Judges Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Judges 5:14–15

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

14Some came from Ephraim, with their roots in Amalek; Benjamin came with your people after you. The commanders came down from Machir, the bearers of the marshal’s staff from Zebulun. 15The princes of Issachar were with Deborah, and Issachar was with Barak, rushing into the valley at his heels. In the clans of Reuben there was great indecision.

What the first hearers heard

For the first hearers, probably sung at gatherings that remembered the victory, this verse was a litany of honour. Hearing your tribe's name, and hearing that your commanders and marshals 'came down', meant your clan had answered when the LORD's people were in danger (v. 13: 'the people of the LORD came down for me against the mighty'). The shout 'Behind you, Benjamin!' would have sounded like the real noise of mobilisation.

The verse also stresses that the leaders came: men with staffs of command and muster officers. In the logic of the song (compare v. 2, 'when leaders led in Israel, when the people volunteered'), the victory began when those with authority stepped forward and the people followed willingly. Placed right before the shaming of Reuben, Gilead, Dan and Asher, the verse set out what loyalty to the LORD and to kin looked like in a society with no king: you came when called.

From the study of Judges 5:14.

Verse by verse

  1. 14Some came from Ephraim, with their roots in Amalek; Benjamin came with your people after you. The commanders came down from Machir, the bearers of the marshal’s staff from Zebulun.

    The verse is a roll-call shouted in verse, naming the clans that answered the summons to fight Sisera:

    "From Ephraim they came, men rooted in the hill-country called Amalek (or, as one ancient copy has it, they went down 'into the valley'). 'Behind you, Benjamin!' went the cry, and Benjamin came with its clansmen under arms. From Machir the commanders came down, men who carry the staff of command. From Zebulun came the muster-officers, the men who hold the marshal's staff and draw the levy out to war."

    The picture is of hill-tribes pouring down into the Jezreel plain. Each tribe is named with honour, and each sends its leaders: commanders with the staff of authority and the officers who count and call up the men. "Amalek" here is not a battle against the Amalekites but most likely a district in Ephraim that bore the name. "After you, Benjamin!" is probably a remembered war cry, since Hosea 5:8 uses the same two words as an alarm. The 'pen of the writer' of older English is really a staff: the men from Zebulun are not clerks with pens but marshals with rods of office, the ones who muster an army.

    Full study →
  2. 15The princes of Issachar were with Deborah, and Issachar was with Barak, rushing into the valley at his heels. In the clans of Reuben there was great indecision.

    Issachar's own captains and chiefs stood with Deborah. The whole tribe was as solidly behind Barak as Barak himself, true to him, and they were let loose down into the valley, the open chariot plain of Jezreel, right on his heels as his followers. Then the song turns from praise to a taunt. Among Reuben's clans, scattered across the stream-cut uplands beyond the Jordan, there were great decisions of the mind: firm resolutions, as if engraved, made with all the seriousness of a war council.

    The irony is sharp. Just before this, the poet praised the "commanders" (literally "decree-makers") who actually came down from Machir. Reuben also made "decrees," but only inside its own head. The next verse finishes the joke by changing one letter: the grand resolves turn into endless searchings of heart, while Reuben sat among its sheepfolds listening to shepherds' pipes. Issachar marched. Reuben only made its mind up, over and over.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v14

    the pen of the writer (KJV); the reed of a writer (YLT)

    šēbeṭ sōpēr

    What we hear
    Clerks or scholars who write with pens, as if Zebulun sent its literate men or record-keepers.
    What they heard
    The staff of the muster-officer: the rod of office carried by the men who counted and called up troops. Šēbeṭ is a rod or staff (the same word as 'scepter' and 'tribe'), never a writing tool.
  • in v14

    lawgivers (YLT); governors (KJV)

    məḥōqəqîm

    What we hear
    Legislators or civil administrators.
    What they heard
    Commanders who carry a staff of authority. In this battle roll-call they are military leaders.
  • in v14

    against Amalek (KJV)

    baʿămālēq

    What we hear
    Ephraim fought the Amalekite nation.
    What they heard
    'In Amalek': most likely an Ephraimite district bearing that name (Judges 12:15), or possibly a copying slip for 'in the valley'. The preposition is 'in', and no war with Amalekites is in view.
  • in v15

    princes

    sarim (sar)

    What we hear
    Sons of a king; royalty.
    What they heard
    Chiefs, officers, commanders: the tribe's leading men and war captains. Issachar had no monarchy.
  • in v15

    heart ("thoughts/resolves/searchings of heart")

    lev

    What we hear
    Feelings and emotions; inner turmoil or soul-searching distress.
    What they heard
    The mind and will: where a person plans and decides. "Resolves of heart" are deliberate decisions.
  • in v15

    on foot (KJV)

    beraglav

    What we hear
    Walking rather than riding: an infantry detail.
    What they heard
    "At his feet" = following him, as his troops (cf. 4:10).
Every word
  1. מִנִּ֣י

    minnî · H4480A

    from, out of; some of · v14

    An old, poetic long form of the ordinary word 'from'. It gives the roll-call a formal, archaic ring: '(Some) from Ephraim…'. It probably means 'some of', i.e., part of the tribe came, not necessarily all of it.

