1 Samuel Chapter 3 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 3:11–18
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
11Then the LORD said to Samuel, “I am about to do something in Israel at which the ears of all who hear it will tingle. 12On that day I will carry out against Eli everything I have spoken about his house, from beginning to end. 13I told him that I would judge his house forever for the iniquity of which he knows, because his sons blasphemed God and he did not restrain them. 14Therefore I have sworn to the house of Eli, ‘The iniquity of Eli’s house shall never be atoned for by sacrifice or offering.’” 15Samuel lay down until the morning; then he opened the doors of the house of the LORD. He was afraid to tell Eli the vision, 16but Eli called to him and said, “Samuel, my son.” “Here I am,” answered Samuel. 17“What was the message He gave you?” Eli asked. “Do not hide it from me. May God punish you, and ever so severely, if you hide from me anything He said to you.” 18So Samuel told him everything and did not hide a thing from him. “He is the LORD,” replied Eli. “Let Him do what is good in His eyes.”
What the first hearers heard
For Israelites hearing this story, the verse did several things:
- It vindicated God's justice at his own sanctuary. The corrupt priests at Shiloh were not protected by having the ark or holding office. God himself announces that he will act against his own house and his own priests.
- It marked a turning point in leadership. The word of the LORD passes from the old priestly line to Samuel, who will be prophet, priest-figure and judge, and who will later anoint Israel's first kings. The account explains why Eli's house fell and why Samuel's authority was legitimate.
- It taught that God's word is effective. What God says, he does. The rare word returns as an event the whole nation will hear about.
- It became a stock phrase for disaster on the sanctuary. Later generations, facing Jerusalem's fall, heard the same words again (2 Kings 21:12; Jeremiah 19:3), and Jeremiah explicitly pointed to Shiloh as a warning: “Go now to my place at Shiloh… and see what I did to it” (Jer 7:12). The ears that rang at Shiloh were meant to ring again for Jerusalem, as a warning that a holy place gives no immunity to a people who corrupt it.
From the study of 1 Samuel 3:11.
Verse by verse
-
11Then the LORD said to Samuel, “I am about to do something in Israel at which the ears of all who hear it will tingle.
Full study →The LORD said to Samuel: “Look, I myself am on the point of acting. I am about to do a thing in Israel, and my word is about to become an event. Everyone who hears the news of it will have both ears ringing, as if they had been struck.”
The verse is spoken at night in the sanctuary at Shiloh, to a boy who has just said, “Speak, for your servant is listening.” The answer turns his own word around: Samuel is the one hearing, and soon everyone who hears will reel. “I” is emphatic. God is not reporting a disaster that will happen to Israel; he is announcing what he himself will do. The Hebrew construction (“look” plus an “-ing” verb) means imminent. Chapter 4 brings the defeat, the capture of the ark, and the deaths of Eli and his sons.
“Tingle” should not be heard as excitement. The Hebrew verb is related to the word for cymbals and describes ringing and shuddering: the stunned buzzing in the head after terrible news. Later prophets used this exact phrase for the fall of Jerusalem itself. The word “thing” (davar) also means “word,” in a chapter about how the word of the LORD, long rare, has come back. When it returns, it comes as an act.
-
12On that day I will carry out against Eli everything I have spoken about his house, from beginning to end.
Full study →On that fixed day, the day I do the thing that makes the ears of everyone who hears it tingle, I will make my word stand up as fact against Eli. I mean every word I have already spoken about his house: his priestly family line, the one that expected to serve before me forever. I am not giving a new sentence. I am confirming the one I already pronounced through the man of God, and none of it will fall to the ground. I will start it and I will see it through to the finish, from the first blow to the last, until I have made an end of it.
The verse closes with two bare verbs, "beginning… and finishing." The pair names both ends to mean "completely," and the second verb also carries a sense of "bringing to an end." God's judgment on this house has a starting point, the day of the disaster in chapter 4, and it will not stop until the whole spoken word has become history.
-
13I told him that I would judge his house forever for the iniquity of which he knows, because his sons blasphemed God and he did not restrain them.
Full study →"And now I am declaring to him that I am about to sit in judgment on his house, his whole priestly line, and the sentence will be permanent. The reason is a guilt he knew all about: his sons were treating God with contempt, making light of the One they served at his own altar. And Eli, whose eyes had grown dim, never brought his authority down on them to stop them."
The Hebrew packs in more than English can easily carry:
- "I am about to judge" is a present-tense participle. The verdict is imminent and already set in motion.
- "His house" is a dynasty of priests, not a building.
- "Forever" answers the "forever" once promised to that house (2:30). It reverses the earlier promise.
- "He knew" removes any plea of ignorance. Eli had heard everything (2:22–24).
- The sons' sin is the verb "to make light", the opposite of the Hebrew word for honour, which comes from "to be heavy". They made God weightless, so God makes them weightless.
- Scribal tradition says the original read "cursing God" and that it was softened to "cursing for themselves".
