2 Chronicles Chapter 34 Read as one passage

2 Chronicles 34:4–7

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

4Then in his presence the altars of the Baals were torn down, and he cut to pieces the incense altars that were above them. He shattered the Asherah poles, the carved idols, and the cast images, crushed them to dust, and scattered them over the graves of those who had sacrificed to them. 5Then he burned the bones of the priests on their altars. So he cleansed Judah and Jerusalem. 6Josiah did the same in the cities of Manasseh, Ephraim, and Simeon, as far as Naphtali, and in the ruins around them. 7He tore down the altars and Asherah poles, crushed the idols to powder, and cut to pieces all the incense altars throughout the land of Israel. Then he returned to Jerusalem.

What the first hearers heard

The Chronicler's readers were Judeans of the Persian period, gathered around a rebuilt but modest temple. For them this verse showed what "seeking the God of David" (34:3) looked like in action. It is not just inner piety. It is the complete and public removal of rival worship, done in the presence of the king and in the vocabulary of Deuteronomy.

Several points would have registered:

  • Completeness. The list of objects (altars, incense altars, Asherahs, carved and cast images) covers every kind of forbidden cult. The verbs move from tearing down, to hacking, to shattering, to grinding into dust, so nothing survives in any usable form.
  • Covenant obedience. The verbs echo Deuteronomy's commands (Deut 7:5; 12:3) and the curse in Lev 26:30. Josiah does what the Torah required, and like Moses with the calf he grinds the idols to powder.
  • Purity. The verse belongs to a cleansing narrative: "he began to cleanse" (34:3) and "so he cleansed Judah and Jerusalem" (34:5). Throwing the dust on graves takes the defiled objects out of the land's sacred life and puts them where impurity belongs.
  • Poetic justice. The dead who sacrificed to these gods have them scattered over their own graves. The worshipers and what they worshiped end up together, under the same contamination.

Readers who knew that Judah had fallen to Babylon only a generation after Josiah would also feel the pathos: even this most complete reform did not avert the coming judgment (34:24–28).

From the study of 2 Chronicles 34:4.

Verse by verse

  1. 4Then in his presence the altars of the Baals were torn down, and he cut to pieces the incense altars that were above them. He shattered the Asherah poles, the carved idols, and the cast images, crushed them to dust, and scattered them over the graves of those who had sacrificed to them.

    With the king standing there watching, crews tore apart the altars where Judah had slaughtered animals to the Baals, the many local "Lords" of storm and fertility. Josiah himself hacked down the cult fixtures (most likely small incense altars) that stood high on top of those altars. Then came the whole set of objects verse 3 had listed: the wooden poles of the goddess Asherah, the images carved from wood or stone, and the images cast from molten metal. He smashed them, ground the pieces until they were fine as dust, as Moses had done with the golden calf, and threw the powder across the graves of the people who had once offered sacrifices to them.

    The verse starts and ends with sacrifice ("altars", then "those who sacrificed"), and it starts and ends with a "face": the king's face overseeing the work, and the face (surface) of the graves receiving the dust. In Israel's purity laws the grave was the most defiling place there was. The gods that had been fed with sacrifices are reduced to powder and buried with their worshipers in uncleanness. The reform is thorough and public, and it is carried out in the very words of Deuteronomy's command to "tear down their altars, smash their pillars, cut down their Asherim" (Deut 7:5; 12:3).

    Full study →
  2. 5Then he burned the bones of the priests on their altars. So he cleansed Judah and Jerusalem.

    "And the bones of the priests — the men who had served at those altars — he burned up on their own altars. In this way he made Judah and Jerusalem clean again."

    The sentence opens with the bones, so the eye goes straight to the grim image. Josiah's men have just smashed the Baal altars and scattered the dust of the idols over the graves of their worshippers (v. 4). Now the dead priests of those cults are dug out of their tombs and their remains burned on the very altars where they once offered sacrifice.

    To an Israelite this did two things at once:

    • It shamed the dead. Dead people were expected to rest undisturbed with their ancestors. Digging up and burning someone's bones was one of the worst insults possible (compare Amos 2:1; Jer 8:1–2).
    • It wrecked the altars for good. Under Israel's purity laws, human bones were the strongest source of uncleanness (Num 19:16). An altar with human bones burned on it could never be used for worship again.

