Isaiah Chapter 8 Read as one passage

Isaiah 8:10–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10Devise a plan, but it will be thwarted; state a proposal, but it will not happen. For God is with us.” 11For this is what the LORD has spoken to me with a strong hand, instructing me not to walk in the way of this people:

What the first hearers heard

To Judah, under threat first from Aram and Israel and then flooded by its supposed rescuer Assyria, the verse said three things:

  • The nations do not have the last word. Coalitions can gather, arm and decide, but their decisions will be voided. This was the same message Isaiah gave Ahaz in 7:7, now widened to "all distant lands".
  • The reason is God, not politics. The verse names no army, ally or tribute payment, only "with us is God". Ahaz had bought Assyria's help instead. The line implicitly rebukes that kind of security and calls for trust in the LORD, which is the theme of verses 11–15 ("do not fear what they fear … the LORD of hosts, him you shall regard as holy").
  • The Immanuel sign still stands. In 8:8 the name Immanuel hangs over a land drowning in the Assyrian flood. Verse 10 picks it up and turns it into a confident statement. Judah would be punished, "up to the neck", but not wiped out, because the child's name declares God's presence.

The "us" is important. In the next verses Isaiah separates himself and his disciples (8:16–18) from "this people", who fear the wrong things. So the confidence of 8:10 belonged above all to those who actually trusted the LORD, not to anyone who simply repeated the slogan. Later generations who saw Sennacherib withdraw from Jerusalem in 701 BC would have heard the verse as fulfilled.

From the study of Isaiah 8:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 10Devise a plan, but it will be thwarted; state a proposal, but it will not happen. For God is with us.”

    Speaking straight to the nations massing for war (verse 9), the prophet taunts them: "Go on, make your plan, scheme your scheme, and it will be broken, cancelled like a voided treaty. Announce your decision, make your declaration, and it will not stand. It will never take effect. For with us is God: Immanu-El."

    The commands are mockery, not advice. Each half of the line repeats a root ("plan a plan", "speak a word") to make fun of the busy deliberations of war councils. The verbs are the ones Israel used for plans and decrees. A plan can be broken or annulled, as covenants and vows are. A decree either stands (takes effect and stays valid) or it does not. Isaiah had already told King Ahaz that the plot of Aram and Israel "shall not stand" (7:7). Now the same verdict covers any coalition of peoples.

    The last words give the reason, and they work in two ways. As a sentence, "with us is God" is the cry of a people whose God fights at their head. Psalm 46 says it: "The LORD of hosts is with us." As a name, Immanuel is exactly the sign-child of 7:14, whose name had just been spoken over a land flooded by Assyria ("your land, O Immanuel", 8:8). The flood may rise "up to the neck", but the land carries the child's name, and that name is a promise. No plan made against it will hold.

    Full study →
  2. 11For this is what the LORD has spoken to me with a strong hand, instructing me not to walk in the way of this people:

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    Take counsel (together)

    ʿutsu ʿetsah

    What we hear
    Seek advice; consult wise people; talk things over.
    What they heard
    Hatch a plan or devise a strategy, here the nations' plan of attack. It is a mocking command: "go ahead and plot."
  • in v10

    speak the word

    dabberu davar

    What we hear
    Proclaim God's word or Scripture; a faith declaration ("speak the word over it").
    What they heard
    The enemy announces *a* word: a decree, resolution or declared intention. The verse says such words will *not* stand.
  • in v10

    God is with us

    ʿimmanu ʾel

    What we hear
    A general comfort that God is near and present with us in hard times.
    What they heard
    A battle assurance that God takes our side against attacking armies, so their plans collapse. The words are also the name of Isaiah's sign-child, Immanuel (7:14; 8:8). God's presence is part of it, but here that presence means protection in war.
Every word
  1. עֻ֥צוּ

    ʿutsu · H5779

    to plan, take counsel · v10

    A plural command addressed to the hostile nations of verse 9: "Go on, make your plans!" It is a taunt, not advice. The command concedes they will plot, and the rest of the line says the plot is already doomed.

  2. עֵצָ֖ה

    ʿetsah · H6098

    counsel, plan, strategy · v10

    The object comes from the same root as the verb ("plan a plan"). The repetition gives the line a mocking ring. In a war setting it means a strategy, a scheme decided in council, here the nations' plan of attack.

  3. וְתֻפָ֑ר

    vetufar · H6565A

    to break, annul, frustrate · v10

    "And it will be broken." The verb is the one used for breaking a covenant or cancelling a vow. The form is passive, and the one who does the breaking goes unnamed. The final clause shows it is God.

  4. דַּבְּר֤וּ

    dabberu · H1696G

    to speak · v10

    A second plural command: "Speak!" Here that means announcing a decision, the way a war council or king pronounces a resolution.

  5. דָבָר֙

    davar · H1697G

    word, matter, thing · v10

    "A word": a proposal, decree or declared intention. It is the enemies' word, not God's. The noun again repeats its verb ("speak a speech"), which matches the first half of the line.

