1 Corinthians Chapter 14 Read as one passage
1 Corinthians 14:1–5
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
1Earnestly pursue love and eagerly desire spiritual gifts, especially the gift of prophecy. 2For he who speaks in a tongue does not speak to men, but to God. Indeed, no one understands him; he utters mysteries in the Spirit. 3But he who prophesies speaks to men for their edification, encouragement, and comfort. 4The one who speaks in a tongue edifies himself, but the one who prophesies edifies the church. 5I wish that all of you could speak in tongues, but I would rather have you prophesy. He who prophesies is greater than one who speaks in tongues, unless he interprets so that the church may be edified.
What the first hearers heard
To the Corinthian believers, gathered in a house and proud of their spiritual experiences, this verse did three things.
- It kept chapter 13 from becoming a sermon you admire and then shelve. "Pursue the love" made the portrait of love a standing order for the whole congregation, and it came first.
- It affirmed their zeal and redirected it. Paul did not dismiss the Spirit's manifestations or tell them to stop seeking them. They were to be zealous, but no longer with the envious, status-seeking zeal (3:3; 13:4) that had made tongues a badge of rank. The verb they knew from their rivalries was now pointed at serving others.
- It reordered their ranking. They likely ranked tongues highest. Paul put prophecy first, because a church that could understand what was said could be built up, encouraged and comforted, and an outsider could be convicted and fall down saying "God is truly among you" (14:25).
The verse also set up the argument of chapter 14: everything in worship should be judged by whether it "builds up" (oikodomē, vv. 3–5, 12, 17, 26). For them, love was not a feeling to add on top of worship. It was the rule for how their worship was run.
From the study of 1 Corinthians 14:1.
Verse by verse
-
1Earnestly pursue love and eagerly desire spiritual gifts, especially the gift of prophecy.
Full study →"Keep running after love, the love I have just described. And yes, be passionately eager for what the Spirit does among you. But above all, be eager that you speak God's message in words the others can understand."
The verse hinges between two chapters. Its first command, pursue love, closes the great portrait of love in chapter 13. The verb is a hunter's or a runner's word ("chase"), and "the love" means that love: patient, kind, not envious, not puffed up. Its second command, be zealous for the spiritual things, picks up where 12:31 left off ("be zealous for the greater gifts"). Paul uses a word that can also mean "be jealous". The Corinthians were already zealous, competitively so, and Paul does not tell them to cool down. He tells them to aim that fire at the right target.
"Spiritual things" means the workings of God's Spirit in the gathering. The word "gifts" is added by translators. And among those workings Paul singles out prophesying, which he names as an activity ("that you may prophesy"), not a badge to own. In this chapter prophesying is not chiefly predicting the future. It is Spirit-prompted speech in plain language that builds up, encourages and comforts (14:3), and that can expose what is hidden in a listener's heart (14:24–25). He prefers it to tongues for a reason that comes straight from love: everyone in the room can understand it and be built up by it.
All the verbs are plural. Paul is speaking to the congregation as a body, not handing each believer a private spiritual project. Love and gifts are not rivals. Love is what you chase, and it decides which gifts you should be most eager for.
-
2For he who speaks in a tongue does not speak to men, but to God. Indeed, no one understands him; he utters mysteries in the Spirit.
Full study →Anyone who speaks in a tongue is not talking to the people around him. He is talking to God. None of them can follow what he says. Moved by the Spirit (or "in his spirit"), he is speaking secrets: things that belong to God and stay hidden from everyone listening, because nothing has opened them up.
Paul repeats the plain verb "speak" three times. Real speech is happening, with a real addressee and real content. His point is who receives it. The speech goes up to God (verses 14–17 show it as prayer, praise and thanksgiving) but does not reach across to the other people in the room. "No one hears" does not mean the speech is silent. Everyone hears the sounds, and no one grasps the meaning. That is the same sense the Greek Old Testament gives the word when Joseph's brothers spoke in front of him, unaware he could understand them without the interpreter.
