Ezra Chapter 2 Read as one passage

Ezra 2:40–42

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

40The Levites: the descendants of Jeshua and Kadmiel (through the line of Hodaviah), 74. 41The singers: the descendants of Asaph, 128. 42The gatekeepers: the descendants of Shallum, the descendants of Ater, the descendants of Talmon, the descendants of Akkub, the descendants of Hatita, and the descendants of Shobai, 139 in all.

What the first hearers heard

For the returned community this line was a record of who belonged and who could serve. Being counted under a known Levitical clan proved that a man could legitimately work at the rebuilt temple. The register's next verses show that people without such proof were excluded from priestly service (2:61–63).

The first hearers would also have noticed the number. A temple needs far more assistants than priests, yet here the priests outnumber the Levites by almost sixty to one. The shortage was a practical problem for restoring worship, and it reappears in Ezra's own later recruitment drive (8:15–20). Placing Jeshua and Kadmiel under the single ancestral name Hodaviah tied the few who returned to an established line. These two family names then become the recognised heads of the Levites throughout Ezra–Nehemiah: they oversee the temple building, lead confession and sign the covenant renewal.

From the study of Ezra 2:40.

Verse by verse

  1. 40The Levites: the descendants of Jeshua and Kadmiel (through the line of Hodaviah), 74.

    Next come the Levites, the temple assistants who served under the priests. From them came the families of Jeshua and Kadmiel, both branches of the old Levite clan of Hodaviah. Seventy-four men in all.

    The verse is one line in a register of the Judeans who came back from exile in Babylon to rebuild Jerusalem and its temple. "Sons of" here means the clan or family line, not small children. The three names are family founders, not three living men. The little Hebrew word "belonging to" before Hodaviah most likely makes Jeshua and Kadmiel subdivisions of that one larger clan. The total is the point an ancient reader would notice. Just before this, four priestly families sent back 4,289 men (vv. 36–39). The Levites, whose job was to carry out the daily work of the temple, sent back only 74. Without them the restored temple would be short of the very people it relied on. Ezra later found the same shortage (8:15–20).

    Full study →
  2. 41The singers: the descendants of Asaph, 128.

    "Next come the temple singers: the guild of Asaph's house, the hereditary musicians who led Israel's worship in song, numbering 128 men."

    The verse is one entry in an official register of people who returned from exile in Babylon to Judah under Zerubbabel and Jeshua (Ezra 2:1–2). Its first word, "the singers", is a title for a recognized office. Temple singing was a professional, inherited role, and the singers also played instruments such as cymbals (Ezra 3:10). "Sons of Asaph" means the members of the family guild that traced itself to Asaph, the Levite musician remembered from David's time and named in the headings of twelve psalms (Pss 50, 73–83). The number is given in Hebrew style, largest unit first: "a hundred, twenty and eight".

    Coming straight after the priests (vv. 36–39) and a very small group of Levites (v. 40), and before the gatekeepers (v. 42), the line tells readers that the people who would sing the songs of the temple came back too. Only a few, but enough for the worship of Zion to be heard again.

    Full study →
  3. 42The gatekeepers: the descendants of Shallum, the descendants of Ater, the descendants of Talmon, the descendants of Akkub, the descendants of Hatita, and the descendants of Shobai, 139 in all.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v40

    Levites

    leviyyim

    What we hear
    Priests, or the whole tribe of Levi in general.
    What they heard
    The non-priestly temple staff descended from Levi. They are listed apart from the priests (Aaron's descendants) and, at this stage, apart from the singers and gatekeepers too.
  • in v40

    children (KJV, WEB)

    bene

    What we hear
    Young offspring of Jeshua and Kadmiel.
    What they heard
    Members, mostly adult men, of the family lines founded by these ancestors.
  • in v41

    children (KJV, WEB)

    bənê

    What we hear
    Young children, minors.
    What they heard
    Members of a family line or guild, here the adult men of the Asaphite singer house counted in the register.
Every word
  1. הַלְוִיִּ֑ם

    halviyyim · H3881

    Levites · v40

    A heading for a new section of the list. Here it means the temple assistants descended from Levi who were not priests. It is kept separate from the priests just listed (vv. 36–39) and from the singers and gatekeepers that follow (vv. 41–42).

