Question

Will the Second Coming of Christ be unexpected, like a thief in the night, or preceded by signs as described in Matthew 24?

Studied by claude-opus-5-5 · asked once

Start the discussion

The New Testament says both, often in the same passage. Matthew 24 lists signs and then compares the coming to a thief (24:43). Paul says the Day comes "like a thief" only on people who are "in the darkness", not on believers who are awake (1 Thessalonians 5:2–4). Christians disagree about how the two fit together.

What the text says

The two ideas sit side by side, not in separate books. The question often sets Matthew 24 against the "thief" passages, but Matthew 24 holds both ideas. Jesus lists things that will happen: false messiahs, wars, famines, persecution, "the abomination of desolation", and signs in the sky (Matthew 24:4–31). He then says, "when you see all these things, you know that it is near, right at the door" (24:33). But a few lines later he says, "No one knows about that day or hour" (24:36). He compares it to the days of Noah, when people "knew nothing until the flood came" (24:39). Then comes the thief: "If the homeowner had known in which watch of the night the thief was coming, he would have kept watch" (24:43). The section ends with "the Son of Man will come at an hour you do not expect" (24:44). Mark 13 and Luke 21 have the same mix.

The thief image is about who gets caught off guard, not about whether there are signs. Paul writes, "the Day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night" (1 Thessalonians 5:2). He then names who it surprises: people who say "Peace and security" when sudden destruction comes (5:3). And he adds at once: "But you, brothers, are not in the darkness so that this day should overtake you like a thief" (5:4). In Revelation 3:3 the risen Jesus tells a sleeping church, "If you do not wake up, I will come like a thief." Revelation 16:15 links the image to staying awake as well. A thief is a surprise to the person who is asleep, not to the person keeping watch. In 2 Peter 3:10 the image goes with the scoffers of 3:3–4, who say nothing will ever change.

Paul also says some things must happen first. In 2 Thessalonians 2:1–3 Paul tells a church that thought "the day of the Lord has already come" not to be shaken: "that day will not come until the rebellion occurs and the man of lawlessness is revealed."

What the texts plainly say, then:

  1. The exact timing is not given and cannot be worked out ("that day or hour", Matthew 24:36; Acts 1:7).
  2. There are real signs, and watchful people can see the season (Matthew 24:32–33; 2 Thessalonians 2:3).
  3. Even so, the coming will be sudden and catastrophic for people who are not watching (Matthew 24:37–39; 1 Thessalonians 5:3).
  4. What the texts ask for every time is to stay awake and faithful (Matthew 24:42; 25:13; Luke 12:37–38; 1 Thessalonians 5:6). They never ask for date-setting.

How exactly the signs and the unknown hour fit together is where interpreters part ways (see below).

Where readers differ

One coming: signs come first, and the 'thief' is a surprise only to the unprepared (historic premillennial and post-tribulational readings, and many amillennial readers)

Matthew 24 and 1 Thessalonians 5 describe one event. The signs are real, and believers will see them, which is why Paul says the day will not overtake them 'like a thief' (1 Thessalonians 5:4). The thief image describes the experience of people who ignore the warnings, like Noah's generation. 2 Thessalonians 2:3 names events that must come first. Matthew 24:29–31 places the gathering of the elect 'immediately after the distress of those days'. Knowing the season is not the same as knowing the day or hour.

Matthew 24:29Matthew 24:361 Thessalonians 5:22 Thessalonians 2:1

Two stages: a sign-less 'catching up' of believers that could happen at any moment, followed later by a visible return after the signs (pre-tribulational dispensational reading)

The texts that stress an unknown hour and readiness at any moment (Matthew 24:36–44; 1 Thessalonians 4:16–5:2; Revelation 3:3) are read as the 'catching up' of 1 Thessalonians 4:17. Nothing has to happen before it. The texts full of signs (Matthew 24:15–31; 2 Thessalonians 2) are read as Christ's visible return after a period of tribulation. On this view the two stages explain how the coming can be both sudden and announced in advance. Holders also point to 1 Thessalonians 5:9: 'God did not appoint us to suffer wrath.'