"Mysteries" here does not mean puzzles or riddles. It is the Jewish and Pauline word for God's secrets, things that remain sealed until God makes them known. The speaker is in touch with divine reality, but for the hearers the seal is still on. So the verse both affirms and limits the gift. Tongue-speech is genuine speech to God from the Spirit. But in the gathered assembly it is speech no one else receives. That sets up verse 3: the one who prophesies speaks to people, building them up, urging them on and comforting them.
-
3But he who prophesies speaks to men for their edification, encouragement, and comfort.
Full study →"But the person who prophesies, unlike the tongue-speaker, is talking to people: what they speak is building work on the community, words that urge and spur people on, and words that steady and console those who are grieving or losing heart."
Paul is setting two kinds of Spirit-given speech side by side. In verse 2 the person speaking in a tongue talks "not to people but to God", and no one understands. Here the person who prophesies talks to people, in words they can understand, and the words do something for them.
The three things prophecy delivers are grammatically the direct objects of "speaks". The prophet literally "speaks building-up, urging and consolation", as though the words themselves were the help being handed over:
- Building up (oikodomē) is a construction word. The picture is a house or temple being raised, and the structure is the church as a whole (verse 4). It is the theme of the whole chapter, and probably the heading over the other two.
- Urging/encouragement (paraklēsis) means "calling someone to your side". It covers both exhorting and encouraging: speech that presses people forward, not only speech that makes them feel good.
- Consolation (paramythia) was the word for the kind of words spoken to the bereaved and the fainthearted: speech that calms and holds people up.
The verse does not say these three are all prophecy can be. Later in the chapter prophecy also carries revelation (verse 30) and can expose the hidden things of an outsider's heart (verses 24–25). Paul is naming what makes prophecy valuable in the gathering: hearers can understand it, and it strengthens them.
-
4The one who speaks in a tongue edifies himself, but the one who prophesies edifies the church.
Full study →The person speaking in a tongue is building up only himself. The person prophesying is building up the assembly, the gathered people of God.
The same verb does the work in both halves: oikodomei, "builds", the word for putting up a house. Paul has already called the Corinthian believers "God's building" and himself its "master builder" (3:9–10). He has said that "love builds up" (8:1) and that not everything "builds up" (10:23). So his readers would picture a construction site and ask what is being built.
The tongue-speaker utters Spirit-given speech directed to God, "mysteries" that no one else in the room understands (14:2). Something real happens: he is strengthened. But the building rises over one person. The prophet speaks Spirit-prompted words in ordinary, understandable speech "for building up, encouragement and comfort" (14:3), and the structure that rises is the whole gathering.
The Greek places "himself" and "an assembly" side by side just before each verb, to show the gap between them: one self against a whole community. Both speakers are described in the present tense, as things that keep happening in Corinth's meetings. The verse grants that tongues do the speaker real good. Its purpose is to rank the two for the gathering. Paul goes on at once: "the one who prophesies is greater… unless someone interprets, so that the assembly may be built up" (14:5).
-
5I wish that all of you could speak in tongues, but I would rather have you prophesy. He who prophesies is greater than one who speaks in tongues, unless he interprets so that the church may be edified.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v1
charity (KJV)
agapē
- What we hear
- Giving money or goods to the needy; a charitable organisation.
- What they heard
- Love: self-giving care that seeks the good of others, as described in 1 Cor 13.
-
in v1
spiritual gifts
ta pneumatika
- What we hear
- Personal talents or aptitudes ('my spiritual gift is administration') to discover through a test; or anything inward, private or non-material.
- What they heard
- 'The things of the Spirit': the Holy Spirit's workings shown publicly in the gathering 'for the common good' (12:7). The word 'gifts' is supplied by translators.
-
in v1
prophesy / prophecy
prophēteuō
- What we hear
- To predict future events.
- What they heard
- To speak a Spirit-prompted message from God in understandable words. In this chapter its aim is the hearers' building up, encouragement and comfort (14:3), and it may expose hidden things (14:24–25). It can include prediction (e.g. Agabus, Acts 11:28) but is not defined by it.
-
in v2
an unknown tongue (KJV)
glōssē
- What we hear
- A language unknown to anyone anywhere, often taken to mean a heavenly or non-human language. 'Unknown tongue' has become a set phrase for the practice itself.
