Ezra Chapter 4 Read as one passage
Ezra 4:9–10
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
9From Rehum the commander, Shimshai the scribe, and the rest of their associates—the judges and officials over Tripolis, Persia, Erech and Babylon, the Elamites of Susa, 10and the rest of the peoples whom the great and honorable Ashurbanipal deported and settled in the cities of Samaria and elsewhere west of the Euphrates.
What the first hearers heard
For Jews in Judah in the Persian period and later, who read or heard Ezra, this verse did several things:
- It established the documents as genuine. The book stresses that it quotes real imperial correspondence, in the empire's own language and with its own titles. The heap of officials' names, unfamiliar to Hebrew ears, sounded like an authentic archive copy. It showed that the obstacles to rebuilding were real and recorded.
- It showed how heavy the opposition was. A senior official, a professional secretary, judges, commissioners and whole communities all write to the king together. The small returned community in Jerusalem faced the combined bureaucracy of the region, and the outcome (4:23, work forcibly stopped) proved how strong that coalition was.
- It drew an identity line. The writers present themselves as descendants of peoples from Uruk, Babylon, Susa and Elam whom an Assyrian king planted in Samaria. That echoes their own claim in 4:2 ("we have sacrificed to him since the days of Esarhaddon… who brought us here"). For the narrator they are not heirs of Israel's covenant, however much they claim to worship Israel's God. Their own letterhead confirms the book's case for why the returnees refused their help (4:3).
- It showed loyalty to the empire as a weapon. By listing their origins as people settled by imperial policy, the writers present themselves as the empire's reliable subjects, in contrast to Jerusalem, "the rebellious and wicked city" (4:12). Ezra's readers would have recognised the argument: in a world run by Persia, the question of whose loyalty the king trusted decided what could be built.
From the study of Ezra 4:9.
Verse by verse
-
9From Rehum the commander, Shimshai the scribe, and the rest of their associates—the judges and officials over Tripolis, Persia, Erech and Babylon, the Elamites of Susa,
Full study →Then, at the head of the letter, stood its senders: Rehum, the official in charge of reports and orders for the province, and Shimshai the secretary who drafted it, and all their fellow officials: the judges, the envoys, the other officers (or "the men of Tripolis"), the Persians (or one more class of Persian official), together with the people of Uruk, the people of Babylon, and the people of Susa, that is, the Elamites…
The sentence carries on into verse 10: "…and the rest of the peoples whom the great and noble Osnappar deported and settled in the cities of Samaria and the rest of the province Beyond the River." The verse has no verb of its own. It reads like the heading of a formal state letter, listing everyone who claims to speak.
The original hearers would have taken in two things. The first is weight: an official with authority to report, a professional secretary, a body of colleagues, judges and commissioners. All of the region's bureaucracy has lined up behind this complaint to the king. The second is origin: the communities named come from Uruk, Babylon and Susa in Mesopotamia and Elam, far to the east. They are descendants of people the Assyrians transplanted into the hill country of Samaria. The opponents name themselves by where their ancestors came from, and for the book of Ezra that is the point: they are not Israel. Several words that older English versions print as strange tribal names ("Dinaites," "Apharsathchites," "Dehavites") are really job titles or the small phrase "that is." The verse lists officials and resettled communities. It is not a list of mysterious lost tribes.
-
10and the rest of the peoples whom the great and honorable Ashurbanipal deported and settled in the cities of Samaria and elsewhere west of the Euphrates.
Full study →"…and all the other peoples whom Osnappar, the great and illustrious king of Assyria (Ashurbanipal), uprooted from their homelands and forcibly resettled in the city of Samaria and throughout the rest of the imperial province called 'Beyond-the-River' (everything west of the Euphrates). And now: [here begins the letter's business]."
The verse ends the list of people sending a hostile letter to the Persian king Artaxerxes. The writers make three claims. First, numbers: it is not just a few officials writing but "the rest" of the peoples and "the rest" of the whole province. Second, pedigree: they were planted here by a "great and honored" king, so they are long-settled subjects placed by royal decree. Third, loyalty: they speak the empire's own administrative language. The two verbs describe forced relocation, uprooting and replanting, which is how Assyria ruled conquered lands. The closing "and now" is the stock phrase of an Aramaic letter as it moves from greeting to business, a sign that the book is quoting real correspondence.
