Psalms Chapter 78 Read as one passage
Psalm 78:17–31
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
17But they continued to sin against Him, rebelling in the desert against the Most High. 18They willfully tested God by demanding the food they craved. 19They spoke against God, saying, “Can God really prepare a table in the wilderness? 20When He struck the rock, water gushed out and torrents raged. But can He also give bread or supply His people with meat?” 21Therefore the LORD heard and was filled with wrath; so a fire was kindled against Jacob, and His anger flared against Israel, 22because they did not believe God or rely on His salvation. 23Yet He commanded the clouds above and opened the doors of the heavens. 24He rained down manna for them to eat; He gave them grain from heaven. 25Man ate the bread of angels; He sent them food in abundance. 26He stirred the east wind from the heavens and drove the south wind by His might. 27He rained meat on them like dust, and winged birds like the sand of the sea. 28He felled them in the midst of their camp, all around their dwellings. 29So they ate and were well filled, for He gave them what they craved. 30Yet before they had filled their desire, with the food still in their mouths, 31God’s anger flared against them, and He put to death their strongest and subdued the young men of Israel.
What the first hearers heard
For the Israelites who sang or heard Psalm 78, this verse was not neutral history. It was the family story told as a warning. Its three ideas were:
- A pattern that escalates. "They added still" taught that the ancestors' failures grew after each rescue rather than shrinking. The listeners are being asked whether they will add to the same pile.
- Defiance, not weakness. The verb mārâ names wilful rebellion against rightful authority. Hearers who knew Deuteronomy would catch the echo of the "stubborn and rebellious son" (Deut 21:18), and verse 8 of the psalm has already used that phrase for the ancestors.
- The absurdity of ingratitude. Defying "the Most High," the supreme king, from a land so dry that every drink came from him, made the rebellion look both outrageous and foolish.
The psalm goes on to say that this kind of defiance has consequences: the rejection of Shiloh and Ephraim, vv. 59–67. It also says that God keeps showing mercy (v. 38) and in the end chooses Zion and David (vv. 68–72). The verse is meant to make the listeners trust and keep faith (v. 7: "that they should set their hope in God and not forget the works of God").
From the study of Psalm 78:17.
Verse by verse
-
17But they continued to sin against Him, rebelling in the desert against the Most High.
Full study →And they did it again. They piled still more sin on top of what came before, wronging him personally and openly defying the Most High, there in the parched, waterless land.
The verse is built on a contrast with what comes just before it. In verses 15–16 God splits rocks and makes water "flow down like rivers." Verse 17 opens with "they added": God added streams, and they added sin. "Still/yet again" shows that this is a pattern that keeps growing, not a single failure.
"Sin against him" describes a personal offense against the one who had just kept them alive. The second phrase says what that sin was: defiance. The Hebrew verb is the one used of a son who rejects his parents' authority (Deuteronomy 21:18), and this psalm uses it of Israel again and again (vv. 8, 40, 56). The one they defy has the highest title there is, "the Most High," ruler over all things. The place they do it is named by a word that means simply "dryness," a land with no water. Everywhere else in that land they were dying of thirst, and every mouthful they drank there was his gift. That is where they set themselves against him.
-
18They willfully tested God by demanding the food they craved.
Full study →"And they put God himself on trial, deliberately and from the inside, by demanding food to fill their own hungry throats."
The verse continues the indictment of verse 17 ("they went on sinning against him"). The verb means testing: the people take the role of examiner and treat God as the one who has to prove himself. That turns the pattern of the wilderness stories upside down. In those stories God tests Israel to see what is in their heart, and here Israel tests God. "In their heart" does not mean a passing feeling. In Hebrew the heart is the place of intent and decision, so this was a settled, chosen stance of distrust, and verse 19 shows it coming out in words: "Can God really set a table in the wilderness?"
They tested him by asking, which is the grammatical link between the two halves of the verse. The asking was not trusting prayer. It was a demand for proof, made right after God had split the sea and drawn rivers from the rock (vv. 13–16). What they asked for was food in general (the psalm goes on to manna and then quail), and they wanted it for their nefesh: their throat, their appetite, the hungry self. The picture is pointed. God is set opposite a craving gullet, and the people want the Most High to serve their stomach. The coming verses make the irony plain: God does give them exactly what their appetite wanted (vv. 27–29), and the meal itself becomes judgment (vv. 30–31).
-
19They spoke against God, saying, “Can God really prepare a table in the wilderness?
Full study →"And they talked against God. They said: 'Is God able, is he, to lay out a proper spread, a set table, here in the empty wilderness?'"
The verse puts into words what verse 18 calls testing God in their hearts. The first verb is not neutral. "Speak against" is the wording of the wilderness complaints in Numbers (Num 21:5), where the people "spoke against God and against Moses" because there was no bread. Their question is a taunt that expects the answer no: "Can he?" It questions God's power, not just his kindness. These are the words Moses feared Egypt would say about Israel's God ("the LORD was not able…", Num 14:16). Now Israel says them.
The picture is one of hospitality. "Arrange a table" is the Hebrew idiom for a host setting out a full, orderly meal, the same phrase as Psalm 23:5 ("You prepare a table before me"). The demand is not only for survival rations but for a proper banquet. And they want it in the midbār, the dry, unfarmed steppe where no one could ever set a table. The Hebrew also has a sound echo: the verse opens with vaydabberu ("they spoke") and closes with bammidbar ("in the wilderness"). The place they doubted in seems to answer their words.
In the psalm the irony is heavy. These people had just seen the sea split and water come out of rock (vv. 13–16, 20). The psalm goes on to say that God did set that table: "grain of heaven," "bread of the mighty," meat raining down like dust (vv. 23–29). Then he judged the craving that lay behind the question (vv. 30–31). So the line is quoted as a warning: this is how the ancestors spoke, and it is not to be repeated.
-
20When He struck the rock, water gushed out and torrents raged. But can He also give bread or supply His people with meat?”
Full study →The psalmist is quoting Israel's ancestors in the desert, and the quotation drips with irony:
"Granted, look: he struck a rock, and water came pouring out, and the dry gullies ran in flood. But bread as well? Is he able to give that? Or can he set out meat, a real meal, for his people?"
The speakers do not deny the miracle. They admit it, and in strong words: water gushing (the verb of a land "flowing" with milk and honey) and wadis in flash-flood. Then they use their own admission to start doubting. "Is he able?" picks up the question of the verse before ("Can God set a table in the wilderness?"). Asked twice, it turns a complaint about supplies into a challenge to God's power. "Bread" points to the manna, and "meat" (she'er, flesh as food) to the craving for meat in Numbers 11. Meat was a luxury, eaten mostly at feasts, so they are asking whether God can give a banquet and not just keep them alive. The verb for "provide" means to set up firmly, make ready. It quietly recalls that this was a generation that never made its own heart firm (v. 8, 37). Even the closing words, "for his people", condemn them: they claim to belong to him while asking whether he can look after them. Verse 21 gives the answer: the LORD heard, and his anger flared.
-
21Therefore the LORD heard and was filled with wrath; so a fire was kindled against Jacob, and His anger flared against Israel,
Full study →That is why, when Yahweh heard it — their sneering question, "Can God really set a table in the wilderness? He gave water from the rock, but can he give bread and meat too?" — he let his fury overflow its banks. Fire caught and broke out among Jacob's people, and anger rose up like smoke from flaring nostrils against Israel.
The verse is the verdict that follows the charge in verses 17–20. The people had just watched water gush from a rock, and they answered by doubting God out loud. "Therefore" is a prophet's word: it marks the sentence after the accusation. The opening, "the LORD heard," repeats Numbers 11:1 almost word for word. Anyone who knew the wilderness stories would recall the actual fire at Taberah, which burned the edge of the camp after the people complained.
The two halves of the verse paint a single picture. In the first line a fire is lit. In the second, "anger" is literally "nose" or "nostril," and it "goes up," the way smoke rises. God's anger appears as heat and smoke rising from the nostrils, as in Psalm 18:8. "Jacob" and "Israel" are the same people under two names: the whole nation, the patriarch's descendants, whom God had just brought out of Egypt. The next verse gives the reason: "they did not believe God or rely on his salvation." What provoked the fire was not hunger. It was distrust of the God who had just provided for them.
