1 Corinthians Chapter 12 Read as one passage
1 Corinthians 12:7–11
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
7Now to each one the manifestation of the Spirit is given for the common good. 8To one there is given through the Spirit the message of wisdom, to another the message of knowledge by the same Spirit, 9to another faith by the same Spirit, to another gifts of healing by that one Spirit, 10to another the working of miracles, to another prophecy, to another distinguishing between spirits, to another speaking in various tongues, and to still another the interpretation of tongues. 11All these are the work of one and the same Spirit, who apportions them to each one as He determines.
What the first hearers heard
For Corinthian believers who measured spirituality by impressive experiences, this sentence did three things at once.
- It levelled them. "To each": the slave, the freedwoman, the quiet member and the ecstatic speaker all have the Spirit showing itself through them. No one in the room could claim to be the only "spiritual" one.
- It humbled them. "Is given" by God: what they had was received, so it could not be a ground for boasting (compare 4:7).
- It redirected them. "For the beneficial": the Spirit's appearing in a person is not a private badge but serves the others. In the political vocabulary they knew, Paul was calling them away from private interest and toward the shared good of the body.
The verse works as a heading for vv.8–11. Wisdom, knowledge, faith, healings, miracles, prophecy, discernment, tongues and interpretation are all one "manifestation" of one Spirit. Each is distributed as the Spirit wills (v.11), and each is meant for everyone else's benefit.
From the study of 1 Corinthians 12:7.
Verse by verse
-
7Now to each one the manifestation of the Spirit is given for the common good.
Full study →To each one of you, every single member, not just a spiritual elite, God keeps giving a way in which his invisible Spirit becomes visible. And it is given to serve what benefits the others, not to raise the status of the one who has it.
Paul has just said three times that behind all the variety in the church stands the same Spirit, the same Lord, the same God (vv.4–6). Now he turns to the individual. The sentence opens with "to each". In the Greek that word comes first, and it is emphatic: no one is left out. "Is given" is present tense, an ongoing giving, and the giver is God, which leaves no room for boasting. What is given is not described as a talent or a possession. It is a showing: the Spirit, whom no one can see, coming into view through speech, healing, faith, discernment and the rest of the list in vv.8–10.
The final phrase, "toward the beneficial", used the language Greek cities used for the public interest as opposed to private gain. The Greek doesn't actually say "common", but the context leaves no doubt. In this letter Paul has already said "not everything is beneficial" and "I seek not my own benefit but that of the many" (10:23, 33). He is about to describe the church as one body whose parts exist for each other (12:12–27). The purpose of the Spirit's appearing in you is the good of everyone else.
-
8To one there is given through the Spirit the message of wisdom, to another the message of knowledge by the same Spirit,
Full study →Paul is filling out what he has just said in verse 7: each believer is given a visible working of God's Spirit, and it is given for the good of everyone. To one person, the Spirit gives the ability to speak wisdom. This means an utterance that opens up God's wisdom, the hidden wisdom of the crucified Messiah that Paul has already set against the world's eloquence and cleverness (1:18–2:16). To another person, the same Spirit gives the ability to speak knowledge. This means an utterance that conveys real understanding of God and his ways, the kind of insight Paul elsewhere mentions alongside mysteries, revelation and teaching (13:2; 14:6).
Several details matter:
- Both gifts are a logos, a spoken message. The gift is not wisdom or knowledge held as a private possession. It is speech offered to the gathered church.
- Both are given. The verb is passive and present tense: God keeps giving, and nobody earns it.
- They go to different people: "to one... to another."
- They come from the same Spirit, and the Spirit hands them out as it chooses (v.11).
The Corinthians prized "wisdom" and "knowledge" above almost everything (1:5; 8:1). By putting them first in the list, Paul honors both while removing any reason to boast about them. They are real gifts, but they are gifts, and they sit alongside faith, healing, prophecy and tongues as gifts of one Spirit.
-
9to another faith by the same Spirit, to another gifts of healing by that one Spirit,
Full study →Paul is still in the middle of the sentence he began in verse 8: to each one is given a showing of the Spirit for the good of all. Verse 9 continues the list. To yet another person the same Spirit gives faith. This is not the trust in Christ that every believer shares. It is a special, God-given confidence that God will act in power in a particular situation, the kind of faith Paul will soon describe as able "to remove mountains" (13:2). To another person the one Spirit gives "gifts of healings." In Greek both words are plural: separate acts of healing, each one a free gift from God's grace, not a skill a person owns and uses at will.
