Isaiah Chapter 49 Read as one passage

Isaiah 49:20–21

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

20Yet the children of your bereavement will say in your hearing, ‘This place is too small for us; make room for us to live here.’ 21Then you will say in your heart, ‘Who has begotten these for me? I was bereaved and barren; I was exiled and rejected. So who has reared them? Look, I was left all alone, so where did they come from?’”

What the first hearers heard

For Judeans who knew Jerusalem as a pile of ruins and their community as scattered and shrunken, this verse was a picture of reversal they could almost hear: children's voices, arguments over space, a house too full. It answered Zion's specific complaints. To "The LORD has forsaken me" (v. 14) it answers that her house will be overfull. To "I was bereaved and barren" (v. 21) it answers that she will have children she did not know she had. To the lament "ṣar lî, I am in distress" (Lam 1:20) it answers that she will hear "ṣar lî, it's too tight!"

It also carried an implied judgement on Babylon, which had boasted of never knowing child-loss (Isa 47:8). The fortunes of the two women would be swapped.

The promise was about people and land: the return and multiplication of Israel's scattered population and the resettling of desolate places (v. 19). It was not a promise of individual comfort. It invited the exiles to see themselves as Zion's returning children and to imagine Jerusalem as a living city again, and so to take the risk of going home.

From the study of Isaiah 49:20.

Verse by verse

  1. 20Yet the children of your bereavement will say in your hearing, ‘This place is too small for us; make room for us to live here.’

    God is speaking to Zion, pictured as a mother who has lost every child and been left alone in a ruined house (v. 14: "The LORD has forsaken me"). He tells her: A day is still coming when you will hear it with your own ears. The very children who belong to your years of child-loss, children you never thought you would have, will be complaining in your hearing: "It's too tight in here for me! Shift over and let me settle down!"

    The picture is a crowded family home, siblings elbowing one another for a place to sit, and the mother overhearing the noise. The complaint "it's tight for me" (ṣar lî) is the same pair of words Hebrew used for "I am in distress", the words Zion herself had cried in her laments (Lam 1:20). Now they are heard again, but as a happy grumble about having too many people. The ruined, empty land of v. 19 becomes too small, not because of its devastation but because there are so many of her people. Proud Babylon, who boasted she would never know child-loss (Isa 47:8–9), is bereaved, and bereaved Zion is overrun with children. The mother is so astonished that in the next verse she asks, "Who bore me these?"

    Full study →
  2. 21Then you will say in your heart, ‘Who has begotten these for me? I was bereaved and barren; I was exiled and rejected. So who has reared them? Look, I was left all alone, so where did they come from?’”

    Mother Zion is talking to herself in wonder. She is amazed, and she can hardly believe what she sees:

    "Who bore these children for me? I had lost my children to death and deportation, and I was barren as stone besides. I was hauled off into exile and set aside, out of my place. And these, who brought them up into grown men and women? Look at me: I was the one left over, all by myself. These, where have they been? Where have they come from?"

    Each phrase takes away a natural explanation. She did not give birth to them, because her children were taken and she could have no more. She did not raise them, because she was in exile and alone. Yet here they are, filling the house so full that they complain there is no room (v. 20). She points at them three times ("these… these… these"), the way a stunned mother would gesture at a crowd at her door.

    The words come from the language of grief. The word for "bereaved" is used of a parent robbed of children. The word for "barren" means hard, unproductive ground. "Left alone" echoes the widowed city of Lamentations. Now that language is turned upside down. The questions get their answer in the next verse: God has raised his signal to the nations, and they come carrying her sons in their arms and her daughters on their shoulders. The children are a gift, brought home to a mother who had given them up for lost.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v20

    bereavement

    šikkulîm

    What we hear
    Grief after the death of any loved one, and the mourning process.
    What they heard
    Specifically the loss of one's children (by death, captivity or miscarriage), and with them the loss of lineage, security and future. 'Children of your bereavement' means the children belonging to the time she counted herself childless.
  • in v20

    too strait (KJV)

