Galatians Chapter 4 Read as one passage

Galatians 4:24–25

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

24These things serve as illustrations, for the women represent two covenants. One covenant is from Mount Sinai and bears children into slavery: This is Hagar. 25Now Hagar stands for Mount Sinai in Arabia and corresponds to the present-day Jerusalem, because she is in slavery with her children.

What the first hearers heard

To the Galatian Gentile believers, the verse turned an argument they had probably heard on its head. If they had been told, "You are like Ishmael, outsiders; come under the law of Sinai and you will belong to Isaac's line," Paul answers that Sinai, taken up as the badge of belonging, is Hagar, the slave mother. Her children cannot inherit.

Several things would land at once:

  • A warning about status. Accepting circumcision and the law as the condition of belonging would not raise them to heirs. In Paul's argument it would lower them to slaves (4:9; 5:1).
  • A claim about Scripture. Paul meets his rivals on their own ground, the Torah, and claims its deeper sense for his gospel (4:21: "you who want to be under law, do you not hear the law?").
  • A claim about identity. By the end of the passage they are told, "we are not children of the slave woman but of the free" (4:31), born "according to the Spirit" (4:29) and through promise, as Isaac was.
  • An implied command. Genesis 21:10, quoted in 4:30, "cast out the slave woman and her son", tells them to stop yielding to the law-observant pressure in their congregations.

For Jewish believers listening in, linking Sinai with Hagar would have been startling, even offensive, because it reversed the familiar identification of Israel with Sarah and Isaac. Paul intended that shock.

From the study of Galatians 4:24.

Verse by verse

  1. 24These things serve as illustrations, for the women represent two covenants. One covenant is from Mount Sinai and bears children into slavery: This is Hagar.

    "This story says more than it seems to say. Read it for its second meaning: the two women are two covenants, two arrangements that each produce a family. One comes from Mount Sinai, and like a slave mother it keeps bearing children who are born slaves. That one is Hagar."

    Paul has just retold Genesis. Abraham had two sons: one by the slave woman, born the ordinary way, and one by the free woman, born because of God's promise. Now he states openly that he is reading the story for an extra meaning. His word is allēgoreō, "to say one thing and mean another". Educated Greeks used it for reading Homer, and Jewish teachers like Philo used it for reading Moses. Paul is not calling Genesis fiction. He is saying the real events form a pattern that speaks to the Galatians' situation now.

    The key word is "covenant" (diathēkē), which Greek speakers also used for a last will. The question underneath is inheritance: whose children are heirs? A child's status followed its mother. A slave woman's son was a slave, and as 4:30 quotes, "the son of the slave woman will not inherit." The verb "bearing" is in the present tense: this covenant is still producing children, and they are still slaves.

    Paul links Sinai, the mountain of the law and of Israel's identity, with Hagar, the Egyptian slave whose line was usually thought to stand outside the promise. That link deliberately turns the expected reading upside down. Paul begins with "on the one hand" and never formally supplies the other. The second covenant appears only in v. 26, as the free "Jerusalem above," who "is our mother."

    Full study →
  2. 25Now Hagar stands for Mount Sinai in Arabia and corresponds to the present-day Jerusalem, because she is in slavery with her children.

    "Now this name, Hagar, means Mount Sinai, the mountain out in Arabia, the country of Hagar's own descendants and outside the land promised to Abraham. Hagar lines up in the same column as the Jerusalem of the present age. Like Hagar, that Jerusalem is a slave mother, and the children she bears and raises share her slave status."

    Paul is reading the Abraham story (Genesis 16 and 21) as a picture with two sides. He sets the items out like a two-column table of opposites:

    • One column: Hagar, the slave woman; the covenant given at Sinai; the present Jerusalem; slavery.
    • The other column: Sarah, the free woman; the promise; the Jerusalem above (v. 26); freedom.

    The verb Paul chooses, systoichei, literally means "stands in the same row". It tells the reader to read down the column. It may also echo the "elemental powers" (stoicheia) he has just called a form of slavery (4:3, 9).

    The jolt for the first hearers is where Paul puts Sinai and Jerusalem. Jews traced their family line through Sarah and Isaac and identified Hagar and Ishmael with the Arab peoples to the south. Paul turns this around. He links the mountain of the Law to the slave woman through geography: Sinai stands in "Arabia", the land of Hagar's people. And he places the present Jerusalem, the mother-city of Law-observant life, among Hagar's family. The reasoning rests on ancient slave law: a slave mother's children are slaves too.