The repeated phrases carry the point: the same Spirit, the one Spirit. Healings in Corinth were the business of the healing god Asclepius, and visible wonders brought prestige. Paul says these dramatic gifts come from exactly the same source as the quieter ones, they are given to different people, and they are handed out for the common good. They are not marks of rank.
-
10to another the working of miracles, to another prophecy, to another distinguishing between spirits, to another speaking in various tongues, and to still another the interpretation of tongues.
Full study →Paul is partway through a list of things the one Spirit gives to different members of the church, and each phrase begins "to another person". To another person is given the outworking of powers: particular occasions when God's power takes visible effect in mighty deeds beyond the healings just mentioned, things God himself "works" through that person (vv. 6, 11). To another, prophecy: speech prompted by the Spirit and spoken for God, in words the whole gathering can understand, to build them up, encourage and comfort them, and sometimes to lay bare what is hidden in a heart. To another, the ability to tell spirits apart: to weigh inspired utterances and judge whether what was just spoken comes from God's Spirit, from a merely human impulse, or from some other spirit. It is a gift that stands guard beside prophecy. To yet a different person, varieties of tongues: Spirit-prompted speech, addressed mainly to God, in language neither the listeners nor the speaker's own mind understand, and coming in more than one kind. And to another, the interpretation of tongues: the ability to put that speech into words the gathered church can understand and be built up by.
The order and pairing carry meaning. Each "speaking" gift comes with a "checking" or "making clear" gift: prophecy is followed by the weighing of spirits, and tongues by interpretation. Tongues, the gift the Corinthians prized most, comes near the end. None of these gifts is handed out to everyone, and none is the badge of an elite. Each is one person's share of the work of one and the same Spirit, who gives as he chooses (v. 11).
-
11All these are the work of one and the same Spirit, who apportions them to each one as He determines.
Full study →Now every one of these gifts, without exception (the word of wisdom, the word of knowledge, faith, healings, workings of miracles, prophecy, discerning spirits, kinds of tongues, interpretation), is the active work of one single Spirit, the very same Spirit each time. That Spirit is continually at work producing them, just as verse 6 says God "works all things in all". The Spirit hands out the shares the way a householder allots portions. Every person gets one, each person's share is fitted to them individually, and the Spirit gives them according to his own settled purpose, not according to what anyone has earned, chosen or ranked.
The sentence ends on as he wills. So the variety of gifts in the Corinthian assembly is not a ladder of spiritual status. It is a deliberate distribution from one source, for the good of the whole body that Paul turns to describe in the next verse.
Where the English drifted
-
in v7
to profit withal (KJV)
pros to sympheron
- What we hear
- To make a profit: financial gain, or getting something out of it for oneself. 'Withal' is opaque to most readers.
- What they heard
- For what is beneficial or advantageous. In context, beneficial to the whole assembly. 'Withal' in 1611 English meant 'with it', i.e., 'to do good with it'.
-
in v7
every man (KJV)
hekastō
- What we hear
- Every male.
- What they heard
- Each person individually, men and women alike. Paul assumes women pray and prophesy in the assembly (11:5).
-
in v8
word (of wisdom / of knowledge)
logos
- What we hear
- Either a single word, or, in modern church idiom, "a word" meaning a short, supernaturally revealed message for a particular person.
- What they heard
- An utterance, message or discourse. The gift is speaking wisdom or knowledge aloud to the gathered church, and nothing in the term limits it to brief or private revelations.
-
in v8
wisdom
sophia
- What we hear
- Good practical judgment or sensible advice.
- What they heard
- In Corinth: prestigious eloquence and philosophical sophistication. In Paul's redefinition: God's hidden wisdom revealed in the crucified Messiah and made known by the Spirit (2:6–13).
-
in v8
knowledge
gnōsis
- What we hear
- Information or facts, or (in charismatic usage) supernatural knowledge of specific details about a person. Some readers also hear later "Gnostic" secret knowledge.
-
in v9
faith
pistis
- What we hear
- The trust in Christ that saves, or religious belief in general, which every Christian has.
- What they heard
- In this list, a particular gift given to some members and not others. Most likely it is an extraordinary God-given confidence that God will act in power, the 'mountain-moving' faith of 13:2.
