Genesis Chapter 30 Read as one passage

Genesis 30:41–42

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

41Whenever the stronger females of the flock were in heat, Jacob would place the branches in the troughs, in full view of the animals, so that they would breed in front of the branches. 42But if the animals were weak, he did not set out the branches. So the weaker animals went to Laban and the stronger ones to Jacob.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this was a story about their ancestor and namesake, Jacob/Israel, getting the better of Laban the Aramean. Laban had cheated him over Leah (29:25) and changed his wages repeatedly (31:7). The scene would have been satisfying and funny: the man named "White" loses his best animals to white-peeled sticks.

Shepherding peoples would have recognized the detail immediately: the troughs where animals gather and mate, the choice of sturdy breeding stock over weak animals, the belief about what a ewe sees. They would also have caught the moral turn. Laban stripped the flock of every marked animal to make sure Jacob got nothing. Jacob answered with cunning and kept the strong animals for himself. Yet the larger story (31:9–12, 42) insists that Israel's ancestor came home rich because God saw his mistreatment and overruled Laban's schemes, not only because of his own tricks. The hearers' own wealth and identity as a people of flocks were traced back to this protection.

From the study of Genesis 30:41.

Verse by verse

  1. 41Whenever the stronger females of the flock were in heat, Jacob would place the branches in the troughs, in full view of the animals, so that they would breed in front of the branches.

    It became Jacob's regular practice: every breeding season, whenever the sturdy, well-built females of the flock came into heat, he would set his peeled, white-striped branches in the watering troughs, right before their eyes, so that they would mate there among the branches.

    Some things the English tends to lose:

    • Habit, not one event. The Hebrew grammar describes something Jacob did repeatedly: "whenever… he would set."
    • Heat, not pregnancy. The verb used twice comes from a word for heat. It describes animals in season and ready to mate. The verse opens with the flock coming into heat and closes with Jacob's purpose, to bring them into heat at the rods.
    • "Strong" means firmly built. The word translated "stronger" literally means "bound, knit together": compact, firm-bodied animals. An ancient Jewish reading takes it as "the early breeders". Either way, Jacob is choosing Laban's best stock for his own wages. The next verse finishes the thought: the weak animals went to Laban, the strong to Jacob.
    • What the animals see is the point. The striped stick sits "before the eyes" of the flock because people of the time believed that what a female looked at during mating marked her young.
    • A pun on Laban's name. In the verses just before, Jacob peels "white" (lavan) stripes into branches of the "white" poplar to beat Laban, whose name means "White". The trickster is out-tricking the man who tricked him.
    Full study →
  2. 42But if the animals were weak, he did not set out the branches. So the weaker animals went to Laban and the stronger ones to Jacob.

    "But whenever the animals in heat were the weak, sickly ones, he would leave the peeled rods out. So, season after season, it turned out that the feeble stock went to Laban and the sturdy, solid-bodied stock went to Jacob."

    This verse completes the method described in verse 41. Jacob did not put his white-streaked rods in front of every mating animal. He used them only for the robust ones (literally the "firmly knit" or "tightly bound" animals) and deliberately held back with the weak ones. The verbs describe a repeated habit, not one clever move: this was a policy carried out over years of breeding. Because Jacob's wages were the rare dark or speckled animals, every strong animal born in his colours became his, and the plain-coloured offspring of weak parents stayed Laban's.

    The sentence ends by setting two names side by side, and the first hearers would have caught the pun. Laban means "White." Jacob had used white streaks peeled into white-poplar rods against the man named White. The result: the feeble ones to "White," the sturdy ones to Jacob. The uncle who had tricked Jacob over Leah and Rachel is now outmanoeuvred at his own watering troughs. Two chapters later Jacob gives the credit not to his rods but to God (31:9-12).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v41

    cattle (KJV)

    tsōʾn

    What we hear
    Cows: bovine livestock.
    What they heard
    The flock of small livestock, sheep and goats together. In 1611 "cattle" could mean any livestock.
  • in v41

    gutters (KJV, YLT)

    rəhāṭîm

    What we hear
    Roof drains or street channels for dirty runoff.
    What they heard
    Watering troughs or channels at a well, where flocks were brought to drink.
  • in v41

    did conceive (KJV)

    yaḥēm

    What we hear
    Had become pregnant, so the rods were set out after conception.
    What they heard
    Came into heat, were in season to mate. The rods were set out at the time of mating.
  • in v42

    cattle (KJV)

    ṣōʾn

    What we hear
    Cows and bulls.
    What they heard
    A mixed flock of sheep and goats. No cattle are involved in this episode.
  • in v42

    he put them not in (KJV, WEB)

    lōʾ yāśîm

    What we hear
    He did not put the weak animals in (a pen or the breeding group).
    What they heard
    He did not put the peeled rods (the object carried over from v.41) in the troughs in front of the weak animals.
Every word
  1. וְהָיָ֗ה

    wəhāyāh · H1961

    and it was / it would be · v41, v42

    Starts a description of something that happened over and over. With the verb form that follows, it gives the sense "it used to happen that…", a habit Jacob kept up season after season, not a single event.

