Deuteronomy Chapter 32 Read as one passage

Deuteronomy 32:28–29

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

28Israel is a nation devoid of counsel, with no understanding among them. 29If only they were wise, they would understand it; they would comprehend their fate.

What the first hearers heard

Israelites singing or hearing this song (Deut 31:19–22 says it was to be taught and memorised as a witness against Israel's future unfaithfulness) would have heard it as part of the song's explanation for why Israel survives its punishment. God limits his judgment so that his name is not misunderstood among the nations.

If they heard "they" as the enemy, the verse was a comfort and a correction at once. The nation that crushes you is not wise or strong in itself. It simply cannot see that your own God handed you over, and that same blindness will be its downfall (vv. 34–43, where God turns to judge the enemies). If they heard "they" as Israel, the verse was a rebuke in line with v. 6 ("a foolish and unwise people"). It was all the sharper because Deut 4:6 had promised that keeping the covenant would make Israel admired by the nations as "a wise and understanding people." Either way, the point for the hearers was the same. History has to be read with discernment: defeat and victory both come from the LORD, and failing to see that is the deepest kind of folly.

From the study of Deuteronomy 32:28.

Verse by verse

  1. 28Israel is a nation devoid of counsel, with no understanding among them.

    "For they are a nation whose good sense has perished. Every plan and piece of sound advice they might have had is lost to them, and there is no discernment in them at all."

    The verse explains why God's judgment is at risk of being misread. In verse 27, God holds back from wiping Israel out completely, because the enemy would boast, "Our own hand did this, not the LORD." Verse 28 gives the reason the boast would come: whoever "they" are, they cannot think straight. The Hebrew picture is stronger than "lacking advice". Their ability to deliberate and plan has perished or wandered off, and the verb used for this usually signals ruin. The second line rephrases the first: there is no understanding, no ability to see how events connect. Verse 29 then completes the thought with the same root: "If only they were wise, they would understand this and see where they are heading."

    The Hebrew never says who "they" are. They may be the enemy nation, too foolish to see that its victory over Israel came only because Israel's Rock had handed Israel over (vv. 30–31). Or they may be Israel, too foolish to understand its own discipline. Ancient Jewish interpreters already disagreed on this, and the translation should leave it open.

    Full study →
  2. 29If only they were wise, they would understand it; they would comprehend their fate.

    "If only they had sense! Then they would see through to what is really going on here, and they would recognize where it is all heading for them."

    The line comes as a sigh in the middle of God's speech. The opening particle lû marks a condition that is not true: they are not wise. The verse grieves the gap between what they could see and what they do see. Three verbs for knowing pile up. To be wise is the practical skill of reading life rightly. To grasp is insight that leads to prudent action. To discern is telling appearance apart from reality.

    What they ought to grasp is "this." In context that points back to v. 27, where God fears the enemy will boast, "our hand is triumphant; the LORD has not done all this." The truth they miss is that the military outcome was God's doing (v. 30: "unless their Rock had sold them"). What they ought to discern is "their end": not a vague fate or the moment of death, but the outcome waiting at the end of the road they are on. For the enemy that means God's coming judgment on them (v. 35). For Israel, in the other reading, it means the ruin their unfaithfulness is bringing on them (compare v. 20, "I will see what their end will be").

    Either way, the verse says that real wisdom is the ability to read history as God's work and to see its outcome before it arrives.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v28

    void of counsel

    ʾōbad ʿēṣôt

    What we hear
    Nobody gave them advice, or they had no counsellor or professional guidance.
    What they heard
    Their own capacity for sound deliberation and planning has perished or been lost. It is a judgment on the nation's collective good sense, with a note of coming ruin carried by the verb 'perish'.
  • in v29

    latter end (KJV, WEB)

    ʾaḥărîṯ

    What we hear
    The end of one's life: death, and what follows it in eternity.
    What they heard
    The outcome or final state a nation's present course leads to in history: defeat, ruin, or God's reversal of fortune.
  • in v29

    fate (BSB)

    ʾaḥărîṯ

    What we hear
    An impersonal, predetermined destiny that cannot be escaped.
    What they heard
    The result that follows from a course of conduct under God's judgment. The whole point is that it can be foreseen, and in principle avoided, by those who are wise.
Every word
  1. כִּי־

    kî · H3588

    for, because · v28

    Gives the reason behind what has just been said. It ties this verse to verse 27: the boasting enemy of verse 27 (or Israel, on the other reading) acts as it does because it has no sense.