- The last verb, "restrain", comes from the same root as Eli's dim eyes in 3:2. The man who could no longer see never damped down his sons' sin.
-
14Therefore I have sworn to the house of Eli, ‘The iniquity of Eli’s house shall never be atoned for by sacrifice or offering.’”
Full study →"And so, because of all this, I have bound myself by oath to Eli's family line: may I never be trusted again if the guilt hanging over Eli's house is ever wiped away. Not by slaughtering an animal, not by bringing a grain offering, not by any sacrifice the altar has. Never, as far ahead as time can be seen."
The verse is God's own words, given to the boy Samuel in the night. It closes the sentence against the priestly family at Shiloh. Three things give it its force:
- It is an oath. Hebrew oaths often hide a self-curse ("if it is atoned..." implying "...may I be cursed"). The plain meaning is an absolute never. A sworn word from God is not a warning that might still be withdrawn.
- The cure is shut off. Eli's family were the priests whose job was to atone, to wipe guilt clean for others through animal and grain offerings. Those are exactly the offerings God says will not work for them. They had treated those offerings with contempt (2:17, 2:29), and now those offerings cannot cover their own guilt. The word for "guilt/iniquity" includes the deed, the guilt it leaves, and the penalty already on its way.
- "Forever" reverses "forever". God had once said this family would serve before him "forever" (2:30). Now the "forever" belongs to the judgment. It is about the family's history and its hold on the priesthood, as the rest of the story shows (1 Sam 4; 22; 1 Kgs 2:27), not about the afterlife.
-
15Samuel lay down until the morning; then he opened the doors of the house of the LORD. He was afraid to tell Eli the vision,
Full study →Samuel lay where he was, in the sanctuary near the ark, for the rest of the night. Hebrew does not say he slept, and after what he had heard he likely did not. When daylight came he did his ordinary job as the sanctuary boy and swung open the doors of the house of YHWH at Shiloh, as he did every morning. The routine stands in sharp contrast with what he now carried inside him. During the night God had broken a long silence: "the word of the LORD was rare in those days; visions were not widespread" (v. 1). What Samuel received was a real prophetic "vision", even though it came mostly as words. It was a terrible message: God had sworn that the guilt of Eli's house would never be wiped clean by any sacrifice. Samuel was afraid, with a plain human dread, to tell it, to put that message in front of Eli. Eli was the old priest who had raised him and would call him "my son" in the next breath. The doors of God's house open, but the boy's mouth stays shut, until Eli presses him and Samuel "told him everything" (v. 18).
-
16but Eli called to him and said, “Samuel, my son.” “Here I am,” answered Samuel.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
17“What was the message He gave you?” Eli asked. “Do not hide it from me. May God punish you, and ever so severely, if you hide from me anything He said to you.”
Full study →Eli said: “What is the word he spoke to you? Please, don’t keep it back from me. May God do this to you, and more besides, if you keep back from me a single word out of everything he spoke to you.”
The old priest starts gently, with a soft please, and then puts the boy under one of the heaviest oaths in the Hebrew language. “Thus may God do to you, and thus may he add” was the standard Israelite curse: the speaker hints at some terrible fate without naming it, and the words “and more besides” leave no ceiling. People normally swore it against themselves to guarantee their own promises. Eli turns it on Samuel, apparently the only time the Bible records this. The effect is to take away the boy’s option of keeping quiet. He was afraid to tell (v. 15). Now he must tell everything, or bring the curse on himself.
The verse rings with the word dabar, “word”: “the word he spoke… not a word out of all the word he spoke.” This is a chapter about the rare “word of the LORD” (3:1) returning to Israel, and Eli, the man that word condemns, insists that not a syllable of it be softened or held back. He never names the LORD; he says only “he spoke to you.” The phrasing quietly admits that God now speaks to the boy, not to the priest.
-
18So Samuel told him everything and did not hide a thing from him. “He is the LORD,” replied Eli. “Let Him do what is good in His eyes.”
Full study →So Samuel laid the whole message out before Eli, every word of it, and kept nothing back. He did exactly what Eli's oath had required, though the words were a sentence of doom on Eli's own family. Eli answered in two short phrases: "He is the LORD" (or "It is the LORD"). He was saying both that this word truly came from YHWH and that YHWH has every right to give it. Then: "What is right in His own judgment, that is what He will do. Let Him do it."
There is no protest, no bargaining and no prayer for the sentence to be lifted. The Hebrew can be read as a calm statement ("He will do what He sees fit") or as a surrender ("Let Him do it"), and probably holds both. The word "good" here does not mean the disaster is pleasant or good for Eli. It means what God judges fitting.
The verse has two halves. First the boy speaks the whole truth to his master, his first act as a prophet. Then the old priest admits that the decision is not his.
Where the English drifted
-
in v11
tingle
tsalal
- What we hear
- A light prickly sensation, often pleasant: thrill, excitement, anticipation (“tingling with excitement”).
- What they heard
- To ring, reverberate, quiver, like a struck cymbal. It is the ringing, stunned shudder after hearing news of catastrophe. Every use of the idiom in the Hebrew Bible concerns disaster on God's own people.
