1 Samuel Chapter 2 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 2:12–17
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
12Now the sons of Eli were wicked men; they had no regard for the LORD 13or for the custom of the priests with the people. When any man offered a sacrifice, the servant of the priest would come with a three-pronged meat fork while the meat was boiling 14and plunge it into the pan or kettle or cauldron or cooking pot. And the priest would claim for himself whatever the meat fork brought up. This is how they treated all the Israelites who came to Shiloh. 15Even before the fat was burned, the servant of the priest would come and say to the man who was sacrificing, “Give the priest some meat to roast, because he will not accept boiled meat from you, but only raw.” 16And if any man said to him, “The fat must be burned first; then you may take whatever you want,” the servant would reply, “No, you must give it to me right now. If you refuse, I will take it by force!” 17Thus the sin of these young men was severe in the sight of the LORD, for they were treating the LORD’s offering with contempt.
What the first hearers heard
Israelites hearing this would have been shocked by it. Priests were supposed to be the guardians of the "knowledge of God" (compare Hos 4:6; Mal 2:7). Here the narrator says plainly that the priests of YHWH's own house did not acknowledge YHWH. Calling them benei beliyya'al put them alongside the worst figures in Israel's memory, like the men of Gibeah and those who led people to other gods.
The verse also does work in the larger story. It explains why the priesthood of Eli's family will be cut off (2:27–36), why the ark is lost (ch. 4), and why leadership passes to Samuel, a boy brought in from outside the priestly line by his mother's vow. The lesson for a people moving toward kingship and a new order of leaders is that birth into the right family guarantees nothing. What matters is acknowledging YHWH, and that shows in how sacred things and ordinary people are treated.
From the study of 1 Samuel 2:12.
Verse by verse
-
12Now the sons of Eli were wicked men; they had no regard for the LORD
Full study →"Now Eli's sons were sons of worthlessness: good-for-nothing, destructive men. They did not acknowledge YHWH as their Lord."
The Hebrew uses "sons" twice, and the repetition stings. Hophni and Phinehas are sons of Eli, priests by birth at Israel's central sanctuary. In character they are sons of beliyya'al. That is one of the harshest labels in Hebrew narrative. It is used for the men of Gibeah, for rebels, for perjurers and for Nabal the boor: men who are useless and actively ruinous, and who trample sacred and social bonds. Here it is not the name of a demon. That sense came centuries later.
"They did not know YHWH" does not mean they lacked information. They served at his altar every day. It means they refused to recognize him as the Lord whose house, sacrifices and people they managed. The next verses spell this out as greed at the altar and contempt for God's portion.
The verse lands straight after "the boy [Samuel] was serving YHWH" (v. 11). The faithful outsider-child and the corrupt priestly heirs are placed side by side. There is also an echo of Hannah, whom Eli wrongly took for a "daughter of beliyya'al" (1:16).
-
13or for the custom of the priests with the people. When any man offered a sacrifice, the servant of the priest would come with a three-pronged meat fork while the meat was boiling
Full study →"And this was the priests' 'rightful due' in their dealings with the people: whenever anyone was slaughtering an animal for a sacrificial feast, the priest's young attendant would come along while the family's meat was simmering in the pot, holding the big three-pronged altar fork in his hand…" (the sentence runs on into v. 14: he would jab it into the pot, and whatever the fork brought up, the priest took for himself).
What the English can miss:
- "Custom" is a loaded word in Hebrew. Mishpat normally means justice, a verdict, or a lawful entitlement. Deuteronomy 18:3 uses almost the same phrase, "the priests' due from the people", to fix exactly which cuts the priests were owed. Here the priests have their own mishpat, a "rule" they made up. The narrator is being ironic: their "right" is a shakedown.
- The "sacrifice" is a feast. A zevach was a festive meal. God received the fat, the priest a set portion, and the family ate the rest together at the sanctuary, as Elkanah's household does in chapter 1. The priests are reaching into the worshipers' own dinner pots.
- Every time, from everyone. The verb forms describe a repeated habit ("would come"), and "every man" means no one was exempt. It was a system.