    "Now" here is set against "above", not against "later". The new age has already arrived from above, and its Jerusalem is the true mother of the Galatian believers. So they must not put themselves under the Sinai covenant through circumcision.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v24

    allegory (KJV, WEB)

    allēgoroumena

    What we hear
    An invented story whose characters and events are symbols, such as a fable; so the Genesis account would not really have happened.
    What they heard
    Speaking of something, or reading something, for a second meaning beyond the surface. It was regularly applied to texts readers considered true and ancient (Homer, Moses). It says nothing against the events having happened.
  • in v24

    two covenants

    duo diathēkai

    What we hear
    The 'Old Testament' and 'New Testament' as the two halves of the Bible, or simply 'the Old Testament period' versus 'the Church age'.
    What they heard
    Two binding arrangements that create two families with different legal status. The free one rests on God's promise to Abraham, which is recorded in Genesis. Naming the parts of the Bible 'Old' and 'New Testament' came only in the late 2nd century.
  • in v24

    serve as illustrations / an illustration (BSB, NLT)

    allēgoroumena

    What we hear
    A helpful teaching picture or analogy Paul chose to make his point clearer.
    What they heard
    A claim that the scriptural story itself carries a further, hidden sense that Paul is now drawing out. It is an argument from Scripture, not a classroom example.
  • in v25

    answereth to / answers to (KJV, WEB)

    systoichei

    What we hear
    Is accountable to, reports to, is under the authority of Jerusalem.
    What they heard
    Stands in the same row or column as; corresponds to. Hagar and Sinai are listed alongside the present Jerusalem in a table of opposites.
  • in v25

    Arabia

    Arabia

    What we hear
    The Arabian Peninsula, or the modern state of Saudi Arabia.
    What they heard
    The broad region south and east of Judea, in Paul's day largely the Nabatean kingdom, which included the Sinai peninsula as well as northwest Arabia. It was also known as the land of Hagar's and Ishmael's descendants.
  • in v25

    the present Jerusalem

    hē nyn Ierousalēm

    What we hear
    The Jewish people as a whole for all time, or the modern city or state of Israel.
    What they heard
    The Jerusalem of the present, passing age: the city as mother-center of the Sinai-covenant way of life and its authorities, which in the Galatian situation included the Jerusalem-linked teachers pressing circumcision. It is contrasted with the Jerusalem 'above' that has broken in with Christ.
Every word
  1. ἅτινά

    hatina · G3748

    which, such things as · v24

    A neuter plural relative pronoun that looks back to the whole story just told in vv. 22–23: Abraham's two sons, one by the slave woman and one by the free woman. Its form leans toward kind or quality: 'which things are the sort that…'.

  2. ἐστιν

    estin · G1510

    is, are · v24, v25

    Singular verb with a neuter plural subject, which is normal Greek. It pairs with the participle that follows to make an ongoing description: 'are being spoken of in another sense'.

  3. ἀλληγορούμενα·

    allēgoroumena · G0238

    to speak allegorically, to say one thing and mean another · v24

    The only use of this word in the New Testament. The Genesis story says more than its surface: besides what happened, it points to something else. Paul is announcing that he will read the story for its second sense. He is not calling the story fiction.

  4. αὗται

    hautai · G3778

    these · v24

    Feminine plural, so it means 'these women', Hagar and Sarah, even though neither has been named in vv. 22–23. That is why translations add 'the women'.

  5. γάρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v24, v25

    Introduces the explanation: this is how the story carries a second sense.

  6. δύο

    duo · G1417

    two · v24

    Two women, two sons, two covenants. The whole passage is built on a doubled contrast that runs from v. 22 to v. 31.

  7. διαθῆκαι,

    diathēkai · G1242

    covenants; arrangements; wills · v24

    Two binding arrangements that define a people's relationship to God. Paul has already used the word for Abraham's promise-covenant, which the law cannot cancel (3:15–17). Here one of the two is tied to Sinai.

  8. μία

    mia · G1520

    one · v24

    'One' of the two covenants. The feminine form matches διαθήκη and also the woman Hagar.