Where the English drifted
-
in v9
Dinaites, Apharsathchites, Tarpelites, Apharsites (KJV, WEB)
dînāyēʾ, ʾăpharsatkāyēʾ, ṭarpĕlāyēʾ, ʾăphārsāyēʾ
- What we hear
- Four obscure ancient tribes or nations living in Samaria.
- What they heard
- Probably mostly official titles: judges, envoys or commissioners, other officers, and Persians or a further class of Persian official. Several are loanwords from Persian administrative language.
-
in v9
the Dehavites (KJV) / the Dehaites (WEB)
dĕhûʾ (Qere) / dhyʾ (written)
- What we hear
- Yet another people group, separate from the Elamites.
- What they heard
- 'That is', an explanatory note: 'the men of Susa, that is, the Elamites.'
-
in v9
chancellor (KJV, WEB)
bĕʿēl ṭĕʿēm
- What we hear
- A head of government (as in Germany) or the head of a university.
- What they heard
- A provincial official, 'master of report/order', responsible for official orders and reports to higher authority.
-
in v9
companions (KJV, WEB, YLT)
kĕnāwāt
- What we hear
- Friends or personal companions.
- What they heard
- Colleagues in office: fellow officials co-signing an administrative document.
-
in v10
on this side the river (KJV)
avar naharah
- What we hear
- The near side of a river, from the speaker's own point of view, perhaps the Jordan.
- What they heard
- The official name of the Persian province west of the Euphrates, i.e. 'across the River' as seen from Mesopotamia and Persia.
-
in v10
at such a time (KJV, YLT)
u-khe'enet
- What we hear
- A date, or a note that the letter was sent 'at a certain time'.
- What they heard
- 'And now', the fixed phrase in Aramaic letters that moves from greeting to business.
-
in v10
brought over (KJV, WEB)
hagli
- What we hear
- Brought over or transported, possibly as willing migrants.
- What they heard
- Deported: forcibly sent into exile by a conquering king.
Every word
-
אֱדַ֜יִן
ʾĕdayin · H0116
then · v9
A connecting word ('then, at that time') common in Ezra's Aramaic narrative. There is no main verb, so it most likely opens the formal heading of the letter that v. 8 just mentioned. KJV supplies '[wrote]' to make a sentence.
-
רְח֣וּם
rĕḥûm · H7348B
Rehum · v9
A personal name from the root for compassion ('pitied' or 'beloved'). It was a common West Semitic name, and Jews bore it too (Nehemiah 3:17). Here it names the senior imperial official who heads the letter.
-
בְּעֵל־
bĕʿēl- · H1169
lord, owner, master of · v9
'Master of', the first half of a fixed official title. It does not mean 'Baal' the god. It is the ordinary word for an owner or holder of something.
-
טְעֵ֗ם
ṭĕʿēm · H2942
decree, report, judgment · v9
With the word before it, 'master of report/order': an official who handled official reports and orders in the province. The title is borrowed from Akkadian bēl ṭēmi.
-
וְשִׁמְשַׁי֙
wĕšimšay · H8124
Shimshai · v9
'And Shimshai', a name probably built on šemeš, 'sun' (perhaps 'my sun' or 'sunny'). He is the second named author.
-
סָֽפְרָ֔א
sāprāʾ · H5613
scribe, secretary · v9
'The scribe': the professional secretary who drafted, wrote and filed official correspondence in Aramaic. He is not a Torah scholar the way Ezra is called a 'scribe'.
-
וּשְׁאָ֖ר
ûšĕʾār · H7606
remainder, rest · v9, v10
'And the rest of': it brings in the whole body of co-signers behind the two named men.
