Job Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Job 5:11–13
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
11He sets the lowly on high, so that mourners are lifted to safety. 12He thwarts the schemes of the crafty, so that their hands find no success. 13He catches the wise in their craftiness, and sweeps away the plans of the cunning.
What the first hearers heard
To an ancient Israelite hearing the book, this line sounded familiar and true, like a line from the temple hymns: God reverses fortunes, puts the crushed back on their feet and lifts mourners out of the ash heap into safety. Nobody in the book disputes that God can do this.
The tension lies in how Eliphaz uses it. For him the line is a promise with a condition attached, as his speech goes on: blessed is the man God corrects, so do not reject the Almighty's discipline (5:17), seek God, and you will be restored. The listener has read the prologue (chs. 1–2), knows Job's suffering is not punishment, and so hears the irony. Job is one of the "darkened ones" (he uses the same word of himself in 30:28), and he will be raised high (42:10–17). But the lifting comes from God's free decision after Job has protested honestly, not from the confession of guilt Eliphaz prescribes. God's verdict that the friends "have not spoken of me what is right" (42:7) concerns how they applied such truths to Job, not the bare claim that God lifts the lowly.
So the verse did two things for its first audience. It affirmed a cherished belief about God, and it showed how that belief can be turned against a sufferer when used as a formula.
From the study of Job 5:11.
Verse by verse
-
11He sets the lowly on high, so that mourners are lifted to safety.
Full study →Eliphaz is in the middle of a hymn about God (vv. 9–16), listing what God does: he works wonders past counting, he sends rain on the land, and, so as to (or simply and he does it to) put the people who have been pushed down up on the height. The "low" are those crushed in status and fortune, the poor and the shamed. Their character is not the point. The second line puts a picture in front of the listener: the "darkened ones", mourners grimy with ash, in dark sackcloth, faces gloomy with grief, are raised high into rescue. They are lifted, as though into a hilltop stronghold, out of reach of whatever was crushing them, and settled in safety and wellbeing. The verb is stated as an accomplished fact, because this is how God reliably acts. If the infinitive connects back to v. 10, the thought may also be that God's rain revives the fields and so lifts up the humble farmer and the grieving household.
Within the book, the line works as dramatic irony, meaning the audience knows more than the speaker. Job is sitting in the ashes (2:8), as low and darkened as a person can be. Eliphaz's words about God are true, and the book's ending bears them out (42:10). But he offers them as a lesson: confess your sin, and God will lift you. God later says the friends did not speak rightly about him (42:7).
-
12He thwarts the schemes of the crafty, so that their hands find no success.
Full study →God is the one who cancels what clever people plot. Their carefully worked-out schemes are made void, as a vow can be cancelled or a treaty broken. The result is that their hands never bring anything solid out of it. Nothing they reach for turns into real, effective achievement.
The verse moves from mind to hands. The plans are made in the head, and the hands are meant to make them real. God breaks the link, so the plotting never becomes a result. The last word, tûšiyyâ, carries an irony: it means both sound practical wisdom and the success such wisdom produces. The shrewd are clever, but they never arrive at the thing that actually works. In Hebrew, "the shrewd" (ʿărûmîm) is the same word Proverbs uses in praise of the "prudent". Here it is skill at outmanoeuvring others, and the line says this kind of cleverness cannot outmanoeuvre God.
In the Hebrew the verse opens with a participle, "the One who breaks…". This works like a title in a hymn of praise and continues the list of God's actions in verses 9–13. The verbs describe what God habitually does, not a single event.
-
13He catches the wise in their craftiness, and sweeps away the plans of the cunning.
Full study →God is the one who keeps catching clever people in their own cleverness: he snares them in the very act of being shrewd, as a hunter takes prey in its own trap. And the carefully worked-out plans of the twisted are rushed to a sudden end; they collapse before they ever mature.
The verse is one line in a short hymn (Job 5:9–16) in which Eliphaz praises God for reversing human fortunes. The first word is a participle, 'catching'. It describes what God habitually does rather than a single event. The 'wise' are not the godly wise. They are clever operators, and the next words define them: they act 'craftily', and they are 'twisted', with dealings bent like a twisted cord. The irony is deliberate. Their skill is the snare, and the Hebrew 'in their being crafty' means both by means of their cunning and at the very moment they use it. In the second half, a scheme (literally 'counsel', a plan worked out with care) 'is hurried'. Plotting needs patience and time, and God takes both away, so the plan is pushed forward too soon and falls apart. The next verse (5:14) finishes the picture: these experts end up groping at noon as if it were night.