  2. ג֛וֹי

    gôy · H1471

    nation, people · v28

    A people seen as a political and ethnic body. In this song the same word is used for the 'foolish nation' God uses against Israel (v. 21). That is one reason many readers think the enemy is meant here, though the word can also describe Israel.

  3. אֹבַ֥ד

    ʾōbad · H6

    to perish, be lost, stray · v28

    A participle, describing an ongoing state: 'lost', 'gone to ruin'. Joined to the next word it means 'lost as to counsels', a nation whose ability to plan wisely has died or wandered off. The verb usually means destruction, so the phrase carries a hint that a nation without sense is heading for ruin.

  4. עֵצ֖וֹת

    ʿēṣôt · H6098

    counsel, plan, advice · v28

    Plural: 'counsels', meaning plans, deliberation, and good advice given and taken. The nation cannot think its situation through to a sound plan.

  5. הֵ֑מָּה

    hēmmâ · H1992

    they · v28

    An emphatic 'they', placed at the end of the clause for weight: 'that is what *they* are.' The verse never names who 'they' are, and that gap drives the main interpretive debate.

  6. וְאֵ֥ין

    wəʾên · H369

    and there is not · v28

    A flat statement that something is absent. It rounds off the second half of a matched pair of lines: no counsel, no understanding.

  7. בָּהֶ֖ם

    bāhem · H9038

    in them · v28

    'In them': the lack is inside the people themselves, not just in their leaders or circumstances.

  8. תְּבוּנָֽה׃

    təbûnâ · H8394

    understanding, discernment · v28

    The skill of seeing how things connect and reading events correctly. Its root (bîn) comes back in the next verse ('they would understand', yābînû), so the thought runs straight on: they lack the very discernment that would let them grasp what is happening and where it ends.

  9. ל֥וּ

    lû · H3863

    if only, would that · v29

    Opens a condition that is not true: "if they were (but they are not)." The same particle also introduces wishes ("O that…"), so the line carries a sigh as well as logic.

  10. חָכְמ֖וּ

    ḥāḵəmû · H2449

    be wise · v29

    "They were wise." In Hebrew this is practical wisdom, the skill of reading a situation and acting well, not book learning. Put after "if only," the form marks something that is not so.

  11. יַשְׂכִּ֣ילוּ

    yaśkîlû · H7919A

    have insight, act prudently, consider · v29

    "They would grasp, have insight into." The verb means seeing through to how things really work, and often the success that follows. This is the result that would follow if they were wise.

  12. זֹ֑את

    zōʾt · H2063

    this · v29

    "This," meaning what has just been described. It most likely echoes v. 27, "it was not the LORD who did all this (kol-zōʾt)": the real cause behind the disaster.

  13. יָבִ֖ינוּ

    yāḇînû · H995

    discern, understand, perceive · v29

    "They would discern." The verb is about telling things apart and seeing what lies beneath the surface. It is the same verb as v. 7, "consider (bînû) the years of many generations."

  14. לְאַחֲרִיתָֽם׃

    ləʾaḥărîṯām · H0319

    end, outcome, afterward, future · v29

    "Their end": where their present course will finish, the outcome still ahead of them. The preposition lə- marks what their discernment would be aimed at. The phrase echoes v. 20, "I will see what their end will be."

The world behind it

The verse sits in the Song of Moses (Deut 32:1–43). The song is written like a court case: heaven and earth are called as witnesses (v. 1), God's faithfulness is recited (vv. 4–14), and Israel's betrayal (vv. 15–18) and God's sentence (vv. 19–25) follow. At verse 26 the song turns. God says he would have scattered Israel and erased its memory (v. 26) except that the enemy would boast and give itself the credit (v. 27). Verses 28–33 then explain and expand on this.

