Job Chapter 27 Read as one passage
Job 27:11–12
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
11I will instruct you in the power of God. I will not conceal the ways of the Almighty. 12Surely all of you have seen it for yourselves. Why then do you keep up this empty talk?
What the first hearers heard
To the first readers of Job, Israelite sages and their students thinking about why the righteous suffer, this verse marked a dramatic moment. The accused man stands up and claims the teacher's chair. The verb of instruction (yarah) and the promise not to conceal (kachad) both belong to the vocabulary of faithful testimony. Job is casting himself as the honest witness, over against friends who, as he said earlier, "speak falsely for God" (13:7).
Readers would also have heard the edge in "the hand of God." In Job that hand has struck an innocent man. Whatever Job goes on to say about the wicked in vv. 13–23, he says it as someone who knows from his own body that God's hand does not move as neatly as the friends' theory requires. The verse leads into v. 12: "you have all seen it yourselves, so why this empty talk?" The facts are available to everyone, and the friends' failure is not lack of evidence but refusal to admit it.
The verse also prepared readers for the great question of chapter 28: where can wisdom be found? Job claims to disclose "what is with Shaddai," and the book soon concludes that wisdom finally lies with God alone (28:23).
From the study of Job 27:11.
Verse by verse
-
11I will instruct you in the power of God. I will not conceal the ways of the Almighty.
Full study →"Now I will be your teacher, all of you. I will point out to you what the hand of God actually does, that hand whose power I have felt in my own body. Whatever Shaddai, the ancient and overwhelming God, holds in his mind and carries out in the world, I will not keep back or hush up."
The verse turns the tables. Through the whole debate the three friends have been the instructors and Job the pupil who needed correcting. Here Job takes up the very verb of instruction, the root behind torah, and points it at them. "The hand of God" is not a neutral phrase in this book: it is what Job says has struck him (19:21). "What is with Shaddai" means God's own purposes and dealings, the hidden things Zophar said no human could search out (11:7). The promise "I will not conceal" carries on the oath Job has just sworn (27:2–6) that his lips will speak no deceit. He will say what is true about God even when it does not fit the tidy picture, and the next verse scolds the friends for their "empty talk" (hevel, vapor) when they have seen the same facts themselves.
-
12Surely all of you have seen it for yourselves. Why then do you keep up this empty talk?
Full study →"Look, you yourselves, every one of you, have seen it with your own eyes. So why on earth do you keep breathing out mere breath?"
Job has just sworn a solemn oath by God that he is innocent (27:2–6) and promised to teach his friends about "the hand of God" without hiding anything (v. 11). Now he turns on all three at once. The first line is heavy with emphasis: "look", "you", "all of you". The friends kept appealing to what they had seen of life, and Job says their eyes have already shown them the truth. The second line is a frustrated "why then?" with a mocking sound in Hebrew: hevel tehbalu, literally "vapor you vapor" or "breath you breathe." Hevel is a puff of air or mist, something with no weight that vanishes as soon as it appears. The verb form shows an ongoing habit: they keep on producing it. The charge isn't that they are conceited ("vain" in the modern sense). It is that their speeches, however pious they sound, are hot air. They have no substance and give no help, and they deny what the friends themselves have witnessed. Behind the image is also a hint, familiar from Jeremiah's "they went after vapor and became vapor", that people who keep talking emptiness are becoming empty themselves.
Where the English drifted
-
in v11
the Almighty
Shaddai
- What we hear
- An abstract theological attribute: omnipotence, God's ability to do anything at all.
- What they heard
- An ancient proper name for God whose origin is uncertain (perhaps "the One of the mountain" or "of the steppe"). In Job it names the God of overwhelming, unanswerable power who has afflicted Job. It is a name with a feel of patriarchal antiquity more than a philosophical term.
-
in v12
vain / altogether vain (KJV, WEB; also ESV)
hevel tehbalu
- What we hear
- Conceited, self-admiring, proud of oneself.
- What they heard
- Empty, breath-like, without substance: speaking or acting in a way that has no weight and achieves nothing. Literally "breathing out breath."
Every word
-
אוֹרֶ֣ה
'oreh · H3384
to teach, point out, instruct · v11
"I will teach / I will show." This is the causative form of a verb that literally means to throw or point. Here it means to point something out, to give instruction. It is the same root as torah, "instruction." Job puts himself in the teacher's seat, which until now his friends had claimed.
-
אֶתְכֶ֣ם
'etkhem · H853
object marker + "you" (plural) · v11
"You all." The plural matters. Job is speaking to all three friends together (Eliphaz, Bildad, Zophar), not to God.
