Hosea Chapter 4 Read as one passage

Hosea 4:11–12

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

11to promiscuity, wine, and new wine, which take away understanding. 12My people consult their wooden idols, and their divining rods inform them. For a spirit of prostitution leads them astray and they have played the harlot against their God.

What the first hearers heard

To an Israelite in Samaria or at a hilltop shrine, the saying would have sounded like common wisdom: everyone knows sex and drink cloud your judgment. Hosea turns that common wisdom into an accusation. The feasts Israel treated as worship, where the new harvest wine flowed and sexual activity was part of the celebration, were the very things emptying the nation of understanding.

That is why the chapter's charge is about knowledge. Covenant knowledge of God meant knowing him personally and knowing his ways and teaching, which priests were meant to preserve and teach (4:6). It was being lost. A people whose "heart" has been taken can no longer tell YHWH's gifts from Baal's or the true God from a carved stick (4:12). The verse explains how a nation slides into the "spirit of whoredom" of the next line: what they chose clouded their judgment, and their clouded judgment led them further from YHWH.

For the first hearers the saying also carried a threat. Verse 10 has just said they will "eat but not be satisfied." The harvest they celebrated without thinking was the harvest YHWH had said he would take back (2:9).

From the study of Hosea 4:11.

Verse by verse

  1. 11to promiscuity, wine, and new wine, which take away understanding.

    Sexual unfaithfulness, wine, and fresh wine of the harvest: together they carry off a person's mind.

    The verse reads like a well-known proverb, short and general. "This is what these things always do." Hosea applies it to Israel. The three things listed are not random vices. They are what went on at the feasts held at the hilltop shrines: drinking the new vintage, and sexual activity that was also a betrayal of Israel's God, the way an unfaithful wife betrays her husband. The "new wine" is the harvest wine that YHWH gave and Israel thanked Baal for (2:8).

    What these things take is the heart. In Hebrew that does not mean the feelings. It means the mind: judgment, discernment, the ability to think clearly and choose rightly. So the saying is not mainly "these things win your affections." It is "these things leave you without sense." That is the charge of the whole chapter: "there is no knowledge of God in the land" (4:1), "my people are destroyed for lack of knowledge" (4:6). The next verse shows it happening: a people with their wits gone ask a wooden idol and a divining stick for answers (4:12).

    Many translations attach "whoredom" to the end of verse 10, which gives: "they have abandoned the LORD to devote themselves to whoredom; wine and new wine take away the understanding." Either way, the point stands. What they turned to in place of YHWH is the very thing that destroys their ability to know him.

    Full study →
  2. 12My people consult their wooden idols, and their divining rods inform them. For a spirit of prostitution leads them astray and they have played the harlot against their God.

    "My people, my own people, put their questions to a piece of wood, and their walking-stick gives them their answers. Because a gust of promiscuity has got hold of them and sent them reeling off the road like drunks, and they have gone whoring out from under their God, slipping out from under the husband they belong to."

    The verse opens with God's own claim, "my people," and immediately sets it against what they do. They use the language of seeking God's will ("inquire of", the phrase used when Israel asked the LORD for direction) and aim it at wood, perhaps a carved image or pole, perhaps one of the sacred trees where they worship (verse 13). Then a stick, the kind a shepherd or traveller carries, is given the job of a prophet: it "tells" them what to do. The two plain words, wood and stick, are deliberately flat and mocking.

    The "for" gives the reason underneath. A rûaḥ, a wind, a driving urge, of habitual unfaithfulness has taken control. The verb pictures someone staggering off the path, picking up the wine of the previous verse that "takes away the heart." The result is stated in marriage-law language: Israel, God's wife, has gone sleeping around "from under" him. In Israel's law a wife was "under" her husband's authority and protection, and Hosea's hearers would have recognised the language of a woman who has left her husband's bed and household. The sentence also shifts quietly from "my people" to "their God": God, speaking, has started talking about them rather than to them.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v11

    take away the heart (KJV); take the heart (YLT)

    yiqqach lev

    What we hear
    These things steal your love or affection; they win your emotional devotion.
    What they heard
    These things carry off your mind: your judgment, discernment and ability to think and decide.
  • in v11

    new wine

    tirosh

    What we hear
    Unfermented grape juice, or a metaphor for spiritual renewal.
    What they heard
    Young wine of the new harvest, able to intoxicate (here it 'takes the heart'; its Ugaritic cognate is drunk 'to drunkenness').
  • in v11

    prostitution / promiscuity

    zenut

    What we hear
    Selling sex for money (prostitution), or simply having many sexual partners (promiscuity): a private sexual sin.
    What they heard
    Sexual unfaithfulness in a broad sense, and above all in Hosea, Israel's unfaithfulness to YHWH pictured as a wife's adultery. Here both senses are present together: sexual activity at the feasts and religious betrayal.
  • in v12