- "Servant" is na'ar, the same word used for the boy Samuel. While one young man "ministered to the LORD" (2:11, 18), the priest's young man went round the cooking pots with a fork.
- The fork replaces the law. The law gave the priests fixed portions. The fork turned their share into a lucky dip of unknown size, and verse 15 shows it getting worse still.
-
14and plunge it into the pan or kettle or cauldron or cooking pot. And the priest would claim for himself whatever the meat fork brought up. This is how they treated all the Israelites who came to Shiloh.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
15Even before the fat was burned, the servant of the priest would come and say to the man who was sacrificing, “Give the priest some meat to roast, because he will not accept boiled meat from you, but only raw.”
Full study →And it got worse. The priests' fork was already raiding the family cooking pots (vv. 13–14). Now, even before the fat had been sent up in smoke on the altar (the rich portion that belonged to the LORD alone, and had to be offered first), the priest's young attendant would come, time after time, to the ordinary Israelite slaughtering his own animal for the family's festival meal. He would not ask. He would order: "Hand over meat for the priest to roast! He won't take boiled meat from you, only raw."
Every detail reverses the proper order. God's portion should go first, then the priest's portion as set by the Law, then the family feast. Instead the priest's appetite comes before God. He takes the worshipper's meat, not his own allotted share. And he wants it raw, so he can pick the cut and roast it, the richer way to eat, rather than accept the boiled meat everyone else ate. The verb forms show this was not a one-off. It was how things were done at Shiloh. The Hebrew word for "servant" (naʿar, "lad") is the same word used for the boy Samuel, so the reader sees two young men serving at the same sanctuary: one serving the LORD, the other serving his masters' stomachs.
-
16And if any man said to him, “The fat must be burned first; then you may take whatever you want,” the servant would reply, “No, you must give it to me right now. If you refuse, I will take it by force!”
Full study →Whenever the worshiper objected, saying to the priest's servant, "They really must send the fat up in smoke first, the LORD's portion, as the rule requires. Then take for yourself whatever and however much your appetite craves," the servant had a stock reply: "No! You'll hand it over now. And if you don't, I'll take it by force. Consider it already taken."
The exchange turns on two words. The worshiper says "first", God's portion before anyone eats. The servant says "now", the priest's appetite before God. The worshiper is generous: he does not haggle over the priest's share and even invites him to take as much as he wants. His only request is that the fat, the choicest part, which the Law reserved wholly for the LORD, goes up on the altar before the meat is shared out. The verb "take" is used twice. In the worshiper's mouth it is a permission ("take for yourself"). In the servant's mouth it becomes a seizure ("I will take it by force"). "By force" is the phrase the Bible uses for oppressors crushing Israel and for bad shepherds ruling the flock harshly. At God's own sanctuary, the priestly household is acting like a conqueror toward the people it was meant to serve. That is why the next verse calls the young men's sin "very great before the LORD": they treated the LORD's offering with contempt.
-
17Thus the sin of these young men was severe in the sight of the LORD, for they were treating the LORD’s offering with contempt.
Full study →And so the offense of the lads became very great, right there before the face of Yahweh, because these men were treating Yahweh's gift with contempt.
The verse is the narrator's verdict on the scene just described (vv. 13–16). At Shiloh, ordinary Israelites came to offer communal sacrifices, which ended in a shared meal. The fat was God's portion and had to be burned on the altar first. Only after that did the priest take his share and the family eat. Eli's sons, Hophni and Phinehas, sent their attendant with a three-pronged fork to grab meat out of the cooking pots. Worse, he demanded raw meat for roasting before the fat had even been burned, and threatened to take it by force.
The "lads" (ne'arim) are the priest's sons together with the servants who did their snatching. The word can mean "boys" or "attendants". Applied to grown, officiating priests it cuts them down to size. It also sets up the next verse, where another "lad", Samuel, ministers faithfully "before the face of Yahweh."
"Sin" here is the same word as the "sin offering" these priests were meant to handle for Israel. The men who were supposed to deal with the people's offense had become the offense.