-
בְּיַד־
beyad- · H3027
hand; power, agency · v11
"Concerning the hand of." In Hebrew the hand is the usual picture for power and for action actually carried out. The little prefix be- most likely means "about" here: the subject of Job's lesson is what God's hand does. It can also be read as "by" (KJV).
-
אֵ֑ל
'El · H410
God · v11
The old, short Semitic word for God. Like the speakers in the rest of Job's poetry, Job uses ancient general names (El, Eloah, Shaddai) instead of the covenant name YHWH.
-
אֲשֶׁ֥ר
'asher · H834
which, that which · v11
"What / that which." It opens the second line's object: whatever is with Shaddai.
-
עִם־
'im- · H5973
-
שַׁ֝דַּ֗י
Shaddai · H7706
Shaddai, "the Almighty" · v11
An ancient divine name used 31 times in Job, set in parallel with El. It is traditionally rendered "Almighty." Here it balances "the hand of God" in the first line.
-
לֹ֣א
lo' · H3808
not · v11
A plain, firm negation: "I will not."
-
אֲכַחֵֽד׃
'akhakhed · H3582
to hide, conceal, withhold · v11
"I will conceal." The intensive form of the verb means to keep back or suppress what one knows. Job promises not to hold back the truth about God's ways, though it is uncomfortable. The friends, in his view, have been doing exactly that by defending God with falsehood (13:7–8).
-
הֵן־
hen · H2005
look!, see!, behold · v12
A word that points at something and asks for attention: "Look here." Job uses it to turn the friends toward evidence they can't deny, much like saying "Come on, you know this."
-
אַתֶּ֣ם
'attem · H0859D
you (masculine plural) · v12
Hebrew doesn't need a separate pronoun here, because the verb already says "you". Adding it puts weight on the word: "you yourselves." Job now speaks to all three friends together, where in chapter 26 he spoke to Bildad alone.
-
כֻּלְּכֶ֣ם
kullekhem · H3605
all of you · v12
Adds to the emphasis: "you, every one of you." None of the three friends can claim he hasn't seen what Job is talking about.
-
חֲזִיתֶ֑ם
ḥazitem · H2372
-
וְלָמָּה־
welammah · H4100
and why? · v12
Literally "and for what?" The usual Hebrew "why". After an emphatic "you have seen", it reads as a frustrated "so why on earth…?"
-
זֶּ֝֗ה
zeh · H2088
this · v12
After a question word, zeh sharpens the question rather than pointing at anything: "why then?", "why ever?". It doesn't mean "this vanity" as an object. It intensifies the "why".
-
הֶ֣בֶל
hevel · H1892
breath, vapor; emptiness, futility · v12
A puff of breath or vapor: something with no substance that is gone at once. As the object of its own related verb, it describes the friends' words as so much breath.
-
תֶּהְבָּֽלוּ׃
tehbalu · H1891
to be/become empty, act or speak emptily · v12
The verb made from hevel: "to do hevel", "to be vapor". The verb form is ongoing (imperfect), so it pictures something they keep doing: "Why do you keep puffing out puffs?" The repeated sound (hevel … tehbalu) makes the scorn audible.
The world behind it
Where the verse stands. Job 27 opens Job's closing speeches (chs. 26–31), after the third round of debate with his friends has broken down. Bildad's last speech is very short (ch. 25), and Zophar does not speak a third time at all. In 27:2–6 Job swears an oath by God that he will hold on to his integrity. In 27:7–10 he calls down on his enemy the fate of the godless. Verses 11–12 then announce a lesson for the friends (the "you" is plural), and vv. 13–23 describe the end of the wicked.
A contest over who may teach. In the wisdom culture of the ancient Near East, the right to instruct belonged to the elder, the sage, and the one backed by the tradition of the fathers (see Job 8:8–10; 15:9–10, 18). The friends claimed that authority. Job's suffering, in their system, proved he was in the wrong, so his claim to teach them reverses the social order. It is a matter of honour as much as of argument.
The hand of God as affliction. In Israel and its neighbours, "the hand of [a god]" was ordinary language for disaster or disease sent by that god. Mesopotamian medical texts diagnose illnesses as the "hand" of a particular deity. So when Job offers to teach about God's hand, a first hearer would think at once of his sores and his losses.
From the study of Job 27:11.
Where scholars differ
in v11
Is Job really the speaker of the lesson that follows (27:13–23)?
-
The text is in its proper place: Job speaks all of chapter 27. Verses 13–23 are either Job's own (sincere) belief that the wicked will finally be judged, or an ironic quotation of the friends' doctrine, whose fate he now turns back on them (they are the ones guilty of falsehood).
