Jeremiah Chapter 28 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 28:13–16

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

13“Go and tell Hananiah that this is what the LORD says: ‘You have broken a yoke of wood, but in its place you have fashioned a yoke of iron.’ 14For this is what the LORD of Hosts, the God of Israel, says: ‘I have put a yoke of iron on the neck of all these nations to make them serve Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon, and they will serve him. I have even given him control of the beasts of the field.’” 15Then the prophet Jeremiah said to the prophet Hananiah, “Listen, Hananiah! The LORD did not send you, but you have persuaded this people to trust in a lie. 16Therefore this is what the LORD says: ‘I am about to remove you from the face of the earth. You will die this year because you have preached rebellion against the LORD.’”

What the first hearers heard

To the priests and people who had watched Hananiah snap the yoke in the temple courts, this verse said that his dramatic act had achieved nothing they hoped for. Breaking a symbol does not break the thing it stands for. Worse, the hope he offered was dangerous. Telling Judah and its neighbours that Babylon was finished invited the rebellion that would bring a harsher subjugation, an "iron yoke" like the one Deuteronomy's covenant curses had warned of.

The verse also settled the question everyone was asking: which of two prophets, both saying "Thus says the LORD", was telling the truth? Jeremiah's message was unpopular. Submit to Babylon, the exile will be long (compare 29:10, seventy years), do not trust promises of a quick return. This verse, and Hananiah's death that followed (28:15–17), marked Jeremiah's word as the real one. For later readers in exile, the passage explained why the comforting prophets had been wrong. Their disaster had come not because God failed but because they had believed a softer word than the one God gave.

From the study of Jeremiah 28:13.

Verse by verse

  1. 13“Go and tell Hananiah that this is what the LORD says: ‘You have broken a yoke of wood, but in its place you have fashioned a yoke of iron.’

    The LORD sends Jeremiah back with an urgent order: Go, say this to Hananiah, as the LORD's own message: "You snapped bars of wood, and the result is that you will make bars of iron in their place."

    Hananiah had torn the wooden yoke off Jeremiah's neck and announced that God was breaking Babylon's power over the nations within two years, the way God once broke Egypt's yoke in the exodus. God's answer takes his gesture seriously and turns it inside out. Yes, something was broken, but it was only wood. The yoke itself (the same word, "bars", is repeated on both sides of the verse) is not going anywhere. What changes is its material. A wooden yoke chafes but can be broken. An iron yoke cannot. By urging the nations to throw off Babylon, Hananiah has not freed anyone. He has, in effect, forged a harder bondage for them. Judean listeners would hear in "iron yoke" the old covenant curse of Deuteronomy 28:48: "he will put an iron yoke on your neck." Babylonian rule was not a passing setback that the right prophecy could cancel. It was a judgment that resistance could only make heavier. (The Greek translation reads "and I will make", which makes the iron yoke God's own counter-move. The point stays the same: breaking the sign does not break the reality.)

    Full study →
  2. 14For this is what the LORD of Hosts, the God of Israel, says: ‘I have put a yoke of iron on the neck of all these nations to make them serve Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon, and they will serve him. I have even given him control of the beasts of the field.’”

    "Because this is what Yahweh, Commander of armies and Israel's own God, has declared: I have already fastened a yoke of iron on the neck of all these nations, the very kingdoms whose envoys are plotting in Jerusalem, Judah among them, harnessing them like oxen to labour for Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon. And labour for him they will. I have even handed over to him the wild creatures of the open country."

    The verse answers Hananiah. He had snapped the wooden yoke-bars off Jeremiah's neck and announced that within two years God would break Babylon's yoke. God's reply is that breaking the wood has only produced iron. The image recalls the covenant curse in Deuteronomy 28:48, "an iron yoke on your neck". The verbs are in the completed form ("I have put", "I have given"). On God's side the matter is settled, and no counter-prophecy or rebellion will undo it. "Serve" here means the servitude of a subject state: tribute, loyalty oaths and forced labour. The closing line about wild animals is deliberate overstatement. It uses the language of humanity's rule over creation to show that Nebuchadnezzar's God-given authority, for the time being, extends even past the boundaries of human society.

    Full study →
  3. 15Then the prophet Jeremiah said to the prophet Hananiah, “Listen, Hananiah! The LORD did not send you, but you have persuaded this people to trust in a lie.

