Psalms Chapter 78 Read as one passage
Psalm 78:23–24
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
23Yet He commanded the clouds above and opened the doors of the heavens. 24He rained down manna for them to eat; He gave them grain from heaven.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelites singing or learning this psalm, the verse did several things:
- It showed God's generosity against the background of unbelief. The psalm's whole lesson is "do not be like your fathers" (v.8). This verse shows how those fathers were treated: they doubted that God could set a table in the desert, and he opened the sky. Their failure looks worse, and his faithfulness looks greater.
- It claimed the sky for YHWH. In a farming world where people looked to storm gods to open the clouds, the psalm says it is Israel's God who gives the sky its orders, and the sky obeys. Rain, dew and food come from his stores.
- It answered a taunt. "Can God spread a table in the wilderness?" (v.19) is answered by the facts: the doors of heaven opened, manna fell, and everyone ate their fill (vv.24–25, 29).
- It prepared the warning. Hearers knew how the story ended (Num 11:33; Ps 78:30–31). The gift did not cure their unbelief. Blessing received without trust can end in judgment, so the next generation should trust as well as receive.
- It recalled the Flood. Hearers who knew Genesis would notice that the openings of heaven, which once poured out destruction (Gen 7:11), were here opened to feed people. The same power over the sky can bring death or life.
From the study of Psalm 78:23.
Verse by verse
-
23Yet He commanded the clouds above and opened the doors of the heavens.
Full study →"And still he gave his orders to the skies up above, and the great double doors of the heavens, he flung them open."
The verse follows directly on Israel's failure: they did not believe God or trust his saving help (v.22). They had just mocked, "Can God spread a table in the wilderness?" (v.19). Hebrew does not need a word like "but" to mark the reversal. It simply goes on telling the story: and he commanded. The bare "and" makes the contrast sharper. They doubted, and he acted anyway.
The picture is of a king and his household. God speaks to the sky the way a ruler gives orders to servants. The word for "clouds/skies" comes from a root meaning to grind something fine, so it suggests the thin, misty layers of the upper sky that normally drop dew and rain. Now they are told to drop food. Then the heavens are pictured as a great building with two-leaf doors, like the gates of a palace storehouse, and God throws them open. Israelites knew the "windows of heaven" from the Flood story, where those openings let loose death. Here the openings in the sky let loose bread. The word order of the second line puts "the doors of heaven" first and ends on the single verb "he opened", so the verse closes on the moment of release.
Taken together: the God whose ability they doubted is in charge of the sky itself. He did not merely put up with their taunt about a table in the desert. He answered it by opening heaven's storehouse over them. The next verses go on: he rained down manna, the "grain of heaven", the "bread of the mighty ones", and they ate their fill. The gift was real, and it was given to people who did not deserve it.
-
24He rained down manna for them to eat; He gave them grain from heaven.
Full study →And he made manna pour down on them like rain, food to eat; the grain of the sky itself he gave them.
This continues the scene from verse 23. The people have just doubted God ("They did not believe God or trust his deliverance," v. 22) and sneered, "Can God spread a table in the wilderness? … Can he also give bread?" (vv. 19–20). God's answer is an act, not an argument. He gives orders to the clouds, throws open the sky's doors, and makes food fall like rain. The verb is the one God used when he first promised this ("I am about to rain bread from heaven for you," Exod 16:4). It is also the verb used, a few lines later, for the quail that ended in judgment (vv. 27–31).
The first line names the food manna, the strange substance whose very name remembers Israel's bewildered "What is it?" (Exod 16:15). The second line restates it as grain of the heavens. Dagan is the ordinary staple crop of a farming people, the wheat and barley at the head of the blessing list "grain, wine and oil". Grain should come up from the ground after rain, plowing and harvest. This grain came down from the sky with no field and no farmer. The paired lines picture God acting as both rain-giver and harvest-giver at once, in a desert where neither rain nor harvest was possible.