-
in v9
gifts of healing
charismata iamatōn
- What we hear
- 'The gift of healing': one permanent ability that a 'healer' has and can use whenever they choose.
- What they heard
- 'Gifts of healings,' both plural. The phrase most naturally means separate healings, each given by the Spirit as a free gift, though the exact force of the plural is debated.
-
in v9
gifts
charismata
- What we hear
- Being 'gifted': a natural talent or personality strength, often found through a spiritual-gifts test.
- What they heard
- Concrete acts of God's free grace (charis), given by the Spirit for the common good. They are not the receiver's own abilities.
-
in v10
prophecy
prophēteia
- What we hear
- Predicting the future, especially end-times events.
-
in v10
discerning / distinguishing between spirits
diakriseis pneumatōn
- What we hear
- A general spiritual intuition or good judgment, or a private ability to sense demons in people.
- What they heard
- Acts of judging between inspired utterances or spirit-influences, used openly in the assembly and most closely tied to weighing prophecy (14:29; 1 Thess 5:20–21).
-
in v10
the working of miracles
energēmata dynameōn
- What we hear
- Events that break the laws of nature.
- What they heard
- Occasions when God's power takes effect in mighty deeds. The emphasis falls on divine power at work, not on suspending natural law.
-
in v11
dividing (KJV, YLT)
diairoun
- What we hear
- Splitting apart, separating, or causing division between people.
- What they heard
- Dealing out portions, giving each person a share, as an estate or plunder is divided among those who receive it.
-
in v11
severally (KJV, YLT)
idia
- What we hear
- Read as "several" (more than one), or simply not understood.
- What they heard
- Individually, one by one, to each person in particular.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v8
Paul never defines the 'word of knowledge' the way it's often taught
- What's often taught
- The "word of knowledge" is the supernatural revelation of specific facts a person could not know naturally, such as someone's illness, circumstances or secret sin. The "word of wisdom" is supernatural direction about what to do with such revelation or about future events.
- What the text supports
Paul names these gifts but does not define them. Here is what the text does show:
- Both are a logos, a spoken message, given to different people "for the common good" (v.7) in the gathered church.
- "Wisdom" (sophia) already has a meaning in this letter. Paul spent chapters 1–2 on it: God's hidden wisdom in the crucified Messiah, "spoken in words taught by the Spirit" (2:13).
- "Knowledge" (gnōsis) also has one. It was the Corinthians' prized spiritual insight (1:5; 8:1). Paul links it to understanding "mysteries" (13:2) and lists it beside revelation, prophecy and teaching (14:6).
The popular reading is partly right. Gnōsis in Paul can involve revelation, and 14:24–25 describes hidden things of the heart being exposed in worship. But Paul calls that prophecy. Nothing in this verse limits the "word of knowledge" to supernatural facts about individuals, or makes the "word of wisdom" a matter of prediction. Those precise definitions come from later classification of the gifts, not from Paul's wording. What Paul does stress is that both are gifts, both are spoken for others, and both come from the same Spirit.
- Where the English feeds it
- KJV and NASB add "the" ("the word of knowledge"), which Greek does not have, so the phrases sound like defined technical offices. "Word" in modern church idiom ("I have a word for you") suggests a brief revealed message. NLT's "special knowledge" adds an idea of secret information that is not in the Greek.
in v10
Paul never gave a fixed list of "the nine gifts of the Spirit"
- What's often taught
- Verses 8–10 are often taught as the complete, official list of "the nine gifts of the Spirit", sometimes neatly sorted into three groups of three (revelation gifts, power gifts, speaking gifts), and treated as the definitive spiritual gifts.
- What the text supports
Paul's "to another... to another" is a sample meant to show variety, not a closed list. Only eighteen verses later (12:28–30) he gives a different list that includes apostles, teachers, "helps" and "guidance/administration" (the Greek words mean acts of helping and of steering a community), and leaves out several items from verses 8–10. Romans 12:6–8 adds serving, giving, leading and showing mercy. Ephesians 4:11 names evangelists and pastors. The point of verses 4–11 is that there are varieties of gifts, services and workings (vv. 4–6), all from one Spirit, one Lord, one God. Paul is making a point about variety and a single source, not drawing up a fixed list. The popular teaching gets one thing right: these are real gifts given by the Spirit, and Paul expects them in the church. The neat "3×3" scheme is a later teaching aid; the text does not mark it.