-
22because they did not believe God or rely on His salvation.
Full study →For they would not lean their weight on God, and they would not rest secure in his power to rescue them.
The verse gives the reason for the blaze of anger in verse 21. The first verb comes from the same root as amen. It means to count something firm and dependable, and to put your weight on it. The second means to rely on something so that you feel safe. "God" in the first line is matched by "his rescue" in the second. Trusting God, for this poet, meant counting on his proven ability to get his people out of trouble.
That ability was not abstract. "His rescue" (yeshu'ah) is the word Moses used at the Red Sea: "stand firm and see the rescue of the LORD." Israel had seen it. The surrounding verses insist they had watched the sea split and water pour from the rock. Their failure was not doubting that God existed or that the miracles happened. Faced with a new need, food in the desert, they refused to treat him as dependable. They put him on trial instead: "Can God spread a table in the wilderness?"
The next verse turns with a striking "yet": even so, God opened the doors of heaven and rained down manna.
-
23Yet He commanded the clouds above and opened the doors of the heavens.
Full study →"And still he gave his orders to the skies up above, and the great double doors of the heavens, he flung them open."
The verse follows directly on Israel's failure: they did not believe God or trust his saving help (v.22). They had just mocked, "Can God spread a table in the wilderness?" (v.19). Hebrew does not need a word like "but" to mark the reversal. It simply goes on telling the story: and he commanded. The bare "and" makes the contrast sharper. They doubted, and he acted anyway.
The picture is of a king and his household. God speaks to the sky the way a ruler gives orders to servants. The word for "clouds/skies" comes from a root meaning to grind something fine, so it suggests the thin, misty layers of the upper sky that normally drop dew and rain. Now they are told to drop food. Then the heavens are pictured as a great building with two-leaf doors, like the gates of a palace storehouse, and God throws them open. Israelites knew the "windows of heaven" from the Flood story, where those openings let loose death. Here the openings in the sky let loose bread. The word order of the second line puts "the doors of heaven" first and ends on the single verb "he opened", so the verse closes on the moment of release.
Taken together: the God whose ability they doubted is in charge of the sky itself. He did not merely put up with their taunt about a table in the desert. He answered it by opening heaven's storehouse over them. The next verses go on: he rained down manna, the "grain of heaven", the "bread of the mighty ones", and they ate their fill. The gift was real, and it was given to people who did not deserve it.
-
24He rained down manna for them to eat; He gave them grain from heaven.
Full study →And he made manna pour down on them like rain, food to eat; the grain of the sky itself he gave them.
This continues the scene from verse 23. The people have just doubted God ("They did not believe God or trust his deliverance," v. 22) and sneered, "Can God spread a table in the wilderness? … Can he also give bread?" (vv. 19–20). God's answer is an act, not an argument. He gives orders to the clouds, throws open the sky's doors, and makes food fall like rain. The verb is the one God used when he first promised this ("I am about to rain bread from heaven for you," Exod 16:4). It is also the verb used, a few lines later, for the quail that ended in judgment (vv. 27–31).
The first line names the food manna, the strange substance whose very name remembers Israel's bewildered "What is it?" (Exod 16:15). The second line restates it as grain of the heavens. Dagan is the ordinary staple crop of a farming people, the wheat and barley at the head of the blessing list "grain, wine and oil". Grain should come up from the ground after rain, plowing and harvest. This grain came down from the sky with no field and no farmer. The paired lines picture God acting as both rain-giver and harvest-giver at once, in a desert where neither rain nor harvest was possible.
The verse ends on an old poetic word, lāmô, "to them". It stresses that they, the same doubting people, are the ones who receive it. The gift is not a reward for their faith. It is God's generosity in the face of their unbelief, and the psalm is building toward the warning that comes next.
-
25Man ate the bread of angels; He sent them food in abundance.
Full study →"The bread of the mighty ones, that is what they ate, every last man of them! He sent them rations for the road, as much as they could eat."
The verse is built on a contrast. The first word pair, leḥem ʾabbîrîm, means "bread of the mighty": the word ʾabbîr is used for great bulls, war-horses, heroes and nobles. Coming straight after "grain from heaven" (v. 24), it points to the powerful beings of God's heavenly court. That is why the earliest Greek translation already said "bread of angels", and that is the sense most translations keep. Food fit for heaven's mighty ones was eaten by ʾîš, "each man", ordinary mortals, every one of them, with nobody left out.
The second line uses a down-to-earth word: ṣêdâ, travel rations, the food you pack before a journey. Israel had fled Egypt without packing any (Exodus 12:39), so God himself sent the supplies. He sent them lāśōbaʿ, "to fullness", the very phrase the people had used when they complained that in Egypt they ate bread "to the full" (Exodus 16:3). The verse praises a lavish, royal generosity. In the psalm's larger argument, though, it also builds the case against the people: they were given heaven's food in full, and they still did not trust (vv. 22, 32).
-
26He stirred the east wind from the heavens and drove the south wind by His might.
Full study →"He sent the east wind breaking camp across the sky, and by his own strength he herded in the south wind."
The first line uses the verb for pulling up tent pegs and setting out. God makes the scorching desert east wind start on a journey through the sky, as if he were ordering a camp to march. This is the same verb Numbers 11:31 uses for the wind that brought the quail. The second line uses a herdsman's verb: God drives the south wind along the way a shepherd drives his flock, and he does it "by his strength", that is, his own personal power.
Together, east and south point to the hot desert quarter of the sky, toward the south-east. The point is that God has complete command of the winds. They go where he sends them and bring what he wants. Here that is the flocks of birds that "rain" down in the next verse.
The verse sits inside a bitter story, though. The same two verbs appear again in v. 52, where God "made his people set out like sheep and drove them like a flock." The God who herds the winds is the God who herded Israel, and the ancestors still asked whether he could "spread a table in the wilderness" (v. 19). The wind brings an abundant answer, and the next verses show the feast turning into judgment (vv. 30–31).
-
27He rained meat on them like dust, and winged birds like the sand of the sea.
Full study →"And he made it rain on them: meat, like dust; and like the sand of all the seashores: winged birds."
The verse opens with the same words used for the manna three verses earlier ("and he rained on them"), so the poet presents a second downpour from heaven, this time of meat. The word for meat, she'er, is the very word the people used when they mocked God in verse 20: "Can he give bread? Can he provide meat for his people?" Here God answers the challenge in their own words.
The two comparisons, dust of the ground and sand of the seashore, are the Bible's standard pictures for "more than anyone could count". They are the same pictures God used when promising Abraham descendants. The second line holds back its subject until the very end. Only after "like the sand of the seas" do we learn what is falling: "birds of wing", the phrase Genesis 1 uses for the flying creatures God made. The wind God set loose in verse 26 sweeps them down, and they drop around the tents (v. 28). Historically they were quail (Exodus 16; Numbers 11).
The verse is a picture of extravagant, almost overwhelming generosity. But the verb "to rain" is the same verb used for fire on Sodom, and the next lines turn: "while the food was still in their mouths, the anger of God rose against them" (vv. 30–31). The gift is real, and it is also the moment the people's distrust is laid bare.
-
28He felled them in the midst of their camp, all around their dwellings.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
29So they ate and were well filled, for He gave them what they craved.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
30Yet before they had filled their desire, with the food still in their mouths,
Full study →They had not yet put their craving behind them. The food was still in their mouths (and then, v. 31, God's anger rose against them).
The verse is the hinge between gift and judgment. Verse 29 has just said they ate and were thoroughly filled, because God brought them exactly what they craved. Verse 30 freezes the moment that follows. Their stomachs were full, but the craving had not become a stranger to them. They had not finished with it, grown tired of it, or pushed it away. Its grip was still on them. The second line makes it concrete: the meat was still in their mouths, not yet swallowed.
