Genesis Chapter 37 Read as one passage

Genesis 37:19–20

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

19“Here comes that dreamer!” they said to one another. 20“Come now, let us kill him and throw him into one of the pits. We can say that a vicious animal has devoured him. Then we shall see what becomes of his dreams!”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites hearing the Joseph story, this line marks the point of no return in the family's breakdown. The brothers' hatred, building since the robe and the dreams, now finds words. Their contempt is wrapped in a nickname that reduces Joseph to his offensive dreams.

Listeners would have caught the irony at once. The brothers think they can stop the dreams by killing the dreamer (verse 20). The rest of the story shows that the dreams come true through the brothers' own actions: selling Joseph leads to Egypt, Egypt leads to his rise, and his rise brings them to bow before him (42:6; 50:18). The title "master of dreams" turns out to be literally true when Joseph interprets dreams for the cupbearer, the baker and Pharaoh. This fits the story's larger point, stated by Joseph at the end: "You meant evil against me, but God meant it for good" (50:20). Human schemes do not cancel what God has announced.

The scene also bears on the tribes' own identity: Israel's ancestors, the heads of the twelve tribes, are shown plotting fratricide (the killing of a brother). This echoes Cain and Abel and Jacob and Esau. The story faces honestly the violence inside the founding family and moves toward its reconciliation.

From the study of Genesis 37:19.

Verse by verse

  1. 19“Here comes that dreamer!” they said to one another.

    As Joseph comes into view across the fields near Dothan, the brothers turn to one another, each passing the word to the next, and sneer: "Look, there he is! His Lordship of the Dreams, that one over there, coming our way!"

    The nickname the English renders "dreamer" is literally "owner/master of the dreams." It does not mean an idealist with big hopes. It points to the two night dreams Joseph had told them, in which their sheaves and then the sun, moon and eleven stars bowed down to him. Calling him "master" of those dreams is a jab at the very thing that enraged them: his dreams made him lord over his brothers. The word for "that one" is rare and emphatic. It points at a figure in the distance and keeps him at arm's length; they do not use his name. The phrasing "said a man to his brother" is the normal Hebrew idiom for "said to one another," but in a story of brothers plotting against a brother it carries a quiet irony.

    The narrator lets a second irony stand: the mocking title will prove true. Joseph really will become the master of dreams, interpreting them in Egypt, and these same brothers will bow before him exactly as he dreamed.

    Full study →
  2. 20“Come now, let us kill him and throw him into one of the pits. We can say that a vicious animal has devoured him. Then we shall see what becomes of his dreams!”

    "So now, come on! Let's kill him and toss his body into one of these cisterns around here. We'll say a savage wild animal got him and ate him. Then we'll see what comes of his dreams!"

    The speakers are Joseph's older brothers, out with the flocks near Dothan. They see him coming in the distance (v.19 calls him "the dream-master") and, before he reaches them, they agree on a murder and the story to cover it. The verb for "kill" is the one Genesis used for Cain killing Abel and for Esau's threat to kill Jacob. That puts them in a line of brothers who want a brother dead. "Throw him" is the language of disposing of rubbish. The "pits" are rock-cut water cisterns, deep and narrow-mouthed, where a body would disappear for good.

    The cover story is believable: in grazing country, predators really did kill shepherds. The beast is "bad" in the sense of dangerous, not "evil" in a moral sense. "Has eaten him" explains why no body could be produced.

    The last line is a sneer. Joseph's dreams were taken as signs of the future, showing his family bowing to him. The brothers think that killing the dreamer will kill the forecast: "We'll see what his dreams turn out to be." The story answers them. The exact words they planned to say, "a harmful beast has eaten him", come out of their father's own mouth (v.37:33). Years later the brothers bow to the ground before Joseph, and he remembers the dreams (42:6–9). They did "see what became of his dreams".

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v19

    dreamer

    ba'al ha-chalomot

    What we hear
    An idealist or visionary; someone with big ambitions or goals for his life, perhaps unrealistic.
    What they heard
    A mocking title: 'the master of the dreams,' i.e. the one who had (and kept telling) the night dreams in which his family bowed to him. The jab is at his claim to lordship, not at his ambition.
  • in v20

    evil beast (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    chayyah ra'ah

    What we hear
    A wicked or even demonic creature; moral evil.
    What they heard
    A dangerous, savage wild animal: a predator. Ra' here means 'harmful', not 'morally wicked'.
  • in v20

    his dreams

    chalomotav

    What we hear
    His ambitions, life goals or personal vision ('follow your dreams').
    What they heard
    The two dreams he literally had while asleep, which were taken as signs of what was coming (his family bowing to him).
  • in v20

    pit

    bor

    What we hear
    A shallow hole or ditch in the ground.
    What they heard
    A deep, rock-cut water cistern with a narrow mouth, from which escape was nearly impossible. The same word is used for a dungeon (Gen 40:15) and, in poetry, for the grave.
Every word
  1. וַיֹּאמְר֖וּ

    vayyomeru · H0559

    and they said · v19, v20

    The ordinary narrative verb for speech, continuing the scene of verse 18 where the brothers spot Joseph far off and begin to plot. What follows is what they say to each other before he arrives.

