Jeremiah Chapter 44 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 44:17–18

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

17Instead, we will do everything we vowed to do: We will burn incense to the Queen of Heaven and offer drink offerings to her, just as we, our fathers, our kings, and our officials did in the cities of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem. At that time we had plenty of food and good things, and we saw no disaster. 18But from the time we stopped burning incense to the Queen of Heaven and pouring out drink offerings to her, we have lacked everything and have been perishing by sword and famine.”

What the first hearers heard

For the exiles who first read the book of Jeremiah, this verse put into words the most pressing question of their generation: why did Jerusalem fall? Two answers were in circulation, and this chapter sets them side by side.

  • The refugees' answer (vv.17–18): Judah prospered while it honoured the Queen of Heaven, as ancestors, kings and officials always had. The trouble began when the reform stopped that worship. In this view the reformers' exclusive loyalty to YHWH was the cause of the catastrophe.
  • Jeremiah's answer (vv.20–23): YHWH 'remembered' exactly that smoke 'in the cities of Judah and the streets of Jerusalem, you and your fathers, your kings and your officials' (v.21). Jeremiah throws their own list back at them word for word. The disaster came because of the cult, not because it stopped.

The verse is written to let the people condemn themselves out of their own mouths. They take the covenant's own vocabulary (a vow that must be kept, 'we will do', 'filled with bread', 'we were well off') and attach it to another deity. Hearers steeped in Deuteronomy would catch every echo, and would hear the speakers turn Sinai upside down.

The chapter goes on to make it a test: whose word will stand, 'mine or theirs' (v.28)? The sign Jeremiah gives is that Pharaoh Hophra, the Egyptian king they trusted, will be handed over to his enemies (v.30). For exiles tempted to blend in with the religions around them, the verse said that the argument from experience ('it worked for us before') is exactly the reasoning that destroyed Judah.

From the study of Jeremiah 44:17.

Verse by verse

  1. 17Instead, we will do everything we vowed to do: We will burn incense to the Queen of Heaven and offer drink offerings to her, just as we, our fathers, our kings, and our officials did in the cities of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem. At that time we had plenty of food and good things, and we saw no disaster.

    "No. We will most certainly carry out every word of the vow that has left our own mouths, not the word you claim came from YHWH. We will send up the smoke of offerings to the Queen of Heaven and pour out wine to her, exactly as we always did: we ourselves, our ancestors, our kings and the officials who governed us, all through the towns of Judah and openly in the streets of Jerusalem. Back then we ate until we were full, we were thriving, and disaster never touched us."

    Behind the plain words lie several pointed echoes:

    • The vow. 'Everything that went out of our mouth' is the formula of the Torah's vow law (Num 30:2): a spoken vow must be kept. They answer the prophet's 'word in the name of YHWH' with 'the word from our mouth'.
    • Sinai turned around. Their 'we will surely do' sounds like Israel's pledge at Sinai, 'all that YHWH has spoken we will do', now made to a goddess.
    • Ancestral and royal precedent. The list 'we, our fathers, our kings, our officials' claims that this was the established religion of Judah, done publicly and approved by the state.
    • Blessing language given to her. 'We were filled with bread' and 'we were well off' are Deuteronomy's words for YHWH's covenant blessing. 'We saw no disaster' uses the very word (raʿah) that YHWH uses in this chapter for the catastrophe he brought.

    The verse is a reasoned counter-theology: honouring the Queen brought prosperity, and abandoning her (v.18) brought sword and famine.

    Full study →
  2. 18But from the time we stopped burning incense to the Queen of Heaven and pouring out drink offerings to her, we have lacked everything and have been perishing by sword and famine.”

    "Ever since we quit sending up our smoke-offerings to the Queen of the Heavens and pouring out our wine-offerings to her, we have gone short of everything, and sword and famine have been finishing us off."