  9. μὲν

    men · G3303

    on the one hand · v24

    Normally sets up an 'on the other hand' (δέ). Here none follows. Paul never formally names the second covenant; its counterpart only appears in v. 26 as 'the Jerusalem above… she is free… our mother'.

  10. ἀπὸ

    apo · G0575

    from · v24

    Origin: this covenant comes from Sinai, the mountain where the law was given.

  11. ὄρους

    orous · G3735

    mountain · v24, v25

    Mount: the place of the law-giving in Exodus 19–24.

  12. Σινᾶ

    Sina · G4614

    Sinai · v24, v25

    For any Jew the name meant the Torah and Israel's founding covenant. Paul links Hagar, an Egyptian slave, to the mountain that stood for Israel's identity, which made the link deliberately jarring.

  13. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, toward · v24

    The result or destination of the childbearing: the children are born into slavery.

  14. δουλείαν

    douleian · G1397

    slavery, bondage · v24

    Legal slavery: the condition of a person owned by another. It picks up Paul's earlier picture of being 'enslaved under the elemental powers' (4:3, 9) and looks ahead to 'do not submit again to a yoke of slavery' (5:1).

  15. γεννῶσα

    gennōsa · G1080

    to beget; (of a woman) to bear, give birth · v24

    Present participle: this covenant 'keeps bearing children'. It goes on producing offspring, and each one shares the mother's slave status.

  16. Ἁγάρ.

    Hagar · G0028

    Hagar · v24, v25

    Sarah's Egyptian slave woman and the mother of Ishmael (Gen 16; 21). Naming her last gives the sentence its sting: the Sinai covenant is Hagar.

  17. τὸ

    to · G3588

    the · v25

    A neuter article in front of a woman's name. It most likely means 'the [name/word] Hagar', so Paul is pointing at the name itself, not just the woman. That is a hint he is about to play on the word.

  18. δὲ

    de · G1161

    now, and · v25

    A light connective that moves the explanation one step further from verse 24 ('…this is Hagar'). It is not a strong contrast. Some manuscripts read γάρ ('for') here instead.

  19. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v25

    'In.' It places the mountain geographically.

  20. Ἀραβίᾳ

    Arabia · G688

    Arabia · v25

    The lands south and east of Judea. In Paul's day these were largely the Nabatean kingdom, a region that included the Sinai peninsula, the Negev, southern Transjordan and northwest Arabia. It was known as the country of Ishmael's descendants, which ties Sinai to Hagar's family. It also places Sinai outside the land of promise.

  21. συστοιχεῖ

    systoichei · G4960

    correspond to, stand in the same row with · v25

    Literally 'stands in the same line or column with'. Hagar and Sinai are lined up in one column with present-day Jerusalem, opposite a second column (Sarah, the Jerusalem above, freedom). The word appears only here in the NT.

  22. νῦν

    nyn · G3568

    now · v25

    Used like an adjective: 'the now-Jerusalem', meaning the Jerusalem of the present order of things. It is set against 'the Jerusalem above' in v. 26. Paul contrasts 'now' with 'above', mixing time and space as Jewish visionary writing did.

  23. Ἰερουσαλήμ

    Ierousalēm · G2419

    Jerusalem · v25

    The Hebrew-style spelling of the name. Paul uses the Greek form Ἱεροσόλυμα when he tells his travel story in 1:17–2:1. The holier, biblical form fits the 'mother city' language that follows. It means the city as the center of the Sinai-covenant way of life and its authorities.

  24. δουλεύει

    douleuei · G1398

    is a slave, serves as a slave · v25

    'She is in slavery.' The present tense describes her ongoing condition. 'She' is most naturally present-day Jerusalem, and through the matching columns Hagar as well. In Galatians this is the slavery of living under the Law and the 'elemental powers' (4:3, 9; 5:1).

  25. μετὰ

    meta · G3326

    with · v25

    'Together with.' The mother and her children share the same status.

  26. τέκνων

    teknōn · G5043

    children · v25

    The city's 'children' are those who belong to her and are shaped by her way of life. This draws on the biblical picture of Zion as a mother (Isa 54; 66; Ps 87). It anticipates the contrast with 'children of promise' in v. 28.

  27. αὐτῆς

    autēs · G846

    her · v25

    'Her', meaning Jerusalem as mother (and by extension Hagar). Under ancient law a slave mother's status passed to her children, which is the whole force of the image.

