Judges Chapter 21 Read as one passage

Judges 21:15–17

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

15The people grieved for Benjamin, because the LORD had made a void in the tribes of Israel. 16Then the elders of the congregation said, “What should we do about wives for those who remain, since the women of Benjamin have been destroyed?” 17They added, “There must be heirs for the survivors of Benjamin, so that a tribe of Israel will not be wiped out.

What the first hearers heard

For the first hearers, this verse sharpens the tragedy and the irony of the book's closing chapters.

  • Real grief over a broken people. Israel was meant to be twelve tribes, one kin-people. Hearers would feel the horror of a tribe nearly gone, and the people's sorrow is presented as genuine. It belongs to people who see their own nation with a hole in it.
  • Grief without repentance. The verb describes regret and pity, not confession. The listener has just heard about the total destruction of Benjamin's towns and the rash oath, and is about to hear of a second massacre's aftermath and the seizing of the Shiloh girls. The sorrow produces clever workarounds, not repair of what went wrong. The verb's earlier use in 2:18, where Yahweh's pity leads to rescue, makes the contrast pointed.
  • Who made the breach? The people say Yahweh made the gap. Hearers knew Yahweh had indeed given Benjamin into Israel's hand (20:35). They had also just heard the people ask Yahweh "why has this happened?" (21:3) about a situation their own vow and slaughter had created. The narrator does not settle this in so many words. He leaves the tension standing and closes the book with: "everyone did what was right in his own eyes" (21:25).
  • Looking ahead. Readers in the time of the kings would know that the surviving tribe of Benjamin produced Saul, Israel's first king, and that Jabesh-gilead became bound to him. The breach being patched here is part of how Israel's later story became possible, patched in a deeply compromised way.

From the study of Judges 21:15.

Verse by verse

  1. 15The people grieved for Benjamin, because the LORD had made a void in the tribes of Israel.

    Now the people were sorry and grieved for Benjamin, because Yahweh had broken a hole in the wall of Israel's tribes.

    This verse is a pause in the story. After the raid on Jabesh-gilead provided only 400 wives for Benjamin's 600 survivors (21:14), the narrator restates why Israel is still trying: the people were sorry for Benjamin. The Hebrew verb means more than "felt bad." It is a deep, painful change of feeling: regret over what had happened, grief at the loss, and pity for the survivors, all together. It is not confession of sin. No one here says "we did wrong." The verb is the same one the book uses in 2:18 for Yahweh's pity on Israel. There, pity led God to rescue his people. Here, Israel's pity leads straight into a new scheme to seize women at Shiloh.

    The reason given is that Yahweh had made a breach. The word is the one for a section of wall smashed through. Israel is pictured as a single structure built of twelve tribes, and one section has been knocked out. The people credit the gap to Yahweh. In one sense that is true: Yahweh sent them into battle and "struck Benjamin before Israel" (20:35). But the reader has just watched Israel wipe out Benjamin's towns, women, children and animals (20:48) and swear never to give their daughters to Benjamin (21:1). The grief is real and the breach is real, but the verse quietly leaves open how much of that breach Israel itself had made.

    Full study →
  2. 16Then the elders of the congregation said, “What should we do about wives for those who remain, since the women of Benjamin have been destroyed?”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 17They added, “There must be heirs for the survivors of Benjamin, so that a tribe of Israel will not be wiped out.

    The elders of Israel's assembly reason it out aloud: "The land of Benjamin still belongs to Benjamin, which now means the handful of men who escaped the slaughter. That holding has to stay with them, so that a tribe is not wiped off the roll of Israel."

    The Hebrew is clipped, almost a slogan: "Possession of an escaped remnant to Benjamin." There is no verb. It is a flat statement of whose land this is. The word for "possession" (yerushshah) is the word for a people's territory. Benjamin's allotted land is still Benjamin's, and only the 600 fugitives from the rock of Rimmon are left to hold it. If they die without sons, the land is empty and the tribe ends. So "There must be heirs" (BSB) states the practical consequence correctly, but the underlying claim concerns land and tribal identity.

    The second half borrows the wording of the levirate law (the law requiring a man to father a son for his dead, childless brother): "so that his name is not wiped out from Israel" (Deut 25:6). The verb means to wipe clean, as a dish is wiped or ink washed off a page. Israel's assembly now sees itself in the position of a brother who must keep a dead brother's name alive, except that this time the dying brother is a whole tribe, and Israel's own hands caused the death. A people of twelve tribes is about to become eleven. That loss is what the elders cannot accept, and it pushes them toward the extreme measures that follow at Jabesh-gilead and Shiloh.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v15

    repented them (KJV); repented (YLT)

    niḥām (nāḥam)

    What we hear
    They turned from their sin, confessed wrongdoing and changed their behavior before God.
    What they heard
    They felt deep regret, grief and pity about what had happened to Benjamin, a painful change of feeling about the situation. The text records no confession, and what follows is a further scheme rather than a moral turnaround.
  • in v17

    inheritance

    yerushshah

    What we hear
    Money or property a person leaves to his or her children at death; a private estate.
    What they heard
    A people's rightful holding of land, here Benjamin's tribal territory. The concern is that the land stays with the tribe through its surviving men and their future sons.
Every word
  1. וְהָעָ֥ם

    wəhāʿām · H5971A

    and the people · v15

    The assembled Israelites, the same tribal gathering that swore the oath at Mizpah (21:1) and fought Benjamin. The sentence opens with the subject, not the verb, which in Hebrew marks a background statement: "Now the people were sorry…" It restates the reason for what follows.

