Isaiah Chapter 51 Read as one passage

Isaiah 51:12–13

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

12“I, even I, am He who comforts you. Why should you be afraid of mortal man, of a son of man who withers like grass? 13But you have forgotten the LORD, your Maker, who stretched out the heavens and laid the foundations of the earth. You live in terror all day long because of the fury of the oppressor who is bent on destruction. But where is the fury of the oppressor?

What the first hearers heard

For Judeans living under Babylonian power, and for those grieving over Jerusalem, this verse did several things:

  • It answered their lament directly. They had just cried for God's arm to wake up (51:9). He replies with the strongest possible 'I', presenting himself as the comforter Lamentations said Zion lacked.
  • It reframed who held the power. Babylon's kings and soldiers were frightening and real. The prophet calls them ʾĕnôš and ben-ʾādām, mortals and children of dust who die and are 'made grass'. To ears that knew 40:6–8 ('all flesh is grass… but the word of our God stands forever'), the echo would be plain.
  • It recalled Zion to her identity. 'Who are you?' rebukes the fear as unworthy of the one God is comforting. The next verse diagnoses the fear as forgetting 'the LORD your Maker, who stretched out the heavens'.
  • It prepared them for action and hope. The chapters around it call Zion to wake up, shake off the dust and leave captivity (51:17; 52:1–2, 11–12). Losing their fear of mortal oppressors was part of making ready for the promised return (51:11, 14).

From the study of Isaiah 51:12.

Verse by verse

  1. 12“I, even I, am He who comforts you. Why should you be afraid of mortal man, of a son of man who withers like grass?

    "I — I myself, and no other — I am the One: the one who is comforting you all. The same God who called himself 'I am he' and who stood before creation is answering your mourning in person. The comfort is what is done for the bereaved: the grief is met, and the loss is undone.

    And you, daughter Zion — who are you, that you have been afraid? The question is about who she is, not only why she fears. A woman with this comforter has no reason to shrink.

    Afraid of a mortal, who dies; of a mere child of Adam, who is turned into grass! The power that terrifies you is human, frail and dying. One hot wind and it is gone, like the grass that withers in a day. Fearing such a creature means forgetting the Maker of heaven and earth (v. 13)."

    The verse turns on a contrast: the God who is emphatically I, I, he, against a human being who dies and is made grass. The 'you' moves from the whole people (plural) to Zion as one woman, so that God's reply to the communal lament becomes a personal word to a grieving city.

    Full study →
  2. 13But you have forgotten the LORD, your Maker, who stretched out the heavens and laid the foundations of the earth. You live in terror all day long because of the fury of the oppressor who is bent on destruction. But where is the fury of the oppressor?

    (Continuing God's question from v.12: "Who are you, that you are afraid of a mortal man… ?")

    …and that you have let slip from your mind and your loyalty the LORD, the One who made you, the One who spreads out the sky like a tent and sets the earth on its foundations? Instead you tremble without a break, all day long, shrinking back from the burning rage of the one who has you squeezed in a vice, as he takes aim to ruin you. Yet where is that rage now, the rage of the one who squeezes you?

    The verse is built on a contrast of size. On one side stands Israel's Maker, described in hymn-like titles as the One who made you, stretches out the heavens and founds the earth. On the other stands "the squeezer", a mortal who (v.12) withers like grass. The two verbs about Israel come as a pair: you forgot and you dread. Forgetting here is a lapse of loyalty and trust, not of memory, and the dread follows from it. When the Creator drops out of view, the tyrant fills the sky. The dread is stated as heavily as Hebrew can manage: an intensive verb plus "continually" plus "all the day".

    The oppressor is pictured with an arrow already fitted to the string (konen, "he has made ready"). That is exactly why the final line lands so hard. The same words, "the fury of the oppressor", come back as a taunt: And where is it? Israel's enemies used to sneer "Where is your God?" Now God asks "Where is your oppressor's fury?" and speaks of it as already gone. The chapter goes on to show why: the real "fury" behind Israel's suffering was God's own, and he is about to hand that cup to the tormentors (vv.17–23).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v12

    son of man

    ben-ʾādām

    What we hear
    A title for Jesus or the heavenly figure of Daniel 7, suggesting someone exalted or messianic.
    What they heard
    An ordinary human being, one of Adam's race. Here it stresses frailty and is a plain parallel to 'mortal' in the previous line.
  • in v12

    comforts

    mənaḥem (niḥam)