    ṣar

    What we hear
    Often misheard as 'straight', or taken as an obscure term of moral strictness.
    What they heard
    Narrow, tight, cramped: not enough room. It also echoes the idiom 'I am in distress' (literally 'it is tight for me').
  • in v21

    say in your heart

    ʾāmar bilvāv

    What we hear
    To feel something emotionally, or to say something deeply heartfelt.
    What they heard
    To think to yourself. In Hebrew the heart (lēvāv) is mainly where a person thinks, decides and reflects. The phrase introduces inner speech, here a private, incredulous thought.
  • in v21

    begotten (BSB, KJV, YLT)

    yālad

    What we hear
    Fathered by a man, or a solemn creed word ('only begotten').
    What they heard
    Most naturally 'bore, gave birth to' in this setting. The question is about who brought these children to birth for a mother who could not, with echoes of the custom of one woman bearing children counted as another's.
  • in v21

    removing to and fro (KJV); wandering back and forth (WEB)

    sûrāh

    What we hear
    A homeless wanderer drifting from place to place.
    What they heard
    Turned aside, removed, put out of place. The picture is of being set aside or displaced, which fits deportation, more than of aimless roaming. A 'wanderer' sense is possible but is an interpretation.
Every word
  1. עוֹד

    ʿôd · H5750

    still, yet, again · v20

    Points ahead to a future that will contradict the present: 'yet / once more' this will happen. It can also carry the sense 'still', meaning in spite of everything she has lost.

  2. יֹאמְרוּ

    yōʾmərû · H0559

    to say · v20, v21

    'They will say.' The verb form looks ahead: a scene the prophet describes as certain to come.

  3. בְאָזְנַיִךְ

    ḇəʾoznayiḵ · H0241

    ear · v20

    'In your ears.' The 'your' is feminine singular: it speaks to Zion pictured as a woman and mother (49:14). She will overhear her children's complaints with her own ears.

  4. בְּנֵי

    bənê · H1121

    son, child · v20

    'Sons/children of.' Here it means the offspring of Zion, that is, her people.

  5. שִׁכֻּלָיִךְ

    šikkulāyiḵ · H7923

    bereavement, loss of children · v20

    'Your child-loss.' This exact word appears only here in the Bible. It comes from the root for losing one's children, so 'children of your child-loss' are the children who belong to the time when she thought she had none left.

  6. צַר־

    ṣar · H6862A

    narrow, tight, cramped · v20

    'Too tight.' It repeats the root of 'too narrow' in v. 19. Elsewhere the phrase 'ṣar lî' is a standard cry of distress ('I am in a tight spot'), and here it is turned into a happy complaint about overcrowding.

  7. לִי

    lî · H9030

    for me · v20, v21

    'For me.' It is singular: each child speaks for himself, which makes the jostling vivid. BSB smooths it to 'us'.

  8. הַמָּקוֹם

    hammāqôm · H4725

    place · v20

    'The place': here the land or city where they live, meaning plain living space.

  9. גְּשָׁה־

    gəšāh · H5066

    draw near, step · v20

    A command with emphatic force, addressed to one male person: 'Shift!' Its basic meaning is 'step/come near', but with 'for me' it works like 'move over, shift up'. Because it is masculine, the speaker seems to be talking to a brother, not to the mother.

  10. וְאֵשֵׁבָה

    wəʾēšēḇāh · H3427

    sit, dwell, settle · v20

    'So that I can settle/sit down.' The form expresses the speaker's wish. It picks up 'inhabitant' (yôšēḇ, same root) in v. 19: the land once empty of inhabitants now has people competing for a place to settle.

  11. בִּלְבָבֵךְ

    bilvāvēkh · H3824

    heart · v21

    'In your heart.' In Hebrew the heart is where a person thinks, so 'say in your heart' means 'think to yourself'. These are Zion's private, astonished thoughts, not words spoken aloud.