The world behind it

The crisis in Galatia. Paul's Gentile converts in central Asia Minor were being urged by other Christian teachers, probably Jewish believers, to be circumcised and take on the law of Moses (5:2–4; 6:12–13). The argument was likely that only this would make them full children of Abraham. Galatians 3–4 is Paul's answer to the question "Who are Abraham's true heirs?" Some scholars think the rival teachers had used the Sarah/Hagar story themselves: Gentiles are like Ishmael and must enter Isaac's line through the law. If so, Paul is taking over their story and turning it around (see Debates).

Slave mothers and their children. In Genesis, and in the wider ancient world, a child born to a slave woman normally took the mother's status. Roman law later stated this as a rule: the child follows the womb (partus sequitur ventrem). In Genesis 21:10 Sarah demands that "the son of this slave woman shall not be heir with my son Isaac." Paul quotes that line in 4:30. So "bearing children into slavery" is not just a vivid phrase. In law, it meant children who could not inherit.

Allegory as a known method. Greek-speaking Jews were used to reading Scripture for a deeper sense. Philo of Alexandria, Paul's older contemporary, wrote a whole treatise reading Abraham's union with Hagar as the mind's training in preliminary school subjects before it is joined to virtue (Sarah). Paul's method would sound familiar. His content would not.

Sinai "in Arabia." The next verse places Sinai "in Arabia," which was Hagar's descendants' territory according to Jewish tradition. Paul himself had spent time in Arabia after his conversion (1:17). He links Sinai to "the present Jerusalem," the city whose leaders and teachers stood behind law-observant demands.

From the study of Galatians 4:24.

Where scholars differ

in v24

Is Paul doing 'allegory' or 'typology'?

  • Essentially typology. Historical persons and events prefigure later realities, and Paul uses 'allegory' loosely.

    Paul treats Hagar, Sarah, Ishmael and Isaac as real people (4:22–23). He reads them as patterns repeated in history ('just as then… so also now', 4:29). Compare 1 Cor 10:6, 11, where events happened 'as types'.

  • Genuine allegory in the Hellenistic sense, mixed with typology.

    Paul uses the technical term itself. Equating a person with an abstract entity ('Hagar is Mount Sinai', 'is a covenant') goes beyond pattern-matching, much like Philo's readings of the same women. The neat modern distinction was formalised by later interpreters.

in v24

Whom or what does Hagar/Sinai represent?

  • Judaism or the Jewish people under the Mosaic covenant in general.

    The direct mention of Sinai and 'the present Jerusalem' (4:25). This reading was widespread from the church fathers onward.

  • Specifically the law-observant mission to Gentiles: the rival teachers' gospel that required Gentile converts to be circumcised.

    The letter's target is Gentiles being pressed toward circumcision (4:21; 5:2–4; 6:12–13). The present participle 'bearing children' suits an ongoing missionary activity. 4:30 ('cast out') addresses a congregational situation (J. L. Martyn, M. de Boer).

in v24

Did Paul pick this story, or answer his opponents' use of it?

  • Paul is reusing a text the rival teachers had already deployed (C. K. Barrett and others).

    The story fits Paul's case awkwardly, since Isaac is the circumcised son and Sinai belongs naturally to Sarah's line. The opponents could easily have cast Gentiles as Ishmael. Paul's elaborate inversion reads like a rebuttal.

  • Paul chose it himself to complete his chapter 3–4 argument about Abraham's heirs.

    The themes of inheritance, slavery and sonship and the 'promise versus flesh' contrast run continuously through 3:6–4:7. The story was a natural climax without needing an opponent's prompt.

in v24

Does the passive 'allēgoroumena' mean the text speaks allegorically or that Paul interprets it so?

  • 'These things are spoken allegorically': the Genesis text itself carries the hidden sense.

    Josephus and Philo speak of Moses himself 'allegorising'. Paul presents his reading as what 'the law' says (4:21).

  • 'These things are being interpreted allegorically': Paul announces his own method.

    The passive participle can describe a text undergoing interpretation. ESV and NIV take it in this direction.

in v25

Why does Paul say Hagar 'is' Mount Sinai? Is there a wordplay, a family link, or simply an allegorical equation?

  • A play on a local word or place name: Arabic ḥajar ('rock') or the place names Hagra/Hegra in the southern wilderness.

