Proverbs Chapter 31 Read as one passage
Proverbs 31:2–3
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
2What shall I say, O my son? What, O son of my womb? What, O son of my vows? 3Do not spend your strength on women or your vigor on those who ruin kings.
What the first hearers heard
Israelite readers of Proverbs heard a royal woman's voice, probably a foreign one, given a place among Israel's wisdom. The verse does not instruct yet. It sets up the authority for the instruction that follows. With three escalating names (son, son of my womb, son of my vows) the mother claims the king's attention on three grounds: affection, the fact that she bore him, and the vow she made to God for him.
For an audience who knew Hannah's story and the seriousness of vows, "son of my vows" meant this king did not belong only to himself. A ruler whose very existence answered a promise made to God owes it to that promise not to squander his strength on a harem or his judgment on drink (vv. 3–7). He must instead speak up for the voiceless and the poor (vv. 8–9). The verse frames kingship as a trust received through a mother's prayer, not as a right. In Proverbs' larger picture it also prepares for the chapter's closing portrait of the capable woman (vv. 10–31). The book that opens with a father's instruction ends with a woman's wisdom.
From the study of Proverbs 31:2.
Verse by verse
-
2What shall I say, O my son? What, O son of my womb? What, O son of my vows?
Full study →The verse is three cries of address that build on each other. The mother calls out to her son, who is a king, three times before giving any instruction, and each time she names more of what ties her to him:
"What, my son? What, son I carried in my own body? What, son I vowed for, whose life I promised to God?"
The repeated "What…?" has no verb. It is the sound of a mother gathering herself: what shall I say to you?, and possibly also what are you doing? The three names climb. My son is the ordinary loving address of a teacher or parent. Son of my womb reminds him that she bore him, the bond that gives a royal mother her standing. Son of my vows goes furthest: he is the child she made a solemn promise to God for (compare Hannah in 1 Samuel 1). His life, and his throne, are already committed to God.
Throughout she uses the Aramaic word for "son" (bar) rather than the normal Hebrew one, which gives her voice a foreign, perhaps northern Arabian, sound. She is a queen mother from beyond Israel whose wisdom Proverbs keeps. Everything she then says about women, wine and justice for the poor (vv. 3–9) carries the weight of these three claims on him.
-
3Do not spend your strength on women or your vigor on those who ruin kings.
Full study →A queen mother speaks to her son the king, and the first thing she says is an urgent, personal "Don't!" — not the language of law, but of a mother who knows the court.
"Don't hand over your power to the women, and don't hand over the course of your life to what wipes kings off the map."
- "Your strength" is ḥayil: your vigor, yes, including sexual vigor, but also your wealth, your resources, your competence, even your army. Everything that makes a king a king.
- "The women" are the king's women: the harem of wives and concubines that ancient kings collected for pleasure, prestige and political alliances. Feeding that appetite drains a ruler's energy, his treasury and his attention, and puts his decisions in the hands of rival wives, their families and their factions.
- "Your ways" is the whole direction of your life and reign (with a possible hint of sexual conduct, as in Prov 30:19–20).
- "Wiping out" is the word for erasing, as the flood erased life or a name is blotted from a record. Kings who go this way don't just lose ground. Their name and line get erased.
The next verses add the second classic royal vice, drink (vv. 4–7), and then say what a king's strength is for: speaking up for those who cannot speak, and judging the poor and needy fairly (vv. 8–9). And the chapter ends with a deliberate echo: the king must not give his ḥayil to "the women," but a "woman of ḥayil" (v. 10), a woman of strength and worth, is beyond price.
Where the English drifted
-
in v2
son of my vows
bar-nĕdārāy
- What we hear
- Wedding vows, so 'the son born of my marriage'.
- What they heard
- A child connected with a solemn promise made to God, either a child prayed for under a vow or a child dedicated to God by vow, as Hannah did with Samuel.
-
in v2
What, my son?
mah-bĕrî
- What we hear
- An impatient or puzzled 'What do you want?', as if she is answering a question from the son.
- What they heard
- An emotional opener with the verb left out: 'What shall I say to you?' or 'What are you doing?', building urgency before her instruction.
-
in v3
strength
ḥayil
- What we hear
- Physical energy or stamina, often heard here as purely sexual energy.
- What they heard
- Power in every form a king has: vigor, but also wealth, resources, competence and military force. The warning covers his treasury and capacity to rule as much as his body.
-
in v3
ways
derakhim
- What we hear
- Habits, methods or manners — something minor.
