Job Chapter 34 Read as one passage

Job 34:18–19

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

18who says to kings, ‘You are worthless!’ and to nobles, ‘You are wicked,’ 19who is not partial to princes and does not favor rich over poor? For they are all the work of His hands.

What the first hearers heard

To its first hearers, the verse is an argument by comparison drawn from everyday political life. Everyone knew you do not call a king a scoundrel to his face, or tell nobles they are guilty. Social order and personal safety both depended on respect for rank. Elihu uses that shared instinct against Job. Job has been demanding a trial in which God would be shown to be in the wrong. Elihu answers that you would never pronounce that verdict on a mere human ruler, so it is absurd and dangerous to pronounce it on God, who rules the rulers.

If the verse is read as describing God ("who says to kings…"), it moves the same way from another angle. God is the one judge who can call kings scoundrels, because he does not flatter princes or favour the rich over the poor (v.19). For an audience used to justice that bent toward the powerful, this pictured a judge who cannot be bribed and is not impressed by rank. That is the kind of God Job says he wants. Elihu argues that he already exists, so Job should not condemn him.

From the study of Job 34:18.

Verse by verse

  1. 18who says to kings, ‘You are worthless!’ and to nobles, ‘You are wicked,’

    Elihu has just asked Job, "Could someone who hates justice govern? Will you declare the righteous, mighty One guilty?" (v.17). Now he presses the point:

    "Would anyone say to a king, 'Scoundrel!' or to noblemen, 'Guilty!'?"

    The two insults are about as harsh as Hebrew has. Beliyya'al is not "useless" in the mild modern sense. It is the word for a base, lawless menace to society, the word Shimei hurled at David (2 Sam 16:7). Rasha' is the courtroom verdict "guilty, in the wrong", the same root as "declare guilty" in v.17. The targets are the king and the nedivim, nobles whose very title means "the generous, the willing-hearted". Calling such people "guilty" is a slap in the face. The logic runs from the lesser to the greater. No one in his right mind passes that verdict on a human ruler to his face. How then can Job pass it on the Ruler of the whole earth?

    Many translations read the same Hebrew letters with different vowels and take the verse as a description of God, continuing from v.17: "the One who says to a king, 'Scoundrel!' and to nobles, 'Guilty!'", the One who "shows no favour to princes" (v.19). On this reading the point is God's complete independence. Kings answer to him, and he can pronounce the harshest verdict on the mightiest of them without fear or favour, because "they are all the work of his hands".

    Both readings serve the same argument. God's justice is above all human rank, so Job has no standing to declare him in the wrong.

    Full study →
  2. 19who is not partial to princes and does not favor rich over poor? For they are all the work of His hands.

    Elihu is describing God as judge (v.17 calls him the "righteous, mighty one"). God is the one who has never lifted up the face of a prince. The picture is a great man bowing before a ruler with a request, waiting for the ruler to raise his face as a sign that he will grant it. God does not do this for the powerful; he never bends a verdict to please the well-placed. Nor does he "recognize" the nobleman ahead of the poor man. "Recognize" here is courtroom language for the judge who notices who is important and rules accordingly. The two people set side by side are the šôaʿ, the eminent, well-off man of standing, and the dal, the thin, weak, low man with no influence. God does not rank one above the other. The reason comes in the last line, which carries the weight: "for the work of his two hands are they all." Prince and pauper alike are things God shaped, as a potter shapes clay. A maker has nothing to gain from flattering one of his own works and no reason to despise another. So, Elihu argues, the charge that God is unjust is impossible. A judge who cannot be impressed, bribed or intimidated, and who made everyone in the court, cannot be the one who perverts justice.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v18

    worthless

    beliyya'al

    What we hear
    Useless, of no value, good-for-nothing in a mild or practical sense. Some readers also hear the demon name "Belial".
    What they heard
    A harsh moral insult: scoundrel, base and lawless person, someone who wrecks the community. In Job it is an ordinary noun, not a demon's name.
  • in v18

    wicked

    rasha'