Hebrew readers who knew the wilderness story would hear Numbers 11 behind every word. God had warned that Israel would eat meat "until it comes out at your nostrils and becomes loathsome to you" (Num 11:20). The psalm uses a related word to say that point never arrived. Numbers 11:33 says the anger of the LORD burned against the people "while the meat was still between their teeth." The place was named "Graves of Craving."
So the line carries three things together:
- Timing: the blow fell mid-meal.
- Irony: the very thing they demanded in order to test God was in their mouths when they died.
- The grip of appetite: having what they wanted did not end their wanting.
The sentence is not complete until verse 31 lands: "...when the anger of God rose up against them."
-
31God’s anger flared against them, and He put to death their strongest and subdued the young men of Israel.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v17
provoking (KJV) / provoke (YLT)
mārâ (lamrôt)
- What we hear
- Annoying, irritating, or deliberately making someone angry.
- What they heard
- Open defiance: rebelling against an authority, like a son rejecting his father (Deut 21:18). The focus is on what Israel did, not on God's feelings.
-
in v17
wilderness (KJV)
ṣiyyâ
- What we hear
- Wild, untouched nature, often forest or backcountry.
- What they heard
- A dry, waterless region where people die of thirst. The word itself means "dryness."
-
in v18
tempted (KJV, WEB)
nasah
- What we hear
- Enticed God toward sin, or tried to lure him into wrongdoing.
- What they heard
- Put God to the test: demanded he prove his power and faithfulness on their terms.
-
in v18
meat (KJV)
'okhel
- What we hear
- Animal flesh specifically.
- What they heard
- Food of any kind. In 1611 English 'meat' still meant food in general (as in 'meat and drink'). The psalm covers both manna and quail.
-
in v18
lust (KJV, YLT)
nefesh
- What we hear
- Sexual desire.
- What they heard
- Appetite: the throat or hungry self, here a craving for food. In 1611 'lust' meant any strong desire.
-
in v19
furnish a table (KJV)
laʿărōkh shulḥān
- What we hear
- To supply a room with a piece of furniture, as in 'furnishing' a house.
- What they heard
- To set out a meal in order, laying food on the table as a host does. In 1611 'furnish' meant 'provide, supply fully', so the KJV meant 'provide a laid table'.
-
in v19
wilderness
midbār
- What we hear
- Wild, untouched natural land, often forested or scenic; a nature reserve or backcountry.
- What they heard
- Dry, unsettled, unfarmed steppe or desert. At best it was grazing land, with no fields, towns or reliable food. It was the opposite of the place where a meal could be prepared.
-
in v20
flesh (KJV)
she'er
- What we hear
- Human flesh, the body, or the 'sinful nature' of New Testament teaching.
-
in v20
Behold (KJV, WEB)
hen
- What we hear
- A solemn exclamation of wonder at a miracle.
- What they heard
- A grudging 'Granted' or 'Sure': the speakers admit the water miracle so that they can question God's further ability.
-
in v21
wrath / was wroth
hitʿabbēr; ʾap̄
- What we hear
- Uncontrolled temper or spite. For many readers it also suggests eternal punishment.
- What they heard
- The hot reaction of Israel's covenant God when the people he had just rescued and fed doubted him. It was a response to a broken relationship, and it is pictured as fire and snorting breath. The same psalm insists that God usually held this back: 'he, being compassionate, atoned for iniquity… and often turned his anger away' (v. 38).
-
in v21
Jacob
yaʿăqōḇ
- What we hear
- The patriarch Jacob, a single person.
- What they heard
- The nation of Israel, called by the name of its ancestor. 'Jacob' and 'Israel' in the two lines are two names for the same people in the wilderness.
-
in v22
believe (in God)
he'emin be-
- What we hear
- To accept that God exists, or to agree that certain statements about him are true.
- What they heard
- To count God as firm and dependable and to put your weight on him. The people in this story never doubted God was real; they had just seen his miracles. They refused to rely on him.
-
in v22
salvation
yeshu'ah
- What we hear
- The individual's rescue from sin and hell, an eternal or spiritual state.
- What they heard
- God's concrete rescuing power and acts in history: bringing Israel out of Egypt, through the sea, and keeping them alive in the desert.
-
in v23
heaven / the heavens
shamayim
- What we hear
- The afterlife: the place where God lives and where believers go when they die.
- What they heard
- The sky and the upper world above the earth, where rain and dew come from and where God is enthroned with his stores. Here it is the physical source the manna fell from.
-
in v23
the doors of heaven
daltei shamayim
- What we hear
- 'Heaven's gates', the entrance souls pass through after death (the 'pearly gates').
- What they heard
- The double doors of a storehouse in the sky. God opens them so that supplies, here manna, pour down onto the earth. They open toward the hungry, not toward the dead.
-
in v24
corn (KJV: "the corn of heaven")
dāgān
- What we hear
- Maize, the yellow-kernelled crop of the Americas.
- What they heard
- Cereal grain in general, chiefly wheat and barley, the staple crop of the land of Israel.
-
in v24
heaven
šāmayim
- What we hear
- Mainly the spiritual realm or afterlife destination, so "grain from heaven" can sound like otherworldly food from paradise.
- What they heard
- First the physical sky, pictured in v. 23 with doors God opens to let rain or food fall, and also God's dwelling above it. The picture is of food falling out of the sky at God's command.
-
in v25
angels / angels' food
ʾabbîrîm
- What we hear
- The Hebrew uses the normal word for angel, and the verse makes a statement about what angels eat in heaven.
- What they heard
- 'Mighty ones', a word used for bulls, stallions, warriors and nobles. Here it most likely means the powerful heavenly beings, so the stress falls on power and rank: food fit for the mighty. The ordinary Hebrew word for angel (malʾak) is not used.
-
in v25
meat (KJV)
ṣêdâ
- What we hear
- Animal flesh, perhaps the quail.
- What they heard
- Provisions, travel rations, food in general for a journey.
-
in v25
venison (YLT)
ṣêdâ
- What we hear
- Deer meat.
- What they heard
- Journey-provisions; YLT is reflecting the word's link to the root 'to hunt' and the older English sense of venison as any game.
-
in v26
east wind
qādîm
- What we hear
- A breeze from the east; just a direction.
- What they heard
- A known and feared weather event: the hot, dry, forceful desert wind that withers crops, drives locusts and wrecks ships. Hearers would expect power, not a gentle breeze.
-
in v26
the heavens
šāmāyim
- What we hear
- Heaven as the place of God and the blessed dead, the afterlife.
- What they heard
- Here the visible sky, the space above the earth where winds blow and birds fly. It is also God's realm above, but the picture is weather moving across the sky.
-
in v27
flesh (KJV, YLT)
šəʾēr
- What we hear
- Human or animal bodies, or, in church language, "the flesh" as humanity's sinful nature (from Paul).
- What they heard
- Meat to eat: bird meat sent as food, the same thing the people demanded in verse 20.
-
in v27
feathered fowls (KJV)
ʿôp kānāp
- What we hear
- Farm poultry such as chickens or ducks.
- What they heard
- "Flyers of wing": wild winged birds (historically, migrating quail), in a phrase borrowed from the creation account.
-
in v30
lust (KJV)
taʾăwāh
- What we hear
- Sexual desire.
- What they heard
- Craving or appetite. Here it is the craving for meat in the wilderness, a demand that put God to the test.
-
in v30
meat (KJV)
ʾōkel
- What we hear
- Animal flesh specifically.
- What they heard
- Food in general, whatever is eaten. (Here it is in fact quail, but the word itself is generic.)
-
in v30
They didn't turn from their cravings (WEB; similar in some modern versions)
lō' zārû mittaʾăwātām
- What we hear
- They refused to repent of their sinful desires, an ongoing moral stubbornness.
- What they heard
- Probably mainly about timing and state: they had not yet become estranged from, or sated and sick of, the craving when judgment struck. The moral accusation is real in the psalm (v. 32), but this line chiefly sets up the moment.
