Daniel Chapter 8 Read as one passage

Daniel 8:21–22

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

21The shaggy goat represents the king of Greece, and the large horn between his eyes is the first king. 22The four horns that replaced the broken one represent four kingdoms that will rise from that nation but will not have the same power.

What the first hearers heard

For Judeans who heard or read this vision, the goat was not a puzzle. Gabriel names it. What mattered was where it placed them in the story. They lived under the Greek kingdoms that came after Alexander, and in the crisis of the 160s BC under Antiochus IV they lived through the desecration of the temple that the vision goes on to describe.

The verse told them several things:

  • The empires are on a script. Persia gives way to Greece, Greece's first king gives way to four kingdoms, and from these comes the persecutor. The sequence is fixed and known ahead of time, revealed in a vision and interpreted by an angel. Even the most terrifying power of their day was one stage in a sequence God had already set out.
  • Great horns break. The mightiest conqueror the world had seen was 'broken' at his height (8:8). That prepares for the promise that the later tyrant will be 'broken, but not by human hand' (8:25).
  • Identity and endurance. Naming the actors helped the faithful read their own suffering as part of a bounded 'time of the end' (8:17, 19), with a set limit (8:14). That was a reason to hold firm rather than give in to Hellenising pressure.

Whether these first hearers met the vision as prophecy given in the 6th century or as a vision written in Daniel's name during the crisis (see debates), the verse functioned the same way: it named the Greek power and its founder so that everything after could be measured from him.

From the study of Daniel 8:21.

Verse by verse

  1. 21The shaggy goat represents the king of Greece, and the large horn between his eyes is the first king.

    The angel Gabriel is decoding Daniel's vision piece by piece. "And the buck, the shaggy he-goat you saw, stands for the royal power of the Greeks. The great horn that sat alone in the middle of its brow, between its eyes, is that power's first king."

    The animal is a full-grown male goat, the kind that leads a flock, thick-coated and powerful. It is not a 'rough' goat in the modern sense of violent. Its hairiness is simply part of the picture of a mature billy goat. 'King of Greece' here means the Greek kingdom as a whole, the Macedonian empire that the Judeans, like other Near Eastern peoples, called Yavan, after the Ionian Greeks. In Hebrew a horn meant strength and rule, so the single huge horn is one overwhelming ruler. It is the first king of this Greek world-power: in history, Alexander the Great, whose lightning campaigns crushed Persia, the two-horned ram of verse 20. The verse also prepares for what comes next. A horn can break while the animal lives on, and that is exactly what happens: the first king falls, and four lesser kingdoms rise from the same nation (v. 22).

    Full study →
  2. 22The four horns that replaced the broken one represent four kingdoms that will rise from that nation but will not have the same power.

    "As for the horn that was snapped off, and the four that stood up in its place: four royal kingdoms will rise to power from that same people, but they will not have his strength."

    The angel Gabriel is explaining the vision to Daniel one piece at a time. In verse 21 he identified the goat as the king of Greece and the great horn between its eyes as its first king. Now he explains what Daniel saw in verse 8: the great horn snapped at the peak of its strength, and four horns grew up in its place, pointing to the four winds.

    The sentence opens abruptly, the way someone points at part of a picture: "And the broken one…" The word "broken" is violent. The first king does not slowly fade; he is cut off at full power. Four horns "stood up" in his place. The Hebrew says literally "under it", meaning they took over its position. Gabriel then turns the past-tense vision into a forecast with the same verb: four kingdoms, each a royal power with its own king, will stand up. In Daniel's Hebrew, "stand up" is the ordinary expression for a ruler taking power.

    These kingdoms come "from a nation", the Greek-Macedonian people of verse 21. They are Greek kingdoms, but not ruled by the first king's family. The last phrase, "and not with his strength", says they are real powers but none of them has the force of the first king. The wording points ahead to verse 24. There the later "fierce" king's power "will be great, but not by his own power". Across the chapter, power is something given and taken away. It never simply belongs to whoever holds it.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v21

    rough goat (KJV, WEB)

    hatsafir hasa'ir

    What we hear
    A harsh, violent or savage goat, as if the adjective described the Greek empire's brutality.
    What they heard
    A hairy, shaggy he-goat, or 'the buck, the he-goat'. The word describes the coat (or simply names the animal), not its temperament.
  • in v21

    king of Greece

    melekh Yavan

    What we hear
    A single monarch of the country we call Greece, centred on Athens or the classical city-states.
    What they heard
    The royal power of 'Yavan', the Near Eastern name for all Greek-speakers. Here it is the Macedonian-Greek empire of Alexander and his successors. 'King' stands for the kingdom, and the individual king is the horn.
  • in v22