    prostitution / played the harlot

    zənûnîm / zānâ

    What we hear
    Selling sex for money; a sex-trade problem.
    What they heard
    Any sexual unfaithfulness by a woman outside the bond she was under (husband or father), and by extension Israel's disloyalty to the LORD by worshipping other gods. The picture is an unfaithful wife, not mainly a paid transaction.
  • in v12

    a spirit of prostitution

    rûaḥ zənûnîm

    What we hear
    A specific demon or evil spirit named 'Prostitution' that has to be cast out; or simply a 'bad attitude'.
    What they heard
    A driving force or compulsion, like a wind that carries someone along, which has taken hold of the nation (Hosea 5:4 puts it 'within them'). The same construction gives 'a spirit of jealousy' (Numbers 5:14) and 'a spirit of deep sleep' (Isaiah 29:10). The Hebrew can describe a force that comes from outside, but the text does not develop a named demon.
  • in v12

    wooden idols

    ʿēṣ

    What we hear
    A carved statue standing in a temple.
    What they heard
    Simply 'his wood', which could be a carved image, a wooden cult pole, or a living sacred tree at a hilltop shrine (compare verse 13).
Every word
  1. זְנ֛וּת

    zenut · H2184

    whoring, prostitution, sexual unfaithfulness · v11

    An abstract noun for the practice or condition of acting like a prostitute. In Hosea it covers literal sexual conduct at the hilltop shrines (4:13–14) and also Israel's unfaithfulness to YHWH as a wife unfaithful to her husband. It heads the list as the first thing that robs people of sense.

  2. וְיַ֥יִן

    veyayin · H3196

    and wine · v11

    The ordinary Hebrew word for fermented grape wine, the drink of feasts, offerings and joy, and of drunkenness. Here it is one of the forces that carry off a person's judgment.

  3. וְתִיר֖וֹשׁ

    vetirosh · H8492

    and new wine, fresh wine of the vintage · v11

    Wine from the new harvest, one of the three staple crops (grain, new wine, olive oil) that Hosea says Israel credited to Baal (2:8). Paired with yayin, it makes a full 'wine and more wine' pair. The verse plainly treats it as able to dull the mind.

  4. יִֽקַּֽח־

    yiqqach · H3947

    takes, takes away, seizes · v11

    Singular verb with a three-part subject: the three are treated as one combined force. The verb form describes what habitually happens, like a proverb: these things carry off the mind.

  5. לֵֽב׃

    lev · H3820

    heart, mind, understanding, will · v11

    In Hebrew the 'heart' is mainly the place of thinking, judging and deciding, not chiefly the feelings. To have your 'heart taken' is to lose your good sense and your ability to see clearly. There is no article or possessive: it is a general saying about 'the heart' of anyone.

  6. עַמִּי֙

    ʿammî · H5971A

    my people · v12

    God's own word for Israel, put first for emphasis and full of hurt. It echoes Hosea 1:9 and 2:23, where the child's name 'Lo-Ammi', 'Not my people', is reversed to 'You are my people'. The ones running to wood for answers are still his.

  7. בְּעֵצ֣וֹ

    bəʿēṣô · H6086G

    by/of his wood, tree · v12

    'Of his wood': either a carved wooden image or pole, or a living sacred tree like the oaks and terebinths of verse 13. The word is deliberately plain and a little contemptuous: they question a piece of timber. 'His' is singular because 'my people' is treated as one person.

  8. יִשְׁאָ֔ל

    yišʾāl · H7592

    he asks, inquires · v12

    With the preposition 'of/by' this is the set phrase for consulting an oracle, the same wording used when Israel 'inquired of the LORD' (Judges 1:1). Here the language of seeking God's guidance is aimed at wood. The verb form describes something they keep on doing.

  9. וּמַקְל֖וֹ

    ûmaqlô · H4731

    and his stick, rod, staff · v12

    An ordinary stick or staff, here used to tell fortunes: probably sticks thrown or held up so that the way they fell or pointed gave an answer. The words 'wood' and 'stick' pair up to mock the source of the 'revelation'.

  10. יַגִּ֣יד

    yaggîd · H5046

    it tells, declares · v12

    'Tells, makes known': a normal verb for reporting news, and also used of God or a prophet announcing what will happen. The irony is sharp: a stick is given the role of a prophet.

  11. ל֑וֹ

    lô · H9033

    to him · v12

    'To him', meaning the people seen as one person. The stick answers the person who asked it.

  12. כִּ֣י

    kî · H3588A

    for, because · v12

    Brings in the explanation. Behind the strange habit of consulting wood lies a deeper cause.