- What they heard
- Simply 'in a tongue/language'. Paul adds no adjective. The verse says the speech is not understood by the hearers who are present. It does not say on its own whether the speech is a human language or not.
-
in v2
mysteries
mystēria
- What we hear
- Puzzles, riddles, the inexplicable, or vaguely 'deep' spiritual experiences beyond words.
- What they heard
- God's secrets: real content that is hidden from human beings until it is disclosed. Here it stays hidden from the listeners because no interpretation has been given.
-
in v3
prophesies
prophēteuō
- What we hear
- Predicts the future.
- What they heard
- Speaks a Spirit-prompted message from God in language the hearers understand. It can include foretelling, revelation or conviction, but here the point is that it is addressed to people and does them good.
-
in v3
edification
oikodomē
- What we hear
- Something personally uplifting or educational: a private spiritual boost.
- What they heard
- Building up, in the sense of construction, especially of the community as God's building or temple (verse 4: 'builds up the church').
-
in v3
comfort
paramythia
- What we hear
- Coziness, ease, feeling pleasant.
- What they heard
- Consolation that steadies the grieving or fainthearted. When the KJV was made, 'comfort' still carried its root meaning, 'strengthen'.
-
in v3
to men
anthrōpois
- What we hear
- To males.
- What they heard
- To human beings, people in general. It contrasts with 'to God' in verse 2.
-
in v4
edifies
oikodomei
- What we hear
- Inspires, uplifts or improves someone inwardly; an "edifying" experience is a personally enriching one.
- What they heard
- Builds, as in building a house. In Paul it is almost always the strengthening and building of the community. "Builds himself" is the narrow exception, set against building the assembly.
-
in v4
prophesies
prophēteuōn
- What we hear
- Predicts future events.
- What they heard
- Speaks a Spirit-prompted message in understandable words to the gathered people, for building up, encouraging and comforting them (14:3). It may include foresight, but that is not the centre.
-
in v4
the church
ekklēsian
- What we hear
- A building, an institution or a denomination.
- What they heard
- An assembly: the believers actually gathered together, here a house meeting in Corinth.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v2
This verse isn't about hiding prayers from the devil
- What's often taught
- Because the one who speaks in tongues 'speaks not to men but to God' and 'no one understands', praying in tongues is a secret code between the believer and God that Satan and demons cannot understand or interfere with.
- What the text supports
The 'no one' (oudeis) who does not understand picks up the 'people' (anthrōpois) of the previous clause. In context these are the believers gathered in the Corinthian assembly. The whole chapter is about what happens when the church meets: other people cannot say 'Amen' (v.16), the outsider who walks in thinks you are mad (v.23), and so interpretation is needed for the church to be built up (vv.5, 12–13, 27–28). Neither this verse nor the chapter mentions spiritual beings overhearing anything. 'Mysteries' means God's secrets that stay sealed to the human hearers, not a code meant to keep out evil spirits. What the popular reading gets right: Paul does present tongues as genuine speech to God that comes from the Spirit and builds up the speaker (v.4). The idea that it shuts out demons is an inference brought to the text, not something found in it.
- Where the English feeds it
- Translations that say 'no one understands' without the context, and the KJV's added 'unknown', make 'no one' sound unlimited. That leaves room to read it as 'no being in the universe'.
ἀκούω akouō μυστήριον mystērion οὐδείς oudeis ἄνθρωπος anthrōpos
in v3
1 Corinthians 14:3 doesn't say prophecy is only ever positive
- What's often taught
- Because this verse lists edification, exhortation and comfort, true New Testament prophecy must always be encouraging and positive. A word that warns, corrects or exposes sin is therefore not genuine prophecy.
- What the text supports
Verse 3 describes what makes prophecy valuable in contrast to uninterpreted tongues. It is spoken to people (not 'to God', v. 2) and it does them good. That is a real and useful standard, and the popular reading is right that prophecy's aim is to build up, not to tear down.
The same chapter, though, shows prophecy doing more than reassure:
- It convicts and examines an outsider, laying bare 'the secrets of his heart' so that he falls down and worships (14:24–25, elenchetai… anakrinetai).
- It rests on revelation (14:30).