Ancient Near Eastern peoples took it for granted that wars were won and lost by gods. A conquering nation would naturally credit its own strength or its own gods. Assyrian royal inscriptions do exactly that. The song's argument is that such a claim would be a failure of understanding. The real cause of the defeat was Israel's own God handing it over (v. 30: "unless their Rock had sold them"). The vocabulary here, "counsel", "understanding", and "wise" in v. 29, comes from Israel's wisdom tradition. Lacking these meant more than low intelligence. It meant being unable to read events morally and theologically, which in the wisdom tradition leads to ruin.

From the study of Deuteronomy 32:28.

Where scholars differ

in v28

Who are 'they', the senseless nation: Israel or the enemy?

  • The enemy nation

    The verse begins with 'for', which links it directly to v. 27, where the enemy wrongly claims the victory. Verses 29–31 make the best sense if the enemy is meant: they would understand if they saw that one could chase a thousand only 'because their Rock had sold them' (v. 30). The song calls the enemy a 'foolish nation' (gôy nābāl) in v. 21. Rabbi Nehemiah takes this view in the early rabbinic commentary Sifre Deuteronomy (§322), and so do many modern commentators (e.g. S. R. Driver; J. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary).

  • Israel

    The song has already called Israel 'a foolish and unwise people' (v. 6), and Israel's failure to understand is the song's main charge. Isa 27:11 uses similar language of Israel. Rabbi Judah takes this view in Sifre Deuteronomy, Rashi follows it ('Israel has lost the Torah, which is good counsel'), and some modern translations (BSB, NLT) write it into the text.

in v29

Who are "they" in vv. 28–29: the enemy nations or Israel?

  • The enemy nations

    Verse 27 has just quoted the enemy's misreading ("the LORD has not done all this"). Verse 30 is spoken from the angle of the victor ("how could one chase a thousand… unless their Rock had sold them"). Verses 31–33 speak of "their rock" and "their vine… from Sodom," clearly foreigners. On this view "this" is the truth that God, not their strength, gave the victory, and "their end" is their own coming judgment (v. 35). Many modern commentators, including J. Tigay (JPS), take this line.

  • Israel

    The song has already called Israel "foolish and not wise" (v. 6). Verse 20 uses the same phrase of Israel: "I will see what their end (ʾaḥărîṯām) will be." On this reading v. 30 shows how Israel's defeat makes no sense unless God had given them up. Rashi applies v. 28 to Israel, and the BSB writes "Israel" into v. 28.

  • Deliberately open

    Some read the pronouns as left vague so that both sides are charged with failing to read history as God's work. The song's purpose of being a witness for Israel (Deut 31:19–21) would make the lesson land on Israel either way.

in v29

Is lû here a wish ("O that…") or an unreal condition ("if they were…, they would…")?

  • Wish

    Lû often introduces wishes (e.g., Num 14:2; Deut 5:29 uses a related construction). KJV, NIV and NASB follow this.

  • Condition with result

    The perfect verb followed by imperfect verbs fits the pattern "if X were so, Y would follow" (compare Judg 13:23). BSB and ESV follow this. The two readings overlap: an unreal condition spoken by God still carries longing.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. אָבַד, עֵצָה, תְּבוּנָה
  • HALOT s.v. עֵצָה, תְּבוּנָה
  • S. R. Driver, Deuteronomy (ICC), on 32:26–31
  • J. H. Tigay, Deuteronomy (JPS Torah Commentary, 1996), on 32:28–31
  • Sifre Deuteronomy §322
  • Rashi on Deut 32:28
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Deut 32:28
  • Vulgate Deut 32:28
  • BDB s.v. לוּ, חָכַם, שָׂכַל, בִּין, אַחֲרִית
  • HALOT s.v. אַחֲרִית; s.v. שׂכל hiph.
  • J. H. Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (1996), on 32:26–31
  • S. R. Driver, Deuteronomy (ICC), on 32:28–30
  • P. C. Craigie, The Book of Deuteronomy (NICOT)
  • Rashi on Deut 32:28–29
  • NETS (New English Translation of the Septuagint), Deuteronomy 32:29
  • Vulgate, Deuteronomium 32:29

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).