  12. מִי

    mî · H4310

    who? · v21

    The first of two 'who?' questions. Each expresses bewildered wonder, not a request for information.

  13. יָלַד־

    yālad · H3205

    to bear, beget · v21

    'Bore' or 'brought to birth.' The verb is masculine because 'who' is general and unspecified, but the picture is of birth. Zion knows she never gave birth to these children.

  14. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    [direct-object marker] · v21

    This word has no English equivalent. It marks 'these' as the object of the verb, which puts weight on the children themselves.

  15. אֵלֶּה

    ʾēlleh · H0428

    these · v21

    'These.' She is pointing at the crowd of children in front of her (v. 20). The word comes three times in the verse, like a finger pointing again and again.

  16. וַאֲנִי

    waʾănî · H0589

    and I · v21

    'When I…' or 'whereas I…' The 'and' here sets up a contrast: they exist, yet I was childless.

  17. שְׁכוּלָה

    šəkhûlāh · H7909

    bereaved (of children) · v21

    This is the specific word for a parent whose children have died or been taken. It is not general sadness. It picks up 'the children of your bereavement' in v. 20.

  18. וְגַלְמוּדָה

    wəgalmûdāh · H1565

    barren, hard, sterile · v21

    'And barren.' A rare word for something hard and unproductive, like stony ground. She could not have had more children.

  19. גֹּלָה

    gōlāh · H1540

    go into exile · v21

    'Exiled.' This is the vocabulary of deportation. The city stands for her deported people. It sounds like galmûdāh just before it, so the two words chime.

  20. וְסוּרָה

    wəsûrāh · H5493

    turn aside; removed · v21

    'And put aside' or 'removed': someone moved out of her place and set aside. Translators vary between 'rejected', 'put away' and 'wandering'.

  21. גִדֵּל

    giddēl · H1431

    make great; rear · v21

    'Brought up' or 'raised.' Literally it means to make big, to grow a child into an adult. These are grown children, and she never raised them.

  22. הֵן

    hēn · H2005

    look! behold · v21

    'Look!' It draws attention to the plain fact that comes next.

  23. נִשְׁאַרְתִּי

    nišʾartî · H7604

    be left, remain · v21

    'I was left (over).' This is the language of what is left after loss, the same root as Isaiah's 'remnant'.

  24. לְבַדִּי

    ləvaddî · H0905

    alone, by myself · v21

    'By myself.' Completely alone. It echoes Lamentations 1:1, where the city sits 'alone' (bādād).

  25. אֵיפֹה

    ʾêpōh · H0375

    where? · v21

    'Where?' In context it means: where were they all this time, and where have they come from?

  26. הֵם

    hēm · H1992

    they · v21

    '[Are/were] they?' Hebrew needs no verb 'to be' here, so the question ends abruptly, as if she has run out of words.

The world behind it

A city as a mother. In the ancient Near East, cities were commonly pictured as women, often as the wife of a god and the mother of their citizens. Lamentations 1–2 shows Jerusalem after 587/586 BCE as a widow sitting alone, her children taken captive or dead. Isaiah 49:14–26 deliberately takes up that figure and reverses it.

What child-loss meant. For a woman in ancient Israel, losing her children was not only grief. It meant losing social standing, support in old age, the continuation of the family name and its hold on the land. A bereaved, childless woman was among the most exposed people in society. Promising such a woman a house overflowing with children promised her restored honour, security and a future.

The historical backdrop. Isaiah 40–55 speaks to Judeans living under, or just after, the Babylonian exile. Jerusalem's population had been killed, deported or scattered, and much of Judah was depopulated. The prophet's audience could see the ruins. In context the "children" are Zion's own scattered people, whom the nations will carry home "in their arms" and "on their shoulders" (v. 22).

Crowded living space. Lack of room was a known problem of settlement (Josh 17:14–18; 2 Kgs 6:1, where the phrase "the place is too narrow for us" also appears). Isaiah 54:1–3 develops the same promise: "Enlarge the place of your tent… for you will spread out to the right and to the left."

