Jeremiah Chapter 49 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 49:7–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

7Concerning Edom, this is what the LORD of Hosts says: “Is there no longer wisdom in Teman? Has counsel perished from the prudent? Has their wisdom decayed? 8Turn and run! Lie low, O dwellers of Dedan, for I will bring disaster on Esau at the time I punish him. 9If grape gatherers came to you, would they not leave some gleanings? Were thieves to come in the night, would they not steal only what they wanted? 10But I will strip Esau bare; I will uncover his hiding places, and he will be unable to conceal himself. His descendants will be destroyed along with his relatives and neighbors, and he will be no more. 11Abandon your orphans; I will preserve their lives. Let your widows trust in Me.”

What the first hearers heard

For Judeans who heard or read this oracle, the opening questions would have hit hard. Edom was the clever neighbour, famous for its sages. It was also the 'brother' remembered for betrayal when Jerusalem fell. Announcing that Teman's wisdom had run dry did several things at once:

  • It mocked a national point of pride. The quality Edom was best known for would fail it exactly when it was needed. The same taunt is aimed at Egypt's advisers (Isa 19:11–13) and Babylon's experts (Isa 47:10–13). Human statecraft cannot hold out when Yahweh decides the outcome.
  • It echoed something said at home. Jeremiah's own enemies had claimed that 'counsel will not perish from the wise' (Jer 18:18). Hearing that same counsel 'perish' in Edom showed that no group of experts, Judean or foreign, could guarantee safety.
  • It declared Yahweh's rule over the nations. The oracle opens with 'Yahweh of armies'. Edom's survival depends on the God of the people it looked down on, not on its own sharp minds or mountain strongholds (v. 16).
  • It gave hope of justice. For a defeated people, being told that the brother who gloated over them would be brought down too was a promise that wrongs would be put right (see Obadiah 15: 'as you have done, it shall be done to you').

The rhetorical questions invite the hearer to answer for themselves: Yes, Teman's wisdom is gone. The next verses show what it looks like when that wisdom fails: flight, exposure, and ruin (vv. 8–10).

From the study of Jeremiah 49:7.

Verse by verse

  1. 7Concerning Edom, this is what the LORD of Hosts says: “Is there no longer wisdom in Teman? Has counsel perished from the prudent? Has their wisdom decayed?

    About Edom. This is the message of Yahweh, commander of the armies of heaven:

    "Has Teman run out of wisdom? Teman, the place famous for its sages! Has good advice gone missing from the people who are supposed to see clearly? Has all that cleverness of theirs leaked away, gone stale like a spilled jar?"

    The questions mock rather than ask. Everyone in the ancient Near East knew Edom as the land of wise men. Teman, one of its chief districts, stands for the whole country, rather as 'Athens' might stand for philosophy. The 'wisdom' meant is practical know-how: the shrewd judgment of royal advisers and diplomats, which ought to spot danger and steer a small kingdom through it. The three lines name three failures one after another: wisdom is gone, counsel (the policy that advisers produce) has perished, and the discernment of the clever has dried up. The verse opens and closes on the word 'wisdom', and in between it all drains away.

    The verb in the last line occurs nowhere else in this form. It pictures something spilling loose or going off. Edom's wisdom is treated as a store that has run out or spoiled. The answer the hearer is meant to give is: yes, it is gone. The next verses explain why. Disaster is coming on 'Esau' (v. 8), and Edom's famous advisers either cannot see it or cannot do anything about it.

    Full study →
  2. 8Turn and run! Lie low, O dwellers of Dedan, for I will bring disaster on Esau at the time I punish him.

    "Run! Turn around and get out! Go deep into hiding and stay there, you people of Dedan! For I, the LORD, have already set Esau's ruin in motion and brought it down on him: the appointed hour when I call him to account."

    The verse begins with four rapid commands shouted at foreign traders who happen to be in Edom's territory. The Dedanites were caravan people from the Arabian oases to the south-east. They are told to stop, turn their camels around, and vanish into the deep places of the desert. The word "dwell" is repeated: you who dwell in Dedan, go and dwell deep. The safe place to live is now somewhere hidden.

