Tobit Chapter 3 Read as one passage

Tobit 3:8–9

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

8because that she had been given to seven husbands, and Asmodaeus the evil spirit killed them, before they had lain with her. And they said to her, “Do you not know that you strangle your husbands? You have had already seven husbands, and you haven’t borne the name of any one of them. 9Why do you scourge us? If they are dead, go your ways with them. Let us never see either son or daughter from you.”

What the first hearers heard

For Jews living in the diaspora, this verse brought together several fears and hopes:

  • Innocent suffering misread as guilt. The audience knows from the narrator that a demon killed the men. Those around Sarah assume the disaster shows something is wrong with her. Tobit's story sets this kind of thinking up so it can be overturned. Like Job, Sarah is innocent, and her later prayer (3:14–15) insists she is pure.
  • The full weight of a woman's shame. Seven failed marriages, no name and no children meant social death. For first hearers, the maids' taunt summed up what childlessness and broken marriage cost a woman in a society built on kinship.
  • A real but limited evil. The demon is named and deadly, but he is not all-powerful. The audience already suspects, and soon learns (3:16–17), that God hears Sarah's prayer the same day and sends Raphael. The verse shows the threat at its worst so that the rescue will feel great.
  • Hope for a scattered people. Sarah stands, in a small way, for Israel in exile: mocked, apparently cut off from a future, waiting for God to act. The marriage to Tobias, a kinsman married 'according to the law of Moses', becomes a picture of faithfulness being rewarded and the family line restored.

The audience heard the verse with dramatic irony: they knew what the maids did not.

From the study of Tobit 3:8.

Verse by verse

  1. 8because that she had been given to seven husbands, and Asmodaeus the evil spirit killed them, before they had lain with her. And they said to her, “Do you not know that you strangle your husbands? You have had already seven husbands, and you haven’t borne the name of any one of them.

    The narrator steps in to explain why the household servants insult their master's daughter. Seven times Sarah's father had given her in marriage, and each time Asmodaeus, the evil demon, a named, malicious spirit, killed the bridegroom on the wedding night, before he could be with her as a husband is with his wife. None of the marriages was ever consummated.

    The reader is told plainly that the demon did it. The maids do not know this, or will not accept it. They sneer at her: "Don't you get it? You're the one who strangles your own husbands!" The picture is brutal and physical: a bride with her hands on her husband's throat in the bridal chamber. "Seven already, and not one of them ever gave you his name". Seven weddings, and she has never become anyone's wife in the eyes of the community. She has no husband's name, no household, no standing. (Another early Greek text reads "not one of them did you any good / gave you any joy.")

    The verse is built on a sharp gap between what the narrator says and what the maids say. The narrator clears Sarah and blames the demon. The maids blame Sarah and turn her tragedy into guilt. The next line (3:9) finishes the curse: "May we never see a son or daughter from you!" To be named by no husband meant to be mother of no child.

    Full study →
  2. 9Why do you scourge us? If they are dead, go your ways with them. Let us never see either son or daughter from you.”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v8

    neither wast thou named after any of them (KJV, Brenton)

    henos autōn ouk ōnomasthēs

    What we hear
    Today 'named after' suggests being given someone's name at birth, as a child is named after a grandparent.
    What they heard
    She was never called by any husband's name. She never became known as his wife or gained the standing, protection and household that came with it (compare Isaiah 4:1).
Every word
  1. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    because, that · v8

    Introduces the reason for the maids' insults in 3:7. The narrator stops to explain what is behind them.

  2. ἦν

    ēn · G1510

    was · v8

    Combined with the next word to make 'had been given'. It points to a settled past state that still hangs over Sarah.

  3. δεδομένη

    dedomenē · G1325

    given · v8

    'Given' (perfect passive). In this world a daughter was given in marriage by her father. Sarah did not choose these marriages; they were made for her.

  4. ἀνδράσιν

    andrasin · G435

    men, husbands · v8

    'To husbands'. The same Greek word means 'man' and 'husband', and here it is husband.