The Hebrew text and every ancient version give the chapter to Job (27:1; 29:1). The plural "you" in vv. 11–12 is addressed to the friends, and v. 12 rebukes them, which fits Job. Job has already called down the fate of the wicked on his enemy (27:7).
-
The third round of debate has been disturbed in transmission. Verses 13–23 (or part of the chapter) are a lost third speech by Zophar, or part of Bildad's speech.
Zophar has no third speech, and Bildad's is unusually short (ch. 25). Verse 13 repeats almost word for word Zophar's conclusion in 20:29. The content of vv. 13–23 (the wicked are always punished) seems to contradict what Job argues in ch. 21. Many modern commentators propose rearranging the text, though they disagree on how.
in v11
Does "be-yad El" mean "about the hand of God" or "by the hand of God"?
-
"About / concerning": God's hand is the subject Job will teach.
Hebrew uses be- after verbs of teaching or speaking to mark the subject. The parallel line names the content of the lesson ("what is with Shaddai"), which favours reading the first line as content too. Most modern translations (ESV, NIV, WEB, BSB) take it this way.
-
"By": Job teaches with God's help or authority, or by pointing to God's acts as his evidence.
Be- is very often instrumental ("by means of"). The Vulgate (*per manum Dei*) and KJV read it so. Prophetic language sometimes speaks of a message given "by the hand of" a messenger, though that idiom usually means "through" a human agent.
in v12
Who speaks Job 27:13–23, and so what is v. 12 introducing?
-
Job speaks throughout. He turns the friends' doctrine back on them as a warning (or quotes it sarcastically), so v. 12 is a scornful lead-in.
The text as it stands gives no new speaker after 27:1. Job announced "I will teach you" (v. 11), and v. 12's plural "you" fits Job addressing the three. Several commentators (e.g. Habel, Andersen) read vv. 13–23 as the fate Job calls down on his accusers, who are his "enemy" in v. 7.
-
Vv. 13–23 are the lost third speech of Zophar (or Bildad's continuation), displaced in transmission, and v. 12 closes Job's own words.
The third round is broken (Bildad very short, Zophar missing). Vv. 13–23 express exactly the friends' doctrine that Job elsewhere denies (21:7–34). V. 13 nearly repeats Zophar's 20:29. Many critical scholars (e.g. Clines, Pope, Dhorme, in varying forms) reassign the section.
in v12
What is it that the friends "have seen"?
-
The truth about God's dealings that Job has just described: the 'hand of God' (v. 11), meaning reality as it actually is, where the wicked often prosper and the innocent suffer.
Follows v. 11 directly. It fits Job's earlier argument that anyone who looks can see the wicked thriving (21:7–34; 24:1–12).
-
The fate of the wicked described in vv. 13–23, which Job says they know as well as he does.
The verb has no stated object and could point forward. On this reading Job's point is that since they know the wicked are judged, they should fear slandering an innocent man (cf. 13:7–11; 19:29).
in v12
Is hevel tehbalu about empty speech or empty conduct and character?
-
Empty speech: "why talk this nonsense?"
The setting is a verbal debate. Job 21:34 ("comfort me with hevel") and 35:16 ("opens his mouth in hevel") apply hevel to words. The Vulgate makes it explicit ("speak").
-
Becoming or acting empty: "why have you become so futile?"
The verb's other uses (Jer 2:5; 2 Kgs 17:15; Ps 62:10) describe conduct and character, not speech. KJV, WEB, ESV and NASB lean this way. The two readings overlap: in a debate, their empty conduct consists of their empty words.
Sources
- BDB s.v. יָרָה (Hiphil: point out, teach)
- HALOT s.v. יָד; s.v. כחד
- HALOT s.v. שַׁדַּי (etymological proposals)
- BDB s.v. עִם (of what is in one's mind/possession)
- Septuagint, Job 27:11 (pantokratōr)
- Vulgate, Job 27:11
- Deir ʿAlla plaster inscription (šdyn)
- Commentary discussions of the third cycle of Job (e.g. Clines, Word Biblical Commentary, Job 21–37; Habel, Old Testament Library, Job)
- BDB s.v. הֶבֶל, הָבַל, חָזָה, הֵן
- HALOT s.v. הֶבֶל; הבל
- D.J.A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary 18A)
- N.C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
- M.H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
- E. Dhorme, A Commentary on the Book of Job
- F.I. Andersen, Job (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
- M.V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up (on hebel)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 27:12
- Vulgate Job 27:12
- Babylonian Talmud, Shabbat 119b (hevel as breath)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).