- It must be weighed by others (14:29), which would hardly be needed if it were only ever gentle.
The second word, paraklēsis, itself includes urging and exhortation, not only soothing. Elsewhere Christian prophets also foretell hardship (Acts 11:28; 21:10–11). The verse teaches that prophecy serves the hearers' good, and that good can include a hard word spoken to build them up.
- Where the English feeds it
- Translations that render paraklēsis as 'encouragement' (BSB, ESV, NIV) and paramythia as 'comfort' make all three terms sound purely soft. 'Exhortation' (KJV, WEB, NASB) better keeps the sense of urging.
οἰκοδομή oikodomē παράκλησις paraklēsis παραμυθία paramythia προφητεύω prophēteuō
in v4
'Edifies himself' is Paul's contrast, not his sales pitch
- What's often taught
- Speaking in tongues is a God-given way to build yourself up spiritually, and this verse shows believers should pray in tongues regularly for that purpose.
- What the text supports
The verse does grant something real. The tongue-speaker is built up, and Paul elsewhere values his own praying in the Spirit (14:15, 18). That part of the teaching is right.
But the sentence is a comparison made to rank the two gifts, not a recommendation:
- The same verb, oikodomeō ("build"), is used twice. The point is what gets built: "himself" against "an assembly", placed side by side for emphasis.
- The next verse draws the conclusion: "the one who prophesies is greater… unless someone interprets, so that the assembly may be built up" (14:5).
- Throughout the letter, building is the work of love for others (8:1; 10:23–24; 14:12, 26). In the chapter just before, love "does not seek its own" (13:5).
So Paul's point is that in the gathering, building others beats building yourself. Turning "builds himself up" into the main reason to pursue the gift reverses the direction of his argument. It does not settle whether private tongues have value; Paul seems to think they do (14:28 "speak to himself and to God").
- Where the English feeds it
- Modern English "edify" means personal inspiration or enrichment, so "edifies himself" sounds like a goal worth chasing. The Greek building picture, which Paul nearly always applies to the community, is lost.
γλῶσσα glōssa ἑαυτοῦ heautou ἐκκλησία ekklēsia οἰκοδομέω oikodomeō προφητεύω prophēteuō
Every word
-
Διώκετε
Diōkete · G1377
pursue, chase, run after · v1
A plural command to the whole congregation: run after love the way a hunter chases game or a runner chases the finish line. The present tense presents it as an ongoing pursuit, not one decision made once.
-
τὴν
tēn · G3588
the · v1, v2, v3, v4
The article points back to the love just described in chapter 13: patient, kind, not envious, not boastful. Paul means 'that love', not love in general.
-
ἀγάπην·
agapēn · G26
love · v1
Love that seeks the other person's good and 'builds up' (8:1). In this chapter it becomes the test for every gift: does it build up the others in the room?
-
ζηλοῦτε
zēloute · G2206
-
δὲ
de · G1161
and, but · v1, v2, v3, v4
A light connecting word, 'and' rather than a strong 'but'. It adds the second command alongside the first; it does not set gifts against love.
-
πνευματικά,
pneumatika · G4152
spiritual, belonging to the Spirit · v1
Literally 'the spiritual things', the ways God's Spirit shows itself in the gathering (12:7). The word 'gifts' is not in the Greek; translators supply it (KJV marks it in italics).
-
μᾶλλον
mallon · G3123
more, rather · v1
'More', 'above all', or 'rather'. It implies a comparison that v. 2 makes explicit: prophecy rather than uninterpreted tongues.
-
ἵνα
hina · G2443
that, in order that · v1
Introduces what they should be eager for: 'that you may prophesy'. Paul names an activity, not a possession.
-
προφητεύητε.
prophēteuēte · G4395
prophesy, speak as a prophet · v1, v3, v4
Speak out, in words others can understand, what the Spirit prompts, so that the church is 'built up, encouraged and comforted' (14:3). Plural 'you', addressed to the congregation.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v2
Introduces the reason for v.1's 'especially that you may prophesy'. Verse 2 explains why prophecy is preferred in the gathering.