  2. נִחָ֖ם

    niḥām · H5162G

    be sorry, regret, be moved with pity · v15

    An emotional change of mind: they felt the pain of regret and pity over what had happened to Benjamin. It is the same verb as 21:6. It does not mean confessing sin or turning from it.

  3. לְבִנְיָמִ֑ן

    ləbinyāmin · H1144G

    for/concerning Benjamin · v15, v17

    The object of their regret: the tribe of Benjamin, cut down to 600 men who escaped to the rock of Rimmon (20:47). Here Benjamin is the tribe, not the patriarch.

  4. כִּֽי־

    kî · H3588A

    for, because · v15

    Gives the reason for their sorrow. It could be the narrator's explanation or the people's own reasoning reported by the narrator (see debates).

  5. עָשָׂ֧ה

    ʿāśâ · H6213H

    made, did · v15

    A completed action that comes before the people's grief, so English rightly says "had made." The breach is an accomplished fact.

  6. יְהוָ֛ה

    YHWH · H3068G

    Yahweh (the LORD) · v15

    Israel's God, named as the one who made the breach. This picks up 20:35 ("Yahweh struck Benjamin before Israel") and the people's complaint to Yahweh in 21:3. Yet the near-wipeout and the oath were Israel's own doing.

  7. פֶּ֖רֶץ

    pereṣ · H6556

    breach, gap (in a wall); outburst · v15

    A hole broken through a wall. Israel's twelve tribes are pictured as a wall, and one section has been smashed out, leaving a gap the whole structure feels.

  8. בְּשִׁבְטֵ֥י

    bəšibṭê · H7626H

    in the tribes of · v15, v17

    The tribes as the units that make up Israel. The word also means "rod" or "staff," the symbol of a tribe's identity and leadership.

  9. יִשְׂרָאֵֽל׃

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v15, v17

    The twelve-tribe people as one whole. The point of the verse is that the whole is now incomplete.

  10. וַיֹּאמְרוּ

    vayyomeru · H0559

    and they said · v17

    The speakers are the "elders of the congregation" from v.16. They are still thinking aloud. The question in v.16 ("What shall we do?") leads to this statement of what is at stake, and v.18 then states their problem.

  11. יְרֻשַּׁת

    yerushshat · H3425

    possession, holding · v17

    A possession someone holds by right, used above all of land a group takes and keeps. Here it means Benjamin's tribal territory. Its form ties it directly to the next word: "the possession of a remnant."

  12. פְּלֵיטָה

    peletah · H6413

    escaped remnant, survivors · v17

    The group that slipped out of a catastrophe alive. In this case it is the 600 Benjaminite men who fled to the rock of Rimmon (20:47). The word carries the feeling of a narrow escape and a fragile remainder.

  13. וְלֹא־

    velo- · H3808

    and not · v17

    This negates the following verb. Together with the "and" it works as a purpose or result clause: "so that … not."

  14. יִמָּחֶה

    yimmacheh · H4229A

    be wiped out, blotted out · v17

    This is a passive form of the verb "to wipe clean." It is the word for wiping a dish (2 Kgs 21:13), for wiping out life in the Flood (Gen 6:7) and for blotting out a name or memory (Ex 17:14; Deut 25:6). Here it means a tribe erased from the roll of Israel, leaving no trace.

The world behind it

The story so far (Judges 19–21). A Levite's concubine was gang-raped and killed at Gibeah, a Benjaminite town. The other tribes gathered at Mizpah and demanded the culprits, and Benjamin refused. In the civil war that followed, Israel, after asking Yahweh and being told to go up (20:18, 23, 28), destroyed Benjamin's army. Then they put every Benjaminite town to the sword, people and animals alike (20:48). Only 600 men escaped to the rock of Rimmon (20:47).

The oath problem. At Mizpah the tribes had sworn: "None of us will give his daughter to Benjamin as a wife" (21:1). With Benjamin's women dead, the tribe faced extinction. An oath sworn before God could not simply be cancelled, so the elders looked for ways around it. First they destroyed Jabesh-gilead, which had not come to the assembly, and took its 400 unmarried girls (21:8–14). Verse 15 comes at the point where that has fallen 200 short. Next comes the plan to let Benjamin seize dancers at the Shiloh festival (21:19–23), so that no father technically "gave" his daughter.

