Deuteronomy Chapter 2 Read as one passage

Deuteronomy 2:28–29

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

28You can sell us food to eat and water to drink in exchange for silver. Only let us pass through on foot, 29just as the descendants of Esau who live in Seir and the Moabites who live in Ar did for us, until we cross the Jordan into the land that the LORD our God is giving us.”

What the first hearers heard

For the generation about to enter Canaan, and for later Israelites hearing Deuteronomy read, the verse did several things:

  • It showed Israel as a people who keep their word and pay their way. Israel asked nothing of Sihon except a road, and offered fair payment for the most basic needs. The blame for the war that followed therefore falls on Sihon's refusal (2:30, 32), not on Israelite aggression. This shapes how Israel remembered its claim to the land east of the Jordan. Jephthah makes exactly that argument to the Ammonites in Judges 11:19–23.
  • It matched the law of approaching a city with peace before war (Deut 20:10–11), which is applied here to a king outside the promised land proper.
  • It reinforced that Israel's goal lay across the Jordan. "Only let me pass through" said that Sihon's land was not what Israel was seeking. When the land did come to Israel, it came because of Sihon's hostility and, in Deuteronomy's telling, as God's gift (2:31).
  • It taught restraint with other peoples' resources. Israel was to buy rather than take. The same instruction was given for Edom (2:6), and the text contrasts it with the hospitality that Ammon and Moab failed to show (23:4).

From the study of Deuteronomy 2:28.

Verse by verse

  1. 28You can sell us food to eat and water to drink in exchange for silver. Only let us pass through on foot,

    Speaking for the whole people as a single "I", Moses tells the Amorite king Sihon:

    "Food, for silver: sell me provisions, and that is what I will eat. Water, for silver: let me have it, and that is what I will drink. All I ask is to walk through on my own two feet."

    Each clause begins with the thing to be paid for: food for silver, water for silver. The emphasis falls on payment. Israel will consume nothing it has not bought. The verb for selling is a word from the grain trade ("sell me provisions"), so Israel is acting like a caravan buying supplies, not an army taking them. The "silver" is weighed metal, the standard payment of the day, not coins. Even water, which in that dry country belonged to whoever owned the well, will be paid for. Then the request narrows to one word: only. Israel asks for nothing except to pass through on foot: no settling, no foraging, no taking of land or livestock. The next verse completes the sentence: just as Esau and Moab allowed, "until I cross the Jordan into the land the LORD our God is giving us." Sihon's country is a road, not a goal.

    Full study →
  2. 29just as the descendants of Esau who live in Seir and the Moabites who live in Ar did for us, until we cross the Jordan into the land that the LORD our God is giving us.”

    Moses' message to Sihon, king of Heshbon, ends by appealing to precedent and stating a clear limit:

    "…treat me the way the descendants of Esau, settled in their mountain country of Seir, treated me, and the way the Moabites, settled in Ar, treated me: sell me food and water for silver and let me go by. I only need this until I have crossed the Jordan into the land that Yahweh, our God, is already in the act of handing over to us."

    Several things are packed in:

    • "Just as… did for me" points to precedent, a common move in ancient diplomacy: your neighbors have already done this; you can too. The verse does not say exactly what Edom and Moab did. Verse 28 fills it in: they sold provisions for silver and let Israel pass.
    • "I" is Israel speaking as one body through its messengers. At the end the voice becomes "our God… to us," the people speaking together about the God they belong to.
    • "Who dwell in Seir… who dwell in Ar" stresses that these are settled peoples in homelands Yahweh assigned them (2:5, 9). Both are also Israel's relatives: Esau was Jacob's brother, and Moab descended from Lot, Abraham's nephew.
    • "Until I cross the Jordan" sets a time limit and points west. Israel's goal is across the river, not Sihon's kingdom. The verb 'cross / pass through' is the thread of the whole episode, and in the next verse Sihon refuses to let Israel 'pass.'
    • "Is giving" shows the gift of land already under way. Israel names its God, Yahweh, as the one assigning territory, even when speaking to a foreign king.
    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v28

    money (KJV, WEB, ESV: "for money")

    kesep

    What we hear
    Coins, currency, cash.
    What they heard
    Silver, weighed out on scales as payment. Coins did not exist in this period.
  • in v28

    meat (KJV: "sell me meat for money")