    "four stood up for it" (KJV)

    taḥteyha

    What we hear
    A modern reader hears 'stood up for it' as 'defended it' or 'supported it', as if the four horns took the broken horn's side.
    What they heard
    'In its place / instead of it.' The four replaced the broken horn. They did not champion it.
  • in v22

    "nation"

    goy

    What we hear
    A nation-state with borders and its own government, i.e. 'Greece' as a country.
    What they heard
    A people as a group: here the Greek-Macedonian people whose generals divided Alexander's empire into kingdoms spread over three continents.
Every word
  1. וְהַצָּפִ֥יר

    vehatsafir · H6842

    and the he-goat · v21

    The adult male goat of the vision (8:5–8). The word is a late one, shared with Aramaic, used in the Bible only in post-exilic books. 'The' points back to the goat Daniel has just seen.

  2. הַשָּׂעִ֖יר

    hasa'ir · H8163B

    the hairy one / the buck · v21

    From the word for 'hair'. Either it describes the goat ('the shaggy one') or it is a second, more common word for 'buck' set beside the rarer tsafir to explain it. Either way the picture is a mature, shaggy billy goat.

  3. מֶ֣לֶךְ

    melekh · H4428G

    king of · v21

    Here 'king' stands for the royal power of the Greeks as a whole, their kingdom and line of rulers, because the next clause picks out one individual horn as 'the first king'. Daniel moves freely between 'king' and 'kingdom' (7:17 vs 7:23; 8:22).

  4. יָוָ֑ן

    Yavan · H3120H

    Greece (Javan) · v21

    The Hebrew name for the Greeks, taken from 'Ionian', the Greeks of the Aegean coast whom Near Eastern peoples met first. Here it means the Greek-speaking Macedonian power that conquered Persia.

  5. וְהַקֶּ֤רֶן

    vehaqqeren · H7161A

    and the horn · v21

    The single horn of the goat (8:5). In Hebrew imagery a horn is an animal's strength and weapon, so it stands for a ruler's power and then for the ruler himself.

  6. הַגְּדוֹלָה֙

    haggedolah · H1419A

    the great / large · v21

    Large in size and so conspicuous and powerful. It contrasts with the four horns that replace it (8:8, 22) and with the 'little horn' that grows later (8:9).

  7. אֲשֶׁ֣ר

    asher · H834A

    which · v21

    Relative word that brings in the identifying detail: 'the one which…'

  8. בֵּין־

    bein · H996G

    between · v21

    Places the horn at the centre of the brow: one horn, not a pair.

  9. עֵינָ֔יו

    einav · H5869A

    his eyes · v21

    Repeats the detail of 8:5, 'a conspicuous horn between his eyes', so the reader knows exactly which horn is meant: the original single horn, before it broke.

  10. ה֖וּא

    hu · H1931

    it / he · v21

    A pronoun used as 'is'. It ties the symbol to its meaning: 'that one is…'. Its masculine form matches 'king' rather than the grammatically feminine 'horn'.

  11. הָרִאשֽׁוֹן׃

    harishon · H7223G

    the first · v21

    First in the sequence of Greek kings the vision traces: this one, then four (8:22), then the 'king of fierce countenance' (8:23). Historically this is Alexander the Great, the first to rule a Greek world-empire.

  12. וְהַ֨נִּשְׁבֶּ֔רֶת

    wehannishberet · H7665

    to break; (passive) be broken · v22

    'And the broken one'. It is a feminine passive form agreeing with 'horn' (qeren, feminine in Hebrew), so it means the great horn of verse 8 that 'was broken'. It stands at the head of the sentence as its topic: 'As for the broken horn…'. The verb is violent. The horn did not fade away; it snapped at the height of its strength.

  13. וַתַּֽעֲמֹ֥דְנָה

    wattaʿamodnah · H5975

    to stand; arise · v22

    'And there stood up'. A feminine plural past-narrative form recalling what Daniel saw in the vision (v. 8): four horns 'came up' or 'stood' where the one had been. The feminine plural matches 'horns'.

  14. אַרְבַּ֖ע

    ʾarbaʿ · H0702

    four · v22

    'Four', meaning the four horns of verse 8, which sprouted 'toward the four winds of heaven'. The number names the actual successors and also hints at a split to every point of the compass.

