2 Kings Chapter 17 Read as one passage
2 Kings 17:3–7
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
3Shalmaneser king of Assyria attacked him, and Hoshea became his vassal and paid him tribute. 4But the king of Assyria discovered that Hoshea had conspired to send envoys to King So of Egypt, and that he had not paid tribute to the king of Assyria as in previous years. Therefore the king of Assyria arrested Hoshea and put him in prison. 5Then the king of Assyria invaded the whole land, marched up to Samaria, and besieged it for three years. 6In the ninth year of Hoshea, the king of Assyria captured Samaria and carried away the Israelites to Assyria, where he settled them in Halah, in Gozan by the Habor River, and in the cities of the Medes. 7All this happened because the people of Israel had sinned against the LORD their God, who had brought them out of the land of Egypt from under the hand of Pharaoh king of Egypt. They had worshiped other gods
What the first hearers heard
Kings was compiled for Israelites and Judeans who had lived through, or were living after, the catastrophes of 722 and 586 BC. To them this verse would have sounded like the beginning of the end. They knew exactly what "became his servant and rendered tribute" meant: a king without real independence, a treasury drained every year, and a sworn treaty whose breach would bring the empire's army.
The verse works as the first link in a chain of cause and effect: invasion → submission → tribute → secret dealings with Egypt → tribute withheld → imprisonment → siege → exile (vv. 3–6). The narrator then stops the story to give the deeper explanation (vv. 7–23). Israel's fall was not finally a failure of foreign policy. It was the outcome of Israel's long disloyalty to the LORD, its covenant overlord. The political vocabulary of this verse (servant, tribute, loyalty, breach) is the same vocabulary Israel's own covenant used. Readers trained in Deuteronomy could not miss the parallel: a nation that would not stay loyal to the LORD ended up as the tribute-paying servant of Assyria, and then lost even that.
For readers in Judah, the verse was also a warning. Their own kings would face the same choice between paying tribute and gambling on Egypt (2 Kgs 18:21; 24:1, 7).
From the study of 2 Kings 17:3.
Verse by verse
-
3Shalmaneser king of Assyria attacked him, and Hoshea became his vassal and paid him tribute.
Full study →It was against Hoshea that Shalmaneser, king of Assyria, marched up with his army. Hoshea then became his sworn vassal, a subject king bound to him by treaty, and he handed over to him the tribute he owed.
The Hebrew puts "against him" first. The sentence opens by pointing at Hoshea, Israel's king, as the target of the empire's campaign. "Came up" is the standard Hebrew phrase for an army marching out to war. "Became his servant" does not mean Hoshea took a job at the Assyrian court. It is treaty language: Hoshea accepted the status of a subordinate king under oath, with Assyria's great king as his master. "Rendered tribute" means he paid what was due. The verb is literally "caused to go back," the idiom for handing over the yearly payment a subject people owed its overlord (compare Moab paying Israel in 2 Kings 3:4). The word for tribute, minḥah, is the same word used elsewhere for a gift offered to a superior and for an offering at the altar. Israel's "offering" now goes to Nineveh.
The verse also sets up the next one through wordplay. Shalmaneser "came up" (ʿalah), and in verse 4 Hoshea stops "bringing up" (heʿelah) the tribute. When the payments stop, the army comes back.
-
4But the king of Assyria discovered that Hoshea had conspired to send envoys to King So of Egypt, and that he had not paid tribute to the king of Assyria as in previous years. Therefore the king of Assyria arrested Hoshea and put him in prison.
Full study →The king of Assyria found treason in Hoshea. Hoshea, the overlord's sworn vassal, had broken his oath. Behind Assyria's back he had already sent envoys to So, king of Egypt, looking for a rival power to lean on. He had also stopped sending up the annual tribute: the "gift" that every subject king carried up to his master's court year after year as a public sign of submission. Doing both was rebellion in the open. So the king of Assyria detained him, bound him and shut him up in a place of confinement.
A few things in the Hebrew sharpen the picture:
- "Found… in Hoshea" sounds like a verdict. The overlord examines his servant (verse 3 calls Hoshea his servant, a vassal) and finds him guilty.
- "Treason" (qesher) literally means a "binding together" against a ruler. It is the same word used in 15:30 for how Hoshea seized the throne from Pekah. He rose by conspiracy and fell for conspiracy, and the man who "bound together" a plot ends up bound himself.
- "Tribute" (minchah) is the word for a gift brought to a superior, which can also mean an offering to God. Here it was compulsory, and the verb "brought up" is the same verb used for offering sacrifices.
- The tenses look back: he had sent envoys and had stopped paying, so the arrest is the consequence of acts already done.
- The phrase "king of Assyria" is repeated four times, so the empire dominates every clause, while Egypt appears once, through a ruler so minor he is named nowhere else.