    ʾōkel

    What we hear
    Animal flesh.
    What they heard
    Food of any kind: bread, grain, provisions.
  • in v29

    the LORD

    YHWH (Yahweh)

    What we hear
    A title, 'the Lord,' meaning a master or ruler in general.
    What they heard
    The personal name of Israel's God. In a message to a foreign king, it says *which* god stands behind Israel's claim: Yahweh, not Sihon's gods.
Every word
  1. אֹ֣כֶל

    ʾōkel · H0400

    food · v28

    Ordinary food or provisions, anything eaten. It comes first in the sentence for emphasis: food is the thing Israel offers to pay for.

  2. בַּכֶּ֤סֶף

    bakkesep · H3701G

    silver, money · v28

    "For the silver": the preposition marks the price. This is silver weighed out by the shekel on scales, not coins, which did not exist yet. The article ("the silver") means silver as the usual way of paying.

  3. תַּשְׁבִּרֵ֙נִי֙

    tašbirēnî · H7666

    to sell grain / provisions · v28

    "You will sell me (provisions)." This verb comes from the noun for grain (šeber) and is a trading word: in this form it means selling food supplies to someone. The 'you will' form works as a polite request: 'you may sell me.'

  4. וְאָכַ֔לְתִּי

    weʾākaltî · H0398

    to eat · v28

    "And I will eat." It gives the result of the sale: Israel will only eat what it has paid for, and will not live off the land by taking from it.

  5. וּמַ֛יִם

    ûmayim · H4325G

    water · v28

    Water, also put first for emphasis. In the dry Transjordan, wells and cisterns belonged to someone, so water was a resource you paid for.

  6. תִּתֶּן־

    titten · H5414G

    to give · v28, v29

    "You will give." Paired with "for silver", this ordinary verb for giving means handing something over in exchange for payment.

  7. לִ֖י

    lî · H9030

    to me · v28, v29

    "To me." The whole nation speaks as one 'I' through Moses. BSB changes this to 'us', and that is a fair reading of the sense.

  8. וְשָׁתִ֑יתִי

    wešātîtî · H8354

    to drink · v28

    "And I will drink." It matches "and I will eat": what Israel consumes depends on what it has bought.

  9. רַ֖ק

    raq · H7535

    only · v28

    "Only" sets a limit. Passage is the one thing Israel asks for; it asks for nothing else.

  10. אֶעְבְּרָ֥ה

    ʾeʿbərâ · H5674A

    to pass over / through · v28, v29

    "Let me pass through." The verb form is a polite wish or request ('let me'). The same verb runs through the chapter and reaches its goal in 2:29: crossing the Jordan.

  11. בְרַגְלָֽי׃

    bəraglāy · H7272

    foot · v28

    "On my (two) feet": walking through and nothing more. Israel will just travel, without stopping to take land, livestock or goods.

  12. כַּאֲשֶׁ֨ר

    ka'asher · H0834D

    just as · v29

    Introduces a precedent. Israel points Sihon to how its neighbors have already dealt with it: 'do what they did.'

  13. עָֽשׂוּ־

    'asu · H6213A

    do, make · v29

    'They did' (completed action). The verb is vague on purpose. What they did has to be supplied from verse 28: selling food and water for silver, and letting Israel pass.

  14. בְּנֵ֣י

    benei · H1121G

    sons, descendants · v29

    'Sons of' in the sense of a people descended from one ancestor. It quietly reminds the reader that Edom is Israel's kin, descended from Jacob's brother.

