1 Timothy Chapter 5 Read as one passage
1 Timothy 5:19–20
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
19Do not entertain an accusation against an elder, except on the testimony of two or three witnesses. 20But those who persist in sin should be rebuked in front of everyone, so that the others will stand in fear of sin.
What the first hearers heard
For Timothy, and for the Ephesian congregation listening as the letter was read aloud, the verse set a clear and familiar rule.
- Fairness grounded in Scripture. "Two or three witnesses" came straight from Deuteronomy, a rule they already accepted as the way God's people judge justly. Leaders were not to be held to a lower standard of proof than anyone else.
- Protection for those who serve. Elders who taught and led were exposed. Opponents, people they had disciplined, rival teachers and gossips could all bring charges. Timothy, as Paul's delegate, was not to be moved by a single complaint, however loud.
- Not immunity. Verse 20 follows immediately: those who are shown to be persisting in sin are to be rebuked publicly, "so that the rest may stand in fear". Verse 21 adds a solemn charge to act "without prejudging, doing nothing from partiality". The first hearers would have heard one even-handed process. Charges need corroboration, and proven charges are dealt with openly.
- Stability in a troubled church. At a time of false teaching, keeping faithful leaders safe from unsupported attacks while dealing openly with leaders who had gone wrong helped preserve both the church's teaching and its reputation with outsiders (compare 3:7).
From the study of 1 Timothy 5:19.
Verse by verse
-
19Do not entertain an accusation against an elder, except on the testimony of two or three witnesses.
Full study →"When someone brings a charge against one of the church's recognised elders, do not accept it as established or act on it on one person's word. It has to be backed by more than one witness, the 'two or three' the law of Moses requires."
The order of the Greek puts the weight on who is accused: "Against an elder…". These are the leaders just described in verses 17–18, men who "rule well", who labour in preaching and teaching, and who deserve "double honour" and fair pay. Because they are visible and influential, and in Ephesus some were in conflict with false teachers, they are easy targets for grudges, gossip and rivalry.
The command is present tense, so it sets a standing policy rather than reacting to one case. The verb means "accept, admit as valid". Timothy is not told to refuse to hear concerns. He is told not to treat a charge as proven or take action on it without corroboration.
"Two or three witnesses" is not a number Paul made up. It is the familiar formula of Deuteronomy 19:15: "a matter shall be established on the testimony of two or three witnesses." Any Jewish hearer would recognise it as the Torah's basic guarantee against false accusation. The church is to give its leaders the same fairness the law gave every Israelite.
The next verse cuts the other way. Elders who are found to be persisting in sin are to be rebuked "in front of everyone", and Timothy is solemnly charged to act "without partiality" (v. 21). So this verse does not shield leaders. It is one half of a fair process: protection from unsupported charges, and public accountability when a charge is proven.
-
20But those who persist in sin should be rebuked in front of everyone, so that the others will stand in fear of sin.
Full study →"Those who are sinning, and keep on sinning, you must expose and correct in front of everyone, so that the rest too will be afraid."
Paul is speaking to Timothy, his delegate at Ephesus, and the command is a standing policy, not a one-off. It follows straight on from v. 19: an accusation against an elder must not even be accepted without two or three witnesses. Once the wrongdoing has been confirmed and is still going on, Timothy may not quietly cover it. The verb (elenchō) means more than "scold". It means to bring the wrong into the light, show it for what it is, and confront the person with it. It is the language of a case proven, not a temper lost.
This is to happen "before all", in the open, and it has two purposes: to correct the offender, and to have an effect on "the rest" as well. That effect is real fear: the sobering dread of doing the same thing and facing the same exposure. The phrasing deliberately recalls the law of Deuteronomy 19. The witness rule Paul just cited (Deut 19:15) is followed there by "and the rest will hear and fear, and never again do such evil among you" (19:20).
So the verse holds together two things the letter is careful to balance. Leaders are protected from unproven accusations (v. 19). When the charge is true, leaders are not protected from the truth (v. 20). And Timothy must do all of this without favouritism (v. 21).
Where the English drifted
-
in v19
entertain (an accusation)
paradechomai
- What we hear
- Don't even listen to or consider a complaint about a leader.
- What they heard
- Don't accept a charge as valid or act on it without corroboration. Hearing a concern and looking into it are not forbidden.
-
in v19
witnesses
martys
- What we hear
- Two or three people who personally saw the wrongdoing happen.
- What they heard
- More than one independent person testifying, so that a charge rests on corroboration rather than one person's word. In Matt 18:16 the "witnesses" are people brought in to the confrontation, not people who saw the original offence.