    The reason is Edom's fate, here called by the name of its ancestor Esau, Jacob's estranged twin. The ruin is "Esau's ruin," the kind Obadiah described when Edom gloated over Judah's fall, now coming back on Edom itself. God speaks of bringing it in the completed tense ("I have brought"), as though it has already happened. The prophet wants it heard as certain.

    The last phrase is not a friendly call. The verb is paqad: a superior who comes to inspect, reviews the case, and acts on what he finds. For a guilty Edom, the "time of visitation" is the hour of sentencing.

    Full study →
  3. 9If grape gatherers came to you, would they not leave some gleanings? Were thieves to come in the night, would they not steal only what they wanted?

    Picture Edom as a vineyard and then as a house. Suppose the grape harvesters came to you: wouldn't they leave a few stray clusters on the vine? Every Israelite knew that harvesters never strip a vine completely. It does not happen in practice, and the law said those last grapes belonged to the poor, the widow and the orphan. Suppose burglars came in the night: wouldn't they wreck and take only as much as they wanted, and then slip away? Even a thief breaking in through the wall in the dark stops at "enough", at what he can carry.

    Both pictures describe ordinary human loss: painful, but limited, and it always leaves something behind. The next verse turns on them: "But I will strip Esau bare." What God brings on Edom will be unlike the harvester or the thief. It will leave no gleanings and stop at no "enough". The harvesters (bōṣərîm) probably also play on the name of Edom's capital, Bozrah: Edom's own "Bozrah" will be harvested. Jeremiah's word for what the thieves do is stronger than "steal". It means "ruin" or "spoil". That makes the contrast sharper still: even destroyers stop somewhere, and this judgment will not.

    Full study →
  4. 10But I will strip Esau bare; I will uncover his hiding places, and he will be unable to conceal himself. His descendants will be destroyed along with his relatives and neighbors, and he will be no more.

    Grape-pickers always leave a few clusters on the vine. Thieves in the night take what they want and go. But I myself, not some passing raider, have already stripped Esau naked. God speaks of what he will do as if it were finished. The words are the ones used for pulling off a person's clothes in public shame. I have laid open every place where he hides, every cave, cleft and rock shelter in Edom's mountains where its people and treasure were hidden. He will try to hide himself, and he will not be able to. Then comes the result, with the ruin put first for emphasis: ravaged — his offspring, his kinsmen and his neighbors. The violence takes the next generation, the related clans, and the peoples around Edom. And in two stark Hebrew words, the same idiom used of Enoch and of Rachel's lost children: "and he is not." Edom, the nation descended from Esau, Jacob's brother, will simply no longer exist.

    Full study →
  5. 11Abandon your orphans; I will preserve their lives. Let your widows trust in Me.”

    Spoken to Edom ("Esau") just after God announces that its hiding places will be exposed and its men, kinsmen and neighbours wiped out:

    "Leave your fatherless children behind; I myself will keep them alive. And your widows can lean on me."

    The picture is a man who knows he will not survive and has no brother or neighbour left to take in his family. The command "leave them" is not a call to desert them heartlessly. It says: when you fall, your children will be left behind, and I will be the one who keeps them alive. "I" is emphatic in the Hebrew: God himself, since no one else is left. The children are "fatherless" rather than orphans in the modern sense, because their mothers are still living as widows. In that world widows and fatherless children were the people with no protector, and protecting them was what a just king or a near kinsman was supposed to do. Edom had relied on its mountain strongholds and its warriors, and those are about to fail. Its most defenceless survivors are now invited to rest their whole security on the God who is judging their nation. Readers have taken the line as genuine mercy inside a judgment oracle, or as a stark way of saying that nobody but God is left. Either way it shows how complete Edom's ruin is.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v7

    wisdom

    ḥokhmah

    What we hear
    Deep spiritual insight, moral maturity, or godly understanding.
    What they heard
    Practical, shrewd expertise. Here it is the political and diplomatic savvy of Edom's sages and royal advisers, valued as a national asset whether or not it had anything to do with God.
  • in v7

    LORD of hosts

    YHWH tseva'ot

    What we hear
    A vague, ceremonial title; 'hosts' suggests a crowd, or someone who welcomes guests.
    What they heard
    'Yahweh of armies': the commander of the heavenly forces. The title signals military power, which suits an oracle announcing war on Edom.
  • in v8

    the time I will visit him (KJV); when I visit him (WEB)