    Then Jeremiah, the prophet, spoke face to face with Hananiah, who was also called "the prophet." The two men carried the same title, used the same formula ("Thus says the LORD of Hosts"), and stood in the same temple court. "Hear this now, Hananiah! The LORD never commissioned you. He did not send you as his messenger or authorize you to speak in his name. But you — you — have made this people lean their whole weight on something that will not hold. You gave them a feeling of safety, and that safety rests on falsehood, an empty promise that is bound to fail them."

    Jeremiah does not dispute Hananiah's sincerity, his eloquence, or his religious credentials. He denies the one thing that made a prophet's word count: being sent. The emphatic "you" contrasts what God did not do with what Hananiah did. The verb is not simply "you told them" but "you caused them to trust." The people's false security is his doing and his responsibility. The final word, sheqer, is Jeremiah's great word for false security: groundless confidence in the temple, in lying scribes, in prophets of quick peace. The verse also sets up a grim wordplay in the next line. The LORD did not send Hananiah, so now the LORD will send him off the face of the earth (28:16).

    Full study →
  4. 16Therefore this is what the LORD says: ‘I am about to remove you from the face of the earth. You will die this year because you have preached rebellion against the LORD.’”

    "So, then, here is what Yahweh has said: Look, I am sending you. Not on a mission, as you claimed, but away, off the face of the ground where the living walk. This very year, not in your 'two years,' you are a dead man, because what you spoke in Yahweh's name was a call to turn away from Yahweh."

    The verse rests on a pun. A moment earlier Jeremiah told Hananiah, "Yahweh did not send you" (v.15). Now Yahweh says, "I am sending you." The same verb in a stronger form means dismissing, driving out, expelling, the word used when Adam is sent out of the garden. The prophet who claimed to be sent gets his sending after all, and it is death. "This year" answers Hananiah's own timetable (he had promised the exiles' return "within two years"). The charge, "you have spoken sārâ," means turning aside or defection, and it repeats word for word the law in Deuteronomy 13 about a prophet who leads the people away from their God and must die. The verb forms make the doom feel already under way: "I am in the act of sending you… you are dying."

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v13

    yoke

    motah / 'ol

    What we hear
    A vague picture of any burden or oppression, or a shoulder yoke for carrying buckets.
    What they heard
    The wooden crossbar tied onto a draft animal's neck, and as an image, a vassal nation's formal submission to an imperial overlord: paying tribute, staying loyal, not rebelling. 'Breaking the yoke' meant political revolt.
  • in v14

    LORD of Hosts

    YHWH tsevaʾot

    What we hear
    A vague grand title. 'Host' suggests a crowd, or someone who welcomes guests.
    What they heard
    'Yahweh of armies': commander of the heavenly and earthly forces. That fits a verse about God assigning imperial power.
  • in v14

    serve

    ʿavad

    What we hear
    Helping, working for someone, offering service, possibly by choice.
    What they heard
    The political servitude of a subject state under an emperor: tribute, loyalty oaths, troops and labour, with rebellion forbidden.
  • in v14

    beasts of the field

    ḥayyat hassadeh

    What we hear
    Farm animals grazing in a field.
    What they heard
    Wild animals of the open country, the creatures outside human control. Giving them to Nebuchadnezzar shows how total his authority is.
  • in v15

    a lie

    sheqer

    What we hear
    A statement the speaker knows is untrue, a deliberate deception, so Hananiah must have been a conscious fraud.
    What they heard
    Falsehood in a wider sense: what is groundless, empty and bound to disappoint those who rely on it. It can describe a message that is false whether or not the speaker believes it. The charge is that the message has no divine backing and will fail, and that Hananiah is accountable for spreading it.
  • in v15

    prophet

    navi

    What we hear
    A person who predicts the future, or a uniquely holy figure set apart from ordinary religious professionals.
    What they heard
    A recognized religious role, a spokesperson claiming to bring a deity's word. The same title is given here to both the genuine and the unsent speaker. The title alone guaranteed nothing.
  • in v16

    rebellion

    sārâ

    What we hear
    Political uprising or general defiance of authority.
    What they heard
    Turning aside, defection, apostasy: speech that draws people off the path of loyalty to Yahweh. It is the specific legal charge against a misleading prophet in Deut 13.
  • in v16

    the face of the earth

    pənê hāʾădāmâ

    What we hear
    The whole planet or the whole world.
    What they heard
    The surface of the ground, the soil where people live, with the overtones of the land and of Cain's expulsion 'from the face of the ground.'
Every word
  1. הָלוֹךְ֩

    halokh · H1980

    to go, walk · v13

    A bare verb form (an infinitive used as a command) meaning 'Go!'. It is brisk and urgent: Jeremiah, who had walked away silently in 28:11, is now sent back with an answer.