-
in v19
elder
presbyteros
- What we hear
- An elderly person, or a church officer with a job description set by a particular denomination's rules.
- What they heard
- A recognised leader in the early house churches. These were usually senior men who taught and gave oversight. In this period the same people were also called "overseers" (Acts 20:17, 28; Titus 1:5–7).
-
in v20
rebuke
elenchō
- What we hear
- To tell someone off sharply; a verbal scolding that expresses the speaker's displeasure.
- What they heard
- To expose and convict: to bring wrongdoing into the light, show it to be wrong, and correct the person. After the witness requirement of v. 19, it describes the open outcome of a verified case.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v19
"Two or three witnesses" is a standard of proof, not a shield
- What's often taught
- This verse is sometimes taught to mean that no accusation against a pastor or elder may be heard or looked into unless two or three people personally saw the wrongdoing. Without such eyewitnesses, the matter must be dropped.
- What the text supports
- The verb is about accepting a charge, not hearing one. Paradechomai means to accept or admit something as valid (compare Acts 22:18, "they will not accept your testimony"). Timothy is told not to treat a single person's charge as proven. He is not told to refuse to listen or to stop inquiring.
- The rule comes from Deuteronomy, and so does the duty to inquire. Deut 19:15 requires more than one witness. The same passage commands judges to "inquire diligently" (19:18) and sets out how to deal with false witnesses. The witness rule belonged inside a careful process of inquiry, not in place of one.
- "Witnesses" means corroboration, not necessarily people who saw the act. In Matt 18:16 the two or three witnesses are brought in after the offence, to confirm the confrontation. Jewish practice (e.g., the Damascus Document) also considered how separate testimonies to repeated offences could be combined.
- The next verses require action without favouritism. Verse 20 commands public rebuke of elders who persist in sin. Verse 21 charges Timothy before God to act "without prejudging, doing nothing from partiality". Verse 24 warns that some sins "appear later".
What this teaching gets right: the verse really does protect leaders from being condemned on one person's unsupported word, and that protection matters. But the passage pairs it with a duty to hold proven wrongdoing to account in the open. It does not make leaders immune from investigation.
- Where the English feeds it
- "Entertain" (BSB, NIV, ESV) and especially "listen to" (NLT) can suggest that a complaint should not even be considered. NIV's "brought by two or three witnesses" can suggest that the witnesses must be the ones making the charge. "Receive" or "accept" (KJV, NASB, WEB) is closer to the Greek.
Every word
-
κατὰ
kata · G2596
against; according to · v19
With the genitive case it means "against", which is the normal way of saying who a charge is brought against. Putting it first in the sentence highlights who is being accused: an elder.
-
πρεσβυτέρου
presbyterou · G4245
-
κατηγορίαν
katēgorian · G2724
accusation, formal charge · v19
A legal word for a charge brought against someone so that it can be judged, the kind of thing a prosecutor files. It is not passing criticism or a rumour, though it may begin as one.
-
μὴ
mē · G3361
not · v19
The negative used with commands. Together with the verb it makes a standing prohibition: "do not".
-
παραδέχου
paradechou · G3858
accept, admit, receive · v19
"Accept as valid" or "admit for action". It is a present-tense command, so it sets a standing policy: Timothy is not to treat a charge against an elder as established or act on it without corroboration. It does not mean "refuse to listen".
-
ἐκτὸς
ektos · G1622
outside; except · v19
Literally "outside". Here it begins the exception clause.
-
εἰ
ei · G1487
if · v19
Part of the stock phrase ektos ei mē, "except if not", which simply means "unless". Paul uses the same phrase in 1 Cor 14:5 and 15:2.
-
ἐπὶ
epi · G1909
upon, on the basis of · v19
"On the basis of", as in the Greek Old Testament wording of Deut 19:15, "on the mouth of two or three witnesses". Some, following the KJV's "before", read it as "in the presence of".
-
δύο
dyo · G1417
two · v19
The minimum number of witnesses set by the Torah, the law of Moses.
-
ἢ
ē · G2228
or · v19
"Two or three" is the set phrase from Deuteronomy. It means more than one witness, not an exact count.
-
τριῶν
triōn · G5140
three · v19
Completes the familiar legal formula "two or three".
-
μαρτύρων
martyrōn · G3144
witness · v19
People who give testimony in a legal sense. More than one independent person has to back up the charge. The word had not yet taken on its later meaning of "martyr".