    Judean refugees in Egypt say this to Jeremiah's face, and in the next verse the women speak in their own name. It is a counter-sermon. In the verse before, they remembered the days when they "were filled with bread, were well off and saw no evil". Now they turn it around. Since that time (most likely King Josiah's reform, which shut down these household rites about forty years earlier) the bread has run out. The words they choose are the words of Israel's own covenant. "Lacking everything" and "famine" are the curse of Deuteronomy 28:48. "Lack nothing" and "bread" were the promise of Deuteronomy 8:9. "Finished by sword and famine" is the sentence Jeremiah has just pronounced on them (44:12). They accept every disaster the prophet named: the war, the starvation, the fall of the city. They deny his explanation. As they read history, the trouble did not come from forsaking Yahweh. It came from forsaking the Queen.

    The "smoke" was more than incense. It was a family offering of baked cakes, fire and poured wine (v.19; 7:18). Their argument is simple. The old way worked, and the new way killed us.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17

    saw no evil (KJV, WEB)

    raʿah lo raʾinu

    What we hear
    We did not see or commit anything morally wicked.
    What they heard
    Nothing bad happened to us: no disaster, harm or misfortune.
  • in v17

    our princes (KJV, WEB)

    sarenu

    What we hear
    The king's sons, members of the royal family.
    What they heard
    Royal officials: administrators, commanders, the ruling class of Judah's government.
  • in v17

    whatsoever thing goeth forth out of our own mouth (KJV)

    kol-haddavar asher yatsa mippinu

    What we hear
    Whatever we feel like saying or doing; doing as we please.
    What they heard
    Every word of the vow we have spoken. It is the Torah's formula for a binding vow (Num 30:2), as v.25 confirms ('we will surely perform our vows').
  • in v17

    burn incense

    leqatter

    What we hear
    Lighting fragrant incense only.
    What they heard
    Making an offering go up in smoke to a deity. It can be incense, but the verb covers burnt offerings in general.
  • in v17

    Queen of Heaven

    melekhet hashshamayim

    What we hear
    Some readers connect the title with the later Christian title for Mary, 'Queen of Heaven' (Regina Caeli).
    What they heard
    A sixth-century-BCE Near Eastern astral goddess, honoured with cakes, smoke offerings and libations. She has no historical link to any later Christian title.
  • in v18

    burning incense

    qaṭṭēr

    What we hear
    Lighting incense sticks or spices, a small symbolic gesture of devotion.
    What they heard
    Making offerings go up as smoke: possibly incense, but also burnt cakes, fat or grain, as part of a full family rite with libations.
  • in v18

    we have wanted all things (KJV)

    ḥāsarnû ḵōl

    What we hear
    We have desired everything.
    What they heard
    We have lacked everything: real material want, matching the covenant curse 'lack of everything' (Deut 28:48).
  • in v18

    Queen of Heaven

    mᵉleḵet haš-šāmayim

    What we hear
    Readers may connect it with the later Christian title for Mary (Regina caeli), or picture 'Heaven' as the afterlife.
    What they heard
    A title of the ancient Near Eastern sky-goddess (Ishtar/Astarte and related goddesses), queen of the visible heavens and the stars.
Every word
  1. כִּ֩י

    ki · H3588A

    for, but rather · v17

    Coming right after the flat refusal of v.16 ('we will not listen to you'), it works as 'no, rather' or 'instead'. It turns from what they reject to what they will do.

  2. עָשֹׂ֨ה

    ʿasoh · H6213A

    do (infinitive absolute) · v17

    The bare verb 'doing' set in front of the same verb for emphasis: 'we will most certainly do'. It is a declaration of fixed resolve.

  3. אֶֽת־

    ʾet · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v17

    Marks 'every word' as what they will carry out. It is not translated.

  4. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all, every · v17, v18

    Every single thing, nothing held back: the whole of their pledge.

  5. הַדָּבָ֣ר׀

    haddavar · H1697I

    word, thing, matter · v17

    The same noun that opened v.16, 'the word you spoke to us in the name of YHWH'. The prophet's word is set against their own word.

  6. אֲשֶׁר־

    ʾasher · H0834A

    which, that · v17

    Introduces the description of the word: the one that 'went out from our mouth'.

  7. יָצָ֣א

    yatsaʾ · H3318O

    go out, come forth · v17

    'Has gone out'. With 'from the mouth' this is the standard idiom for a vow or oath once spoken, which binds the speaker (Num 30:2; Judg 11:36). Verse 25 confirms it: 'we will surely perform our vows'.