    The closing words, "and he purified Judah and Jerusalem," turn this desecration into a cleansing. The idolatrous worship had polluted the land itself. By making the false altars permanently unclean, Josiah restored the land's purity before the LORD. Readers who knew the older story would also hear a prophecy coming true: three centuries earlier a man of God had cried out against the altar at Bethel that a Davidic king named Josiah would burn human bones on it (1 Kgs 13:2).

    Full study →
  3. 6Josiah did the same in the cities of Manasseh, Ephraim, and Simeon, as far as Naphtali, and in the ruins around them.

    And in the towns of Manasseh, Ephraim and Simeon, all the way up to Naphtali, he did the same: [working] with their blades — or, [even] in their ruined sites — on every side.

    The verse has no verb of its own. It takes the actions just described for Judah and Jerusalem and carries them into the old northern territories: cutting down altars and sacred poles, smashing images, grinding them to dust, burning the bones of the shrine priests. The list of tribes runs from Simeon in the far south, through Manasseh and Ephraim in the heartland, to Naphtali in far Galilee. It is meant to say the whole land of Israel, every tribe. That land had been an Assyrian province for about a century, and now a king of David's line was purifying it again.

    The last phrase is unclear in the Hebrew. The scribes' vowels say 'with their blades', meaning the tools of demolition. A one-vowel change gives 'in their ruins', meaning places still lying waste since Assyria's conquest. Either way, the picture is a reform that went into every corner, 'all around'. Verse 7 sums it up: 'throughout all the land of Israel.'

    Full study →
  4. 7He tore down the altars and Asherah poles, crushed the idols to powder, and cut to pieces all the incense altars throughout the land of Israel. Then he returned to Jerusalem.

    He demolished the altars, the many local places of sacrifice, including those of the Baals. The Asherahs, wooden poles or carved tree-symbols standing for the goddess Asherah, and the carved cult images he hammered to pieces and kept grinding until they were dust, just as Moses once ground the golden calf to powder. Every one of the smaller cult fixtures, probably the incense altars that stood above the Baal altars, he hacked down as with an axe. He did this across the whole land of Israel, reaching even into the old northern tribal lands that had long been under Assyrian rule. Then he came back to Jerusalem.

    The verbs come straight from Deuteronomy's command to "tear down their altars … hack down their Asherahs … burn their carved images" (Deut 7:5; 12:3). Josiah is shown carrying out that command point by point. The word for grinding things to powder recalls Moses and the golden calf, so the king undoes Israel's first great idolatry. The repeated "all" (all the incense altars, all the land) makes the purge complete. The final "he returned to Jerusalem" closes the circuit: the king goes out from the one legitimate sanctuary, clears the land, and returns to it. That return sets up the next scene, the cleansing and repair of the temple (v. 8).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v4

    groves (KJV)

    ʾasherim

    What we hear
    Natural clumps of trees or woodland where worship took place.
    What they heard
    Man-made cult objects (wooden poles or stylized trees) standing for the goddess Asherah, set up at shrines and altars.
  • in v4

    images that were on high above them (KJV)

    ḥammanim

    What we hear
    Statues or pictures of a god placed over the altars.
    What they heard
    A specific cult fixture, most likely a small incense altar, set on or above the sacrificial altar. Its exact form is uncertain.
  • in v4

    Baal / Baalim

    beʿalim

    What we hear
    The personal name of one specific pagan god.
    What they heard
    A title, 'Lord/Master/Owner', used for the storm-and-fertility god in his many local forms. The plural means numerous local Baal cults.
  • in v5

    cleansed / purged

    vaytaher (taher, piel)

    What we hear
    A moral clean-up or general reform. With 'purged', possibly a political purge in which people are eliminated.
    What they heard
    He restored the ritual purity of the land: its fitness to be the place where the LORD is worshipped. Idolatry had polluted the land, and making the rival altars unclean removed that pollution.
  • in v7

    groves (KJV)

    ʾăšērîm

    What we hear
    Stands of trees, natural woods or orchards where worship took place.
    What they heard
    Man-made wooden cult objects (carved poles or stylised trees) standing for the goddess Asherah, often set up beside an altar.
  • in v7

    idols (KJV, for the ḥammānîm)

    ḥammānîm

    What we hear
    Generic statues of gods, the same thing as the 'graven images' just mentioned.
    What they heard
    A specific item of cult equipment, most likely small incense altars (possibly 'sun-pillars' or small shrines), distinct from the carved images.
  • in v7