-
in v12
house
bayit
- What we hear
- A building, or at most the people currently living in Eli's household.
- What they heard
- A family line across generations, here a priestly line holding a hereditary office at the sanctuary.
-
in v12
perform (KJV, WEB)
’āqîm (hiphil of qûm)
- What we hear
- To put on a performance, or simply to do an action.
- What they heard
- To make a spoken word stand, so that it comes true: to fulfil or carry out what was said.
-
in v13
forever
ad olam
- What we hear
- Eternal, possibly eternal punishment beyond this life.
- What they heard
- Permanently, with no end in view, across the generations of a family line. Here it means the irreversible loss of the house's priestly standing and its fortunes in this world.
-
in v13
made themselves vile (KJV)
meqallelim lahem
- What we hear
- The sons became morally disgusting, as a matter of personal corruption.
- What they heard
- They treated something holy, most likely God himself (see textual notes), as light and contemptible. This is the opposite of giving honour, and they did it through what they did with the sacrifices.
-
in v14
atoned for
kipper (yitkappēr)
- What we hear
- Personal reconciliation with God, usually thought of through Christ's death; being forgiven in the heart.
- What they heard
- A ritual removal of guilt carried out by priests at the altar: wiping it clean, covering it, or ransoming it. Here the claim is that the normal ritual remedy will not be available for this family's guilt.
-
in v14
for ever / never
ʿad-ʿôlām
- What we hear
- Endless eternity, often assumed to mean eternal punishment after death.
- What they heard
- For all time to come in the history of this family line, permanently, with no end in view. It mirrors and cancels the 'forever' priesthood promised in 2:30.
-
in v14
offering
minḥāh
- What we hear
- Money given in church, or any gift to God in general.
- What they heard
- A tribute gift, and at the altar especially the grain offering. Paired with zevaḥ (animal sacrifice) it means 'every kind of sacrifice'.
-
in v15
shew / show Eli the vision (KJV, WEB)
haggid
- What we hear
- To display something, to let Eli see it.
- What they heard
- To tell, report or announce. To put a message in front of someone in words.
-
in v15
vision
mar'ah
- What we hear
- A picture or scene seen in the mind's eye.
-
in v17
God do so to thee, and more also (KJV; similar in ESV, NASB, WEB)
koh ya'aseh lekha Elohim vekhoh yosif
- What we hear
- A vague or puzzling phrase. 'So' seems to point back to something mentioned earlier, and many readers do not realise it is a curse at all.
- What they heard
- A recognised, solemn curse: 'May God strike you with [unnamed disaster], and worse still.' Here it is aimed at Samuel to force full disclosure.
-
in v17
What is the thing… all the things (KJV, WEB)
davar
- What we hear
- An object, or some unspecified matter.
- What they heard
- The spoken word or message, meaning the revelation itself. It repeats the chapter's theme of the 'word of the LORD'.
-
in v18
what seemeth him good / what seems good to him
hattov be'enav
- What we hear
- What looks good to God, or what turns out well. Often taken to mean that the outcome itself is good, or good for the person accepting it.
- What they heard
- What God, in His own judgment, decides is fitting. The idiom names whose verdict counts, not whether the result is pleasant. Eli is not calling the destruction of his house good. He is yielding to God's judgment.
Every word
-
וַיֹּ֤אמֶר
vayyomer · H0559
and he said · v11, v17, v18
The ordinary storytelling verb that moves the scene along. After the vision of verse 10, where the LORD “came and stood,” what Samuel now gets is speech, not a sight.
-
יְהוָה֙
YHWH · H3068
Yahweh, the LORD · v11, v15, v18
Israel's God, named by his own personal name. In a chapter that opens by saying “the word of the LORD was rare in those days” (3:1), the point is that this God has started speaking again.
-
אֶל־
el- · H0413
to, toward · v11, v12, v15, v17
The speech is aimed at Samuel personally. It does not go to Eli, the priest, who would normally be the one to receive God's word.
-
שְׁמוּאֵ֔ל
Shemu'el · H8050
Samuel · v11, v15, v18
The boy who has just said “Speak, for your servant is listening.” His name sounds like the Hebrew for “hear” (shama), and hearing is what this verse is all about.
-
הִנֵּ֧ה
hinneh · H2009
look! behold! · v11
A word that grabs the hearer's attention. Paired with the participle that follows, it signals that something is about to happen, not something far off.
-
אָנֹכִ֛י
anokhi · H0595
I · v11
Hebrew does not need a separate pronoun here, so including it adds weight: I myself am the one acting. The coming disaster will not be bad luck or the Philistines acting alone.
-
עֹשֶׂ֥ה
'oseh · H6213
doing, making · v11, v17, v18
An active participle, an “-ing” form describing action under way. After “look!”, it means “I am on the point of doing.” The deed is about to happen.