  6. וְלֹ֣א

    velo · H3808

    and not · v10

    A flat negative, "and ... not." The "and" joins the command to its result, much as English says "try it, and it won't work."

  7. יָק֔וּם

    yaqum · H6965I

    to rise, stand, be established · v10

    "It will not stand": it will not come true, take effect or stay valid. This picks up God's words about the Aram–Israel plot in 7:7 ("it shall not stand") and points ahead to 40:8, where God's word "will stand forever."

  8. כִּ֥י

    ki · H3588A

    for, because · v10

    Gives the reason for everything before it. The plans fail not because of Judah's army or diplomacy but because of what follows.

  9. עִמָּ֖נוּ

    ʿimmanu · H5973A

    with (+ us) · v10

    "With us." It is placed first for emphasis: with *us*, on our side. In war language "with" means standing alongside as an ally and fighter.

  10. אֵֽל׃

    ʾel · H0410G

    God · v10

    "God." Together with the previous word it makes exactly the name *Immanuel* from 7:14 and 8:8. So the line is both a sentence ("God is with us") and a pointed echo of the sign-child's name.

The world behind it

The Syro-Ephraimite crisis (about 735–732 BC). Rezin, king of Aram (Damascus), and Pekah, king of the northern kingdom of Israel, joined forces against Judah. They wanted to force it into their alliance against Assyria and to put their own puppet, "the son of Tabeel", on the throne in Jerusalem (Isaiah 7:1–6). Isaiah told King Ahaz that their plan "shall not stand" and gave the sign of a child to be called Immanuel (7:7–14). Ahaz refused to trust it and paid Tiglath-pileser III of Assyria to rescue him (2 Kings 16:7–9).

The flow of chapter 8. In 8:5–8 the people have rejected "the gently flowing waters of Shiloah", the quiet water supply of Jerusalem and a picture of trusting the LORD. So the LORD will bring "the River" (the Euphrates, meaning Assyria) over them, flooding Judah "up to the neck". Its spread wings will fill "your land, O Immanuel". Then 8:9–10 turns sharply to the nations themselves: let them gather, arm and plot; they will be shattered. Verses 11–15 go on to tell Isaiah and his circle not to fear what "this people" fears.

War councils and battle cries. In the ancient Near East, kings went to war after their counsellors had deliberated and the decision had been formally announced. Assyrian royal inscriptions boast about plans carried out at the gods' command. Isaiah's "plan … speak" mimics that process (compare the war council in Judges 19:30, which uses the same pair of verbs). Israel's answer was the old holy-war assurance that God goes out with his people (Numbers 14:9; 2 Chronicles 13:12). The Jerusalem psalms sang the same thing about Zion: nations rage against the city and are broken, "the LORD of hosts is with us" (Psalms 46 and 48; compare Psalm 2).

How it played out. Readers of the finished book of Isaiah would have heard this line come true in 701 BC. Sennacherib of Assyria overran Judah's fortified towns but did not take Jerusalem (Isaiah 36–37). Hezekiah's words to his officers there, "with us is the LORD our God" (2 Chronicles 32:8), are close to this line.

From the study of Isaiah 8:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

Is "ʿimmanu ʾel" here the name of the sign-child or simply a statement that God is with us?

  • Mainly a reference to the child Immanuel of 7:14, carried on from 8:8.

    The consonants and words are identical to 7:14 and 8:8. It comes two verses after the address "O Immanuel". Isaiah's children have names that act as signs (8:18), so the name is meant to echo through the passage.

  • Mainly a confession of faith, a battle or Zion slogan ("God is with us").

    It is introduced by "for" and works grammatically as the reason for the failure of the plans. It matches the refrain of Psalm 46 and other battle assurances (Num 14:9; 2 Chr 13:12; 32:8). The Septuagint translates it as a sentence.

  • Deliberately both.

    Most commentators (e.g. Wildberger, Childs, Oswalt) see wordplay: the sign-name is spelled out as the reason the nations fail. The child's name and the confession explain each other.

in v10

Who speaks 8:9–10, and is the confidence genuine?

  • Isaiah's own word of assurance, reversing the threat of 8:5–8.

    It fits Isaiah's repeated theme of the LORD frustrating the nations' plans (7:7; 14:24–27; 17:12–14; 29:7–8). The "for" at the start of verse 11 ties it to what follows.

  • A hymn or slogan of the Zion tradition taken up into the prophecy, perhaps sung by Isaiah's circle of disciples.

    It is close to Psalms 46 and 48, it is in plural "us" voice, and the next verses (8:11–18) speak of the prophet and his disciples standing apart from "this people".

  • A later addition shaped by Jerusalem's escape from Sennacherib in 701 BC.

    Some critical scholars point to the abrupt switch from the Assyrian flood over Judah (8:8) to the defeat of the nations (8:9–10). Others answer that sudden shifts from judgment to hope are typical of Isaiah's own oracles.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.