Jeremiah Chapter 40 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 40:14–16

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

14and said to him, “Are you aware that Baalis king of the Ammonites has sent Ishmael son of Nethaniah to take your life?” But Gedaliah son of Ahikam did not believe them. 15Then Johanan son of Kareah spoke privately to Gedaliah at Mizpah. “Let me go and kill Ishmael son of Nethaniah,” he said. “No one will know it. Why should he take your life and scatter all the people of Judah who have gathered to you, so that the remnant of Judah would perish?” 16But Gedaliah son of Ahikam said to Johanan son of Kareah, “Do not do such a thing! What you are saying about Ishmael is a lie.”

What the first hearers heard

For the people who first heard or read this account, exiles in Babylon and refugees in Egypt in the decades after 586 BC, the verse was part of an explanation of how the last chance in the land was lost.

  • Real hope, briefly. Under Gedaliah, Judah had a small new beginning: people gathered, crops were harvested, and Jeremiah himself chose to stay (40:6). Johanan's words, "all Judah who have gathered to you", name that hope.
  • A warning that was not heeded. The reader knows what happens next. Gedaliah refuses to believe it (40:16), and Ishmael kills him (41:2). Johanan's "no one will know" comes back as "no one knew" (41:4). The story builds suspense and grief.
  • The irony around Johanan. The man who here fears the remnant will be scattered and perish later leads that same remnant to Egypt, against God's word through Jeremiah (43:1–7). There, Jeremiah announces, the remnant of Judah will perish (44:12). The vocabulary of this verse (scatter, remnant, perish) runs through to the end of the story.
  • Moral unease. Hearers who knew the law's curse on whoever "strikes his neighbour in secret" (Deut 27:24) would feel the tension in Johanan's plan, even though the text does not condemn him outright. Gedaliah's refusal can be read as honourable but fatally naïve, or as righteous restraint. The narrative leaves the reader to weigh it.

Above all, the passage helped later communities understand why the future of Judah ended up depending on the exiles in Babylon rather than on those who stayed in the land (compare Jer 24).

From the study of Jeremiah 40:15.

Verse by verse

  1. 14and said to him, “Are you aware that Baalis king of the Ammonites has sent Ishmael son of Nethaniah to take your life?” But Gedaliah son of Ahikam did not believe them.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 15Then Johanan son of Kareah spoke privately to Gedaliah at Mizpah. “Let me go and kill Ishmael son of Nethaniah,” he said. “No one will know it. Why should he take your life and scatter all the people of Judah who have gathered to you, so that the remnant of Judah would perish?”

    Then Johanan son of Kareah, the leading commander of Judah's surviving troops, took Gedaliah aside in secret at Mizpah, the governor's seat after Jerusalem's destruction. Politely but urgently he asked his superior for permission: "Please let me go and strike down Ishmael son of Nethaniah. No one will ever know who did it. Why should he strike you down, take your very life, and so cause all Judah, everyone who has come back and gathered around you, to be scattered again, and what is left of Judah to be wiped out?"

    The Hebrew turns on one repeated verb, strike: "let me strike him... why should he strike you?" Johanan frames the choice as kill or be killed. His promise that "no one will know" is grimly reversed a few verses later, when Ishmael murders Gedaliah and the text uses the same words: "no one knew" (41:4). The second half of his appeal uses the old language of exile. The survivors have just been gathered (the verb the prophets use for God bringing his people home), and losing their leader would scatter them again, as the covenant curses had threatened. "Remnant" here means the literal survivors of 586 BC, the last of Judah still in the land. The question is whether even they will survive.

    Full study →
  3. 16But Gedaliah son of Ahikam said to Johanan son of Kareah, “Do not do such a thing! What you are saying about Ishmael is a lie.”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v15

    smite thy soul (YLT)

    hikkah nefesh

    What we hear
    Attacking or destroying someone's inner spiritual self or immortal soul.
    What they heard
    A fixed Hebrew idiom for killing a person: 'strike someone as to life', i.e. take his life.
  • in v15

    the Jews (KJV, WEB)

    kol-Yehudah

    What we hear
    Jewish people as a religious and ethnic community in the later, post-biblical sense.
    What they heard
    'All Judah': the Judeans, people of the former kingdom and territory of Judah, gathered at Mizpah. It is a national and regional name. The religion later called 'Judaism' was still taking shape and is not what the word means here.
Every word
  1. וְיוֹחָנָ֣ן

    veYochanan · H3110

    and Johanan · v15

    'Yah has been gracious.' Johanan is the leading commander of the Judean troops who had survived out in the countryside (40:8, 13). Putting his name first in the Hebrew makes him the focus: after the group warning of v.14, he now acts alone.

