Judges Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Judges 9:28–30

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

28Then Gaal son of Ebed said, “Who is Abimelech, and who is Shechem, that we should serve him? Is he not the son of Jerubbaal, and is not Zebul his officer? You are to serve the men of Hamor, the father of Shechem. Why should we serve Abimelech? 29If only this people were under my authority, I would remove Abimelech; I would say to him, ‘Muster your army and come out!’” 30When Zebul the governor of the city heard the words of Gaal son of Ebed, he burned with anger.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this was the story of Israel's first failed experiment with kingship. It was also a story of rough justice: the men who made a murderer king are now turned against him.

  • Irony and judgment. The audience already knew from 9:23–24 that God had set Abimelech and Shechem against each other to repay the blood of Jerubbaal's seventy sons. Gaal's speech is the first spark of that repayment. In the end it destroys both Abimelech and the lords of Shechem, as Jotham's curse had said (9:20, 56–57).
  • No heroes. Gaal is not presented as a liberator. He is a newcomer, a "servant's son", boasting over wine. He echoes Pharaoh's and Nabal's "Who is…?" contempt, and he folds the moment Abimelech's army appears (9:36–40). Hearers would recognise a type: the loud man at the feast.
  • Canaanite versus Israelite. By setting the "son of Jerubbaal" against the "men of Hamor", the speech reminds Israelite hearers that Shechem's ruling class worshipped Baal-berith and claimed descent from the Hamor of Genesis 34. Abimelech had tied an Israelite family to a Canaanite city and its Baal temple. Now that alliance falls apart along the lines of blood and religion it was built on.
  • Kingship. Coming right after Gideon's refusal ("The LORD will rule over you," 8:23), the squabble over "whom should we serve?" shows what happens when the question of rule is settled by money, murder and clan loyalty instead of by Israel's God.

From the study of Judges 9:28.

Verse by verse

  1. 28Then Gaal son of Ebed said, “Who is Abimelech, and who is Shechem, that we should serve him? Is he not the son of Jerubbaal, and is not Zebul his officer? You are to serve the men of Hamor, the father of Shechem. Why should we serve Abimelech?

    At the grape-harvest festival, drinking in the house of Shechem's god, a newcomer named Gaal, whose father's name simply means "servant", stands up and pours scorn on the king:

    "Abimelech? Who does he think he is? And what is 'Shechem' to him, or what have we come to as Shechem, that we should be his subjects? Isn't he just the son of Jerubbaal, the man who picked a fight with Baal? And isn't Zebul nothing but his appointed deputy? If you're going to be anyone's subjects, be subject to the clan of Hamor, Shechem's founding father, our own ancient ruling house! So why should we, of all people, bow to him?"

    "Serve" here does not mean helping someone. It means being someone's subjects: owing a ruler obedience, dues and labour. Gaal says it three times, so he is calling openly for revolt. His argument is about bloodlines. Abimelech had won the city by stressing his Shechemite mother ("I am your bone and your flesh," 9:2). Gaal turns this round by naming only the father, Jerubbaal, an Israelite whose very name recalls his war on the Baal worshipped in Shechem's temple. Against him Gaal sets Hamor, the city's ancient Canaanite founder from the days of Jacob (Genesis 34).

    A possible alternative reading of the middle line, using the same Hebrew letters, is: "Didn't the son of Jerubbaal and his deputy Zebul themselves once serve the men of Hamor?" In other words, these are former underlings, so why should we serve them? Either way the point is the same: Abimelech has no rightful claim on Shechem.

    The storyteller wants the reader to catch the irony. A "son of a servant" lectures the town on whom not to serve, and he makes his big speech while drunk at a festival. A few verses later Zebul throws it back at him: "Where is your mouth now?" (9:38).

    Full study →
  2. 29If only this people were under my authority, I would remove Abimelech; I would say to him, ‘Muster your army and come out!’”

    Gaal, warmed by wine at Shechem's vintage festival, voices a wish in the familiar Hebrew form "who will give…?", that is, "If only someone would put this people in my hands!" He means: if only these Shechemites would rally behind me as their commander, "then I'd get Abimelech out of the way!" The verb is "make him turn aside", removing him from power or from the scene altogether, and Gaal leaves it vague. Then comes the dare, aimed at a king who is not even in the city: "Make your army as big as you like, Abimelech, and come on out!" "Come out" is the regular Hebrew phrase for marching out to battle in the open field.

    Nobody prays here. The KJV's "would to God" is simply old English for "if only". The words are a drunken boast made in public, meant to win over the crowd and insult the absent ruler. The narrator records them because they will soon be thrown back at Gaal: Abimelech does come, and it is Gaal who has to "go out" and is beaten (vv. 38–40).