Where the English drifted
-
in v11
the lowly
šəpālîm
- What we hear
- Humble, modest people, a virtue God rewards.
- What they heard
- People brought low in standing and fortune: the poor, the shamed, the ruined. Their position is in view, not their character.
-
in v12
disappointeth (KJV)
mēfēr (pārar, Hiphil)
- What we hear
- Makes the crafty feel let down or sad.
- What they heard
- Breaks, cancels, makes void. God actively defeats their plans so they never take effect.
-
in v12
enterprise (KJV, WEB)
tûšiyyâ
- What we hear
- A business venture or company.
- What they heard
- Sound, effective wisdom and the real success it produces. The hands achieve nothing substantial.
-
in v12
wisdom (YLT)
tûšiyyâ
- What we hear
- Intellectual insight or knowledge.
- What they heard
- Practical competence that gets results: what works and holds up, together with its successful outcome.
-
in v13
the wise
ḥăkhāmîm
- What we hear
- People of real wisdom, good judgment and virtue, or educated and thoughtful people generally, so that God seems to oppose wisdom or learning as such.
- What they heard
- Clever, skilled operators. The surrounding words ('crafty', 'twisted') show that this is self-serving shrewdness, not the God-fearing wisdom of Proverbs.
-
in v13
the froward (KJV)
niptālîm
- What we hear
- An unfamiliar word, often misheard as 'forward', meaning bold or pushy.
- What they heard
- 'Twisted ones': devious, crooked people whose dealings are bent.
Every word
-
לָשׂ֣וּם
lāśûm · H7760A
-
שְׁפָלִ֣ים
šəpālîm · H8217
low, lowly · v11
People who are literally "low": pushed down in standing, poor, without power. The word is about where they stand in society and in life, not mainly about a humble character.
-
לְמָר֑וֹם
ləmārôm · H4791
height, high place · v11
"To the height": a raised, honoured, out-of-reach place. Elsewhere the same word names God's own high dwelling, so the low are lifted toward the place where God himself is.
-
וְ֝קֹדְרִ֗ים
wəqōdərîm · H6937
be dark, be dirty; go about mourning · v11
Literally "the darkened ones": mourners, named after how they looked, unwashed, dressed in dark sackcloth, ash on the face, gloomy. The picture is of grief you can see.
-
שָׂ֣גְבוּ
śāgəbû · H7682
be high, be inaccessibly high, be secure · v11
"They are raised high" in the sense of being lifted out of reach, like people inside a hilltop fortress. The completed verb form presents their rescue as settled and reliable, the way God always acts.
-
יֶֽשַׁע׃
yešaʿ · H3468
deliverance, rescue, safety · v11
Describes the state they are lifted into: "in safety" or "into rescue". It means being concretely rescued from danger and trouble, with room to live. It is not the later idea of the soul's salvation.
-
מֵפֵר
mēfēr · H6565A
to break, annul, frustrate · v12
A participle (a verb used like a title: "the one who breaks"), describing God's ongoing way of acting. The verb is used for breaking a covenant or cancelling a vow; here God makes the schemers' plans void, so they never take effect.
-
מַחְשְׁבוֹת
maḥšəvôt · H4284
thought, plan, plot, design · v12
"The plans of". Deliberate plans worked out in the mind, here schemes against others. The same word can mean a craftsman's design, but in this context it means calculated plotting.
-
עֲרוּמִים
ʿărûmîm · H6175
shrewd, prudent, crafty · v12
"Shrewd ones": people clever at getting what they want. In Proverbs the word is a virtue ("prudent"), but here it means cleverness used to scheme. It is the same word used for the serpent in Genesis 3:1.
-
וְלֹא־
wəlōʾ · H3808
and not · v12
Joins the result to the first clause: because God breaks their plans, their hands do not get anywhere.
-
תַעֲשֶׂינָה
taʿăśênâ · H6213A
do, make, accomplish · v12
"They will (not) do/achieve". The grammatical subject is "their hands". The form describes what typically happens: their hands never carry the plan through.
