Micah Chapter 6 Read as one passage

Micah 6:11–12

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

11Can I excuse dishonest scales or bags of false weights? 12For the wealthy of the city are full of violence, and its residents speak lies; their tongues are deceitful in their mouths.

What the first hearers heard

To Micah's hearers, Jerusalem's traders and the farmers and buyers who dealt with them, this was a charge with evidence attached. The city's wealth was "treasure of wickedness" (v.10) because it had been weighed out on rigged scales.

The question "Can I be clean?" pulls apart worship and commerce. Temple offerings (compare 6:6–7, "thousands of rams") could not make clean someone who went back to the market with a light stone in his bag. A commercial habit everyone knew about, hard to prove and easy to excuse, was treated as covenant breach and brought before God's court. God himself would check the merchant's pouch.

For the poor, who lost a little silver on every purchase, it was a promise that the cheating had been seen. For the rich it announced a sentence: v.13 begins "Therefore I have struck you", and vv.14–15 describe eating without being satisfied and sowing without reaping. The punishment fits the crime, since those who shorted others will themselves come up short.

From the study of Micah 6:11.

Verse by verse

  1. 11Can I excuse dishonest scales or bags of false weights?

    "Can I come out clean, not guilty, while using scales that make me guilty, with a pouch full of stone weights carved to cheat?"

    The question expects the answer No. It is spoken in God's court of judgment over "the city", which is Jerusalem (v.9). In the market a trader weighed silver against small marked stones that he carried in his own bag. If he kept one set heavy for buying and another light for selling (the "large and small stone" banned in Deuteronomy 25:13), he could cheat every customer without anyone seeing it.

    Micah calls these "scales of wickedness", the deliberate opposite of the "scales of righteousness" that the covenant law requires (Leviticus 19:36). The word translated "wickedness" means being in the wrong, the guilty party in a lawsuit. So the crooked scale is itself the evidence against its owner, and no one holding it can be declared innocent.

    The Hebrew can be heard two ways. As it stands it reads "Can I be clean?". That may be the cheat's own question thrown back at him, or God asking whether he could remain just and still let this pass. With different vowels it reads "Can I acquit?", which is God as judge refusing to pronounce the merchant clear. Either way the verdict is the same.

    The surrounding lines tie the pieces together. The "treasures of wickedness" in v.10 were filled by the "scales of wickedness" in v.11, and the "stones of deceit" match the "tongue of deceit" in v.12. In the merchant the fraud and the lie are the same thing.

    Full study →
  2. 12For the wealthy of the city are full of violence, and its residents speak lies; their tongues are deceitful in their mouths.

    Because (the city's) rich are crammed full of ruthless wrongdoing, the kind of violence done with rigged scales, land grabs and crooked courts as much as with fists, and her residents have made lying their way of speaking, their tongue is nothing but treachery, lodged right there in their mouths.

    The verse belongs to God's case against "the city" (v. 9), Jerusalem. It moves from the top of society to everyone. The rich are "full" of ḥāmās. That word covers bloodshed, but also robbery by fraud and false testimony. Coming straight after the false scales and weights of v. 11, it means the powerful are doing violence through their business. The residents in general "have spoken falsehood". This is the lying that makes the cheating work: false oaths at market, false witness at the city gate, comforting lies from prophets. Then comes the sharpest picture. Their tongue is deceit, and it sits in their mouth, the source of every word. The word for "deceit" comes from the same root as the "fraud" of the weights in v. 11. A merchant's crooked stone and a citizen's crooked tongue are the same sin in two forms. The phrase "full of violence" recalls the world before the flood (Gen 6:11). That sets up the next verse, where God announces that he is striking the city.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v11

    count them pure (KJV); reckon it pure (YLT)

    zākāh

    What we hear
    Moral or sexual spotlessness, or ritual cleanness, as in 'a pure heart'.
    What they heard
    Being in the clear or innocent before a judge, or (on the alternative vowelling) being declared not guilty. It is courtroom language.
  • in v11

    wicked balances (KJV)

    reshaʿ

    What we hear
    Something sinister or monstrously evil, or, as slang, 'awesome'.
    What they heard
    Scales that put their owner in the wrong, i.e. fraudulent scales. Reshaʿ is the guilt of the guilty party in a lawsuit, and the phrase is the deliberate opposite of the 'scales of righteousness' in Lev 19:36.
  • in v12

    full of violence

    mālʾû ḥāmās

    What we hear
    The rich are physically brutal: assault, bloodshed, armed force.
    What they heard
    The rich are saturated with ruthless wrongdoing against others. That includes physical violence, but here, right after the false scales of v. 11, it chiefly means robbery by fraud, extortion, land seizure and corrupt or perjured legal proceedings. Hebrew counts these as violence.
Every word
  1. הַאֶזְכֶּה

    ha'ezkeh · H2135

    to be clean, pure, innocent · v11

    The prefix ha- turns the sentence into a question that expects the answer 'No!'. The verb as vowelled means 'Can I be clean / in the clear?' in the sense of legal innocence, not ritual washing. Many read it as 'Can I pronounce clean / acquit?' (see textual notes).