  8. מִפִּ֗ינוּ

    mippinu · H6310G

    from our mouth · v17

    'From our mouth', not from YHWH's mouth. The contrast with the prophet's 'word in the name of YHWH' is deliberate.

  9. לְקַטֵּ֞ר

    leqatter · H6999H

    to make (offerings) smoke · v17, v18

    'To send up in smoke', meaning burning incense or other offerings so the smoke rises to the deity. In Jeremiah it is a stock verb for worship of other gods.

  10. לִמְלֶ֣כֶת

    limlekhet · H4446

    to the queen of · v17, v18

    A royal title for a goddess, 'the Queen'. Its unusual vowels may be a scribal way of avoiding the plain word 'queen' (see textual notes).

  11. הַשָּׁמַיִם֮

    hashshamayim · H8064

    the heavens, the sky · v17, v18

    The sky where the astral powers live. The title places her among the heavenly bodies, probably tied to the planet Venus.

  12. וְהַסֵּֽיךְ־

    vehassekh · H5258A

    and to pour out · v17, v18

    'And to pour out' a liquid offering. The word pairs naturally with the burnt offering before it, so together they describe a full worship ritual.

  13. לָ֣הּ

    lah · H9034

    to her · v17, v18

    'To her': the feminine pronoun makes plain that a female deity receives the offerings.

  14. נְסָכִים֒

    nesakhim · H5262

    drink offerings, libations · v17, v18

    Libations, usually wine, poured out for a deity. The same kind of offering belonged to YHWH's own sacrifices (Num 15:5–10).

  15. אֲנַ֤חְנוּ

    ʾanachnu · H0587

    we · v17

    An emphatic 'we ourselves' that heads a list of everyone who took part.

  16. וַאֲבֹתֵ֙ינוּ֙

    vaʾavoteinu · H0001G

    and our fathers · v17

    'Our ancestors'. Ancestral practice carried great authority in a kinship society: this is the religion of the family line.

  17. מְלָכֵ֣ינוּ

    melakheinu · H4428G

    our kings · v17

    'Our kings'. They claim royal sanction, meaning the cult had been official, not fringe.

  18. וְשָׂרֵ֔ינוּ

    vesareinu · H8269

    and our officials · v17

    The royal administrators and commanders, the governing class of Judah. It does not mean the king's sons.

  19. בְּעָרֵ֣י

    beʿarei · H5892B

    in the cities of · v17

    Across the towns of the land. The practice was widespread.

  20. יְהוּדָ֔ה

    Yehudah · H3063G

    Judah · v17

    The southern kingdom, now destroyed. The speakers are its refugees.

  21. וּבְחֻצ֖וֹת

    uvechutsot · H2351

    and in the streets of · v17

    'The outside places', meaning open streets and public spaces. The worship was done openly, not in secret.

  22. יְרוּשָׁלִָ֑ם

    Yerushalayim · H3389

    Jerusalem · v17

    The capital and YHWH's chosen city. The goddess was honoured in its very streets (compare Jer 7:17–18).

  23. וַנִּֽשְׂבַּֽע־

    vannisbaʿ · H7646

    and we were satisfied · v17

    'And we ate our fill'. It is a narrative past tense, describing how things were back then. In Deuteronomy 'eat and be satisfied' is the language of covenant blessing (Deut 8:10; 11:15).

  24. לֶ֙חֶם֙

    lechem · H3899G

    bread, food · v17

    Bread as the staple, and so food in general. 'Filled with bread' means there was no hunger. It is the reverse of the famine in v.18.

  25. וַנִּֽהְיֶ֣ה

    vannihyeh · H1961

    and we were · v17

    Another narrative past: 'and we were'.

  26. טוֹבִ֔ים

    tovim · H2896A

    good, well-off · v17

    'Well', in the sense of prosperous and thriving, not morally good. It means 'we were doing well'.

  27. וְרָעָ֖ה

    veraʿah · H7451C

    and harm, disaster · v17

    Calamity or misfortune. It is placed first for emphasis: 'disaster we did not see'. It is the same word YHWH uses in this chapter for the disaster he brings (44:2, 11).