-
יְדֵיהֶם
yədêhem · H3027G
hand(s) · v12
"Their hands". In Hebrew the hand stands for a person's ability to act. The plotting happens in the mind (the plans); the hands are where it would become real, and that is where it fails.
-
תּוּשִׁיָּה
tûšiyyâ · H8454
sound wisdom, success, effective achievement · v12
The object of "do": their hands do not produce anything solid or effective. The word joins practical wisdom with the success that wisdom brings. It is the thing that actually works, and the schemers never reach it.
-
לֹכֵ֣ד
lōkhēd · H3920
to capture, catch, trap · v13
An active participle ('the one who catches'), describing God's ongoing habit rather than a single event. It is the word for snaring an animal or taking a city: the clever are caught like prey.
-
חֲכָמִ֣ים
ḥăkhāmîm · H2450
wise, skilled, clever · v13
'Wise ones' in the sense of clever, capable operators. Paired with 'crafty' and 'twisted', the word is used here with irony for people whose skill serves their own schemes, not for the godly wise.
-
בְּעָרְמָ֑ם
bəʿormām · H6191
to be shrewd, crafty · v13
Literally 'in their being shrewd'. The word 'in' (bə-) can mean both 'by means of' and 'in the very act of': God catches them with their own cunning, while they are using it.
-
וַעֲצַ֖ת
waʿăṣat · H6098
counsel, advice, plan · v13
'And the plan of'. ʿēṣāh is a considered strategy or piece of advice, the thing a counsellor works out. Here it is a scheme that has been carefully thought through.
-
נִפְתָּלִ֣ים
niptālîm · H6617
twisted, crooked, tortuous · v13
'Twisted ones': people whose dealings are bent and devious, like a cord twisted on itself. It answers 'wise' in the first half and shows what kind of 'wisdom' is meant.
-
נִמְהָֽרָה׃
nimhārāh · H4116A
to hasten; (passive) be hurried, be rash · v13
'Is hurried' (its subject is the feminine noun 'counsel'). The scheme is rushed forward before it is ready and comes to a sudden, premature end. The word also carries a hint that such plans are rash.
The world behind it
Who is speaking. This is the first speech of Eliphaz the Temanite (chs. 4–5), the first of Job's three friends to answer him. In 5:8 he says, "As for me, I would seek God," and then he moves into a hymn. Its lines are built on descriptions of what God does ("who does great things," v. 9; "who gives rain," v. 10), the style of Israel's praise psalms. Verse 11 continues that list.
The reversal theme. Raising the low and bringing down the proud is a set theme of ancient Israelite praise (1 Sam 2:7–8; Ps 113:7–8; 147:6; Ezek 17:24), and similar praise of high gods who raise up the weak appears in older Mesopotamian hymns. Eliphaz uses it to support the friends' belief in strict moral cause and effect: God's world is ordered, so suffering can be reversed by turning back to God (5:17–27).
Mourning dress. In Israel and its neighbours, grief was something you could see. Mourners tore their clothes, put on dark goat-hair sackcloth, sprinkled ash or dust on their heads, sat on the ground and did not wash or anoint themselves (2 Sam 12:20; 14:2; Job 2:8, 12–13). That is why the Hebrew can call mourners simply "the darkened ones."
Height as safety. In hill-country Israel, safety meant height: walled towns and refuges on hilltops where enemies could not reach. Hebrew poetry uses that picture for God's protection (misgāb, "high refuge").
From the study of Job 5:11.
Where scholars differ
in v11
Is v. 11 a purpose clause depending on the rain in v. 10, or simply the next item in the list of God's deeds?
-
Purpose or result: God sends rain so as to lift up the lowly, since rain restores the poor farmer and the grieving household.
Lamed + infinitive often expresses purpose. Rain as the basis of prosperity is a natural link in a farming society. Several translations (NASB, WEB, BSB's "so that") lean this way.
-
Continuation: "[who] sets the low on high", a third act of God alongside wonders and rain.
Hebrew poetry often continues descriptive phrases with lamed + infinitive. Vv. 12–16 move to new acts such as thwarting the crafty and saving the needy, which suggests a list. The LXX and Vulgate translate it as a parallel description.
in v11
How far does the book endorse what Eliphaz says here?
-
The statement is true. Only its application to Job is faulty.