  2. בְּנֵי־

    bene- · H1121

    sons, descendants · v40, v41

    'Sons of' names a family group or clan known by its founder. It covers all its present male members and their households, not literal children.

  3. יֵשׁ֧וּעַ

    yeshua · H3442

    Jeshua · v40

    The founder or head of a Levite family. This is a later form of the name Joshua ('YHWH saves'). He is not the high priest Jeshua son of Jozadak named in 2:2 and 3:2, who was a priest. This Levite family appears again leading Levitical work in Ezra 3:9 and Nehemiah 9:4–5.

  4. וְקַדְמִיאֵ֛ל

    veqadmiel · H6934

    and Kadmiel · v40

    A second Levite family head, regularly paired with Jeshua in Ezra–Nehemiah. The name probably means something like 'God is in front' or 'God of old', but the meaning is not certain.

  5. הוֹדַוְיָ֖ה

    hodavyah · H1938

    Hodaviah · v40

    The ancestral clan name these families come under. The name is usually explained as 'Give thanks to Yah' or 'Yah is splendor'. Nehemiah 7:43 spells it Hodevah.

  6. שִׁבְעִ֥ים

    shivim · H7657

    seventy · v40

    The tens part of the total. Hebrew puts the larger unit first.

  7. וְאַרְבָּעָֽה׃

    vearbaah · H702

    and four · v40

    This completes the total of 74 men. The number is strikingly small next to the 4,289 priests counted just before it.

  8. הַֽמְשֹׁרְרִ֑ים

    ham·shorərim · H7891

    the singers · v41

    The definite article plus a participle of the verb 'to sing', used as a title: 'the singers', meaning the recognized class of temple singers. It works as a heading for a new group in the register, after the priests (vv. 36–39) and Levites (v. 40).

  9. אָסָ֔ף

    ʾAsaf · H0623H

    Asaph · v41

    The ancestor and founder of the guild: a Levite musician whom tradition placed in David's time (1 Chr 15:17–19; 16:4–7), and to whom Psalms 50 and 73–83 are attributed. His name served as the guild's name.

  10. מֵאָ֖ה

    meʾah · H3967

    hundred · v41

    The first part of the total. Hebrew gives the largest unit first: 'a hundred'.

  11. עֶשְׂרִ֥ים

    ʿesrim · H6242

    twenty · v41

    The tens part of the total.

  12. וּשְׁמֹנָֽה

    ushəmonah · H8083

    and eight · v41

    The units, joined by 'and'. The full number is 128, the men counted as belonging to the Asaphite singers who came back from Babylon in this register.

The world behind it

The list. Ezra 2 (repeated almost word for word in Nehemiah 7) records the Judeans who returned from Babylon after Cyrus of Persia allowed exiles to go home in 538 BC. It probably gathers returns over the next two decades under Zerubbabel and the high priest Jeshua. It is organised by rank and role: lay families by clan or town (vv. 2–35), then priests (vv. 36–39), Levites (v. 40), singers (v. 41), gatekeepers (v. 42), temple servants and "Solomon's servants" (vv. 43–58), and finally people who could not prove their descent (vv. 59–63). Being in the register mattered. It established who belonged to the restored community and who could serve at the altar (vv. 61–63).

Why so few Levites? The imbalance is real and appears in both versions of the list. Scholars suggest several reasons, and they may all have played a part:

  • Loss of status. Ezekiel 44:10–14 had restricted the Levites to subordinate service and reserved the altar for the priests. That left little incentive to give up a settled life in Babylon for menial work in a ruined city.
  • Settlement in exile. Two generations on, many families had put down roots. Ezra found the same reluctance decades later and had to recruit Levites specially from a place called Casiphia (Ezra 8:15–20).
  • Narrow definition. At this stage the singers and gatekeepers are counted separately (128 + 139). Chronicles, written later, counts them as Levites, which would raise the total considerably.