  2. בְּמֹאזְנֵי

    bəmōʾznê · H3976

    balance, pair of scales · v11

    The word has a 'pair' ending: a beam with two pans, the trader's basic tool. The prefix bə- means 'with', so either 'while using' or 'despite' such scales.

  3. רֶשַׁע

    reshaʿ · H7562

    wickedness, guilt, wrongdoing · v11

    It describes the scales: 'scales of wickedness', meaning scales that put their owner in the wrong. It is the exact opposite of the 'scales of righteousness' that Leviticus 19:36 requires. It repeats the word from v.10, 'treasures of wickedness'.

  4. וּבְכִיס

    ūvəkhîs · H3599

    bag, pouch, purse · v11

    'And with a bag': the pouch in which a merchant carried his stone weights. Deuteronomy 25:13 warns against keeping two different weights in it.

  5. אַבְנֵי

    ʾavnê · H68

    stone; (stone) weight · v11

    Literally 'stones'. In Judah weights were small carved stones, often limestone, marked with their value, and silver was weighed against them on the scales.

  6. מִרְמָה

    mirmāh · H4820

    deceit, fraud, treachery · v11

    'Stones of deceit': weights deliberately made off-standard so as to cheat. Its root comes back in v.12, 'their tongue is deceit (rəmiyyāh)', which ties fraud in the market to lying in speech.

  7. אֲשֶׁ֤ר

    ʾăšer · H0834A

    which, who; because · v12

    A connecting word that can mean 'whose' (pointing back to 'the city' of v. 9) or 'because/for' (giving the reason for the judgment in v. 13). Its exact link here is debated; most English versions take it as 'for'.

  8. עֲשִׁירֶ֙יהָ֙

    ʿăšîrêhā · H6223

    rich, wealthy (person) · v12

    'Her rich ones': the wealthy class of the city. In the prophets this is the group with the money and influence to control markets, land and courts, and so the group able to oppress.

  9. מָלְא֣וּ

    mālʾû · H4390

    to be full, to fill · v12

    'Are full (of)': a settled condition, not a single act. The rich are packed to the brim with ḥāmās, the same language used of the earth before the flood (Gen 6:11, 13) and of corrupt trading cities (Ezek 28:16).

  10. חָמָ֔ס

    ḥāmās · H2555

    violence, wrong, injustice · v12

    Not only physical brutality: ḥāmās is ruthless wrongdoing against others, including robbery by fraud, rigged trade and perjury in court. Coming right after the false scales of v. 11, it names the violence of crooked business.

  11. וְיֹשְׁבֶ֖יהָ

    wəyōšəbêhā · H3427

    to sit, dwell; (participle) inhabitant · v12

    'And her inhabitants', literally 'those who sit/dwell in her'. The accusation widens from the rich to the city's residents generally: the lying is not confined to the elite.

  12. דִּבְּרוּ־

    dibbərû · H1696G

    to speak · v12

    'Have spoken': the Hebrew form presents the speaking as an established fact, which can be rendered as an ongoing habit ('speak') or a record ('have spoken').

  13. שָׁ֑קֶר

    šāqer · H8267

    falsehood, lie, deception · v12

    'Falsehood': speech that betrays the trust placed in it, the word used for false testimony in court (Exod 20:16) and false prophecy (Mic 2:11). Here it is the lying that props up cheating in trade and law.

  14. וּלְשׁוֹנָ֖ם

    ûləšônām · H3956G

    tongue; language · v12

    'And their tongue': the organ of speech, standing for what people say. The pronoun switches from 'her' (the city) to 'their' (the people themselves).

  15. רְמִיָּ֥ה

    rəmiyyâ · H7423A

    deceit, treachery · v12

    '[Is] deceit': the tongue is not just sometimes deceitful, it *is* deceit. The word comes from the same root as mirmâ, 'fraud', in v. 11's 'bag of fraudulent weights', so lying speech and lying weights are tied together.

  16. בְּפִיהֶֽם׃

    bəpîhem · H6310G

    mouth · v12

    'In their mouth': a bodily picture. Deceit sits right inside the mouth, where every word starts; nothing they say comes out clean.

The world behind it

Weighing, not coins. In Micah's Judah (late 8th century BCE) there was no coined money. Payment meant weighing out pieces of silver on a two-pan balance against stone weights, and grain was measured in an ephah, a dry-measure basket or container (v.10's "short ephah"). The merchant owned both the scales and the weights. The buyer had to trust them, and archaeologists have found that inscribed Judean weights from this period often differ from their stated values.