- Where the English feeds it
- Some English Bibles add section headings such as "Spiritual Gifts" or "The Gifts of the Spirit" above verses 8–11, and many versions lay the list out cleanly, so it can look like a complete catalogue.
γλῶσσα glōssa ἕτερος heteros ἄλλος allos προφητεία prophēteia
Every word
-
Ἑκάστῳ
Hekastō · G1538
each, every one · v7, v11
Put first for emphasis: 'to each one', taken one at a time. It is a rebuke to the idea that only a few gifted people have the Spirit. The masculine form is the ordinary Greek way of saying 'each person' and includes women. Paul assumes women pray and prophesy in the assembly (11:5).
-
δὲ
de · G1161
and, now, but · v7, v8, v9, v10, v11
A light connective that moves from the big picture (one God 'works all things in all', v.6) to the individual. 'Now' or 'and' fits better than a strong 'but'.
-
δίδοται
didotai · G1325
to give · v7, v8
Present tense, passive voice: 'is being given'. The giver goes unnamed but is plainly God, through the Spirit (vv.6, 11). The present tense presents the giving as ongoing, happening again and again in the assembly's life, not a one-time handout.
-
ἡ
hē · G3588
the · v7, v8, v9, v11
The article marks 'the manifestation of the Spirit' as one recognizable thing that shows up in different forms in different people.
-
φανέρωσις
phanerōsis · G5321
a making visible, disclosure · v7
An uncommon noun formed from the verb 'to make visible/plain'. It describes the activity of bringing something hidden into view. Paul has just called these things 'gifts', 'services' and 'workings' (vv.4–6). Here he names what they all do: they make the invisible Spirit visible in the community.
-
πνεύματος
pneumatos · G4151
spirit, breath, wind · v7, v8, v9, v10, v11
Here it means God's Spirit, the one Spirit behind every gift (vv.4, 11), not a human spirit or a general 'spirituality'. The Corinthians' word for these phenomena was 'spirituals' (pneumatika, 12:1). Paul redirects attention from the experiences to the one Spirit who gives them.
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
toward, for, with a view to · v7
With the accusative it gives purpose or goal: the manifestation is aimed at something beyond the person who receives it.
-
συμφέρον
sympheron · G4851
to be advantageous, to benefit · v7
Literally 'that which brings together / bears with'. In use it meant 'what is advantageous, beneficial, profitable'. The Greek has no separate word for 'common'. But the chapter (one body, many members) and Paul's earlier uses (10:23, 33) make plain whose benefit is meant: everyone's, not the gifted person's own.
-
ᾧ
hō · G3739
which, who; (with μέν) to one · v8
A relative pronoun used as a pointer: "to one (person)". Together with μέν and the later ἄλλῳ δέ it sets up the pattern "to one... to another..." that runs through the whole list in verses 8–10.
-
μὲν
men · G3303
on the one hand · v8
A small particle that sets up a contrast or series. It has no real English equivalent here. It tells the hearer that a matching "to another" is coming, so the gifts are spread across different people.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v8
Ties this verse to verse 7. Paul has just said that "to each" a showing of the Spirit is given for the common good. The list that follows explains and illustrates that statement.
-
διὰ
dia · G1223
through · v8
With the genitive it marks the means or agent: the Spirit is the one through whom the gift reaches the person. It is not something the person produces.
-
λόγος
logos · G3056
word, utterance, message, speech · v8
Not a single vocabulary word. It means a spoken utterance or message. The gift is the speaking of wisdom to others, not simply being wise. There is no article in Greek: "a word" or "an utterance".
-
σοφίας,
sophias · G4678
wisdom · v8
A heavily loaded word in this letter. Corinthians prized it as rhetorical and philosophical prestige. Paul has already redefined it as God's hidden wisdom shown in the crucified Messiah (1:18–2:16). The utterance conveys that kind of wisdom.
-
ἄλλῳ
allō · G0243
another · v8, v9, v10
"To another (person)". This completes the "to one... to another" pattern. No single person holds every gift.
-
γνώσεως
gnōseōs · G1108
-
κατὰ
kata · G2596
according to · v8
"In keeping with, by the decision of" the same Spirit. It looks ahead to verse 11: the Spirit distributes "just as he wills." Paul varies his prepositions (through, according to, in) for style, but all of them point to one source.