-
τοὺς
tous · G3588
the · v20
The article joins with the participle that follows to make a noun phrase, 'the ones who…'. It is in the object case and stands first in the sentence, so the people concerned are put up front for emphasis: 'those who are sinning, these you must expose.'
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, now · v20
Found only in some manuscripts and editions. Where it appears it marks a light contrast with v. 19: unproven accusations are not to be accepted, but proven wrongdoing must be dealt with openly.
-
ἁμαρτάνοντας
hamartanontas · G0264
to sin, do wrong · v20
A present participle: 'those who are sinning.' The present tense pictures wrongdoing that is still going on, not a single lapse that is long over. That is why some translations say 'persist' or 'continue'. In context it most likely means elders whose wrongdoing has been confirmed by the witnesses required in v. 19.
-
ἐνώπιον
enōpion · G1799
before, in the presence of · v20
Literally 'in the sight of'. The word carries a strong flavour of the Greek Old Testament and was used for standing before a judge or before God. Here the correction is to happen openly, not behind closed doors.
-
πάντων
pantōn · G3956
all · v20
'Everyone.' The word does not say whether this means all the elders or the whole gathered congregation, and interpreters differ. Either way, the matter is not handled privately.
-
ἔλεγχε
elegche · G1651
to expose, convict, reprove · v20
A command to Timothy (second person singular) in the present tense, so it states a standing practice: 'make it your practice to expose and correct.' The verb means bringing wrongdoing into the light and showing it to be wrong. It is more than scolding.
-
ἵνα
hina · G2443
so that · v20
Introduces the purpose of the public correction.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
also, too · v20
'The rest too.' Public correction is meant to help the offender and also to have an effect on everyone else.
-
λοιποὶ
loipoi · G3062
remaining, the rest · v20
'The rest' or 'the others'. If the sinners are elders, the most natural sense is the other elders, though the whole church may be included. The word recalls 'the rest' in Deuteronomy 19:20, which follows the two-or-three-witnesses law quoted in v. 19.
-
φόβον
phobon · G5401
fear · v20
Real fear: a sober dread of doing the same thing and facing the same exposure. It is the fear that deters people from doing wrong. Mild 'respect' is too weak for it.
-
ἔχωσιν
echōsin · G2192
to have · v20
'May have', in a form that expresses purpose. 'Have fear' is a common Greek idiom for 'be afraid'.
The world behind it
Ephesus and its elders. The letter places Timothy in Ephesus as Paul's personal delegate (1:3). His job is to stop certain people from teaching "different doctrine". At least two, Hymenaeus and Alexander, are named and have already been excluded (1:20). The church met in homes and was led by a group of elders (see Acts 20:17–30, where Paul warns the Ephesian elders that men "from among your own selves" will arise and distort the truth). So in Ephesus elders could be the source of trouble or the target of it. This verse opens a short section (5:19–25) on how Timothy is to handle charges against elders, right after instructions on honouring and paying them (5:17–18).
A community prone to talk. A few verses earlier (5:13) the letter worries about people "going from house to house… gossips and busybodies, saying things they ought not". In small house churches where everyone knew everyone, an unsupported charge could ruin a leader's standing almost instantly. In an honour-based society, a public accusation itself did damage, whether or not it was true.
The Torah's witness rule. Deuteronomy 17:6 and 19:15 forbid convicting anyone on a single witness. Deuteronomy 19:16–19 adds that a malicious witness is to suffer the penalty he tried to bring on the accused, and requires judges to "inquire diligently". Jews of Paul's day applied this rule widely. Josephus (Antiquities 4.219) repeats it. The Dead Sea community's Damascus Document works out how it applies to repeated offences seen by different single witnesses. Jesus (Matt 18:16) and Paul (2 Cor 13:1) both carry it over into how the community handles discipline. When 1 Timothy cites it, it is invoking a principle its readers would already have accepted as just.
Authorship. Scholars debate whether Paul wrote 1 Timothy himself or a later follower wrote it in his name. Either way, the verse reflects early Christian communities taking over Jewish legal procedure to govern their own life together.
From the study of 1 Timothy 5:19.
Where scholars differ
in v19
Does "elder" here mean an office-holder or simply an older man?
-
A church leader (office).
Verses 17–18 speak of elders who "rule", "labour in preaching and teaching", and deserve pay. Verses 19–25 deal with discipline and appointment ("do not lay hands on anyone hastily", v. 22). Elsewhere the letter treats leaders as a recognised group (3:1–7; 4:14, "the council of elders").
-
An older man, or an age-based sense alongside the office.