  2. בְּכָל־

    bəkhol · H3605

    in all, every · v41

    With the preposition "in" and an infinitive, it means "whenever" or "every time that". It stresses that the practice was regular.

  3. יַחֵם֮

    yaḥēm · H3179

    to be hot, be in heat, conceive · v41

    An infinitive: "the coming into heat of". The root means "be warm, hot", and it is the ordinary word for an animal in season and ready to mate. The picture is the breeding season, not the moment of pregnancy.

  4. הַצֹּ֣אן

    haṣṣōʾn · H6629G

    flock, small livestock · v41, v42

    The mixed flock of sheep and goats. The word is collective (one word for the whole flock) and treated as feminine, which explains the feminine forms around it.

  5. הַמְקֻשָּׁרוֹת֒

    haməqushshārôt · H7194

    to tie, bind; (pual) be bound, knit firm · v41, v42

    A feminine plural passive participle, literally "the bound/tied ones". It most likely means compact, firmly built, sturdy animals. Its opposite in v. 42 is the "feeble" ones. An old Jewish line of interpretation reads it as "the early-breeding ones" instead.

  6. וְשָׂ֨ם

    wəśām · H7760H

    and he set, placed · v41, v42

    "And he would set." This continues the habitual sense: each time this happened, Jacob would put the rods out.

  7. יַעֲקֹ֧ב

    yaʿăqōv · H3290

    Jacob · v41, v42

    The subject. In this story his name has already been tied to grabbing and supplanting (Gen 25:26; 27:36), and the scene shows him outmaneuvering Laban.

  8. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    [marks the object] · v41

    An untranslated marker showing that "the rods" is the definite object of the verb.

  9. הַמַּקְל֛וֹת

    hammaqlôt · H4731

    rod, staff, stick, cut branch · v41

    "The rods": the particular fresh branches of poplar, almond and plane tree from v. 37, which Jacob had peeled in strips so the white wood showed through.

  10. לְעֵינֵ֥י

    ləʿênê · H5869A

    to the eyes of · v41

    "Before the eyes of", meaning in plain sight of. The phrase matters because the whole method depends on the animals seeing the striped rods while they mate.

  11. בָּרֳהָטִ֑ים

    bārŏhāṭîm · H7298A

    trough, watering channel · v41

    "In the troughs": the watering troughs or channels of v. 38, where the animals gathered to drink and, according to v. 38, came into heat.

  12. וּבְהַעֲטִ֥יף

    ûḇəhaʿăṭîp̄ · H5848

    to be feeble, faint · v42

    'And when [the flock] was feeble.' The 'when' is a time phrase ('in the being-feeble of'). Although the verb form is often called causative, here it describes a state the animals were in, not something done to them: whenever the animals in heat were the weak, sickly ones.

  13. לֹ֣א

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v42

    Plain negation. It goes with the verb that follows: he deliberately held back.

  14. לְלָבָ֔ן

    ləlāḇān · H3837

    Laban (name meaning 'white') · v42

    'Belonging to Laban.' The little word 'to' marks who owns them. Laban's name means 'white', and the episode has been playing on that name all along (the white streaks on the rods, v.37).

The world behind it

The wage deal. Jacob had agreed to take as his pay every speckled, spotted or dark lamb and every speckled or spotted goat (30:32–33). These were normally a minority in Near Eastern flocks, where sheep were mostly white and goats mostly black or brown. Laban at once removed every marked animal and sent them three days' journey away with his sons (30:35–36). Jacob was left with a plain-colored flock that should have produced few marked young.

Maternal impression. The ancient world widely believed that what a mother sees or imagines at conception can shape the appearance of her offspring. Later Greek and Roman writers report it for animal and human births. For example, the Greek poet Oppian (2nd century AD) describes horse breeders painting or decorating mares to produce spotted foals, and Jerome and the rabbis tell stories of a child resembling a picture its mother had looked at. Jacob's peeled rods apply this folk belief: striped things in front of the eyes, striped young in the womb.

Real husbandry alongside it. The verse also describes a real breeder's skill: choosing the robust animals for the breeding Jacob wanted. Plain-looking animals can carry hidden color genes, and repeatedly breeding the best stock would build up a strong marked flock. The text does not explain this. It simply shows an experienced shepherd (31:38–40) working the system.

The narrator's own answer. Genesis does not leave the rods as the final explanation. In 31:9–12 Jacob tells his wives that God took Laban's livestock and gave it to him. In a dream he saw that the males mounting the flock were already streaked, speckled and spotted, "for I have seen all that Laban is doing to you." The story sets Jacob's technique and God's hidden involvement side by side.

From the study of Genesis 30:41.