-
αὐτὸ
auto · G0846
-
ἑτέρῳ
heterō · G2087
other, different · v9, v10
"To a different person." The dative case marks the person who receives, carrying over the verb "is given" from verse 8. The masculine form is generic: it means any member of the church, not only men. Paul switches here from ἄλλος to ἕτερος. Some read the switch as marking a new group of gifts; others think it is just variety of style.
-
πίστις
pistis · G4102
faith, trust, confidence, faithfulness · v9
Not the basic trust in Christ that every believer has (12:3). It is a particular gift, given to some and not to others. Most likely it means the unusual, God-given confidence that God will act in power in a specific situation, the 'faith to move mountains' of 13:2.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in, by, with · v9
Here it probably means 'by' or 'through' (the Spirit as the one who gives). It may also carry the sense of 'in the realm of' the Spirit. It stands parallel to 'through the Spirit' and 'according to the Spirit' in verse 8.
-
χαρίσματα
charismata · G5486
gift (freely given), favor bestowed · v9
'Gifts' in the plural. The word is built on charis ('grace, favor'), so it means a concrete expression of God's free generosity. It is something received, not a skill the person has earned or developed.
-
ἰαμάτων
iamatōn · G2386
healing, cure, remedy · v9
'Of healings,' in the plural. Each word in the phrase is plural ('gifts of healings'). This suggests separate acts of healing, each one a gift, rather than a single power that someone holds.
-
ἑνὶ
heni · G1520
-
ἐνεργήματα
energēmata · G1755
-
δυνάμεων
dynameōn · G1411
power; mighty deed · v10
"Of powers". In the plural this is the ordinary New Testament word for mighty deeds such as healings, exorcisms and nature miracles. Together the phrase means "acts in which divine power takes effect".
-
προφητεία
prophēteia · G4394
prophecy · v10
Speech prompted by the Spirit and spoken for God, in words everyone present can understand. In Paul's usage its main aim is to build up, encourage and comfort the gathered church (14:3). It can include prediction, but prediction is not its core.
-
διακρίσεις
diakriseis · G1253
distinguishing, judging between · v10
Plural: "acts of distinguishing". The idea is separating one thing from another and weighing it. It comes straight after "prophecy", in the same way that "interpretation" comes straight after "tongues".
-
γένη
genē · G1085H
kind, family, race · v10
"Kinds" or "varieties". The word points out that the speaking in tongues Paul has in mind was not one uniform thing.
-
γλωσσῶν
glōssōn · G1100
tongue, language · v10
"Of tongues" or "of languages". Here it means Spirit-prompted speech that the hearers (and, in 14:14, the speaker's own mind) do not understand.
-
ἑρμηνεία
hermēneia · G2058
interpretation, translation · v10
Putting into understandable words what was spoken in a tongue. In ordinary Greek the word covers both translating and explaining.
-
πάντα
panta · G3956
all · v11
Comes first for emphasis: every gift just listed in verses 8–10, from wisdom to interpreting tongues, with none left out.
-
ταῦτα
tauta · G3778
these (things) · v11
Neuter plural, "these things", pointing back to the gifts and workings named in verses 8–10.
-
ἐνεργεῖ
energei · G1754
to work, be active, put into effect · v11
Present tense: the Spirit is the one actively producing these effects, again and again. It is the same verb used of God in verse 6 ("God who works all things in all"), so what God does, the Spirit does.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v11
Joins "one" to "the same", piling up the emphasis on oneness.
-
διαιροῦν
diairoun · G1244
to divide out, distribute, apportion · v11
Present participle: "distributing" or "giving out shares". It picks up the related noun in verse 4 ("there are *distributions* of gifts"). The picture is portions being handed out, not something being split apart.
-
ἰδίᾳ
idia · G2398
one's own, privately, individually · v11
Used as an adverb: "individually", to each person in particular. Each person's share is fitted to them. It is not a single bulk handout.
-
καθὼς
kathōs · G2531
just as, according as · v11
Brings in the standard the shares are measured by: the Spirit's own will.
-
βούλεται
bouletai · G1014
to will, intend, purpose · v11
"He wills" or "he intends". This is a settled, purposeful decision, not a passing wish. It puts the choice of who gets which gift with the Spirit, not with the person who receives it.