    Asherah poles

    ʾăšērîm

    What we hear
    Plain wooden posts, a minor piece of pagan décor.
    What they heard
    Objects standing for a major goddess. In popular Israelite religion she was sometimes linked with Yahweh himself, so removing them was theologically and socially weighty.
  • in v7

    the land of Israel

    ʾereṣ yiśrāʾēl

    What we hear
    Either the modern state or simply the Israelite people in general.
    What they heard
    The traditional tribal territory treated as one whole, here especially the former northern kingdom that had been an Assyrian province since 722 BC.
Every word
  1. וַיְנַתְּצ֣וּ

    vayenattetsu · H5422

    tear down, demolish · v4, v7

    An intensive verb form: they knocked the altars apart, stone from stone. The subject is an unnamed 'they', the work crews, while the following verbs credit the king himself.

  2. לְפָנָ֗יו

    lefanav · H6440

    before, in front of (lit. 'to his face') · v4

    'In his presence': Josiah stood by and oversaw the demolition. The destruction was a public royal act, not something delegated and forgotten.

  3. אֵ֚ת

    ʾet · H853

    marker of the definite direct object · v4, v5, v7

    Not translated. It marks 'the altars of the Baals' as the object of the tearing down.

  4. מִזְבְּח֣וֹת

    mizbeḥot · H4196

    altar (lit. 'place of slaughter') · v4, v5, v7

    Altars for animal sacrifice. The word comes from the same root as 'those who sacrificed' at the end of the verse, so the verse begins and ends with sacrifice.

  5. הַבְּעָלִ֔ים

    habbeʿalim · H1168

    Baal; 'lord, owner, master' · v4

    Plural, 'the Baals': the many local forms of the storm-and-fertility god worshiped at different shrines. Manasseh, Josiah's grandfather, had built these altars (2 Chr 33:3).

  6. וְהַֽחַמָּנִ֛ים

    vehaḥammanim · H2553

    incense altar (traditionally 'sun image') · v4, v7

    Cult objects placed on or above the Baal altars. Most modern scholars take them as small incense altars, though the exact meaning is debated (see Debates).

  7. אֲשֶׁר־

    ʾasher · H834

    which, that · v4

    Introduces the description of where the hammanim stood.

  8. לְמַ֥עְלָה

    lemaʿlah · H4605

    upward, above · v4

    Together with the next word: 'high above them'. The objects stood elevated on or over the altars.

  9. מֵעֲלֵיהֶ֖ם

    meʿalehem · H5921

    from upon them, above them · v4, v5

    'Them' refers to the Baal altars. Hebrew stacks prepositions here ('upward from upon them') to stress how high and prominent these objects were.

  10. גִּדֵּ֑עַ

    giddeaʿ · H1438

    hew down, cut off, chop to pieces · v4, v7

    An intensive form: he hacked them down. This is the verb Deuteronomy uses for destroying Canaanite cult objects (Deut 7:5; 12:3).

  11. וְ֠הָאֲשֵׁרִים

    vehaʾasherim · H842

    Asherah; the cult object of the goddess Asherah · v4, v7

    Wooden poles or stylized trees standing for the goddess Asherah. The object list repeats verse 3 word for word: the purge does exactly what that verse announced.

  12. וְהַפְּסִלִ֤ים

    vehappesilim · H6456

    carved image · v4, v7

    Images shaped by carving wood or stone (from the verb 'to hew, carve').

  13. וְהַמַּסֵּכוֹת֙

    vehammassekhot · H4541

    cast (molten) image · v4

    Images made by pouring molten metal into a mold. Together with 'carved images' it covers idols made by either method, so none is left out.

  14. שִׁבַּ֣ר

    shibbar · H7665

    break, shatter · v4

    An intensive form: he smashed them into fragments. In the Hebrew the objects come before this verb, which puts the emphasis on the list of what was destroyed.

  15. וְהֵדַ֔ק

    vehedaq · H1854

    crush fine, pulverize · v4, v7

    'He made them fine', i.e. ground to dust. This recalls Moses grinding the golden calf 'until it was fine as dust' (Deut 9:21; Exod 32:20).

