Job Chapter 19 Read as one passage
Job 19:24–28
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
24by an iron stylus on lead, or chiseled in stone forever. 25But I know that my Redeemer lives, and in the end He will stand upon the earth. 26Even after my skin has been destroyed, yet in my flesh I will see God. 27I will see Him for myself; my eyes will behold Him, and not as a stranger. How my heart yearns within me! 28If you say, ‘Let us persecute him, since the root of the matter lies with him,’
What the first hearers heard
Job is set in the distant patriarchal past in the land of Uz. The book was probably composed somewhere between the late monarchy and the Persian period; its date is debated. It reached Israelite readers who knew the go'el custom from daily life, and probably knew the prophets' use of go'el as a name for YHWH.
For them the line would have landed with great force. Job, abandoned by every relative who ought to act as his go'el, claims a living go'el anyway. Job's dispute is with God, so the claim raises a question the book leaves unresolved here. Is Job calling on some heavenly advocate to defend him against God? Or is he daring to believe that God, his accuser, will in the end act as his next-of-kin and clear his name?
Either way, the verse expresses defiant trust that justice will finally be done for him, even if it comes only after he has gone down to the dust. In the book's own story, it anticipates God speaking from the whirlwind (chs. 38–41) and God's verdict that Job, unlike the friends, has "spoken of me what is right" (42:7). Readers did not hear it as a doctrine of the end of the world. It was a sufferer's cry of confidence in a coming vindication.
From the study of Job 19:25.
Verse by verse
-
24by an iron stylus on lead, or chiseled in stone forever.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
25But I know that my Redeemer lives, and in the end He will stand upon the earth.
Full study →"But as for me, I know it: my champion, my next-of-kin bound to take up my cause, is alive. And at the last, when all others have spoken and I am gone, he will rise up over the dust and speak for me."
Job has just wished his protest could be carved into rock with an iron tool so it would outlive him (19:23–24). Now he reaches past even that. A living defender is better than a dead inscription.
The word behind "Redeemer" is go'el. In Israel's family law, the go'el was the relative who had to step in when one of his own lost his land, his freedom or his life: he bought back, avenged, and pleaded the case. Job has just said that every relative and friend has abandoned him (19:13–19). Yet he insists he has a go'el who has not.
"Lives" sets this champion against Job's own coming death. "At the last" is open: it may mean in the end, after I am gone, or he will be the last to speak, the one whose testimony settles the case. "Upon the dust" is literally dust, the dust of the grave where Job expects to lie. "Will rise" is the verb for a witness getting to his feet in court.
So the picture is a courtroom, possibly over Job's grave. Job's living kinsman-champion stands up last and clears his name, and Job's case is against God himself.
-
26Even after my skin has been destroyed, yet in my flesh I will see God.
Full study →"And after my skin has been struck off, flayed away like this, yet from my own flesh I will behold God."
Job speaks as a man whose skin is already peeling and rotting off him (2:7; 7:5; 19:20). He looks ahead to the point where the stripping is complete, which may mean death itself, and insists that it will not be the end of his case. He will still see God. The verb is a strong one: to gaze at, to behold, the word used for vision. He expects an encounter, not a vague hope.
The phrase "from my flesh" is deliberately compact. It can mean looking out from within my own body: Job, still a physical person, sees God with his own eyes. It can also mean apart from my flesh: after his body is gone. The next verse presses hard on personal, physical sight: "I myself will see Him, my own eyes, and not another's." That emphasis leans toward a seeing in which Job is himself and present.
"God" here is Eloah, the same God Job has just accused of striking him (19:6, 21). The man insists he will stand face to face with the one he is suing, and that God will, in the end, take his side. The Hebrew contains no worms and no word for "body". It contains a stripped man, a sharp verb, and an unshaken expectation of seeing God.
-
27I will see Him for myself; my eyes will behold Him, and not as a stranger. How my heart yearns within me!
Full study →"…the God whom I, I myself, will behold, and he will be on my side. My own eyes will see him, and not as a stranger, not through someone else. My insides are spent with longing within me!"
Job has just declared that his vindicator lives and will rise up on the dust (v.25), and that even after his skin is torn away he will 'behold God' (v.26). This verse finishes that sentence and then breaks. He piles on the first person: I, for me, my eyes. What he hopes for is not a rumour about God or a verdict passed on through others. It is a face-to-face audience, the kind of 'beholding' psalm-singers longed for when they hoped to see God's face in the temple.