From the study of Isaiah 49:20.

Where scholars differ

in v20

Who are 'the children of your bereavement'?

  • Children born to Zion during her bereavement: a new generation she did not know she had (NIV, KJV's paraphrase, many commentators).

    v. 21: Zion is astonished ('Who bore me these? I was bereaved and barren… where did they come from?'), which makes sense only if she does not recognise them. The paradox of childlessness producing children fits Isa 54:1 ('more are the children of the desolate one').

  • The very children she lost, now restored (LXX 'whom you had lost'; NASB).

    The plain sense of the root ('to lose children'). v. 22 shows the nations carrying 'your sons' and 'your daughters' home, which suggests the returning exiles are the lost children themselves.

  • Both at once: the exiles and their exile-born offspring, Zion's lost children who come back greater in number than she lost.

    Ancient 'sons' language covers descendants. The returning community was largely a generation born in Babylon (compare NLT's interpretation), so they are her lost children and also children she never bore.

in v20

Is the echo of Lamentations ('ṣar lî', Lam 1:20) intentional?

  • Yes: Isaiah 40–55 systematically answers Zion's laments in Lamentations.

    Studies of the prophet's use of earlier texts (e.g. Sommer; Willey) note many verbal links. Isa 49:14–21 takes up Lamentations' picture of the bereaved, abandoned woman, and the identical phrase on a speaker connected to Zion is striking.

  • Possibly coincidental: ṣar lî is an ordinary idiom.

    The phrase also occurs in the Psalms (31:10; 69:18 Heb.), and here its literal spatial sense, 'narrow', is driven by v. 19 (tēṣrî, 'you will be too narrow').

in v21

Who are the children Zion does not recognise?

  • The returning diaspora: Zion's own scattered people, who grew up and multiplied in exile and among the nations.

    Verse 22 calls them 'your sons' and 'your daughters', carried by the nations. Verse 12 has them coming from far away, from north and west and the land of Sinim. Verse 18 says 'they all gather and come to you'. Her failure to recognise them fits a generation born and raised abroad.

  • The children include, or point toward, people added to Zion from outside: proselytes or the nations themselves. Later Jewish and Christian interpreters developed this reading (Christians often applied it to the church).

    Zion insists she bore none of them. Isaiah 56:3–8 welcomes foreigners who join themselves to the LORD. In Galatians 4:27 Paul applies the closely related Isaiah 54:1 ('the children of the desolate one are more…') to a people of promise beyond natural descent. Within 49:21–22 itself, however, the nations are the carriers, not the children, so this reading goes beyond what the verse states.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. שׁכל, שִׁכֻּלִים, צַר, נָגַשׁ, יָשַׁב
  • HALOT s.v. שִׁכֻּלִים; צַר I; נגשׁ
  • Septuagint, Isaiah 49:20 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Isaiah 49:20
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 40–55 (Anchor Bible)
  • B. S. Childs, Isaiah (Old Testament Library)
  • C. Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (OTL)
  • J. Goldingay & D. Payne, Isaiah 40–55 (ICC)
  • B. D. Sommer, A Prophet Reads Scripture: Allusion in Isaiah 40–66
  • P. T. Willey, Remember the Former Things: The Recollection of Previous Texts in Second Isaiah
  • BDB s.v. גַּלְמוּד, שָׁכֹל, גָּדַל, סוּר
  • HALOT s.v. גַּלְמוּד, שָׁכוּל, גָּלָה
  • Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Isaiah 49:21
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus at Isa 49:21
  • Joseph Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 40–55 (Anchor Bible)
  • Claus Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (Old Testament Library)
  • Brevard S. Childs, Isaiah (Old Testament Library)
  • Patricia Tull Willey, Remember the Former Things: The Recollection of Previous Texts in Second Isaiah
  • Christl M. Maier, Daughter Zion, Mother Zion

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).