  15. עֵשָׂ֗ו

    'Esav · H6215H

    Esau · v29

    Jacob's twin brother, the ancestor of the Edomites. Deuteronomy 2:4–5 calls them 'your brothers' and says Yahweh gave them Seir.

  16. הַיֹּֽשְׁבִים֙

    hayyoshevim · H3427

    to sit, dwell · v29

    'Who dwell': a participle describing settled people with an established homeland. Israel, still on the march, is the one without a home.

  17. בְּשֵׂעִ֔יר

    beSe'ir · H8165A

    Seir · v29

    'In Seir': the mountain country of Edom, south and southeast of the Dead Sea, which Deuteronomy 2:5 says Yahweh gave to Esau as a possession.

  18. וְהַמּ֣וֹאָבִ֔ים

    vehamMo'avim · H4125

    Moabites · v29

    'And the Moabites': the second kin people, descended from Lot, Abraham's nephew (Deut 2:9; Gen 19:37).

  19. בְּעָ֑ר

    be'Ar · H6144

    Ar · v29

    'In Ar': a Moabite city, or the district around it, that stands for Moab as a whole (compare Deut 2:9, 18). Where exactly it was is uncertain, but it was probably near the Arnon gorge.

  20. עַ֤ד

    'ad · H5704

    until · v29

    Together with the next word, it means 'until.' It sets a time limit on the request: Israel is passing through, not staying.

  21. אֶת־

    'et · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v29

    Marks 'the Jordan' as the thing crossed. It has no English equivalent.

  22. הַיַּרְדֵּ֔ן

    hayYarden · H3383

    the Jordan · v29

    The river boundary. Naming it tells Sihon that Israel's goal lies west of the river, not in his kingdom east of it.

  23. אֶל־

    'el · H0413

    to, toward · v29

    'Into, toward': the direction of travel, toward the promised land.

  24. הָאָ֕רֶץ

    ha'arets · H0776G

    land, earth, country · v29

    'The land': a particular territory, Canaan west of the Jordan, not the whole earth.

  25. יְהוָ֥ה

    YHWH · H3068G

    Yahweh (the LORD) · v29

    The personal name of Israel's God. In a message to a foreign king it names which god is behind Israel's move: not Sihon's gods, but Yahweh.

  26. אֱלֹהֵ֖ינוּ

    'eloheinu · H0430G

    God, gods · v29

    'Our God.' The speaker shifts from 'me' to 'us,' and the people speak together of the God they belong to.

  27. לָֽנוּ׃

    lanu · H9035

    to us · v29

    'To us': the people as a whole receive the gift. This closes the message to Sihon.

The world behind it

The scene. This verse is part of the "words of peace" (2:26) that Moses sent from the wilderness of Kedemoth to Sihon, the Amorite king who ruled from Heshbon over the land between the Arnon and Jabbok rivers, east of the Jordan. Numbers 21:21–23 tells the same event, and Judges 11:19–20 recalls it.

How armies fed themselves. In the ancient Near East a moving army normally supplied itself by foraging, taking crops, animals and water from the land it crossed. A large group asking to cross your territory was therefore a real threat. Israel's offer to buy every meal and every drink, and to keep to the main road (2:27, "I will not turn to the right or to the left"), answers that fear directly.

Water as property. In the semi-arid Transjordan, wells and cisterns were dug, owned and fought over (compare Gen 21:25; 26:18–22). Offering to pay for water was not excessive politeness. It respected a real economic resource. Numbers 20:19 makes the same offer to Edom: "if we drink your water... I will pay for it."

Silver before coins. Payment was made by weighing silver pieces against standard weights. Coins came centuries later.

The pattern in the chapter. God had told Israel to pay Esau's descendants for food and water "with silver" (2:6) and not to provoke Edom, Moab or Ammon, because God had given them their lands (2:5, 9, 19). Sihon receives the same peaceful terms. But 2:24 has already announced that his land is given to Israel, and 2:30 says that God "hardened his spirit." His refusal leads to the battle at Jahaz (2:32–36).