The verb for "treating with contempt" is a strong one. Elsewhere it is used for Israel spurning God himself. What they despised was the minchah of Yahweh: the gift or tribute owed to the divine King, his portion of the sacrifice. To seize it before the King had received it was a public insult to him, done in his own house and at his own table. The narrator measures the result as "very great", setting up Eli's warning in v. 25 that when someone sins against Yahweh himself, no one can intercede for them.
Where the English drifted
-
in v12
sons of Belial (KJV)
benei beliyyaʿal
- What we hear
- Children or followers of a demon called Belial, or Satan.
- What they heard
- An idiom for 'worthless, ruinous men': people marked by lawless, destructive contempt for God and community. Not a personal name in Samuel.
-
in v12
they knew not the LORD / did not know the LORD
loʾ yadeʿu ʾet-YHWH
- What we hear
- They lacked knowledge about God, or in devotional terms, had no personal conversion experience.
- What they heard
- They did not acknowledge YHWH's authority or honor him as the covenant Lord. They refused allegiance, and it showed in what they did at his altar.
-
in v13
sacrifice
zevaḥ
- What we hear
- Giving something up at a cost; or an animal killed and burned on an altar, often for sin.
- What they heard
- A slaughter-offering that was mainly a festive sacred meal. God received the fat and blood, the priest a fixed cut, and the worshiper's family ate the rest together at the sanctuary.
-
in v13
custom
mishpaṭ
- What we hear
- A neutral, traditional way of doing things, perhaps harmless habit.
- What they heard
- The word for justice, a verdict, or a lawful entitlement. Here it means the priests' 'practice', but it echoes the law's 'priests' due' (Deut 18:3), so it is ironic: the priests' self-made 'right' that replaced the right the law gave them.
-
in v13
servant
na'ar
- What we hear
- A household employee of any age, with no link to other characters.
- What they heard
- A young man or attendant. The same word is used for Samuel throughout chapters 1–3, inviting direct comparison between the priest's 'young man' and the LORD's 'young man'.
-
in v15
the fat
ḥelev
- What we hear
- Waste trimmed off the meat and burned to get rid of it.
- What they heard
- The choicest, richest part of the animal, reserved entirely for God and offered first as a pleasing aroma.
-
in v15
burned (the fat)
hiqṭir
- What we hear
- Destroyed, disposed of in a fire.
-
in v15
sodden flesh (KJV)
basar mevushshal
- What we hear
- Soggy, waterlogged meat.
- What they heard
- Boiled meat, the normal way sacrificial meat was cooked. In early modern English 'sodden' was the past participle of 'seethe', meaning 'to boil'.
-
in v16
as thy soul desireth (KJV); as much as your soul desires (WEB)
ka'asher te'avveh nafshekha
- What we hear
- Whatever your spirit or inner self longs for, as though a spiritual desire were meant.
- What they heard
- Whatever your appetite craves. Nefesh here is the hungry throat, the wanting self, and the verb 'avah is the ordinary word for craving food, especially meat.
-
in v16
presently (KJV)
kayyom
- What we hear
- Soon, in a little while.
- What they heard
- First, at once, before anything else. In 1611 English "presently" meant "immediately".
-
in v17
offering
minchah
- What we hear
- A voluntary donation, like a church collection, or, to readers of Leviticus, specifically the grain offering.
- What they heard
- Tribute or a gift owed to a superior. Here it is YHWH's portion of the sacrifices, especially the fat that was his by right and had to be given to him first.
-
in v17
young men
ne'arim
- What we hear
- Youths whose sin came from immaturity or youthful foolishness.
- What they heard
- 'Lads' in the sense of attendants or retainers as well as young males. Here it most likely covers the priest's servants (vv. 13, 15) and Eli's adult sons, who held office. It is about role and responsibility more than age, and it carries a demeaning edge.
-
in v17
abhorred (KJV)
ni'atsu
- What we hear
- Felt intense disgust toward, a feeling. With KJV's 'men', readers often take it to mean the worshipers came to loathe the sacrifices.
- What they heard
- Actively treated with contempt, spurned or insulted. It is conduct, not emotion, and the same verb is used for spurning YHWH himself.