    What we hear
    Evil in character, villainous, the way a story villain is wicked.
    What they heard
    Guilty, in the wrong, the losing party in a judgment, as well as wicked in character. Here it answers v.17's "will you declare guilty?"
  • in v19

    accepteth not the persons of / doesn't respect the persons of (KJV, WEB)

    lōʾ nāśāʾ pənê

    What we hear
    God doesn't accept people, or doesn't hold people in esteem.
    What they heard
    He does not 'lift the face' of the powerful. He does not grant them favour or a better verdict because of their rank. The point is impartial judgment, not disrespect for people.
  • in v19

    the rich

    šôaʿ

    What we hear
    Someone with a lot of money.
    What they heard
    A notable, a man of standing and independence, with wealth as part of his social weight. In Isa 32:5 it sits alongside 'noble'.
Every word
  1. הַאֲמֹ֣ר

    ha'amor · H0559

    to say · v18

    The question marker ha- joined to the bare infinitive "to say": "Is it [fit] to say…?" or "Does one say…?" The answer expected is no. If the vowels are read differently it becomes "the one who says", describing God (see textual notes).

  2. לְמֶ֣לֶךְ

    lemelekh · H4428

    to a king · v18

    Singular and without "the": any king, the highest human authority there is. In the ancient world a king was the guarantor of justice, and insulting one could be treated as a crime.

  3. בְּלִיָּ֑עַל

    beliyya'al · H1100

    worthlessness, scoundrel · v18

    Used here as a one-word insult shouted at a king: "Scoundrel!" "Good-for-nothing!" In Hebrew it is a harsh word for someone who is morally base and tears down the social order. It is much stronger than English "useless".

  4. רָ֝שָׁ֗ע

    rasha' · H7563

    wicked, guilty · v18

    The second insult, parallel to the first. It is a courtroom word, the opposite of tsaddiq ("in the right"): the person a court finds guilty. It echoes v.17's tarshia', "will you declare guilty?", the same root.

  5. אֶל־

    'el · H0413

    to, toward · v18

    "To". It marks who is being addressed and parallels the le- ("to") on "king".

  6. נְדִיבִֽים׃

    nedivim · H5081

    nobles, princes · v18

    Aristocrats, the ruling nobility, paired with "king". The root means "willing, generous", so the word carries the ideal that a noble is open-handed. That makes calling one rasha' ("guilty") especially pointed.

  7. אֲשֶׁ֤ר

    ʾăšer · H0834A

    who, which · v19

    Starts a clause that describes someone already named. It most naturally points back to God, the 'righteous and mighty one' of v.17, and goes on to say what kind of judge he is.

  8. לֹֽא־

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v19

    Flat negation: this is something God never does.

  9. נָשָׂ֨א׀

    nāśāʾ · H5375Q

    to lift, carry · v19

    The first half of the idiom 'lift the face', meaning show favour. The perfect tense describes his settled character: he has never done this and does not do it.

  10. פְּנֵ֥י

    pənê · H6440N

    face(s); person, presence · v19

    'The faces of' princes. Together with the verb it means 'show partiality to'. The face stands for the person and the status they show.

  11. שָׂרִ֗ים

    śārîm · H8269

    prince, official, commander · v19

    The ruling class: royal officials, chiefs, commanders. They pick up the 'kings' and 'nobles' of v.18.

  12. נִכַּר־

    nikkar · H5234A

    to recognize, regard, take notice of · v19

    An intensive form of the verb meaning 'give recognition to, single out'. With 'before' it means preferring one party to another, as a biased judge 'recognizes' the important man in court.

  13. שׁ֭וֹעַ

    šôaʿ · H7771A

    noble, eminent, well-off · v19

    A rare word for a man of standing, wealthy and independent. It is about status and means, not only cash. It is the 'big man' set against the 'little man' (dal).

  14. דָ֑ל

    dāl · H1800

    poor, weak, low, thin · v19

    Someone without resources or social weight. The word covers being thin, weak and helpless, not just short of money.

  15. כִּֽי־

    kî · H3588A

    for, because · v19

    Gives the reason God shows no favouritism: what follows is the ground of his impartiality.

  16. מַעֲשֵׂ֖ה

    maʿăśēh · H4639G

    work, deed, thing made · v19

    A crafted product. Both kinds of people are things God has made, not clients he answers to.

  17. יָדָ֣יו

    yādāyw · H3027G

    his hands · v19

    The dual form, meaning a pair: 'his two hands'. It is the image of a craftsman or potter shaping each person directly.

  18. כֻּלָּֽם׃

    kullām · H3605

    all of them · v19

    Prince and poor man, noble and nobody, all together. Placed last for emphasis, it erases the ranking the first half refused to honour.