  5. ἑπτὰ

    hepta · G2033

    seven · v8

    Seven is a literal count in the story. It is also the biblical number of completeness, so it makes her disaster total.

  6. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v8

    Links her marriages to the real cause of the deaths.

  7. Ἀσμοδαῖος

    Asmodaios

    Asmodaeus (proper name) · v8

    The demon is named. This is one of the earliest named demons in Jewish literature. The name is probably Persian in origin (see studies).

  8. τὸ

    to · G3588

    the · v8

    The article marks him as a specific, known being, 'the' evil demon, not just any spirit.

  9. πονηρὸν

    ponēron · G4190

    evil, wicked, harmful · v8

    Says this spirit is malicious and destructive, not neutral. In ordinary Greek a 'daimonion' could be good or bad.

  10. δαιμόνιον

    daimonion · G1140

    demon, spirit · v8

    A spirit being below God. In Jewish Greek the word had already taken on the sense of a hostile spirit.

  11. ἀπέκτεινεν

    apekteinen · G615

    killed · v8

    A plain word for killing. The narrator puts the deaths squarely on the demon.

  12. αὐτοὺς

    autous · G846

    them · v8

    The seven husbands.

  13. πρινὴ

    prin ē · G4250

    before · v8

    'Before' (written as one word in this edition, normally prin ē). Each man died before the marriage was consummated.

  14. γενέσθαι

    genesthai · G1096

    to become, to be · v8

    With 'with her' it means 'to be with her', a modest phrase for sexual union.

  15. μετʼ

    met' · G3326

    with · v8

    'With her', meaning in union with her.

  16. ὡς

    hōs · G5613

    as · v8

    'As (is the way)'. It introduces the normal pattern of married life.

  17. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, among, with · v8

    With the next word: 'as with wives', meaning as a husband normally is with his wife.

  18. γυναιξί

    gynaixi · G1135

    women, wives · v8

    'Wives'. The whole phrase is a modest way of saying the marriage was never consummated.

  19. εἶπαν

    eipan · G2036

    they said · v8

    The subject is the father's maidservants from 3:7. Household servants are openly insulting the daughter of the house.

  20. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v8

    Starts a question that expects the answer 'yes, you do'. It is a sneer.

  21. συνιεῖς

    synieis · G4920

    understand, realise · v8

    'Don't you get it?' The word normally means understanding something, here used mockingly.

  22. ἀποπνίγουσά

    apopnigousa · G638

    choke, strangle, suffocate · v8

    '(You) strangling'. A present participle (an '-ing' form), so it paints her as the habitual strangler. The maids blame her for what the narrator has just pinned on the demon.

  23. σου

    sou · G4675

    your · v8

    'Your own' husbands. It adds to the horror of the charge.

  24. ἤδη

    ēdē · G2235

    already · v8

    'Already seven'. It mocks how many there have been.

  25. ἔσχες

    esches · G2192

    you had · v8

    'You have had' seven husbands, though not in the full sense of marriage.

  26. ἑνὸς

    henos · G1520

    one · v8

    'By (even) one' of them. Not a single one.

  27. ὠνομάσθης

    ōnomasthēs · G3687

    you were named / called · v8

    'You were not named (by any of them)'. She never became known as any man's wife and never took a husband's name and the standing that came with it. Sinaiticus has a near-identical word meaning 'you had no benefit'.

The world behind it

Where and who. The scene happens in Ecbatana, capital of Media (modern Hamadan, Iran), in the Persian east. Sarah is the only daughter of Raguel, a Jew of the tribe of Naphtali living in exile. The book is told as happening in the Assyrian period but was written centuries later (3rd–2nd century BC). It addresses Jews living away from the land who are trying to stay faithful far from Jerusalem.

Marriage within the clan. Tobit stresses marrying within one's own family line (4:12–13). Because Sarah is an only daughter, she is also the heir of her father's property (6:12–13). That echoes the law of Zelophehad's daughters (Num 36), where heiresses married within their tribe so the land stayed in the family. This explains why there were suitors at all, and why Tobias, her closest kinsman, has the right to marry her later. In the longer Greek text Tobias says he has heard that a demon loves her and kills any man who comes near her (6:14–15). That suggests a jealous spirit.

