Job Chapter 15 Read as one passage

Job 15:8–9

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

8Do you listen in on the council of God or limit wisdom to yourself? 9What do you know that we do not? What do you understand that is not clear to us?

What the first hearers heard

Ancient readers would hear an elder sage putting a younger, presumptuous man in his place. The weapons are irony and familiar religious imagery: the heavenly council, the primeval wise man, wisdom as something given by God and handed down through generations. The rhetorical questions require the answer "No". No human sits in God's council or owns wisdom.

The book, however, frames the speech so that the reader knows more than Eliphaz does. Chapters 1–2 have already shown God's council debating Job. The point Eliphaz makes against Job, that no one has been in God's council, turns back on Eliphaz. His confident account of why the wicked suffer (15:20–35) is also not based on any seat in that council. Job 28 and the divine speeches (38:4, "Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?") later develop the same theme Eliphaz raises here. When God asks, God asks everyone, and Eliphaz is finally rebuked as well (42:7). For the first readers, then, the verse is both a sound principle (human wisdom has limits) and a warning about using that principle as a weapon while ignoring one's own limits.

From the study of Job 15:8.

Verse by verse

  1. 8Do you listen in on the council of God or limit wisdom to yourself?

    Eliphaz is mocking Job: "Were you sitting in on God's private council, listening in to what is discussed there? Have you drained all wisdom away from the rest of us and kept it for yourself?"

    Both halves are scornful questions, and both expect the answer "Of course not." The first line pictures God enthroned among his heavenly advisors, a closed inner circle (Hebrew sod) where God's plans are discussed and decided. Eliphaz asks whether Job attends and listens there regularly. The second line pictures wisdom as a shared supply that Job has "drawn off" and diverted to himself, as if he had cornered the market. The verb is the one Eliphaz used four verses earlier, when he said Job's words "diminish" devotion toward God. So the charge has two sides: Job takes away from piety and hoards wisdom.

    Together with v. 7 ("Were you the first man born, brought forth before the hills?"), the verse sarcastically gives Job the status of a primeval being, as old as creation and present when God made his decisions. Only someone like that could claim the certainty Job seems to claim.

    The reader catches an irony that Eliphaz does not. Job 1–2 has already shown a heavenly council where Job's case was discussed, and none of the human speakers, Eliphaz included, was present. His question also strikes his own confident claims about how God works.

    Full study →
  2. 9What do you know that we do not? What do you understand that is not clear to us?

    Eliphaz throws two scornful questions at Job, both expecting the answer "nothing at all": "What have you come to know that we do not know? What do you see into that we don't already have in hand?"

    The verse is built from Job's own words. Earlier Job had said, "What you know, I also know; I am not inferior to you" (13:2), and had mocked the friends: "Truly you are the people, and wisdom will die with you!" (12:2). Eliphaz now reverses the boast. If Job claims equality, what superior knowledge does he actually have? The second line, literally "and it is not with us?", uses the language of possession: wisdom is something held, kept, inherited, and Eliphaz insists the friends hold it. In the next verse he names where it came from: the gray-haired elders, men older than Job's father.

    "Know" and "understand" together cover the whole range of wisdom, both settled knowledge and discerning insight. The contrast between one man ("you") and a group ("we") frames the dispute as a solitary sufferer presuming against the consensus of the wise. The question comes right after verse 8, "Do you listen in on the council of God?", so Eliphaz is accusing Job of claiming private access to divine secrets that would put him above everyone else.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v8

    secret (KJV), secret counsel (WEB, YLT)

    sod

    What we hear
    A piece of hidden information or a mystery that Job might have found out.
    What they heard
    The closed council around God's throne together with the confidential deliberations held there. The image is an assembly room, not a hidden fact.
  • in v8

    restrain wisdom to thyself (KJV)

    garaʿ ʾeleikha

    What we hear
    Holding wisdom back or keeping it in check, as if Job were being reticent.
    What they heard
    Drawing wisdom off from others to yourself, so that you have it all and they have none.
Every word
  1. הַבְס֣וֹד

    havsod · H5475

    council, intimate circle; confidential talk · v8

    The prefix ha- turns the whole line into a question, and be- means "in". Sod is the closed circle of trusted insiders and the private discussion that goes on inside it. Here it is God's own council in heaven. The question is sarcastic: "Were you in the room?"

  2. אֱל֣וֹהַ

    ʾeloah · H0433

    God · v8

    The singular, old poetic name for God that the book of Job prefers. It suits the speakers' setting outside Israel and gives the debate a formal, lofty tone.

  3. תִּשְׁמָ֑ע

    tishmaʿ · H8085

    hear, listen · v8

    "Do you listen?" The verb form describes something ongoing or habitual. The picture is a regular attendee or eavesdropper who keeps hearing what God and his council discuss. It is more than having heard one secret once.

  4. וְתִגְרַ֖ע

    wetigraʿ · H1639

    diminish, take away, withdraw, draw off · v8

    Used with "to yourself", it means pulling something away from others and drawing it to yourself, as if Job had cornered the supply of wisdom so that nobody else has any. Eliphaz used the same verb in v. 4 ("you diminish devotion before God"). The repeated word sharpens the charge: Job takes away piety from God and draws off wisdom for himself.

  5. אֵלֶ֣יךָ

    ʾeleikha · H0413

    to, toward (you) · v8

    "To yourself" or "toward yourself". It gives the direction of the drawing-off: wisdom flows to Job and stops there.