    Full study →
  3. 30When Zebul the governor of the city heard the words of Gaal son of Ebed, he burned with anger.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v28

    serve

    ʿāḇaḏ

    What we hear
    To help, work for, or be of service to someone, often voluntarily.
    What they heard
    To be someone's subject or vassal: to obey, pay tribute and give labour to a ruler. Here it is the vocabulary of political allegiance and revolt.
  • in v28

    officer (KJV, ESV, BSB)

    pāqîḏ

    What we hear
    A military or police officer, someone with rank in uniform.
    What they heard
    An appointed overseer or deputy acting for a superior. Zebul is the governor Abimelech installed over Shechem (9:30).
  • in v29

    would to God (KJV)

    mi yitten

    What we hear
    A prayer or appeal to God: Gaal asking God to give him the people.
    What they heard
    A set wish formula, literally 'who will give?', meaning simply 'if only' or 'I wish'. No divine name appears and no deity is addressed.
Every word
  1. וַיֹּאמֶר

    wayyōʾmer · H0559

    and he said · v28, v29

    The ordinary storytelling verb that moves the narrative on. The speech it introduces is given at the drunken harvest feast of 9:27, which colours everything that follows.

  2. גַּעַל

    gaʿal · H1603

    Gaal · v28

    A newcomer who has just moved into Shechem with his kinsmen (9:26). The name sounds like the Hebrew root 'to loathe, abhor', which may be a deliberate, unflattering touch by the storyteller (see studies).

  3. בֶּן־

    ben- · H1121A

    son of · v28

    Identifies him by his father, the normal way of naming a man. The verse is full of 'son of' language: lineage is the whole argument.

  4. עֶבֶד

    ʿeḇed · H5651G

    Ebed · v28

    The father's name is the ordinary word for 'servant' or 'slave'. So 'Gaal son of Ebed' can be heard as 'son of a servant', the man who then asks three times why 'we' should 'serve'. The irony is hard to miss in Hebrew.

  5. מִי־

    mî- · H4310

    who? · v28, v29

    A scornful question, not a request for information: 'Who does he think he is?' The same contemptuous formula is used by Pharaoh of the LORD (Exod 5:2) and by Nabal of David (1 Sam 25:10).

  6. אֲבִימֶלֶךְ

    ʾăḇîmeleḵ · H0040H

    Abimelech · v28, v29

    Gideon's son by a Shechemite concubine (8:31), who murdered his seventy brothers and was made king by the lords of Shechem (9:1–6). His name means 'my father is king', an ironic name for a man whose father refused kingship (8:23).

  7. שְׁכֶם

    šəḵem · H7927G

    Shechem · v28

    Either the city/its people, Abimelech's claimed Shechemite identity, or the city's legendary founder. The Greek translation read 'the son of Shechem'.

  8. כִּי

    kî · H3588A

    that, for · v28

    Here it introduces the consequence that the scornful question rules out: 'that we should serve him'.

  9. נַעַבְדֶנּוּ

    naʿaḇdennû · H5647G

    we should serve him · v28

    'Serve' in the political sense: be his subjects, obey him, pay him dues and labour. The form expresses obligation or propriety: 'that we ought to be subject to him'.

  10. הֲלֹא

    hălōʾ · H3808

    is not? · v28

    A question expecting 'yes': 'Isn't he just…?' It reminds the listeners of something they already know and turns it into an accusation.

  11. יְרֻבַּעַל

    yərubbaʿal · H3378

    Jerubbaal · v28

    Gideon's other name, explained in 6:32 as 'Let Baal contend against him', because he tore down Baal's altar. In a city whose temple belonged to Baal-berith (9:4), calling Abimelech 'son of the Baal-fighter' marks him as an Israelite outsider and an enemy of the local god.

  12. וּזְבֻל

    ûzəḇul · H2083

    and Zebul · v28

    Abimelech's man in charge of the city while Abimelech lived elsewhere (9:30, 41). Gaal names him to say that Shechem is being run by a stand-in for an absentee king.

  13. פְּקִידוֹ

    pəqîḏô · H6496

    his overseer · v28

    An appointed official, someone put in charge by a superior: here the governor installed by Abimelech (called 'ruler of the city' in 9:30). The point is that Zebul is Abimelech's appointee, not a local leader.

  14. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    (object marker) · v28, v29

    Untranslatable marker showing that 'the men of Hamor' is the object of 'serve'.

  15. אַנְשֵׁי

    ʾanšê · H0582

    men of · v28

    'Men of Hamor' means the people or clan belonging to Hamor: his descendants and followers, Shechem's old aristocracy.

  16. חֲמוֹר

    ḥămôr · H2544

    Hamor · v28

    The Hivite prince of Shechem in Jacob's time (Gen 33:19; 34:2). The name means 'donkey'. Invoking him appeals to Shechem's ancient, pre-Israelite Canaanite ruling line.