    ʿēt peqadtiv

    What we hear
    A friendly call or a time of personal attention. In devotional language, 'a visitation' can even suggest a revival or a blessing.
    What they heard
    The appointed hour when God, as overlord and judge, inspects Edom's case and acts on it. Here that means judgment and punishment.
  • in v9

    they will destroy till they have enough (KJV)

    hišḥîtû dayyām

    What we hear
    The thieves keep destroying until they are satisfied, which sounds like an extended rampage.
    What they heard
    The thieves ruin and take only as much as they need and then stop. The phrase is about a limit, and the contrast with v.10 depends on it.
  • in v10

    Esau

    ʿēśāw

    What we hear
    The individual man in Genesis, Jacob's brother, as if God were judging him personally.
    What they heard
    The nation of Edom, called by its ancestor's name and spoken of as one man.
  • in v10

    his secret places (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    mistārāyw

    What we hear
    His secrets, hidden sins or private thoughts that God will reveal.
    What they heard
    Physical hiding places: caves, rock clefts, lairs and hidden stores in Edom's mountains.
  • in v10

    his seed is spoiled (KJV)

    šuddad zarʿô

    What we hear
    'Spoiled' sounds like rotten or pampered, and 'seed' like something planted in the ground.
    What they heard
    His offspring (descendants) are violently plundered and devastated.
  • in v11

    orphans (BSB, NASB)

    yetomim

    What we hear
    Children whose mother and father have both died.
    What they heard
    Children who have lost their father, and with him their protector and provider. Here their mothers are explicitly alive, as 'your widows'.
  • in v11

    Abandon (BSB)

    ʿozvah

    What we hear
    A callous command to desert one's children.
    What they heard
    Leave behind, as a doomed father leaves his family behind, here into God's keeping.
Every word
  1. לֶאֱד֗וֹם

    le'edom · H0123

    to/concerning Edom · v7

    A heading, like 'concerning Moab' (48:1) and 'concerning the Ammonites' (49:1): it names who the oracle is about. Edom ('red') was the people descended from Esau, Jacob's twin, living south-east of the Dead Sea.

  2. כֹּ֤ה

    koh · H3541

    thus · v7

    Opens the standard messenger formula: 'Thus says…'. A royal envoy used the same words to deliver his master's message word for word.

  3. אָמַר֙

    'amar · H0559

    he said / says · v7

    Grammatically a completed action ('has said'). In the messenger formula it presents the message as already spoken by the sender, with the prophet only passing it on.

  4. יְהוָ֣ה

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh, the LORD · v7

    Israel's God by his own name. Speaking about a foreign nation's fate, he is presented as ruling beyond Israel's borders.

  5. צְבָא֔וֹת

    tseva'ot · H6635

    armies, hosts · v7

    'Of armies': Yahweh as commander of the heavenly forces, and in the end of earthly ones too. It suits an oracle announcing the military disaster that follows (vv. 8–22).

  6. הַאֵ֥ין

    ha'ein · H0369

    is there not? / is there no…? · v7, v10

    The question marker ha- joined to 'there is not'. It opens a mocking question. The first hearers knew the answer: no, it is gone. The question seems to carry over to the next two lines as well.

  7. ע֛וֹד

    'od · H5750

    still, any longer · v7

    'Any more'. It assumes Teman once had famous wisdom and asks whether it has run out.

  8. חָכְמָ֖ה

    ḥokhmah · H2451

    wisdom, skill · v7

    Practical, shrewd know-how: here the political and diplomatic savvy of Edom's sages and advisers, the kind that keeps a small kingdom alive.

  9. בְּתֵימָ֑ן

    betheiman · H8487

    in Teman · v7

    A major district or town of Edom, named after a grandson of Esau (Gen 36:11). It stands for Edom as a whole and was famous for wise men (Eliphaz the Temanite in Job).

  10. אָבְדָ֤ה

    'avedah · H0006

    perished, been lost · v7

    'Has perished / gone missing'. Used of things that are lost and of people who die. Counsel has dropped out of existence. The Hebrew puts the verb first for emphasis.

  11. עֵצָה֙

    'etsah · H6098

    counsel, advice, plan · v7

    Policy advice given in a royal council, and the plans that come out of it. What has failed is Edom's ability to plan its way out of danger.