-
כְּנָוָתְה֑וֹן
kĕnāwātĕhôn · H3675
colleague, associate · v9
'Their colleagues': a technical word in Persian-era Aramaic for fellow officials of the same rank or office. It is not 'friends' or 'companions' in a social sense.
-
דִּ֠ינָיֵא
dînāyēʾ · H1784
judges (traditionally 'Dinaites') · v9
Most likely 'the judges', from dîn, 'judgment'. The traditional vowel marks treat it as the name of a people ('Dinaites'), but no such people is known, and an official title fits the list better.
-
וַאֲפַרְסַתְכָיֵ֞א
waʾăpharsatkāyēʾ · H0671B
envoys, officials (traditionally 'Apharsathchites') · v9
'And the envoys/officials': probably an Old Persian title for a kind of commissioned official, perhaps an envoy or investigator. KJV turned it into a people, the 'Apharsathchites'.
-
טַרְפְּלָיֵ֣א
ṭarpĕlāyēʾ · H2967
officials (?) / men of Tripolis (?) · v9
Meaning uncertain. It is either another official title (so the supplied gloss 'officials') or people of a place, sometimes identified as Tripolis on the Phoenician coast (so BSB).
-
אֲפָֽרְסָיֵ֗א
ʾăphārsāyēʾ · H0670
Persians (?) · v9
Read either as 'the Persians' or as one more Persian official title. Some scholars emend it to 'Sipparites', men of the Babylonian city of Sippar. The supplied in-context gloss gives that reading, although its lemma gloss says 'Persian'.
-
אַרְכְּוָיֵ֤א
ʾarkĕwāyēʾ · H0756
men of Erech (Uruk) · v9
'The men of Erech', the ancient city of Uruk in southern Babylonia (Genesis 10:10). These are descendants of people deported from there.
-
בָבְלָיֵא֙
bāblāyēʾ · H0896
Babylonians · v9
'The Babylonians': descendants of deportees from the city of Babylon who had been resettled in the west.
-
שֽׁוּשַׁנְכָיֵ֔א
šûšankāyēʾ · H7801
men of Susa · v9
'The men of Susa', the old Elamite capital and later a Persian royal city. The -k- in the word is a Persian-style ending for 'people of a place'.
-
דֶּהָיֵ֖א
dĕhāyēʾ (read dĕhûʾ) · H1723
that is (traditionally 'Dehavites') · v9
The scribes' reading (Qere) is dĕhûʾ, 'that is'. It works as an explanatory note: 'the men of Susa, that is, the Elamites'. The written consonants were taken in KJV as yet another people, the 'Dehavites'.
-
עֵלְמָיֵֽא׃
ʿēlĕmāyēʾ · H5962
Elamites · v9
'The Elamites': people from Elam, the land east of Babylonia whose capital was Susa. With the word before it, this explains who the 'men of Susa' are.
-
אֻמַּיָּא
ummayya · H0524
the peoples, nations · v10
Ethnic groups, meaning communities of shared descent and origin. Here these are the transplanted population groups listed in v. 9 (Babylonians, people of Susa, Elamites and others). They are not states.
-
דִּי
di · H1768
which, whom · v10
Relative particle introducing what was done to these peoples.
-
הַגְלִי
hagli · H1541
deported, carried into exile · v10
A causative form of a root whose basic sense is 'uncover, lay bare'. In this causative form it means 'to make go into exile, deport'. It is the vocabulary of Assyrian mass relocation of conquered peoples.
-
אָסְנַפַּר
Osnappar · H0620
Osnappar (= Ashurbanipal) · v10
A shortened Aramaic form of an Assyrian royal name. It is almost universally identified with Ashurbanipal (Aššur-bāni-apli), king of Assyria 668–c. 631 BC.
-
רַבָּא
rabba · H7229
the great · v10
A royal honorific. It echoes the Assyrian kings' standard title 'great king' (šarru rabû).
-
וְיַקִּירָא
we-yaqqira · H3358
and the honored, noble · v10
Literally 'weighty, precious'. Here it is an honorific, 'the illustrious'. The writers speak of the Assyrian conqueror with respect because their own standing in the land rests on his decree.