The short phrase lî can mean 'for myself' or 'on my side'. The God who has been treating Job as an enemy will be for him. The phrase 'and not a stranger' deliberately echoes the lines just before it: Job's relatives have become strangers to him and his servants treat him as an outsider (vv.13–15). He will see with no one standing in for him, and the meeting will not be a hostile encounter with someone alien.
Then his body gives out under the weight of the hope. 'My kidneys are spent in my bosom': in Hebrew thought the kidneys held a person's deepest feelings, roughly what English means by 'my heart' or 'my gut'. The verb means both 'used up' and 'fainting with longing.' The sounds echo each other (kālû kilyōtay), so the line ends almost as a gasp: hope so intense that it drains him.
-
28If you say, ‘Let us persecute him, since the root of the matter lies with him,’
Full study →Job turns from his great hope (vv. 25–27: "I know that my Redeemer lives… my eyes will see him") back to the three men sitting with him. He sums up their whole approach in one sentence and puts it in their mouths: "How we'll run him down! The grounds of the case are plainly in him."
The picture is a hunt. The verb is the one used for armies chasing a beaten enemy or a hunter after game. Job has already complained that his friends hound him the way God does (v. 22). The second half uses courtroom language. "Root" means the hidden source something grows from. "Matter" is the Hebrew word for a legal case. "Is found in" is the phrase Israelite law used when guilt was discovered in someone. So the friends' theory is that whatever is happening to Job grew from a root inside Job. It is a sharp image, because Bildad has just described the wicked man whose "roots dry up below" (18:16).
The standard Hebrew text ends with "in me." That may be Job dropping out of the quotation and speaking for himself. Or he may be repeating their accusation from where he stands: "the root of it is in me, you say." Many manuscripts and all the main ancient translations read "in him," which keeps the whole line as the friends' words. Either way the point is the same. The sentence is the first half of a warning, and verse 29 completes it: if this is how you talk, then be afraid of the sword yourselves, because men who hunt down an innocent man with false charges are bringing judgment on their own heads.
Where the English drifted
-
in v25
Redeemer
go'el
- What we hear
- A title of Jesus Christ as the one who saves sinners from sin and death, usually capitalised.
- What they heard
- A kinsman-champion: the relative bound to buy back, avenge and legally defend a family member. Here it means a vindicator who will take up Job's case.
-
in v25
at the latter day (KJV)
'acharon
- What we hear
- The Last Day, the Day of Judgment at the end of history.
- What they heard
- "Last" or "at last." Possibly "afterward" (after Job's death), or "as the last one," the one who has the final word in court. No "day" is in the Hebrew.
-
in v25
upon the earth
ʿal-ʿafar
- What we hear
- On planet earth, the world to which Christ returns.
- What they heard
- "Upon / over the dust," a word that in Job repeatedly means the grave and the dust of the dead. It most likely means standing over Job's grave or over Job brought down to dust.
-
in v26
though … worms destroy this body (KJV)
niqqəpû zōʾt
- What we hear
- A corpse decaying in the grave and eaten by worms, the sense the line has carried for centuries in burial services and Handel's Messiah.
- What they heard
- '(My skin) has been struck off, like this.' Neither 'worms' nor 'body' is in the Hebrew. The verb means to strike off or cut away, and the image is Job's skin being stripped by disease, possibly up to and including death.
-
in v26
in my flesh
mibbəśārî
- What we hear
- Clearly in a raised, resurrected body.
- What they heard
- Literally 'from my flesh'. It can mean 'from within / from the vantage of my flesh' or 'apart from my flesh'. The Hebrew leaves open whether Job means seeing God before death, after death in the body, or after death without it.
-
in v27
reins (KJV, YLT)
kilyōt
- What we hear
- The straps used to steer a horse, or in a vague sense 'control'.
- What they heard
- The kidneys, regarded as the seat of a person's deepest emotions and hidden thoughts.
-
in v27
and not another (KJV, ESV, NASB, NIV)
wəlōʾ-zār
- What we hear
- Simply 'I and no one else': purely about who does the seeing.
- What they heard
- Zār is the 'outsider' or 'estranged' word that Job has just used for how his family treats him (vv.13–15). It can mean 'someone else', but in this chapter it also suggests that God will not meet him as a stranger or enemy.
