1 Esdras Chapter 2 Read as one passage

1 Esdras 2:8–16

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

8Then the chief of the families of Judah and of the tribe of Benjamin stood up, with the priests, the Levites, and all whose spirit the Lord had stirred to go up, to build the house for the Lord which is in Jerusalem. 9Those who lived around them helped them in all things with silver and gold, with horses and cattle, and with very many gifts that were vowed by a great number whose minds were so moved. 10King Cyrus also brought out the holy vessels of the Lord, which Nabuchodonosor had carried away from Jerusalem and had stored in his temple of idols. 11Now when King Cyrus of the Persians had brought them out, he delivered them to Mithradates his treasurer, 12and by him they were delivered to Sanabassar the governor of Judea. 13This was the number of them: one thousand gold cups, one thousand silver cups, twenty-nine silver censers, thirty gold bowls, two thousand four hundred ten silver bowls, and one thousand other vessels. 14So all the vessels of gold and of silver were brought up, even five thousand four hundred seventy-nine, 15and were carried back by Sanabassar, together with the returning exiles, from Babylon to Jerusalem. 16In the time of King Artaxerxes of the Persians, Belemus, Mithradates, Tabellius, Rathumus, Beeltethmus, and Samellius the scribe, with their other associates, dwelling in Samaria and other places, wrote to him against those who lived in Judea and Jerusalem the following letter:

What the first hearers heard

For Greek-speaking Jews of the 2nd century BC, this verse opens a familiar story pattern: God's people begin restoring Jerusalem with royal permission (Cyrus, 2:1–15), and then jealous neighbours use the empire's own machinery to stop them.

  • It explained a delay. Why did the restoration stall after such a promising start? Not because God had abandoned the project, but because hostile officials slandered the builders to the king (the letter calls Jerusalem "rebellious and wicked", 2:18).
  • It framed the opposition as outsiders. The accusers are identified by office and by location: Samaria and "other places". They are distinct from "those who dwell in Judea and Jerusalem". This reinforced the identity of the returned community as the true heirs of Jerusalem, a live issue in the translator's own day, when Jerusalem and its neighbours competed for favour from Hellenistic kings.
  • It set up the reversal. The ban that follows (2:25–30) lasts only until Darius's second year. The next chapters show a wise young Judean, Zerubbabel, winning Darius's favour by arguing that truth is the strongest thing of all. Readers would hear this verse as the low point before God's vindication through a just king. The same pattern appears in Esther, Daniel and 3 Maccabees: Jews accused at a foreign court and then vindicated.
  • It sounded authentic. By quoting the "letter written below" with named officials, the book presents itself as drawing on real archives, as Ezra does. That gave Diaspora readers confidence that their history was documented in the empire's own records.

From the study of 1 Esdras 2:16.

Verse by verse

  1. 8Then the chief of the families of Judah and of the tribe of Benjamin stood up, with the priests, the Levites, and all whose spirit the Lord had stirred to go up, to build the house for the Lord which is in Jerusalem.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 9Those who lived around them helped them in all things with silver and gold, with horses and cattle, and with very many gifts that were vowed by a great number whose minds were so moved.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 10King Cyrus also brought out the holy vessels of the Lord, which Nabuchodonosor had carried away from Jerusalem and had stored in his temple of idols.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  4. 11Now when King Cyrus of the Persians had brought them out, he delivered them to Mithradates his treasurer,

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  5. 12and by him they were delivered to Sanabassar the governor of Judea.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  6. 13This was the number of them: one thousand gold cups, one thousand silver cups, twenty-nine silver censers, thirty gold bowls, two thousand four hundred ten silver bowls, and one thousand other vessels.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  7. 14So all the vessels of gold and of silver were brought up, even five thousand four hundred seventy-nine,

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  8. 15and were carried back by Sanabassar, together with the returning exiles, from Babylon to Jerusalem.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  9. 16In the time of King Artaxerxes of the Persians, Belemus, Mithradates, Tabellius, Rathumus, Beeltethmus, and Samellius the scribe, with their other associates, dwelling in Samaria and other places, wrote to him against those who lived in Judea and Jerusalem the following letter:

    "Then, in the reign of Artaxerxes, the Great King of Persia, a formal written complaint was lodged with him against the people settled in Judea and Jerusalem. It was drawn up by Belemus, Mithradates, Tabellius, Rathumus, Beeltethmus and the government secretary Samellius, together with all their fellow office-holders, officials based in Samaria and across the rest of the region. What follows is the letter, copied out below."

    The verse is the official heading of a document. Its tone is bureaucratic, not dramatic. The verb means to put on record, and with "against" it becomes a written accusation. The signatories are the officials of the neighbouring Persian province of Samaria and the wider western region, led by a senior officer and his secretary. They do not attack Jerusalem with soldiers. They go to the king with paperwork. The phrase "the letter written below" is the standard formula an archive used to introduce a copy, so the narrator is telling readers they are about to hear the accusers' own words (2:17–24).