-
דָבָ֖ר
davar · H1697
-
בְּיִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל
be-Yisra'el · H3478
in Israel · v11
The event's reach is national. It is aimed at Eli's house (v. 12), but the whole people will feel it: in chapter 4 the army is defeated and the ark of God is captured.
-
אֲשֶׁר֙
asher · H0834
which, that · v11, v12, v13, v17
Links the “thing” to its effect on those who hear about it: “a thing of which…”
-
כָּל־
kol- · H3605
all, every · v11, v12, v17, v18
“Every single one.” Nobody who hears the news will be unaffected by it.
-
שֹׁ֣מְע֔וֹ
shom'o · H8085
hearing it · v11
“The one hearing it,” singular with “it” attached. It picks up Samuel's own word in v. 10, “your servant is hearing (shomea).” Samuel hears first, and soon everyone will hear.
-
תְּצִלֶּ֖ינָה
tetsillenah · H6750
tingle, quiver, ring · v11
“They will ring/quiver.” The verb is feminine plural to agree with “ears.” It describes the ringing, shuddering effect of hearing shocking, terrible news, like the reverberation of a struck cymbal.
-
שְׁתֵּ֥י
shtei · H8147
two · v11
“The two of” his ears, meaning both. It stresses how complete the shock is: not one ear but both, the whole person jolted.
-
אָזְנָֽיו׃
ozenav · H0241
his ears · v11
In Hebrew the ear is the organ of hearing and also of taking things in and responding. Here it is the place the blow lands. The news itself hits like a physical shock.
-
בַּיּוֹם
bayyôm · H3117
day · v12
"On the day." Here it points to a particular, fixed moment when the judgment will break out. It is not a vague "someday".
-
הַהוּא
hahû’ · H1931
he, that · v12, v18
"That" (literally "the that"). It ties the day to v. 11: the day God does the thing that makes ears tingle. In ch. 4 this turns out to be the disaster at Aphek.
-
אָקִים
’āqîm · H6965
rise; (causative) raise, establish, fulfil · v12
"I will make stand." This is the usual Hebrew way of saying a spoken word comes true. God will make his earlier word get up and stand as fact. The form looks forward to an act still to come.
-
עֵלִי
‘ēlî · H5941
Eli · v12, v14, v15
The old priest of Shiloh who has raised Samuel. Even though the word concerns his "house," the verse names him personally, because he is its head and the one responsible.
-
אֵת
’ēt · H853
[marks the direct object] · v12, v13, v15, v18
Not translated. It marks what follows ("all that I have spoken") as the thing God will make stand.
-
דִּבַּרְתִּי
dibbartî · H1696
speak · v12, v17
"I have spoken." The form looks back to a completed act. It refers to the oracle God already gave through the unnamed "man of God" in 2:27–36. Samuel's vision brings no new sentence. It confirms that one.
-
בֵּיתוֹ
bêtô · H1004
house; household; family line · v12, v13, v14, v15
"His house." This means Eli's priestly family line across generations, not a building or just the people living with him. Compare 2:30–31: "your house and your father's house… there will not be an old man in your house."
-
הָחֵל
hāḥēl · H2490
(causative) begin · v12
"Beginning." The verb is in a bare, unconjugated form (the infinitive absolute) and works like an adverb. It is the first half of a pair that covers the whole process. The same root letters (ḥ-l-l) also give the Hebrew words for "profane" and for "far be it" (2:30), but those are usually treated as separate words.
-
וְכַלֵּה׃
wəkallēh · H3615
finish, complete; bring to an end, destroy · v12
"And finishing." Another bare infinitive. The verb means to carry something through to completion, and in contexts of judgment it shades into "make an end of" or "destroy." Together with "beginning" it means "completely, start to finish."
-
וְהִגַּ֣דְתִּי
vehiggadti · H5046
to tell, declare, make known · v13, v15, v18
'And I declare / I will make known.' The verb means bringing something into plain view, making it public. Here it is a formal announcement of a verdict. This form usually looks forward ('and I will tell him'), which fits God now sending the message through Samuel. It can also be read as 'I have told him', looking back to the prophet of 2:27–36.
-
ל֔וֹ
lo · H9033
to him · v13, v18
To Eli. The verdict is addressed to the head of the house, who is responsible for it.
-
כִּֽי־
ki · H3588A
that · v13
Introduces what is being announced: the content of the verdict.
-
שֹׁפֵ֥ט
shofet · H8199
to judge · v13
A participle, 'judging', which here means 'I am about to judge.' The action is imminent and already under way. To judge in Hebrew means to act as ruler and judge who sets things right. Here that means passing sentence and carrying it out on Eli's house.
-
אֲנִ֛י
ani · H0589
I · v13
An emphatic 'I'. God himself is the judge. No human court is involved.
-
עַד־
ad · H5704
until, as far as · v13, v14, v15
Combines with olam to make the set phrase 'in perpetuity'.
-
עוֹלָ֑ם
olam · H5769G
long duration, perpetuity · v13, v14
'Lastingly', with no end in view. The sentence on the family line is permanent. This answers the 'forever' promised to Eli's ancestors in 2:30.