  2. וְאָמַרְתָּ֨

    ve'amarta · H0559

    to say · v13, v14, v15, v16

    'And you shall say.' This form carries on the command 'Go', so it means 'go and say', a commission like a king sending a herald.

  3. אֶל־

    'el · H0413

    to, toward · v13, v15, v16

    Marks Hananiah as the person spoken to. The message is aimed at him personally, not at the crowd in general.

  4. חֲנַנְיָ֜ה

    chananyah · H2608

    Hananiah · v13, v15

    The prophet from Gibeon (28:1) who had announced in the LORD's name that Babylon's yoke was broken. His name means 'Yahweh has been gracious', which sharpens the irony: he promised a grace God had not announced.

  5. כֹּ֚ה

    koh · H3541

    thus, so · v13, v14, v16

    First word of the messenger formula 'Thus says…'. Hananiah had used the very same formula (28:2, 11), so two prophets are claiming the same authority with opposite messages.

  6. יְהוָ֔ה

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh, the LORD · v13, v14, v15, v16

    The personal name of Israel's God. The real dispute in this chapter is which prophet actually carries this name's message.

  7. מוֹטֹ֥ת

    motot · H4133

    bars, poles; yoke-bars · v13

    The wooden crossbars of a yoke, the physical object Jeremiah had worn on his neck (27:2) and Hananiah had snapped (28:10). The plural likely means the whole set of bars that made up the yoke.

  8. עֵ֖ץ

    'ets · H6086

    wood, tree · v13

    'Of wood.' This stresses that the yoke was breakable. Wood is set against iron at the end of the verse.

  9. שָׁבָ֑רְתָּ

    shavarta · H7665

    to break, shatter · v13

    'You have broken.' It echoes Hananiah's own oracle, 'I have broken the yoke of the king of Babylon' (28:2). God answers: what you broke was only wood.

  10. וְעָשִׂ֥יתָ

    ve'asita · H6213

    to make, do · v13

    Normally 'and you will make', which presents the iron yoke as the result of the broken wooden one. Some translations put it in the past ('you have made'). The Greek has 'I will make' (see textual notes).

  11. תַחְתֵּיהֶ֖ן

    tachteihen · H8478

    under; in place of · v13

    'In their place': the iron bars replace the wooden ones. Breaking the sign did not remove the yoke. It swapped in a harder one.

  12. בַּרְזֶֽל׃

    barzel · H1270

    iron · v13, v14

    'Of iron': the hardest common metal of the age, a picture of what cannot be broken. It closes the verse and recalls the covenant curse of an 'iron yoke' in Deuteronomy 28:48.

  13. כִּ֣י

    ki · H3588A

    for, because · v14, v16

    Links this oracle to verse 13 and gives the reason behind it: Hananiah's broken wooden yoke has been replaced with iron because of what God has decreed.

  14. צְבָא֜וֹת

    tsevaʾot · H6635B

    armies, hosts · v14

    'Of armies.' It presents Yahweh as commander of heavenly and earthly forces. That fits a verse where he decides which empire rules the nations.

  15. אֱלֹהֵ֣י

    ʾelohei · H0430G

    God of · v14

    'The God of'. Israel's own God is the one handing his people and their neighbours over to Babylon, so the defeat is not a sign that Babylon's gods have won.

  16. יִשְׂרָאֵ֗ל

    Yisraʾel · H3478

    Israel · v14

    The covenant people. By this time it effectively means Judah, the surviving southern kingdom.

  17. עֹ֣ל

    ʿol · H5923

    yoke · v14

    The wooden harness put on draught oxen. It was a standard ancient image for political subjection and forced labour under an overlord. Here it means vassalage to Babylon.

