Joshua Chapter 17 Read as one passage
Joshua 17:12–13
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
12But the descendants of Manasseh were unable to occupy these cities, because the Canaanites were determined to stay in this land. 13However, when the Israelites grew stronger, they put the Canaanites to forced labor; but they failed to drive them out completely.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers, this verse explained something they could see for themselves. The great valley cities, with their well-known names, had stayed in Canaanite hands for generations, even though they lay inside Manasseh's allotted borders. It made three points:
- Promise given, but not complete. The land is shared out by God's command (Josh 17:1–11), and yet allotment is not the same as actual control. The book's broad summaries ('Joshua took the whole land', 11:23; 21:43–45) sit next to sober notes like this one (13:13; 15:63; 16:10; 17:12–13). Hearers were meant to hold both together.
- A will on the other side. The Canaanites are not passive. They 'resolved' to stay. The land was contested, and the hearers knew the resistance was real: walls, chariots and long-established ruling houses.
- A warning. Read alongside v. 13 and Joshua's farewell (23:12–13: the remaining nations will be 'a snare and a trap… thorns in your eyes'), the verse prepares for Judges 1–2. There the failure to dispossess becomes the root of Israel's later entanglement with Canaanite religion. Even Manasseh, a tribe of honoured Joseph, could not, and then did not, finish the task.
The very next scene (17:14–18) has the Joseph tribes complaining that their land is too small. Joshua answers by telling them to clear the forested hills and to take on the chariot-armed valleys anyway. So this verse also sets up a story about whether these tribes would act on the strength they were told they had.
From the study of Joshua 17:12.
Verse by verse
-
12But the descendants of Manasseh were unable to occupy these cities, because the Canaanites were determined to stay in this land.
Full study →"But the sons of Manasseh were not able to dispossess these cities: to break the hold of the people living in them and take them over. And the Canaanite made up his mind to stay put, to go on living in this very land."
Verse 11 has just given Manasseh six famous cities on paper: Beth-shean, Ibleam, Dor, Endor, Taanach and Megiddo. Verse 12 tells how things stood on the ground. The verb used for Manasseh's task is the conquest's key word: not simply 'move in' but dispossess, meaning end one people's ownership so that another's can begin. The tribe lacked the strength for it. The verse then gives the other side. The Canaanite population, spoken of as a single 'he', resolved or set himself to remain. Two wills meet. The weaker one is Israel's, and the stronger is the native population's, determined to keep living in 'this land', the same land promised to Israel. The next verse makes it sharper. When Israel did grow strong, it put these people to forced labour instead of dispossessing them. So 'could not' slides into 'did not'.
-
13However, when the Israelites grew stronger, they put the Canaanites to forced labor; but they failed to drive them out completely.
Full study →"Later, when the Israelites had grown strong enough to prevail, they did not remove the Canaanites. They turned them into a forced-labor workforce. As for dispossessing them and taking the land as their inheritance, that they did not do."
Read this right after verse 12. There, Manasseh could not take the fortified cities of the Jezreel Valley and the coast (Beth-shean, Ibleam, Dor, En-dor, Taanach, Megiddo), because the Canaanites were determined to stay. Verse 13 moves the story forward in time: Israel did become strong. The word is ḥazaq, the same root as God's repeated charge to Joshua to "be strong and courageous," and the same word Joshua will use of the Canaanite in v. 18 ("though he is strong, you shall drive him out"). So the problem is no longer weakness. With power in hand, Israel chose to keep the Canaanites and use them as a mas. That is a corvée: a subject population owing unpaid labor in fields and on building projects. It was a familiar and profitable arrangement in the region. A king of Megiddo itself boasted of supplying such gangs centuries earlier.
The last clause repeats the key verb for emphasis: literally, "and dispossessing, he did not dispossess him." Here Israel is treated as one man and "the Canaanite" as another. The verb horish means more than shoving people off a field. It means turning a land held by others into one's own inheritance. The sentence ends on the failure, and it is the failure the narrator wants heard. English "did not drive them out completely" can sound as if Israel nearly finished the job. The Hebrew stresses the non-dispossession itself, and in these cities the Canaanites were evidently still there, working for Israel.
Where the English drifted
-
in v12
the Canaanites would dwell (KJV, WEB)
wayyôʾel hakkənaʿănî lāšeḇet
- What we hear
- Sounds like a conditional ('would dwell if…') or a habit ('used to live there'), or simply 'went on living there'.