  12. מִבָּנִ֔ים

    mibbanim · H0995

    from the discerning · v7

    'From people of understanding'. Read this way it is a form of the verb bin, 'to discern'. The same letters can also mean 'from sons', which is how the Vulgate took it, but the parallel with 'wisdom' favours 'the discerning'.

  13. נִסְרְחָ֖ה

    nisreḥah · H5628

    has run off, spilled, gone stale · v7

    This verb form occurs only here. The root means to hang over, sprawl or spread loose. Here it probably pictures wisdom leaking away or going off, like spilled or spoiled liquid. Related Aramaic and Syriac words mean 'to stink, be corrupt', which lies behind renderings like 'decayed'.

  14. נֻ֤סוּ

    nusu · H5127

    flee · v8

    A plural command: 'Run away!' It is the word for running from battle or danger. It opens the verse with alarm, as a warning shouted to people who are still standing where they shouldn't be.

  15. הָפְנוּ֙

    hofnu · H6437G

    turn; (passive) be turned back · v8

    As the vowels stand, it is a rare passive command, 'be turned around!' The picture is a caravan or traveller turning back the way they came. With 'flee' just before it, it means turning your back on Edom and getting out.

  16. הֶעְמִ֣יקוּ

    he'miqu · H6009

    make deep, go deep · v8

    A causative command: 'make it deep,' that is, go deep into hiding. Together with the next word it means 'hide yourselves deep': in caves, in ravines, or far off in the desert, out of reach of the invading army.

  17. לָשֶׁ֔בֶת

    lashevet · H3427

    to dwell, to stay · v8

    'In order to stay / settle.' This finishes the idea of the word before it: 'go deep to stay,' meaning find a hidden place and stay there until the disaster has passed.

  18. דְּדָ֑ן

    dedan · H1719A

    Dedan · v8

    A caravan oasis and trading people in north-west Arabia, south-east of Edom. The Dedanites are outsiders to Edom, probably caught up in its trade, and they are told to get clear before God's judgment falls on Edom.

  19. כִּ֣י

    ki · H3588A

    for, because · v8, v10

    Gives the reason for the warning. Dedan must run because of what is about to happen to Esau.

  20. אֵ֥יד

    'ed · H0343

    calamity, ruin, disaster · v8

    A crushing disaster that brings a people down. It is the same word Obadiah uses three times for 'the day of their calamity' in his oracle against Edom (Obad 13). It means total ruin, not a setback.

  21. עֵשָׂ֛ו

    'esav · H6215H

    Esau · v8, v10

    Edom called by the name of its ancestor, Jacob's twin brother (Gen 25; 36). Using the brother's name recalls the long family rivalry between Israel and Edom.

  22. הֵבֵ֥אתִי

    hevetí · H0935P

    I have brought, I bring · v8, v9

    A causative verb in the completed tense, 'I have brought.' Prophets use this tense for a future event that is as good as done. God himself is the one bringing the ruin.

  23. עָלָ֖יו

    'alav · H5921A

    upon him · v8, v11

    'Upon him,' meaning on Esau/Edom, treated as one person. The ruin comes down on him like a weight.

  24. עֵ֥ת

    'et · H6256

    time, appointed time · v8

    A fixed moment, not time in general. God has a set hour for reckoning with Edom.

  25. פְּקַדְתִּֽיו׃

    peqadtiv · H6485H

    attend to, inspect, call to account; punish · v8

    'When I have called him to account.' A superior steps in, examines, and acts on what he finds. Against a guilty party, as here, that action is punishment.

  26. אִם־

    ʾim · H0518A

    if · v9

    Opens an imagined situation: 'suppose harvesters came...'. The verbs after it describe a hypothetical case, not something that has happened.

  27. בֹּֽצְרִים֙

    bōṣərîm · H1219

    grape-harvesters · v9

    Workers who cut the clusters off the vine at vintage. The word sounds like Bozrah, Edom's chief city, which is named in v.13.

  28. לָ֔ךְ

    lāk · H9032

    to you · v9

    'To you' in the singular. Edom/Esau is addressed directly as one person, as though he were a vineyard or a house.

  29. לֹ֥א

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v9, v10

    A plain negative. With no question word present, it allows either 'would they not leave...?' or 'they would not leave...'.

