jesus. They urged the Galatians to be circumcised and keep the law's calendar so as to be full members of Abraham's family (4:10, 21; 5:2–4; 6:12–13). Just before this verse Paul complains that these teachers are 'courting' the Galatians to cut them off from him (4:17). Verse 19 is his answer: he is not a rival suitor but their mother.
Childbirth in the ancient world. Labor was the most common way young women died. Saying 'I am in labor for you' meant pain, life-and-death risk and total investment in the outcome. Men almost never used maternal imagery of themselves, so Paul's choice was startling. It has precedent, though, in Moses (Num 11:12) and in Paul's own letters (1 Thess 2:7, a nursing mother; 1 Cor 3:2, feeding with milk). Philosophers and teachers of the time sometimes described themselves as gentle nurses to their pupils. Paul goes further and takes the role of the mother giving birth.
Scriptural echoes. The prophets used labor pains for Zion's anguish and for the birth of a restored people (Isa 26:17–18; 66:7–9; Mic 4:9–10). Jewish expectation spoke of 'birth pangs' that would come before the new age, language also found in the Gospels (Mark 13:8) and in Paul (1 Thess 5:3; Rom 8:22). In this same chapter Paul quotes Isa 54:1 (Gal 4:27), where Jerusalem, once barren and never in labor, ends up with more children than the married woman. His own labor is set inside that story.
From the study of Galatians 4:19.
Where scholars differ
in v19
Is Paul's 'labor' an apocalyptic image or simply a pastoral metaphor?
-
Apocalyptic: Paul's pains belong to the 'birth pangs' of God's new age breaking into the world. His suffering as an apostle is part of the cosmic birth of the new creation.
The 'birth pangs' language of Isaiah, Micah and Jewish apocalyptic texts, Rom 8:22, 1 Thess 5:3, the quotation of Isa 54:1 in Gal 4:27, and the letter's 'new creation' language (6:15). Argued by Beverly Gaventa ('The Maternity of Paul') and J. Louis Martyn.
-
Pastoral/relational: the image mainly expresses Paul's anguish and parental bond with converts who are straying.
The setting is personal (4:12–20: their former welcome, his illness, his wish to be present). Paul uses parental images elsewhere for pastoral care (1 Cor 4:14–15; 1 Thess 2:7, 11). Many standard commentaries (e.g. Longenecker, Moo) stress this, while some allow the apocalyptic echo as well.
in v19
Does 'Christ formed in you' mean in each individual or among the community?
-
Individual: Christ taking shape within each believer's inner life and character.
Parallel with 2:20 'Christ lives in me' and the transformation language of Rom 12:2 and 2 Cor 3:18.
-
Corporate: Christ taking shape in the common life of the congregations, especially their unity across Jew/Gentile lines.
The pronoun is plural, Paul's concern is the communities' identity markers (circumcision, calendar), and 3:28 says 'you are all one in Christ Jesus'. Stressed by Martyn and Susan Eastman. Many interpreters hold both together.
in v19
How do the mixed images fit together: Paul in labor, yet Christ formed in the Galatians?
-
A deliberately mixed metaphor: Paul is the mother giving birth, and the Galatians are at the same time like a womb in which Christ is gestating.
The verb morphoō was used for embryonic shaping. Paul often shifts images rapidly (e.g. 1 Thess 2:7, 11 moves from nurse to father).
-
A single image of an unfinished birth: the 'child' being born is the Galatian community, and it is not fully born until it bears Christ's shape.
'Until' marks the endpoint of Paul's own labor. Its completion is defined by Christ's form appearing in them.
in v20
What does Paul mean by 'change my voice'?
-
Soften the tone: exchange the severity of this letter for a gentler voice.
This is the most widely held view and lies behind most modern translations' 'tone.' It fits the sharp rebukes earlier in the letter (1:6–9; 3:1) and the tender family language of 4:19 ('my children'). Paul would rather speak as a mother than as a prosecutor.
-
Exchange the letter for the living voice: speak in person instead of through a written page read by someone else.
ἀλλάσσω can mean 'exchange,' and the verse opens with the wish to 'be present.' Ancient letter theory treated letters as substitutes for presence, and Paul elsewhere contrasts his letters with his presence (2 Cor 10:10–11). Commentators attentive to ancient rhetoric and letter conventions (e.g., H. D. Betz) stress this background.
-
Adapt the voice to the situation: in person Paul could vary his speech, gentle or firm, as he saw their responses.
A letter speaks in one fixed register, while a present speaker can read the audience and adjust. This fits the reason Paul gives ('because I am at a loss'): not knowing their state, he cannot choose the right tone from afar. Older commentators often favoured this reading.
in v20
Is 'I am at a loss about you' a genuine emotional admission or a rhetorical device?
-
Genuine bewilderment and distress.
It is the climax of the most personal section of the letter (4:12–20), alongside tears-and-labour imagery. Paul uses the same verb of real hardship in 2 Cor 4:8.
-
A recognised persuasive move, in which the speaker voices helplessness to draw the audience in.
Ancient rhetoric knew a figure of 'perplexity' (Greek aporia, Latin dubitatio), where a speaker professes not to know what to say or do. Rhetorical analyses of Galatians note it here. The two views are not exclusive: a real emotion can be expressed in a familiar persuasive form.
Sources
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Gal 4:19
- BDAG s.v. ὠδίνω
- BDAG s.v. μορφόω
- BDAG s.v. τέκνον
- Septuagint: Isa 26:17–18; 44:13; 54:1; 66:7–9; Mic 4:9–10; Num 11:12
- J. Louis Martyn, Galatians (Anchor Bible 33A)
- Beverly Roberts Gaventa, 'The Maternity of Paul: An Exegetical Study of Galatians 4:19'
- Susan Eastman, Recovering Paul's Mother Tongue: Language and Theology in Galatians
- Richard N. Longenecker, Galatians (Word Biblical Commentary 41)
- Douglas J. Moo, Galatians (Baker Exegetical Commentary on the New Testament)
- BDAG s.v. ἀπορέω
- BDAG s.v. ἀλλάσσω
- BDAG s.v. φωνή
- BDAG s.v. πάρειμι
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §359 (imperfect of unattainable wish)
- H. D. Betz, Galatians (Hermeneia, 1979), on 4:12–20 and epistolary conventions
- R. N. Longenecker, Galatians (WBC 41, 1990)
- J. L. Martyn, Galatians (Anchor Bible 33A, 1997)
- D. J. Moo, Galatians (BECNT, 2013)
- R. W. Funk, 'The Apostolic Parousia: Form and Significance' (1967)
- Demetrius, On Style 223–235 (ancient letter theory)
- LXX Genesis 32:7(8)
- Vulgate, Ad Galatas 4:20
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).