Joshua Chapter 17 Read as one passage
Joshua 17:2–3
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
2So this allotment was for the rest of the descendants of Manasseh—the clans of Abiezer, Helek, Asriel, Shechem, Hepher, and Shemida. These are the other male descendants of the clans of Manasseh son of Joseph. 3But Zelophehad son of Hepher (the son of Gilead, the son of Machir, the son of Manasseh) had no sons but only daughters. These are the names of his daughters: Mahlah, Noah, Hoglah, Milcah, and Tirzah.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse confirmed who holds what. Each named clan could point to this register as the basis of its claim to its villages and fields in the central hills. Because the land had been given by lot, the claim rested on God's assignment, not just on conquest or custom. For clans like Abiezer and Shemida, whose names were still in use as district names under the later kings of Israel, hearing their names was hearing the title deed to their own home ground.
The verse also tied the western Manassites firmly to Joseph, and therefore to the honour of being one of the two "Joseph tribes" that held the largest and richest part of the central highlands (compare their complaint in 17:14-18 that their share is too small).
Finally, by stressing "the males", the verse prepares hearers for the story in verses 3-6. An earlier ruling given through Moses was now carried out by Eleazar and Joshua: five daughters received an inheritance alongside their male kin. For the first audience the point was that promises made under Moses were honoured in the land, and that a line without sons was not erased from Israel's map.
From the study of Joshua 17:2.
Verse by verse
-
2So this allotment was for the rest of the descendants of Manasseh—the clans of Abiezer, Helek, Asriel, Shechem, Hepher, and Shemida. These are the other male descendants of the clans of Manasseh son of Joseph.
Full study →And the lot also came out for the rest of Manasseh's people, clan by clan. These were the clans not already settled with Machir's land east of the Jordan. Their names were Abiezer (Gideon's clan, later), Helek, Asriel, Shechem, Hepher and Shemida. Each clan was a network of villages and extended households, not a single family, and each is named separately because each received its own share of the hill country west of the Jordan. These, clan by clan, were the male lines of Manasseh, Joseph's son.
The verse reads like a land register, and it begins and ends with the same phrase, "by their clans". The closing words "the males" are deliberate. The narrator has just listed the male-descended clans so that the next verse can turn to the exception. In the Hepher line, Zelophehad had no sons, only five daughters: Mahlah, Noah, Hoglah, Milcah and Tirzah. They also receive land, so that Manasseh's western territory is finally counted as ten portions, "because the daughters of Manasseh received an inheritance among his sons" (17:6).
-
3But Zelophehad son of Hepher (the son of Gilead, the son of Machir, the son of Manasseh) had no sons but only daughters. These are the names of his daughters: Mahlah, Noah, Hoglah, Milcah, and Tirzah.
Full study →But as for Zelophehad (a man whose pedigree runs, generation by generation, from Hepher back through Gilead and Machir to Manasseh himself, so that his place in the tribe cannot be disputed) he had no sons. Nothing but daughters. In a society where land passed from father to son and a man's "name" lived on in the fields his sons farmed, that sentence means his household should have disappeared from the tribal map.
And these are the names of his daughters, entered into the record: Mahlah and Noah, Hoglah, Milcah and Tirzah. The list is formal, like a land register. These are women, but they stand where male clan heads stood in the previous verse. Several of their names are also names of towns and districts in Manasseh's hill country (Tirzah became a royal city; Noah and Hoglah appear as districts on 8th-century receipts from Samaria). So the verse names five women and also marks out five land shares that will carry their father's name. ("Noah" here is a woman's name, unrelated to the Noah of the flood.)
The verse sets up verse 4. Years earlier these women had won a ruling from Moses (Numbers 27). Now they come to collect, and Joshua grants them land "among their father's brothers."
Where the English drifted
-
in v2
families (KJV, WEB: "by their families")
mishpaḥah
- What we hear
- A household: parents and their children.
- What they heard
- A clan: a large kin group made up of many households, spread over a cluster of villages, holding land together and bound by mutual duties (protection, redemption of land and people).