The verse ends on an old poetic word, lāmô, "to them". It stresses that they, the same doubting people, are the ones who receive it. The gift is not a reward for their faith. It is God's generosity in the face of their unbelief, and the psalm is building toward the warning that comes next.
Where the English drifted
-
in v23
heaven / the heavens
shamayim
- What we hear
- The afterlife: the place where God lives and where believers go when they die.
- What they heard
- The sky and the upper world above the earth, where rain and dew come from and where God is enthroned with his stores. Here it is the physical source the manna fell from.
-
in v23
the doors of heaven
daltei shamayim
- What we hear
- 'Heaven's gates', the entrance souls pass through after death (the 'pearly gates').
- What they heard
- The double doors of a storehouse in the sky. God opens them so that supplies, here manna, pour down onto the earth. They open toward the hungry, not toward the dead.
-
in v24
corn (KJV: "the corn of heaven")
dāgān
- What we hear
- Maize, the yellow-kernelled crop of the Americas.
- What they heard
- Cereal grain in general, chiefly wheat and barley, the staple crop of the land of Israel.
-
in v24
heaven
šāmayim
- What we hear
- Mainly the spiritual realm or afterlife destination, so "grain from heaven" can sound like otherworldly food from paradise.
- What they heard
- First the physical sky, pictured in v. 23 with doors God opens to let rain or food fall, and also God's dwelling above it. The picture is of food falling out of the sky at God's command.
Every word
-
וַיְצַ֣ו
vay-tsav · H6680
to command, give orders · v23
The narrative 'and he commanded'. God speaks like a king giving orders to his servants, and the sky has to obey. The 'and' follows straight on from v.22 ('they did not believe God'), so the contrast is sharp: they doubted, and he gave orders anyway.
-
שְׁחָקִ֣ים
shechaqim · H7834
thin cloud, fine dust; (plural) skies, clouds · v23
The high cloud-layers or upper sky. The root means to grind or crush something fine, so the picture is a fine, misty sky-layer. Here these 'skies' are the servants that receive the order, and from them the manna falls in v.24.
-
מִמָּ֑עַל
mimma'al · H4605
above, upward; (with min) from above · v23
'From above' / 'up there'. It places the clouds in the upper realm, so the reader looks up toward the source of what comes down. The Hebrew can mean either 'the clouds above' or 'commanded from above'; most translations take the first.
-
וְדַלְתֵ֖י
ve-daltei · H1817C
door, door-leaf · v23
'And the doors of'. The Hebrew form is dual, the form used for pairs, so this means two-leaf doors like the double doors of a city gate, a palace or a storehouse. The sky is pictured as a building whose great doors swing open.
-
שָׁמַ֣יִם
shamayim · H8064
heavens, sky · v23, v24
The sky, the visible upper world above the earth, which is also where God dwells and holds his stores. The point here is the physical sky that rain, dew and now manna come down from, not the place where the dead go.
-
פָּתָֽח׃
patach · H6605A
to open · v23
'He opened' (a completed act). The object comes first in this half-line ('the doors of heaven he opened'), which puts the stress on what was opened. The word order mirrors the first half-line and closes the verse on the decisive action.
-
וַיַּמְטֵ֬ר
wayyamṭēr · H4305
to rain; (causative) to make rain fall · v24
"And he made it rain." The causative form puts God in the role of the one who sends rain down. It is the same verb God uses in Exodus 16:4 ("I am about to rain bread from heaven for you"). The form continues the story from verse 23: he commanded the clouds, he opened the doors, and so he rained.
-
עֲלֵיהֶ֣ם
ʿălêhem · H5921A
upon, over · v24
"Upon them." The food falls down on the people from above the way rain falls on a field. The same people were just described as not trusting God (v. 22).
-
מָ֣ן
mān · H4478A
manna · v24
The wilderness food described in Exodus 16 and Numbers 11. Exodus 16:15 explains the name with the people's puzzled question "man hu?", meaning "What is it?". The name itself remembers how strange the food was.