Every word
-
וַיּוֹסִ֣יפוּ
wayyôsîpû · H3254G
and they added / did again · v17
Literally "they added." With an infinitive after it, this verb means "they did more of it" or "they did it again." The picture is piling up: God had just poured out water (v. 16), and their answer was to pile on more sin.
-
ע֭וֹד
ʿôd · H5750
still, yet, again · v17, v30
Strengthens the verb: "yet again" or "still more." Together with "added," it stresses that this was not a first slip but a pattern that kept growing.
-
לַחֲטֹא־
laḥăṭōʾ · H2398
to sin, to do wrong · v17
"To sin," meaning to fail in what you owe someone and so wrong them. Joined to "against him," it describes an offense against a person, here the God who had just rescued them, not only the breaking of a rule.
-
ל֑וֹ
lô · H9033
to him, against him · v17
The preposition marks who was wronged. With the verb "sin" it means "against him." The wrong is aimed at God personally.
-
לַֽמְר֥וֹת
lamrôt · H4784
to rebel, to defy · v17
A shortened causative-stem infinitive (from *lehamrôt*): "to act defiantly," "to set oneself against." It can explain the previous phrase ("sinning, *that is*, defying") or run alongside it as a parallel line. The same root marks Israel's history throughout this psalm (vv. 8, 40, 56).
-
עֶ֝לְי֗וֹן
ʿelyôn · H5945B
Most High · v17
An ancient royal title for God as the supreme ruler over everything. It sets the highest power in the universe against a wandering people who are openly defying him.
-
בַּצִּיָּֽה׃
baṣṣiyyâ · H6723
dryness, parched land · v17
"In the dry land," a waterless place. Coming right after v. 16, where God made water "flow down like rivers," the word is pointed: they defied him in the very land where they could only live because he gave them water.
-
וַיְנַסּוּ־
vayenassu · H5254
and they tested · v18
To put someone to the test in order to find out what they will do or can do. Here Israel is the one doing the testing and God is being tested, which turns the usual direction around: normally God tests Israel (Exodus 16:4; Deuteronomy 8:2). The verb form carries the story on from verse 17, as the next step in a chain of rebellion.
-
אֵ֥ל
'el · H410
-
בִּלְבָבָ֑ם
bilvavam · H3824
in their heart · v18
In Hebrew the heart is mainly where you think, decide and plan, not chiefly where you feel. 'In their heart' means the testing came from their inner intent and settled attitude: it was deliberate, not a slip of the tongue. That is why BSB and NIV render it 'willfully'.
-
לִֽשְׁאָל־
lish'ol · H7592
to ask, request · v18
The ordinary verb for asking. The grammar ('to ask' with the little prefix 'l-') tells us how they tested God: they tested him by asking. Next to 'tested' and 'in their heart', the asking reads as demanding proof rather than trusting prayer, which is why modern versions say 'demanding'.
-
אֹ֥כֶל
'okhel · H400
-
לְנַפְשָֽׁם׃
lenafsham · H5315
appetite; throat; life, self · v18
Nefesh is first of all the throat, and from there the living, hungry self that wants and needs. Next to 'food' it means appetite. They asked for food to satisfy their own craving, and the psalm names that craving outright a few verses later (vv. 29–30).
-
וַֽיְדַבְּר֗וּ
vayedabberu · H1696
and they spoke · v19
An intensive verb form of the ordinary word for speaking, in the past-narrative form that carries the story forward from verse 18. Here it means sustained talk, and with the preposition that follows it turns hostile: they talked against God.
-
בֵּֽאלֹ֫הִ֥ים
bēʾlōhîm · H430
against God · v19, v22
The prefix bĕ- (usually 'in, with, by') joined to 'speak' commonly means 'speak against', as in Numbers 21:5 ('the people spoke against God and against Moses'). Elohim is the usual word for God. It is grammatically plural but refers to the one God of Israel.
-
אָ֭מְרוּ
ʾāmerû · H559
they said · v19
The ordinary verb that introduces a quotation. After the general 'they spoke against God', it brings in the actual words of the complaint.
-
הֲי֣וּכַל
hayûkhal · H3201
is he able? · v19, v20
The prefix ha- turns the sentence into a yes/no question, and yûkhal means 'can he / is he able'. The tense points to present and future ability: can he do it, here, now? This is a skeptical question that expects 'no', not a request for information.
-
לַעֲרֹ֥ךְ
laʿărōkh · H6186
-
שֻׁ֝לְחָ֗ן
shulḥān · H7979
table · v19
A table, or a meal set out on one. In Hebrew usage it suggests hospitality and plenty: a king's table, a host's table, the sanctuary table. The mockers ask whether God can give a real meal, not just keep them barely alive.
-
בַּמִּדְבָּֽר׃
bammidbār · H4057
in the wilderness · v19
'In the steppe/desert': dry, unsettled land where flocks might graze but no one farms. Its consonants d-b-r echo the opening verb 'they spoke' (va-y-DaBBeRu … ba-mi-DBaR), so the verse begins and ends on the same sounds.
-
הֵ֤ן
hen · H2005
look!, behold · v20
A pointing word that opens the speakers' admission. In their mouths it works like 'Granted' or 'Sure': they admit the water miracle so they can question everything else.
-
הִכָּה־
hikkah · H5221
to strike, smite · v20
'He struck', a completed act. The word is the same one used in Exodus 17:6, where Moses is told to strike the rock at Horeb. Here God is named as the one who struck it.
-
צ֨וּר׀
tsur · H6697
rock, cliff · v20
A mass of solid rock or a cliff face, as in the Horeb story. In the same psalm (v. 35) 'Rock' is also a title for God, so there is a quiet irony: they talk about the rock and forget who their Rock is.
-
וַיָּז֣וּבוּ
vayyazuvu · H2100
to flow, gush · v20
'And they flowed out'. It is the verb of the 'land flowing with milk and honey' and is used again for the rock-water in Psalm 105:41 and Isaiah 48:21. It pictures a steady, abundant stream, not a trickle.
-
מַיִם֮
mayim · H4325
water(s) · v20
Water, the most urgent need in the desert. The Hebrew word is always plural, so it naturally suggests 'waters', a quantity.
-
וּנְחָלִ֪ים
unechalim · H5158
wadi, torrent, stream · v20
'And wadis/torrents'. A nachal is a stream bed that is usually dry and fills suddenly. The picture is dry gullies suddenly running full.
-
יִ֫שְׁטֹ֥פוּ
yishtofu · H7857
to overflow, flood, wash away · v20
'They overflowed' or 'they ran in flood'. It is a flash-flood word (compare Isaiah 28:2, 17). The speakers admit that the water came in overwhelming quantity.
-
הֲגַם־
hagam · H1571
also, even (with question marker) · v20, v21
The question marker plus 'also': 'Is it also…?' The turn from admission to doubt hangs on this word: 'Fine, water. But bread as well?'
-
לֶ֭חֶם
lechem · H3899
bread, food · v20, v25
Bread, the basic word for food in general. In this psalm it points to the manna, which verses 24–25 call 'grain of heaven' and 'bread of the mighty ones'.
-
תֵּ֑ת
tet · H5414
to give · v20, v24
'To give'. It completes 'is he able': can he give bread, the way he gave water?
-
אִם־
im · H518
if; or (in questions) · v20
Here it introduces the second half of a two-part question: 'or…?' Each half sharpens the doubt.
-
יָכִ֖ין
yakhin · H3559
to establish, make ready, prepare, provide · v20
'Will he make ready / provide'. The word means setting something up firmly, ready for use. It echoes v. 8, where this generation 'did not make its heart firm' (lo hekhin libbo). A people who never steadied their own hearts ask whether God can 'make ready' a meal.
-
שְׁאֵ֣ר
she'er · H7607
flesh, meat; blood relative · v20, v27
Meat as food: the craving of Numbers 11, answered with quail in Ps 78:27 ('he rained she'er on them like dust'). It has nothing to do with the 'sinful flesh' of later theology.
-
לְעַמּֽוֹ׃
le'ammo · H5971
people; 'for his people' · v20
'For his people'. The complainers call themselves God's people even while they doubt him. They admit the relationship and still question whether it will feed them.