-
in v28
the root of the matter
shoresh davar
- What we hear
- The core issue or essential point. In older devotional English it also meant genuine inward faith or saving grace ('he has the root of the matter in him').
- What they heard
- The source or grounds of the case: the friends' claim that the cause of Job's disaster grows from something hidden in Job, namely his guilt.
-
in v28
persecute
radaph
- What we hear
- Oppressing someone for their faith, ethnicity or beliefs.
- What they heard
- To chase, pursue or hound, the picture of hunters or soldiers running down their quarry. Here it describes the friends' relentless verbal attack.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v25
"The latter day" isn't in Job's Hebrew
- What's often taught
- In this verse Job explicitly foretells the Last Day, when Christ will return to stand on the earth and raise the dead.
- What the text supports
The Hebrew says: "my go'el is alive, and last (or at last) he will rise over the dust."
- There is no word for "day." 'Acharon (H0314) means "last." It may mean "in the end," "after me," or "the one who speaks last" in court.
- "Earth" is ʿafar (H6083), "dust," which in Job is the dust of the grave (7:21; 17:16; 21:26).
- "Stand" is qum (H6965I), the verb for a witness rising in court, and the setting is Job's lawsuit (9:33; 16:19–21; 19:6–7).
- Go'el (H1350A) is a kinsman-champion and vindicator.
The reading gets something right. Job does voice a remarkable hope that he will be vindicated, possibly beyond his death, and Christians have long seen that hope answered in Christ. But the verse itself expresses Job's confidence that a living champion will clear his name over his grave. It does not lay out an end-times timetable.
- Where the English feeds it
- The KJV, following Jerome's Vulgate ("on the last day"), supplies "day" in italics. Nearly all versions render "dust" as "earth," which suggests a return to the planet. Capitalising "Redeemer" and "He" settles the identity in advance. Handel's Messiah fixed the KJV wording in popular memory.
in v26
The worms in Job 19:26 come from English Bibles, not Job's Hebrew
- What's often taught
- Through its long use at funerals and in Handel's Messiah, the verse is often read as Job describing his corpse eaten by worms in the grave, followed by a clearly stated bodily resurrection.
- What the text supports
The Hebrew says only 'after my skin has been struck off, this…'. The verb niqqəpû (strike off, cut away) describes skin being stripped. In context it fits Job's skin disease (2:7; 7:5; 19:20; 30:30), whether or not death is in view. 'Worms' and 'body' are not in the text. The second half reads literally 'from my flesh I will see God', and 'from' can mean either 'from within' or 'without'.
The common reading gets some things right. The verse does voice a hope that reaches toward, and possibly past, the edge of death, and early Greek and Latin readers heard resurrection in it. But the Hebrew is compressed and debated. It does not paint the grave scene, and on its own it does not state a worked-out doctrine of bodily resurrection. The book itself fulfils Job's 'seeing' while he is alive (42:5).
- Where the English feeds it
- The KJV supplies 'worms' and 'body' (marked in italics, but lost when spoken or sung). NLT adds 'decayed'. Most versions render 'from my flesh' as 'in my flesh', which settles an open question.
Every word
-
וַאֲנִ֣י
va'ani · H0589
-
יָ֭דַעְתִּי
yadaʿti · H3045
I know · v25
The perfect form, used for a settled state: "I know, I am sure." It is a confession of conviction, not a reasoned proof. It is striking from a man who has spent the book saying he cannot find out why he suffers.
-
גֹּ֣אֲלִי
go'ali · H1350A
my redeemer / kinsman-champion / vindicator · v25
The go'el was the relative bound to step in when a family member lost land, freedom or life: he bought back, avenged and pleaded the case. "My" go'el is personal. Job means a champion who will take up his cause, here in a lawsuit.
-
חָ֑י
chai · H2416A
alive, living · v25
"Is alive" or "lives." Job is close to death, and the inscription he has just wished for (19:23–24) would be dead letters in stone. His go'el, by contrast, is living and will outlast him. It can also be heard as a title, "the Living One" (as in YLT).
-
וְ֝אַחֲר֗וֹן
ve'acharon · H0314
and last · v25
Literally "and last," an adjective. It can work as an adverb ("at last, in the end, afterward"). Or it can describe the go'el as "the last one," either the one who stands up after Job is gone or the one who has the last word in court. No word for "day" is present.