-
in v2
children of (KJV, WEB: "the children of Abiezer", "the male children of Manasseh")
benei
- What we hear
- Young sons and daughters, literally the offspring of the named man.
- What they heard
- Descendants or members of a lineage. "Sons of Abiezer" = the Abiezrite clan, potentially many generations removed from Abiezer himself.
-
in v3
Noah
No'ah (נֹעָה)
- What we hear
- The famous man of the ark, or a name that implies a connection to him.
- What they heard
- A woman's name spelled with the guttural letter ayin, unrelated to Noach (נֹחַ) of Genesis 6-9. It is also attested as a district name in Manasseh. Its meaning is uncertain (perhaps linked to a root for 'moving' or 'swaying').
-
in v3
had no sons
lo hayu lo banim
- What we hear
- A family detail: he happened to have only girls.
- What they heard
- A legal crisis. With no male heir, his household's land share and 'name' stood to vanish from the clan. This verse is the formal premise of an inheritance case.
Every word
-
וַ֠יְהִי
vayhi · H1961
and it was · v2, v3
Picks up the subject of verse 1, "the lot" (goral): "and [the lot] fell / came to be" for the groups that follow. The verb carries the narrative forward from Machir's eastern share to the western share.
-
לִבְנֵ֨י
livnei · H1121G
for the sons of · v2, v3
"For the sons of": the preposition le- marks who receives the allotment. "Sons of Manasseh" means the people who trace their descent from Manasseh, i.e. the tribe, not his literal children.
-
מְנַשֶּׁ֥ה
menashsheh · H4519G
Manasseh · v2, v3
The elder son of Joseph (Gen 41:51) and the tribe named after him, here the tribe as a whole.
-
הַנּוֹתָרִים֮
hannotarim · H3498
the ones remaining · v2
"The ones left over": the Manassite clans not already provided for by Machir's land east of the Jordan (v. 1). It means "the rest", not "survivors" of a disaster.
-
לְמִשְׁפְּחֹתָם֒
lemishpeḥotam · H4940
by their clans · v2
"According to their clans": land was assigned clan by clan, the middle level of Israelite society between tribe and extended household.
-
אֲבִיעֶ֜זֶר
aviʿezer · H0044I
-
חֵ֗לֶק
ḥeleq · H2507
Helek · v2
Clan name (Num 26:30). As an ordinary noun the word means "portion, share", a fitting name in a land-allotment list, though the text does not make anything of the pun.
-
אַשְׂרִיאֵל֙
asriʾel · H0844G
Asriel · v2
Clan name (Num 26:31; 1 Chr 7:14). The name also turns up as a district name in the Samaria ostraca.
-
שֶׁ֔כֶם
shekhem · H7928G
-
חֵ֖פֶר
ḥefer · H2660A
Hepher · v2, v3
Clan name (Num 26:32). Hepher's line runs through Zelophehad, who had only daughters (v. 3). That is the hinge for the next verses. "Hepher" is also a place or district (Josh 12:17; 1 Kgs 4:10).
-
שְׁמִידָ֑ע
shemidaʿ · H8061
Shemida · v2
Clan name (Num 26:32; 1 Chr 7:19). It is also attested as a district name in the Samaria ostraca.
-
אֵ֠לֶּה
ʾelleh · H0428
these · v2, v3
Opens a closing summary, the usual way biblical lists are wrapped up ("these are...").
-
יוֹסֵ֛ף
yosef · H3130G
Joseph · v2
The patriarch whose two sons Ephraim and Manasseh became two tribes (Gen 48).
-
הַזְּכָרִ֖ים
hazzekharim · H2145
the males · v2
"The males", added after "sons of Manasseh". Since "sons" already implies male lines, the extra word is pointed. It prepares for verse 3, where one line (Hepher, through Zelophehad) has no males, only five daughters.