-
לָכֵן
lāḵēn · H3651C
therefore · v21
Made of 'to' + 'so', meaning 'that is why'. Prophets use it to move from the charge to the sentence. Here it turns from what the people said (vv. 19–20) to how God answered.
-
שָׁמַע
šāmaʿ · H8085G
hear · v21
God heard their mocking words, 'Can God set a table in the wilderness?' (v. 19). It is the same opening as Numbers 11:1, 'the LORD heard, and his anger burned'.
-
יְהוָה
YHWH · H3068G
Yahweh (the LORD) · v21
Israel's God, called by his personal covenant name. Most English versions print it as 'the LORD'. The one who just split the rock (v. 20) is the one who now hears the people doubt him.
-
וַיִּתְעַבָּר
wayyitʿabbār · H5674B
become furious, let fury overflow · v21
This form of the verb means to give way to fury, or to show oneself furious. It is related to ʿebrâ, 'overflowing rage'. The picture is anger that bursts its banks.
-
וְאֵשׁ
wəʾēš · H0784
fire · v21
Real fire and a picture of anger together. It recalls the fire from the LORD that burned the edge of the camp at Taberah (Num 11:1–3).
-
נִשְּׂקָה
niśśəqāh · H5400
be kindled, catch fire · v21
A rare verb meaning 'was set alight'. The form is feminine because it agrees with 'fire'. Nobody is named as lighting it, but the context makes clear it comes from God.
-
בְיַעֲקֹב
ḇəyaʿăqōḇ · H3290
in/against Jacob · v21
'Jacob' means the whole nation descended from the patriarch. The little word bə- can mean 'in, among' (the fire broke out inside the camp) or 'against'. Both senses are present.
-
אַף
ʾap̄ · H0639G
nose, nostril; anger · v21
Literally 'nose'. Hebrew pictured anger as hot breath snorting from flared nostrils. With 'went up' it suggests smoke rising from the nostrils, as in Psalm 18:8.
-
עָלָה
ʿālāh · H5927G
go up, rise · v21
'Went up' goes with the fire of the first line. Smoke and anger both rise. 'Flared' and 'mounted' come close but drop the plain verb of rising.
-
בְיִשְׂרָאֵל
ḇəyiśrāʾēl · H3478
in/against Israel · v21
This line matches 'Jacob' in the first: the same people under their covenant name. The anger is aimed at the people God had just rescued.
-
כִּ֤י
ki · H3588A
for, because · v22
Gives the reason for verse 21. God's anger flared *because* of what this verse describes. The poet is not just reporting a mood; he is explaining what set off the fire.
-
לֹ֣א
lo' · H3808
not · v22, v30
The ordinary Hebrew word for 'not'. It flatly negates the verb. They did not do it at all.
-
הֶ֭אֱמִינוּ
he'eminu · H0539
to trust, believe, consider reliable · v22
This is the causative form of the root behind 'amen' and 'faithful', meaning roughly 'to treat as firm, to count as dependable'. With the preposition 'in' it means to put your weight on someone. The point is not doubting that God existed; they had just watched him split rock for water (v. 20). They refused to rely on him.
-
בָ֝טְח֗וּ
vatechu · H0982
to trust, rely on, feel secure · v22
To lean on something and feel safe because of it. Hebrew uses it for trusting walls, allies, riches or God. They did not rest easy in God's ability to rescue, so they complained and made demands instead (vv. 18–20).
-
בִּֽישׁוּעָתֽוֹ׃
bishu'ato · H3444
salvation, deliverance, rescue, victory · v22
'In his rescue', meaning God's power to save in concrete, visible ways. Here that means the rescue from Egypt, the sea crossing and the water from the rock, plus the help they now needed in the desert: food. It is the same word as Exodus 14:13, 'see the salvation of the LORD'.
-
וַיְצַ֣ו
vay-tsav · H6680
to command, give orders · v23
The narrative 'and he commanded'. God speaks like a king giving orders to his servants, and the sky has to obey. The 'and' follows straight on from v.22 ('they did not believe God'), so the contrast is sharp: they doubted, and he gave orders anyway.
-
שְׁחָקִ֣ים
shechaqim · H7834
thin cloud, fine dust; (plural) skies, clouds · v23
The high cloud-layers or upper sky. The root means to grind or crush something fine, so the picture is a fine, misty sky-layer. Here these 'skies' are the servants that receive the order, and from them the manna falls in v.24.
-
מִמָּ֑עַל
mimma'al · H4605
above, upward; (with min) from above · v23
'From above' / 'up there'. It places the clouds in the upper realm, so the reader looks up toward the source of what comes down. The Hebrew can mean either 'the clouds above' or 'commanded from above'; most translations take the first.
-
וְדַלְתֵ֖י
ve-daltei · H1817C
door, door-leaf · v23
'And the doors of'. The Hebrew form is dual, the form used for pairs, so this means two-leaf doors like the double doors of a city gate, a palace or a storehouse. The sky is pictured as a building whose great doors swing open.
-
שָׁמַ֣יִם
shamayim · H8064
heavens, sky · v23, v24, v26
The sky, the visible upper world above the earth, which is also where God dwells and holds his stores. The point here is the physical sky that rain, dew and now manna come down from, not the place where the dead go.
-
פָּתָֽח׃
patach · H6605A
to open · v23
'He opened' (a completed act). The object comes first in this half-line ('the doors of heaven he opened'), which puts the stress on what was opened. The word order mirrors the first half-line and closes the verse on the decisive action.
-
וַיַּמְטֵ֬ר
wayyamṭēr · H4305
to rain; (causative) to make rain fall · v24, v27
"And he made it rain." The causative form puts God in the role of the one who sends rain down. It is the same verb God uses in Exodus 16:4 ("I am about to rain bread from heaven for you"). The form continues the story from verse 23: he commanded the clouds, he opened the doors, and so he rained.
-
עֲלֵיהֶ֣ם
ʿălêhem · H5921A
upon, over · v24, v27
"Upon them." The food falls down on the people from above the way rain falls on a field. The same people were just described as not trusting God (v. 22).
-
מָ֣ן
mān · H4478A
manna · v24
The wilderness food described in Exodus 16 and Numbers 11. Exodus 16:15 explains the name with the people's puzzled question "man hu?", meaning "What is it?". The name itself remembers how strange the food was.
-
לֶאֱכֹ֑ל
leʾĕkōl · H0398
to eat · v24, v25
"To eat," stating the purpose. It answers the challenge in verses 19–20: "Can God spread a table in the wilderness? … Can he also give bread?" He could, and it was meant to be eaten.
-
וּדְגַן־
ûdəgan- · H1715
grain, cereal crop · v24
"And the grain of …" Dagan is the ordinary staple grain of the land (wheat and barley), the first item in the familiar blessing list "grain, new wine and oil". Calling manna "grain" pictures it as a harvest God gave without anyone plowing or sowing.
-
לָֽמוֹ׃
lāmô · H9038
to them · v24, v25
An older, poetic form of the usual lāhem ("to them"), kept mostly in poetry. It closes the line with a solemn, old-fashioned ring.
-
אַ֭בִּירִים
ʾabbîrîm · H0047J
mighty, strong ones · v25
Literally 'mighty ones', a word used for powerful bulls, war-horses, warriors and nobles. Paired with 'grain of heaven' in verse 24, it most naturally means the powerful beings of heaven, so the ancient Greek translation already rendered it 'angels'. The Hebrew itself does not use the ordinary word for angel (malʾak).
-
אִ֑ישׁ
ʾîš · H0376I
man; each one · v25
Singular but meaning 'each one' or 'every man': no one was left out (compare Exodus 16:16–18, where each gathered what he needed). It also sets mere humans against the 'mighty ones': ordinary people were eating the food of the mighty.
-
צֵידָ֬ה
ṣêdâ · H6720
provisions, journey-food · v25
The word for travel rations, the food packed for a journey. Exodus 12:39 says Israel left Egypt without having prepared any ṣêdâ, so here God himself supplies the rations they never packed.