  2. אִ֣ישׁ

    ish · H0376

    man, each one · v19

    Here used distributively, 'each one,' as part of the idiom 'a man to his brother' meaning 'to one another.' It shows the remark passing around the group, not one brother's isolated comment.

  3. אֶל־

    el · H0413

    to, toward · v19

    Marks who is being addressed: the brothers speak among themselves, out of Joseph's hearing.

  4. אָחִ֑יו

    achiv · H0251

    his brother · v19

    In the idiom it simply means 'one another,' but the word is literally 'brother.' In a chapter about brothers turning on their brother, the idiom quietly underlines the irony: brothers agree with each other about killing a brother.

  5. הִנֵּ֗ה

    hinneh · H2009

    look!, behold · v19

    A pointing word that grabs attention and puts the scene before the eyes: 'Look!' or 'There he is!' Paired with the participle 'coming,' it captures the moment of spotting him on the horizon.

  6. בַּ֛עַל

    ba'al · H1167

    owner, master, possessor of · v19

    Joined to another noun, it describes someone defined by or possessing that thing ('owner of dreams'). Here it is a mocking nickname: 'Mr. Dreams,' 'the dream-master,' with a sneer at the 'master' who dreamed he would rule them.

  7. הַחֲלֹמ֥וֹת

    ha-chalomot · H2472

    the dreams · v19, v20

    The definite article points to particular dreams: the two night dreams Joseph told them (37:5–11), the sheaves bowing to his sheaf and the sun, moon and eleven stars bowing to him. These are not hopes or ambitions but sleep-visions understood as messages about the future.

  8. הַלָּזֶ֖ה

    hallazeh · H1976

    this, that one (yonder) · v19

    A rare, emphatic pointing word ('that one there'), found only here and in Genesis 24:65. It points to someone at a distance and, in this mouth, has a dismissive edge: 'that one.'

  9. בָּֽא׃

    ba · H0935

    coming · v19

    A participle, describing action in progress: 'is coming,' 'on his way.' He is approaching, unaware; the brothers have the time it takes him to arrive to settle what they will do.

  10. וְעַתָּה

    ve'attah · H6258

    and now · v20

    Marks the turn from observation to action: Joseph has just been spotted coming (v.19), so 'now' is the moment to act. It gives the plan a sense of sudden opportunity.

  11. לְכוּ

    lekhu · H1980

    go; come! · v20

    Literally 'go!' (plural command), but used as a rallying word, 'Come on!', urging the group to act together. The brothers egg one another on.

  12. וְנַהַרְגֵהוּ

    venahargehu · H2026

    kill, slay · v20

    'And let us kill him.' The ordinary Hebrew verb for a violent killing by human hands. It is the same verb used when Cain killed his brother Abel (Gen 4:8) and when Esau vowed to kill his brother Jacob (Gen 27:41).

  13. וְנַשְׁלִכֵהוּ

    venashlikhehu · H7993

    throw, cast, fling · v20

    'And let us throw him.' A verb of discarding: things you fling away. The plan treats Joseph's body as refuse to be disposed of with no burial.

  14. בְּאַחַד

    be'achad · H259

    one · v20

    'Into one of': any one will do. The casualness is part of the picture; the land around Dothan has several such pits.

  15. הַבֹּרוֹת

    habborot · H953

    pit, cistern · v20

    'The pits': rock-cut water cisterns in the herding country. Verse 24 says the one they used was empty, with no water in it. A deep, narrow-mouthed cistern was a place a body would vanish and a living man could not climb out of.

  16. חַיָּה

    chayyah · H2416

    living thing; wild animal · v20

    Here it means a wild animal, as opposed to livestock. In open grazing country, lions, bears and wolves were a real danger to shepherds and flocks.

  17. רָעָה

    ra'ah · H7451

    bad, harmful, evil · v20

    Describes the animal as dangerous or savage, not morally wicked. 'A bad beast' in the sense of a vicious, harmful one.

  18. אֲכָלָתְהוּ

    akhalatehu · H398

    eat, devour · v20

    'Has eaten him': the verb form presents it as a done deed. That the body was eaten explains why there is no body to show. Jacob later says these exact three Hebrew words himself (v.33).

  19. וְנִרְאֶה

    venir'eh · H7200

    see · v20

    'And let us see' / 'then we will see.' Sarcastic: with the dreamer dead, they will watch his dreams come to nothing. The story will turn the sarcasm back on them.

  20. מַה

    mah · H4100

    what? · v20

    'What': here a mocking question, close to 'what good will his dreams be then?'

  21. יִּהְיוּ

    yihyu · H1961

    be, become, happen · v20

    'Will they be / become': whether the dreams will actually happen. The whole question is about whether the dreams will be fulfilled.