    Two of the "names" are probably not people at all. The Greek translator took them from the Aramaic of Ezra 4:7–8. "Beeltethmus" is the Aramaic title be'el-te'em, "master of decree" (a chancellor or commander), which belonged to Rathumus/Rehum. "Belemus" stands for a word that may be a name or may mean "with the agreement of". For the first readers, the point is simply that the whole provincial establishment had lined up against the returned exiles. In this book's order of events, the result is that the work on Jerusalem and its temple is halted until Darius's second year (2:30).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v16

    Samellius the scribe

    grammateus

    What we hear
    A Jewish religious scholar, like the 'scribes and Pharisees' of the Gospels.
    What they heard
    A government secretary in the Persian provincial administration who drafted and filed official correspondence. A civil servant, not a teacher of the Law.
  • in v16

    dwelling in Samaria

    oikountes en Samareia

    What we hear
    The 'Samaritans', the religious community with its own temple on Mount Gerizim known from the Gospels (the Good Samaritan, the woman at the well).
    What they heard
    Officials and settlers based in the Persian province of Samaria, Judah's administrative neighbour. The verse is about provincial politics. It does not describe a separate religious sect, which emerged and hardened later.
Every word
  1. Ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v16

    Opens a time phrase, 'in the times of…', which is not finished until the word chronois several words later.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but, and, now · v16

    A light connective that marks a new episode after the list of Cyrus's returned temple vessels (2:15). Brenton and KJV read it as a contrast ('But'), which suits the move from royal favour to accusation.

  3. τοῖς

    tois · G3588

    the · v16

    Article belonging to chronois ('the times'), placed early so that the phrase 'under Artaxerxes…' sits between article and noun.

  4. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    upon, in the time of · v16

    With a ruler's name in the genitive, epi means 'in the reign of' or 'under'. This was the normal Greek way to date events by kings.

  5. Ἀρταξέρξου

    Artaxerxou

    Artaxerxes · v16

    The Persian Great King. In the parallel in Ezra 4:7 this is most likely Artaxerxes I (465–424 BC). 1 Esdras places him before Darius, which raises a chronological problem (see textual notes).

  6. Περσῶν

    Persōn

    Persians · v16

    'King of the Persians' is the standard Greek title for the Achaemenid ruler, who ruled the whole Near East including Judah and Samaria.

  7. βασιλέως

    basileōs · G935

    king · v16

    Stands beside Artaxerxes' name to identify him. He is the absolute authority to whom provincial officials answer.

  8. χρόνοις

    chronois · G5550

    times, period · v16

    Plural 'times', meaning 'the reign of'. It closes the dating phrase that began with En.

  9. κατέγραψαν

    kategrapsan · G2608

    wrote down, recorded, registered · v16

    'They put in writing.' It is a formal, documentary word, and the following kata ('against') turns the document into a written complaint.

  10. αὐτῷ

    autō · G846

    to him · v16

    The person addressed is the king. This is a petition sent up to the throne.

  11. κατὰ

    kata · G2596

    against · v16

    With the genitive kata means 'against'. The letter is an accusation, not a report.

  12. κατοικούντων

    katoikountōn · G2730

    dwell, be settled · v16

    'Those settled/residing'. The target is the whole resident community of Judah and Jerusalem, especially the returned exiles who were building.

  13. Ἰουδαίᾳ

    Ioudaia · G2449

    Judea · v16

    The small Persian province of Yehud around Jerusalem. The Greek name is the one the translator's own (Hellenistic) readers used.

  14. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v16

    Joins the province to its city.

  15. Ἱερουσαλὴμ

    Ierousalēm · G2419

    Jerusalem · v16

    The city whose rebuilding is the real issue of the letter (2:18).

  16. Βήλεμος

    Bēlemos

    Belemus · v16

    Treated as a personal name, it represents Ezra 4:7's bishlam. That word may itself be a name (Bishlam), or it may be an Aramaic phrase meaning 'in peace / with the agreement of' (see debates).

  17. Μιθραδάτης

    Mithradatēs

    Mithradates · v16

    A Persian name meaning 'given by Mithra' (Ezra 4:7 Mithredath). It points to a Persian official among the accusers.

  18. Ταβέλλιος

    Tabellios

    Tabellius · v16

    Ezra's Tabeel, an Aramaic name meaning 'God is good', given a Greco-Latin ending.

  19. Ῥάθυμος

    Rhathymos

    Rathumus · v16

    Ezra's Rehum, the leading official behind the letter (in 2:17 he is 'the recorder of events'). The Greek spelling happens to look like the adjective rhathymos, 'easy-going', but this is very probably a coincidence.

  20. Βεέλτεθμος

    Beeltethmos

    Beeltethmus · v16

    Not originally a person. It is Aramaic be'el-te'em, 'master of decree' (roughly 'chancellor' or 'commander'), which was Rehum's title in Ezra 4:8. Here it has become an extra name in the list.

  21. Σαμέλλιος

    Samellios

    Samellius · v16

    Ezra's Shimshai, the provincial secretary who drafted the document.

  22. γραμματεὺς

    grammateus · G1122

    scribe, secretary · v16

    A government secretary in the Persian provincial office, not a Jewish teacher of the Law.