  6. חָכְמָֽה׃

    ḥokhmah · H2451

    wisdom, skill, insight · v8

    In Job, wisdom is insight into how the world and God's ways work. In the Hebrew wisdom tradition it is also linked with God's own plans from the time of creation. Eliphaz mocks Job for acting as if he owns it.

  7. מַה־

    mah · H4100

    what? · v9

    Opens a rhetorical question that expects the answer "nothing." It probably governs both halves of the verse, so the second line is also a "what" question even though the word is not repeated.

  8. יָּדַעְתָּ

    yāḏaʿtā · H3045

    to know · v9

    "You have come to know / you know" (completed form, second person singular). It points at knowledge Job claims to have gained: what does he possess as settled knowledge?

  9. וְלֹא

    wəlōʾ · H3808

    and not · v9

    "And not": sets Job's supposed knowledge against the friends' lack of it. In English it works like "that we do not."

  10. תָּבִין

    tāḇîn · H995

    to understand, discern · v9

    "You understand / discern." A near-synonym of "know" in the parallel line, with more of the sense of insight, of seeing through to how things are. With no question word of its own it leans on the "what" at the start of the verse.

  11. עִמָּנוּ

    ʿimmānû · H5973

    with us · v9

    "With us," meaning in our possession, held by us. In Job, wisdom is spoken of as something that resides "with" someone (12:2, 12:13), so this picks a fight over who actually holds wisdom.

  12. הוּא

    hûʾ · H1931

    he, she, it · v9

    "It": the thing Job supposedly understands. Hebrew needs no "is" here, so the line literally reads "and not with us [is] it."

The world behind it

Where this falls in the book. Chapter 15 opens the second round of speeches. Eliphaz, the oldest and mildest of the three friends, is now openly impatient. Verses 2–6 call Job's speech windy and self-condemning. Verses 7–10 then challenge Job's credentials as a wise man. Job had said in 12:3 and 13:2, "I am not inferior to you", and 15:7–9 answers that boast.

God's council. Israel and its neighbours often pictured the high God holding court, surrounded by heavenly attendants who discuss and carry out his decisions. Examples are 1 Kings 22:19–22, Psalm 82 and Psalm 89:5–7, and the assembly of El in the Ugaritic texts. Being admitted to that council and hearing its deliberations was the mark of a true prophet (Jer 23:18, 22; Amos 3:7). Eliphaz is asking whether Job has inside access of that kind. Eliphaz himself had claimed a night-time revelation in 4:12–17, which makes the question especially pointed.

The "first man" and Wisdom. Verse 7 sets up v. 8. "Brought forth before the hills" repeats the words of personified Wisdom in Proverbs 8:25, who was present when God made the world. Ezekiel 28:12–15 describes a figure in Eden, full of wisdom, on God's mountain. Eliphaz may be drawing on a tradition about a primeval wise man who stood near God's council. Whatever the exact background, the logic is clear: wisdom about God's ways belongs to the ancient and the initiated, and Job is neither.

Age and wisdom. In v. 10 Eliphaz adds that "the grey-haired and the aged are on our side". In that honour culture, accumulated tradition and seniority carried authority. Eliphaz is putting Job in his place as a junior who has overreached.

From the study of Job 15:8.

Where scholars differ

in v8

Does v. 7–8 allude to a specific myth of a primeval wise man who sat in God's council?

  • Yes. Eliphaz is drawing on a tradition, also reflected in Ezekiel 28:12–15 (the wise being in Eden on God's mountain), of a first human who had access to the divine council and divine wisdom, and possibly took wisdom for himself.

    Ezekiel 28 and Job 15:7–8 share wisdom, Eden or primeval origins, and nearness to God. The sense "draw off for yourself" of garaʿ fits a story of seizing wisdom. Commentators such as Pope and Habel discuss this background.

  • No specific myth is needed. The lines are ironic exaggeration built from Israel's own wisdom tradition, especially personified Wisdom in Proverbs 8.

    "Brought forth before the hills" repeats Proverbs 8:25 almost word for word. The divine-council image is common in Israel's own scriptures (Jer 23; Ps 89; 1 Kgs 22). Several commentators, including Clines, are cautious about reconstructing a lost myth.

in v8

What exactly does garaʿ + "to yourself" mean here?

  • "Draw off, take for yourself": Job has seized or monopolised wisdom.

    Numbers 36:3–4 (an inheritance taken from one and added to another); Job 36:27 ("draws up" drops); the preposition "to yourself". This is the reading of most modern commentators and is reflected in idioms like "monopoly".

  • "Limit or restrict wisdom to yourself": Job confines wisdom to his own person.

    This keeps closer to the common meaning "diminish, reduce" and is the choice of KJV, ESV, BSB and WEB. The practical sense is close to the first view.

  • "Diminish" with wisdom as the subject: wisdom (God's) becomes less than you.

    Apparently the Vulgate's reading. It uses the basic meaning of the verb but requires taking ḥokhmah as the subject, which the Hebrew word order does not favour.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. סוֹד; גָּרַע; אֱלוֹהַּ
  • HALOT s.v. סוֹד; גָּרַע
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary), on 15:7–9
  • M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible), on 15:7–8
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (OTL), on ch. 15
  • Supplied source text with lemma/Strong's/morphology (Job 15:8)
  • BSB, KJV, WEB, YLT (supplied)
  • BDB s.v. יָדַע
  • HALOT s.v. יָדַע
  • BDB s.v. בִּין
  • HALOT s.v. בִּין
  • BDB s.v. עִם (possession sense)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs-Hanhart), Job 15:9
  • Vulgate, Job 15:9
  • Supplied interlinear data (lemma, Strong's, morphology)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).