Genesis Chapter 42 Read as one passage
Genesis 42:33–34
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
33Then the man who is lord of the land said to us, ‘This is how I will know whether you are honest: Leave one brother with me, take food to relieve the hunger of your households, and go. 34But bring your youngest brother back to me so I will know that you are not spies but honest men. Then I will give your brother back to you, and you can trade in the land.’”
What the first hearers heard
The Israelites who first heard this story heard it as part of the account of how their ancestors, the twelve sons of Jacob, came down to Egypt. This verse falls at the point where the pressure on the brothers starts to build.
- They would have caught the repetition with changes. Hebrew storytellers often have a character repeat earlier words, and they make the meaning sit in the differences. Hearers who had just heard Joseph say "one brother bound in prison… do this and live, for I fear God" (42:18–20) would notice that the sons' report to Jacob leaves out the threat of death and Joseph's appeal to God, and turns "bound" into "left". The brothers are protecting their father, and perhaps themselves, from the full harshness of what happened.
- They would have heard the irony. "The man", "lord of the land", the one who needs to "know" whether they are honest, is the brother they sold. The audience watches the guilty being questioned by the one they wronged, who is unrecognised and in full control.
- They would have felt the moral test. "Honest" is the claim on trial for the whole story. The question is whether the sons of Jacob are now men who will not give up a brother. This verse sets up the hostage arrangement that ends in Judah offering himself for Benjamin (44:33). In Israel's memory that act was where the brothers' unity, and so the people's future, was rebuilt.
- They would have felt the hunger. "The hunger of your households" reminded them that the nation's survival once depended on grain from Egypt, received at the cost of humbling themselves before a foreign ruler.
From the study of Genesis 42:33.
Verse by verse
-
33Then the man who is lord of the land said to us, ‘This is how I will know whether you are honest: Leave one brother with me, take food to relieve the hunger of your households, and go.
Full study →The brothers are back in Canaan, telling their father Jacob what happened in Egypt, and they quote the official word for word as they remember it:
"The man, the one who rules the country, said to us: 'Here is the test by which I will find out whether you really are what you claim to be, straight men and not spies. Leave one of your brothers here with me. Take what your starving families need, and go.'"
Several things sit under the surface. To the brothers he is only "the man", a nameless, all-powerful Egyptian. The reader knows he is Joseph, the brother they sold, so their calling him "lord" fulfils the dreams they once hated (37:5–8). His claim that he needs a test to "know" them is ironic, because he recognised them at once (42:8). What he is really testing is whether they are "honest" in the deeper sense: men who are what they say they are, which they had not been when they showed Jacob a bloodied robe. The "one" brother to be left behind echoes the previous line, where Joseph is "the one who is no more". One brother is already gone and another is now held. The brothers also choose their words for their father. They say Simeon was "left" with the man, when Joseph's actual words were that he would be "bound in prison" (42:19, 24). Finally, the Hebrew literally says "take the hunger of your households", a compressed phrase meaning take food for the hunger. It puts the families' need, not the grain, at the centre of what they carry home.
-
34But bring your youngest brother back to me so I will know that you are not spies but honest men. Then I will give your brother back to you, and you can trade in the land.’”
Full study →The brothers are telling their father Jacob what the Egyptian official said, and this verse ends their quotation: "Bring your brother, the young one, here to me, in person, so that I can confirm it: that you are not scouts spying out the land but men who are what you say you are. Then your brother, the one I am holding, I will hand back to you, and you will be free to come and go and do business in the land."
The verse is a strict deal: one brother brought, the other released. The proof is about identity. They called themselves kenim, "genuine, truthful men" (42:11), and now they have to show it. The reward is more than one more load of grain. It is a change of status, from suspects under watch at a foreign border to men allowed to move about and trade in Egypt.
Hebrew readers would also notice how carefully the brothers word it. Joseph actually said "so that your words may be verified and you will not die" (42:20). In their retelling the death threat is gone, Simeon is just "your brother" (they leave out that he was bound in front of them), and a promise of free trade has been added. They are softening the news for a grieving father. The irony runs underneath: men who sold their brother to "traders" now hope to "trade", and the man promising to "give your brother back to you" is the brother they sold.
Where the English drifted
-
in v33
houses (WEB, KJV 'households', YLT 'houses')
bāttêkhem (bayit)
- What we hear
- Buildings or homes: the places where the family lives.
- What they heard
- Households: the extended family group under one head, including wives, children and dependants. They are the people who are hungry.
-
in v33
true men (KJV)
kēnîm
- What we hear
- 'Genuine' or 'real men', or simply 'not lying' in a narrow sense.
- What they heard
- Upright men who are what they claim to be. In context it means not spies and with no hidden purpose. In 1611 'true' commonly meant loyal and honest.