  23. λοιποὶ

    loipoi · G3062

    rest, remaining · v16

    'The rest': the remaining officials and groups. It condenses the long list of peoples and offices in Ezra 4:9.

  24. τούτοις

    toutois · G3778

    these · v16

    'With these men', meaning the named officials.

  25. συντασσόμενοι

    syntassomenoi · G4929

    arranged together, ranked with, colleagues · v16

    Those 'ranked together with' them: their official colleagues in the administration (Aramaic kenawathon, 'their associates'). Brenton/KJV say 'in commission with them'.

  26. οἰκοῦντες

    oikountes · G3611

    living, residing · v16

    Places the accusers geographically. They are outsiders to Judah, based in the neighbouring administration.

  27. Σαμαρείᾳ

    Samareia · G4540

    Samaria · v16

    The Persian province (and city) of Samaria, Judah's larger northern neighbour and administrative rival.

  28. ἄλλοις

    allois · G243

    other · v16

    'Other places', a compression of Ezra 4:10's 'the rest of Beyond-the-River', the whole western province.

  29. τόποις

    topois · G5117

    places · v16

    Localities across the region, showing that the opposition was broad, not one town.

  30. ὑπογεγραμμένην

    hypogegrammenēn

    written below, subjoined · v16

    A perfect participle meaning 'the letter written out below'. It is a document formula that introduces the copy quoted in 2:17–24.

  31. ἐπιστολήν

    epistolēn · G1992

    letter, official dispatch · v16

    An official letter or dispatch to the king. The Greek is singular: one letter.

The world behind it

The Persian administrative world. After Cyrus let exiles return (538 BC), Judah (Yehud) was a small province of the vast western satrapy, the large regional governorate the Persians called "Beyond the River". Samaria to its north was older, larger and better connected. Provincial governors, military officers and secretaries wrote to the Great King in Imperial Aramaic, and the court checked archives before replying (2:21–22). A letter from a province's leading officials was a serious political move. The king's answer could stop a project dead.

Who the accusers were. In Ezra 4:9–10 the senders include judges, officials and peoples deported into Samaria by the Assyrian king "Osnappar" (Ashurbanipal). 1 Esdras compresses all this into "their associates, dwelling in Samaria and other places." These were imperial office-holders and settler populations with local interests. A walled, rebuilt Jerusalem would shift power and revenue in the region.

The translator's own world. 1 Esdras was produced in Greek, probably in the 2nd century BC, likely in Egypt or Judea under Ptolemaic or Seleucid rule. In the next verse (2:17) he renders "Beyond the River" as "Coelesyria and Phoenicia", the administrative name of his own day. In the same way he turned unfamiliar Aramaic titles into personal names. This is updating and some misunderstanding, not deliberate distortion.

Where the episode sits in the book. In Ezra 4 this letter is part of a run of grouped examples of opposition, gathered by theme from different reigns. 1 Esdras moves it to stand immediately after Cyrus's decree and before the famous contest of Darius's bodyguards (chapters 3–4). As a result, the book's storyline makes Artaxerxes come before Darius.

From the study of 1 Esdras 2:16.

Where scholars differ

in v16

Is 'Belemus' (Ezra's bishlam) a person or a phrase?

  • A personal name, Bishlam/Belemus.

    1 Esdras and Josephus treat it as a name, and it heads a list of names in Ezra 4:7. Most English versions of Ezra print 'Bishlam'.

  • A phrase, be-shelam, 'in peace / with the agreement of (Mithredath)'.

    The other Greek version of Ezra (2 Esdras 4:7) translates it 'in peace'. Shelam occurs in Aramaic letter greetings. A phrase reading makes Mithredath the lead author, which explains the singular verb 'wrote' in Hebrew Ezra 4:7.

in v16

Is 1 Esdras a rearranged retelling of Ezra–Nehemiah, or a witness to an earlier edition?

  • A later compilation that rearranged and expanded Ezra (e.g. moving this letter and adding the bodyguards' contest).

    The chronological confusion (Artaxerxes before Darius) looks like the result of editing. The merged list of names and the mistranslated titles suggest someone working from Ezra's text (Williamson, Talshir).

  • It preserves an earlier or alternative edition of the Ezra material from before the canonical Ezra–Nehemiah took its final shape.

    1 Esdras lacks Nehemiah entirely, has its own distinct order of events, and in places seems to reflect a different Hebrew/Aramaic text (Pohlmann, Böhler).

Sources
  • Brenton, The Septuagint with Apocrypha (1851), 1 Esdras 2:16
  • Hanhart, R., Esdrae liber I, Septuaginta Göttingen vol. VIII/1 (1974)
  • Talshir, Z., I Esdras: A Text Critical Commentary (2001)
  • Williamson, H. G. M., Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16, 1985), on Ezra 4:7–10
  • Myers, J. M., I and II Esdras (Anchor Bible 42, 1974)
  • Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 11.21–30
  • LSJ s.v. καταγράφω, συντάσσω, ὑπογράφω
  • BDAG s.v. γραμματεύς
  • HALOT (Aramaic) s.v. בְּעֵל טְעֵם, שְׁלָם
  • LXX 2 Esdras (Ezra) 4:7–8

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

8 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.