  15. תַּחְתֶּ֑יהָ

    taḥteyha · H8478

    under; in place of · v22

    'In its place', literally 'under it'. Here taḥat means substitution: the four took over the position the single horn had held. The 'her/its' ending refers back to the broken horn.

  16. מַלְכֻי֛וֹת

    malkuyot · H4438

    royalty, reign, kingdom · v22

    'Kingdoms', meaning royal domains: realms each ruled by its own king. This is a late Hebrew word, typical of Daniel, Esther, Ezra and Chronicles, and its plural is rare. The four horns are now identified as four royal powers.

  17. מִגּ֥וֹי

    miggoy · H1471

    nation, people · v22

    'From a nation'. The successor kingdoms grow out of the same people as the first king, the Greek-Macedonian people named in verse 21 ('king of Yavan/Greece'). The Hebrew has no 'his'. The ancient translations read 'from his nation' (see textual notes).

  18. וְלֹ֥א

    welo · H3808

    not · v22

    'And not' / 'but not'. It adds a brief limitation to the clause: they will rise, but something will be missing.

  19. בְכֹחֽוֹ׃

    bekhoḥo · H3581

    strength, power, might · v22

    'With his strength', most likely the strength of the first king (Alexander), whose force the four successors will not match. The same phrase comes back in v. 24 about the later 'fierce' king, which ties the two together.

The world behind it

Where this sits. Daniel 8 is the first vision after the book switches back from Aramaic (2:4b–7:28) to Hebrew. Daniel sees a two-horned ram charging west, north and south (8:3–4). Then a goat with one conspicuous horn races from the west 'without touching the ground', shatters the ram, grows great, and has its horn broken. Four horns grow in its place, and from one of them a 'little horn' grows that attacks the sanctuary and stops the daily offering (8:5–12). Gabriel then explains it (8:15–26). Verse 20 names the ram as Media and Persia, and verse 21 names the goat.

The history the symbols fit. Alexander of Macedon crossed into Asia in 334 BC and defeated the Persian king Darius III at the Granicus, Issus (333) and Gaugamela (331). Within about a decade he ruled from Greece to the Indus. He died suddenly at Babylon in 323, still young. His generals carved up the empire, and it settled into four main blocks: Macedon (Cassander), Thrace and Asia Minor (Lysimachus), Syria and Mesopotamia (Seleucus), and Egypt (Ptolemy). Judea lay between the Ptolemaic and Seleucid kingdoms. The Seleucid king Antiochus IV Epiphanes profaned the Jerusalem temple in 167 BC, and he is the figure most interpreters, ancient and modern, see in the 'little horn' and the 'king of fierce countenance' (8:9–12, 23–25).

Why animals and horns? Kings were commonly called shepherds, and leaders were 'rams' or 'he-goats' of the flock (Ezekiel 34:17; Jeremiah 50:8; Zechariah 10:3; Isaiah 14:9). A horn was power (Psalm 89; 1 Samuel 2:10). A ram against a goat is two flock-leaders butting for mastery, an image any herding people would understand at once.

From the study of Daniel 8:21.

Where scholars differ

in v21

Is *hasa'ir* a description ('shaggy') or a second name for the goat ('the buck')?

  • A describing word: 'the shaggy/hairy he-goat'.

    *Sa'ir* means 'hairy' in Genesis 27:11, 23. A noun with the article followed by a word with the article is the normal Hebrew way to attach an adjective. Most modern translations follow this reading.

  • A noun in apposition or an explanatory note: 'the he-goat, the buck'.

    *Sa'ir* is the standard word for a male goat in Leviticus. *Tsafir* is rare and late, so a scribe may have added the familiar word to explain it. Some commentators (e.g. Montgomery) take it as a gloss. The Greek versions and the Vulgate ('he-goat of the goats') read it as a noun.

in v21

When was the vision written, and from what vantage point?

  • Written by Daniel in the 6th century BC as prediction.

    The book presents the vision as given in Belshazzar's third year (8:1). Traditional Jewish and Christian interpretation, and many conservative scholars, read the naming of Greece as genuine prophecy long before Alexander.

  • Written in Daniel's name around 167–164 BC, during the crisis under Antiochus IV.

    Most critical scholars point out that the detail grows sharper as the vision reaches the 160s BC. It covers the desecration of the temple but not, they argue, Antiochus's death in 164. It also has close parallels with other writings from that period (1 Enoch's Animal Apocalypse). On this view the vision frames recent history as foretold in order to encourage the persecuted.