-
λαλῶν
lalōn · G2980
speaking · v2, v3, v4
Present participle, 'the one speaking'. It describes the act as it is happening. λαλέω is the ordinary verb for producing speech and stresses the sounding out of words. Paul repeats it three times in this verse.
-
γλώσσῃ
glōssē · G1100
tongue, language · v2, v4
Dative case, 'in/by means of a tongue', meaning a language or speech form that the speaker produces by the Spirit and has not learned. There is no article and no adjective: Paul does not say 'unknown'.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v2
A plain factual negation: such speech does not, in fact, reach human hearers.
-
ἀνθρώποις
anthrōpois · G0444
humans, people · v2, v3
Dative plural, 'to people'. It means human beings in general, and in context the other believers present in the assembly. It is not about men as opposed to women.
-
ἀλλὰ
alla · G0235
but rather · v2
A strong contrast: not to people, but to God instead.
-
θεῷ
theō · G2316
God · v2
Dative, 'to God'. God is the only one who receives what is said. Verses 14–17 show what such speech is: prayer, singing praise, blessing and thanksgiving.
-
οὐδεὶς
oudeis · G3762
no one · v2
'No one', meaning no one among the human listeners in the room. It picks up 'not to people' from the previous clause.
-
ἀκούει
akouei · G0191
hears · v2
Literally 'hears', but here in the common sense 'understands'. Everyone hears the sounds. No one catches the meaning (compare v.16, 'he does not know what you are saying').
-
πνεύματι
pneumati · G4151
spirit, Spirit · v2
Dative with no article: 'in spirit' or 'by the Spirit'. Interpreters disagree whether this is God's Spirit giving the speech (12:10–11) or the speaker's own spirit as opposed to the mind (14:14). The point is that the speech comes from a source other than the speaker's conscious thinking.
-
μυστήρια
mystēria · G3466
mysteries, secrets · v2
Plural, 'secrets'. These are things that belong to God and stay hidden from the hearers because nothing has disclosed them. Without interpretation the content stays sealed.
-
οἰκοδομὴν
oikodomēn · G3619
building, building up · v3
A construction word: the act of building. Here it means strengthening the community as a structure (verse 4: prophecy 'builds up the church'). It is the main idea of the chapter and probably the umbrella over the other two nouns.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v3
Links the first two items of the list.
-
παράκλησιν
paraklēsin · G3874
exhortation, encouragement, appeal, comfort · v3
Literally 'a calling alongside'. It covers urging someone forward, appealing to them, and encouraging them. Here it is speech that moves hearers to act and keep going, so it is firmer than just 'being nice'.
-
παραμυθίαν
paramythian · G3889
consolation, comfort · v3
Speech that calms and steadies people who are grieving, discouraged or fainthearted. This noun appears only here in the New Testament. It is the gentlest of the three words.
-
ἑαυτὸν
heauton · G1438
himself · v4
"Himself." It comes before the verb for emphasis and sets up the contrast with "assembly" in the second half. The person who gains is the speaker alone.
-
οἰκοδομεῖ
oikodomei · G3618
-
ἐκκλησίαν
ekklēsian · G1577
assembly, gathering · v4
"An assembly": the believers gathered together, here the house meeting in Corinth. There is no article, which puts the stress on what kind of thing is built (a whole gathered community) as against "himself". YLT keeps this as "an assembly".
The world behind it
Corinth and competitive spirituality. Corinth was a rebuilt Roman colony full of status-seeking, and the church reflected it: factions (1:12), boasting (4:7), the wealthy humiliating the poor at the Lord's Supper (11:21–22). In chapters 12–14 the issue is worship. Some prized speaking in tongues, inspired speech nobody understood, as proof of being truly "spiritual" (pneumatikos).
Inspired speech in the Greek world. Ecstatic, unintelligible utterance was familiar from Greek religion: the Pythia at Delphi, Dionysian frenzy. At Delphi the official called the prophētēs had the job of putting the god's utterance into understandable words. A Corinthian could easily equate frenzy with closeness to the divine. Paul reverses that value: the Spirit's speech that matters most is the kind that others understand and that builds them up.
Jewish hope. For Jewish believers, Joel 2:28–29 promised that in the last days God's Spirit would be poured out on all, and "your sons and daughters shall prophesy". Widespread prophesying in the congregation, by women as well as men (11:5), was a sign that the promised age had dawned.