Every word
-
וּבְנֵ֥י
uvenei · H1121
-
עֵלִ֖י
ʿEli · H5941
Eli · v12
The aged high priest at Shiloh. Calling them 'sons of Eli' points to their family line and inherited priesthood. That inheritance is exactly what the next phrase undercuts.
-
בְלִיָּ֑עַל
veliyyaʿal · H1100
worthlessness, ruinous wickedness · v12
Not a proper name here. It is a strong word for men who are good for nothing and do active harm: lawless, destructive, contemptuous of what is sacred and of social bonds. In Hebrew narrative it is one of the harshest labels you can give someone.
-
לֹ֥א
loʾ · H3808
not · v12, v15, v16
A flat negation of the verb that follows.
-
יָדְע֖וּ
yadeʿu · H3045
they knew · v12
'Know' here means to acknowledge, recognize and honor someone's claim on you, not to have information. These priests knew plenty about YHWH and his rituals. What they did not do was treat him as the Lord whose sacrifices and people they served. The verb form describes a settled condition, not a lapse.
-
אֶת־
ʾet- · H853
[direct object marker] · v12, v15, v17
Untranslatable marker showing that YHWH is the direct object of 'know.'
-
יְהוָֽה׃
YHWH · H3068
Yahweh, the LORD · v12, v17
Israel's covenant God, using his personal name. These are the priests of his own sanctuary, so the irony is sharp: the men who serve at YHWH's house do not acknowledge YHWH.
-
וּמִשְׁפַּ֥ט
ū-mishpaṭ · H4941
and the custom / due / judgment of · v13
Usually 'judgment, justice, legal right'. Here it means the established practice, the 'way things were done', of the priests. It is the same word Deuteronomy 18:3 uses for the priests' legally fixed share of a sacrifice, so it carries an ironic edge: their 'rightful due' has become a racket.
-
הַכֹּהֲנִ֖ים
ha-kōhănîm · H3548
-
אֶת־
'et · H0854
with · v13, v17
'With', meaning 'in their dealings with'. The Greek translation and Deuteronomy 18:3 have 'from' instead, so the phrase may originally have read 'the priests' due from the people' (see textual notes).
-
הָעָ֑ם
hā-'ām · H5971
the people · v13
The ordinary Israelite worshipers who came to Shiloh (v. 14: 'all Israel who came there'), as distinct from the priestly household.
-
כָּל־
kol · H3605
all, every · v13
'Every': no worshiper was exempt. The point is that the practice was systematic, not an occasional lapse.
-
אִ֞ישׁ
'îsh · H0376
man, person · v13, v15, v16
'Anyone'. Paired with 'every', it means any worshiper. In practice this was usually the head of a family offering on its behalf, like Elkanah in 1:3–4.
-
זֹבֵ֣חַ
zōvēaḥ · H2076
sacrificing, slaughtering · v13, v15
A participle that describes ongoing, repeated action: whenever anyone was offering a slaughter-sacrifice. The verb means slaughtering an animal for a sacred meal.
-
זֶ֗בַח
zevaḥ · H2077
sacrifice (slaughter-offering) · v13
The kind of sacrifice whose meat the worshipers ate in a festive meal at the sanctuary, after the fat was burned for God and the priest received his set portion. This was not a burnt offering that went up in smoke entirely.
-
וּבָ֨א
ū-vā' · H0935
and he would come · v13, v15
The verb form describes a habit in the past: 'would come', every time. It pictures the servant walking into the family's meal uninvited.
-
נַ֤עַר
na'ar · H5288
-
כְּבַשֵּׁ֣ל
kə-vashshēl · H1310
as / when boiling · v13, v15
'While (the meat) was being boiled'. Sacrificial meat was normally boiled in pots for the meal. The servant comes when the family's portion is already cooking.
-
הַבָּשָׂ֔ר
ha-bāśār · H1320
the flesh, meat · v13, v15
The meat of the sacrificed animal, which was now the worshipers' share for their feast.
-
וְהַמַּזְלֵ֛ג
və-ha-mazlēg · H4207
-
שְׁלֹ֥שׁ־
shəlōsh · H7969
three · v13
'Three': the detail fixes the shape of the tool, a trident-like fork.