  28. לֹ֥א

    loʾ · H3808

    not · v17

    A plain negative.

  29. רָאִֽינוּ׃

    raʾinu · H7200G

    we saw · v17

    'Saw', in the Hebrew sense of experiencing. 'We never saw disaster' means 'nothing bad happened to us'.

  30. וּמִן־

    ū-min · H4480A

    and from · v18

    'And from…' Paired with the next word it means 'ever since'. It marks the start of a period that runs up to the moment of speaking. The 'and' carries on from v.17 and sets the bad present against the good past.

  31. אָ֡ז

    ʾāz · H0227B

    then · v18

    'Then'. With 'from' it means 'since that time'. The speakers point to a turning point everyone in the crowd knows, most likely King Josiah's reform about forty years earlier.

  32. חָדַ֜לְנוּ

    ḥādalnû · H2308

    we ceased, left off · v18

    'We stopped'. The verb means quitting a habit or practice. They present the ending of the goddess's rites as the moment everything went wrong.

  33. חָסַ֣רְנוּ

    ḥāsarnû · H2637

    we have lacked, been in want · v18

    'We have gone short'. It is the opposite of 'we were filled with bread' in v.17. It also echoes Deuteronomy's promise of a land where 'you will lack nothing' (Deut 8:9), now said to have failed.

  34. וּבַחֶ֥רֶב

    ū-ḇa-ḥereḇ · H2719

    and by the sword · v18

    'And by the sword': war, invasion and slaughter. It is the first half of Jeremiah's own stock phrase of judgment.

  35. וּבָרָעָ֖ב

    ū-ḇā-rāʿāḇ · H7458

    and by the famine · v18

    'And by famine', the hunger of siege and ruined harvests. The 'the' points to the specific famine they had all lived through, above all the siege of Jerusalem.

  36. תָּֽמְנוּ׃

    tāmᵉnû · H8552

    we have come to an end, been finished · v18

    'We have been finished off', used of a people being used up and wiped out. It is the same verb Jeremiah used in his threat of 44:12 ('by sword and famine they will be finished'), and the people throw it back at him.

The world behind it

Where and when. After Jerusalem fell (586 BCE) and the Babylonian-appointed governor Gedaliah was murdered, a group of Judahites fled to Egypt and forced Jeremiah to go with them (Jer 41–43). Chapter 44 is set among Judahite communities at Migdol, Tahpanhes, Memphis (Noph) and Upper Egypt (Pathros). These are Jeremiah's last recorded words.

Who is speaking. Verse 15 describes 'all the men who knew their wives were burning offerings to other gods, and all the women standing by'. In v.19 the women speak directly: they made cakes 'in her image' and poured libations, with their husbands' approval. Jeremiah 7:17–18 describes the same cult as a family affair: children gather wood, fathers light the fire, women knead dough. It was household and neighbourhood religion, done on rooftops and in the streets, not temple religion.

'From the time we stopped' (v.18). Most scholars link the end of the cult to King Josiah's reform (c. 622 BCE; 2 Kgs 23), which removed the cult objects of Asherah, the rooftop altars, and the priests who made offerings 'to the sun, moon, constellations and all the host of heaven'. From the speakers' point of view the record is clear. Under Manasseh, who tolerated these cults, Judah had a long and stable reign (2 Kgs 21). Josiah's reform was followed by his death at Megiddo (609), then subjection to Egypt and Babylon, two sieges and the destruction of the city.

How Near Eastern people thought. Across the ancient Near East, disaster was commonly explained as the anger of a neglected deity. Babylonian texts, for example, blame the god Marduk's anger on a king who neglected his cult. The refugees are using the standard reasoning of their world. The book of Jeremiah reverses it: the disaster came because of this worship (44:20–23).

The goddess. The Queen of Heaven was an astral goddess, probably linked with Venus. Her identity is debated (Ishtar, Astarte, Anat, Asherah, or a blend of these; see debates). Thousands of small clay 'pillar figurines' of a female figure have been found in eighth- to seventh-century Judahite homes. Their identity is also debated, but they show that devotion to a goddess was widespread in Judah. A century later, the Jewish garrison at Elephantine in Upper Egypt still honoured goddess figures (Anat-Yahu, Anat-Bethel) alongside YHW.