-
לֶאֱכֹ֑ל
leʾĕkōl · H0398
to eat · v24
"To eat," stating the purpose. It answers the challenge in verses 19–20: "Can God spread a table in the wilderness? … Can he also give bread?" He could, and it was meant to be eaten.
-
וּדְגַן־
ûdəgan- · H1715
grain, cereal crop · v24
"And the grain of …" Dagan is the ordinary staple grain of the land (wheat and barley), the first item in the familiar blessing list "grain, new wine and oil". Calling manna "grain" pictures it as a harvest God gave without anyone plowing or sowing.
-
נָ֣תַן
nātan · H5414G
to give · v24
"He gave." A plain word for a gift. Hebrew poetry often moves the verb to the end of the second line, as here, which puts weight on "grain of heaven". The giving stands against the people's doubt in verse 20.
-
לָֽמוֹ׃
lāmô · H9038
to them · v24
An older, poetic form of the usual lāhem ("to them"), kept mostly in poetry. It closes the line with a solemn, old-fashioned ring.
The world behind it
The psalm. Psalm 78 is a "maskil of Asaph", a long teaching poem that retells Israel's history so that the next generation "would set their hope in God and not forget his works" (vv.4–8). It runs from the Exodus and wilderness through the settlement and the loss of the Shiloh sanctuary to God's choice of Judah, Zion and David (vv.67–72). Its repeated pattern is that God acts generously, Israel forgets and rebels, God disciplines and yet holds back his anger (v.38).
The episode. Verses 17–31 blend two wilderness stories. One is the first gift of manna and quail (Exodus 16, where God says, "I will rain bread from heaven for you", v.4). The other is the later craving for meat at Kibroth-hattaavah (Numbers 11), which ended in a plague. In the psalm, the people "test God in their heart" by demanding food (v.18) and taunting him (vv.19–20). God is angry (v.21). Then comes this verse: he gives anyway (vv.23–29). Only after that does judgment fall on the greedy (vv.30–31). Verse 23 is the turning point where God's generosity runs straight against their unbelief.
The picture of the world. Ancient Israel, like its neighbours, spoke of the sky as an upper structure with storehouses (for rain, snow, hail and wind: Deut 28:12; Job 38:22; Ps 135:7) and with openings, "windows" or here "doors", through which their contents came down. Hearers would have heard "the doors of heaven opened" as God unlocking his own stores. Canaanite myth credited Baal, the storm god, with opening a rift in the clouds to send rain. Psalm 78 gives that power to YHWH alone, and he uses it to feed his people in a place where nothing grows.
From the study of Psalm 78:23.
Where scholars differ
in v23
Does v.23 continue the story ('and then he commanded'), or look back ('though he had commanded')?
-
Forward-moving narrative: in spite of their unbelief (v.22), God gave manna and then quail (vv.23–29). Most modern versions ('Yet he commanded').
וַיְצַו is the standard form for moving a story forward. Verses 23–29 read as one connected sequence: command, opening, manna, meat, eating to the full. Then comes judgment in vv.30–31, following the order of Num 11.
-
Looking back or conceding: they did not trust, even though he had already opened heaven for them (KJV, some older commentators).
In Numbers 11 the manna had been falling for a long time before the people complained, so the manna (vv.23–25) comes before the complaint historically. Hebrew poetry sometimes uses this form loosely, without strict time order. The psalm also blends Exodus 16 and Numbers 11, so its order is theological rather than strictly chronological.
in v23
How literally did the psalmist mean 'the doors of heaven'?
-
It reflects a real ancient picture of the world: a solid sky with storehouses and openings.
Gen 1:6–8 (the raqia, an expanse or 'firmament', separating waters); Job 37:18 (skies 'hard as a cast mirror'); 'windows of heaven' in Gen 7:11; storehouses in Deut 28:12 and Job 38:22. Similar pictures appear across the ancient Near East (the Ugaritic Baal window; the gates of heaven in Mesopotamia).