-
הַשִּׁנַּ֖יִם
ha-shinnayim · H8127
the teeth, prongs · v13
Literally 'teeth'. Hebrew uses 'tooth' for the prong of a fork, as English does for the teeth of a comb or rake.
-
בְּיָדֽוֹ׃
bə-yādô · H3027
in his hand · v13
'In his hand': he arrives with the tool ready. The sentence carries straight on into verse 14, where he plunges it into the pot.
-
גַּם
gam · H1571
also, even · v15
Marks escalation. Verses 13–14 have already described the priests' fork grabbing meat from the cooking pots; gam says 'and worse still'.
-
בְּטֶרֶם
beṭerem · H2962
before, not yet · v15
'Before' is the key to the offence. The demand came before God's portion had been offered, so the order of the sacrifice was turned upside down.
-
יַקְטִרוּן
yaqṭirun · H6999A
make smoke, burn as an offering · v15, v16
The verb for turning an offering into smoke that rises to God, not for burning rubbish. The extra -un ending and the ongoing verb form describe something that kept happening: 'before they would turn the fat to smoke.' The subject is indefinite ('they'), meaning the officiants.
-
הַחֵלֶב
haḥelev · H2459
fat · v15, v16
The fat around the entrails, kidneys and liver, which the Law reserved wholly for YHWH (Lev 3:16, 'all fat is the LORD's'). It was the choicest part, the first thing owed to God.
-
וְאָמַר
veʾamar · H0559
and he said · v15, v16
Also habitual: 'and would say'. This was his standing demand.
-
תְּנָה
tenah · H5414G
give! · v15, v16
A command with a lengthened ending that adds insistence. It is blunt and gives no reason.
-
לִצְלוֹת
litslot · H6740
to roast · v15
To roast over a fire. In this world that was the more luxurious way to eat meat, compared with stewing it in a pot.
-
יִקַּח
yiqqaḥ · H3947H
take, accept · v15, v16
'He will not take.' The priest dictates terms. The same verb comes back in verse 16 as a threat: 'I will take it by force.'
-
מִמְּךָ
mimmekha · H4480A
from you · v15
Directed personally at the worshipper. It is his family meal being raided.
-
כִּי
ki · H3588B
but, rather · v15, v16, v17
Together with the next word it forms 'but only', which sets up a strong exception.
-
אִם־
ʾim- · H0518B
except · v15, v16
Completes the exception: 'nothing but…'.
-
חָי
ḥay · H2416A
living; raw · v15
Literally 'living'. Applied to meat it means raw and uncooked (compare 'raw flesh', basar ḥay, in Lev 13:10). The priest wants the meat before anyone else has done anything to it.
-
אֵלָ֜יו
elav · H0413
to him · v16
To the priest's servant (the na'ar of v. 15), who has come to collect the meat.
-
כַּיּוֹם֙
kayyom · H3117L
as the day / first · v16
An idiom meaning "first, right away, before anything else". Compare Jacob's "sell me first (kayyom) your birthright" (Gen 25:31). The worshiper is not refusing the priest. He is insisting on the right order.
-
לְךָ֔
lekha · H9031
for yourself · v16
"For yourself": the worshiper accepts that the priest has a rightful share.
-
כַּאֲשֶׁ֥ר
ka'asher · H0834D
just as · v16
"However much" or "in whatever way". This is a generous concession that leaves the amount up to the priest.
-
תְּאַוֶּ֖ה
te'avveh · H0183
to crave, desire · v16
To long for or crave, often for food (Num 11:4; Deut 12:20, "when your appetite craves meat"). The wording is a little pointed: the priest is free to satisfy his craving, but only after God has been given his part.
-
נַפְשֶׁ֑ךָ
nafshekha · H5315I
your appetite / throat / self · v16
Here nefesh means appetite: the hungry throat, the person as someone who wants. It does not mean an immaterial soul. "As much as your appetite wants".
-
עַתָּ֣ה
attah · H6258
now · v16
"Now", meaning before the fat is burned. It answers the worshiper's "first" (kayyom) head-on: the priest's appetite comes before God's portion.