  30. יַשְׁאִ֖רוּ

    yašʾîrû · H7604

    they leave remaining · v9

    'Cause to remain, leave behind'. The same root gives the prophets' word for a 'remnant', the survivors who are left.

  31. עֽוֹלֵל֑וֹת

    ʿôlēlôt · H5955

    gleanings · v9

    The stray grapes left on the vine after the main harvest. Israelite law said these were to be left for the poor (Lev 19:10; Deut 24:21).

  32. גַּנָּבִ֥ים

    gannābîm · H1590

    thieves · v9

    Burglars who take property secretly. They are not an army. The point is that they take only what they can carry off.

  33. בַּלַּ֖יְלָה

    ballaylâ · H3915

    in the night · v9

    Night-time burglary means working quickly and in secret, so it is limited by its nature.

  34. הִשְׁחִ֥יתוּ

    hišḥîtû · H7843

    they ruined / did damage · v9

    'Ruin, spoil, wreck.' This is a stronger word than Obadiah's 'steal': the thieves damage and plunder, but only up to a point.

  35. דַיָּֽם׃

    dayyām · H1767

    their sufficiency · v9

    'Their enough', meaning only as much as they wanted. This is the limit every human plunderer reaches, and it sets up God's total stripping in v.10.

  36. אֲנִ֞י

    ʾănî · H0589

    I · v10, v11

    The verb already says 'I', so the separate pronoun adds emphasis: 'I myself'. The real plunderer is not a human raider but the LORD, the God of Israel.

  37. חָשַׂ֣פְתִּי

    ḥāśaptî · H2834

    to strip bare, lay bare · v10

    'I have stripped bare.' The word is used for pulling off a covering, whether clothing, bark or a sleeve. It carries the shame of being exposed in public. The past-tense form announces a future act as if it were already done.

  38. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    [direct-object marker] · v10

    Marks 'Esau' as the thing stripped. It has no English equivalent.

  39. גִּלֵּ֙יתִי֙

    gillêtî · H1540I

    to uncover, reveal · v10

    'I have uncovered.' It pairs with 'strip bare'. In the intensive form used here, this verb is the standard Hebrew wording for uncovering nakedness (Lev 18), so the two verbs together suggest shameful public exposure.

  40. מִסְתָּרָ֔יו

    mistārāyw · H4565

    hiding place, lair · v10

    'His hiding places': physical places of concealment, like the lurking-spots of a predator (Ps 10:8–9). In Edom these are the caves and rock clefts of its mountains (v.16), where people and stored goods could be hidden.

  41. וְנֶחְבָּ֖ה

    wəneḥbâ · H2247

    to hide oneself · v10

    'And to hide himself...' The written form looks like a finite verb ('and he hides'), but the sense is plain. Edom will try to hide and fail. Most translations treat it as 'to hide'.

  42. יוּכָ֑ל

    yûkāl · H3201

    to be able, prevail · v10

    'He will (not) be able.' The mountain hideouts that made Edom feel untouchable (v.16) give it no power to escape.

  43. שֻׁדַּ֥ד

    šuddad · H7703

    to devastate, plunder violently · v10

    'Devastated is...' The verb is passive and stands first for emphasis. Jeremiah uses this word again and again for armies sacking a land (4:20; 48:1; 49:3). It means violent ruin, not just loss.

  44. זַרְע֛וֹ

    zarʿô · H2233H

    seed; offspring · v10

    'His seed', meaning his offspring or descendants: the next generation of Edom, its future.

  45. וְאֶחָ֥יו

    wəʾeḥāyw · H0251G

    brother; kinsman · v10

    'And his brothers': Edom's kin, probably related clans and tribes. It does not mean Israel here, although Esau was Jacob's brother.

  46. וּשְׁכֵנָ֖יו

    ûšəkēnāyw · H7934

    neighbor, inhabitant nearby · v10

    'And his neighbors': the peoples living around Edom, possibly the Arabian groups such as Dedan named in v.8. The ruin spreads beyond Edom's own borders.

  47. עָזְבָ֥ה

    ʿozvah · H5800A

    leave, leave behind, forsake · v11

    A command to one man, Esau/Edom, in a lengthened form that makes it more emphatic: 'leave them behind!' The picture is a man who will not survive leaving his dependants behind, as a dying father leaves his children in someone else's care. It is not a call to desert them callously.