    What we hear
    Soothing someone's feelings, making them feel better or at ease.
    What they heard
    Consoling a mourner: coming to the grieving, speaking to their heart, and in Isaiah 40–55 acting to reverse the loss (51:3: turning Zion's wilderness into Eden). It answers Lamentations' 'she has no comforter'.
  • in v13

    forgotten (the LORD)

    shakach

    What we hear
    A lapse of memory: something slipped your mind, perhaps through no fault of your own.
    What they heard
    Neglecting God in practice and loyalty: ceasing to rely on him and act on what you know of him. Israel still 'knew' Yahweh was Creator, but they were living as if the empire were the greater power.
Every word
  1. אָנֹכִ֧י

    ʾānōkî · H0595

    I · v12

    God speaks first, and speaks of himself. Hebrew verbs already show who the subject is, so a separate 'I' adds emphasis: 'I myself'.

  2. ה֖וּא

    hûʾ · H1931

    he; it · v12

    'He' here works as 'the one' or 'the very one'. 'I, I am he' is the formula God uses in these chapters to claim that he alone is God and stays the same (41:4; 43:10, 13; 46:4; 48:12).

  3. מְנַחֶמְכֶ֑ם

    mənaḥemkem · H5162

    comfort, console · v12

    An ongoing participle, 'your comforter' or 'the one comforting you'. The 'you' is plural: the whole exiled people. The comfort answers grief, and in these chapters it means real restoration, not only kind words.

  4. מִֽי־

    mî · H4310

    who? · v12

    Asks about identity, not reason: 'Who are you?' It is a rebuke that is also an appeal. Someone who has this comforter has no business cowering.

  5. אַ֤תְּ

    ʾat · H0859

    you (feminine singular) · v12

    The address suddenly turns to one woman: Zion/Jerusalem pictured as a bereaved woman, as in 49:14–21, 51:17–23 and 52:1–2. English 'you' cannot show the change.

  6. וַתִּֽירְאִי֙

    wattîrəʾî · H3372

    fear, be afraid · v12

    'And you have feared.' After the question, the form means 'that you should be afraid'. This is fear of danger, the dread of a captive people before the powers that hold it.

  7. מֵאֱנ֣וֹשׁ

    mēʾĕnôš · H0582

    human being, mortal · v12

    'Of a mortal.' The poetic word for humanity often stresses frailty. The same word appears in 51:7: 'do not fear the reproach of mortals'.

  8. יָמ֔וּת

    yāmût · H4191

    die · v12

    '[Who] dies.' This describes what humans are like: they are the kind of thing that dies. It is not a forecast of one future death. Even the oppressor is mortal.

  9. וּמִבֶּן־

    ûmibben · H1121

    son, child · v12

    'And of a son of…' In the Hebrew idiom 'son of X' means 'a member of the class X'.

  10. אָדָ֖ם

    ʾādām · H0120

    humankind, man · v12

    With 'son of' it means 'a human being', the plain parallel to 'mortal' in the line before. It is not a title. The word carries an echo of the creature formed from the ground (ʾădāmâ).

  11. חָצִ֥יר

    ḥāṣîr · H2682

    grass, green growth · v12

    Grass that lasts only a season and is scorched in a day. It deliberately recalls 40:6–8: 'all flesh is grass… the grass withers'.

  12. יִנָּתֵֽן׃

    yinnātēn · H5414

    give; set, make · v12

    Passive of 'give/make': 'is made', 'is turned into', or 'is given up'. Without even a 'like', the human is simply made grass, reduced to something that withers.

  13. וַתִּשְׁכַּ֞ח

    vattishkach · H7911

    and you forgot · v13

    This picks up the question in v.12 ('Who are you that you fear…'): 'and that you have forgotten…'. In Hebrew, forgetting God means no longer living by what you know of him. It is less about a gap in memory than about neglecting him and no longer relying on him.

  14. יְהוָ֣ה

    YHWH · H3068

    the LORD (Yahweh) · v13

    Israel's covenant God, named by his personal name. That name stands in sharp contrast with the nameless 'mortal man' of v.12.

  15. עֹשֶׂ֗ךָ

    ʿoshekha · H6213

    your Maker · v13

    A participle ('the one making you') with 'you' attached. God made Israel as a people as well as making the cosmos (cf. 44:2, 'your Maker, who formed you from the womb'). The point is that he owns them and is bound to them.

  16. נוֹטֶ֣ה

    noteh · H5186

    stretching out · v13

    Another participle, a stock phrase in Isaiah 40–55 for the Creator who spreads out the sky like a tent (40:22; 42:5; 44:24; 45:12). The participle presents this as what God characteristically is and does, not only as one past act.