-
עַל־
ʿal · H5921A
upon, over · v25
"Upon" or "over." It places the go'el's standing above the dust, which may mean over Job's grave.
-
עָפָ֥ר
ʿafar · H6083
-
יָקֽוּם׃
yaqum · H6965I
he will rise, stand up · v25
"He will rise / stand up." In legal settings qum is the word for a witness or advocate rising in court to speak (Deut 19:15–16; Ps 27:12; Job 16:8). The picture is a champion getting to his feet to plead Job's case.
-
וְאַחַר
wəʾaḥar · H0310
and after; behind · v26
Most likely temporal: 'and after' the stripping of his skin. The word can also mean 'behind', and a few scholars read 'behind/within my skin', but the time sense is the usual reading. It echoes the 'last' or 'at the end' (ʾaḥărôn) of verse 25.
-
עוֹרִי
ʿôrî · H5785
-
נִקְּפוּ־
niqqəpû · H5362
to strike off, cut down, flay · v26
A strong verb of cutting or knocking off, used for felling thickets (Isa 10:34). The 'they' has no named subject, which is a common Hebrew way of saying 'has been struck off'. Job pictures his skin hacked or peeled away.
-
זֹאת
zōʾt · H2063
this · v26
'This', a feminine pointing word. It may point to his skin or body, as if he gestured at himself, or work like an adverb, 'thus, like this'. Its role in the sentence is unclear. The KJV's 'this body' adds 'body' to make sense of it.
-
וּמִבְּשָׂרִי
ûmibbəśārî · H1320
and from my flesh · v26
'And from my flesh.' The small prefix min ('from') carries the verse's main ambiguity. It can mean 'from within / from the vantage of my flesh', so still embodied, or 'apart from / without my flesh'. Basar is the whole physical, mortal body.
-
אֶחֱזֶה
ʾeḥĕzeh · H2372
I will see, behold · v26, v27
'I will see/behold.' The verb is incomplete action, pointing to the future or to a firm expectation. Chazah is a weighty verb for looking intently, often used of seeing in a vision. Verse 27 repeats it ('whom I will see for myself') and insists on his own eyes.
-
אֱלוֹהַּ
ʾĕlôah · H0433
God · v26
Eloah, the singular, poetic name for God that the book of Job uses far more than any other book. It names the very God Job is accusing of wronging him. Job expects to see his opponent in court face to face.
-
אֲשֶׁ֤ר
ʾăšer · H0834A
who, which, whom · v27
Links back to 'God' (ʾĕlôah) at the end of v.26: 'the God whom…'. The verse continues v.26's sentence, so the one Job will see is God, whom Job may also identify with the 'redeemer' of v.25.
-
לִּ֗י
lî · H9030
to me, for me · v27, v28
Either 'for myself' (stressing that Job sees in person) or 'on my side, in my favour' (as in Ps 56:9, 'God is for me', ʾĕlōhîm lî). Both readings fit; the second makes God appear as Job's ally, no longer his opponent.
-
וְעֵינַ֣י
wəʿênay · H5869A
eye(s) · v27
'And my eyes': a pair of eyes, his own. Job insists on bodily, physical sight, not a figure of speech or a report passed on by others.
-
רָא֣וּ
rāʾû · H7200G
to see · v27
Grammatically a completed-action form ('have seen'), used here of a future event. Hebrew poetry often speaks of a certain future as if already done, so it means 'my eyes will surely see'. The word anticipates Job 42:5, 'but now my eye has seen you.'
-
וְלֹא־
wəlōʾ · H3808
and not · v27
Negates the short clause that follows. The clause has no verb, so readers must supply one, which is why translations differ.
-
זָ֑ר
zār · H2114A
stranger, outsider, someone else · v27
Either 'and not another person' (Job himself will see, not a stand-in) or 'and not as a stranger' (God will no longer be estranged from Job, or Job will no longer be treated as an outsider). The word picks up vv.13–15, where Job's kin are 'estranged' (zārû) and his servants count him 'a stranger' (zār).
-
כָּל֖וּ
kālû · H3615J
-
כִלְיֹתַ֣י
kilyōtay · H3629
kidneys · v27
'My kidneys.' In Hebrew thought the kidneys were the seat of the deepest emotions and hidden thoughts, roughly what English means by 'heart' or 'gut'. KJV's 'reins' is an old English word for kidneys.