House-church gatherings. The church met in homes, probably a few dozen people. Several could speak in one meeting (14:26–31), so who spoke, and how, shaped the whole gathering. That is why Paul's ranking of gifts is about the common good rather than personal experience.
From the study of 1 Corinthians 14:1.
Where scholars differ
in v1
What exactly is the 'prophesying' Paul prefers?
-
Spontaneous, Spirit-prompted speech based on a revelation given in the moment, distinct from prepared teaching.
14:30 ('if a revelation comes to another sitting there'); prophets and teachers are listed separately (12:28); prophecies must be weighed (14:29). Held by e.g. Fee, Aune, Forbes and Grudem.
-
Closely related to, or including, Spirit-led pastoral preaching that applies God's word to the congregation.
Its stated effects (building up, encouragement, comfort, 14:3) overlap with preaching. This line runs from Calvin and the Reformed 'prophesyings' to scholars such as David Hill and, in nuanced form, Thiselton.
in v1
Did congregational prophecy carry the same authority as Old Testament prophecy or apostolic teaching?
-
No: it was a lesser, mixed form, real but fallible, which is why it had to be weighed.
14:29 ('let the others weigh what is said'); 1 Thess 5:20–21. Argued by Grudem.
-
Yes: true prophecy was God's word, and weighing meant telling true prophets from false, not sorting good from bad within one message.
Continuity with OT prophecy; Eph 2:20 ('apostles and prophets' as foundation). Argued by Gaffin and others.
in v1
Who is told to seek prophecy: every individual, or the congregation as a whole?
-
The congregation collectively: the church should desire that prophecy happen among it, since not all are prophets.
All verbs are plural; 12:29 ('Are all prophets?' expects 'no'); the gifts are distributed 'as the Spirit wills' (12:11).
-
Individuals too: any believer may be eager to prophesy.
14:5 ('I wish you all … to prophesy'), 14:24 and 14:31 ('you can all prophesy one by one').
in v1
Is 'pneumatika' the Corinthians' own slogan?
-
Yes: Paul quotes their preferred word and then substitutes his own, charismata ('grace-gifts').
The shift from pneumatika (12:1) to charismata (12:4); their pride in being pneumatikoi (2:15; 3:1; 14:37). Fee and others.
-
Not necessarily: Paul uses the two words interchangeably.
Paul uses pneumatikos freely elsewhere in positive senses (e.g. Rom 1:11 'some spiritual charisma'); here he urges zeal for the pneumatika himself.
in v2
What were the 'tongues' at Corinth: human languages, or a non-human or ecstatic kind of speech?
-
Real human languages the speaker had not learned (xenolalia), as at Pentecost.
*Glōssa* normally means 'language'. Acts 2 describes recognisable languages. Paul's own comparisons in 14:10–11 are with foreign human languages ('I will be a foreigner to the speaker'), and in 14:21 he quotes Isaiah on foreign tongues. (R. H. Gundry, *JTS* 1966; C. Forbes, *Prophecy and Inspired Speech*, 1995, who also argues against close links to pagan ecstasy.)
-
Speech that is not a human language: 'tongues of angels', or inspired utterance that no one present could know.
13:1 mentions 'tongues of angels'. Here 'no one understands' and the speaker addresses God alone, whereas in cosmopolitan Corinth some known foreign language would probably have been recognised. Interpretation is a spiritual gift (12:10), not language skill. The *Testament of Job* 48–50 shows a Jewish belief in angelic dialects. (G. D. Fee, NICNT; D. B. Martin, *JAAR* 1991.)
-
Uncontrived speech from deep within, beyond the mind's control: released praise or longing not carried in normal words.
14:14 says 'my spirit prays but my mind is unfruitful'. Compare Romans 8:26, 'groanings too deep for words'. The stress throughout falls on lack of understanding, not on any language identity. (A. C. Thiselton, NIGTC.)
in v2
Does πνεύματι mean 'by the (Holy) Spirit' or 'in his (human) spirit'?
-
God's Spirit is the source of the speech (BSB, ESV, NIV).