- What they heard
- The road one's whole life travels: one's conduct and the direction of one's reign, possibly with a sexual overtone (cf. Prov 30:19–20).
Every word
-
מַה־
mah · H4100
what? · v2
Opens the mother's speech with a bare 'What…?' that has no verb. It works as an emotional opener, either 'What shall I say to you?' or 'What are you doing?', and it gets the son's full attention before the warnings of verses 3–9.
-
בְּ֭רִי
bĕrî · H1121A
my son · v2
'My son', but spelled with the Aramaic word *bar* instead of the usual Hebrew *ben* (Aramaic was a sister language of Hebrew). It is the standard tender address of a teacher or parent in wisdom instruction, and here it comes from the mother.
-
בִּטְנִ֑י
biṭnî · H0990H
my womb, belly · v2
'My womb' (literally 'my belly'). She reminds the king that she carried and bore him, and that bodily bond gives her the right to speak to him with authority.
-
נְדָרָֽי׃
nĕdārāy · H5088
my vows · v2
'My vows': solemn promises made to God, usually in the form 'If you give me X, I will do Y.' She is saying he is the child she prayed and bargained with God for, or the child she promised to God. His life belongs to God, not just to her, and so does his kingship.
-
אַל־
ʾal · H408
not, do not · v3
The negative used for urgent, face-to-face prohibitions ("don't!"), not the negative of permanent law (lōʾ, as in "you shall not"). It sets the tone of a mother pleading with her son rather than a legal code.
-
תִּתֵּ֣ן
tittēn · H5414
give · v3
"Give, hand over." The verb governs both halves of the verse: do not give your strength … and do not give your ways. The picture is of surrendering something you own and control into someone else's hands.
-
לַנָּשִׁ֣ים
lannāšîm · H802
woman, wife · v3
"To the women": plural and with the article. In a royal setting this points to the king's women, the harem of wives and concubines that kings accumulated, not to women as a class.
-
חֵילֶ֑ךָ
ḥêlekā · H2428
strength, wealth, army, capability · v3
"Your strength" in the widest sense: physical and sexual vigor, but also your wealth, your resources, your capacity to act, even your army. For a king these are all one thing: his power. The same word returns in v. 10, "a woman of ḥayil."
-
וּ֝דְרָכֶ֗יךָ
ūdərākêkā · H1870
way, road, conduct, course of life · v3
"And your ways": the direction and conduct of your life, your whole course of action. Proverbs 30:19–20 uses "way" of sexual conduct, so a sexual overtone is possible here, though the main sense is the king's life and rule.
-
לַֽמְח֥וֹת
lamḥôt · H4229
wipe out, blot out, erase · v3
"To the wiping out of": a strong verb used of the flood wiping out life (Gen 6:7) and of blotting a name from a record. Kings are not merely weakened but erased: their dynasty and memory blotted out.
-
מְלָכִֽין׃
məlākîn · H4428
king · v3
"Kings", spelled with the Aramaic-style plural ending -în instead of the usual Hebrew -îm. Together with "bar" (son) in v. 2, it gives the speech a foreign, non-Israelite colour, which fits a queen mother from Massa.
The world behind it
A queen mother instructs a king. Verse 1 calls this "the words of Lemuel, king, a massa [burden/oracle, or the place-name Massa] that his mother taught him." In the ancient Near East and in Judah the king's mother (Hebrew gĕbîrâ, "great lady") often held real influence at court. Bathsheba sits at Solomon's right hand (1 Kgs 2:19), and the books of Kings regularly name the mother of each king of Judah. Wisdom literature almost always shows a father teaching a son. Advice from a mother to a son is rare across the ancient Near East, which makes this passage stand out, though Proverbs 1:8 and 6:20 already tell the son not to forsake "your mother's teaching."
Vows for children. Asking God for a child and promising something in return was a familiar practice. Hannah's vow (1 Sam 1:11) is the classic example. Numbers 30 regulates women's vows, which shows they were common. A child born after such a vow was understood as owed in some sense to God.
Massa and the Aramaic coloring. If massa in verse 1 is a place-name, as many scholars think, Lemuel ruled an Ishmaelite tribe in northern Arabia (Gen 25:14; 1 Chr 1:30). The Aramaic word bar here and the Aramaic-style plural mĕlākîn in verse 3 fit a non-Israelite setting. Jewish tradition instead identified Lemuel with Solomon and his mother with Bathsheba (b. Sanhedrin 70b), but that is a later reading.