The line matches standard Israelite praise (1 Sam 2; Ps 113), and the epilogue literally carries it out for Job (42:10–17).
-
The whole speech, true-sounding lines included, belongs to a theology the book rejects.
God says the friends did not speak rightly about him (42:7). Eliphaz's hymn serves a retribution scheme, the idea that suffering signals sin and repentance brings restoration, which the prologue has already shown to be false in Job's case.
in v12
How much weight should Eliphaz's words carry, given that God says the friends did not speak rightly (42:7)?
-
The hymn is sound teaching, misapplied to Job.
Its content matches mainstream wisdom and psalm teaching (Ps 33:10; Prov 19:21; 21:30). Paul cites 5:13 as Scripture with the formula "it is written" (1 Cor 3:19). On this view, the friends' error lies in applying the pattern to Job, not in the statements themselves.
-
The hymn is part of a framework the book deliberately questions, so it should not be lifted out as a standalone proof-text.
In 42:7 God judges the friends' speech as a whole. Eliphaz uses the hymn to argue that Job must have sinned (4:7–8; 5:8, 17). The book's poetry repeatedly shows the neat pattern of retribution failing to explain innocent suffering.
in v12
What does tûšiyyâ basically mean?
-
Substantial or effective wisdom, linked to yēš ("being, substance").
This fits uses like Prov 8:14 and Job 12:16, where tûšiyyâ is paired with counsel and strength, and Job 6:13, where it means resources or ability to cope.
-
Mainly success or effective result.
In contexts like Job 5:12, where the hands "do" tûšiyyâ, it reads naturally as achieved success. Many modern translations take it this way. The origin of the word is uncertain, so the meaning is worked out mostly from context.
in v13
How can a line from Eliphaz, whom God later says did not speak rightly (Job 42:7), be quoted as authoritative scripture (1 Cor 3:19)?
-
Eliphaz's general statements about God are largely true. His error lies in applying them to Job, as if Job's suffering proved hidden sin. Paul cites the general truth, not the misapplication.
The saying matches widely attested wisdom elsewhere (Ps 7:15–16; 33:10; Isa 29:14; 44:25). Paul pairs it with Psalm 94:11 to make a general point about worldly wisdom, not about suffering. Job 42:7 condemns what the friends said about Job's case, not every sentence they spoke.
-
The book of Job deliberately puts traditional maxims under strain, so even true-sounding lines from the friends are meant to be weighed critically. Paul's citation shows that the maxim had an independent life as accepted wisdom, and he introduces it with 'it is written' because it stands in the scriptural book.
The book's structure presents the friends' speeches as a foil to Job and to God's speeches. Paul's Greek wording differs from the Septuagint, which may show a saying known and quoted in its own right. 'It is written' (gegraptai) marks the source as scripture without endorsing every use of it within Job.
in v13
What exactly does nimhārāh ('is hurried') say happens to the scheme?
-
The plan is brought to a sudden, premature end: it is rushed to ruin before it can succeed.
This fits the parallel with verse 12 ('their hands achieve no success') and the KJV/ESV-type renderings ('carried headlong', 'brought to a quick end').
-
The plotters are pushed into rashness: their counsel becomes hasty and ill-considered, and that leads to their downfall.
Elsewhere the niphal of māhar describes people as 'rash' or 'hasty' (Isa 32:4; Hab 1:6), and verse 14 pictures the schemers groping in confusion, which suits a loss of judgment.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. שָׁפָל, קָדַר, שָׂגַב, יֵשַׁע, מָרוֹם
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (WBC 17)
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (OTL)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs; Ziegler Göttingen edition) Job 5:11
- Vulgate Job 5:11
- Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew (lamed + infinitive continuing participles; adverbial accusative)
- BDB s.v. פָּרַר, עָרוּם, תּוּשִׁיָּה, מַחֲשָׁבָה
- HALOT s.v. תּוּשִׁיָּה
- STEP Bible / TAHOT morphological data (supplied)
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 5:12–13; 1 Corinthians 3:19
- HALOT s.v. לכד, חָכָם, ערם, פתל, מהר
- BDB s.v. עָרַם, פָּתַל, מָהַר
- Septuagint, Job 5:13 (Rahlfs/Göttingen)
- 1 Corinthians 3:19 (NA28)
- Vulgate, Iob 5:13
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Job 4–5
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).