    The neuter article ('the [word] Hagar') suggests Paul is commenting on a name. Targumic 'Hagra' for the region of Shur, the Nabatean town of Hegra, and patristic comments that the mountain bore such a name locally all point this way. Critics note there is no clear first-century evidence that Sinai itself was called 'Hagar'.

  • A family-and-geography link: Hagar's descendants are the Arabs, and Sinai is in their land.

    The Hagrites and Ishmaelites were widely identified with Arab peoples (1 Chr 5:10; Ps 83:6; Josephus), and the phrase 'in Arabia' supports this. It needs no pun and fits all the textual variants.

  • A purely allegorical equation following from v. 24, with 'in Arabia' as a passing geographical remark.

    Verse 24 already says the Sinai covenant 'is Hagar'. If the original reading omits 'Hagar' in v. 25 (Sinaiticus, P46, Latin), the verse is simply a location note.

in v25

Who is 'the present Jerusalem and her children'?

  • Judaism or the Jewish people as a whole, insofar as they live under the Sinai covenant without Christ.

    Paul pairs Sinai, the Law and the city that was the center of Jewish life. Rom 9–11 shows Paul thinking about Israel as a whole. This has been the traditional reading in much of church history.

  • Primarily the Jerusalem-linked, Law-observant mission within the Jesus movement that was pressing the Galatians to be circumcised (associated especially with J. Louis Martyn and Martinus de Boer).

    The context is a dispute within the church: 'false brothers' (2:4), 'people from James' (2:12), the agitators (1:7; 5:10–12). The 'children' who 'persecute' (4:29) and are to be 'cast out' (4:30) fit these opponents in Galatia better than the Jewish people at large.

  • Mixed views: the Jerusalem-centered Law-covenant order generally, with the agitators as its present local expression.

    Paul's sweeping covenant language (v. 24) is broad, but the letter's purpose is concrete. Many commentators (e.g. Longenecker, Moo) hold both in view.

in v25

Is Paul's method 'allegory' in the Greek philosophical sense, or something closer to typology?

  • Genuine allegory, close to Philo's method of reading persons as abstract realities.

    Paul uses ἀλληγορούμενα (v. 24). Philo also allegorizes Hagar and Sarah, as preliminary schooling versus true virtue, in De Congressu.

  • Closer to typology: historical figures foreshadow later stages of God's dealings with his people.

    Paul does not deny the history. He ties it to covenants, cities and stages in salvation history ('now' versus 'above') rather than timeless virtues.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἀλληγορέω, διαθήκη, δουλεία, γεννάω
  • LSJ s.v. ἀλληγορέω
  • Heraclitus, Homeric Problems 5.2
  • Plutarch, De audiendis poetis 19E–F
  • Josephus, Antiquities 1.24; 1.214–221
  • Philo, De congressu eruditionis gratia (On Mating with the Preliminary Studies)
  • C. K. Barrett, 'The Allegory of Abraham, Sarah, and Hagar in the Argument of Galatians' (1976)
  • J. Louis Martyn, Galatians (Anchor Bible), comments on 4:21–5:1
  • Richard N. Longenecker, Galatians (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Hans Dieter Betz, Galatians (Hermeneia)
  • Martinus C. de Boer, Galatians (New Testament Library)
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed. apparatus on Gal 4:24–25
  • BDAG s.v. συστοιχέω, δουλεύω, Ἀραβία, Ἄγαρ
  • Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. συστοιχέω
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.), on Gal 4:25
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Gal 4:25
  • J. B. Lightfoot, Saint Paul's Epistle to the Galatians, notes on Gal 4:25 and 'The Words Ἁγὰρ and Σινᾶ'
  • J. Louis Martyn, Galatians (Anchor Bible 33A)
  • Richard N. Longenecker, Galatians (Word Biblical Commentary 41)
  • Douglas J. Moo, Galatians (BECNT)
  • Aristotle, Metaphysics 986a (Pythagorean table of opposites, συστοιχία)
  • Targum Onqelos, Gen 16:7; 20:1 ('Hagra')
  • Josephus, Antiquities (Nabatean 'Arabia')
  • Philo, De Congressu Eruditionis Gratia (allegory of Hagar and Sarah)
  • Vulgate, Ad Galatas 4:25

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).