-
בַּעֲוֹ֣ן
ba'avon · H5771G
iniquity, guilt, its punishment · v13, v14
'Because of the iniquity.' The Hebrew word covers the crooked act, the guilt it creates, and the punishment that guilt brings, all at once. The prefix gives the reason for the verdict.
-
יָדַ֗ע
yada · H3045
to know · v13
'He knew.' Eli was not unaware. He had heard the reports and spoken to his sons about them (2:22–25). His guilt lies in knowing and failing to act.
-
מְקַֽלְלִ֤ים
meqallelim · H7043
to treat as light, despise, curse · v13
'Making light of / cursing.' The root means 'be light', the opposite of 'heavy', which in Hebrew is the root of 'honour'. The sons treated what was holy as weightless. The participle shows this was their ongoing habit.
-
לָהֶם֙
lahem · H9038
to/for themselves · v13
As the Hebrew stands, 'for themselves', which is awkward. Ancient scribal tradition says the original was 'God' (elohim). The two words differ by only two letters, and the change was made so the text would not have to say 'cursing God'.
-
בָּנָ֔יו
banav · H1121A
-
וְלֹ֥א
velo · H3808
and not · v13, v18
Negates the next verb. This is the heart of the charge against Eli himself.
-
כִהָ֖ה
khihah · H3543B
to restrain, rebuke (lit. make dim/faint) · v13
This root normally means 'grow dim, grow faint'. In this intensive form it means to damp someone down, to check or restrain them. It is a pointed wordplay: Eli's eyes had 'grown dim' (3:2, same root), yet he never 'dimmed' his sons.
-
וְלָכֵ֥ן
və-lākhēn · H3651C
and therefore · v14
'And' + 'to' + 'so', together meaning 'and therefore'. In prophetic speech this word often marks the turn from the charge to the sentence: the case has been laid out (v.13), and now the verdict follows.
-
נִשְׁבַּ֖עְתִּי
nishbaʿtî · H7650
I have sworn · v14
God puts himself under oath. The completed verb form can mean 'I swore' (pointing back to the oracle of 2:27–36) or work as a declaration, 'I hereby swear'. Either way, a divine oath makes the sentence final.
-
אִֽם־
ʾim · H0518I
if · v14, v17
In an oath, a bare 'if' carries an unspoken curse: '[May such-and-such happen to me] if X happens.' So 'if it will be atoned' means 'it will certainly not be atoned'. English versions rightly turn it into a strong negative.
-
יִתְכַּפֵּ֞ר
yitkappēr · H3722A
be atoned for / wiped clean · v14
A rare reflexive-passive form of kipper (here only in this form): 'be covered, wiped away, ransomed'. It is the technical word for what priestly sacrifice does to remove guilt. Here it is denied.
-
בְּזֶ֥בַח
bə-zevaḥ · H2077
by sacrifice · v14
An animal slaughtered as a sacrifice, mostly eaten in a shared meal. This was the very kind of offering the sons had been abusing by taking the meat before God's portion was burned (2:13–17).
-
וּבְמִנְחָ֖ה
û-və-minḥāh · H4503G
and by offering / grain offering · v14
A gift or tribute. In priestly language it is especially the grain offering. Paired with zevach, it means 'animal or grain offering', so any sacrifice at all. The same pair appears in God's charge in 2:29.
-
וַיִּשְׁכַּ֤ב
vayyishkav · H7901
lie down · v15
"And he lay." Samuel goes back to his sleeping place in the sanctuary (v. 3) and stays there. The Hebrew does not say whether he slept. After what he has just heard, the plain sense is that he simply lay there until dawn.
-
הַבֹּ֔קֶר
habboqer · H1242
morning · v15
Daybreak. It closes the night scene that began while "the lamp of God had not yet gone out" (v. 3). The night of revelation gives way to the day of duty.
-
וַיִּפְתַּ֖ח
vayyiftach · H6605
open · v15
"And he opened." This was one of Samuel's normal jobs as a sanctuary attendant. He does his routine work as if nothing had happened.
-
דַּלְת֣וֹת
daltot · H1817
doors · v15
Doors, usually swinging double doors or door-leaves. They suggest a fixed structure with real doorways at Shiloh, not only tent curtains (compare the "doorpost" in 1:9).
-
יָרֵ֔א
yare' · H3372
be afraid · v15
"Was afraid." This is ordinary fear or dread, not worshipful awe. Samuel shrinks from a frightening social and emotional task: delivering a sentence of doom to the old priest who raised him.
-
הַמַּרְאָ֖ה
hammar'ah · H4759
-
מָ֤ה
mah · H4100
what? · v17
A direct, urgent question. Eli already suspects what the message is about (compare 2:27–36).
-
אַל־
al · H0408
do not · v17
The negative used with a wish or request ('don't…'). It is softer than the flat prohibition lo'.
-
נָ֥א
na · H4994
please, I pray · v17
A softening particle. The first request is gentle and almost pleading, which makes the curse that follows all the sharper.