The world behind it
Corinth and the "spiritual ones." Roman Corinth was a commercial colony, rebuilt in 44 BC, whose population was intensely status-conscious. The church there brought that competition inside. Chapters 12–14 answer a question about "the spiritual things" (pneumatika, 12:1). Speaking in tongues seems to have been prized as proof of a higher spiritual standing, much as inspired, unintelligible speech marked the person possessed by a god in Greek oracle and mystery religion (cf. 12:2, "you were led astray to mute idols").
The language of the city. "The advantageous" (to sympheron) was a standard term in Greek political speech. Orators urging a divided city toward unity appealed to what benefits all. They often used the image of the community as a body whose members must not rebel against each other; the Roman fable of the belly and the limbs, told by Livy (2.32), is the famous example. Paul uses both, the "beneficial" here and the body in vv.12–27, but grounds them in the one Spirit and the one Lord rather than in civic loyalty.
The test that follows. Verse 7 sets the standard Paul applies in chapter 14. Whatever builds up the assembly (prophecy, interpreted tongues, teaching) is preferred over what builds up only the speaker (14:3–5, 12, 26).
From the study of 1 Corinthians 12:7.
Where scholars differ
in v7
What does 'the manifestation of the Spirit' mean: the Spirit shown, or the Spirit doing the showing?
-
The Spirit is what is made visible (objective genitive): each gift is a disclosure that the Spirit is present.
Phanerōsis means making something visible. The argument of vv.4–6 is that one unseen Spirit lies behind visible variety. The Corinthians needed to see their experiences as evidence of the Spirit rather than of themselves.
-
The Spirit is the one who makes something visible (subjective genitive): each gift is the Spirit's own act of revealing.
In vv.8–11 the Spirit is the active agent ('through the Spirit', 'the same Spirit works all these, distributing… as he wills').
-
Both at once; Paul does not separate them.
Several commentators (e.g., Thiselton, Fee) note that the Spirit's activity is precisely what makes the Spirit visible, so the distinction may be artificial here.
in v7
Does 'manifestation' cover all the ways the Spirit works in members, or mainly the more striking phenomena listed in vv.8–10?
-
It is a general term covering every gift, service and working in vv.4–6.
Verse 7 follows directly on the three summary statements and uses 'each', which v.18 and vv.28–30 extend to every member and role, including 'helps' and 'administrations'.
-
It refers especially to the Spirit's activity in the gathered worship, as in the list in vv.8–10.
The list that illustrates v.7 is made up of worship and power phenomena (prophecy, tongues, healings), and chapters 12–14 address the assembly at worship (14:26).
in v8
What exactly are the "word of wisdom" and the "word of knowledge"?
-
Spirit-inspired speech that sets out God's wisdom (centered on the cross) and gives understanding of God's truth, close to inspired teaching.
Paul's own use of logos and sophia in 1 Cor 1–2, especially 2:6–13 ("we speak God's wisdom... in words taught by the Spirit"). The pairing of knowledge with teaching and revelation in 14:6. Held in various forms by Fee, Thiselton and Garland.
-
Revelatory gifts: supernatural insight into God's purposes, or into specific facts and situations that could not be known naturally.
Γνῶσις is tied to "mysteries" in 13:2 and to "revelation" in 14:6. In 14:24–25 secrets of the heart are exposed in worship. Narrative examples such as Peter and Ananias (Acts 5:3) are cited. This is the standard Pentecostal and charismatic reading. Critics note that Paul calls the 14:24–25 phenomenon prophecy.
-
The two terms cannot be sharply distinguished. Paul lists them first because they were Corinthian catchwords, not because he is defining technical categories.
The list in 12:8–10 is illustrative, not exhaustive, and differs from the lists in 12:28–30 and Romans 12:6–8. Paul gives no definitions. Both terms recur throughout the letter as Corinthian concerns (1:5; 8:1). Fee and Dunn stress this point.
in v8
Are these permanent abilities belonging to certain people, or occasional workings of the Spirit?
-
Occasional manifestations given in the moment, as the Spirit chooses.
Verse 7 calls them a "manifestation" (φανέρωσις). The present tense "is given" and "as he wills" (v.11) stress the Spirit's ongoing initiative.
-
Recognizable, recurring endowments that characterize particular members.