-
in v34
traffick (KJV)
tischaru (sachar)
- What we hear
- Illegal 'trafficking' in drugs, weapons or people.
- What they heard
- To travel about and do ordinary, lawful business in a land; freedom to come and go and trade.
Every word
-
וַיֹּ֣אמֶר
vayyōmer · H0559
and he said · v33
The ordinary narrative 'and he said'. The brothers are now quoting the Egyptian official to Jacob, so this begins a report inside a report.
-
אֵלֵ֗ינוּ
ʾēlênû · H0413
to us · v33, v34
'To us.' The brothers put themselves in the scene as the ones who were spoken to, and under pressure.
-
הָאִישׁ֙
hāʾîsh · H0376G
-
אֲדֹנֵ֣י
ʾădōnê · H0113
lord of · v33
'Lord of'. It is plural in form but refers to one person. Hebrew sometimes uses a plural to stress rank or greatness. It marks him as the man with authority over the country, not a landowner.
-
הָאָ֔רֶץ
hāʾāreṣ · H0776G
the land · v33, v34
'The land', meaning Egypt as a country. Joseph is 'the governor over the land' (42:6), the one who controls the grain.
-
בְּזֹ֣את
bĕzōʾt · H2063
by this · v33
'By this.' It points forward to the test that follows. It introduces a proof the brothers must carry out, not just an order.
-
אֵדַ֔ע
ʾēdaʿ · H3045
I will know · v33, v34
'I will know.' Here it means knowing something because it has been proved, finding out by testing. The irony is that Joseph already knows exactly who they are. What he is testing is what kind of men they have become.
-
כִּ֥י
kî · H3588A
that · v33, v34
'That.' It introduces what will be known.
-
כֵנִ֖ים
khēnîm · H3651A
-
אַתֶּ֑ם
ʾattem · H0859D
you (plural) · v33, v34
'You [are]'. Hebrew needs no verb 'are' here. The plural makes the ten brothers one group on trial.
-
אֲחִיכֶ֤ם
ʾăḥîkhem · H0251G
your brother · v33, v34
'Your brother.' 'Brother' and 'brothers' run all through the Joseph story. The man they are speaking about is himself their brother.
-
הָֽאֶחָד֙
hāʾeḥād · H0259
the one · v33
'The one', so 'one of your brothers'. It repeats the 'one' of the verse before: 'the one is no more' (42:32). One brother is already lost, and now another 'one' (Simeon) is being held.
-
הַנִּ֣יחוּ
hannîḥû · H5117
-
אִתִּ֔י
ʾittî · H0854
with me · v33
'With me.' The hostage stays in the official's personal keeping, as a guarantee that they will come back.
-
וְאֶת־
wĕʾet · H0853
and [object marker] · v33, v34
'And' plus a small word that marks the next noun as the object. It puts 'the hunger of your households' first, before the verb, for emphasis.
-
רַעֲב֥וֹן
raʿăvôn · H7459
hunger, famine · v33
'The hunger of'. A rare word for famine or hunger. Read literally, 'take the hunger of your households' is a compressed way of saying 'take what your starving households need'.
-
בָּתֵּיכֶ֖ם
bāttêkhem · H1004M
your houses, households · v33
'Your households': the whole extended family each brother is responsible for, including wives, children and servants. Not buildings.
-
קְח֥וּ
qĕḥû · H3947G
take · v33
'Take!' A plural command: carry away what you came for.
-
וָלֵֽכוּ׃
wālēkhû · H1980G
and go · v33
'And go.' It closes the order bluntly. They are dismissed, but with a debt hanging over them: they must come back with the youngest brother (v. 34).
-
וְהָבִיאוּ
vehavi'u · H0935
and bring · v34
An order form of 'come' that means 'make come', so 'bring'. It is the condition everything else hangs on: no Benjamin, no proof.
-
הַקָּטֹן
haqqaton · H6996
-
לֹא
lo' · H3808
not · v34
A flat denial that sets aside the charge.
-
מְרַגְּלִים
meraggelim · H7270
spies · v34
From the word for 'foot': men who go over a land on foot to scout it, i.e. spies or reconnaissance agents (compare Joshua 2:1). The charge Joseph has repeated since 42:9 is that they came to see 'the nakedness of the land', its weak points.
-
אֶתֵּן
'etten · H5414
I will give · v34
'I will give', here meaning give back or hand over. A promise of release that matches the condition at the start of the verse: bring one brother, receive the other.
-
לָכֶם
lakhem · H9036
to you (plural) · v34
'To you', the brothers as a group.
-
תִּסְחָרוּ
tischaru · H5503
you will go about / trade · v34
A verb whose root sense is 'go around, travel about', which led to 'go around as a merchant, trade'. Here it promises free movement and dealing in Egypt: no longer suspects under watch, but men allowed to come and go and do business.