-
תְכַחֵ֖ד
tekhakhed · H3582
hide, conceal · v17, v18
Here it means to keep back information, to withhold. Samuel was afraid to tell the vision (v. 15), and Eli names that fear exactly.
-
מִמֶּ֑נִּי
mimmenni · H4480
from me · v17, v18
'From me': Eli presses that the message concerns him and is his to hear.
-
כֹּ֣ה
koh · H3541
thus, so · v17
The first word of a fixed curse formula. 'Thus' points to some unnamed harm, possibly acted out by a gesture, which is left unspoken.
-
לְּךָ֤
lekha
to you · v17
This is the striking word. Elsewhere the formula almost always says 'to me': speakers curse themselves to back up their own promise. Eli turns it on Samuel.
-
אֱלֹהִים֙
Elohim · H0430
God · v17
The general word for God, which is standard in this oath formula. The verb with it is singular, so it means the one God of Israel.
-
יוֹסִ֔יף
yosif · H3254
may he add · v17
'And may he add more': the curse has no fixed limit. KJV's 'and more also' comes from this word.
-
הַטּ֥וֹב
hattov · H2896
the good · v18
"The good" here is one half of an idiom, "the good in his eyes": what He judges fitting, what He decides. It is not a claim that the coming disaster is pleasant or good for Eli.
-
בְּעֵינָ֖יו
be'enav · H5869
in his eyes · v18
"In his eyes" means by His own judgment. The standard of what is good is God's view, not Eli's.
The world behind it
- Shiloh and its priesthood. Before the Jerusalem temple, the ark of the covenant stood in a sanctuary at Shiloh, in the hill country of Ephraim, served by Eli and his sons Hophni and Phinehas. The sons took the best of the sacrificial meat by force before the fat had been offered to God, and they slept with the women who served at the sanctuary entrance (2:12–17, 22). Their misconduct was against God and against the worshippers who brought offerings.
- An earlier warning. An unnamed “man of God” had already told Eli that his family would lose its priestly standing and that his two sons would die on the same day (2:27–36). Verse 11 confirms that this judgment is now about to fall. Verse 12 says so explicitly: “from beginning to end.”
- A silent heaven. The chapter opens by saying that “the word of the LORD was rare in those days; visions were not widespread” (3:1). In the ancient Near East, a god's silence suggested he had withdrawn his favor. That the god speaks again is good news, but what he says is terrible.
- A child as recipient. Normally the priest received and passed on divine messages. Here God bypasses the old priest and speaks to a boy apprentice, and the message is about the priest. That reversal is itself part of the judgment.
- What happened. In chapter 4 Israel is defeated by the Philistines at Aphek, the ark is captured, Hophni and Phinehas are killed, Eli falls and dies when he hears the news, and his daughter-in-law names her newborn Ichabod, “Where is the glory?”. Eli's own death is literally caused by hearing the report. Later texts remember that Shiloh itself was destroyed (Psalm 78:60; Jeremiah 7:12–14; 26:6).
From the study of 1 Samuel 3:11.
Where scholars differ
in v11
What exactly is the “thing” that will make ears ring?
-
The disaster of 1 Samuel 4: the defeat at Aphek, capture of the ark, and deaths of Hophni, Phinehas and Eli.
Verse 12 ties the oracle to Eli's house. Chapter 4 fulfills 2:34 (both sons die on one day). The news itself kills Eli when he *hears* it (4:18), which fits “everyone who hears it” closely.
-
It also includes the destruction of the Shiloh sanctuary and the later decline of Eli's priestly line.
Psalm 78:60–64 and Jeremiah 7:12–14 remember God abandoning and ruining Shiloh. The longer outworking of 2:30–36 extends to Abiathar's removal (1 Kings 2:27). Samuel never narrates Shiloh's destruction, and the archaeological evidence for a destruction around the 11th century BC is debated among excavators.
in v12
Does "on that day … beginning and finishing" mean the whole judgment falls at once, or that it begins on one day and is carried through over time?
-
All at once: the pair means "thoroughly, completely," and the judgment falls fully on the single day of Aphek.
"On that day" points to one moment. Ch. 4 compresses the disaster into one day: the ark is captured, both sons die (fulfilling the sign of 2:34), Eli dies, and Ichabod is born. Pairs like this usually express totality rather than sequence.
-
Over time: judgment begins on that day and continues until the whole oracle is fulfilled.
The oracle of 2:31–36 covers generations: no old men in the house, descendants begging for priestly work, a faithful priest replacing them. v. 13 says "forever." The narrative records later stages at Nob (ch. 22) and in Abiathar's expulsion, which 1 Kgs 2:27 explicitly calls the fulfilment of "the word … concerning the house of Eli." The Septuagint and Vulgate ("I will begin and I will complete") also suggest a process.
in v13
What did the sons 'curse' or treat with contempt: themselves or God?
-
Original reading 'God' (elohim). The scribes softened it to 'lahem'.
The Septuagint has 'God'. Rabbinic lists of scribal corrections include this verse. The letters are close (אלהים / להם). Exodus 22:28 forbids cursing God, and the Hebrew as it stands is grammatically awkward.