-
וְלִצְלָפְחָד֩
ve-li-Tselofchad · H6765
and to Zelophehad · v3
The 'and' sets up a contrast with verse 2. The 'to/for' ending works like 'as for Zelophehad', putting him forward as the exception to the list of male clan heads. The name's meaning is uncertain. 'Shadow/protection from dread' is a guess, not a settled meaning.
-
גִּלְעָ֜ד
Gil'ad · H1568H
Gilead · v3
Here a person, the ancestor of the western Manassite clans. Gilead is also the name of the highland region east of the Jordan, so here too an ancestor's name doubles as a land name.
-
מָכִ֣יר
Makhir · H4353G
Machir · v3
Manasseh's firstborn (Josh 17:1), the leading line of the tribe, whose descendants held Gilead and Bashan.
-
לֹא־
lo- · H3808
not · v3
Flatly negates the expected male heirs.
-
ל֛וֹ
lo · H9033
to him · v3
Hebrew has no verb 'to have'. 'There were not to him' is the normal way to say 'he had no'.
-
כִּ֣י
ki · H3588B
but/except · v3
First half of the paired expression ki im, 'except' or 'but only'.
-
אִם־
im- · H0518B
except · v3
Completes ki im. After a negative it means 'nothing but', which stresses that daughters were his only offspring.
-
בָּנ֑וֹת
banot · H1323G
daughters · v3
The feminine counterpart of 'sons'. The sound-play banim / banot puts the problem in a single vowel change.
-
שְׁמ֣וֹת
shemot · H8034
names of · v3
In Israel a 'name' carried identity and lineage. Recording these women's names fixes them in the tribal land record.
-
מַחְלָ֣ה
Machlah · H4244G
Mahlah · v3
The eldest, always named first except in Numbers 36:11 where the order shifts. The name's meaning is uncertain (perhaps linked to roots for 'weakness' or 'dance').
-
וְנֹעָ֔ה
ve-No'ah · H5270
and Noah · v3
A woman's name spelled with a guttural 'ayin'. It is unrelated to the flood hero Noah (Noach, נֹחַ). A district called 'Noah' appears in the Samaria ostraca.
-
חָגְלָ֥ה
Choglah · H2295
Hoglah · v3
Probably 'partridge' (compare the Arabic cognate). Also a Manassite district name in the Samaria ostraca.
-
מִלְכָּ֖ה
Milkah · H4435H
Milcah · v3
Related to the root for 'king', so roughly 'queen'. It is also the name of Nahor's wife (Gen 11:29).
-
וְתִרְצָֽה׃
ve-Tirtsah · H8656G
and Tirzah · v3
From a root meaning 'be pleasing'. Also the name of a major town in Manasseh's hill country, later the first capital of the northern kingdom (1 Kgs 15:21, 33).
The world behind it
Land by lot, clan by clan. Joshua 13–19 records how the land was shared out by lot (goral, v. 1), with the result understood as God's own decision (Prov 16:33). Land was not owned by individuals in the modern sense. It was the family's "inheritance" (naḥalah), held by the clan and its households and meant to stay in the line for good (Lev 25:23-28; Num 36:7-9; 1 Kgs 21:3). So a list of clans is really a map of who holds which land for all time.
Manasseh split in two. Machir, Manasseh's firstborn line and "a man of war", had already taken Gilead and Bashan east of the Jordan (Num 32:39-42; Josh 13:29-31). This verse covers the rest of the tribe, whose land lay west of the Jordan in the central hill country, between Ephraim to the south and the Jezreel Valley to the north. It included the region around the city of Shechem.
The names on the ground. Several of these clan names also appear as district names in the Samaria ostraca. These are pottery sherds from the Israelite royal capital, usually dated to the early 8th century BC, that record deliveries of wine and oil. They name Abiezer, Helek, Asriel, Shechem and Shemida, and also Hoglah and Noah, two of Zelophehad's daughters (v. 3). Hepher's area is also known as a district (1 Kgs 4:10). This shows that the names were more than genealogy: for centuries they were the actual administrative units of the Manassite hills. It also suggests that the "daughters" stood for real territories as well as individual women.