  16. וַיִּזְרֹק֙

    vayyizroq · H2236

    throw, toss, scatter, sprinkle · v4

    He tossed the dust out. This is also the ordinary priestly word for dashing sacrificial blood against the altar, which may be a deliberate ironic echo.

  17. הַקְּבָרִ֔ים

    haqqevarim · H6913

    grave, tomb · v4

    Burial sites. In Israelite purity law these were sources of the most severe ritual impurity (Num 19:16).

  18. הַזֹּבְחִ֖ים

    hazzovḥim · H2076

    sacrifice (slaughter an animal for offering) · v4

    'The ones who sacrificed': the dead worshipers of these gods. The verse ends with the same root it began with in 'altars'.

  19. לָהֶֽם׃

    lahem · H9038

    to them · v4

    'To them', meaning to the idols and cult objects just destroyed. The Hebrew grammatically treats the objects as the receivers of worship.

  20. וְעַצְמוֹת֙

    ve'atsmot · H6106G

    and the bones of · v5

    Human skeletal remains, which under Israel's purity law were the strongest source of defilement (Num 19:16). The phrase comes first in the sentence, so the bones are the focus: 'the bones of priests, those he burned.'

  21. כֹּֽהֲנִ֔ים

    kohanim · H3548

    priests · v5

    In context these are the priests who had served at the Baal altars and shrines torn down in v. 4, not the temple priests of the LORD. The word has no article: literally 'bones of priests'.

  22. שָׂרַ֖ף

    saraf · H8313

    he burned · v5

    To burn up, destroy by fire. This is the word for burning to destroy or dispose of something, not the usual word for making an offering go up in smoke. It repeats the wording of the old prophecy against the Bethel altar (1 Kgs 13:2).

  23. וַיְטַהֵ֥ר

    vaytaher · H2891

    and he purified · v5

    The intensive form (piel), 'he made clean'. The verb is about ritual purity before God, and here it sums up the whole campaign of vv. 3–5. It picks up 'he began to purify Judah and Jerusalem' in v. 3.

  24. יְהוּדָ֖ה

    yehudah · H3063G

    Judah · v5

    The land and people of the southern kingdom, treated as a territory that can be polluted and then cleansed.

  25. יְרוּשָׁלִָֽם׃

    yerushalaim · H3389

    Jerusalem · v5, v7

    The capital and site of the temple. 'Judah and Jerusalem' is the Chronicler's standard pair for the whole kingdom, centred on the place where God was to be worshipped.

  26. וּבְעָרֵ֨י

    u-ve'arei · H5892

    and in the cities of · v6

    Opens with 'and in', so this verse carries on from the purge of Judah and Jerusalem in vv. 3–5. The verse has no verb of its own. The actions are understood from the verses before it (cutting down, burning, smashing) and are spelled out again in v. 7. 'Cities' (ʿir) covers any settlement with a wall or fortification, including small towns.

  27. מְנַשֶּׁ֧ה

    menashsheh · H4519

    Manasseh · v6

    The tribal territory of Manasseh in the central hill country and the Jezreel region. This was the heart of the old northern kingdom, which had been an Assyrian province since 722 BC. The name is also the name of Josiah's grandfather, King Manasseh (33:1–20). For the Chronicler it is the tribe that is meant here.

  28. וְאֶפְרַ֛יִם

    ve'efrayim · H669

    and Ephraim · v6

    The leading northern tribe. Its land included Bethel and the old royal centres. 'Ephraim' was often used as a name for the whole northern kingdom (e.g. Hosea).

  29. וְשִׁמְע֖וֹן

    veshim'on · H8095

    and Simeon · v6

    An unexpected name in a list of northern tribes. Simeon's land lay in the far south, in the Negev, inside Judah (Joshua 19:1–9). Naming it helps show that Josiah's reform reached all the tribes of Israel, not only the north. Chronicles also links Simeonites with Ephraim and Manasseh in Asa's day (15:9).

  30. וְעַד־

    ve'ad- · H5704

    and as far as, up to · v6

    Marks the outer limit: 'all the way to'. It tells the reader how far the reform reached.

  31. נַפְתָּלִ֑י

    naftali · H5321

    Naphtali · v6

    The northernmost tribal territory, in Upper Galilee west of the Sea of Galilee. Assyria took it first, in 733–732 BC (2 Kings 15:29). 'As far as Naphtali' means as far north as Israel's land went.