-
Keep the Masoretic 'for themselves' (they brought a curse or contempt on themselves).
It is the received Hebrew text. Some argue the scribal-correction lists are later reflection rather than evidence of an actual change, and that the reflexive sense ('making themselves contemptible') echoes 2:30, 'they shall be lightly esteemed'.
in v13
Is God's 'telling' past (via the man of God) or present (via Samuel)?
-
Present or future: 'I am declaring / will declare to him' through Samuel.
The Hebrew verb form normally continues the future sense of verse 12, and Samuel does tell Eli the next morning (3:18).
-
Past: 'I have told him', referring to 2:27–36.
Eli had already heard the same verdict from the man of God, and verse 12 refers to 'all that I have spoken' about his house.
in v14
Does 'I have sworn' look back to an earlier oath or announce the oath now?
-
It looks back. God refers to the judgment already sworn through the man of God in 2:27–36, and Samuel's vision confirms it.
The verb is in the completed form. 3:12 says God will carry out 'all that I have spoken concerning his house', which points back to an earlier word.
-
It announces the oath now ('I hereby swear'), with the oath taken in the act of speaking.
Hebrew often uses the completed form for oaths and declarations spoken in the moment. 2:27–36 contains no explicit oath formula, but 3:14 does.
in v14
Is the guilt absolutely unforgivable, or only beyond the reach of sacrifice?
-
The sentence on the family is fixed. Nothing will reverse the judgment of deaths and loss of the priesthood.
A divine oath, the word 'forever', and the story's own record of fulfilment (1 Sam 4; 22; 1 Kgs 2:27). Eli accepts it as final (3:18).
-
The verse limits only the ritual remedy. Sacrifice cannot cancel it, but this says nothing about God's mercy toward individuals by other means.
The wording specifies 'by sacrifice and by offering'. Rabbinic tradition (b. Rosh HaShanah 18a) read it this way. The verse is about the family's earthly fate, not about anyone's eternal destiny.
in v14
What is the basic picture behind kipper?
-
'Cover' over the sin so that it is no longer seen.
Arabic kafara 'to cover'. The word kappōret, the lid of the ark.
-
'Wipe off, purge.'
Akkadian kuppuru, a word used for ritual wiping and cleansing. Leviticus pairs kipper with 'cleanse' (Lev 16:19, 30).
-
'Ransom': pay off the penalty.
The related noun kōfer means 'ransom price' (Exod 21:30; 30:12). Some scholars argue that the purging and ransom ideas overlap.
in v15
Was the Shiloh sanctuary a tent or a permanent building?
-
A permanent structure (or a building complex) stood at Shiloh.
1 Sam 1:9 speaks of the "doorpost of the temple (heikal) of YHWH". This verse mentions "doors", and Samuel sleeps "in the temple" (3:3). It is called "house of YHWH" (1:7, 24), and Jer 7:12 speaks of God's "place" at Shiloh.
-
The sanctuary was the tent (tabernacle) tradition.
Josh 18:1 sets up the tent of meeting at Shiloh. Ps 78:60 calls it "the tent he had pitched among men". 2 Sam 7:6 has God say he never lived in a house but moved about in a tent. 1 Sam 2:22 mentions the "tent of meeting", but that clause is missing from the Septuagint and a Dead Sea Scrolls copy of Samuel, so it may be a later addition.
-
A combination: a tent shrine inside a compound with buildings, doors and gates.
This would explain both kinds of language. Archaeological work at Shiloh shows occupation in this period but has not clearly identified the sanctuary itself.
in v15
What exactly was Samuel afraid of?
-
Eli's reaction: anger or punishment from his superior.
The social gap between a boy attendant and the chief priest. Eli's strong demand in v. 17 ("May God do so to you, and more") shows how charged the moment was.
-
Grieving the man who raised him.
Eli's affectionate "Samuel, my son" (v. 16). The message announces the end of Eli's family line.
-
Dread at the message itself and at his new role.
This was his first revelation (v. 7: he "did not yet know YHWH"). The content was an irrevocable oath of judgment (v. 14). The narrator gives no reason, which leaves all of these possible.
in v17
Why does Eli put Samuel under a curse?
-
Coercion: Eli uses his priestly authority to force out a message he dreads. This shows his anxiety and his need to control the situation.
The curse is turned on the addressee rather than the speaker, which is unparalleled. It moves sharply from 'please' to a curse. Eli has already heard one oracle of doom (2:27–36) and suspects the rest.
-
Release: the oath frees Samuel from the impossible social position of a youth giving bad news to his master. Silence now carries the heavier penalty, so speaking becomes obedience rather than insolence.
V. 15 says Samuel 'was afraid to tell'. V. 18 shows the oath worked completely. Eli then accepts the verdict with submission rather than anger.
in v17
What does the unnamed 'thus' (koh) refer to?
-
An accompanying gesture or ritual act, such as cutting up an animal, that showed what fate the oath-breaker would suffer.