-
וְהוֹתֵב
we-hotev · H3488
and he settled · v10
Causative of 'sit, dwell': 'he made them dwell'. This is the second half of Assyrian deportation policy: remove a population, then plant it somewhere else.
-
הִמּוֹ
himmo · H1994
them · v10
Object pronoun referring back to the deported peoples.
-
בְּקִרְיָה
be-qiryah · H7149
in the city, town · v10
Singular in the Aramaic text: 'in the city of Samaria'. Ancient translations read 'cities' (see variants).
-
שָׁמְרָיִן
Shamrayin · H8115
Samaria · v10
The Aramaic name of the old northern Israelite capital. In the Persian period it was also the name of the province governed from it, and it is attested in contemporary Aramaic papyri as šmryn.
-
עֲבַר־
Avar- · H5675
the region beyond, across · v10
First half of a fixed administrative name: 'Beyond-the-River'.
-
נַהֲרָה
Naharah · H5103G
the River (Euphrates) · v10
'The River' with no further name is the Euphrates. Avar-Naharah is the official Persian name of the province west of the Euphrates (Syria-Palestine), named from the point of view of the imperial centre in Mesopotamia and Persia.
-
וּכְעֶנֶת
u-khe'enet · H3706
and now · v10
The standard phrase in Aramaic letters that closes the address and greeting and moves into the business of the letter. It shows that the narrator is quoting, or splicing together, an actual letter heading.
The world behind it
The Aramaic switch. At 4:8 the book changes from Hebrew to Aramaic. Aramaic was the working language of the Persian Empire's administration, written from Egypt to India. Ezra quotes official correspondence in that language (4:8–6:18), and this verse is the opening of such a document. Imperial letters began by naming the senders and their colleagues. Papyri from the Jewish garrison at Elephantine in Egypt open the same way ("X and his colleagues…").
The province 'Beyond the River.' Seen from Mesopotamia, everything west of the Euphrates (Syria, Phoenicia, Samaria, Judah) was "Beyond the River" (ʿĂbar-Nahărāh). Samaria was the leading provincial centre near Jerusalem, and its officials had good reason to resist a rebuilt, walled Jerusalem that could compete with them.
Out of chronological order. The letter is addressed to Artaxerxes (most likely Artaxerxes I, 465–424 BC) and concerns rebuilding Jerusalem's walls (4:12). Chapter 4 as a whole is about rebuilding the temple under Darius (520–515 BC). The writer has collected examples of opposition from several reigns (4:5–7) to show a pattern, so this letter comes from decades after the surrounding events.
Who the deportees were. Assyria deported conquered peoples and resettled them elsewhere to break up local loyalties. After Samaria fell in 722 BC, Assyrian kings brought in people from Babylon, Cuthah and other places (2 Kings 17:24). Ezra 4:2 mentions settlement under Esarhaddon, and 4:10 credits "Osnappar," almost certainly Ashurbanipal (668–c. 627 BC). The list fits his wars closely: he crushed the Babylonian revolt of his brother Shamash-shum-ukin (652–648 BC) and sacked Susa, Elam's capital (c. 647 BC). Deportees from Babylon, Uruk and Susa are exactly what those campaigns would have produced. Two centuries later, their descendants still identified themselves by those origins in an official letter.
From the study of Ezra 4:9.
Where scholars differ
in v9
Are dînāyēʾ, ʾăpharsatkāyēʾ, ṭarpĕlāyēʾ and ʾăphārsāyēʾ ethnic groups or official titles?
-
Ethnic or place names, as the vowel marks indicate (Dinaites, Apharsathchites, Tarpelites, Apharsites).
They share the gentilic ending -āyēʾ with the undoubted city-names that follow (Erech, Babylon, Susa). This is how the Masoretes, the Greek versions, the Vulgate and the KJV tradition read them.