  2. בֶּן־

    ben- · H1121

    son of · v15

    Names him by his father, the normal way to identify a man publicly.

  3. קָרֵ֡חַ

    Qareach · H7143

    Kareah · v15

    His father's name, probably meaning 'bald'. Known only as Johanan's father.

  4. אָמַ֣ר

    amar · H559

    said · v15

    Plain past tense 'said'. The verb form breaks the chain of the story, signalling a new scene after the officers' joint report.

  5. אֶל־

    el- · H413

    to · v15

    Directed to Gedaliah personally.

  6. גְּדַלְיָהוּ֩

    Gedalyahu · H1436

    Gedaliah · v15

    'Yah is great.' The Judean noble the Babylonians had made governor of the land after Jerusalem fell (40:5, 7).

  7. בַסֵּ֨תֶר

    vasseter · H5643

    in secret · v15

    'In the hiding / in secret.' This is a private, confidential approach, away from the other officers and from anyone who might tip off Ishmael. The secrecy suits the plan: a covert killing.

  8. בַּמִּצְפָּ֜ה

    bammitspah · H4709

    at Mizpah · v15

    'The Lookout.' The town in Benjamin north of Jerusalem that served as Gedaliah's seat of government after Jerusalem was destroyed.

  9. אֵ֤לְכָה

    elekhah · H1980

    let me go · v15

    A first-person request form: 'let me go.' Johanan volunteers and asks for authorisation; he does not act on his own.

  10. נָּא֙

    na · H4994

    please · v15

    A softening word of request ('please', 'I pray you'). It is deferential: a soldier asking his superior for permission.

  11. וְאַכֶּה֙

    ve'akkeh · H5221

    and let me strike · v15

    'And I will strike / let me strike down.' In context of a human target, the verb means to kill. This is a pre-emptive strike: kill the assassin before he kills the governor.

  12. אֶת־

    et- · H853

    (object marker) · v15

    An untranslatable word marking Ishmael as the definite object of the verb.

  13. יִשְׁמָעֵ֣אל

    Yishma'el · H3458

    Ishmael · v15

    'God hears.' A member of the Davidic royal family and a former high officer of the king (41:1), now said to be an agent of the Ammonite king.

  14. נְתַנְיָ֔ה

    Netanyah · H5418

    Nethaniah · v15

    'Yah has given.' Ishmael's father; 41:1 adds that his grandfather was Elishama, of royal descent.

  15. וְאִ֖ישׁ

    ve'ish · H376

    and a man / anyone · v15

    With the negative that follows, 'a man ... not' means 'no one'.

  16. לֹ֣א

    lo · H3808

    not · v15

    Negates 'will know'.

  17. יֵדָ֑ע

    yeda' · H3045

    will know · v15

    'No one will know.' Johanan promises the killing can be done without being traced back to Gedaliah. The same words come back with bitter irony in 41:4, where Ishmael murders Gedaliah and 'no one knew.'

  18. לָ֧מָּה

    lammah · H4100

    why? · v15

    'Why should...?' A rhetorical question that urges action: there is no reason to let this happen.

  19. נֶּ֗פֶשׁ

    nefesh · H5315

    life · v15

    'Strike you as to life', a fixed Hebrew expression for killing someone. Nefesh here is the person's life, not an inner 'soul'.

  20. וְנָפֹ֙צוּ֙

    venafotsu · H6327

    and be scattered · v15

    'And they will be scattered.' The governor's death would break up the community that had just regathered, a word that carries the language of exile.

  21. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all · v15

    'All of' the Judeans gathered there: the whole fragile community, not a faction.

  22. יְהוּדָ֔ה

    Yehudah · H3063

    Judah · v15

    Used as a collective for the people: 'all Judah' = all the Judeans. KJV and WEB render 'the Jews'.

  23. הַנִּקְבָּצִ֣ים

    hanniqbatsim · H6908

    who have been gathered · v15

    'The ones gathered.' It recalls 40:11–12, where Judeans who had fled to Moab, Ammon and Edom came back to Gedaliah. This is the same verb the prophets use for God regathering his scattered people.

  24. וְאָבְדָ֖ה

    ve'avedah · H6

    and perish · v15

    'And it will perish / be lost.' The verb is feminine singular, agreeing with 'remnant'. It speaks of destruction or vanishing: the end of Judah's remaining population in the land.

  25. שְׁאֵרִ֥ית

    she'erit · H7611

    remnant · v15

    'What is left' after the catastrophe of 586 BC. Here it means the actual survivors in the land. The word was also taking on the prophetic sense of the people through whom Judah would go on.