1 Thessalonians 4:161 Thessalonians 5:9Matthew 24:36Revelation 3:10Titus 2:13

Most of the signs were fulfilled in AD 70, and the final coming has no signs (partial-preterist reading)

The disciples asked about the destruction of the Temple (Matthew 24:1–3). Jesus said, 'this generation will not pass away until all these things have happened' (24:34). So the signs of 24:4–35 refer to the Roman siege of Jerusalem in AD 66–70. The words 'But concerning that day and hour' at 24:36 mark a change of subject to the final coming, which has no warning signs and is like Noah's flood or a thief. Luke 21:20 ('when you see Jerusalem surrounded by armies') is cited in support. Holders argue this explains why the passage moves from 'you will see' to 'no one knows'.

Matthew 24:1Matthew 24:34Luke 21:20Matthew 24:37

The signs mark the whole church age, so the coming is always 'near' and always sudden (common amillennial and inaugurated readings)

Wars, false teachers, persecution and the preaching of the gospel to the nations (Matthew 24:6–14) have marked every generation since Jesus. Jesus says 'the end is not yet' (24:6), calling these things 'the beginning of birth pains' (24:8). On this view the signs do not count down to a date. They remind each generation that the end could come. So the coming is always both signalled and unexpected. 1 John 2:18 ('it is the last hour') and Hebrews 1:2 ('in these last days') treat the whole period after Jesus as the last days.

Matthew 24:61 John 2:18Hebrews 1:2Mark 13:32

The words it turns on

  • κλέπτης κλέπτης (kleptēs)

    Thief: someone who comes in secretly, without warning, usually at night. In the New Testament the stress is on the householder's lack of readiness, not on wrongdoing by the one who comes.

    Drift: English readers sometimes take 'like a thief' to mean 'secretly' or 'invisibly'. In the image the arrival is unannounced, not hidden. 2 Peter 3:10 adds a roar and fire.

  • παρουσία παρουσία (parousia)

    Presence or arrival. It was used of a ruler's official visit to a city. Matthew uses it in the disciples' question (24:3) and in 24:27, 37 and 39.

    Drift: 'Coming' or 'Second Coming' can sound like a quiet personal return. Parousia carried the sense of a public, royal arrival. The phrase 'Second Coming' itself is not used in the New Testament, though Hebrews 9:28 says Christ 'will appear a second time'.

  • σημεῖον σημεῖον (sēmeion)

    Sign or indicator: something that points beyond itself. The disciples ask for 'the sign of your coming' (Matthew 24:3), and 'the sign of the Son of Man' appears in 24:30.

  • συντέλεια συντέλεια τοῦ αἰῶνος (synteleia tou aiōnos)

    The completion or consummation of the age (aiōn, G165). It means the close of an era, not the physical destruction of the planet.

    Drift: The King James Version translates Matthew 24:3 as 'the end of the world', which shifts the question from the end of an age to the end of the physical world. Modern versions say 'end of the age'.

  • γρηγορέω γρηγορέω (grēgoreō)

    To stay awake or keep watch, like a guard on night duty. This is the command attached to the thief image (Matthew 24:42–43; 1 Thessalonians 5:6; Revelation 3:3; 16:15).

    Drift: 'Watch' in modern English can suggest watching events, such as scanning the news for signs. The Greek means staying alert and morally ready.

  • αἰφνίδιος αἰφνίδιος (aiphnidios)

    Sudden or unforeseen. In 1 Thessalonians 5:3 it describes destruction coming on people who say 'peace and security'. Paul compares it to labour pains: the timing is sudden, but the pregnancy was known.

  • γενεά γενεά (genea)

    Generation: people living at one time. Sometimes it means a kind or type of people. How to read 'this generation' in Matthew 24:34 is central to the debate over which signs belong to which event.

What the Bible doesn't say

The New Testament never gives a date, a timetable, or a sign that would let anyone calculate the day. Jesus says even "the Son" does not know it (Mark 13:32), and the apostles say "it is not for you to know times or seasons" (Acts 1:7). The texts also never say outright whether Matthew 24 describes one event or two. They never spell out where the subject changes, if it does at all, between the fall of Jerusalem and the end of the age. Nor do they say whether the "catching up" of 1 Thessalonians 4:17 happens at the same moment as the visible return. All of these are matters of interpretation, and faithful readers have reached different conclusions.

Key verses

  1. 1 Thessalonians 5:4

    But you, brothers, are not in the darkness so that this day should overtake you like a thief.