-
שָׁלַ֖ח
šālaḥ · H7971G
to send · v25
'He sent'. God is the unnamed subject, dispatching food like a king sending supplies to his troops. The supplied gloss 'depart' belongs to a different use of the verb; here it is plainly 'send'.
-
לָשֹֽׂבַע׃
lāśōbaʿ · H7648
fullness, satiety · v25
'To fullness', meaning until they were satisfied, as much as they could eat. It echoes the exact phrase of Exodus 16:3, 8 ('bread to the full'), and it prepares for the bitter turn in verses 29–31, where being 'well filled' leads to judgment.
-
יַסַּ֣ע
yassaʿ · H5265
to pull up (stakes), set out; (causative) make set out · v26
The causative form: God made the east wind 'break camp' and set off on a journey. The verb is the one used for Israel pulling up tent pegs and marching through the wilderness, and Numbers 11:31 uses it of the very wind that brought the quail.
-
קָ֭דִים
qādîm · H6921
east; east wind · v26
The east wind: in Israel, the hot, dry, often violent wind off the desert. It is a forceful wind that carries things in, not a gentle breeze.
-
וַיְנַהֵ֖ג
waynahēg · H5090
to drive, lead, guide (as a herd) · v26
'And he drove.' This is a herdsman's verb for driving livestock. God herds the south wind the way a shepherd drives a flock, and the same verb is used of God leading Israel 'like a flock' in v. 52.
-
בְּעֻזּ֣וֹ
bəʿuzzô · H5797
-
תֵימָֽן׃
têmān · H8486
south; south wind · v26
The south, here the south wind. The word comes from the root for 'right hand': a person facing east (the basic orientation) has the south on the right. It balances 'east' in the first line.
-
כֶּעָפָ֣ר
keʿāpār · H6083
dust, dry earth · v27
"Like the dust." A picture of a quantity nobody could count, like the loose dirt of the ground. Elsewhere dust is also what humans return to (Genesis 3:19), a note that fits the deaths in verses 30–31, though the main point here is the amount.
-
וּֽכְח֥וֹל
ūkəḥôl · H2344
sand · v27
"And like the sand of." The second picture of something countless, matching "dust" in the first line. Dust and sand together are a fixed biblical pair for numbers beyond counting.
-
יַ֝מִּ֗ים
yammîm · H3220G
sea · v27
"Seas" (plural). "Sand of the seas" is a set poetic phrase (Job 6:3; Jeremiah 15:8) that means the endless sand of every shoreline. It does not refer to several particular seas.
-
ע֣וֹף
ʿôp · H5775
flying creature(s), birds · v27
"Birds", a singular word used for a whole mass of them. Held back to near the end of the line, it finally says what the "meat" was: birds. The historical accounts name them as quail (Exodus 16:13; Numbers 11:31).
-
כָּנָֽף׃
kānāp · H3671
wing; edge, extremity · v27
"Of wing." Put together, "birds of wing" is a set phrase meaning "winged birds". It echoes Genesis 1:21 ("every winged bird"). The creatures of the air that God made come down on command as food.
-
זָר֥וּ
zārû · H2114A
be a stranger, turn aside, be estranged · v30
"They had become strangers to / had moved away from." The picture is distance: the craving had not yet become something foreign to them that they had left behind. It probably also echoes God's threat in Numbers 11:20 that they would eat meat until it became zārā', loathsome, to them. They never reached that point.
-
מִתַּאֲוָתָ֑ם
mittaʾăwātām · H8378
desire, craving, appetite · v30
"From their craving." It picks up the same word from verse 29 ("He gave them what they craved") and recalls Kibroth-hattaavah, "Graves of Craving" (Numbers 11:34). This is appetite, not sexual desire.
-
בְּפִיהֶֽם׃
bᵉpîhem · H6310G
mouth · v30
"In their mouths." The image is physical and close-up: judgment arrives mid-bite. It matches Numbers 11:33, "while the meat was still between their teeth."
The world behind it
A history lesson sung for the next generation. Psalm 78 is a long teaching poem ("a maskil of Asaph") that retells Israel's story from Egypt to King David. It says plainly why it exists (vv. 1–8): so the children will "not be like their fathers, a stubborn and rebellious generation." The poem is a warning drawn from the past.
The events behind the verse. Verses 15–16 recall the water from the rock (Exodus 17:1–7 at Massah/Meribah; Numbers 20:2–13). Verses 18–31 move on to the demand for meat and the quail (Numbers 11). The psalm arranges these episodes by theme rather than in strict order, so that each act of rescue is followed by a new act of defiance. Verse 17 is the hinge between the gift of water and the demand for food.
Why the words land hard. In the dry country of the Sinai and the Negev, water decided whether people lived or died. For a people in the parched land, God giving water was the most basic act of keeping them alive. In the ancient world, defying a benefactor or a king who had just provided for you was shameful ingratitude. Defying a father who fed you was a capital offense in Israel's law (Deut 21:18–21). The poet's vocabulary draws on both pictures.
From the study of Psalm 78:17.
Where scholars differ
in v17
What does "still / again" point back to?
-
It points to the sins already listed in vv. 10–11 (not keeping the covenant, forgetting God's works). The water episode is one more mercy they answered with more sin.
The psalm is arranged by theme. Verse 17 follows the account of rescue (vv. 12–16) and picks up the earlier list of sins, so "added still" means added to what had come before.
-
It means sin committed right after, and in spite of, the gift of water in vv. 15–16.
The verse directly follows v. 16. The contrast between "made water flow down like rivers" and "in the dry land" is sharp, and vv. 18–20 have the people mentioning the water gift while they demand bread and meat (v. 20). In Exodus, though, the grumbling at Massah comes *before* the water, so the psalm is ordering events by theme rather than by date.
in v17, v21, v24
When was Psalm 78 composed?
-
Before the exile, in the time of the kings. Some say soon after the united monarchy, others after the fall of the northern kingdom (722 BC), perhaps under Hezekiah.
The psalm ends with God rejecting Ephraim and choosing Judah, Zion and David (vv. 67–72). It does not mention the destruction of Jerusalem, which would be strange if that had already happened.
-
After the exile, or edited then.
Its teaching style and its use of Pentateuch traditions in combination are like other historical psalms (105, 106) that many date late. This position argues that the silence about Jerusalem's fall carries less weight.
in v18
Which wilderness episode does verse 18 have in view: the manna (Exodus 16) or the quail (Numbers 11)?
-
Mainly the quail craving of Numbers 11.
The language of appetite (nefesh) and craving matches Numbers 11:4–6, and Psalm 78:29–31 ends with God giving 'their craving' and striking them while the food was still in their mouths, which is the Kibroth-hattaavah story.
-
A summary charge covering the whole sequence of food demands (manna and quail, possibly after the water at Massah).
The psalm goes on to narrate both the manna (vv. 23–25) and the quail (vv. 26–29). The general word 'okhel ('food') and the general question 'Can God set a table?' (v. 19) suggest a summary of the wilderness pattern rather than one incident. Psalm poetry often merges episodes.
in v20
Does hen here express wonder ('Behold!') or reluctant concession ('Granted…')?
-
Exclamatory 'Behold/Look'.
The basic meaning of hen is a pointing particle, and KJV, WEB, NASB and YLT keep it that way.
-
Concessive 'True/Granted', or a premise ('since').
The speech is an argument: an admitted fact followed by a doubting question with 'also' (hagam). Hen often sets up a premise (e.g. Exod 6:12). The Septuagint's epei ('since') and NIV's 'True' both read it as a premise.
in v20
Are vv. 19–20 a quotation of words actually spoken, or the psalmist's dramatisation?
-
A poetic voicing of what the complaints amounted to.
No such speech appears in Exodus or Numbers. The order (water before bread) differs from Exodus 16–17. The speech blends several episodes into one argument.
-
A faithful summary of recorded complaints.
Numbers 11:4 ('Who will give us meat?'), Numbers 21:5 and Exodus 17:7 ('Is the LORD among us or not?') contain the same substance, so the psalm condenses real complaints.
in v21
Is the 'fire' a literal memory of Taberah or a metaphor for divine anger?