  17. שָׁמַיִם֮

    shamayim · H8064

    heavens, sky · v13

    The visible sky stretched over the earth, one half of the 'heavens and earth' pair that means the whole created world.

  18. וְיֹסֵ֣ד

    veyosed · H3245

    and founding · v13

    A building word: laying a foundation so the structure stands firm. The earth rests on footings God himself laid, which is the opposite of how unstable Israel feels.

  19. אָרֶץ֒

    ʾarets · H776

    earth, land · v13

    Here the earth as a whole, the other half of the 'heavens and earth' pair.

  20. וַתְּפַחֵ֨ד

    vattefached · H6342

    and you dread · v13

    An intensive form of the verb (the Piel), which is rare. It means trembling, sustained dread rather than a moment of fright. Fear and forgetting are joined in one sequence: the dread grows where the Maker has dropped out of view.

  21. תָּמִ֜יד

    tamid · H8548

    continually · v13

    'Without a break.' The same word describes the never-ending daily offering and the lamp that never went out. Here what never stops is the fear.

  22. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all · v13

    Part of the phrase 'all the day'. Piled on top of 'continually', it stresses that the dread never lets up.

  23. הַיּ֗וֹם

    hayyom · H3117

    the day · v13

    'All the day' is an idiom for 'all day long, every day'.

  24. מִפְּנֵי֙

    mippenei · H6440

    from before, because of · v13

    Literally 'from the face of'. It gives the cause of the fear and pictures the people shrinking back from what stands in front of them.

  25. חֲמַ֣ת

    chamat · H2534

    heat, rage, fury · v13

    Burning, overheated anger, from a root meaning 'be hot'. The same chapter uses this word for God's own fury, the 'cup of his wrath' (vv.17, 20, 22), which God then takes from Israel and hands to its tormentors (vv.22–23).

  26. הַמֵּצִ֔יק

    hammetsiq · H6693

    the oppressor, the one who distresses · v13

    A causative participle: 'the one who presses in, squeezes, hems in'. The picture is of being cornered or crushed. In context it refers to the Babylonian overlord, though he is not named.

  27. כַּאֲשֶׁ֥ר

    kaʾasher · H834

    as, when, as though · v13

    It can mean 'when' (he takes aim) or 'as though' (he were about to destroy). Translations split over which, and the choice affects whether the threat sounds real or only apparent.

  28. כּוֹנֵ֖ן

    konen · H3559

    he has set up, made ready, aimed · v13

    An intensive form of 'establish'. Elsewhere it is used for fitting an arrow to the string or making a bow ready (Ps 7:12–13; 11:2), so it suggests an enemy taking aim. The verb is in the perfect: his preparations are complete.

  29. לְהַשְׁחִ֑ית

    lehashchit · H7843

    to destroy, ruin · v13

    'To bring to ruin, to wreck.' The word is used of armies laying land waste. It names what the oppressor intends to do.

  30. וְאַיֵּ֖ה

    veʾayyeh · H346

    and where? · v13

    A taunting 'where is…?'. Enemies used it to mock Israel ('Where is your God?', Ps 42:3; 79:10). Here the question is turned on the oppressor: where has his fury gone?

The world behind it

Exile and the lament of Zion. Isaiah 40–55 speaks to Judeans under Babylonian rule after Jerusalem fell in 587/586 BC. Many scholars date these chapters to about 550–539 BC. Traditional interpretation reads them as Isaiah of Jerusalem's prophecy looking ahead to that time. Either way, the 'oppressor' of v. 13 is the imperial power that held Judah captive.

The answer to a lament. Verses 9–11 are the people's cry: 'Awake, awake, arm of the LORD!' Verse 12 begins God's reply. Just as important is the book of Lamentations, written over the ruined city. Its refrain is that Jerusalem, pictured as a widowed woman, has 'no one to comfort her' (Lam 1:2, 9, 16, 17, 21). Isaiah 40–55 answers that refrain point by point. 'Comfort, comfort my people' (40:1) and 'I, I am your comforter' (51:12) present God as the comforter Lamentations said was missing. That is why the address suddenly becomes feminine singular: God is speaking to Zion the bereaved woman.

Comforting mourners. In ancient Israel, comforting was a social duty toward the grieving. Relatives and allies came, sat with the mourner, spoke kindly and helped restore their standing (Gen 37:35; 2 Sam 10:2–3; Job 2:11). For God to call himself Zion's comforter is for him to take up the role of the kinsman who comes to the house of mourning and ends the mourning.