  18. נָתַ֜תִּי

    natatti · H5414H

    I have put / set · v14

    'I have put.' A completed action: from God's side the decision is already in force, whatever Hananiah predicts.

  19. עַל־

    ʿal · H5921A

    upon · v14, v15, v16

    'On.' The weight rests on top of the neck, as with a draught animal.

  20. צַוַּ֣אר׀

    tsawwar · H6677A

    neck · v14

    Singular, 'the neck of all these nations'. Hebrew often uses a singular this way for a group, but the picture fits a team yoked together. It also recalls Jeremiah wearing the yoke on his own neck (27:2; 28:10).

  21. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all · v14

    No nation in the anti-Babylonian alliance is left out, Judah included.

  22. הַגּוֹיִ֣ם

    haggoyim · H1471A

    nations · v14

    Peoples as political units. It is not a word for individual non-Jews here.

  23. הָאֵ֗לֶּה

    haʾelleh · H0428

    these · v14

    Points to a known group: Edom, Moab, Ammon, Tyre and Sidon, whose envoys were in Jerusalem (27:3), together with Judah (27:12).

  24. לַעֲבֹ֛ד

    laʿavod · H5647G

    to serve, work for · v14

    'To serve.' The service of a subject state: tribute, loyalty, labour and military obligation to an overlord. It does not mean helping out or volunteering.

  25. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    [marks the object] · v14, v15

    Shows that Nebuchadnezzar is the one who is served. It has no English equivalent.

  26. נְבֻכַדְנֶאצַּ֥ר

    Nevukhadnetsar · H5019

    Nebuchadnezzar · v14

    Nebuchadnezzar II of Babylon (reigned 605–562 BC). Earlier in this section God calls him 'my servant' (27:6).

  27. מֶֽלֶךְ־

    melekh · H4428G

    king of · v14

    His royal title. It puts him alongside the kings whose envoys were meeting in Jerusalem, and above them.

  28. בָּבֶ֖ל

    Bavel · H0894

    Babylon · v14

    The Neo-Babylonian empire, centred on the city of Babylon.

  29. וְגַ֛ם

    vegam · H1571

    and also, even · v14

    'And even.' It adds a further, surprising extent to his authority.

  30. חַיַּ֥ת

    ḥayyat · H2416C

    living creature(s), wild animal(s) · v14

    A collective singular, 'the wildlife'. It means untamed animals, as distinct from domestic livestock (behemah).

  31. הַשָּׂדֶ֖ה

    hassadeh · H7704G

    field, open country · v14

    The open land beyond the towns, wild or grazing country. It does not mean a fenced farm field. 'Beasts of the field' means wild animals.

  32. לֽוֹ׃

    lo · H9033

    to him · v14

    'To him', meaning Nebuchadnezzar. It closes the verse on the person who holds the power God has granted.

  33. יִרְמְיָה

    yirmeyah · H3414

    Jeremiah · v15

    The name probably means something like 'Yahweh lifts up' or 'Yahweh establishes.' Chapters 27–29 use this shorter spelling (-yah rather than the usual -yahu).

  34. הַנָּבִיא

    hannavi · H5030

    the prophet · v15

    Jeremiah's title. The narrator gives exactly the same title to Hananiah in the next breath, so on the surface the two men look alike.

  35. שְׁמַע־

    shema- · H8085

    hear! · v15

    A command: 'Hear!' In Hebrew, 'hearing' includes paying attention and taking it to heart. It is the word of the Shema (Deut 6:4), now turned on a prophet who claimed to speak for God.

  36. נָא

    na · H4994

    please, now · v15

    A small particle that softens or presses a command: 'do hear,' 'listen now.' Here it is less politeness than an urgent call for attention before the verdict.

  37. לֹא־

    lo- · H3808

    not · v15

    A flat denial placed first for emphasis: 'Not — has the LORD sent you.'

  38. שְׁלָחֲךָ

    shelachakha · H7971

    he sent you · v15, v16

    'Sent' is the technical word for a prophet's commission, like an envoy dispatched by a king. Denying that he was sent denies his authority altogether. The next verse plays on the same verb: God will now 'send' Hananiah off the face of the earth.

  39. וְאַתָּה

    ve'attah · H0859

    and you · v15, v16

    Hebrew does not need the separate pronoun, so including it is emphatic: 'but YOU.' It sets what God did not do against what Hananiah did do.