-
It recalls the actual fire at Taberah (Num 11:1–3).
Ps 78:21 shares Num 11:1's distinctive vocabulary ('heard', 'anger', 'fire'). The psalm then follows Numbers 11's order: complaint, fire, quail, plague (vv. 26–31).
-
It is chiefly a poetic figure for God's anger.
The two lines are parallel: 'fire was kindled' matches 'anger went up', and fire is a standard Hebrew picture for anger (Deut 32:22; Ps 18:8; 89:46). The psalm compresses and reshapes the wilderness stories freely.
-
Both at once.
Many commentators (e.g., Tate, Goldingay) read the line as remembered event and image together. Hebrew poetry often lets a historical detail double as a figure of speech.
in v22
When was Psalm 78 composed, and so who first heard this warning?
-
Before the exile, in the monarchy period (perhaps the time of Hezekiah or earlier).
The psalm ends with God choosing Judah, Zion and David and rejecting Ephraim/Shiloh (vv. 67–72). It never mentions the fall of Samaria or of Jerusalem, which would be odd if either had already happened. On this view it warns northern-southern Israel against Ephraim's unfaithfulness.
-
Later, after the exile, or composite.
Its style as a teaching poem and its use of a Pentateuch-like wilderness tradition resemble other late historical psalms (105, 106). Some scholars see the David-Zion ending as a later community's way of defining itself.
in v23
Does v.23 continue the story ('and then he commanded'), or look back ('though he had commanded')?
-
Forward-moving narrative: in spite of their unbelief (v.22), God gave manna and then quail (vv.23–29). Most modern versions ('Yet he commanded').
וַיְצַו is the standard form for moving a story forward. Verses 23–29 read as one connected sequence: command, opening, manna, meat, eating to the full. Then comes judgment in vv.30–31, following the order of Num 11.
-
Looking back or conceding: they did not trust, even though he had already opened heaven for them (KJV, some older commentators).
In Numbers 11 the manna had been falling for a long time before the people complained, so the manna (vv.23–25) comes before the complaint historically. Hebrew poetry sometimes uses this form loosely, without strict time order. The psalm also blends Exodus 16 and Numbers 11, so its order is theological rather than strictly chronological.
in v23
How literally did the psalmist mean 'the doors of heaven'?
-
It reflects a real ancient picture of the world: a solid sky with storehouses and openings.
Gen 1:6–8 (the raqia, an expanse or 'firmament', separating waters); Job 37:18 (skies 'hard as a cast mirror'); 'windows of heaven' in Gen 7:11; storehouses in Deut 28:12 and Job 38:22. Similar pictures appear across the ancient Near East (the Ugaritic Baal window; the gates of heaven in Mesopotamia).
-
It is poetic, descriptive language and should not be pressed as an account of how the sky is built.
The phrase 'doors of heaven' occurs only here and varies freely with 'windows'. 2 Kgs 7:2 uses 'windows in heaven' almost proverbially. Poets use building images loosely, as in Ps 104:2–3, where God stretches out the heavens like a tent.
in v24
What was manna, physically?
-
A miraculous food with no natural explanation.
The texts describe features no natural substance fully explains: daily supply for a whole people, spoiling when hoarded but not on the Sabbath, the double portion on Friday, and its ending exactly when Israel reached Canaan (Exod 16; Josh 5:12). The psalm presents it as God commanding the clouds.
-
A known desert product, the sweet honeydew left by scale insects on tamarisk shrubs in Sinai, presented as God's provision.
F. S. Bodenheimer (1947) and others documented sweet, flaky deposits in Sinai still called *mann* in Arabic, which appear in early summer and melt in the sun (compare Exod 16:21). Critics point out that the quantities are tiny and seasonal, not enough for the biblical account.
-
The question doesn't decide the psalm's meaning.
Either way, the psalm's claim is about who gave it: God "rained" and "gave" it in answer to unbelief. The poem's interest is theological and historical, not scientific.
in v24
Where does the name 'manna' come from?
-
From the question "man hu?" ("What is it?") as Exodus 16:15 says.
*Man* as "what" is attested in Aramaic and some related languages, and the Greek of Exodus keeps the question form.
-
From an existing word for the substance (compare Arabic *mann*, tamarisk honeydew), with Exodus 16:15 offering a wordplay on it.
Biblical name-explanations are often wordplays rather than technical etymologies. The Arabic term matches the proposed natural substance.
in v25
Who are the ʾabbîrîm, 'mighty ones', whose bread Israel ate?
-
Heavenly beings (angels): food from heaven's court.
Parallel with 'grain of heaven' and 'doors of heaven' (vv. 23–24). The Septuagint, Wisdom 16:20, the Targum and Rabbi Akiva (b. Yoma 75b) all read it this way. Most modern translations follow.
-
Human nobles or heroes: a feast fit for the mighty, princely food.
Everywhere else ʾabbîr is used of strong animals or powerful humans, never of angels. Jerome's 'bread of the strong' and the Jewish Publication Society's 'hero's meal'-type rendering reflect this.
-
God himself, 'the Mighty One' (a plural expressing majesty): bread from the Mighty One.
The related title ʾăbîr Yaʿăqōb, 'Mighty One of Jacob'. This is a minority view: the vowels differ, and the plural is otherwise unexplained.
-
Rabbinic wordplay: bread absorbed by the 'limbs' (ʾêbārîm), leaving no waste.
Rabbi Ishmael in b. Yoma 75b, objecting that angels do not eat. This is homiletical wordplay, not a reading of the plain sense.
in v25
Does the second line ('He sent them provisions to the full') still describe the manna, or does it begin the quail account?
-
Manna: the line completes the manna section of vv. 23–25.
Parallel with the first line. Echo of Exodus 16:8, 'bread to the full'. The quail are introduced with a new verb sequence in v. 26.
-
A bridge to the quail.
ṣêdâ is related to ṣayid, 'game', and v. 29 uses the same root for being 'filled' with the meat. Some read 25b as anticipating vv. 26–29.
in v26
Does the verse describe one wind or two?
-
One south-easterly wind, described across both lines.
Hebrew poetry often splits a single idea between two parallel lines (compare the 'dust' and 'sand' in v. 27). East plus south describes the desert quarter from which a quail-bearing wind would come. Numbers 11:31 mentions only one wind.
-
Two winds, east then south, acting in turn or together.
Each line has its own verb and object. Some interpreters, ancient and modern, read a combined or changing wind pattern. The Septuagint keeps two distinct winds, though with different directions.
in v27
Do "dust" and "sand of the seas" deliberately echo God's promise to Abraham?
-
Yes, as irony: the people promised to be as countless as dust and sand are fed, and then many die, under birds as countless as dust and sand.
The same pair of images marks the promise of countless descendants (Genesis 13:16; 22:17; 28:14; 32:12). Psalm 78 is steeped in the Torah stories, and verses 30–31 report the deaths of Israel's young men.
-
No deliberate allusion: dust and sand are simply the most common Hebrew pictures for huge numbers.
The same images describe locusts, armies, grain, silver and wisdom with no link to Abraham (Judges 7:12; Genesis 41:49; Job 27:16; 1 Kings 4:29). Nothing in the verse itself points to the patriarchs.
in v27
How do the "east wind" and "south wind" (v. 26) relate to Numbers 11's wind "from the sea"?
-
The psalm simply says in poetry what Numbers says in prose: God drove the birds in by wind. The two winds side by side are parallel poetic lines, not a weather report.
Hebrew poetry often pairs terms (east // south) to mean one event. Numbers 11:31 says only that "a wind went out from the LORD".
-
The directions reflect a particular local tradition or a real wind pattern (for example, birds carried from the Gulf of Aqaba or the Red Sea region by southeasterly winds).
Quail migration over Sinai and the Red Sea is well documented. "From the sea" in Numbers could refer to a southern or eastern body of water.
in v30
Does "they were not estranged from their craving" describe moral stubbornness or the timing and state of their appetite?
-
Moral: they did not turn away from their sinful desire, even after God gave it to them.