"To one... to another" assigns gifts to persons. In 12:28–30 Paul speaks of people who are apostles, prophets and teachers, implying stable roles.
in v9
What kind of 'faith' is this gift?
-
Faith that works miracles: a confidence given for a specific moment, by which God does mighty works.
Its place next to healings and miracles (12:9–10). Paul's own gloss in 13:2, 'all faith so as to remove mountains.' The Jesus sayings in Mark 11:22–23. Chrysostom's comment 'not of doctrines but of miracles.' This is the majority view (e.g. Fee, Dunn).
-
A broader extraordinary confidence or trust in God for particular situations, not limited to miracles.
pistis in general means trust and confidence, and Paul does not define the gift narrowly here. Some commentators (e.g. Thiselton) stress a robust, settled confidence in God that serves the community, which can show itself in more than miracles.
in v9
What does the double plural 'gifts of healings' signify?
-
Each healing is its own gift. No one 'possesses' healing as a permanent ability.
Both nouns are plural in all three occurrences (12:9, 28, 30), and charisma names a concrete instance of grace. Fee and others take this to mean the gift comes freshly with each healing.
-
The plural refers to different kinds of healing for different illnesses, or is simply a fixed way of speaking. A person may still be regularly used to heal.
Plurals for abstract things are common in Greek, and 12:28 speaks of 'gifts of healings' in a list that also names people with recurring roles (apostles, prophets, teachers). The grammar alone cannot settle how lasting the gift is.
in v9
Does Paul's switch from ἄλλος to ἕτερος divide the list into groups?
-
Yes. ἕτερος opens new groups: gifts of speech (wisdom, knowledge), gifts of power and revelation (faith through discernment), and tongues with interpretation.
ἕτερος appears exactly at 'faith' (12:9) and 'kinds of tongues' (12:10), which are reasonable places for a break. Older commentators such as Robertson and Plummer proposed this.
-
No. The variation is stylistic.
In Koine Greek ἄλλος and ἕτερος often mean the same thing. The proposed groups do not fit the content neatly, and Paul's other gift lists (12:28–30; Rom 12:6–8) are ordered differently.
in v10
What exactly is "distinguishing of spirits"?
-
Weighing prophetic utterances in the assembly, judging whether a given word comes from God's Spirit.
It is placed right after prophecy, matching interpretation after tongues. In 14:29 the related verb diakrinō is used for weighing prophets' words. 1 Thess 5:20–21 pairs prophecy with testing. 14:12 and 14:32 use "spirits" for inspired impulses. (Held in various forms by Dunn, Fee, Grudem.)
-
A broader ability to recognise the spiritual source behind any phenomenon: God's Spirit, the human spirit, or demonic spirits.
The plural "spirits" and the warning about pagan inspiration in 12:2–3. 1 John 4:1 ("test the spirits"). Episodes such as Acts 16:16–18, where a spirit is behind seemingly true speech.
-
"Interpretation of Spirit-revelations", that is, explaining prophetic speech, in parallel with interpreting tongues.
Argued by G. Dautzenberg from the parallel with "interpretation of tongues". It has been widely criticised (e.g. by Grudem) because diakrisis normally means distinguishing or judging, not explaining.
in v10
Were "kinds of tongues" human languages or non-human speech?
-
Real human languages unknown to the speaker.
Acts 2:4–11, where hearers recognise their own languages. Paul's comparison with foreign languages in 14:10–11. The ordinary meaning of glōssa as "language".
-
Non-human or heavenly speech (or at least not necessarily a human language).
14:2 ("no one understands... he speaks mysteries in the Spirit"). 13:1 ("tongues of men and of angels"). Testament of Job 48–50 on angelic dialects. Paul's 14:10–11 is an analogy, which implies tongues are like foreign languages rather than the same as them.
-
Both; the "kinds" cover varied forms.
The plural genē ("kinds") and 13:1's "of men and of angels" may point to a range rather than one type.
in v10
Does the switch from allos to heteros group the gifts?
-
Yes: heteros starts new groups (wisdom/knowledge; faith through distinguishing of spirits; tongues and interpretation).
Heteros appears exactly at "faith" (v. 9) and "kinds of tongues" (v. 10), which produces three sensible groups. Older commentators such as Robertson & Plummer, and others, take this view.
-
No: it is stylistic variation.