  40. הִבְטַחְתָּ

    hivtachta · H0982

    you made (them) trust · v15

    This is the causing form of 'to trust, feel secure': 'you have caused to rely, you have made feel safe.' The verb form presents it as something already done. The people's false sense of security is laid at Hananiah's door.

  41. הָעָם

    ha'am · H5971

    the people · v15

    The people of Judah and Jerusalem, the whole community whose national policy was at stake, not only the crowd in the temple court.

  42. הַזֶּה

    hazzeh · H2088

    this · v15

    'This people.' In Jeremiah the phrase often carries a note of distance or disappointment (compare 7:16; 14:11).

  43. שָׁקֶר

    shaqer (sheqer) · H8267

    falsehood, deception · v15

    What is false, groundless, and bound to let you down. It is one of Jeremiah's keywords. The stress is on the message being empty and failing, not only on whether Hananiah knew it was untrue.

  44. לָכֵ֗ן

    lākēn · H3651C

    therefore · v16

    Preposition 'to' + 'so': 'for that reason.' This is the standard word that turns a prophet's accusation (v.15) into the sentence that follows from it.

  45. הִנְנִי֙

    hinnî · H2005

    look! / here I am · v16

    'Look, I…' Placed before a participle, it marks something about to happen, almost under way: 'I am right now about to…'

  46. פְּנֵ֣י

    pənê · H6440J

    face, surface · v16

    Literally 'faces of.' Together with 'ground' it forms the stock phrase 'the face of the ground,' the inhabited surface where the living walk.

  47. הָאֲדָמָ֑ה

    hāʾădāmâ · H0127I

    ground, soil, land · v16

    The tillable ground and the land people live on, not 'the planet.' The phrase recalls Cain being driven 'from the face of the ground' (Gen 4:14) and the warnings that Israel would be removed from its land.

  48. הַשָּׁנָה֙

    haššānâ · H8141

    year · v16

    With the article, 'this year,' meaning the current one. It answers Hananiah's 'within two years' (28:3, 11): his promised timeline will not come, but this one will.

  49. מֵ֔ת

    mēt · H4191

    to die · v16

    Participle, 'dying.' It reads like a verdict already in force: 'you are a dead man,' with death imminent.

  50. סָרָ֥ה

    sārâ · H5627

    turning aside, defection, revolt · v16

    From 'to turn aside.' It means defection or disloyal apostasy, a message that leads people away from their God. It is the exact word of the false-prophet law in Deut 13:5 (13:6 Heb).

  51. דִבַּ֖רְתָּ

    dibbartā · H1696G

    speak · v16

    'You have spoken.' Hananiah's crime was his speech: public prophetic words given in Yahweh's name.

The world behind it

When and where. Jeremiah 27–28 is set in 594/593 BC, the fourth year of King Zedekiah (28:1). Three years earlier, in 597, Nebuchadnezzar had taken Jerusalem, deported King Jehoiachin and the city's leading citizens, and carried off temple vessels. Now envoys from Edom, Moab, Ammon, Tyre and Sidon had come to Jerusalem (27:3), apparently to plan a joint revolt. The Babylonian Chronicle records an uprising inside Babylon itself around 595/594, which may have encouraged hopes that the empire was weakening.

The yoke as political language. In the ancient Near East, "yoke" was the ordinary picture for a vassal's submission to an overlord, the way an ox submits to its driver. Assyrian and Babylonian kings boasted of laying "the yoke of my lordship" on conquered peoples. "Bearing the yoke" meant paying tribute and staying loyal. "Breaking the yoke" meant rebellion. When Jeremiah walked around Jerusalem wearing an ox yoke (27:2), everyone understood: submit to Babylon and live (27:11–12).

Prophetic sign-acts. Prophets often acted out their messages, and these acts were understood not as mere illustrations but as setting the announced word in motion (compare Zedekiah son of Chenaanah's iron horns in 1 Kings 22:11). So when Hananiah broke Jeremiah's yoke in front of priests and people in the temple (28:1, 10), it was a counter-sign meant to undo Jeremiah's message. Jeremiah did not argue on the spot. He "went his way" (28:11). Only afterwards did a word come (28:12), and this verse is that word. Hananiah died within the year (28:17). In 589–586 Judah rebelled, and Jerusalem was destroyed.