  48. יְתֹמֶ֖יךָ

    yetomeykha · H3490

    fatherless child · v11

    'Your fatherless ones.' The children of Edom's dead men. Their mothers are still alive (the widows in the next clause). What makes them a yatom is that they have lost their father, the one who protected and provided for them.

  49. אֲחַיֶּ֑ה

    ʾaḥayyeh · H2421

    keep alive, preserve alive · v11

    This is the form of 'live' that means 'cause to live': 'I will keep alive.' It is used for sparing and sustaining life, as when the midwives 'let the boys live' (Exod 1:17) or Joseph's role was 'to keep many people alive' (Gen 50:20). The object 'them' is not written but is clearly the orphans.

  50. וְאַלְמְנֹתֶ֖יךָ

    veʾalmenoteykha · H0490

    widow · v11

    'And your widows.' The women left without husbands, and here apparently without any male relatives either (v.10). In Israel's world that made them among the most exposed people there were.

  51. תִּבְטָֽחוּ׃

    tivṭaḥu · H0982

    trust, rely on, feel secure · v11

    'Let them rely' or 'they may rely.' The form is unusual with a feminine plural subject. It can be parsed as 'you (plural) shall trust' or as a rare form of 'they (women) shall trust'. Either way the sense is permission or invitation: the widows may lean their whole safety on God.

The world behind it

Edom and its reputation. Edom lay in the highlands south-east of the Dead Sea (Mount Seir). Its capital was Bozrah, and the King's Highway ran through it, carrying the caravan trade from Arabia, including incense and spices, north to Damascus and the coast. A trading kingdom of this kind depended on clever negotiation. Its contacts with Arabian oases such as Dedan (named in v. 8) probably helped build the 'wisdom of the east' reputation found across the Bible: Eliphaz the Temanite in Job, the 'people of the east' in 1 Kings 4:30, and Obadiah's 'wise men of Edom' (Obad 8).

Brother nation, bitter history. Israel traced Edom back to Esau, Jacob's twin (Gen 25:30, where 'Edom' means 'red'). The two were related and often hostile. In 594 BC Edom's envoys came to Jerusalem to plot revolt against Babylon (Jer 27:3). When Jerusalem fell in 586 BC, Edom was remembered as gloating over it, or even helping (Ps 137:7; Lam 4:21–22; Ezek 25:12–14; Obad 10–14). Jeremiah's oracle may date from somewhere in this period; its exact date is uncertain. Edom itself was later crushed, probably during the Babylonian king Nabonidus's campaign in the 550s BC. Its people drifted into southern Judah, which later became 'Idumea'.

The oracles against the nations. Jeremiah 46–51 is a collection of oracles against foreign peoples. Each begins with a heading of the form 'Concerning X' and declares that Yahweh, not local gods, decides their fate. The Edom section (49:7–22) shares much of its wording with Obadiah 1–9: compare Jer 49:9–10, 14–16 with Obad 1–6. Teman is named in both, and wisdom is singled out as Edom's pride.

From the study of Jeremiah 49:7.

Where scholars differ

in v7

What does נִסְרְחָה (nisreḥah) mean: 'vanished/spilled' or 'decayed/gone stale'?

  • Let loose, spilled out, dissipated ('vanished').

    Elsewhere the Hebrew root means 'hang loose, overhang, sprawl' (Exod 26:12; Amos 6:4). BDB takes the form here as 'be let loose, i.e. poured out'. The Old Greek's ᾤχετο ('has gone') supports the idea of wisdom departing.

  • Gone bad, spoiled, stale ('decayed').

    Aramaic and Syriac s-r-ḥ mean 'stink, be corrupt'. HALOT and several modern versions follow this. It also fits the picture of wisdom as a stored good that can spoil.

in v7

Does מִבָּנִים mean 'from the discerning' or 'from sons'?

  • 'From the discerning', a participle of bin.

    It matches 'wisdom' in the lines on either side, and Isaiah 29:14 has a close parallel. Most modern translations and commentators read it this way, as does the supplied data.

  • 'From sons', the plural of ben (perhaps the sons of Teman, or the younger generation).