In Koine Greek allos and heteros often overlap. Paul freely varies his lists (12:28–30; Rom 12:6–8), and the proposed groups do not fully hold together.
in v11
If the Spirit gives gifts "as he wills", should believers seek particular gifts?
-
The Spirit's free choice does not rule out seeking. Paul expects believers to desire gifts and ask for them.
12:31 and 14:1 ("be zealous for the greater gifts… especially that you may prophesy"), and 14:13 ("let the one who speaks in a tongue pray that he may interpret"). On this reading the Spirit's will and the believer's prayer work together.
-
The verse stresses that gifts are received, not chosen. Seeking a particular gift, especially a high-status one, works against Paul's point.
The emphasis on βούλεται here and on God's placing "as he willed" in 12:18. Some read 12:31 as a statement rather than a command ("you *are* zealous for the supposedly greater gifts"), Paul describing the Corinthians' rivalry before he corrects it in chapter 13. The Greek form can be read either way.
in v11
Does "as he wills" show that Paul thought of the Spirit as a personal agent?
-
Yes. Paul attributes will, purpose and distribution to the Spirit, and in verses 4–11 he puts the Spirit's activity on the same level as God's.
The verb βούλεται; the same verb ἐνεργέω used of God (v. 6) and of the Spirit (v. 11); the parallel triad of Spirit, Lord and God (vv. 4–6); and Romans 8:26–27, where the Spirit intercedes and has a "mind".
-
Paul's language comes from Jewish ways of speaking about God's own Spirit as God's active presence. Later creeds spelled out a distinct personhood in more technical terms than Paul himself uses.
Old Testament and Second Temple texts speak of God's Spirit acting and grieving (Isaiah 63:10) as an expression of God himself. Paul calls it the "Spirit of God" (12:3). Both views agree that Paul treats the Spirit's giving as God's own giving.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. φανέρωσις
- BDAG s.v. συμφέρω
- BDAG s.v. ἕκαστος
- Gordon D. Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NICNT)
- Anthony C. Thiselton, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NIGTC)
- David E. Garland, 1 Corinthians (BECNT)
- Margaret M. Mitchell, Paul and the Rhetoric of Reconciliation
- Dale B. Martin, The Corinthian Body
- Aristotle, Rhetoric 1.3; Politics 3.7 (1279a)
- Livy, History of Rome 2.32 (fable of the belly and the members)
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed.; Vulgate
- BDAG s.v. λόγος, σοφία, γνῶσις
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. γνῶσις
- James D. G. Dunn, Jesus and the Spirit
- Septuagint, Isaiah 11:2; Wisdom of Solomon 7–9
- Vulgate, 1 Corinthians 12:8
- BDAG s.v. πίστις, χάρισμα, ἴαμα, ἕτερος
- LSJ s.v. ἴαμα
- Gordon D. Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NICNT), on 12:8–10
- Anthony C. Thiselton, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NIGTC), on 12:9
- James D. G. Dunn, Jesus and the Spirit (1975), on charismata
- John Chrysostom, Homilies on 1 Corinthians 29
- Epidaurus healing inscriptions (IG IV² 1, 121–124), headed Ἰάματα
- Carl Roebuck, Corinth XIV: The Asklepieion and Lerna (1951)
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed. apparatus; Robinson-Pierpont Byzantine text
- Vulgate, 1 Cor 12:9
- BDAG s.v. ἐνέργημα, δύναμις, προφητεία, διάκρισις, γλῶσσα, ἑρμηνεία
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. διάκρισις
- Wayne Grudem, The Gift of Prophecy in 1 Corinthians
- Gerhard Dautzenberg, Urchristliche Prophetie
- Christopher Forbes, Prophecy and Inspired Speech in Early Christianity and Its Hellenistic Environment
- Plato, Timaeus 71e–72b
- Didache 11
- Testament of Job 48–50
- Tosefta Sotah 13:3
- Vulgate, 1 Cor 12:10
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament
- BDAG s.v. ἐνεργέω, διαιρέω, ἴδιος, βούλομαι
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. διαιρέω
- Septuagint Genesis 15:10 (διεῖλεν)
- Vulgate, 1 Corinthians 12:11
- Margaret M. Mitchell, Paul and the Rhetoric of Reconciliation (on the body image and unity speeches)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on 1 Corinthians 12
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).