  13. ר֤וּחַ

    rûaḥ · H7307G

    wind, breath, spirit · v12

    A driving force that takes hold of a person: an impulse, a mood, a pull, like a wind that pushes someone along. Hosea 5:4 places this same 'spirit of whoredoms' 'within them'. It is a compulsion that has gripped the nation.

  14. זְנוּנִים֙

    zənûnîm · H2183

    whorings, promiscuity · v12

    Plural noun meaning sexual unfaithfulness as a habit or character, 'promiscuity' rather than a single act. It is the same word as in Hosea 1:2 ('a wife of whoredom'), tying the nation's behaviour to the prophet's marriage.

  15. הִתְעָ֔ה

    hitʿâ · H8582

    caused to wander, led astray · v12

    'Has made them wander', used of sheep straying off and of drunks staggering (Isaiah 19:14; 28:7; Job 12:25). Coming right after verse 11's wine that 'takes away the heart', it pictures a people reeling off the road under a drunken compulsion.

  16. וַיִּזְנ֖וּ

    wayyiznû · H2181

    and they whored, were promiscuous · v12

    'And so they went whoring', the result of being led astray. The verb normally describes a woman's sexual activity outside her proper bond to a husband or father. Here the people, as God's wife, are the subject.

  17. מִתַּ֥חַת

    mittaḥat · H8478H

    from under · v12

    Literally 'from under'. In Israelite law a married woman was 'under' her husband, under his authority and protection (Numbers 5:19–20, 29). To go whoring 'from under' God means slipping out from under the husband she belongs to.

  18. אֱלֹהֵיהֶֽם׃

    ʾĕlōhêhem · H0430G

    their God · v12

    'Their God', the LORD who is the nation's husband. The Hebrew form is grammatically plural but means the one God of Israel here, not 'gods'. Note the switch from 'my people' to 'their God': God now speaks about them, not to them.

The world behind it

Northern Israel, mid-8th century BC. Hosea spoke to the northern kingdom ("Ephraim") during the wealthy last years of Jeroboam II and the turmoil after him. Chapter 4 opens as a lawsuit YHWH brings against the land (4:1). Verses 4–10 target the priests, who "rejected knowledge" and "feed on the sin of my people" (4:6, 8). From verse 11 on, the charge widens to the whole people.

Worship on the hills. The following verses describe the scene: sacrifices "on the tops of the mountains" under shady trees (4:13), daughters and daughters-in-law engaging in sexual activity, and men "going aside" with women called qedeshot (4:14). Exactly what the qedeshot did is debated (see Debates). Drinking at these feasts was heavy: "when their drink is gone, they keep on whoring" (4:18). Amos, a contemporary, mocks the rich at their feasts "drinking wine from bowls" (Amos 6:6).

Grain, new wine and oil. These three farm products were the measure of whether the land was blessed. Hosea's accusation is that Israel credited them to Baal, the Canaanite storm and fertility god, and celebrated the harvest in his style (2:5, 8; 9:1–2). So mentioning tirosh (new wine) would have reminded Hosea's hearers of the harvest festival and the question of which god gave the crops.

Priests and wine. The law forbade priests to drink wine when serving, "so that you can distinguish between the holy and the common" (Lev 10:9–10). Coming right after an attack on priests who have lost knowledge, a saying about wine taking away the mind may have pointed especially at them. This connection is suggested by the context, not stated.

From the study of Hosea 4:11.

Where scholars differ

in v11

Does 'prostitution' (zenut) belong to verse 10 or verse 11, and does 'my people' (v. 12) belong to verse 11?

  • Keep the Masoretic division: 'Whoredom, wine and new wine take away the heart' is a complete proverb-like saying.

    The Masoretic accents; the KJV, NASB and WEB; the saying's balanced, compact form; the Vulgate.

  • Move zenut to the end of verse 10: 'they abandoned YHWH to keep up whoredom.'

    Otherwise 'to keep/guard' (lishmor) has no object. Adopted by the BSB, ESV and NIV and by many commentaries.

  • Attach 'my people' to verse 11: 'wine and new wine take away the heart of my people.'

    The Septuagint reading 'the heart of my people'; it gives verse 11 a stated owner of the 'heart' and lets verse 12 start with the verb. Opponents note that 'my people' opening verse 12 is good Hebrew and matches 4:6, 8.

in v11

Is the 'whoredom' here literal sexual activity in worship ('sacred prostitution') or a metaphor for idolatry?

  • Literal sexual rites: shrine sexual activity tied to fertility worship.

    4:13–14 (daughters committing whoredom, men sacrificing with qedeshot); older readings of ancient Near Eastern fertility religion; Herodotus 1.199 on Babylon.

  • Mainly metaphor for apostasy, perhaps with ordinary sexual looseness at festivals, but no organized 'sacred prostitution.'