-
Mostly or entirely official titles (judges, envoys, officials, Persians or inspectors), followed by the communities descended from deportees.
dînāyēʾ fits the common Aramaic dîn, 'judgment', and no 'Dinaite' people is known. ʾăpharsatkāyēʾ and its relative ʾăpharsĕkāyēʾ (5:6; 6:6) look like Old Persian administrative terms. Opening with officials and then naming communities matches how Persian-era letters list senders. This is the majority view in modern lexicons and commentaries (e.g., HALOT, Williamson, Blenkinsopp), but the exact meaning of each title remains uncertain.
in v9
What does ṭarpĕlāyēʾ mean?
-
'Men of Tripolis', the Phoenician city.
The consonants resemble the Greek place-name, and a Phoenician coastal group would suit a coalition from 'Beyond the River'. This is BSB's choice. Against it: the city name is Greek, and its existence as early as the 5th century BC is debated.
-
An official title of uncertain origin ('officials').
It stands between two other probable titles, and no deportation from Tripolis is known. The supplied gloss follows this view. No proposed derivation has won general agreement.
in v9
Does ʾăphārsāyēʾ mean 'Persians', a title, or 'Sipparites'?
-
'Persians'
The simplest reading of the Masoretic text, followed by several modern versions.
-
An Old Persian title (e.g., 'inspectors' or 'secretaries')
Its similarity to ʾăpharsĕkāyēʾ (5:6; 6:6), and ethnic Persians are unlikely among people deported by Assyria. NASB follows a version of this.
-
'Sipparites', by emendation
It would match the Assyrian resettlement from Sepharvaim/Sippar (2 Kings 17:24). It has no support in manuscripts.
in v10
Who is 'Osnappar'?
-
Ashurbanipal, king of Assyria (668–c. 631 BC). This is the majority view.
The name can plausibly be traced to Aššur-bāni-apli. His campaigns against Babylon and Susa/Elam match the peoples listed in v. 9. Ancient versions support a form 'snpr.
-
Another Assyrian king (e.g. Esarhaddon, named in Ezra 4:2) or an Assyrian official acting for the king.
Esarhaddon is the king the opponents themselves cite in 4:2. Rab can be a title for an official. However, the sound correspondence is poor, and the pair of epithets reads like royal praise.
in v10
How should the closing u-khe'enet be understood?
-
The letter-formula 'and now', marking where the body of a quoted letter began.
There are close parallels in Elephantine and other Persian-period Aramaic letters, and in Ezra 4:11, 4:17 and 7:12.
-
An editorial 'etc.', meaning the narrator abbreviated the list of senders or the heading.
It stands awkwardly at the end of a list, and v. 11 restarts the address. These two views can be combined: the formula is left in as a marker where the narrator cut the text.
Sources
- HALOT (Koehler–Baumgartner), Aramaic section, s.v. בְּעֵל, טְעֵם, כְּנָת, דִּינַי, אֲפַרְסַתְכָי, טַרְפְּלָי, אֲפָרְסָי, דְּהוּא
- BDB, Biblical Aramaic section, s.v. טְעֵם and כְּנָת
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16, 1985), on Ezra 4:7–11
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library, 1988), on Ezra 4:8–10
- F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT, 1982)
- L. S. Fried, Ezra: A Commentary (2015), on the Aramaic correspondence and Persian titles
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt (TAD A4.7 = Cowley 30, 'Jedaniah and his colleagues')
- F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic, on Persian loanwords
- 1 Esdras 2:16 (Greek) and Septuagint 2 Esdras 4:9, for early reception
- 2 Kings 17:24; Ezra 4:2, 10 (resettlement of Samaria)
- BDB (Aramaic section) s.v. גְּלָה, יְתִב, כְּעֶנֶת, עֲבַר
- HALOT (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. אָסְנַפַּר, יַקִּיר, קִרְיָה
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra-Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT)
- J. A. Fitzmyer, 'Some Notes on Aramaic Epistolography', JBL 93 (1974)
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt, A4.7 (Elephantine petition naming the governor of Samaria)
- Septuagint 2 Esdras 4:10; Vulgate Ezra 4:10; 1 Esdras 2:16
- 2 Kings 17:24; Ezra 4:2; 5:12
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).