Jer 34:18–20; 1 Sam 11:7; the 8th-century BC Aramaic Sefire treaty curses, where a symbolic act shows what will happen to the violator.
-
A deliberate euphemism: the disaster is left unnamed so that it is not spoken aloud. By the time of these narratives the phrase had become a fixed verbal formula with no gesture.
The formula appears in quick dialogue, often in messages sent by others (1 Kgs 19:2; 20:10), where no ritual is possible. No text describes a gesture accompanying it.
in v18
Is Eli's reply humble submission or passive resignation?
-
Humble, even admirable, acceptance of just judgment. This is Eli's best moment.
He uses the same words as David in 2 Sam 15:26 ("let him do to me as is good in his eyes"), which the narrator clearly presents favourably. He accepts the word from a boy without anger, and he confesses "He is YHWH." The sentence has been declared beyond atonement (3:14), so pleading would be pointless.
-
Resigned passivity that matches his failure to restrain his sons.
Eli does not repent, intercede, or remove his sons, even after two warnings (2:27–36; 3:11–14). 3:13 blames him precisely because he "did not restrain them". Some compare Hezekiah's complacent "the word… is good" in 2 Kgs 20:19. Moses in Exod 32 shows that intercession after a pronounced judgment was an option. Commentators such as McCarter and Alter note the ambiguity.
-
Deliberately ambiguous: both at once.
The narrator gives no comment. Eli's words are pious, and his record is weak. Many modern commentators (e.g. Tsumura, Gordon) read the restraint as intentional, presenting a tragic figure rather than a simple saint or villain.
in v18
Does "YHWH hu'" mean "It is the LORD" or "He is the LORD"?
-
"It is the LORD": Eli confirms the oracle's source.
Context: the question in v. 17 was whether Samuel had truly received a word, and v. 18 confirms it, preparing for v. 20 where Samuel is recognised as a prophet. Followed by KJV, ESV and NASB.
-
"He is the LORD": Eli affirms God's sovereign right to judge.
Similar clauses elsewhere are confessions of who God is (1 Kgs 18:39; Ps 100:3), and the next clause is about God's freedom to act. Followed by BSB and NIV.
Sources
- BDB s.v. צָלַל I
- HALOT s.v. צלל I
- BDB s.v. דָּבָר
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §116p, participle with הִנֵּה for imminent future
- Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew §121e
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 3:11
- Vulgate, 1 Samuel 3:11
- BDB s.v. קוּם (hiphil: 'carry out, fulfil a word')
- HALOT s.v. קום hif.; s.v. חלל III hif. 'begin'; s.v. כלה pi.
- BDB s.v. בַּיִת ('household, family, descendants')
- Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley (GKC) §113 on the infinitive absolute
- Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax, on the adverbial infinitive absolute
- Septuagint 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 3:12 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate 1 Samuel (1 Regum) 3:12
- BDB s.v. קָלַל; כָּהָה; עוֹלָם; עָוֺן
- HALOT s.v. כהה (piel 'to rebuke, restrain'), קלל
- Septuagint 1 Kingdoms 3:13 (κακολογοῦντες θεόν)
- Vulgate 1 Samuel 3:13
- Masoretic lists of tiqqune soferim (emendations of the scribes)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 3:13
- Emanuel Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, on scribal corrections
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 2–3
- BDB s.v. כָּפַר, עָוֺן, עוֹלָם, מִנְחָה
- HALOT s.v. כפר, עָוֺן, עוֹלָם
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §149 on oath formulas with אִם
- Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew §165 (oaths)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 2:27–3:14
- Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on kipper
- Emanuel Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, on tiqqunê sopherim (1 Sam 3:13)
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 3:13–14
- Babylonian Talmud, Rosh HaShanah 18a; Yevamot 105a
- BDB s.v. מַרְאָה, נָגַד, יָרֵא
- HALOT s.v. מַרְאָה (vision; mirror), נגד hiphil
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Kingdoms 3:15
- Vulgate, 1 Samuel 3:15
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 5.348 (Samuel's age)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 3:15
- Robert Alter, The David Story, on 1 Sam 3
- BDB s.v. כָּחַד, דָּבָר, כֹּה
- HALOT s.v. כחד (Piel 'hide, conceal'; Niphal/Hiphil 'be effaced / annihilate')
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8), notes on 3:17
- Yael Ziegler, Promises to Keep: The Oath in Biblical Narrative (VTSup 120)
- Sefire treaty inscriptions (KAI 222), curse rituals
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) 1 Reigns 3:17; Vulgate 1 Samuel 3:17
- BDB s.v. נָגַד, כָּחַד, דָּבָר, טוֹב
- HALOT s.v. כחד (piel 'hide'; niphal/hiphil 'be effaced, efface')
- David Toshio Tsumura, The First Book of Samuel (NICOT)
- Robert Alter, The David Story
- Robert P. Gordon, I & II Samuel: A Commentary
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) 1 Reigns 3:18; Vulgate 1 Samuel 3:18
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.