    This is the most common meaning of the identical form, and the Vulgate reads it so ('a filiis'). It is a minority view today.

in v7

How is the Edom oracle related to Obadiah?

  • Jeremiah adapted Obadiah.

    Obadiah's version reads as a more tightly connected whole. Some scholars think Jeremiah's version shows signs of reworking.

  • Obadiah drew on Jeremiah, or both used an older oracle against Edom.

    Each text has material the other lacks, and the order of shared lines differs. That suggests a common source rather than simple copying. Many commentators leave the question open.

in v8

Why is Dedan told to flee: as an innocent bystander, or as Edom's partner?

  • Bystanders: Dedanite traders are warned to get clear so they are not caught in Edom's fall.

    The verse is addressed to Dedan but gives Esau's ruin as the reason. Dedan was a caravan people whose trade ran through Edom (Isa 21:13; Ezek 27:20). Most commentators read it this way.

  • Partners or dependants: Dedan is warned because it is bound up with Edom and will share in its judgment.

    Ezek 25:13 'from Teman to Dedan' marks the area of judgment against Edom. Jer 25:23 puts Dedan among the nations that drink the cup of wrath. On this reading, the order to flee shows the danger rather than a guaranteed escape.

in v8

What does 'turn back' (hofnu) picture?

  • Turning one's back and running, as in a rout.

    It stands between 'flee' and 'go deep,' and the related active form is used for turning one's back in retreat (Jer 46:5, 21; 48:39). Jerome's 'turn your backs' reads it this way.

  • Caravans turning around and going home.

    Fits Dedan's identity as traders who travelled into Edom. 'Turn back' would then mean stop your journey and go home to Arabia.

in v9

Are the lines rhetorical questions ('would they not leave gleanings?') or statements ('they will leave no gleanings')?

  • Rhetorical questions: even harvesters and thieves leave something, but God will leave nothing (v.10).

    The parallel Obadiah 5 has the question word hălôʾ. Hebrew can ask questions without a particle. The 'But I' (kî-ʾănî) of v.10 reads naturally as a contrast. This is the view of most modern translations and commentaries.

  • Statements: the harvesters who come against Edom will leave nothing, and the thieves will destroy all they can.

    Jeremiah lacks the question particle that Obadiah has, and may have reshaped the saying deliberately. The Septuagint appears to read statements, and YLT follows the Hebrew literally.

in v9

How is Jeremiah 49:7–22 related to Obadiah 1–6?

  • Jeremiah adapted Obadiah.

    Obadiah's version is tighter and more natural in its context. Jeremiah's changes (the order, 'ruin' for 'steal', no question words) look like reworking.

  • Obadiah drew on Jeremiah.

    Obadiah is often dated after 587 BC because of its account of Edom's conduct at Jerusalem's fall, which could make it later than Jeremiah's oracle.

  • Both used an older oracle against Edom.

    Each version has material the other lacks, and each fits its own context. A shared earlier saying explains the overlap and the differences.

in v10

Who are 'his brothers and his neighbors'?

  • Related clans and tribes allied with Edom, such as Dedan, Tema or Buz, which are named around this oracle (49:8; 25:23).

    Verse 8 tells the people of Dedan to flee, which places them in the same disaster. 'Brothers' often means kin groups or tribes.

  • The terms simply round out the picture of total destruction: family, kin and surroundings.

    Lists like 'seed, brothers, neighbors' are a common way of saying 'everyone connected to him'.

  • In the Greek tradition, brother and neighbor are the agents of Edom's ruin.

    The Septuagint appears to read 'by the hand of his brother and neighbor', which some link to the later Arab (Nabataean) takeover of Edom.

in v10

How does 'he is no more' fit with God's care for Edom's orphans and widows in v.11?

  • Verse 11 is a real offer of mercy: God will look after the helpless survivors even as the nation ends.

    'I will keep them alive' and 'let your widows trust in me' match God's usual role as protector of orphans and widows (Deut 10:18; Ps 68:5).

  • Verse 11 is ironic or bitter. No men will be left to care for the families, so 'leave them to me'.

    It directly follows the statement that the men, kin and neighbors are destroyed, and its tone in context is debated among commentators.

in v10

Did Jeremiah borrow from Obadiah, or Obadiah from Jeremiah?