Honour and shame. In this world a woman's honour came through marriage and children. Her husband's name, and the household it stood for, gave her a place. A woman married seven times with no consummated marriage and no child was a figure of deep social disgrace. When slave-girls taunt the daughter of the house, the social order has been turned upside down, which shows how far she has fallen. The word in 3:7 is oneidizō, 'to reproach, put to shame'. The same experience hits Tobit in Nineveh on the same day (3:6). That parallel sets up both prayers and God's single answer through Raphael (3:16–17).

Demons in Second Temple Judaism. In the centuries before Jesus, Jewish writings show a growing interest in evil spirits, their names, and the remedies against them (for example 1 Enoch, Jubilees, and exorcism texts among the Dead Sea Scrolls). Tobit fits this trend. The demon is defeated by a God-given remedy, a fish's heart and liver burned as smoke (6:8; 8:2–3), together with prayer, while Raphael binds the demon in Egypt.

A probable later echo. In the Gospels, the Sadducees' trick question about one woman married in turn to seven brothers, each of whom dies without children (Mark 12:20–23; Matt 22:25–28; Luke 20:29–33), is widely thought to draw on this story, or at least to share its storytelling pattern. Many scholars think the link is likely. It cannot be proved.

From the study of Tobit 3:8.

Where scholars differ

in v8

Where does the name Asmodaeus come from?

  • From the Persian *aēšma-daēva*, 'demon of wrath'.

    Aēšma is a prominent evil being in Zoroastrian texts. The story is set in Media and the book shows other Persian influence. This is the majority view in commentaries such as Moore and Fitzmyer.

  • From a Semitic root *šmd*, 'destroy', meaning 'the Destroyer'.

    The Hebrew and Aramaic verb *hishmid* means 'to destroy', and later Jewish tradition spells him *Ashmedai*. Critics answer that the Greek ending and the setting point more naturally to Persian.

in v8

Was Sarah 'not named' by any husband, or did she have 'no benefit' from any?

  • 'Not named' (*ōnomasthēs*): she never gained a husband's name and standing.

    Found in the shorter Greek text (Vaticanus, Alexandrinus). Fits the biblical idea of being called by a husband's name to remove reproach (Isa 4:1).

  • 'No benefit / no joy' (*ōnasthēs*): she never enjoyed a husband.

    Found in Sinaiticus, generally the better witness to the original. As the less obvious word, it is the kind of reading a scribe might have 'corrected' into the more familiar 'named'.

in v8

Does the Sadducees' question about a woman with seven husbands (Mark 12:18–27 and parallels) depend on Tobit?

  • Yes. It is a deliberate allusion to Tobit.

    Both have seven husbands who all die and a childless woman, and both raise the question of marriage and death. Tobit was well known by the first century (it was found at Qumran).

  • Shared trope, not direct dependence.

    The Gospel case is built on levirate marriage (Deut 25:5–10), with seven brothers, not seven unrelated suitors, and there is no demon. 'Seven' is a common storytelling number.

Sources
  • Joseph A. Fitzmyer, *Tobit* (Commentaries on Early Jewish Literature, 2003)
  • Carey A. Moore, *Tobit* (Anchor Bible 40A, 1996)
  • Robert Hanhart, ed., *Tobit* (Göttingen Septuaginta VIII/5, 1983)
  • Alexander A. Di Lella, 'Tobit', in *A New English Translation of the Septuagint* (NETS)
  • LSJ s.v. ἀποπνίγω; ὀνίνημι; ὀνομάζω
  • BDAG s.v. δαιμόνιον; ἀποπνίγω
  • Brenton, *The Septuagint with Apocrypha* (1851)
  • Babylonian Talmud, Gittin 68a (Ashmedai)
  • *Testament of Solomon* (Asmodeus)
  • Isaiah 4:1 (MT and LXX)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.