-
בְחָזְקָֽה׃
veḥozqah · H2394
-
וַתְּהִ֨י
vattehi · H1961
and it was / and it became · v17
The narrative 'and so it was' form that moves the story forward. It sums up the scene of vv. 13–16 and gives the narrator's verdict on it: this is what it all came to.
-
חַטַּ֧את
chattat · H2403
sin, offense; also sin offering · v17
The offense of the lads. It is the same word used for the 'sin offering' that priests handled, so men whose job was to deal with Israel's chattat have become the chattat at the sanctuary.
-
גְּדוֹלָ֥ה
gedolah · H1419
great, large · v17
'Great' as a measure of seriousness: the offense was heavy and large in scale.
-
מְאֹ֖ד
me'od · H3966
very, exceedingly · v17
An intensifier: 'very great', the strongest normal way to say this in Hebrew prose.
-
פְּנֵ֣י
penei · H6440
face, presence · v17
'The face of' YHWH: the sin was done in his presence, at his own sanctuary where worshipers came to 'appear before his face'. The same phrase comes back in v. 18 for Samuel.
-
נִֽאֲצוּ֙
ni'atsu · H5006
they spurned, treated with contempt · v17
An intensive verb form: they actively treated something with contempt, disrespected it, and in effect insulted it. Elsewhere this verb is used for Israel spurning YHWH himself (Num 14:11).
-
הָֽאֲנָשִׁ֔ים
ha-anashim · H582
the men · v17
'The men' are most likely the same priests and attendants, now called grown 'men', not 'lads', and so fully accountable. A minority reading takes them as the worshipers who were put off by the abuse.
-
מִנְחַ֥ת
minchat · H4503
gift, tribute, offering · v17
Here it is not the technical grain offering of Leviticus 2. It is the gift or tribute brought to YHWH in general, above all the fat that belonged to him and was to be burned before anyone else took a share.
The world behind it
- Shiloh, late in the judges period (about 11th century BC). Shiloh housed the ark and was Israel's main sanctuary before Jerusalem. Eli was the old priest there, and his sons Hophni and Phinehas did the hands-on priestly work (1:3).
- How priests were fed. Priests had no farmland and lived on set portions of the offerings: in the Torah, the breast and right thigh of fellowship offerings (Lev 7:31–34), or shoulder, jaws and stomach (Deut 18:3). All the fat belonged to YHWH and had to be burned first (Lev 3:16; 7:23–25). Verses 13–17 show Eli's sons breaking both rules: they took whatever the fork brought up, and they demanded raw meat by force before the fat was burned. Verse 22 adds that they slept with the women serving at the tent entrance.
- How the story is built. Chapters 2–3 switch back and forth between Samuel growing up before YHWH (2:11, 18–21, 26; 3:1) and the corruption of Eli's house (2:12–17, 22–25). This verse is the headline for the corruption. The judgment announced in 2:27–36 comes true in chapter 4: both sons die in battle and the ark is captured.
From the study of 1 Samuel 2:12.
Where scholars differ
in v12
Where does the word beliyya'al come from?
-
From beli ('without') + ya'al ('profit, worth'): 'worthlessness, good-for-nothing.'
The simplest analysis. It matches the Septuagint's descriptive translations and the word's use for useless, harmful people. Most standard lexicons (BDB, HALOT) favor it or list it first.
-
From beli + a root meaning 'go up': '(place of) no return,' an old name for the underworld. Or from bala' ('swallow'): 'the Swallower.'
Ps 18:4–5 puts 'torrents of beliyya'al' in parallel with death and Sheol. Proposed by scholars such as Cross & Freedman and D. W. Thomas. If right, the word suggests deadly, chaotic forces.
in v12
Does 'they did not know' also govern the start of v. 13?
-
Yes: 'they did not know YHWH, nor the priests' due from the people.'
Deut 18:3 uses the same phrase, mishpat ha-kohanim, for the priests' lawful portion 'from the people.' So the sons ignored both God and the legal limits of their share. The BSB follows this.
-
No: v. 13 begins a new sentence describing the custom the priests actually practiced.
The Masoretic accents end the thought at v. 12. Verses 13–16 describe a practice ('the custom of the priests was…'). The ESV and others follow this.
in v13
Does 'the mishpat of the priests with the people' belong with verse 12 or start a new sentence?