    Recent studies (e.g. S. Budin; Stark) argue that ancient evidence for cultic prostitution is thin or misread; the marriage metaphor dominates Hosea 1–3.

  • Both together: sexual activity at the feasts and religious betrayal, without deciding whether it was a formal rite.

    Hosea moves freely between literal and figurative uses of the root in chapter 4; pairing zenut with wine suggests real festival behaviour while the chapter frames it as betrayal of YHWH.

in v12

What is the 'wood' the people consult?

  • A carved wooden idol or image.

    Prophetic mockery of idols as 'wood' (Isaiah 44:13–19; Jeremiah 10:3–8; Habakkuk 2:19). Most modern translations take it this way.

  • A wooden cult pole (asherah) at the shrine.

    Asherah poles were standard at hill shrines, and verse 13 describes worship 'under oak, poplar and terebinth'.

  • A living sacred tree used as an oracle.

    Hebrew ʿēṣ commonly means 'tree'. There were oracle-trees in Israelite tradition (the 'oak of Moreh', Genesis 12:6; 'the diviners' oak', Judges 9:37), and Jeremiah 2:27 mocks those who say 'to a tree, You are my father'. The ambiguity may be intentional.

in v12

Is the 'spirit of whoredoms' an inner disposition or an outside spiritual agent?

  • An inner compulsion or character trait that has taken over the nation.

    Hosea 5:4 says it is 'within them'. Parallel phrases ('spirit of jealousy', Numbers 5:14; 'spirit of deep sleep', Isaiah 29:10) describe overpowering states of mind. Verse 11 pairs it with wine taking away the heart.

  • A force that comes from outside the person, possibly sent as judgment.

    Hebrew rûaḥ can describe an outside force: God 'mixes a spirit of distortion' in Egypt that makes it stagger (Isaiah 19:14, same verb as here), an 'evil spirit from the LORD' troubles Saul (1 Samuel 16:14), and a 'lying spirit' misleads prophets (1 Kings 22:22). Even so, Hosea does not name or describe a demon, and the two ideas overlap in Hebrew thought.

in v12

How literal is the 'whoring' in this passage?

  • Mainly metaphor for worshipping other gods and syncretism (blending them with the LORD).

    Hosea's controlling image is the marriage between the LORD and Israel (chapters 1–3). 'Whore after other gods' is standard covenant language (Exodus 34:15–16; Deuteronomy 31:16).

  • Metaphor plus real sexual rites at the shrines, sometimes called 'sacred' or 'cultic' prostitution.

    Verses 13–14 mention daughters and daughters-in-law committing adultery and men sacrificing with 'qedeshot' (women connected with the shrines). Older scholarship (e.g. Wolff) reconstructed fertility rites with ritual sex.

  • Real sexual misconduct, but organised 'sacred prostitution' is doubtful.

    Recent studies (Phyllis Bird; Stephanie Budin, The Myth of Sacred Prostitution, 2008) argue the evidence for an institution of ritual prostitution in the ancient Near East is thin and largely built from later Greek reports. They read verses 13–14 as general sexual licence associated with shrine festivals, which Hosea links to the religious unfaithfulness.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. זְנוּת, יַיִן, תִּירוֹשׁ, לָקַח, לֵב
  • HALOT s.v. תִּירוֹשׁ; s.v. לֵב
  • H. W. Wolff, Hosea (Hermeneia), on 4:10–12
  • H. W. Wolff, Anthropology of the Old Testament, ch. on lēb
  • F. I. Andersen & D. N. Freedman, Hosea (Anchor Bible)
  • A. A. Macintosh, Hosea (ICC)
  • D. Stuart, Hosea–Jonah (WBC)
  • KTU 1.114 (Ugaritic 'Marzeah of El' text: yn // trṯ)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Hosea 4:11–12
  • Vulgate, Osee 4:11
  • S. L. Budin, The Myth of Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity (2008)
  • BDB s.v. שָׁאַל, עֵץ, מַקֵּל, רוּחַ, זָנָה, תָּעָה, תַּחַת
  • HALOT s.v. זנה, זְנוּנִים, מַקֵּל, תעה
  • H. W. Wolff, Hosea (Hermeneia), on 4:11–14
  • F. I. Andersen & D. N. Freedman, Hosea (Anchor Bible 24), on 4:12
  • A. A. Macintosh, Hosea (ICC), on 4:12
  • D. Stuart, Hosea–Jonah (Word Biblical Commentary 31)
  • P. Bird, 'To Play the Harlot: An Inquiry into an Old Testament Metaphor' (1989)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Hosea 4
  • Herodotus, Histories 4.67; Tacitus, Germania 10 (rod divination)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) and Vulgate, Hosea 4:12

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).