  32. (בחר בתיהם)

    [Ketiv: bḥr btyhm]

    written form, not read aloud · v6

    This is the consonantal text, written as two words. The supplied data shows it as an empty slot. It could be read as 'in the mountain, their houses' (be-har battêhem) or something like 'he searched their houses'. Neither makes good sense in context, and the Masoretes told readers to replace it with the next word.

  33. בְּחַרְבֹתֵיהֶ֖ם

    be-ḥarvoteihem · H2719

    with their swords/blades; or, in their ruins · v6

    The Masoretic vowels (pataḥ under the ḥ) make this the plural of ḥerev, 'sword, blade, cutting tool': 'with their blades'. In context that would mean the tools used to hack down the cult objects. KJV and YLT follow this reading. Change one vowel to ḥorvoteihem and it becomes 'in their ruins', meaning the towns still lying waste after the Assyrian conquest. Most modern versions take this reading.

  34. סָבִֽיב׃

    saviv · H5439

    all around, surrounding · v6

    'On every side'. It stresses how thorough the purge was. Josiah went through the towns and the countryside around them, not just a few chosen sites.

  35. כִּתַּ֣ת

    kittat · H3807

    to beat, crush, shatter by blows · v7

    "He smashed." The intensive form means beating something to pieces. Hezekiah did the same to the bronze serpent (2 Kgs 18:4), and Moses to the golden calf (Deut 9:21).

  36. וְכָל־

    wəkol- · H3605

    and all, every · v7

    "And all." It stresses that the purge was complete. The narrator makes the same point with the second 'all' a few words later.

  37. אֶ֣רֶץ

    ʾereṣ · H0776G

    land, country, earth · v7

    "The land of." Here it means a territory, the land that belongs to a people.

  38. יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v7

    "Israel." In context this means the old tribal territory as a whole, and especially the former northern kingdom (Manasseh, Ephraim, Naphtali, v. 6), which had been under Assyria since 722 BC. The Chronicler sees it as still part of one Israel.

  39. וַיָּ֖שָׁב

    wayyāšob · H7725G

    to return, turn back · v7

    "And he returned." It closes the tour. The king goes out from the centre, purges the land, and comes back to it.

The world behind it

Josiah's reform. Josiah reigned about 640–609 BCE. His grandfather Manasseh had reigned for 55 years and filled Judah with the cults of the Baals, Asherah and the "host of heaven" (2 Chr 33:3–7). Assyria, Judah's overlord, began to decline after Ashurbanipal's death (around 631 BCE), which gave Judah more room to change its religious life. In Chronicles, Josiah begins to "seek" God in his 8th year (about 632) and begins the purge in his 12th year (about 628). The temple repairs and the finding of the Book of the Law come later, in his 18th year (34:8–14).

Chronicles and Kings. The parallel account in 2 Kings 23:4–20 puts all of the purge after the book is found and describes it in much more detail. Chronicles compresses it, moves it earlier, and presents Josiah as a king who seeks God from his youth. Chronicles was written for Judeans living under Persian rule (probably 4th century BCE), and its "seeking" theme spoke to them directly.

Why the graves. Under Israelite purity law (Num 19:11–16), contact with a corpse, a bone or a grave caused the most severe kind of ritual impurity. Throwing the idols' dust there was not tidy disposal. It finally degraded them: whatever had been treated as holy was dumped where nothing holy could exist. Verse 5 goes further, saying Josiah burned the bones of the idolatrous priests on their own altars, which permanently defiled those sites.

The objects. Archaeology fits the list. Many small horned limestone altars have been found at Iron Age sites; the shrine at Arad had two incense altars. Asherah symbols appear in 8th-century inscriptions that bless "by YHWH and his asherah". Small cast-metal figurines and carved figures are common finds. These belonged to the ordinary religion of Judah, not only to foreigners.

From the study of 2 Chronicles 34:4.

Where scholars differ

in v4

What were the ḥammanim?

  • Incense altars (majority modern view)

    Palmyrene and Nabataean Aramaic inscriptions use ḥmn' for small altars. Many small horned incense altars have been found at Iron Age sites in Israel and Judah. The biblical texts pair ḥammanim with altars, and here they sit on top of them. This is the view of HALOT and most modern translations.

  • Small shrine or chapel

    A Phoenician inscription from Umm el-ʿAmed uses ḥmn for a structure dedicated to a deity. Ezekiel 6:4 in the Septuagint has 'precincts' (temenē).