- What they heard
- 'The Canaanite resolved / set himself to dwell.' It is a deliberate decision and a stubborn refusal to leave. The old English 'would' meant 'willed, insisted on'.
-
in v12
the Canaanites
hakkənaʿănî
- What we hear
- One distinct ethnic nation with its own clear identity.
- What they heard
- A collective singular for the established native population, here especially the walled city-states of the plains and coast with their chariot forces and Egyptian connections.
-
in v13
put the Canaanites to tribute (KJV, YLT)
natan lamas
- What we hear
- Made the Canaanites pay a tax or a regular payment of money or goods.
- What they heard
- Made them a corvée: a subject population forced to give unpaid labor gangs for fields and building projects.
-
in v13
did not drive them out completely / utterly
vehoresh lo horisho
- What we hear
- Israel drove out most of the Canaanites but left a few.
- What they heard
- An emphatic doubled verb: "as for dispossessing, they did not dispossess them." In these cities the Canaanites stayed on as laborers. The emphasis falls on the non-dispossession itself, not on a small remainder.
Every word
-
וְלֹ֤א
wəlōʾ · H3808
and not · v12, v13
The plain Hebrew negative, with 'and' attached. After the list of cities in v. 11, the 'and' works as 'but' or 'yet': the tribe got them on paper, but not on the ground.
-
יָכְלוּ֙
yāḵəlû · H3201
be able, prevail · v12
'They were able', a completed action. With the negative it states a real lack of ability, not just a lack of will. The same verb can mean 'prevail over' an enemy, so 'not able' here also suggests 'did not get the upper hand'.
-
בְּנֵ֣י
bənê · H1121G
sons, descendants · v12, v13
'Sons of', the usual way of naming a tribe as one family descended from its ancestor. The whole tribe as a kin group is in view, not only its fighting men.
-
מְנַשֶּׁ֔ה
mənaššeh · H4519G
Manasseh · v12
The tribe of Joseph's firstborn son. Here it means the western half-tribe, whose land reached north into the Jezreel Valley and the coastal plain.
-
לְהוֹרִ֖ישׁ
ləhôrîš · H3423H
dispossess, drive out · v12, v13
In this causative form the verb means 'to make someone lose possession': to drive out the people living there so the land passes to you. It is the key word of the conquest stories, and it comes back twice in v. 13.
-
אֶת־
ʾet- · H0853
[object marker] · v12, v13
An untranslated word that marks the direct object. It points to 'the cities' as what Manasseh failed to dispossess.
-
הֶֽעָרִ֣ים
heʿārîm · H5892B
the cities · v12
A walled, permanent settlement, the opposite of open villages. Saying 'dispossess the cities' means their populations, and KJV adds '[the inhabitants of]' to make that clear. These were some of the strongest fortified towns in Canaan.
-
הָאֵ֑לֶּה
hāʾēlleh · H0428
these · v12
Points back to the six cities just named in v. 11: Beth-shean, Ibleam, Dor, Endor, Taanach and Megiddo.
-
וַיּ֙וֹאֶל֙
wayyôʾel · H2974
resolve, undertake, be determined, be content · v12
'He set himself to', 'he made up his mind to'. The subject is the Canaanite population taken as one. The word shows a will at work on the Canaanite side, which explains the failure in the first half of the verse.
-
הַֽכְּנַעֲנִ֔י
hakkənaʿănî · H3669A
the Canaanite · v12, v13
Singular in form ('the Canaanite') but meaning the whole native population. In Joshua it is a broad name for the long-settled people of the land, especially the city-dwellers of the plains and coast.
-
לָשֶׁ֖בֶת
lāšeḇet · H3427
to dwell, sit, remain · v12
'To dwell, to stay settled'. The root picture is sitting down and staying put. The Canaanites set themselves to remain exactly where they were.
-
בָּאָ֥רֶץ
bāʾāreṣ · H0776G
land, country · v12
'In the land', meaning the territory itself. In Joshua it is never just ground: it is the land promised to the ancestors and now being shared out.
-
הַזֹּֽאת׃
hazzōʾt · H2063
this · v12
'This land'. The phrase is weighty: the very land Israel was being given is the land the Canaanites resolved to keep living in.
-
וַֽיְהִ֗י
vayhi · H1961
and it was / it came about · v13
This is the standard Hebrew way of opening a new scene in a story ("and it came to pass"). It marks a turn from v. 12, where Manasseh could not take the cities, to a later stage.
-
כִּ֤י
ki · H3588A
when, because, that · v13
Here it means "when" and sets the time: once Israel grew strong. It points to a change in circumstances, not a reason.