  2. אֶפְרַ֗יִם

    ʾeprayim · H0669G

    Ephraim · v14

    The large central hill-country tribe. It is named first among the tribes that answered the call.

  3. שָׁרְשָׁם֙

    šoršām · H8328

    root · v14

    'Their root': where they are planted or where they come from. The image is of a people rooted in a territory. The word is difficult in this context, and some scholars emend it (see textual notes).

  4. בַּעֲמָלֵ֔ק

    baʿămālēq · H6002G

    Amalek · v14

    'In Amalek'. It most likely refers to a district inside Ephraim that carried the Amalekite name (Judges 12:15, 'the hill country of the Amalekites'). It does not mean the Amalekite enemy people, and it does not say Ephraim fought 'against Amalek'. The early Greek read 'in the valley' here.

  5. אַחֲרֶ֥יךָ

    ʾaḥărêkā · H0310A

    after you, behind you · v14

    'After you!' or 'Behind you!' Hosea 5:8 uses the exact phrase 'Behind you, Benjamin!' as an alarm or battle cry, so this is probably a traditional Benjaminite war cry quoted in the song.

  6. בִנְיָמִ֖ין

    binyāmîn · H1144G

    Benjamin · v14

    The small tribe just south of Ephraim, famous for its fighters. It is probably being addressed directly ('Benjamin!').

  7. בַּֽעֲמָמֶ֑יךָ

    baʿămāmêkā · H5971B

    people, kinsmen; fighting force · v14

    'Among (or with) your kin-troops.' An unusual old plural of ʿam. In early Hebrew ʿam often means the kin-group mustered as an army, so 'your people' here means 'your clansmen under arms'.

  8. מָכִ֗יר

    mākîr · H4353G

    Machir · v14

    Machir was Manasseh's son (Genesis 50:23; Numbers 26:29). Here it is the name of a clan-group that stands where the tribe of Manasseh would later be listed. This is a sign of how old the tribal list is.

  9. יָֽרְדוּ֙

    yārədû · H3381

    they went down, came down · v14

    'They came down.' This is the song's key verb for answering the muster (vv. 11, 13). It pictures fighters coming down from the hills to the battle in the Jezreel plain.

  10. מְחֹ֣קְקִ֔ים

    məḥōqəqîm · H2710

    one who decrees; commander; ruler's staff · v14

    Literally 'those who inscribe / decree'. Here it means commanders or officers who carry a staff of command (compare Genesis 49:10 and Numbers 21:18, where the same form means a ruler's staff). These are military leaders, not legislators.

  11. וּמִ֨זְּבוּלֻ֔ן

    ûmizzəbûlun · H2074

    and from Zebulun · v14

    Zebulun, the Galilean tribe next to the battlefield. In the prose account (Judges 4:6, 10) it is one of Barak's two core tribes, and v. 18 praises it for risking its life.

  12. מֹשְׁכִ֖ים

    mōšəkîm · H4900

    drawing, pulling; leading out; wielding · v14

    'Drawing' or 'wielding'. The verb echoes Judges 4:6–7, where Barak is told to 'draw' (deploy) the men to Tabor and God will 'draw' Sisera out. Here the officers hold the staff and draw the troops out to battle.

  13. בְּשֵׁ֥בֶט

    bəšēbeṭ · H7626G

    rod, staff, scepter; tribe · v14

    'With the staff of'. A rod of office, the visible sign of authority to summon and command. It is not a writing tool.

  14. סֹפֵֽר׃

    sōpēr · H5608B

    counter, recorder, scribe; muster-officer · v14

    'Of the counter / muster-officer'. The root means 'to count' as well as 'to write'. In military settings the sōpēr enrolled the men called up for war (2 Kings 25:19). The phrase means the marshal's staff.

  15. וְשָׂרַ֤י

    wesaray · H8269

    official, commander, leader · v15

    The tribe's military and clan leaders, not royalty. As vowel-marked it means "my commanders," which may be Deborah or the singer claiming them as their own. Many scholars read the same consonants as "the commanders of."

  16. בְּיִשָּׂשכָר֙

    beyissaskhar · H3485

    Issachar · v15

    "In Issachar": the tribe whose land lay in and around the Jezreel Valley, right where the battle was fought (4:13–16; 5:19–21).

  17. עִם־

    ʿim · H5973

    with · v15

    "With" as in standing alongside: they joined Deborah's side in the muster.