Law and wisdom on weights. Israel's law made honest weights a covenant matter (Lev 19:35–36; Deut 25:13–16, where dishonest weights are "an abomination to the LORD"). The wisdom tradition said the same (Prov 11:1; 16:11; 20:10, 23). Micah's contemporaries Amos (8:5) and Hosea (12:7) attack the same practice.

The lawsuit. Micah 6:1–8 is a covenant lawsuit in which God brings his people to court and sums up what he requires: "to do justice, to love loyal kindness, and to walk humbly with your God" (6:8). In vv.9–16 the case moves from principle to evidence. Here are the city's rich men, their scales and their weights, and the sentence follows (vv.13–16).

From the study of Micah 6:11.

Where scholars differ

in v11

Should the verb be read 'Can I be clean?' (as vowelled) or 'Can I acquit?' (re-vowelled)?

  • Keep the vowelled Hebrew: 'Can I be clean/innocent with wicked scales?'

    It is the received text and the harder reading, and copyists tend to smooth a hard reading rather than create one. It can be understood as the cheat's rhetorical question, or as God asking whether he could stay just and tolerate this. The supplied morphology also reads Qal.

  • Re-vowel to the intensive form: 'Can I acquit / declare clean?'

    It fits God as the speaker of vv.9–16 more smoothly. It is supported by the Vulgate's 'iustificabo' and the Septuagint's verdict sense ('be justified'), and it needs no change to the consonants. Most modern English versions adopt it.

in v11

Who is the 'I' of the question?

  • God, the judge of the city.

    God is the voice addressing the city from v.9, and v.13 continues in his first person ('I have struck you').

  • A representative inhabitant or merchant whose own question is quoted back at him.

    This is possible if the Qal is kept ('can I be innocent?'). The prophets sometimes voice the people's own words, as Micah does in 6:6–7.

in v12

How does the opening word ʾăšer connect the verse to its context?

  • Causal: 'For/Because her rich are full of violence…', giving the grounds for the judgment announced in v. 13.

    ʾăšer can function causally in Biblical Hebrew (BDB lists 'because' among its uses); the sequence charge (v. 12) → sentence (v. 13, 'and I also…') fits a judgment speech. Followed by KJV, BSB and many others.

  • Relative: 'whose rich are full of violence…', referring back to 'the city' of v. 9.

    This is ʾăšer's most common use and the feminine suffixes ('her rich', 'her inhabitants') require a feminine antecedent, which is 'the city' (ʿîr) in v. 9. Kept by YLT; often paired with the proposal that v. 12 originally followed v. 9 directly.

  • Textual rearrangement: v. 12 has been displaced and belongs after v. 9 (or before v. 10).

    Proposed by a number of critical commentators to resolve the distant antecedent; there is no manuscript support, so others prefer to read the MT order as a loosely connected prophetic speech.

in v12

Who are 'her inhabitants' (yōšəbêhā)?

  • The general population of the city, widening the charge from the rich to everyone.

    The normal meaning of the participle of yāšab with a city ('those who dwell in her'); fits the prophetic pattern of corruption spreading through society (Jer 5:1–5; 9:2–6).

  • The ruling class, 'those who sit (enthroned/in office)' in the city, in parallel with 'her rich'.

    yōšēb can mean 'ruler, the one enthroned' (e.g. Amos 1:5, 8), and the verse's parallel lines might name two elite groups. This is a minority reading; the context does not require it.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. זָכָה, מֹאזְנַיִם, רֶשַׁע, כִּיס, אֶבֶן, מִרְמָה
  • HALOT s.v. זכה
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus at Mic 6:10–11
  • Septuagint, Micah 6:11 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Michaeas 6:11
  • Leviticus 19:35–36; Deuteronomy 25:13–16; Proverbs 11:1; 16:11; 20:10, 23; Hosea 12:7; Amos 8:5
  • Archaeological studies of inscribed Judean stone weights (late Iron Age II), e.g. R. Kletter, Economic Keystones: The Weight System of the Kingdom of Judah (1998)
  • BDB s.v. חָמָס, שֶׁקֶר, רְמִיָּה, אֲשֶׁר
  • HALOT s.v. חָמָס; s.v. רְמִיָּה I and II
  • TDOT s.v. חָמָס (H. Haag)
  • D. R. Hillers, Micah (Hermeneia)
  • F. I. Andersen & D. N. Freedman, Micah (Anchor Bible)
  • B. K. Waltke, A Commentary on Micah
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament (Micah 6)
  • R. Kletter, Economic Keystones: The Weight System of the Kingdom of Judah

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).