  • Both draw on an older shared oracle against Edom.

    Each has material the other lacks, and the order of shared lines differs.

  • Jeremiah adapted Obadiah (or the reverse).

    Close verbal overlap in Jer 49:9–10, 14–16 and Obad 1–6. Scholars disagree about which version is smoother and therefore secondary.

in v11

Is verse 11 a genuine word of mercy, or a grim way of saying Edom's ruin is total?

  • A genuine promise: God himself will care for Edom's widows and fatherless, even as he judges the nation.

    It is first-person divine speech with an emphatic 'I'. It uses the standard language of God as protector of widow and fatherless (Deut 10:18; Ps 68:5; 146:9). Jeremiah's oracles against the nations elsewhere include notes of mercy (48:47; 49:6, 39). The ancient versions (e.g. the Vulgate) and most translations read it this way.

  • Mainly a statement of how complete the disaster is: no man, kinsman or neighbour is left, so only God could look after the survivors. Some readers hear a note of irony.

    It comes straight after verse 10 ('his offspring, brothers and neighbours are destroyed, and he is no more') and is followed at once by the inescapable cup of wrath (v.12). Edom receives no promise of restoration, unlike Moab, Ammon and Elam. A few commentators take the line as rhetorical or as mocking.

  • The words of a neighbour or kinsman whom verse 10 says no longer exists ('there is none to say, "Leave your orphans, I will keep them alive"').

    It would make a smooth link with the end of verse 10 and has some support from the Greek text's wording. But it needs a small change to, or reinterpretation of, the Hebrew. 'Let your widows trust in me' also fits God far more naturally than a human neighbour.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. חָכְמָה, עֵצָה, סָרַח, בִּין, תֵּימָן
  • HALOT s.v. סרח (niphal), תֵּימָן, צָבָא
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible)
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia)
  • J. R. Bartlett, Edom and the Edomites
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 29:8 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 49:7
  • Parallel texts: Obadiah 1–9; Jeremiah 18:18; Isaiah 19:11–13; 29:14; Job 2:11; Baruch 3:22–23
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. פָּקַד
  • HALOT s.v. אֵיד
  • HALOT s.v. עמק (Hiphil)
  • HALOT s.v. דְּדָן
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (Kautzsch-Cowley) §46a on Hophal imperatives
  • Nabonidus inscriptions (Harran stele) on campaigns to Tema and Dedan
  • Obadiah 1-14 (parallel oracle against Edom)
  • Jeremiah 25:23; 46:21; 49:30; Isaiah 21:13; Ezekiel 25:13; 27:20
  • OSHB morphology as supplied
  • BDB s.v. בָּצַר, עֹלֵלוֹת, שָׁחַת, דַּי
  • HALOT s.v. עֹלֵלוֹת; שׁחת hiphil
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §150a on questions without an interrogative particle
  • Obadiah 1–6 (parallel text)
  • Leviticus 19:10; Deuteronomy 24:21 (gleaning laws)
  • Exodus 22:2–3; Job 24:16 (night burglary)
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia) on 49:7–22
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible) on 49:9
  • Septuagint Jeremiah ch. 29 (Edom oracle)
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 49:9
  • BDB s.v. חָשַׂף, מִסְתָּר, שָׁדַד, אַיִן
  • HALOT s.v. חשׂף, מִסְתָּר, חבה, שׁדד
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia), on 49:7–22
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible), on 49:9–10
  • Josephus, Antiquities 13.257–258
  • Nabonidus relief at as-Sela' (southern Jordan)
  • BHS critical apparatus on Jer 49:10
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. עָזַב, יָתוֹם, אַלְמָנָה, בָּטַח, חָיָה
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) on lengthened imperatives and irregular feminine plural imperfect forms
  • Code of Hammurabi, prologue/epilogue (justice for the widow and orphan)
  • Ugaritic Epic of Aqhat (Danel judging the widow and fatherless) and Epic of Kirta
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 29 (Edom oracle); Vulgate, Jeremiah 49:11
  • Parallel text: Obadiah 1-6
  • Standard Jeremiah commentaries (e.g. Holladay, Hermeneia; McKane, ICC; Lundbom, Anchor Bible) on Jer 49:7-22

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).