From the study of Proverbs 31:2.
Where scholars differ
in v2
What does the repeated, verbless 'What…?' (mah) mean?
-
Hesitation or emotion: 'What shall I say?' The mother searches for words before giving solemn instruction.
Verbless questions can carry strong feeling. BSB and many commentators supply 'say'. It fits the affectionate tone of the three names.
-
Reproach: 'What are you doing, my son?'
The verses that follow warn against women and wine, which suggests the king is already in danger. Talmudic tradition (b. Sanhedrin 70b) read it as a rebuke. ESV follows this.
-
A call for attention or an exclamation: 'Listen!' or 'Oh!'
*Mah* is used in exclamations (Ps 8:1). Some compare uses in other Semitic languages. NIV, WEB and NLT follow this, though the comparative evidence for 'Listen!' is thin.
in v2
Who are Lemuel and his mother, and is 'Massa' a place?
-
A non-Israelite king of Massa, an Ishmaelite tribe in northern Arabia.
Massa appears among Ishmael's sons (Gen 25:14). Proverbs 30:1 may also use Massa as a place-name. The Aramaic forms *bar* (v. 2) and *mĕlākîn* (v. 3) point to a non-Israelite dialect.
-
'Massa' means 'oracle' or 'burden', and Lemuel is an Israelite king or an ideal figure, traditionally Solomon.
*Massa* is a common word for a prophetic burden or oracle. Jewish tradition identified Lemuel with Solomon and the mother with Bathsheba. The Aramaic forms could be poetic colour.
in v2
What exactly does 'son of my vows' mean?
-
A child she vowed for before he was conceived: the answer to a conditional vow.
Vows usually took the form 'If God gives…, I will…'. Compare Hannah (1 Sam 1:11) and Kirta at Ugarit.
-
A child she dedicated to God by vow, or over whom she made vows after birth.
Hannah's vow also dedicated Samuel to God for life. Talmudic tradition has the mother vowing about the kind of son he would be.
in v3
Does "your ways" stand, or should it be "your loins"?
-
Keep "your ways" (Masoretic text).
All Hebrew manuscripts read it; ancient versions reflect a word other than "loins"; derekh can carry sexual connotation (Prov 30:19–20) and also fits the broader point of surrendering the direction of one's reign.
-
Emend to "your loins" (yerekhekha) or translate as "vigor."
Gives a tighter parallel with ḥayil and matches the sexual focus of "women"; BSB and NIV's "vigor" reflects this kind of reading. But it is conjectural.
in v3
Who or what "wipes out kings"?
-
An abstract: "that which destroys kings" — the whole harem lifestyle (Masoretic pointing as infinitive).
Hebrew vowel pointing as transmitted; followed by KJV, NASB, WEB, YLT.
-
Persons: "those [women] who destroy kings" (re-pointed as participle).
Same consonants; gives a closer match with "the women" in the first line; followed by ESV, NIV, BSB.
in v3
Who were Lemuel and his mother?
-
A non-Israelite king of Massa, an Ishmaelite/north-Arabian tribe.
Massa as a son of Ishmael (Gen 25:14); Aramaic-like forms in vv. 2–3; Proverbs includes other foreign sages (Agur, 30:1).
-
A pseudonym for Solomon, his mother being Bathsheba.
Later Jewish tradition (midrash, followed by Rashi) reads "Lemuel" ("belonging to God") as a name for Solomon; the verse's warning fits Solomon's story. Nothing in the text itself makes this identification.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. נֶדֶר, בַּר, בֶּטֶן, מָה
- Strong's H1248 (bar), H5088 (neder), H990 (beten), H4100 (mah)
- Michael V. Fox, Proverbs 10–31 (Anchor Yale Bible), on 31:1–9
- Bruce K. Waltke, The Book of Proverbs: Chapters 15–31 (NICOT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Proverbs 31:1–9
- Septuagint, Proverbs 31:2 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Proverbs 31:2
- Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 70b
- Sayings of Ahiqar (Aramaic, Elephantine papyri)
- Ugaritic Kirta epic (KTU 1.14–1.16)
- HALOT s.v. חַיִל
- BDB s.v. דֶּרֶךְ
- BDB s.v. מָחָה
- Michael V. Fox, Proverbs 10–31 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- Roland E. Murphy, Proverbs (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus to Prov 31:3
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Proverbs 31:3
- Deuteronomy 17:17; 1 Kings 11:1–13; Nehemiah 13:26
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).