-
בְּחֵקִֽי׃
bəḥēqî · H2436G
bosom, lap, chest · v27
'In my bosom,' meaning deep inside his body. The expression places the longing in the core of his physical self.
-
כִּ֣י
ki · H3588A
for, that, when, if · v28
Opens a condition: 'If (or when) you say…'. The 'then' half comes in verse 29: 'then be afraid of the sword.'
-
תֹ֭אמְרוּ
tomeru · H0559
to say · v28
'You (plural) say', addressed to all three friends. It can mean 'say aloud' or 'say to yourselves, intend'. Job is putting words in their mouths that sum up their attitude.
-
מַה־
mah · H4100
what? how? why? · v28
Can be a question ('Why…?', 'How…?') or an exclamation ('How we will…!'). Most read it as the friends' exclamation of eagerness: 'How we will hound him!'
-
נִּרְדָּף־
nirdof · H7291
to pursue, chase · v28
'We will pursue / let us pursue'. The picture is of hunters or soldiers running down a quarry. It picks up Job's complaint in 19:22: 'Why do you pursue me as God does?'
-
ל֑וֹ
lo · H9033
to him, him · v28
'Him', meaning Job, the target of the chase. Normally this verb takes a direct object. With 'to/after him' the sense may be 'go after him' or 'take up the chase against him'.
-
וְשֹׁ֥רֶשׁ
veshoresh · H8328
root · v28
'And the root of'. Used in a figurative sense: the source or underlying cause. It is a pointed image, because Bildad has just said the wicked man's 'roots dry up below' (18:16).
-
דָּ֝בָ֗ר
davar · H1697I
word, thing, matter, case · v28
'The matter', here in the sense of the affair or the case in dispute. Job uses courtroom language throughout, so 'the root of the case' means the real grounds behind what has happened to him.
-
נִמְצָא־
nimtsa · H4672
to find; (passive) be found · v28
'Is found / has been found'. In Hebrew law this phrasing is used when guilt or wrongdoing is discovered in someone (for example, 'if wickedness is found in him', 1 Kings 1:52).
The world behind it
The go'el in Israelite life. Israel's family system relied on the obligations of kinship. If a man fell into debt and sold his land, sold himself into slavery, was murdered, or died without an heir, his nearest relative, the go'el, was expected to act (Lev 25; Num 35; Ruth 3–4). Proverbs 23:10–11 gives the go'el a legal role: the orphan's go'el "is strong; he will plead their cause against you." Prophets in exile called YHWH Israel's go'el (Isa 41–54), the divine next-of-kin who would buy back a scattered family.
The lawsuit frame of Job. From chapter 9 onward Job uses courtroom language. He wants to take God to court but has no "arbiter" between them (9:33). He claims a "witness in heaven" who will argue for a man with God (16:19–21). In chapter 19 he accuses God of putting him in the wrong and denying him justice (19:6–7). He lists, one by one, the kin and household who should stand by him and have not (19:13–19). He begs his friends for pity (19:21). He wishes his words were permanently inscribed as legal testimony (19:23–24). Verse 25 is the climax of this run: the hope of an advocate who outlives him.
Dust and death. Throughout Job, "dust" (ʿafar) is where the dead go (7:21; 17:16; 21:26). In 14:7–14 Job doubts that a man who dies will rise again. So "over the dust" probably looks beyond Job's death. How far beyond is debated, and the debate depends on the very difficult verse 26.
From the study of Job 19:25.
Where scholars differ
in v25
Who is Job's go'el?
-
God himself: Job appeals from God the accuser to God the defender.
YHWH is regularly called go'el (Isa 41–54; Ps 19:14). Verse 26 goes straight on to "I shall see God," and verse 27 says Job's heart longs for it. In the end God does vindicate Job (42:7). Many Jewish and Christian interpreters and commentators such as Hartley and Andersen take this view. Christian tradition reads it further as a pointer to Christ.
-
A heavenly third party who pleads Job's case before God.
Job has already longed for an "arbiter" between himself and God (9:33) and claimed a "witness in heaven" who argues for a man with God (16:19–21). It would be odd for God to defend Job against God. Mesopotamian texts know a personal intercessor god. Scholars such as Pope and Habel favour some form of this view.
-
Job's own testimony or cry, pictured as a living advocate.