1 Corinthians 12:7–11 lists tongues among gifts given 'through the Spirit' and 'by the same Spirit'. Paul elsewhere uses the dative *pneumati* without the article for God's Spirit (e.g. 12:3).
-
The speaker's own spirit, as opposed to the mind (KJV, NASB).
In 14:14–15 Paul says 'my spirit prays … my mind is unfruitful' and 'I will pray with the spirit and with the mind'. Here *pneuma* clearly refers to his own inner self.
-
Both: the Holy Spirit working through the person's spirit.
Fee's 'S/spirit' proposal. Paul does not sharply separate the two in this setting, as in Romans 8:16, 'the Spirit bears witness with our spirit'.
in v2
Is verse 2 a commendation of tongues or a criticism of how the Corinthians used them?
-
Mainly positive: it describes the real value of tongues as speech to God.
Paul says tongues build up the speaker (v.4), wishes all spoke in tongues (v.5), practises them more than all (v.18), and permits private use, 'to himself and to God' (v.28).
-
Mainly a limit: in context it explains why tongues are inferior in the assembly.
The verse begins with 'for', which explains v.1's preference for prophecy. 'Not to people' is set against v.3's 'to people for building up'. The argument as a whole (vv.6–19) presses intelligibility, and 13:1–2 treats tongues and mysteries without love as worthless.
in v3
What kind of speech is 'prophecy' here: spontaneous revelation, or something close to Spirit-led preaching?
-
Spontaneous, revelation-based speech, distinct from teaching. The speaker reports something God brings to mind during the meeting, and others weigh it.
14:30 ('if a revelation comes to another sitting there'); 14:29 (others evaluate); 14:24–25 (secrets of the heart disclosed); prophecy and teaching are listed separately in 12:28–29. Held, in different forms, by scholars such as Gordon Fee, Wayne Grudem and David Aune.
-
Prophecy includes or overlaps with pastoral, applied proclamation: Spirit-led speech that applies God's word to the community.
The effects listed in 14:3 (building up, exhortation, consolation) are the aims of preaching. Acts 15:32 shows prophets exhorting. This line runs from Calvin and the Reformation-era 'prophesyings' to modern scholars such as David Hill (prophecy as 'pastoral preaching') and, in part, Anthony Thiselton.
in v3
Is 14:3 a definition of prophecy, or a description of its benefit?
-
A description of benefit and direction, chosen to contrast prophecy with uninterpreted tongues. It does not set limits on prophecy's content.
The verse answers verse 2 point by point ('to people', not 'to God'). Verse 4 sums up only with 'builds up the church'. Later verses add conviction and revelation (14:24–25, 30).
-
A working definition: whatever else prophecy is, it is marked by building up, exhortation and consolation, and this can serve as a test.
Paul lists these three outcomes as what the prophet 'speaks' (direct objects), and 14:26 makes building up the rule for everything said in the meeting.
in v4
Is "builds up himself" a genuine good or a quiet criticism?
-
A genuine, positive benefit. The speaker really is strengthened through Spirit-given communion with God, even though the mind is not engaged.
Tongues are speech to God in the Spirit (14:2). Paul prays and sings "with the spirit" himself (14:15), thanks God that he speaks in tongues more than all of them (14:18), and wishes they all spoke in tongues (14:5). Many commentators, Gordon Fee for example, take the self-building at face value.
-
There is a critical or ironic edge: building yourself is the opposite of what Paul says love does.
Elsewhere in the letter, building is always communal (8:1; 10:23; 14:12, 26). Love "does not seek its own" (13:5), and "let no one seek his own good, but that of the other" (10:24). In 8:10 Paul uses "built up" ironically. The emphatic placement of "himself" sharpens the contrast.
-
Both: the benefit is real but lesser, and out of place as the main goal in the assembly.
The very next verse ranks the two ("greater is the one who prophesies", 14:5). Paul's solution is not to ban tongues but to require interpretation in the meeting (14:27–28, 39), so that it is valued but placed under the good of the community.
in v4
What were the Corinthian "tongues"?
-
Real human languages unknown to the speaker, as at Pentecost.