Where scholars differ

in v41

What does הַמְקֻשָּׁרוֹת ("the stronger") mean?

  • Sturdy, robust, firmly built animals.

    The root means "bind, tie", and the passive gives "knit firm, compact". It is set against הָעֲטֻפִים in v. 42, which usually means "feeble, faint" (see Ps 61:2; Lam 2:11–12 for ʿāṭaf as "grow faint"). BDB, HALOT and most modern versions.

  • Early-breeding animals (spring breeders), versus late breeders.

    Targum Onkelos ("the early ones… the late ones"), followed by Jerome's Vulgate and noted by Rashi. It reflects ancient shepherding knowledge that early-season lambs were stronger.

in v41

What actually produced Jacob's marked flock, according to the text?

  • The narrator presents Jacob's folk technique (maternal impression) at face value, as his trick.

    Vv. 37–42 describe the method and its result (v. 39: "they bore streaked, speckled and spotted") without comment.

  • The larger narrative credits God, and the rods are Jacob's own idea of how it worked.

    Gen 31:9–12: God "took away your father's livestock and gave them to me". The dream shows the breeding males were already marked, "for I have seen all that Laban is doing to you." See also 31:42.

  • A real husbandry effect lies behind the story: selective breeding (and, some suggest, substances in the peeled bark).

    Choosing sturdy animals that may carry hidden color genes would raise the number of marked young. Suggestions about chemical effects of poplar or almond bark are speculative and not well supported.

in v42

What do the paired terms ʿăṭupîm / qəšurîm mean?

  • 'Feeble' versus 'strong/sturdy' animals.

    These are the ordinary meanings of the roots (ʿāṭap̄ 'grow faint', Lam 2:11-19, Jonah 2:7; qāšar 'bind', so 'firmly knit'). This view is followed by BDB, HALOT and nearly all modern translations.

  • 'Late-breeding' versus 'early-breeding' animals.

    Targum Onkelos and the Vulgate render the words this way, and Rashi and Jerome explain it with ancient herding practice, where earlier-season young were judged stronger. It fits the farming background but has a weaker basis in the meanings of the words.

  • 'Unmarked' versus 'marked' animals.

    The Septuagint's rendering ties v.42 directly to the colour terms of the wage deal. It is probably an interpretive translation rather than evidence for a different Hebrew text.

in v42

What actually produced Jacob's flock?

  • The narrative records Jacob's folk technique (the rods) as the means.

    30:37-41 describes the rods in detail and v.43 states the result. The ancient belief that what a female sees at conception marks her young is well attested.

  • Selective breeding is the real mechanism the text describes in v.42.

    Jacob deliberately applies his method only to the strong breeders (30:41-42). Many commentators note that strong animals carrying hidden genes for off-colours would give his result.

  • God gave the increase, whatever Jacob's methods.

    In 31:9-12 Jacob says God took Laban's livestock and gave it to him, and describes a dream revealing the speckled males. Commentators such as Wenham and Sarna read the juxtaposition as showing that the blessing, not the technique, was decisive.

in v42

Was Jacob acting fraudulently?

  • Jacob's practice was sharp dealing that bordered on cheating his employer.

    He secretly manipulated breeding to the owner's loss. Laban's sons complain that 'Jacob has taken all that was our father's' (31:1).

  • The narrative presents it as legitimate turnabout against an exploitative employer.

    Laban first stripped the flock of all marked animals (30:35-36) and changed Jacob's wages ten times (31:7). Jacob kept the letter of the agreement. The narrator and the angel in the dream (31:12) side with Jacob.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. קָשַׁר, יָחַם, מַקֵּל, רַהַט
  • HALOT s.v. קשׁר, יחם, מַקֵּל, רַ֫הַט, עטף
  • Targum Onkelos, Genesis 30:41–42
  • Vulgate, Genesis 30:41–42
  • Septuagint, Genesis 30:41–42
  • Rashi on Genesis 30:41
  • N. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis (on 30:37–43)
  • G. Wenham, Word Biblical Commentary: Genesis 16–50
  • C. Westermann, Genesis 12–36
  • Oppian, Cynegetica 1 (maternal impression in horse breeding)
  • BDB s.v. עָטַף (III, 'be feeble, faint')
  • BDB s.v. קָשַׁר ('bind'; Gen 30:41-42 'strong')
  • HALOT s.v. עטף II; קשׁר
  • HALOT s.v. צֹאן
  • Septuagint, Genesis 30:41-42
  • Targum Onkelos, Genesis 30:41-42
  • Vulgate, Genesis 30:41-42; Jerome, Hebrew Questions on Genesis
  • Rashi on Genesis 30:41-42
  • Laws of Hammurabi §§261-267 (herdsmen)
  • G. J. Wenham, Genesis 16-50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • N. M. Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
  • V. P. Hamilton, The Book of Genesis 18-50 (NICOT)
  • J. H. Walton et al., IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).