The verse follows directly on Job's wish for his words to be recorded forever (19:23–24). Some take the "witness" of 16:19 as Job's own cry (compare 16:18, "let my cry find no resting place"). Clines is the best-known proponent of this view for the witness of 16:19.
in v25
Does Job expect vindication before death, after death, or through resurrection?
-
After death, possibly involving Job's restored body: a hope beyond the grave.
"Over the dust" (the grave), "after my skin has been stripped off" (v26), and "from my flesh I shall see God" read as "in my flesh." The LXX and the Vulgate point this way, and this has been the classic Christian reading.
-
After death, but without the body: Job's spirit will witness his vindication.
Mibbesari (v26) can mean "apart from my flesh." In 14:7–14 Job doubts bodily revival, so a vision of God after death without the body fits the book's outlook.
-
Within Job's lifetime: he is sure vindication will come, even at the last moment.
'Acharon can simply mean "at last." The book ends with God appearing to the living Job (42:5, "now my eye sees you"), which may fulfil 19:26–27. The Hebrew of v26 is too uncertain to bear a resurrection doctrine.
in v25
What does 'acharon ("last") mean here?
-
Adverbial: "at last, in the end."
Most modern versions read it this way. The adverbial use is attested (Isa 8:23).
-
Describing the go'el as "the last," one who stands up after Job, or who speaks last in court.
Grammatically it is an adjective agreeing with the subject. In legal disputes the final speaker settles the matter (compare Prov 18:17).
-
A title, "the Last," echoing "the First and the Last."
Isa 44:6 and 48:12 use 'acharon of YHWH. YLT reads "The Living and the Last."
in v26
Does 'from my flesh' (mibbəśārî) mean seeing God while embodied, or without a body?
-
Embodied: 'from within my flesh', with Job seeing God as a physical person.
Min often marks the place a person looks from (Job 36:25). Verse 27 stresses 'my eyes' and 'I myself, not a stranger', which suits bodily sight. The Vulgate, many church fathers and many modern commentators take this view.
-
Disembodied: 'apart from / without my flesh', a seeing after death once the body is gone.
Min also means 'without' (Job 11:15; 21:9). If 26a describes Job's death, a seeing without the body follows naturally. ESV, NRSV and NIV list this in footnotes, and some commentators (e.g., Dhorme, and in part Pope) favour it.
in v26
When does Job expect to see God: before death or after it?
-
Before death: Job expects to be proved right while still alive, even if reduced to skin and bone.
Job has repeatedly denied any return from Sheol (7:9; 14:12). The book's ending fulfils the hope in his lifetime: 'now my eye sees you' (42:5). Some Jewish interpreters and several modern scholars (e.g., Clines, Gordis in his own way) lean here.
-
After death: Job reaches beyond the grave, a seed of hope in resurrection or life after death.
'After my skin is struck off' most naturally implies death. Job has already longed for God to recall him from Sheol (14:13–15). The Septuagint and Vulgate both read restoration or resurrection here, and much Christian tradition follows them.
in v26
Who is the go'el ('redeemer') of verse 25, whose action leads to this seeing?
-
God himself.
In Isaiah 40–55 God is repeatedly Israel's go'el. Verse 26 resolves in seeing God, which suggests the vindicator and God are the same.
-
A heavenly third party, a witness or advocate distinct from God.
Job has already wished for an arbiter (9:33) and a heavenly witness (16:19–21) to plead his case against God. This reading avoids having God be both accused and defender.
in v27
When does Job expect to see God: after death (a resurrection or afterlife hope) or while still alive?
-
After death or in bodily resurrection.
V.26 says 'after my skin has been destroyed' and 'from my flesh I will see God'. The stress on 'my eyes' suggests bodily sight after physical ruin. This is the reading of the Vulgate, much of later Jewish and Christian tradition, and Handel's Messiah.
-
In this life, as vindication before Job dies.
Elsewhere Job denies any return from death (7:9; 14:10–12). 'From my flesh' can mean 'while in my flesh'. 'After my skin is struck off' can describe his disease-ravaged state. The book's own fulfilment comes in 42:5, 'now my eye sees you', while Job is alive.
-
Deliberately open: a desperate leap of hope, not a defined doctrine.
The Hebrew of vv.25–27 is among the most difficult in the Old Testament. The poet may have Job reach beyond what his own theology allows, without spelling out when or how.
in v27
What does 'and not zār' mean?
-
'And not another': Job himself, not a substitute, will see.