From the study of Deuteronomy 2:28.

Where scholars differ

in v28

Was the peace offer to Sihon sincere, given that God had already announced in 2:24 that his land was handed over to Israel?

  • The offer was real. Deuteronomy shows Israel following the peace-first rule (20:10), and Sihon's refusal is what turned the situation into war.

    2:26 calls the message 'words of peace'. The terms are identical to those given to Edom and Moab, who were spared (2:29). Judges 11:19–23 treats the offer as made in good faith.

  • The offer forms part of a story that had already been decided by God, who hardens Sihon's spirit (2:30), much as with Pharaoh. The offer serves to show that the war was justified rather than to look for a real alternative.

    2:24–25 ('begin to possess it, and engage him in battle') comes before the embassy, and 2:30–31 gives God's purpose explicitly. Some commentators (e.g. Weinfeld) note that the narrative is shaped theologically.

in v28

Did Edom and Moab really sell Israel food and water, as 2:29 says?

  • There is a real tension between traditions. Numbers 20:18–21 has Edom refusing passage, and Deut 23:4 says Ammon and Moab did not meet Israel with bread and water.

    Num 20:14–21 and Deut 23:4–5 compared with Deut 2:29.

  • The accounts can be reconciled. The Edomites of Seir, along the route around the land, traded with Israel even though the kingdom refused passage through its heartland. Deut 23:4 refers to a failure of hospitality (meeting with gifts), not a refusal of paid trade.

    Deut 2:4–8 describes Israel going 'around' Seir and buying provisions there. Traditional Jewish commentators and modern scholars such as Tigay and Craigie offer harmonizations along these lines.

in v29

What did Edom and Moab 'do for' Israel, and how does this fit Numbers 20:14–21 (Edom refuses passage) and Deuteronomy 23:4 (Moab did not meet Israel with bread and water)?

  • It refers only to selling food and water, not to granting passage.

    Verse 28 asks for food and water for silver. Deut 2:6 tells Israel to buy food and water from the sons of Esau. Medieval Jewish commentators such as Rashi read 'as they did for me' as referring to these sales. Deut 23:4's phrase 'did not *meet* you with bread and water' can then mean that Moab offered no gift of welcome. Commercial sale and a gift of welcome are different things.

  • Israel passed along the edges of Edom and Moab, not through their heartland, and Deuteronomy describes this as peaceful.

    Deut 2:8 says Israel 'passed by' (or 'away from') the sons of Esau, and 2:29 does not explicitly claim they used the King's Highway. This reading fits Num 20:21–22 and 21:4, 11–13, where Israel goes around Edom and skirts Moab.

  • Deuteronomy preserves a different tradition from Numbers and Deut 23, and the accounts cannot be fully harmonized.

    Many critical scholars see Deut 2 as an independent retelling with its own emphasis: respect for kin nations whose lands Yahweh assigned. Numbers 20 and Deut 23:4 reflect a more hostile memory of Edom and Moab. The Samaritan Pentateuch's harmonizing additions show the tension was felt in antiquity.

in v29

Was the peaceful offer to Sihon sincere, given that Yahweh had already said he was giving Sihon's land to Israel (2:24)?

  • The offer was genuine as an offer, and the outcome lay with Sihon's choice under Yahweh's control.

    2:26 calls it 'words of peace,' and Deut 20:10 requires an offer of peace before attacking a city. 2:30 explains Sihon's refusal as Yahweh hardening him, which presupposes that a peaceful outcome had been offered.

  • The offer was a formal diplomatic step, and its main purpose in the story is to place the blame for the war on Sihon.

    The narrator already knows the outcome (2:24–25), and the stress on Sihon's refusal and Yahweh's hardening serves to justify the conquest of land east of the Jordan, which this verse says was not Israel's goal.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).