The world behind it
Famine refugees at Egypt's border. Egypt's grain came from the Nile flood, not from rain, so it often had food when Canaan did not. Egyptian records describe people from the Levant (the lands east of the Mediterranean) coming in during hard times. A frontier official's report from the late 1200s BC (Papyrus Anastasi VI) records letting herders from Edom past the border fortress "to keep them alive and to keep their cattle alive". The same sources show that the north-eastern frontier was guarded closely. That is why "you are spies, come to see the nakedness of the land" (42:9), meaning its undefended points, was a believable charge against ten armed men from Canaan travelling together.
Hostages as a guarantee. Holding one member of a group so that the rest will come back or keep their word was a familiar practice in the ancient Near East. Kings and treaty partners did it, and so did creditors. Keeping Simeon is a guarantee. Under the logic of the time, if the brothers do not return with Benjamin, their story is shown to be false and the hostage's life is forfeit.
The household. A bayit ("house") was the extended family under one head: Jacob, his sons, their wives and children, and servants. Each brother carries the hunger of his own household, and all of them depend on their father's decision.
From the study of Genesis 42:33.
Where scholars differ
in v33
Why does the brothers' report to Jacob (42:29–34) differ from what Joseph actually said (42:14–20)?
-
The brothers deliberately soften their account to spare their grieving father and to make the return with Benjamin sound less dangerous.
They leave out Joseph's three days of imprisonment, the death threat ('you shall not die', v. 20), and his 'I fear God' (v. 18). They turn 'bound in your prison house' (v. 19) into 'leave with me' (v. 33), and they add a reassuring promise that 'you may trade in the land' (v. 34), which Joseph never said. Commentators such as Sarna (JPS) and Wenham (WBC) read these as purposeful changes that show the brothers' new concern for Jacob.
-
The changes are mainly the narrator's art. Repeated speech is retold with variation to show the speakers' point of view and to keep the story moving, and not every change needs to be read as deliberate on the brothers' part.
Studies of Hebrew narrative technique (e.g. Robert Alter, The Art of Biblical Narrative; Meir Sternberg) show that repetition with small changes is a standard storytelling device. The narrator does not comment on the differences, and some of them, such as dropping 'grain', may simply be condensing.
in v34
Does sachar here mean 'trade' or 'move about freely'?
-
It means to trade or do business.
The participle socher means 'merchant' (Genesis 23:16; 37:28; Ezekiel 27). The Septuagint uses a commercial verb. The brothers came to buy grain, so commercial access is the natural reward.
-
It means to travel about, move freely through the land.
The root sense is 'go around'. Here the verb takes 'the land' as a direct object, which suits 'traverse the land'. Speiser (BASOR 164, 1961) argued that in Genesis 34:10, 21 and 42:34 it means freedom of movement for outsiders rather than commerce as such.
-
Both: the right of resident foreigners to move about and do business.
In practice the two went together. Being allowed to come and go in a foreign land was what made trading possible, so many commentators keep 'trade' while noting the movement sense.
in v34
Did Joseph promise trade, or did the brothers add it?
-
The brothers embellish to win Jacob over.
Joseph's recorded words (42:18–20) contain the death threat and no trade promise. The report also leaves out that Simeon was bound and that he was chosen in front of them. Many literary readers see deliberate softening.
-
The narrator abbreviates, and Joseph may have said more.
Hebrew narrative often reports only part of a conversation and fills in details later (compare 42:21–22 and 37:24). The promise follows naturally from being cleared of the spying charge.
Sources
- BDB s.v. כֵּן (adj. 'right, just, honest')
- HALOT s.v. כֵּן II; s.v. רְעָבוֹן; s.v. נוח hiphil
- Septuagint, Genesis 42 (Rahlfs), εἰρηνικοί for כֵּנִים
- Nahum M. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis (1989), on 42:29–38
- Gordon J. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary), on 42:29–38
- Claus Westermann, Genesis 37–50 (Continental Commentary)
- Robert Alter, The Art of Biblical Narrative; Genesis: Translation and Commentary
- Papyrus Anastasi VI (frontier report on Edomite herders admitted to Egypt), as discussed in Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia apparatus, Gen 42:33
- BDB s.v. סָחַר, כֵּן, רָגַל
- HALOT s.v. סחר, כֵּן II, רגל
- E. A. Speiser, 'The Verb SHR in Genesis and Early Hebrew Movements,' BASOR 164 (1961)
- G. J. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (WBC)
- V. P. Hamilton, The Book of Genesis 18–50 (NICOT)
- N. M. Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
- Septuagint, Genesis 42
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Genesis 42
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).