The world behind it
  • The dreams. In Genesis 37:5–11 Joseph, seventeen and his father's favourite (marked by the special robe of 37:3), tells his brothers two dreams: their sheaves bowing to his sheaf, and the sun, moon and eleven stars bowing to him. In the ancient Near East such dreams were commonly taken as messages from God about the future, not as private fantasies. That is why the brothers do not laugh them off but "hated him even more" (37:8). They feared the dreams might be real.
  • The scene. Jacob sends Joseph from Hebron to check on his brothers pasturing the flocks; he finds them at Dothan, far from home and from their father (37:12–17). They recognise him from a distance (probably by the robe) and plot before he reaches them (37:18). This verse is their first spoken reaction, and verse 20 follows straight on: kill him, throw him in a pit, blame a wild animal, "and we shall see what becomes of his dreams."
  • Later echo. The KJV wording of verses 19–20 ("Behold, this dreamer cometh… we shall see what will become of his dreams") is inscribed at the Lorraine Motel in Memphis, where Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated. That use plays on the modern 'visionary' sense of "dreamer" alongside the story's theme of killing a man to kill his dream. It is a powerful later application, though in Genesis the dreams are night visions about rule, not a social vision.

From the study of Genesis 37:19.

Where scholars differ

in v19

Is 'master of dreams' just a sneer, or does it hint at a dream-specialist?

  • A sarcastic nickname: 'the dream-man,' 'Mr. Dreams.'

    The ba'al + noun pattern commonly just describes someone by a trait (hairy man, hot-tempered man). The context is pure hostility (37:8, 18, 20).

  • It also carries an ironic hint of 'dream-expert,' foreshadowing Joseph's role as interpreter.

    Ancient Near Eastern cultures had professional dream interpreters, and Genesis 40–41 makes Joseph exactly that. The narrator may intend the title to read differently in hindsight. This is a literary reading about the narrator's design, not a claim that the brothers meant it.

in v19

Is hallazeh ('that one') contemptuous in itself?

  • Yes, it has a dismissive, distancing tone here.

    Many commentators hear scorn in the brothers' refusal to name him, pointing at him instead.

  • It is mainly a pointing word for something at a distance; the contempt comes from context.

    Its only other use (Genesis 24:65, Rebekah asking about Isaac) is neutral and also concerns a man seen far off.

in v20

Is Genesis 37 one unified story, or two versions woven together (Reuben and Midianites vs. Judah and Ishmaelites)?

  • Two sources combined: a 'Reuben' strand and a 'Judah' strand, often labelled E and J in the documentary hypothesis, the theory that the Pentateuch was combined from earlier written sources.

    Two brothers each try to save Joseph (Reuben, vv.21–22, 29–30; Judah, vv.26–27). Both Midianites and Ishmaelites appear as traders (vv.25, 28, 36). Reuben seems unaware of the sale. Scholars such as Westermann and many source critics read these as duplications.

  • A single, deliberately crafted narrative.

    Literary readers (e.g., Alter, Wenham) argue that the repetitions are purposeful. Reuben's absence explains his shock. 'Midianites' and 'Ishmaelites' may overlap as terms for desert caravan traders (compare Judg 8:24). The Reuben/Judah contrast sets up Judah's later leadership in chs. 43–44. On either view, v.20 is the brothers' shared plan, which both rescuers then modify.

in v20

Does 'the pit' (bor) carry an overtone of death and the underworld here?

  • Yes, a deliberate overtone.

    In biblical poetry bor is a common term for the grave or Sheol (Ps 28:1; 30:3; 88:4; Isa 14:15). Jacob says he will 'go down to Sheol' mourning Joseph (37:35). Joseph's prison in Egypt is also called a bor (40:15), and his release from it reads like a rising from death (41:14).

  • Primarily literal; any overtone is secondary.

    The verse uses the ordinary plural 'cisterns', and v.24 describes the physical detail (empty, no water). The underworld sense belongs mainly to poetry. The prose here is about getting rid of a body practically, so a symbolic reading should be offered as a possibility, not a certainty.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. בַּעַל (construct uses describing a possessor of a quality)
  • HALOT s.v. בַּעַל, חֲלוֹם, הַלָּזֶה
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §34f on הַלָּזֶה
  • Septuagint, Genesis 37:19
  • Vulgate, Genesis 37:19
  • Targum Onkelos, Genesis 37:19
  • Gordon Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Nahum Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis
  • Robert Alter, The Five Books of Moses (note on 'master of dreams')
  • Victor Hamilton, The Book of Genesis 18–50 (NICOT)
  • BDB s.v. הָרַג, בּוֹר, רַע, חֲלוֹם
  • HALOT s.v. הרג; בּוֹר; רַע; חַיָּה
  • Nahum Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
  • Robert Alter, Genesis: Translation and Commentary
  • Claus Westermann, Genesis 37–50
  • John Walton, Victor Matthews, Mark Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Genesis 37:20, 33
  • Vulgate, Genesis 37:20, 33
  • Chester Beatty Papyrus III (Egyptian dream book)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).