  18. דְּבֹרָ֔ה

    devorah · H1683

    Deborah ("bee") · v15

    The prophetess and judge who called up the tribes (4:4–10). Here she is named as the rallying point.

  19. כֵּ֣ן

    ken · H3651

    so, thus; right, true · v15

    Either "as Issachar, so Barak" (equal in commitment) or, taking ken as "true, loyal" (as in Gen 42:11, "honest men"), "Issachar was true to Barak." Both readings point to steady loyalty.

  20. בָּרָ֔ק

    baraq · H1301

    Barak ("lightning") · v15

    The field commander from Kedesh in Naphtali whom Deborah summoned (4:6). The tribe is lined up behind him.

  21. בָּעֵ֖מֶק

    baʿemeq · H6010

    valley, broad lowland · v15

    "Into the valley": the broad plain of Jezreel along the Kishon, where Sisera's chariots had the advantage. Going down into it was the dangerous move.

  22. שֻׁלַּ֣ח

    shullach · H7971

    was sent, was let loose · v15

    A passive form, "was sent forth / was unleashed." It suggests troops launched or released down the slopes of Tabor, not a casual trip. BSB's "rushing" captures the momentum.

  23. בְּרַגְלָ֑יו

    beraglav · H7272

    foot; (idiom) following · v15

    "At his feet" is a Hebrew idiom for "as his followers, right behind him." The same phrase is used of Barak's 10,000 men in 4:10. It does not mean "on foot" as opposed to riding.

  24. בִּפְלַגּ֣וֹת

    bifluggot · H6391

    divisions, clans; (related) channels · v15

    "Among the divisions/clans of." The root means "split, divide," and a related word means "stream-channel." So the phrase can also call up Reuben's wadi-cut land east of the Dead Sea, and it fits a tribe that was divided in mind.

  25. רְאוּבֵ֔ן

    reʾuven · H7205

    Reuben · v15

    The Transjordanian herding tribe, Jacob's firstborn. The song now shifts from praising tribes that came to taunting those that stayed home.

  26. גְּדֹלִ֖ים

    gedolim · H1419

    great, large · v15

    "Great" (plural). Here it is almost certainly ironic: grand resolutions that came to nothing, as v. 16 makes clear.

  27. חִקְקֵי־

    chiqqe · H2711

    decree, resolution, decision · v15

    From a root meaning "engrave, inscribe, decree." These are firm determinations, as if carved in stone. It echoes the "commanders" (meḥoqeqim, same root) of v. 14: Machir sent decree-makers who actually came down, while Reuben only decreed inside its own head.

  28. לֵֽב׃

    lev · H3820

    heart, mind, will · v15

    In Hebrew the heart is where a person thinks, plans and decides, not mainly where they feel. "Resolves of heart" means decisions of the mind and will.

The world behind it

A tribal militia, not a standing army. In the time of the judges Israel had no king and no professional army. When a threat arose, a leader such as Barak sent out a summons and each tribe decided whether to send its men. The clan was the army: the same word, ʿam, meant both 'kin' and 'troops'. Officers with a staff of office (šēbeṭ, məḥōqēq) had the authority to call men up, and a sōpēr ('counter') enrolled them.

The roll-call of honour and shame (vv. 14–18). Deborah's Song praises the tribes that 'came down' (Ephraim, Benjamin, Machir, Zebulun, Issachar, Naphtali) and taunts those that stayed home (Reuben 'among the sheepfolds', Gilead beyond the Jordan, Dan with its ships, Asher by the coast). In an honour-shame society, being named in a victory song was lasting public honour. Being named as a no-show was lasting disgrace. Verse 14 is the honour side of the list.

Geography. Ephraim, Benjamin and Machir (Manasseh) lived in the central hills. Zebulun lived in lower Galilee, next to the battlefield. The battle took place in the Jezreel valley by the Kishon brook (4:7, 13; 5:19–21), so the tribes literally 'came down' from the highlands.

An old tribal map. The song names Machir where later lists have Manasseh, and it does not mention Judah, Simeon or Levi at all. Most scholars take this as a sign that the song reflects a very early stage of Israel's tribal arrangement. It is often counted among the oldest Hebrew poems, though its exact date is debated. The prose account in Judges 4 names only Zebulun and Naphtali (4:6, 10), and the song widens the circle.

Amalek in Ephraim. Judges 12:15 mentions 'the hill country of the Amalekites' inside Ephraim's land, so 'Amalek' could be a local place-name. That makes the phrase intelligible without supposing a battle with the Amalekite people.

From the study of Judges 5:14.

Where scholars differ

in v14

What does 'their root in Amalek' mean?

  • It is a place-name: Ephraimites from the district called 'Amalek' within Ephraim.