-
It is poetic, descriptive language and should not be pressed as an account of how the sky is built.
The phrase 'doors of heaven' occurs only here and varies freely with 'windows'. 2 Kgs 7:2 uses 'windows in heaven' almost proverbially. Poets use building images loosely, as in Ps 104:2–3, where God stretches out the heavens like a tent.
in v24
What was manna, physically?
-
A miraculous food with no natural explanation.
The texts describe features no natural substance fully explains: daily supply for a whole people, spoiling when hoarded but not on the Sabbath, the double portion on Friday, and its ending exactly when Israel reached Canaan (Exod 16; Josh 5:12). The psalm presents it as God commanding the clouds.
-
A known desert product, the sweet honeydew left by scale insects on tamarisk shrubs in Sinai, presented as God's provision.
F. S. Bodenheimer (1947) and others documented sweet, flaky deposits in Sinai still called *mann* in Arabic, which appear in early summer and melt in the sun (compare Exod 16:21). Critics point out that the quantities are tiny and seasonal, not enough for the biblical account.
-
The question doesn't decide the psalm's meaning.
Either way, the psalm's claim is about who gave it: God "rained" and "gave" it in answer to unbelief. The poem's interest is theological and historical, not scientific.
in v24
Where does the name 'manna' come from?
-
From the question "man hu?" ("What is it?") as Exodus 16:15 says.
*Man* as "what" is attested in Aramaic and some related languages, and the Greek of Exodus keeps the question form.
-
From an existing word for the substance (compare Arabic *mann*, tamarisk honeydew), with Exodus 16:15 offering a wordplay on it.
Biblical name-explanations are often wordplays rather than technical etymologies. The Arabic term matches the proposed natural substance.
in v24
When was Psalm 78 composed?
-
In the time of the monarchy, before the exile, perhaps after the fall of the northern kingdom (722 BC) or under Hezekiah or Josiah.
The psalm's climax is the rejection of Ephraim and the choice of Zion and David (vv. 67–72), with no mention of the temple's destruction or the exile.
-
During or after the exile.
Similarities with Deuteronomy's language and with the history-reciting prayers of Nehemiah 9 suggest to some scholars that the psalm took its final shape later.
Sources
- BDB s.v. צָוָה, שַׁחַק, דֶּלֶת, שָׁמַיִם, פָּתַח
- HALOT s.v. שַׁחַק (fine dust; thin cloud; sky)
- Septuagint, Psalm 77:23 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Gallican Psalter and Iuxta Hebraeos, Psalm 77:23
- Babylonian Talmud, Hagigah 12b (seven heavens; Shechaqim and the manna millstones)
- KTU 1.4 VII (Ugaritic Baal cycle: the window in Baal's palace)
- Enuma Elish, Tablet V (gates of heaven)
- Exodus 16; Numbers 11; 2 Kings 7:2, 19; Genesis 7:11; 8:2; Deuteronomy 28:12; Malachi 3:10
- John 6:31–33
- BDB s.v. מָטַר, מָן, דָּגָן, שָׁמַיִם
- HALOT s.v. מטר, מָן, דָּגָן
- Septuagint, Psalm 77:24 (Rahlfs)
- Exodus 16; Numbers 11:6–9; Deuteronomy 8:3, 16; Nehemiah 9:15; Hosea 2:8; 2 Kings 7:2, 19
- John 6:31–35; 1 Corinthians 10:3; Wisdom of Solomon 16:20
- F. S. Bodenheimer, "The Manna of Sinai," Biblical Archaeologist 10 (1947)
- M. E. Tate, Psalms 51–100 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- F.-L. Hossfeld & E. Zenger, Psalms 2 (Hermeneia)
- Ugaritic Baal Cycle, KTU 1.4 VII (Baal's window)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).