The psalm's broader indictment (v. 32, "in spite of all this they kept sinning"; vv. 17–18). This is how KJV, WEB and NIV-type renderings read it.
-
Timing and state: they had not yet had their fill or grown sick of the craving when God struck.
The close parallel with Numbers 11:20 (meat becoming zārā', loathsome) and Numbers 11:33 ("while the meat was still between their teeth, before it was consumed"); the second line's "still... in their mouths"; the way verse 30 flows syntactically into verse 31. Followed by ESV, BSB, NIV ("before") and many commentators.
in v30
How does verse 30 fit with verse 29's "they ate and were well filled"?
-
Body versus desire: their stomachs were full, but the craving was not exhausted.
Different words: śābaʿ ("be sated") in v. 29 describes eating; zûr from taʾăwāh in v. 30 describes the desire. Compare Psalm 106:15.
-
The Septuagint reading: verse 30 continues the description of fulfilment ("they were not deprived of their desire").
LXX ouk esterēthēsan. The judgment begins only in verse 31.
Sources
- BDB s.v. יָסַף, עוֹד, חָטָא, מָרָה, עֶלְיוֹן, צִיָּה
- HALOT s.v. מרה (hiphil: 'to behave rebelliously, defy')
- HALOT s.v. צִיָּה
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Psalm 77:17
- Exodus 17:1–7; Numbers 11; 20:2–13; Deuteronomy 21:18–21
- Psalm 78:8, 35, 40, 56; Psalm 105:41; Psalm 106:7, 33, 43
- Hebrews 3:7–19 (use of parapikrainō/parapikrasmos)
- Genesis 14:18–22 (El Elyon)
- BDB s.v. נָסָה, לֵבָב, שָׁאַל, נֶפֶשׁ
- HALOT s.v. נסה, לֵבָב, נֶפֶשׁ
- Septuagint, Psalm 77:18 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Gallican Psalter, Psalm 77:18
- Exodus 16–17; Numbers 11; Deuteronomy 6:16; 8:2; Psalms 95, 105, 106
- H. W. Wolff, Anthropology of the Old Testament (on nefesh and lev)
- Oxford English Dictionary, historical senses of 'tempt', 'meat', 'lust'
- BDB s.v. דָּבַר (Piel with בְּ, 'speak against')
- HALOT s.v. עָרַךְ; s.v. שֻׁלְחָן; s.v. מִדְבָּר
- BDB s.v. יָכֹל
- Septuagint, Psalm 77:19 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Psalm 77:19
- Marvin E. Tate, Psalms 51–100 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Hossfeld & Zenger, Psalms 2 (Hermeneia)
- John Goldingay, Psalms vol. 2 (Baker Commentary on the Old Testament)
- Numbers 11; 14:16; 21:5; Exodus 16; Deuteronomy 9:28; Psalm 23:5; Proverbs 9:2 (comparative usage)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. שְׁאֵר, כּוּן, יָכֹל, הֵן, נַחַל, שָׁטַף
- Septuagint, Psalm 77:20 (Rahlfs); Brenton's English translation of the Septuagint
- Vulgate, Psalm 77:20 (Gallican Psalter) and Jerome's Psalter from the Hebrew
- Exodus 16–17; Numbers 11; 20; Deuteronomy 6:16 (parallel narratives)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Psalm 78
- BDB s.v. עָבַר II (hithp. 'be furious'), עֶבְרָה, אַף, נָשַׂק
- HALOT s.v. עבר II hitp., נשׂק, אַף
- Numbers 11:1–35 (Taberah; quail at Kibroth-hattaavah)
- Psalm 18:8 (Eng.) / 18:9 (Heb.) — smoke rising from the nostrils
- Septuagint Psalm 77:21 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Gallican Psalter, Ps 77:21
- John Goldingay, Psalms, vol. 2: Psalms 42–89 (Baker Commentary on the Old Testament Wisdom and Psalms)
- Frank-Lothar Hossfeld & Erich Zenger, Psalms 2 (Hermeneia)
- BDB s.v. אָמַן, בָּטַח, יְשׁוּעָה
- HALOT s.v. אמן (hif.), בטח, יְשׁוּעָה
- A. Jepsen, 'aman', in Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament vol. 1
- Hans-Joachim Kraus, Psalms 60–150
- John Goldingay, Psalms vol. 2
- Septuagint, Psalm 77:22 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Gallican Psalter Psalm 77:22
- BDB s.v. צָוָה, שַׁחַק, דֶּלֶת, שָׁמַיִם, פָּתַח
- HALOT s.v. שַׁחַק (fine dust; thin cloud; sky)
- Septuagint, Psalm 77:23 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Gallican Psalter and Iuxta Hebraeos, Psalm 77:23
- Babylonian Talmud, Hagigah 12b (seven heavens; Shechaqim and the manna millstones)
- KTU 1.4 VII (Ugaritic Baal cycle: the window in Baal's palace)
- Enuma Elish, Tablet V (gates of heaven)
- Exodus 16; Numbers 11; 2 Kings 7:2, 19; Genesis 7:11; 8:2; Deuteronomy 28:12; Malachi 3:10
- John 6:31–33
- BDB s.v. מָטַר, מָן, דָּגָן, שָׁמַיִם
- HALOT s.v. מטר, מָן, דָּגָן
- Septuagint, Psalm 77:24 (Rahlfs)
- Exodus 16; Numbers 11:6–9; Deuteronomy 8:3, 16; Nehemiah 9:15; Hosea 2:8; 2 Kings 7:2, 19
- John 6:31–35; 1 Corinthians 10:3; Wisdom of Solomon 16:20
- F. S. Bodenheimer, "The Manna of Sinai," Biblical Archaeologist 10 (1947)
- M. E. Tate, Psalms 51–100 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- F.-L. Hossfeld & E. Zenger, Psalms 2 (Hermeneia)
- Ugaritic Baal Cycle, KTU 1.4 VII (Baal's window)
- BDB s.v. אַבִּיר
- HALOT s.v. אַבִּיר; s.v. צֵידָה
- Septuagint Psalm 77:25 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate Psalm 77:25; Jerome, Psalterium iuxta Hebraeos
- Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 75b
- Targum of Psalms 78:25
- Wisdom of Solomon 16:20
- Exodus 12:39; 16:3, 8, 16–18; Numbers 11
- BDB s.v. נָסַע, נָהַג, קָדִים, תֵּימָן
- HALOT s.v. נסע (Hiphil), נהג (Piel), קָדִים, עֹז, תֵּימָן
- Numbers 11:31–34 (narrative source)
- Psalm 78:52 (parallel use of nāsaʿ and nāhag)
- Septuagint Psalm 77:26 (Rahlfs), recalled from memory
- Vulgate (Gallican Psalter) Psalm 77:26
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Numbers 11 (quail migration)
- BDB s.v. מָטַר, שְׁאֵר, עָפָר, עוֹף, כָּנָף
- HALOT s.v. שְׁאֵר (meat as food; body; kin)
- HALOT s.v. מטר (Hiphil: cause to rain)
- Exodus 16:4, 13; Numbers 11:4–34 (quail narrative, Kibroth-hattaavah)
- Genesis 1:21; 13:16; 19:24; 22:17
- Septuagint Psalm 77:27 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Gallican Psalter, Psalm 77:27
- Josephus, Antiquities 3.1.5 (quail in the wilderness)
- John Goldingay, Psalms vol. 2: Psalms 42–89 (Baker Commentary on the OT)
- Hans-Joachim Kraus, Psalms 60–150 (Continental Commentary)
- BDB s.v. זוּר, זָרָא, תַּאֲוָה, אֹכֶל
- HALOT s.v. זור I, תַּאֲוָה
- Septuagint Psalm 77:30 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Gallican Psalter Ps 77:30
- Numbers 11:4–34 (Hebrew text)
- Psalm 106:13–15
- M. E. Tate, Psalms 51–100 (Word Biblical Commentary) on Ps 78
- Hossfeld & Zenger, Psalms 2 (Hermeneia) on Ps 78
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
3 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.