Grass in a dry land. In the Levant, green growth after the winter rains can be burned brown within days when the hot desert east wind (the sirocco) blows. 'Grass' was therefore the obvious picture of power that looks lush and vanishes suddenly (Isa 40:7; Ps 103:15–16).

From the study of Isaiah 51:12.

Where scholars differ

in v12

What does 'I, I am he' (ʾānōkî ʾānōkî hûʾ) claim?

  • It is a statement of identity and uniqueness: 'I am the one, the same', meaning God alone is God and acts consistently from first to last.

    The parallels in Deut 32:39 and Isa 41:4; 43:10–13; 46:4; 48:12 all stress that no other god exists and that God is the same through time. 'Hûʾ' works normally as 'the one (who)' joined to the participle 'comforter'.

  • It works almost as a divine self-designation, close to a name, which later Greek-speaking Jewish and Christian readers heard as 'I am' (egō eimi).

    The phrase is concentrated and set out like a formula in Isaiah 40–55. The Septuagint renders it egō eimi. Studies such as C. H. Williams, *I Am He* (2000), trace its later reception, including in John's Gospel. Even this reading accepts that in Isaiah it remains a claim to exclusive deity, not a new name.

in v12

Who is the feminine 'you' in 'who are you'?

  • Zion/Jerusalem, pictured as a woman.

    The feminine-singular address to Zion surrounds this verse (51:17–23; 52:1–2; 49:14–21; 54:1–8), and so does the Lamentations language of the comfortless woman. Most commentators take this view (e.g. Blenkinsopp, Childs, Goldingay).

  • The people as a whole, with the gender shift being stylistic or the result of textual disturbance.

    The verse begins with a plural 'you' and v. 13 continues with a masculine singular 'you', so some older critics proposed emendation. No manuscript supports a change, and the feminine reading fits the context well.

in v13

Does kaʾasher konen lehashchit present the oppressor's threat as real ('when he makes ready to destroy') or only apparent ('as though he were ready/able to destroy')?

  • Temporal or real: 'when he takes aim to destroy.'

    Kaʾasher often means 'when' with a completed verb. Konen is a real weapon-readying verb (Ps 7:12; 11:2). The exiles' fear was not imaginary; Babylon had destroyed Jerusalem. ESV, WEB, NASB and most modern commentators (e.g. Westermann, Blenkinsopp) read it this way.

  • Comparative or apparent: 'as if he were ready to destroy.'

    Kaʾasher can mean 'as, as though'. The following taunt, 'where is his fury?', suggests the threat is hollow next to the Creator. The KJV and some older commentators take this line.

in v13

Does the closing 'where is the fury of the oppressor?' mean the fury has already vanished, or does it express confident expectation?

  • Prophetic certainty about the near future.

    Verse 14 promises release 'soon' (*maher*), and vv.22–23 put the transfer of the cup of wrath in the future. The question speaks of a coming collapse as though it were already done.

  • A reflection of events already under way, such as Cyrus's rise.

    Scholars who date Isaiah 40–55 to around 540 BCE note that Cyrus is named in 44:28–45:1 and that Babylon's fall was imminent or had begun. The LXX and Vulgate add 'now', reading the question as present.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. נָחַם, אֱנוֹשׁ, חָצִיר, נָתַן
  • HALOT s.v. נחם (piel), אֱנוֹשׁ, נתן (niphal)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 40–55 (Anchor Bible)
  • B. S. Childs, Isaiah (Old Testament Library)
  • C. Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (Old Testament Library)
  • J. Goldingay & D. Payne, Isaiah 40–55 (International Critical Commentary)
  • K. Baltzer, Deutero-Isaiah (Hermeneia)
  • P. T. Willey, Remember the Former Things: The Recollection of Previous Texts in Second Isaiah (1997)
  • B. D. Sommer, A Prophet Reads Scripture: Allusion in Isaiah 40–66 (1998)
  • C. H. Williams, I Am He: The Interpretation of ʾAnî Hûʾ in Jewish and Early Christian Literature (2000)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) and Vulgate, Isaiah 51:12
  • HALOT s.v. שׁכח, פחד, חֵמָה, צוק, כון, נטה
  • BDB s.v. שָׁכַח, פָּחַד, צוּק, כּוּן
  • J. N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah, Chapters 40–66 (NICOT)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs-Hanhart), Isaiah 51:13
  • Vulgate, Isaias 51:13
  • Enuma Elish, Tablet IV (Marduk and Tiamat)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).