Why losing a tribe mattered. Israel understood itself as twelve tribes descended from Jacob's twelve sons, each with an inherited share of the land. A tribe dying out meant a name "blotted out from Israel" (21:17) and an inheritance left without heirs. That was a catastrophe for the whole kin-based people, not just for Benjamin. The wall image of pereṣ fits this: the twelve together make one structure.

The frame of the book. These chapters are bracketed by the refrain "In those days there was no king in Israel; everyone did what was right in his own eyes" (19:1; 21:25). Benjamin was later the tribe of King Saul, and Jabesh-gilead was later tied to Saul (1 Sam 11; 31). Many readers think the story is told with that later history in view.

From the study of Judges 21:15.

Where scholars differ

in v15

Does the narrator endorse the claim that Yahweh made the breach, or is it the people shifting responsibility?

  • A straightforward theological statement: Yahweh did make the breach.

    Yahweh authorized the attack three times (20:18, 23, 28) and "struck Benjamin before Israel" (20:35). Hebrew narrative regularly credits outcomes to God even when humans act. *Pereṣ* elsewhere describes divine judgment breaking out (2 Sam 6:8).

  • Ironic: the narrator lets the people put on Yahweh what their own oath and total war caused.

    Israel went beyond defeating Benjamin's army and wiped out its towns, women and animals (20:48). The oath of 21:1 created the marriage crisis, and Yahweh is never said to have commanded it. In 21:3 the people ask Yahweh "why has this happened?" as if they had no part in it. The book's closing verdict (21:25) casts these chapters as moral chaos. Commentators such as Webb and Block read the chapter's divine-agency language with this irony in view. The 'because' clause may also be the people's own reasoning reported by the narrator rather than his own comment.

in v15

Is the people's niḥām chiefly regret or chiefly compassion?

  • Chiefly regret over their own actions (NASB "were sorry"; KJV "repented").

    This verb form most often means regret or change of mind about a course of action (Gen 6:6; 1 Sam 15:11, 35). The people who grieve are the ones who caused the loss and swore the oath, and the next step is an attempt to undo its consequences.

  • Chiefly pity or compassion for a kinsman tribe (ESV "had compassion").

    21:6 adds "Benjamin their brother," stressing kinship. The same form means "be moved to pity" in Judg 2:18. The focus of 21:15–17 is preserving the survivors, not self-reproach.

  • Both together.

    Studies of the root (e.g. Parunak) find its core in emotional pain over a situation. That pain can show up as regret, pity or grief depending on context, and this context supplies grounds for all three.

in v17

What exactly does "possession of a remnant to Benjamin" mean?

  • Land claim: Benjamin's tribal territory still rightfully belongs to its surviving men, so they must be enabled to keep it.

    *Yerushshah* is used almost entirely of territorial holdings (Deut 2; Josh 12). Tribal land was meant to stay within the tribe (Num 36:7–9). The preposition "to Benjamin" marks ownership.

  • Heirs/continuity: the survivors must have offspring to carry on Benjamin. This is how BSB, NIV and similar versions translate it.

    The next words ("so that a tribe is not wiped out") and the whole context (wives, v.16, 18) make descendants the practical issue. The verb family *yarash* can mean "inherit," and heirs are what keep a holding.

  • The text is damaged and should be emended.

    Some older critical commentators found the verbless phrase too abrupt and proposed changes. Against this, the Septuagint reflects essentially the same Hebrew, and most modern commentators keep it.

in v17

Does the narrator approve of the elders' reasoning?

  • Their concern is presented as legitimate: preserving all twelve tribes is a genuine good, and the story shows Israel restoring its wholeness.

    Israel's grief over the "breach" in the tribes (21:3, 6, 15). Benjamin's later importance, including Saul and Jerusalem's location on the Benjamin border.

  • The verse is part of an ironic picture of moral chaos. A good goal is pursued through new atrocities because of a rash oath.

    The "no king… right in his own eyes" frame (21:25). The massacre at Jabesh-gilead and the abductions at Shiloh follow directly. The parallel with Jephthah's rash vow (Judg 11).

Sources
  • BDB s.v. נָחַם
  • HALOT s.v. נחם (niphal)
  • HALOT s.v. פֶּרֶץ
  • BDB s.v. שֵׁבֶט
  • H. Van Dyke Parunak, "A Semantic Survey of NHM," Biblica 56 (1975)
  • H. Simian-Yofre, "nḥm," TDOT vol. 9
  • Daniel I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary)
  • Barry G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT)
  • Trent C. Butler, Judges (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Septuagint, Judges 21:6, 15
  • Vulgate, Iudicum 21:15
  • BDB s.v. יְרֻשָּׁה, פְּלֵיטָה, מָחָה, שֵׁבֶט
  • HALOT s.v. יְרֻשָּׁה; פְּלֵיטָה; מחה I
  • G. F. Moore, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Judges (ICC)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 19–21
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Judges 21:17
  • Supplied STEPBible/OSHB morphology for Judg 21:17

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.