  17. אֲבִי

    ʾăḇî · H0001G

    father of · v28

    'Father of Shechem' presents Hamor as the founding father of the city (and the father of the man Shechem in Gen 34). It sets the true 'father' of Shechem against Abimelech's father, Jerubbaal.

  18. וּמַדּוּעַ

    ûmaddûaʿ · H4069

    and why? · v28

    A protest question: 'So why on earth should…?' It closes the speech by returning to the opening complaint.

  19. אֲנָחְנוּ

    ʾănāḥnû · H0587

    we · v28

    An extra, emphatic 'we' at the very end, already included in the verb: 'why should WE serve him, we of all people?' It sets 'us true Shechemites' against Abimelech and his deputy.

  20. יִתֵּ֜ן

    yitten · H5414

    give · v29

    Literally 'will give'. Together with mi it makes the set wish 'O that…'. Nobody in particular is being asked to give. It is the standard way to say 'I wish'.

  21. הָעָ֤ם

    ha'am · H5971

    the people · v29

    The people of Shechem, and above all the men who could fight. In battle stories 'am often means the men under arms. Gaal wants them as his militia.

  22. הַזֶּה֙

    hazzeh · H2088

    this · v29

    'This people', the crowd standing around him at the festival in v. 27. It points at his listeners and works on them.

  23. בְּיָדִ֔י

    beyadi · H3027

    in my hand · v29

    'In my hand' means under my control or command. Gaal wishes the Shechemites would put themselves under his leadership.

  24. וְאָסִ֖ירָה

    ve'asirah · H5493

    and I will remove · v29

    'Make turn aside', meaning remove or get rid of. The ending is the Hebrew 'let me / I will' form, here giving the result of the wish: 'then I would get rid of…'. It may mean deposing Abimelech or doing away with him altogether.

  25. רַבֶּ֥ה

    rabbeh · H7235

    make many, increase · v29

    A command, 'make many': enlarge your army, gather all the troops you can. It is a taunt: bring as many men as you like, it won't help you.

  26. צְבָאֲךָ֖

    tseva'akha · H6635

    your army, host · v29

    'Your army'. This is the ordinary word for a mustered fighting force, the same word as in the title 'LORD of hosts'.

  27. וָצֵֽאָה׃

    vatse'ah · H3318

    and come out! · v29

    'And come out!', with an extra ending that adds force: 'come on out!' 'Going out' is the usual Hebrew phrase for marching out to battle. This is a challenge to fight in the open field.

The world behind it

The city. Shechem, in the hill country between Mount Gerizim and Mount Ebal, was an old Canaanite city long before Israel. In the Amarna letters of the 14th century BC its ruler Lab'ayu was a troublesome vassal of Egypt. In Genesis it is ruled by Hamor the Hivite (Gen 33–34). In Judges it still has a mixed population and a temple of Baal-berith / El-berith, "lord of the covenant" (8:33; 9:4, 46). Excavations at Tell Balata uncovered a large fortress-temple that many identify with this sanctuary.

How Abimelech came to power. Gideon (Jerubbaal) refused to be king (8:22–23), but his son Abimelech, born to a Shechemite concubine (8:31), persuaded the "lords of Shechem" to back him because of his mother's family. Paid with silver from Baal-berith's temple, he murdered his seventy half-brothers "on one stone" (9:5) and was crowned beside the sacred oak (9:6). Jotham, the one survivor, cursed the deal (9:7–21). After three years "God sent an evil spirit between Abimelech and the lords of Shechem" (9:23). Abimelech lived away at Arumah (9:41) and governed Shechem through his appointee Zebul.

The festival. Verse 27 sets the speech at the grape harvest. People trod grapes, held a hillulim, a festival of praise and thanksgiving, in "the house of their god", ate, drank and cursed Abimelech. Harvest feasts were times of wine, boasting and loosened tongues. That is the setting for Gaal's speech: rousing words given under the influence.

Kinship as politics. In this world, who your father was decided your claim to rule. Abimelech had campaigned on his maternal blood. Gaal counters with paternal blood (son of the Israelite Jerubbaal) and ancestral blood (the house of Hamor, the city's founding father). This is ethnic and clan politics: Canaanite Shechem against an Israelite strongman.

From the study of Judges 9:28.

Where scholars differ

in v28

What does 'and who is Shechem?' mean?

  • 'Shechem' stands for the city and its people: 'What has Shechem come to, that we should serve him?'

    Cities are often personified in Hebrew. But it is awkward that Gaal then says 'we', as if Shechem were the one being served.

  • It refers to Abimelech's claimed Shechemite identity: 'Who is this so-called Shechemite?'

    Fits Gaal's attack on Abimelech's pedigree and his reversal of 9:2 ('I am your bone and flesh'). The NLT reads it this way.