The world behind it

Elihu's speech. Job 32–37 belongs to Elihu, a younger man who speaks after Job's three friends have fallen silent. In chapter 34 he quotes Job's complaint, "I am in the right, and God has taken away my justice" (34:5–6), and sets out to show that God cannot pervert justice (34:10–12).

Speaking against rulers. In the ancient Near East and in Israel, the king was the protector of justice, and insulting him was dangerous and could be treated as a crime. Israel's law said, "You shall not curse a ruler of your people" (Exod 22:28). Ecclesiastes warns, "Do not curse the king even in your thoughts" (Eccl 10:20). Shimei's cry of "man of beliyya'al!" at David (2 Sam 16:7) was remembered as a capital offence (1 Kgs 2:8–9, 44–46). Elihu's audience would feel at once how outrageous it would be to shout "Scoundrel!" at a king.

Echo of Job. Job had said that God "pours contempt on nobles (nedivim)" (12:21). Elihu takes the same class of people and argues that if God treats rulers that way, it shows he is sovereign over them. It does not show that he is unjust.

From the study of Job 34:18.

Where scholars differ

in v18

Who is speaking the insults: a hypothetical human, or God?

  • Human speaker (rhetorical question): no one would call a king "scoundrel", so how much less may Job condemn God.

    The Masoretic vowels (ha'amor, question + infinitive). It fits v.17b's challenge "Will you condemn the righteous mighty One?" as an argument from lesser to greater. Followed by KJV and Jewish tradition.

  • God is the speaker: God is the one who denounces kings and nobles, showing he is impartial and sovereign over them.

    The same consonants revocalised as a participle (ha'omer). The Septuagint and Vulgate have participles. It flows into v.19's "who (asher) does not show favour to princes". Adopted by many commentators (e.g. Dhorme, Pope, Clines) and by BSB, ESV, NASB and NIV.

in v18

What is the origin of beliyya'al?

  • "Without worth" (beli, "without" + ya'al, "profit").

    The most widely accepted explanation (BDB, HALOT). It fits the word's use for useless, destructive people.

  • Connected with the underworld: "[the place of] no coming up", or with a root meaning "to swallow".

    Proposed from passages like Ps 18:4 (= 2 Sam 22:5), "torrents of beliyya'al", alongside death and Sheol. It is less certain and does not change the sense in Job 34:18, where it is plainly a personal insult.

in v19

Does v.18 (and so v.19) describe God rebuking kings, or argue that if one may not insult a king, still less may one accuse God?

  • God is the subject: he is the one who says to kings 'worthless' and who does not favour princes.

    The Septuagint and Vulgate read a participle ('the one who says'). The 'who' at the start of v.19 runs smoothly on from such a description. Verse 20 continues with God bringing down the mighty. Followed by most modern translations.

  • An argument from lesser to greater: is it proper to say 'worthless' to a king? How much less to God, who is impartial?

    Follows the traditional Hebrew vowels (ha'amor, 'is it to say?'). The KJV supplies 'How much less to him' to make the logic explicit. It fits Elihu's charge that Job has spoken rashly against God.

in v19

How far should Elihu's speech be taken as the book's own view?

  • Elihu is a reliable voice who prepares for God's speeches.

    His themes, God's justice and his sovereignty over creation and rulers, lead into chs. 38–41, and God does not rebuke him in 42:7 as he does the three friends. This verse matches Deut 10:17 exactly.

  • Elihu is a self-confident young man repeating the friends' error in better words.

    He still assumes Job's suffering must reflect wrongdoing (34:7–8, 34–37). God ignores him entirely, and the prologue shows the suffering was not punishment. On this view the statement about God is true, but using it against Job is not.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. בְּלִיַּעַל, רָשָׁע, נָדִיב
  • HALOT s.v. בְּלִיַּעַל
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
  • É. Dhorme, A Commentary on the Book of Job
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Job 34:18
  • Vulgate, Job 34:18
  • BDB s.v. נָשָׂא (idiom נָשָׂא פָנִים)
  • HALOT s.v. נכר (Piel)
  • HALOT s.v. שׁוֹעַ
  • BDB s.v. דַּל
  • BDAG s.v. προσωπολημψία (for the later Greek development of the idiom)
  • Code of Hammurabi, prologue and epilogue (protection of the weak)
  • Septuagint and Vulgate of Job 34:18–19
  • STEPBible / OSHB tagged Hebrew text (supplied)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).