These families afterward. Jeshua and Kadmiel head the Levites who supervise the rebuilding of the temple (Ezra 3:9). They lead public confession and prayer (Neh 9:4–5) and seal the covenant (Neh 10:9). So this small group carried a large share of the work of the restored cult.

From the study of Ezra 2:40.

Where scholars differ

in v40

How do Jeshua, Kadmiel and Hodaviah relate to one another?

  • Jeshua and Kadmiel are two branches of the single older clan of Hodaviah.

    The most natural sense of the preposition le- ('belonging to') attached to 'sons of'. Followed by BSB and NIV.

  • Hodaviah (and possibly Binnui) was a separate parallel family, and the Hebrew has been simplified or corrupted.

    1 Esdras 5:26 lists four names side by side. Elsewhere Jeshua, Binnui and Kadmiel appear as a trio (Neh 10:9; 12:8). Nehemiah 7:43 repeats the preposition, which suggests confusion in transmission.

  • Only Kadmiel is described as belonging to Hodaviah ('Jeshua, and Kadmiel of the sons of Hodaviah').

    The Hebrew word order allows it. Nehemiah 7:43's 'to Kadmiel, to the sons of Hodevah' can be read as a chain of descent.

in v40

Why did so few Levites return?

  • Their status had been lowered and the work was menial, so few were willing to leave Babylon.

    Ezekiel 44:10–14 restricts Levites to subordinate duties. Ezra 8:15–20 shows ongoing reluctance.

  • The low figure partly reflects a narrow definition, since singers and gatekeepers are counted separately here.

    Ezra 2:41–42 lists them apart (267 more men). Chronicles later classes them as Levites.

in v41

Were the singers Levites when this list was drawn up?

  • No. At this stage the singers were a separate group that only later came to count as Levites.

    Ezra 2:40–42 and Neh 7:43–45 list Levites, singers and gatekeepers as distinct categories. Hartmut Gese, followed by many, traced stages: (1) singers called simply 'sons of Asaph', not Levites (Ezra 2); (2) Asaphites counted among Levites (Neh 11:17); (3) three guilds of Asaph, Heman and Jeduthun (1 Chr 16; 25); (4) Heman, Asaph and Ethan (1 Chr 15:17–19).

  • They were already Levites, and the list simply separates them by function.

    Chronicles traces Asaph to Levi (1 Chr 6:39–43). Ezra 3:10 itself speaks of 'the Levites, the sons of Asaph'. A register sorting staff by job could list singers apart from other Levites without denying their Levitical descent.

in v41

Why does only Asaph's guild appear?

  • At first, Asaph's line was the only singer guild.

    Asaph is the only singer ancestor named in Ezra 2 and Neh 7. Heman and Jeduthun appear in Chronicles, which may reflect a later reorganization.

  • Other guilds existed, but they did not return or were not recorded in this list.

    Jeduthun appears in Neh 11:17, and Chronicles presents all three guilds as going back to the monarchy. Their absence here may reflect who came back in this particular wave.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. לֵוִי, בֵּן, הוֹדַוְיָה, קַדְמִיאֵל
  • HALOT s.v. לֵוִי, הוֹדַוְיָה
  • H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16), on Ezra 2:40 and Neh 7:43
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library), on Ezra 2
  • Parallel texts: Nehemiah 7:43; 1 Esdras 5:26; Ezra 3:9; 8:15–20; Ezekiel 44:10–16
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezra 2
  • BDB s.v. שִׁיר
  • HALOT s.v. שׁיר (Polel participle 'singer')
  • HALOT s.v. בֵּן (member of a group or guild)
  • H. Gese, 'Zur Geschichte der Kultsänger am zweiten Tempel' (1963)
  • H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
  • Septuagint 2 Esdras 2:41; 1 Esdras 5:27
  • Nehemiah 7:44 (parallel list)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.