  • Read 'son of Shechem' with the Septuagint, or take 'Shechem' as the city's founder (Hamor's son), contrasted with Abimelech.

    The Greek has 'son of Shechem'. The verse goes on to mention 'Hamor, father of Shechem', which supports a reference to the eponymous ancestor.

  • Some suggest 'Shechem' here refers to Zebul as Abimelech's representative in the city.

    Zebul is named in the next line, but there is no direct textual support for calling him 'Shechem'; a minority view.

in v28

Is 'serve the men of Hamor' a command or a statement about the past?

  • Command (standard Hebrew vowels): Gaal urges Shechem to give allegiance to its ancient native clan instead of Abimelech.

    Received Masoretic vowels; followed by KJV, ESV, NIV, NASB, BSB. Fits a rabble-rousing speech.

  • Statement: 'Did not the son of Jerubbaal and Zebul serve the men of Hamor?', i.e. they were once subjects themselves.

    Same consonants vowelled differently; adopted by RSV/NRSV and several critical commentators. Makes the final 'why should we serve him?' follow smoothly.

in v28

Is 'Gaal son of Ebed' a real name or a mocking label?

  • Ordinary names: Ebed is attested as a personal name (Ezra 8:6), and Gaal need not be negative.

    Names built on 'servant' (often 'servant of [a god]', shortened) are common in the ancient Near East.

  • The storyteller chose or shaped the names ironically: 'Loathing, son of Servant'.

    Judges likes meaningful names (Jerubbaal, Abimelech 'my father is king'). The play on ʿeḇed and the threefold 'serve' is very pointed. The Greek manuscripts' disagreement over the father's name suggests early uncertainty.

in v28

Do the 'men/sons of Hamor' reflect a 'donkey covenant' league?

  • Yes: 'sons of the donkey' meant members of a treaty confederation, matching Shechem's god Baal-berith, 'lord of the covenant'.

    Mari texts speak of 'killing a donkey foal' to make a treaty. Proposed by Albright and followed by Boling and others.

  • No firm evidence: Hamor is simply the personal name of Shechem's legendary ruler.

    The Bible itself presents Hamor as an individual prince (Gen 33–34). The donkey-treaty link is suggestive but cannot be proved.

in v29

Who speaks the last line, and how is Abimelech addressed when he is not present?

  • Follow the Greek reading 'and I would say': the challenge is part of Gaal's imagined scenario.

    The Septuagint has καὶ ἐρῶ. The Hebrew needs only a one-letter change. It makes the verse one continuous boast and explains how an absent king could be addressed. Adopted by ESV, NIV, BSB and NRSV, and favoured by many critical commentators.

  • Keep the Hebrew 'and he said': Gaal shouts a taunt at Abimelech as if he were there.

    The Hebrew is the harder reading, and scribes tend to smooth hard readings, not create them. Public taunts at absent enemies suit a drunken festival scene. Kept by KJV, NASB, WEB and YLT, and defended by commentators who prefer to keep the received text.

  • Keep the Hebrew but read it as words that reached Abimelech, or words spoken about him.

    The Vulgate's impersonal rendering ('it was said to Abimelech'). Verse 31 has Zebul send messengers who report the speech, so the challenge did in fact 'get said' to Abimelech. Le- can sometimes mean 'concerning'.

in v29

Does 'remove' mean depose or kill?

  • Depose: drive Abimelech out of power over Shechem.

    The causative of sur is used for removing a person from office (1 Kgs 15:13, the queen mother removed). Gaal's argument in v. 28 is about whom Shechem should 'serve'.

  • Get rid of him entirely, by violence if necessary.

    The verb also covers removing a head (1 Sam 17:46), and the chapter's politics are bloody (9:5). The dare to come out and fight implies a battle to the death.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. עָבַד, פָּקִיד, גַּעַל
  • HALOT s.v. עבד, פָּקִיד, חֲמוֹר
  • G. F. Moore, Judges (ICC, 1895), on 9:28
  • R. G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible 6A, 1975)
  • D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary, 1999)
  • B. G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT, 2012)
  • T. C. Butler, Judges (Word Biblical Commentary 8, 2009)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 9
  • Rahlfs-Hanhart Septuaginta, Judges (A and B texts)
  • G. E. Wright, Shechem: The Biography of a Biblical City (1965)
  • Amarna letters (EA 252–254, Lab'ayu of Shechem)
  • BDB s.v. מִי (mî yittēn as a wish formula)
  • HALOT s.v. נתן and s.v. סור (hiphil)
  • Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew §163d (wishes with mî yittēn)
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar §151 (wish clauses)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Judges 9:29
  • Vulgate, Judges 9:29
  • G. F. Moore, Judges (ICC, 1895)
  • R. G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
  • D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary)
  • T. C. Butler, Judges (Word Biblical Commentary)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.