From the study of Jeremiah 28:13.

Where scholars differ

in v13

Who makes the iron yoke: Hananiah (Hebrew) or the LORD (Greek)?

  • The standard Hebrew text ('you will make') is original. Hananiah's false prophecy, by encouraging revolt, is what produces the harsher yoke.

    It is the harder reading, and scribes tend to smooth hard readings rather than create them. It makes sense in context: rebellion against Babylon led to 586. The Vulgate and the Masoretic tradition support it, and it carries the irony of the wood/iron reversal.

  • The Greek ('I will make') reflects the original Hebrew, and God answers Hananiah's sign with his own.

    It matches 28:14, 'I have put a yoke of iron.' Greek Jeremiah often preserves an older, shorter Hebrew text (Hebrew fragments of Jeremiah from Qumran, such as 4QJer-b, show that a shorter form of the book existed). The difference is one letter.

in v13

Is the iron yoke past ('you have made') or future ('you will make')?

  • Future: it is the consequence that will follow from Hananiah's act.

    This is the normal force of the Hebrew form after a past-tense verb (KJV, Vulgate).

  • Past or completed: Hananiah has in effect already made the iron yoke by his act.

    This is how many modern translations read it (BSB, WEB). Prophets often speak of what is certain as already done, and 28:14 says 'I have put' an iron yoke.

in v14

What does the change from a wooden to an iron yoke mean: harsher servitude, or a servitude that cannot be broken?

  • Harsher servitude. Hananiah's defiance, and the people's trust in him, made the coming subjection more severe.

    Verse 13 says 'you have made in its place bars of iron', which makes Hananiah responsible. The echo of Deut 28:48 ('until he has destroyed you') points to escalating judgment, and the later rebellion did bring Jerusalem's destruction.

  • An unbreakable decree. The iron does not increase the burden; it shows that no counter-prophecy or rebellion can break what God has set.

    In verse 14 God says 'I have put' the yoke, with nothing about it getting heavier. Iron stands for firmness elsewhere in Jeremiah (1:18; 15:12). The point of the confrontation is whose word stands.

in v14

Is the grant of wild animals to Nebuchadnezzar part of the original text or a later expansion?

  • A later addition in the longer Hebrew edition, borrowed from 27:6.

    The Old Greek lacks it, and Greek Jeremiah generally reflects an earlier, shorter Hebrew text supported by Dead Sea Scroll fragments.

  • Original to the Hebrew tradition of this oracle, which deliberately repeats 27:6 to tie the two halves of the yoke story together.

    The theme of dominion over wild animals appears again in Dan 2:38 and 4:12, 21. The Greek translator of Jeremiah sometimes condenses repeated material.

in v15

Was Hananiah a conscious deceiver or a sincere prophet who was wrong?

  • Sincere but mistaken: Hananiah honestly spoke from Judah's established Zion theology.

    His message echoes Isaiah's tradition of God defending Jerusalem (vindicated in 701 BC). He uses the proper messenger formula and performs a public sign-act. Jeremiah's first response is 'Amen, may the LORD do so' (28:6), which takes the hope seriously. Scholars of prophetic conflict (e.g. Crenshaw, Overholt) stress how hard it was for hearers at the time to tell the two apart. Sheqer need not imply deliberate lying.

  • Culpable regardless of sincerity: the text holds him fully responsible.

    The verse uses the emphatic 'you' and a causing verb ('you made this people trust'). Verse 16 charges him with 'speaking rebellion' (quoting Deut 13:5), and he dies as Deut 18:20 prescribes. Jeremiah 23:16, 26 accuses such prophets of speaking 'the vision of their own heart' and 'the deceit of their own heart,' so in Jeremiah's view self-generated confidence is itself guilt.

in v15

How could the original audience tell which prophet was sent?

  • By fulfilment, following Deuteronomy 18:21–22.

    Jeremiah himself says the prophet of peace is recognized 'when his word comes to pass' (28:9). The chapter closes by recording Hananiah's death as Jeremiah foretold (28:17).

  • By the content and its moral direction, not only by outcome.