-
It starts a new sentence describing the abusive practice: 'The practice of the priests with the people was this…' (KJV, ESV, NIV, WEB).
The Masoretic verse division and accents. On this reading the abuse itself is ironically called the priests' 'mishpat'.
-
It is a second object of 'they did not know' in v. 12: 'they knew neither the LORD nor the priests' due from the people' (Vulgate, NRSV, BSB, NASB; many critical commentators).
The Vulgate's construction. The parallel with Deut 18:3, read as the lawful due the sons ignored. The Septuagint's 'from'. And verse 13 otherwise begins rather abruptly.
in v13
Was the fork method in verses 13–14 already wrongdoing, or a tolerated local custom that verses 15–16 then abuse?
-
Verses 13–14 already describe abuse. The arbitrary fork replaced the fixed portions the law laid down, and it is listed among the sons' sins.
The surrounding verses frame it as evidence that they 'did not know the LORD' (v. 12). It ignores the set cuts of Lev 7:31–34 and Deut 18:3, and v. 14 ends 'this is how they treated all Israel.'
-
Verses 13–14 may record an older Shiloh practice of letting chance decide the priest's share. The real offence is the escalation in v. 15–16: taking raw meat before the fat was burned, by force.
Verse 15 opens with 'even before' (gam bəṭerem), which marks escalation. The two Torah codes themselves differ on which cuts the priest got, suggesting local variation. Verse 17 focuses on contempt for 'the LORD's offering', which fits the burning of the fat best.
in v15
Was the fork custom of vv. 13–14 already wrong, or does the real offence start in v. 15?
-
Verses 13–14 describe a local Shiloh custom that was tolerable or even legitimate, and v. 15 is where the sons go over the line.
Verse 13 calls it 'the custom (mishpaṭ) of the priests with the people', a neutral-sounding phrase. The fork-in-the-pot method left the priest's share to chance, and the meat was taken after it had been offered. Verse 15 opens with gam, 'even/moreover', which suggests a new and worse step.
-
Verses 13–14 are already an abuse, and v. 15 makes it worse.
Verse 12 says the sons 'did not know the LORD'. The fork method ignores the specific portions set in Lev 7:31–34 and Deut 18:3, and the Septuagint reads v. 12–13 as 'they did not know the LORD, nor the priest's due from the people', framing the whole practice as a breach. Verse 14 ends with 'this is how they treated all Israel', a critical summary.
in v15
Why did the priest insist on raw meat?
-
Taste and luxury: roasting was the finer way to cook meat.
Boiling was the normal method at the sanctuary (v. 14; Ezek 46:20–24). Roasting was associated with special meals (Exod 12:8–9) and kept the meat richer. Verse 16 says 'whatever your appetite (nefesh) desires'.
-
Control and quantity: raw meat let the priest pick prime cuts, and possibly take more than he could eat or keep it for later.
Raw meat can be selected and carried away, whereas the fork took whatever came up. This is a reasonable inference, but the text does not say so explicitly.
in v16
Was the servant's answer "No!" (written text) or "he said to him" (marginal reading)?
-
Read "No" (לֹא): a blunt refusal.
It is the consonantal text. The Septuagint reads "No". "No, but rather (ki) now" is a natural Hebrew construction. Most modern critical commentators (e.g. McCarter) and translations follow it.
-
Read "to him" (לוֹ): "he would say to him, 'Indeed, you will give now.'"
It is the Masoretic marginal reading. Hebrew often writes "say to him" before a quotation, the confusion of לא and לו happens elsewhere (e.g. Exod 21:8; 1 Sam 20:2), and it matches "said to him" at the start of the verse.
in v16
Was the fork custom of vv. 13–14 already a sin, or only the demand before the fat was burned (vv. 15–16)?
-
Both stages are abuses, and v. 16 is the climax.
V. 13 calls it "the custom (mishpat) of the priests with the people", an ironic use of a word that usually means justice. A random fork-grab replaces the fixed portions of Lev 7:31–34. "Also" (gam) in v. 15 marks an escalation.
