1 Chronicles Chapter 4 Read as one passage

1 Chronicles 4:23–24

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

23These were the potters who lived at Netaim and Gederah. They lived there in the service of the king. 24The descendants of Simeon: Nemuel, Jamin, Jarib, Zerah, and Shaul.

What the first hearers heard

To a Jewish reader in Persian-period Judah, this short verse said that Simeon still counted. The tribe had no territory of its own and no independent history. Its people had blended into Judah, as the Chronicler himself admits (4:27, 31). Yet it is given a heading, five named clans and a family line that continues.

The names were not invented. They match the old census list in Numbers 26, so they tie the present community to the wilderness generation and to Jacob's household that went down to Egypt (Genesis 46). Leaving out Genesis' remark that Shaul was "the son of a Canaanite woman" puts the stress on legitimate membership rather than on mixed origins. That fits the concerns of a community defining itself after the exile, though the Chronicler may simply have been copying the shorter Numbers list.

The verse also prepares for what follows. These clans are the people who held the southern towns (verses 28–33), who grew unevenly (verse 27), and who later pushed out to new pasture (verses 38–43). Through them the Chronicler's picture of a complete Israel stays intact.

From the study of 1 Chronicles 4:24.

Verse by verse

  1. 23These were the potters who lived at Netaim and Gederah. They lived there in the service of the king.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 24The descendants of Simeon: Nemuel, Jamin, Jarib, Zerah, and Shaul.

    "These are the clans that sprang from Simeon, Jacob's son: Nemuel, Jamin, Jarib, Zerah and Shaul."

    The verse is a heading and a roll-call. "The sons of Simeon" names the five founding fathers of the five clans that made up the tribe of Simeon. The names mostly look back to Numbers 26:12–13, the census of the clans taken in the wilderness, rather than to the older list in Genesis 46:10. From Numbers come the spelling Nemuel (Genesis has Jemuel) and Zerah (Genesis has Zohar). The list also leaves out Ohad, who appears in Genesis and Exodus but founded no clan. And it drops Genesis' note that Shaul was "the son of a Canaanite woman." Jarib in third place is a variant of the Jachin found in all the earlier lists.

    The names carry meanings a Hebrew hearer would have caught: Simeon, "heard"; Jamin, which sounds like "right hand", a word that also means "south"; Jarib, "he contends"; Zerah, "dawning"; Shaul, "asked for." The point of the verse, though, is belonging. A tribe that had long since disappeared into Judah is given its own heading, its own named clans and a line that runs on (through Shaul, verse 25). So it is counted again among the sons of Israel.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v24

    sons of (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    bənê

    What we hear
    A private family record: one man and his five boys.
    What they heard
    The founding heads of a tribe's recognised clans. These men are treated as Simeon's own sons, but the list functions as a register of the kin groups that made up the tribe (compare Numbers 26:12–14, where every name becomes '-ites').
Every word
  1. בְּנֵ֖י

    bənê · H1121

    sons of, descendants of · v24

    Opens the list as a heading: 'Simeon's sons are these.' In a tribal genealogy the word names the founding heads of the clans that made up the tribe. They are presented as Simeon's literal sons (as in Genesis 46), but what matters to the list is that each became a clan.

  2. שִׁמְע֑וֹן

    shimʿôn · H8095

    Simeon · v24

    Jacob's second son by Leah, and the tribe named after him. Genesis 29:33 explains the name from shamaʿ, 'to hear': 'the LORD has heard that I am unloved.' Here it means both the ancestor and the tribe he stands for.

  3. נְמוּאֵ֣ל

    nəmûʾēl · H5241

    Nemuel · v24

    The first clan head. Genesis 46:10 and Exodus 6:15 spell the name Jemuel (יְמוּאֵל); Numbers 26:12 has Nemuel, as here. The ending -el means 'God', but what the first part means is uncertain.

  4. וְיָמִ֔ין

    wəyāmîn · H3226

    and Jamin · v24

    The second clan head. The name is the same in every list. It sounds like the common word yamin, 'right hand', which in Hebrew also means 'south' (you face east to take your bearings). That fits a tribe living in the far south, though no source makes this point explicitly.

  5. יָרִ֖יב

    yārîb · H3402

    Jarib · v24

    The third clan head. Genesis 46:10, Exodus 6:15 and Numbers 26:12 have Jachin (יָכִין) here. The name probably means 'he contends' or 'he pleads a case' (from riv). Most likely it is the same clan under a variant or miscopied name.

  6. זֶ֥רַח

    zeraḥ · H2226

    Zerah · v24

    The fourth clan head. Numbers 26:13 also has Zerah; Genesis 46:10 and Exodus 6:15 have Zohar (צֹחַר). Zerah means 'dawning' or 'shining'. The same name belongs to a son of Judah and to an Edomite clan, both neighbours of Simeon in the south.

  7. שָׁאֽוּל׃

    shāʾûl · H7586

    Shaul · v24

    The fifth clan head. The name means 'asked for' and is the same as King Saul's. Genesis 46:10 and Exodus 6:15 add that he was 'the son of a Canaanite woman'; Chronicles leaves this out. His line continues in verse 25 and leads to Shimei, through whom the list carries on.

The world behind it

Where this list sits. 1 Chronicles 1–9 traces "all Israel" from Adam to the community that returned from exile. Judah gets the most space (2:3–4:23), and Simeon comes straight after (4:24–43). The order follows the land: Joshua 19:1–9 gives Simeon's towns from inside Judah's territory, and the Chronicler's town list in 4:28–33 closely parallels that passage.

A tribe that disappeared. Simeon barely appears in Israel's later history. Genesis 49:7 foresees it being scattered. Deuteronomy 33 leaves it out of Moses' blessing. Chronicles itself says the Simeonites "did not multiply like the sons of Judah" (4:27), and that their towns were theirs only "until David reigned" (4:31). It does record later raids into Gedor and against the Amalekites at Mount Seir in Hezekiah's day (4:38–43).

The first readers. Chronicles was written for Jews in the small Persian province of Yehud (Judah), probably in the 4th century BC. For them genealogies were not trivia. They established who belonged, which family claims were legitimate, and the continuity between the restored community and the twelve-tribe Israel of old. Putting the long-lost Simeon in the list makes a claim: Israel is still all twelve tribes, even when some survive only as names inside Judah.

From the study of 1 Chronicles 4:24.

Where scholars differ

in v24

Why do the lists of Simeon's sons differ (Jemuel/Nemuel, Jachin/Jarib, Zohar/Zerah)?

  • Copying errors: scribes mistook similar-looking letters at some stage of transmission.

    י/נ were easily confused in some scripts. Parts of יכין and יריב look alike, as do parts of צחר and זרח. Ancient versions sometimes bring the names into line with each other, which suggests scribes noticed the problem.

  • Genuine variant forms: the clans were known by alternate names in different traditions or periods.

    Numbers 26 already differs from Genesis 46. Clan names could change over time, and similar variation shows up throughout the genealogies of Chronicles. The Chronicler seems to have deliberately followed the Numbers list.

in v24

Why does Chronicles omit 'son of a Canaanite woman' after Shaul?

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.