    Jeremiah 28:8 notes that true prophets of old generally announced war, disaster and plague. Jeremiah 23:14, 17, 22 judges prophets who strengthen evildoers and promise 'peace' without calling for repentance. Deuteronomy 13 shows that even a fulfilled sign does not validate a word that leads away from the LORD.

in v16

Is the closing clause ('because you have spoken rebellion against the LORD') original?

  • It is a later addition to the Hebrew text.

    The Greek lacks it. The same phrase appears in Jer 29:32 and Deut 13:5, which makes borrowing likely, and the longer Hebrew edition of Jeremiah elsewhere shows editors filling out phrases (Holladay, Carroll).

  • It belongs to the text, and the Greek reflects a shortened or different edition.

    The clause fits the logic of the scene (accusation in v.15, legal charge in v.16), and Jeremiah uses the same formula of Shemaiah in 29:32 (Lundbom).

in v16

Was Hananiah a deliberate deceiver or a sincere prophet who was wrong?

  • A sincere prophet standing in an established tradition.

    His message echoes Isaiah's promises that Zion would be protected (Isa 37:33–35). He uses the correct prophetic forms and even acts out his message, breaking the yoke. Scholars such as Crenshaw and Overholt read the chapter as a clash between two traditions, with no sure test available in the moment.

  • The text presents him as culpable, whatever his inner motives.

    The narrative's verdict is 'Yahweh did not send you… you made this people trust in a lie' (v.15). The charge is sārâ, and his death confirms the verdict (v.17). The text judges what he said and its effect, not his sincerity.

in v16

How far has the episode been shaped by later editors?

  • Strongly shaped by later editors steeped in Deuteronomy.

    The vocabulary of Deut 13 and 18, the neat fulfillment, and the parallel with Shemaiah in ch. 29 suggest a story shaped by editors to teach how to tell true prophets from false (Thiel, Carroll).

  • Based on a remembered historical confrontation.

    The specific dates (fifth and seventh months of Zedekiah's fourth year), the named person and the hometown, and the setting of the anti-Babylonian coalition fit known history in 594/593 BC (Lundbom, Holladay).

Sources
  • BDB s.v. מוֹטָה
  • HALOT s.v. מוֹטָה, בַּרְזֶל
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia)
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible)
  • W. McKane, Jeremiah II (ICC)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 35:13 (Göttingen/Rahlfs)
  • Babylonian Chronicle (ABC 5), Nebuchadnezzar years 1–11
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 27–28
  • Deuteronomy 28:48; Leviticus 26:13 (cross-references)
  • BDB s.v. עֹל, בַּרְזֶל, עָבַד, חַיָּה, שָׂדֶה, צָבָא
  • HALOT s.v. עֹל; מוֹטָה; צָבָא
  • E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (on the two editions of Jeremiah)
  • Babylonian Chronicle (ABC 5 / BM 21946), Nebuchadnezzar's 10th–11th years
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 35:14 (Göttingen ed., Ziegler)
  • BDB s.v. שֶׁקֶר, בָּטַח, שָׁלַח, נָבִיא
  • HALOT s.v. שֶׁקֶר; בטח (hiphil)
  • Thomas W. Overholt, The Threat of Falsehood: A Study in the Theology of the Book of Jeremiah (1970)
  • James L. Crenshaw, Prophetic Conflict: Its Effect upon Israelite Religion (1971)
  • William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia)
  • Jack R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible)
  • Babylonian Chronicle (Grayson ABC 5) on Nebuchadnezzar's reign, 597–594 BC
  • Septuagint Jeremiah 35 (= MT 28); Vulgate Jeremiah 28:15
  • Deuteronomy 13:1–5; 18:15–22; Jeremiah 14:14–15; 23:21, 32; 27:15; 29:9, 31
  • BDB s.v. סָרָה; s.v. שָׁלַח
  • HALOT s.v. סָרָה; s.v. אֲדָמָה; s.v. שׁלח
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar §116p (participle after הִנֵּה for imminent action)
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia), on Jer 28
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible), on Jer 28
  • R. P. Carroll, Jeremiah (Old Testament Library)
  • J. L. Crenshaw, Prophetic Conflict (1971)
  • T. W. Overholt, The Threat of Falsehood (1970)
  • Rahlfs-Hanhart Septuaginta, Jeremias 35:16
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, Jer 28:16

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).