The world behind it

After the fall of Jerusalem (586 BC). Babylon had burned the Temple and deported much of the population. It appointed Gedaliah son of Ahikam as governor over those left in the land, mostly the poor plus some officials and soldiers (40:7). His family, the house of Shaphan, had supported Jeremiah and favoured submission to Babylon (26:24; 36:10). His father Ahikam had protected the prophet from a lynch mob.

Mizpah (most likely Tell en-Nasbeh, about 13 km north of Jerusalem) became the new administrative centre. Excavations there show the town was occupied without a break through the Babylonian period while Jerusalem lay in ruins. A seal found there reading "belonging to Jaazaniah, servant of the king" is often linked to the "Jaazaniah" of 40:8, though the identification is not certain.

The players.

  • Johanan son of Kareah led one of the "commanders of the forces in the open country" (40:7, 13), troops who had escaped capture when Jerusalem fell.
  • Ishmael son of Nethaniah was "of the royal seed" (41:1), a member of the Davidic family. He might well resent a non-royal governor serving Babylon.
  • Baalis, king of Ammon (40:14) was apparently stirring up resistance to Babylon. A 7th–6th century BC seal impression found at Tell el-'Umeiri in Jordan reads "belonging to Milkom'ur, servant of Ba'alyasha'", and many scholars identify Ba'alyasha' with the Baalis of this verse.

Why the stakes were so high. Gedaliah had promised under oath that those who served Babylon would be safe (40:9–10), and refugees came back from Moab, Ammon and Edom to harvest wine and summer fruit (40:11–12). A Babylonian-appointed governor murdered by Judeans would look like rebellion and bring reprisals. Johanan's fear came true: after Ishmael's assassination the survivors fled to Egypt in terror of Babylonian revenge (41:16–18; 43:5–7). Jewish tradition later kept a fast in the seventh month in memory of the murder (Zech 7:5; 8:19, the "Fast of Gedaliah").

From the study of Jeremiah 40:15.

Where scholars differ

in v15

Was Gedaliah's refusal (v.16) admirable or fatally naïve, and was Johanan's plan justified?

  • Gedaliah was naïve and the narrative faults his misplaced trust.

    The warning is given twice (v.14 by all the officers, v.15 privately by Johanan). Gedaliah calls it 'a lie' (sheqer, v.16), a strong word in Jeremiah usually used for false prophecy, and the 'lie' turns out to be true (41:1–3). The story's structure stresses that the warning was rejected.

  • Gedaliah's refusal reflects principled restraint, and the narrative does not endorse pre-emptive secret killing.

    Deut 27:24 curses 'striking a neighbour in secret'. Killing a Davidic prince on rumour could set off exactly the chaos Johanan feared. Johanan's later conduct (taking the remnant to Egypt against God's word, ch. 43) makes him an unreliable guide to wisdom. The text records but never praises his proposal.

in v15

How soon after Jerusalem's fall did Gedaliah's governorship end?

  • Within a few months, in the seventh month of 586 BC.

    Jer 41:1 dates the murder to 'the seventh month' without naming a year, and the narrative flow from 40:12 (summer harvest) suggests the same year.

  • Several years later, around 582 BC.

    The amount of administrative activity and resettlement implied seems hard to fit into a few weeks. Jer 52:30 records a third Babylonian deportation in Nebuchadnezzar's 23rd year (582 BC), which may have been the reprisal for Gedaliah's murder. Scholars such as Lipschits have weighed this option.

in v15

Why did Baalis of Ammon want Gedaliah dead?

  • An anti-Babylonian strategy: removing Babylon's client government in Judah.

    Ammon had joined earlier anti-Babylonian plotting (Jer 27:3). Ezek 21:18–32 pictures Nebuchadnezzar choosing between Jerusalem and Rabbah of Ammon. Josephus (Antiquities 10.181–182) reports a Babylonian campaign against Ammon and Moab around 582 BC.

  • Regional rivalry: keeping a revived Judah weak, using a disaffected Davidic prince.

    Ishmael's royal descent (41:1) gave him his own motive, and after the murder he fled to Ammon (41:10, 15), which suggests a working alliance whatever Baalis's wider aims.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. סֵתֶר, נָכָה, נֶפֶשׁ, פּוּץ, שְׁאֵרִית
  • HALOT s.v. נֶפֶשׁ, שְׁאֵרִית, קבץ
  • Jack R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible)
  • William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia)
  • Oded Lipschits, The Fall and Rise of Jerusalem: Judah under Babylonian Rule
  • Larry G. Herr, 'The Servant of Baalis', Biblical Archaeologist 48 (1985) — Tell el-'Umeiri seal impression
  • Jeffrey R. Zorn, studies of Tell en-Nasbeh (Mizpah) in the Babylonian period
  • Josephus, Antiquities 10.155–182
  • 2 Kings 25:22–26 (parallel account)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.