-
חָֽזְקוּ֙
ḥazqu · H2388G
be/become strong, prevail · v13
"They became strong" or "gained the upper hand." It is the same root God uses in "Be strong and courageous" (Josh 1:6–9) and that Joshua uses in v. 18 ("though the Canaanite is strong"). So the inability of v. 12 was not permanent. Israel did reach a position of power.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל
yisra'el · H3478
Israel · v13
The tribal people as a whole. Verse 12 named Manasseh, but this verse widens the subject to "Israel", so the notice reads as typical of the whole people, as it does again in Judges 1:28.
-
וַיִּתְּנ֥וּ
vayyittnu · H5414H
give, put, set, make · v13
With the preposition "into/as" (le-), natan means "to make something into something": they turned the Canaanites into a labor force. The verb is plural, picturing the tribes acting together.
-
לָמַ֑ס
lamas · H4522
forced labor, labor gang · v13
"Into the corvée." A corvée is compulsory unpaid labor owed to an overlord: work gangs for fields, building and public projects. It is not a money tax. The Canaanites stayed in the land but were put under obligation.
The world behind it
The cities. The six towns of v. 11 run along the Jezreel Valley (Megiddo, Taanach, Ibleam, Endor), its eastern outlet into the Jordan Valley (Beth-shean), and the Carmel coast (Dor). They were the key points of the main trade and military road through the land. Megiddo and Taanach were old walled Canaanite city-states. Their kings appear in Egyptian records and in the 14th-century BC Amarna letters as vassals of Pharaoh. Beth-shean held an Egyptian garrison and administrative centre well into the 12th century BC, as excavations there show.
Why hill tribes could not take them. The Joseph tribes say it themselves in vv. 16–18: 'all the Canaanites who live in the valley have chariots of iron, both those in Beth-shean… and those in the Valley of Jezreel'. Chariots were the most powerful weapon of the age on flat ground. Walled cities could hold out against forces with no siege equipment. Israel's settlements were mostly in the hills, so the plains stayed out of reach.
How long it lasted. Elsewhere in the Bible these cities stay non-Israelite for a long time. Saul's body is hung on the wall of Beth-shean by the Philistines (1 Sam 31:10). Only under Solomon do Taanach, Megiddo and Beth-shean appear in an Israelite administrative district (1 Kgs 4:12), and Megiddo is rebuilt as a royal city (1 Kgs 9:15). The arrangement in v. 13, Canaanites kept on as forced labourers, matches what Solomon later did (1 Kgs 9:20–21).
Forced labour. The word in v. 13 (mas) means a labour levy: conscripted work gangs for building and farming. Deuteronomy allows this for distant cities that surrender (Deut 20:10–11), but for the peoples of the land itself it commands dispossession (Deut 7:1–2; 20:16–17). That is why v. 13 sounds like a compromise.
From the study of Joshua 17:12.
Where scholars differ
in v12
Was Manasseh's failure a matter of military weakness or of unfaithfulness?
-
Real military inability
The verb 'were not able' states inability plainly. Verses 16–18 give the reason: chariots in Beth-shean and the Jezreel Valley. Archaeology shows Egyptian control at Beth-shean and strong Canaanite cities at Megiddo into the 12th century BC. Judg 1:19 likewise explains Judah's failure by the plain-dwellers' iron chariots.
-
Inability that became unwillingness or unfaithfulness
Verse 13 says that once Israel 'grew strong' it chose forced labour over dispossession. Judg 1:27–28 says 'did not' instead of 'could not'. Josh 23:12–13 and Judg 2:1–3, 20–23 treat the surviving nations as the result of covenant failure and as a test. Joshua's reply in 17:17–18 insists the Joseph tribes *can* drive out the chariot-armed Canaanites.
-
Both, deliberately held in tension
The narrator sets 'could not' (v. 12), 'grew strong yet did not' (v. 13), and Joshua's 'you shall drive them out' (v. 18) side by side. The effect is to blur any neat excuse while still admitting the real odds.
in v12
Does wayyôʾel mean the Canaanites were 'determined' or only 'content' to stay?
-
Determined / persisted (resistance)
The causative form of *yāʾal* often means 'undertake, resolve' (Deut 1:5; Hos 5:11). It is set against Israel's inability, and verse 13 shows coercion was needed. Most modern versions take it this way.
-
Content / agreed to stay (settled continuation)
The exact phrase 'yāʾal + to dwell' in Exod 2:21 and Judg 17:11 means 'was content to settle'. On this reading the verse says the Canaanites simply stayed on, without stressing armed resistance.