Why "the males" matters. Inheritance normally passed through sons. Numbers 27 and 36 tell how Zelophehad's daughters challenged this. Moses brought their case before God, and God ruled that daughters inherit when there is no son, on condition that they marry within their father's tribe so the land stays in it. Joshua 17:3-6 shows that ruling carried out. Verse 2 sets up the contrast.
From the study of Joshua 17:2.
Where scholars differ
in v2
How do these six western clans relate to Machir, whom v. 1 places east of the Jordan?
-
Genealogical harmony: these clans are Machirite by descent (through Gilead) but settled west of the Jordan. "The rest" means the parts of Manasseh not covered by the eastern Machirite settlement (Jair, Nobah and others, Num 32:39-42).
Num 26:29-33 explicitly makes all six descendants of Gilead son of Machir. Hebrew "sons of" readily covers grandsons and later descendants, so "sons of Manasseh" here is not a contradiction.
-
Clan history: the lists reflect shifting groups. Machir may originally have been a western group that later moved or extended east, and the genealogies were arranged later to express how the clans related.
In the Song of Deborah, Machir is listed among the western tribes, apparently in place of Manasseh (Judg 5:14). 1 Chr 7:14-19 arranges the same names differently. The clan names doubled as district names (Samaria ostraca), and lists of districts were commonly given genealogical form.
in v3
Are the daughters individual women, personified clan districts, or both?
-
Historical individuals whose legal case was remembered.
The narrative in Numbers 27 and 36 describes specific actions (petitioning, marrying cousins). Personal names for real people often matched place names.
-
The names are eponyms: a group or territory is represented in the genealogy as a person. The 'daughters' encode districts that came into Manasseh through a female line or by later absorption.
Tirzah is a city. Noah and Hoglah appear as districts in the Samaria ostraca alongside the clan names of Josh 17:2. Verses 5-6 count the daughters as land portions.
-
Both: genealogies regularly join persons and territories, and the text need not choose.
The same overlap occurs with Gilead, Hepher and Shechem in this passage.
in v3
What is the point of the daughters' story: women's rights, or preserving the father's line?
-
A real expansion of women's legal standing, won by women's initiative and approved by God.
Num 27:7 ('the daughters of Zelophehad speak right'). The ruling becomes a general law (27:8). Josh 17:4 shows them pressing their claim in person.
-
Mainly a safeguard for patrilineal land-holding. Daughters inherit so that the father's name and the tribe's land are preserved.
Their own argument concerns 'our father's name' (Num 27:4). Num 36 restricts their marriages so the land stays in the tribe. Josh 17:4 places the land 'among their father's brothers'.
-
Both are true at once. The women gain real standing, but within a system designed around male lineage.
The narrative honours their initiative and also limits its effect (Ben-Barak; Milgrom's Numbers commentary).
Sources
- HALOT s.v. מִשְׁפָּחָה
- BDB s.v. יָתַר (Niphal)
- BDB s.v. זָכָר
- BDB s.v. בֵּן
- Numbers 26:29-33; 27:1-11; 36:1-12 (parallel census and inheritance texts)
- 1 Chronicles 7:14-19 (variant Manassite genealogy)
- Samaria ostraca (G. A. Reisner et al., Harvard Excavations at Samaria; discussed in Y. Aharoni, The Land of the Bible)
- R. G. Boling & G. E. Wright, Joshua (Anchor Bible)
- R. D. Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library)
- R. S. Hess, Joshua (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
- STEPBible Hebrew data (TAHOT) as supplied
- BDB and HALOT s.v. צְלָפְחָד, נֹעָה, חָגְלָה, תִּרְצָה, כִּי אִם
- Jacob Milgrom, JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (excursus on the daughters of Zelophehad)
- Zafrira Ben-Barak, Inheritance by Daughters in Israel and the Ancient Near East (2006)
- Martha Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor (Laws of Lipit-Ishtar, provision on daughters inheriting)
- Gudea Statue B inscription (daughter installed as heir)
- Samaria ostraca, as discussed in Y. Aharoni, The Land of the Bible
- Trent Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Richard Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).