From the study of Jeremiah 44:17.

Where scholars differ

in v17, v18

Who was the 'Queen of Heaven'?

  • Ishtar, or a blend of Ishtar and Astarte (the most widely held view).

    Ishtar bears the title *šarrat šamê*, 'queen of heaven', and is the Venus star. The *kawwanim* cakes of v.19 match the Akkadian *kamānu* cakes for Ishtar. Assyrian influence in Judah was strong under Manasseh. West Semitic Astarte was the local counterpart of Ishtar (argued by S. Olyan and S. Ackerman).

  • Asherah.

    Asherah was the most prominent goddess in Judah: the Kuntillet ʿAjrud and Khirbet el-Qom inscriptions mention 'YHWH and his asherah', and Josiah removed Asherah's objects (2 Kgs 23). But the title 'queen of heaven' is not attested for her, and she is not especially an astral goddess.

  • Anat.

    An Egyptian-period stela from Beth-Shan calls Anat 'queen of heaven'. Jews at Elephantine in Egypt later venerated Anat-Yahu. Against this, Anat is not clearly attested in seventh-century Judah.

  • A composite figure, not one deity.

    Ancient worshippers easily merged goddesses. A Hermopolis papyrus shows a 'Queen of Heaven' temple in Egypt c. 500 BCE without naming her. Jeremiah himself never gives a personal name.

in v17

Was this a foreign cult or part of traditional Judahite religion practised alongside YHWH?

  • Popular Judahite religion, practised alongside YHWH worship.

    The speakers claim ancestral, royal and official sanction across Judah and Jerusalem. Female figurines are found throughout Judahite homes. Jews at Elephantine later worshipped goddesses alongside YHW. Jeremiah 44:26 implies these people still swore 'as the Lord YHWH lives'.

  • Apostasy to 'other gods', as the book presents it.

    Jeremiah consistently classes the cult under 'other gods' (7:18; 44:3, 5, 8, 15). Deuteronomy's demand for exclusive worship, which these texts assume, leaves no room for a consort or a second divine provider.

in v18

What moment does 'since we stopped' refer to?

  • Josiah's reform (c. 622 BCE)

    2 Kings 23 records the removal of 'host of heaven' worship. After that came Josiah's death, vassalage, deportation and destruction, which matches the speakers' story of decline. Most commentators (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom) take this view.

  • A later, more local break, such as during the final siege or in response to Jeremiah's preaching

    The vague 'from then' could refer to a shorter interruption remembered by those present. But 7:18 shows the cult was alive again under Jehoiakim, so any stopping was not permanent.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. מְלֶכֶת, קָטַר, רָעָה, שָׂבֵעַ
  • HALOT s.v. קטר (piel: 'to make a sacrifice go up in smoke'), s.v. מְלֶכֶת
  • S. Ackerman, 'And the Women Knead Dough: The Worship of the Queen of Heaven in Sixth-Century Judah', in P. Day (ed.), Gender and Difference in Ancient Israel (1989)
  • S. Ackerman, Under Every Green Tree: Popular Religion in Sixth-Century Judah (1992)
  • S. M. Olyan, 'Some Observations Concerning the Identity of the Queen of Heaven', Ugarit-Forschungen 19 (1987)
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia)
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible)
  • O. Keel and C. Uehlinger, Gods, Goddesses, and Images of God in Ancient Israel
  • B. Porten, The Elephantine Papyri in English (Hermopolis papyri)
  • Septuagint Jeremiah 51:17 and 7:18; Targum Jonathan to Jeremiah 44:17; Vulgate
  • BDB s.v. קָטַר, חָסֵר, תָּמַם, מְלֶכֶת
  • HALOT s.v. קטר, חסר, תמם, מְלֶכֶת
  • S. Ackerman, 'And the Women Knead Dough: The Worship of the Queen of Heaven in Sixth-Century Judah' (1989)
  • M. Haran, Temples and Temple-Service in Ancient Israel (on qṭr)
  • B. Porten, The Elephantine Papyri in English (Hermopolis letters; Anat-Yahu)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 51:17–19 (Greek order)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).