-
The fork custom may have been a legitimate local Shiloh practice, and the sin lies in seizing before the fat was burned and using force.
The Torah's portion laws differ between Leviticus and Deuteronomy, which suggests local variation. The worshiper in v. 16 objects only to the timing, not to the priest taking a share.
in v17
Who are 'the lads' (ne'arim) whose sin was great?
-
Eli's sons, Hophni and Phinehas, called 'lads' in a belittling way.
Verse 12 makes the sons the subject of the whole section. Verses 22–25 and 29 hold them and Eli's house responsible. Most English versions (e.g., BSB 'these young men') read it this way.
-
The priests' servants, the 'na'ar of the priest' of vv. 13 and 15.
The same word was just used twice for the servant with the fork who did the actual seizing. The plural would naturally take up that figure.
-
Both: the whole operation, with the servants as agents and the sons responsible.
The servant acts on the priest's authority ('give meat for the priest', v. 15). Later verdicts (2:29; 3:13) blame Eli's house for what was done in its name.
in v17
Who 'treated with contempt' the offering: the priests' party or the worshipers?
-
The priests and their servants spurned YHWH's offering (most modern versions).
The intensive form of na'ats normally means actively treating with contempt. 'The men' with the article most naturally points back to the culprits just described. The clause explains why their sin was so great.
-
The worshipers ('men' in general) came to despise or loathe sacrificing because of the abuse (KJV; Latin tradition).
'The men' is a new noun after 'the lads', which could signal a different group. In 2 Sam 12:14 the same intensive form may mean 'cause to be scorned'. Verse 24 speaks of the sons making YHWH's people transgress.
Sources
- BDB s.v. בְּלִיַּעַל
- HALOT s.v. בְּלִיַּעַל
- HALOT s.v. יָדַע
- H. B. Huffmon, 'The Treaty Background of Hebrew Yāda',' BASOR 181 (1966)
- F. M. Cross & D. N. Freedman on Ps 18 (beliyya'al and the underworld)
- D. Winton Thomas, 'בְּלִיַּעַל in the Old Testament' (1963)
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 2:12
- Vulgate, 1 Samuel 2:12
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, 1 Sam 2
- BDB s.v. מִשְׁפָּט, זֶבַח, נַעַר, מַזְלֵג, בָּשַׁל
- HALOT s.v. מִשְׁפָּט; מַזְלֵג
- Deuteronomy 18:3; Leviticus 3:16; 7:11–36; Exodus 27:3; Ezekiel 46:20–24
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 2:12–17
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary), on 2:12–17
- Septuagint 1 Kingdoms 2:13; Vulgate 1 Samuel 2:12–13
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 2:13–16
- BDB and HALOT s.v. חֵלֶב, קטר, נַעַר, חַי, בָּשַׁל, צָלָה
- Leviticus 3; 7:22–34; Deuteronomy 18:3; Ezekiel 46:20–24; Exodus 12:8–9
- Septuagint 1 Kingdoms 2:15 (Brenton translation)
- Vulgate 1 Samuel 2:15
- P. Kyle McCarter, I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
- David Toshio Tsumura, The First Book of Samuel (NICOT)
- Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on the fat portions
- Oxford English Dictionary s.v. 'sodden' (past participle of 'seethe')
- BDB and HALOT s.v. קָטַר (hiphil), חֵלֶב, חׇזְקָה, נֶפֶשׁ, אָוָה
- Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley, Hebrew Grammar §47m (paragogic nun), §113 (infinitive absolute), §106n (perfect of certainty)
- Septuagint, 1 Reigns 2:16
- Leviticus 3; 7:23–34; Deuteronomy 18:3; Judges 4:3; Ezekiel 34:4; Genesis 25:31
- BDB s.v. נאץ, נַעַר, מִנְחָה, חַטָּאת
- HALOT s.v. נאץ; s.v. נַעַר; s.v. מִנְחָה
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8)
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
- S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel
- John MacDonald, 'The Status and Role of the Na'ar in Israelite Society', JNES 35 (1976)
- Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible) on chattat and the fat portions
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Kingdoms 2:17
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 2:12–17
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.