  • Sun pillars or sun images

    A connection with ḥammah ('sun, heat'), followed in medieval Jewish exegesis and the KJV margin. Sun worship is attested in Josiah's purge (2 Kgs 23:5, 11). The etymology is uncertain, however, and there is no direct evidence for such objects.

  • Objects connected with the god Baal Hammon

    Similarity to the name of the Phoenician-Punic god Baal Hammon. This is suggestive, but no biblical text makes the link explicit.

in v4

When did Josiah's purge happen: before or after the law book was found?

  • Chronicles preserves a credible earlier phase

    Assyria's weakening around 630 BCE makes an early start plausible, and Josiah's age (about 20 in his 12th year) fits a king beginning to act on his own. Some scholars think reform happened in stages.

  • Chronicles rearranged the events for theological reasons

    Kings puts everything after the book's discovery in the 18th year (2 Kgs 22–23). Chronicles regularly shows good kings acting on their piety early, and its 'seeking God' theme drives the arrangement.

in v5

Does the verse imply that living priests were executed, or only that dead priests' bones were exhumed?

  • Only exhumed remains are meant.

    Chronicles speaks of 'bones', not killing, and its wording matches 2 Kgs 23:16, where bones are taken from tombs. The Chronicler leaves out the slaughter described in 2 Kgs 23:20, perhaps on purpose.

  • The verse compresses the fuller Kings account, which included executions.

    2 Kgs 23:20 says Josiah killed the priests of the high places on their altars and burned human bones on them. Readers who knew Kings would have filled in that detail.

in v5

When did the purge happen: Josiah's 12th year (Chronicles) or after the law book was found in his 18th year (Kings)?

  • The Chronicler reordered events for theological reasons.

    Chronicles likes to show that faithfulness comes before blessing. Placing the purge before the finding of the book shows Josiah's piety from his youth (Japhet; Williamson discusses the issue).

  • The reform really did happen in stages, beginning earlier.

    Assyria's grip weakened from the 630s–620s BC, which would have made an early start possible. Chronicles may preserve a memory of a gradual reform that Kings compressed into one event.

in v5

Who were 'the priests'?

  • Priests of the Baal and Asherah cults only.

    Verse 4 lists the Baal altars, incense altars, Asherah poles and images, and 'their altars' follows directly.

  • Priests of all unauthorised shrines, including local shrines to the LORD.

    Kings treats the 'priests of the high places' as one category (2 Kgs 23:8–9, 20), and Deuteronomy's ideal outlaws every altar outside the chosen place. Kings, though, spares the Judean high-place priests, so the bone-burning there is tied to the northern shrines.

in v6

Does the closing word mean 'with their blades/tools' or 'in their ruins'?

  • 'With their blades/tools' (Masoretic Qere as pointed; KJV, YLT)

    Keeps the received vowels. ḥerev can mean a cutting or stone-working tool (Exod 20:25; Josh 5:2). It fits the demolition verbs in vv. 4 and 7.

  • 'In their ruins' (vowel change to ḥorvoteihem; most modern versions)

    Fits the historical state of the north after Assyria's conquests. Phrases like 'their ruins round about' are natural Hebrew. Swords are odd tools for destroying cult objects.

  • The text is damaged and the original cannot be recovered

    The two-word Ketiv makes no clear sense. The Septuagint and Vulgate disagree with both readings. Scholars have proposed several different corrections.

in v6

How far did Josiah's reform actually reach into the north?

  • Broadly as Chronicles describes, with Assyria's withdrawal leaving a power vacuum

    Kings also records action at Bethel and in 'the cities of Samaria' (2 Kgs 23:15–20). Josiah was at Megiddo, in the north, when he died (2 Chr 35:22).

  • Mainly limited to Bethel and Judah's northern border; the wider list reflects the Chronicler's 'all Israel' ideal

    Archaeological evidence for Judean control far north is thin and disputed. Chronicles moves the reform earlier than Kings and sets it in a larger area, which fits the book's theological concerns.

in v7

What exactly were the ḥammānîm?

  • Incense altars

    A Palmyrene inscription names a small altar ḥmnʾ. Small horned incense altars are common at Iron Age sites, and 2 Chr 34:4 places the ḥammānîm 'above' the Baal altars, which fits small portable altars. This is the view of HALOT and most modern translations.