Acts 2:4–11 says hearers recognised their own languages. Paul compares tongues to foreign languages (14:10–11) and quotes Isa 28:11 about foreign speech (14:21). The word glōssa normally means language.
-
Non-human speech, whether heavenly, angelic or a kind of inspired utterance, not a human language.
"Tongues of men and of angels" (13:1). "No one understands" (14:2), with no hint that a foreign visitor might. The speech needs a separate spiritual gift to interpret it (12:10). There are Jewish traditions of angelic languages (e.g. Testament of Job 48–50).
in v4
What exactly is the "prophecy" Paul prefers?
-
Spontaneous, Spirit-given revelation spoken in the meeting and tested by others.
"If a revelation comes to another sitting there" (14:30). Prophecies are weighed (14:29) and can expose the secrets of the heart (14:24–25). This view is argued by Wayne Grudem and Christopher Forbes, among others.
-
Inspired speech that includes or is close to preaching and applying scripture.
Its purposes, building up, encouraging and comforting (14:3) and instruction (14:19, 31), overlap with teaching. Reformation-era interpreters (e.g. Calvin) often identified prophecy with inspired exposition of scripture. Critics answer that 14:30's "revelation" points to something more spontaneous.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. διώκω, ἀγάπη, ζηλόω, πνευματικός, προφητεύω
- LSJ s.v. προφήτης, ζηλόω
- Gordon D. Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NICNT)
- Anthony C. Thiselton, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NIGTC)
- David E. Garland, 1 Corinthians (BECNT)
- David E. Aune, Prophecy in Early Christianity and the Ancient Mediterranean World
- Christopher Forbes, Prophecy and Inspired Speech in Early Christianity and Its Hellenistic Environment
- Wayne Grudem, The Gift of Prophecy in the New Testament and Today
- Richard B. Gaffin Jr., Perspectives on Pentecost
- David Hill, New Testament Prophecy
- Septuagint (LXX): Ps 33:15; Deut 16:20; Num 25:11; 2 Sam 13:15; Joel 3:1 [Eng. 2:28]
- Vulgate, 1 Cor 14:1
- Didache 11
- BDAG s.v. γλῶσσα
- BDAG s.v. μυστήριον
- BDAG s.v. πνεῦμα
- BDAG s.v. ἀκούω
- Gordon D. Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NICNT, rev. ed. 2014)
- Anthony C. Thiselton, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NIGTC, 2000)
- David E. Garland, 1 Corinthians (BECNT, 2003)
- Christopher Forbes, Prophecy and Inspired Speech in Early Christianity and its Hellenistic Environment (1995)
- Robert H. Gundry, "'Ecstatic Utterance' (N.E.B.)?" Journal of Theological Studies 17 (1966)
- Dale B. Martin, "Tongues of Angels and Other Status Indicators," JAAR 59 (1991)
- Plato, Timaeus 71e–72b
- Aristotle, Poetics 21 (on glōtta)
- LXX Genesis 11:7; 42:23; Daniel 2:18–47
- Testament of Job 48–50
- Vulgate, 1 Corinthians 14:2
- NA28 apparatus / Textus Receptus
- BDAG s.v. προφητεύω, οἰκοδομή, παράκλησις, παραμυθία
- LSJ s.v. παραμυθία, προφήτης
- Septuagint: Isaiah 40:1; Jeremiah 1:10; Joel 3:1 (2:28 Eng.)
- BDAG s.v. οἰκοδομέω
- BDAG s.v. προφητεύω
- BDAG s.v. ἐκκλησία
- Louw-Nida, Greek-English Lexicon (domains 'build up', 'assembly')
- Septuagint: Ruth 4:11; Jer 1:10; 38:4 LXX (31:4); Num 11:25–29; Joel 3:1 LXX; Deut 4:10; 9:10
- Plato, Timaeus 71e–72b; Phaedrus 244a–b
- Aristotle, Poetics 1457b; Rhetoric 1410b (glōtta as strange word)
- Dead Sea Scrolls, Community Rule 1QS 8:5–9
- Christopher Forbes, Prophecy and Inspired Speech in Early Christianity and its Hellenistic Environment
- Wayne Grudem, The Gift of Prophecy in 1 Corinthians
- Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.