    Judges 12:15 places Pirathon 'in the land of Ephraim, in the hill country of the Amalekites'. The Hebrew text stands without emendation.

  • The original read 'in the valley' (baʿēmeq): Ephraim deployed into the Jezreel valley.

    Codex Vaticanus of the Greek reads 'in the valley'. The two words differ by one letter, and baʿēmeq appears in v. 15.

  • It refers to fighting against, or uprooting, Amalekites.

    The Alexandrinus Greek has 'uprooted them in Amalek', and the KJV has 'against'. But the Hebrew preposition b- normally means 'in', and the context is a muster against Sisera, not Amalek.

in v14

Who is 'you' in 'after you, Benjamin'?

  • Benjamin is addressed. The phrase is a traditional war cry ('Behind you, Benjamin!').

    Hosea 5:8 uses the identical phrase as a battle alarm.

  • Ephraim is addressed: Benjamin came 'after you' (Ephraim).

    It follows straight after the Ephraim line. The masculine singular 'you' fits a tribe.

  • Barak is addressed: Benjamin followed 'you' (Barak) with its troops.

    Barak is addressed directly in v. 12, and v. 15 mentions following Barak 'at his heels'.

in v14

Is the sōpēr a scribe or a muster-officer?

  • A muster-officer or marshal who enrolled and counted troops.

    The root means 'count'. 2 Kings 25:19 and Jeremiah 52:25 have the army's sōpēr mustering the people. šēbeṭ is a staff of office, and the Vulgate reads it militarily.

  • A literate scribe or official, with 'staff' perhaps meaning a stylus.

    Sōpēr usually means 'scribe' elsewhere. Some Greek and older English readings took the phrase as a writing instrument. But šēbeṭ never clearly means 'pen' anywhere else.

in v14

How old is the Song of Deborah?

  • Very early (12th–11th century BC), close to the events.

    Archaic grammar and vocabulary (e.g., minnî, the plural ʿămāmîm), the early tribal list (Machir, no Judah), and no king or temple.

  • Later composition or editing, written in a deliberately archaic style.

    Some scholars see literary shaping and argue that archaic forms can be imitated. The song is now set within the edited book of Judges.

in v15

What does "Issachar ken Barak" mean?

  • "As Issachar, so Barak": the tribe matched its commander in commitment (or simply "Issachar too, and Barak").

    Ken normally means "so, thus." The KJV and WEB take it this way.

  • "Issachar was true/loyal to Barak": ken as an adjective meaning "right, honest."

    Ken as an adjective is attested (Gen 42:11, kenim, "honest men"; 2 Kgs 7:9, "not right"). It fits the praise context. Followed by YLT ("right with") and ESV ("faithful").

  • The text originally read "Naphtali" (or similar) instead of the second "Issachar."

    Barak's home tribe was Naphtali (4:6, 10), which is otherwise mentioned only in v. 18. This is conjectural, with no direct manuscript support.

in v15

Is "great resolves of heart" (v. 15) sincere or sarcastic, and is it original?

  • Original and ironic: grand resolutions (v. 15) collapse into endless deliberation (v. 16).

    The one-letter shift ḥiqqe/ḥiqre is a typical poetic play. Ḥeqeq echoes v. 14's meḥoqeqim ("commanders"), and v. 16's "Why did you sit…?" makes the sarcasm plain. Many modern commentators (e.g. Block, Butler) read it this way.

  • A copying variant: one verse originally matched the other.

    Refrains are usually repeated exactly. A few manuscripts and versions read ḥiqre in v. 15, and ר and ק could be confused in some scripts. Many modern translations (ESV, NIV) render both as "searching(s)."

Sources
  • BDB s.v. שֹׁרֶשׁ, חָקַק, סָפַר, שֵׁבֶט, מָשַׁךְ
  • HALOT s.v. מְחֹקֵק, סֹפֵר, עַם
  • C. F. Burney, The Book of Judges (1918), on 5:14
  • R. G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible, 1975)
  • J. A. Soggin, Judges (OTL, 1981)
  • B. Lindars, Judges 1–5 (1995)
  • Septuagint, Judges 5:14 (Codex Alexandrinus and Codex Vaticanus text forms)
  • Vulgate, Judices 5:14
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Judges 5
  • Cross-references: Judges 4:6–10; 12:15; Hosea 5:8; Genesis 49:10; Numbers 21:18; 2 Kings 25:19
  • BDB s.v. חָקַק, חֵקֶק, פְּלַגָּה, שַׂר, כֵּן
  • HALOT s.v. חֵקֶק; פְּלֻגָּה; כֵּן II ("right, honest")
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus to Judg 5:15–16
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §130a, construct before a preposition
  • R. G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
  • B. Lindars, Judges 1–5 (ICC)
  • D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary)
  • T. C. Butler, Judges (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judg 4–5

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).