  • Sun-pillars or sun-images

    Derivation from ḥammâ, 'sun, heat', and a possible link to Baal-Hammon. It was favoured by older lexicons and the English Revised Version (1885), but has weaker support from objects and inscriptions.

  • Small shrines or chapels

    Some scholars (e.g. V. Fritz) read Palmyrene and Nabataean ḥmnʾ as a small sanctuary rather than an altar.

in v7

Did the reform happen in the order and extent Chronicles describes?

  • Chronicles reshapes the Kings account for theological reasons

    Kings puts the whole reform after the 18th-year discovery of the book. Chronicles moves the purge earlier to show Josiah's piety from youth and fits it to its 'all Israel' theme. This is a common view in critical commentaries (e.g. Japhet, Klein).

  • Chronicles preserves a plausible early phase

    Assyria's decline after c. 631 BC fits a reform beginning in Josiah's 12th year (c. 628 BC). Some (e.g. Williamson, cautiously) allow that the Chronicler had sources or a reasonable historical basis for a staged reform.

  • The northern reach is limited or idealised

    Archaeological evidence for Judean control in the north under Josiah is thin and disputed. The list of tribes in v. 6 (including Simeon, a southern tribe) may be more ideological than administrative.

Sources
  • HALOT s.v. חַמָּן
  • HALOT s.v. אֲשֵׁרָה
  • BDB s.v. דָּקַק, גָּדַע, נָתַץ
  • BDB s.v. בַּעַל
  • Septuagint (LXX), Lev 26:30; Ezek 6:4; 2 Chr 34:4
  • Vulgate, 2 Par 34:4
  • 2 Kings 23:4–20 (parallel account)
  • Deuteronomy 7:5; 9:21; 12:3; Leviticus 26:30; Numbers 19:11–16
  • Kuntillet ʿAjrud and Khirbet el-Qom inscriptions (YHWH and his asherah)
  • Ugaritic texts on Athirat and Baʿlu
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Chr 34
  • H. G. M. Williamson, 1 and 2 Chronicles (NCBC)
  • S. Japhet, I & II Chronicles (OTL)
  • BDB s.v. עֶצֶם, כֹּהֵן, שָׂרַף, טָהֵר
  • HALOT s.v. טהר, שׂרף, עֶצֶם
  • Sara Japhet, I & II Chronicles (OTL)
  • Ralph W. Klein, 2 Chronicles (Hermeneia)
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (AB), on corpse impurity
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Chr 34 and 2 Kgs 23
  • ANET: Ashurbanipal's annals on the desecration of the Elamite royal tombs
  • 1 Kgs 13:2; 2 Kgs 23:4–20; Num 19:16; Amos 2:1; Jer 8:1–2; Ezek 6:5; Lev 18:24–28
  • Masoretic Text (Leningrad Codex), Ketiv/Qere at 2 Chr 34:6
  • BDB s.v. חֶרֶב; s.v. חָרְבָּה
  • HALOT s.v. חֶרֶב; s.v. חָרְבָּה
  • Parallel account: 2 Kings 23:15–20
  • Joshua 19:1–9 (territory of Simeon); 2 Kings 15:29; 17:24
  • Standard commentaries on Chronicles (e.g. H. G. M. Williamson, Sara Japhet) on the textual crux and the Chronicler's 'all Israel' theme
  • BDB s.v. אֲשֵׁרָה, חַמָּן, כָּתַת, דָּקַק, נָתַץ, גָּדַע
  • HALOT s.v. חַמָּן ('incense altar'), אֲשֵׁרָה
  • Sara Japhet, I & II Chronicles (Old Testament Library)
  • H. G. M. Williamson, 1 and 2 Chronicles (New Century Bible)
  • Judith M. Hadley, The Cult of Asherah in Ancient Israel and Judah
  • Kuntillet ʿAjrud and Khirbet el-Qom inscriptions (Yahweh 'and his asherah')
  • V. Fritz, 'Die Bedeutung von hammān im Hebräischen und von hmn' in den palmyrenischen Inschriften', Biblische Notizen 15 (1981)
  • Septuagint and Vulgate of 2 Chronicles 34 and Leviticus 26:30, Isaiah 17:8
  • Supplied word-by-word source data (lemma, Strong's, morphology)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).