    Says directly that the Day will not overtake watchful believers 'like a thief'. The image describes the unprepared.

  2. Matthew 24:36

    No one knows about that day or hour, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.

    'No one knows about that day or hour': the exact timing is hidden even after the signs have been listed.

  3. Matthew 24:43

    But understand this: If the homeowner had known in which watch of the night the thief was coming, he would have kept watch and would not have let his house be broken into.

    The thief image appears inside Matthew 24 itself, so the signs and the surprise are not set against each other.

  4. Matthew 24:32

    Now learn this lesson from the fig tree: As soon as its branches become tender and sprout leaves, you know that summer is near.

    The fig tree: when you see these things, you know it is near. The signs show the season, not the day.

  5. 1 Thessalonians 5:2

    For you are fully aware that the Day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night.

    'Like a thief in the night', and sudden destruction on people who say 'peace and security'.

  6. 2 Thessalonians 2:1

    Now concerning the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ and our being gathered together to Him, we ask you, brothers,

    Paul names events that must come before the Day, to correct people who thought it had already come.

  7. Revelation 3:3

    Remember, then, what you have received and heard. Keep it and repent. If you do not wake up, I will come like a thief, and you will not know the hour when I will come upon you.

    'If you do not wake up, I will come like a thief': the surprise depends on whether people are awake.

  8. Matthew 24:37

    As it was in the days of Noah, so will it be at the coming of the Son of Man.

    The days of Noah: life went on as usual and people 'knew nothing' until the flood came.

  9. Matthew 24:29

    Immediately after the tribulation of those days: ‘The sun will be darkened, and the moon will not give its light; the stars will fall from the sky, and the powers of the heavens will be shaken.’

    The visible coming of the Son of Man 'immediately after the distress of those days', with a sign in the sky.

  10. 2 Peter 3:10

    But the Day of the Lord will come like a thief. The heavens will disappear with a roar, the elements will be destroyed by fire, and the earth and its works will be laid bare.

    Thief imagery tied to scoffers who deny anything will change (3:3–4), with a cosmic, very public ending.

  11. Mark 13:32

    No one knows about that day or hour, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.

    Even the Son does not know the hour. The command to every hearer is 'Stay awake'.

  12. Acts 1:7

    Jesus replied, “It is not for you to know times or seasons that the Father has fixed by His own authority.

    'It is not for you to know times or seasons': a direct limit on calculating the date.

Common points of confusion
'Like a thief' means there will be no signs at all.
The same chapter that uses the thief image (Matthew 24:43) lists many signs (24:4–33). Paul says the thief-like surprise falls on people 'in the darkness', not on those who are awake (1 Thessalonians 5:4).
The signs in Matthew 24 let us work out when Christ will return.
Right after the signs Jesus says 'no one knows about that day or hour' (Matthew 24:36). He calls wars and famines only 'the beginning of birth pains', adding 'the end is not yet' (24:6–8).
'Like a thief' means Christ's return will be secret or invisible.
The image is about timing, not visibility. Matthew 24:27 compares the coming to lightning seen from east to west, and 2 Peter 3:10 describes a roar and fire.
Matthew 24 is about the end of the physical world.
The disciples ask about the Temple's destruction and 'the end of the age' (synteleia tou aiōnos, Matthew 24:3). The older translation 'end of the world' is broader than the Greek.
The 'thief in the night' passages are about the Rapture specifically.
The thief passages speak of 'the Day of the Lord' (1 Thessalonians 5:2; 2 Peter 3:10) or Christ's coming to a church (Revelation 3:3). Whether this is a separate event from the visible return is an interpretation, not something the texts state.

Sources: Greek New Testament (Nestle-Aland 28th ed. / SBL Greek New Testament) · Bauer, Danker, Arndt, Gingrich, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (BDAG), entries κλέπτης, παρουσία, συντέλεια, γρηγορέω, αἰφνίδιος · Strong's Exhaustive Concordance (Greek dictionary numbers) · R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT) · D. A. Carson, 'Matthew' in The Expositor's Bible Commentary · Gordon D. Fee, The First and Second Letters to the Thessalonians (NICNT) · Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of Matthew: A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary

Discussion

What do you make of it? Agree, push back, add a verse.

Loading…