-
Began / undertook (as in the Greek and Latin versions)
The Septuagint and Vulgate render the verb 'began', which may reflect an early understanding: the Canaanites went on to establish themselves alongside Israel.
in v12
How does this fit with Joshua's statements that the whole land was taken (11:23; 21:43–45)?
-
Ancient conquest-report style
Studies of Assyrian, Egyptian and Hittite military records (e.g. K. Lawson Younger, *Ancient Conquest Accounts*) show that sweeping 'total victory' summaries were a normal convention next to more detailed, partial reports. Joshua uses both kinds.
-
Different sources or layers in the book
Many critical scholars see the lists of unconquered cities (13:2–6, 13; 15:63; 16:10; 17:11–13) as old geographic material, built into a framework that celebrates complete conquest. They point to the close overlap with Judges 1.
-
Promise fulfilled in principle, completed over time
Josh 13:1–7 and 23:4–5 speak of land that 'remains' and that God will still drive out. Total possession is presented as given, yet still waiting to be carried out.
in v13
Does "vehoresh lo horisho" mean "did not drive them out completely" or "did not drive them out at all"?
-
Partial: they drove out some but not all, or did not finish the job.
This is the reading behind most English versions ("completely", "utterly"). The doubled verb is thought to intensify "dispossess" to "dispossess fully", so negating it denies full completion. The wider picture in Joshua includes real conquests elsewhere.
-
Emphatic negation: "as for dispossessing them, they did not dispossess them."
The doubled verb normally emphasizes the action itself, not its completeness (compare Gen 3:4; Exod 34:7). In context, the Canaanites of these specific cities stayed and were made laborers (vv. 12–13), which describes no dispossession of them at all. The refrain lo' horish in Judges 1:19–33 reads naturally as flat non-dispossession, city by city.
in v13
Is this notice a moral verdict on Israel, or a neutral record of how things turned out?
-
Implicit verdict of disobedience.
The contrast between "grew strong" and "did not dispossess" removes the excuse given in v. 12. Deuteronomy 7:1–5 and 20:16–18 forbid keeping the peoples of the land. Judges 2:1–3 explicitly interprets this same situation as covenant failure. In vv. 17–18 Joshua himself insists dispossession is still achievable.
-
Mainly an explanation of a known later situation, reflecting the monarchy's labor system.
The "to this day" notices (Josh 15:63; 16:10) and the close match with 1 Kgs 9:20–21 (Solomon's Canaanite corvée) lead many critical scholars to see these lines as explanations, written from the period of the kings, of why Canaanite labor gangs existed. On this view the tone is more descriptive than judgmental, though Deuteronomistic editors (the writers who shaped Joshua–Kings in the light of Deuteronomy) gave it a theological edge.
Sources
- HALOT s.v. יאל II (hiphil 'to undertake, resolve')
- HALOT s.v. ירשׁ (hiphil 'to dispossess')
- BDB s.v. יָאַל, יָרַשׁ, יָכֹל
- N. Lohfink, 'yāraš', Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament vol. 6
- BDB / HALOT s.v. כְּנַעֲנִי
- J. H. Walton, V. H. Matthews, M. W. Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Josh 17:11–18
- T. C. Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary)
- M. H. Woudstra, The Book of Joshua (NICOT)
- K. Lawson Younger Jr., Ancient Conquest Accounts (1990)
- A. Mazar et al., excavation reports on Tel Beth-Shean (Egyptian garrison levels)
- Parallel texts: Judg 1:19, 27–28; Josh 15:63; 16:10; 23:12–13; Exod 2:21; Judg 17:11; Deut 1:5; 1 Kgs 4:12; 9:15, 20–21
- BDB s.v. מַס; חָזַק; יָרַשׁ
- HALOT s.v. מַס (corvée, labor gang)
- TDOT s.v. יָרַשׁ (N. Lohfink)
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (Kautzsch-Cowley) §113 (infinitive absolute)
- Joüon-Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew §123
- Amarna letter EA 365 (Biridiya of Megiddo, corvée workers at Shunem)
- I. Mendelsohn, "State Slavery in Ancient Palestine," BASOR 85 (1942)
- R. Boling & G. E. Wright, Joshua (Anchor Bible)
- T. Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary)
- R. Hess, Joshua (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Joshua 17:13; Vulgate Josue 17:13
- Parallel texts: Judges 1:27–28; Joshua 16:10; Deuteronomy 20:10–18; 1 Kings 9:20–21; Exodus 1:11
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).