Zār means 'another person' in Prov 27:2. This fits the emphatic 'I' and 'my eyes'. It follows the Septuagint and the Vulgate.
-
'Not as a stranger': God will no longer be estranged or hostile, or Job will no longer be an outsider.
In this chapter zār is used of Job's estrangement from his family (vv.13, 15). Job has said God treats him as an enemy (v.11). This fits 'on my side' (lî).
in v27
Who is the 'whom' Job will see: God, or a separate heavenly advocate?
-
God himself is both the redeemer (v.25) and the one seen.
The nearest antecedent is 'God' (ʾĕlôah) in v.26. Elsewhere in the Bible God is often called Israel's gōʾēl (Isa 41:14; Ps 19:14).
-
A third party: a heavenly witness or advocate who argues Job's case before God.
Job has longed for an 'umpire' between himself and God (9:33) and a 'witness in heaven' (16:19). On this view, v.27 still refers to seeing God, but the redeemer of v.25 is distinct from him.
in v28
Does the verse end 'in me' or 'in him'?
-
Read 'in him' (bo). The whole line is the friends' words: 'the root of the trouble is in him.'
Septuagint, Vulgate, Syriac and a number of Hebrew manuscripts. It gives a smooth quotation that fits v. 29's warning. Followed by most modern commentators and translations (ESV, NIV, NRSV, BSB).
-
Keep 'in me' (bi) as the standard Hebrew text has it.
It is the harder reading, which copyists were less likely to create. Job may stop quoting partway ('…and the root is found in me', you claim), or he may cite the charge from his own viewpoint. Followed by KJV, YLT and WEB.
in v28
Is the friends' line a question or an exclamation?
-
An exclamation of eagerness: 'How we will hound him!'
The Hebrew word mah can introduce exclamations, and this reading fits v. 22's picture of the friends as relentless pursuers. Adopted by ESV, NIV and WEB.
-
A question: 'Why do we pursue him?' or 'How shall we pursue him?'
Mah is most often interrogative. KJV and YLT read it this way, though KJV then makes it what the friends ought to say.
in v28
What does 'the root of the matter' mean?
-
The cause or grounds of the case: Job's suffering springs from his own guilt.
Davar is often 'case' in legal texts, and 'be found in' is used for discovered guilt. Bildad's root imagery in 18:16 and the courtroom framing of the whole book support it. This is the majority view among modern commentators.
-
Job's claim that the true substance of godliness is in him.
This reading depends on KJV 'in me' and was common in older Protestant commentary. It has little support from how shoresh and davar are used elsewhere, and it ignores the conditional link to v. 29.
Sources
- BDB s.v. גָּאַל, אַחֲרוֹן, עָפָר, קוּם
- HALOT s.v. גאל I, אַחֲרוֹן, עָפָר, קום
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary 17)
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible 15)
- J. E. Hartley, The Book of Job (NICOT)
- F. I. Andersen, Job (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
- R. Gordis, The Book of Job: Commentary, New Translation and Special Studies
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 19:25–26
- Vulgate Job 19:25
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Job 19
- BDB s.v. נָקַף I, II
- HALOT s.v. נקף II; s.v. מִן
- BDB s.v. חָזָה
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- N. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
- M. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
- E. Dhorme, A Commentary on the Book of Job
- Septuagint, Job 19:25–26; 42:17a
- Vulgate, Job 19:26
- Book of Common Prayer, Order for the Burial of the Dead
- BDB s.v. חָזָה, זוּר, כָּלָה, כִּלְיָה, חֵיק
- HALOT s.v. זָר, כִּלְיָה, כָּלָה
- STEPBible / TAHOT tagged Hebrew text (supplied data)
- Septuagint, Job 19:26–27 (Old Greek)
- Vulgate, Iob 19:26–27
- Standard critical commentaries on Job (e.g. Clines, Word Biblical Commentary; Habel, Old Testament Library; Pope, Anchor Bible) for the main interpretive options
- BDB s.v. רָדַף, שֹׁרֶשׁ, דָּבָר, מָצָא
- HALOT s.v. רדף, שֹׁרֶשׁ, דָּבָר
- S. R. Driver & G. B. Gray, Job (International Critical Commentary)
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus at Job 19:28
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Job 19:28
- Vulgate, Job 19:28
- Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible, Job 19 (for the older devotional reading)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.