  • Common ground.

    Both camps agree that the goat is the Greek-Macedonian empire and the great horn is Alexander. The text itself names Greece. Differences over dating do not change what this verse identifies.

in v21

Why is Greece pictured as a goat?

  • Flock-leader imagery.

    Rams and he-goats are biblical images for leaders and powerful nations (Jeremiah 50:8; Ezekiel 34:17; Zechariah 10:3; Isaiah 14:9). A ram-versus-goat fight pictures two leaders contending.

  • Macedonian associations with goats.

    The old Macedonian capital Aegae means 'goat-town' in Greek, and a legend in Justin's *Epitome* (7.1) says its founder Caranus followed a herd of goats there. The vision does not make this link, so it is suggestive rather than proven.

  • Astrological geography.

    Franz Cumont pointed to a Hellenistic astrological scheme that placed Persia under Aries (the ram) and Syria under Capricorn (the goat-fish), which would fit a Seleucid-era perspective. Others find the evidence too late or too indirect.

in v22

Whose 'strength' is meant in 'and not with his strength'?

  • The first king's (Alexander's): none of the four will match his power.

    The nearest personal antecedent is 'the first king' (v. 21). Daniel 11:4 says the division will not be 'according to the dominion with which he ruled'. Most commentators and most English versions (BSB, NIV 'the same power') read it this way.

  • The nation's or goat's strength (the suffix referring to goy, 'nation', which is masculine): the kingdoms will not have the united strength of the Greek people as a whole.

    Goy is the nearest masculine noun. YLT renders 'its power'. The two readings come to much the same thing in practice.

in v22

Are the 'four kingdoms' a precise historical list or a symbolic four?

  • Historical: the four realms left after Ipsus (301 BCE): Cassander, Lysimachus, Seleucus and Ptolemy.

    Jerome and most modern commentators. The fit is close, and the narrative of Daniel 11 goes on to follow two of them (the Ptolemies and Seleucids) in detail.

  • Mainly schematic: 'four' matches the four winds (v. 8; 11:4) and means a break-up in every direction, without a tidy list.

    The real succession was messier: Antigonus, Lysimachus's kingdom disappearing by 281 BCE, and shifting borders. Daniel uses four symbolically elsewhere (four beasts, four winds in ch. 7). Many scholars hold that both are true: a real fourfold division described in symbolic terms.

in v22

When was this written, and does that affect the reading?

  • Composed or completed in the 160s BCE during the crisis under Antiochus IV, presenting earlier history as prophecy in the apocalyptic manner.

    The detailed accuracy of Daniel 8 and 11 up to about 165 BCE, and the late Hebrew style. This is the majority view in critical scholarship (e.g. Collins, Newsom).

  • Written in the 6th century BCE as the book presents itself, with genuine prediction.

    The book's own dating (8:1). Traditional Jewish and Christian interpretation, and conservative scholars (e.g. Baldwin, Miller). Either way, the verse's reference to Alexander's successors is not in dispute.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. צָפִיר, שָׂעִיר, קֶרֶן, יָוָן
  • HALOT s.v. צָפִיר, שָׂעִיר, קֶרֶן, יָוָן, רִאשׁוֹן
  • J. A. Montgomery, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Book of Daniel (ICC, 1927)
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia, 1993)
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (WBC 30)
  • C. A. Newsom, Daniel (OTL, 2014)
  • J. H. Walton et al., IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Daniel 8
  • 1 Maccabees 1:1–9
  • 1 Enoch 90:9 (Animal Apocalypse)
  • Justin, Epitome of Pompeius Trogus 7.1
  • F. Cumont, 'La plus ancienne géographie astrologique', Klio 9 (1909)
  • Septuagint (Old Greek and Theodotion) and Vulgate, Daniel 8:21
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. עָמַד (late Hebrew sense 'arise, come to power')
  • HALOT s.v. תַּחַת ('in place of')
  • HALOT s.v. מַלְכוּת
  • BHS critical apparatus at Dan 8:22 (miggoy / miggoyo)
  • John J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia, 1993)
  • Carol A. Newsom, Daniel (Old Testament Library, 2014)
  • John E. Goldingay, Daniel (Word Biblical Commentary 30)
  • James A. Montgomery, Daniel (International Critical Commentary, 1927)
  • Jerome, Commentary on Daniel
  • Diodorus Siculus, Library of History bks. 18–20; Plutarch, Life of Demetrius (the wars of Alexander's successors)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).