In 5:1 the same word plainly means "an older man". Some argue the letter moves between the two senses, and that in the early house churches being senior and being a leader were not yet clearly separate. Most commentators still take vv. 17–25 as being about office.
in v19
Do the witnesses have to support the charge before it is even heard, or before it is acted on?
-
The charge must not be formally taken up at all without at least two witnesses.
The verb means "admit, receive", and some read it as a gatekeeping rule that keeps single-person complaints from ever starting a proceeding, to protect leaders' reputations.
-
The charge must not be accepted as proven or acted on without corroboration. Hearing it and looking into it are allowed.
Elsewhere the verb means accepting testimony as valid (Acts 22:18). Deut 19:18 requires judges to "inquire diligently". Matt 18:16 shows witnesses being gathered during the process. 1 Tim 5:21–24 assumes careful weighing of cases and warns that some sins only "appear later".
in v19
Does "upon" (epi) mean "on the basis of" or "in the presence of"?
-
"On the basis of" the witnesses' testimony.
This follows the Greek Old Testament of Deut 19:15, "on the mouth of" witnesses, which means on their testimony. Most modern translations and lexicons (BDAG, under epi) take it this way.
-
"In the presence of" witnesses (KJV "before").
Epi with the genitive can mean "before" a judge or authority (e.g., Acts 25:9, "before me"; 1 Cor 6:1). On this view the charge must be made formally in front of witnesses, not passed along privately. Few modern scholars hold it.
in v20
Who are 'those who are sinning': sinning elders, or any church member?
-
Elders specifically (the majority view among modern commentators, e.g. Fee, Mounce, Towner, Marshall, Knight).
Verses 17–25 form one unit about elders. Verse 19 is about accusations against an elder, verse 21 warns against partiality in judging, and verse 22 is about appointing elders. The letter's concern with false teachers among the leaders points the same way. Verse 20 naturally reads as the other side of v. 19: unproven charges are rejected, proven ones are dealt with openly.
-
Believers in general, or at least not limited to elders.
Verse 20 switches from the singular 'elder' (v. 19) to a general plural participle with no mention of office. The principle matches wider church discipline texts (Matt 18:15–17; Titus 3:10). Some older interpreters applied the verse to all members.
in v20
Does the present participle mean 'persist in sin', or simply 'those who sin'?
-
Ongoing, unrepentant sin.
The present tense naturally pictures continuing action. Public exposure fits best for someone who has not stopped, perhaps after private correction (compare Matt 18:15–17). BSB, ESV, NASB and NIV ('are sinning') reflect this.
-
Simply those found to have sinned, with no special stress on persistence.
Greek present participles are often used as plain descriptions ('sinners', 'those who do wrong') without stressing duration. On this view the trigger for public correction is the verified charge of v. 19, not whether the person has repented.
in v20
Is the correction 'before all' made to the whole congregation or to the body of elders?
-
The whole assembly.
'All' is unqualified. The Deuteronomic echo ('all Israel shall hear and fear') points to the whole community. NLT takes it this way.
-
The other elders.
If the offenders are elders, 'the rest' most naturally means their fellow elders, and 'all' may mean the same group. Compare Qumran, where reproof went before witnesses before reaching the full assembly.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. παραδέχομαι, κατηγορία, μάρτυς, πρεσβύτερος, ἐπί
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. παραδέχομαι
- Septuagint, Deuteronomy 17:6; 19:15–19
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 4.219
- Damascus Document (CD) 9:16–10:3
- I. Howard Marshall, The Pastoral Epistles (ICC)
- George W. Knight III, The Pastoral Epistles (NIGTC)
- William D. Mounce, Pastoral Epistles (WBC)
- Philip H. Towner, The Letters to Timothy and Titus (NICNT)
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at 1 Tim 5:19
- Biblia Sacra Vulgata, 1 Tim 5:19
- BDAG s.v. ἐλέγχω, ἁμαρτάνω, φόβος, λοιπός, ἐνώπιον
- F. Büchsel, TDNT s.v. ἐλέγχω
- Septuagint: Lev 19:17; Deut 13:11; 17:13; 19:15–20; 21:21
- Dead Sea Scrolls, Community Rule (1QS) 5:24–6:1
- Vulgate, 1 Tim 5:20
- G. D. Fee, 1 and 2 Timothy, Titus (NIBC)
- W. D. Mounce, Pastoral Epistles (WBC 46)
- P. H. Towner, The Letters to Timothy and Titus (NICNT)
- I. H. Marshall, The Pastoral Epistles (ICC)
- G. W. Knight III, The Pastoral Epistles (NIGTC)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).