-
5Then the king of Assyria invaded the whole land, marched up to Samaria, and besieged it for three years.
Full study →Then the overlord himself, the great king of Assyria, went up to war. He swept through the whole of what was left of Israel's country, then climbed against Samaria, the fortified royal city on its hill. There he tied the city up in a siege: he surrounded it, cut it off, and squeezed it. Samaria held out into a third year.
The verse answers the verse before it. Hoshea, Assyria's sworn vassal, had stopped sending his yearly tribute 'up' to the king and had looked to Egypt for help. So the king of Assyria came 'up' himself, with an army instead of a tax collector. The repeated 'went up' narrows the scene step by step: first the countryside, then the capital. The verb 'besiege' draws on a root that means to bind or shut in, and every Israelite who knew the stories of earlier sieges of Samaria knew what that meant: hunger and slow despair behind the walls. The 'three years' is counted the ancient way, from Hoshea's seventh year to his ninth (2 Kings 18:9–10). That is parts of three years, a long siege that ended in the fall told in the next verse.
-
6In the ninth year of Hoshea, the king of Assyria captured Samaria and carried away the Israelites to Assyria, where he settled them in Halah, in Gozan by the Habor River, and in the cities of the Medes.
Full study →In the ninth year of Hoshea, the king of Assyria took Samaria. He drove Israel out of its land into exile in Assyria and resettled them: in Halah, near the Assyrian heartland; along the Habor, the river on which Gozan stands; and in the towns of the Medes, at the far eastern edge of the empire.
The verse is written like an entry in a royal chronicle: a date, then three quick actions. The king captured the city after a three-year siege (v. 5). He made Israel go into exile, using the verb whose root gives the later words for "the exile" and "the diaspora". He made them dwell in distant provinces, the term for planned imperial resettlement. The capital Omri built and his successors ruled from for about 150 years is gone in a single verb. The king on the throne at the end was named Hoshea, "salvation".
"Israel" here means the northern kingdom, not Judah. The destinations are real, identifiable places, spread hundreds of kilometres apart, so the people were broken up and absorbed into the empire. The verse is deliberately spare and gives no verdict. The explanation starts in the next verse: "All this happened because the people of Israel had sinned…" (v. 7).
-
7All this happened because the people of Israel had sinned against the LORD their God, who had brought them out of the land of Egypt from under the hand of Pharaoh king of Egypt. They had worshiped other gods
Full study →And so it came to pass, because the sons of Israel had wronged Yahweh, their own God. He is the One who brought them up out of the land of Egypt and lifted them out from under the hand, the grip and rule, of Pharaoh king of Egypt. And they gave their fear, their reverence, worship and loyalty, to other gods.
The verse is the narrator stepping back from the report of Samaria's fall (v. 6) to say why it happened. It is built like a charge of treason against a loyal subject who turned. First comes who the Lord is and what he did for them: he is their God, and he freed them from the most powerful king they had ever known. Then comes what they did in return: they gave the loyalty owed to him to rivals. "Sinned against" means a wrong done to a person in a relationship, the way a vassal "sins against" his overlord. "Feared" is not mainly about being afraid. It is the language of worship and allegiance, and the rest of the chapter keeps repeating it (vv. 25–41). The irony is sharp. A people once taken out from under one foreign king's hand are, as the chapter goes on to say, given back into foreign hands (v. 20) and carried out of their own land (v. 6). "Other gods" is the wording of the first commandment, which is how the narrator names the root of everything that follows. The sentence keeps going into the next verses, piling up charges that all grow from this one.
Where the English drifted
-
in v3
servant (KJV, WEB, YLT)
ʿeved
- What we hear
- A household employee or helper, or someone with a humble, serving attitude.
- What they heard
- A vassal king, the sworn political subject of an imperial overlord, obliged to pay tribute and stay loyal under a treaty oath.
-
in v3
presents (KJV), a present (YLT)
minḥah
- What we hear
- Voluntary, friendly gifts.
- What they heard
- Compulsory tribute paid each year by a subject king to his overlord as the sign and substance of submission.
-
in v4
present (KJV, YLT)
minchah
- What we hear
- A voluntary gift, given out of kindness or celebration.
- What they heard
- Compulsory annual tribute owed by a vassal king as a public sign of submission. It was called a 'gift' as a courtesy, but failing to pay it was an act of rebellion.
-
in v4
conspiracy
qesher
- What we hear
- A secret plot by a hidden group, or something out of a 'conspiracy theory.'
- What they heard
- Treason: a vassal 'binding himself' with others against his sworn overlord, here by secretly allying with Egypt and withholding tribute. It means betrayal of an oath of loyalty.
-
in v5
three years
shalosh shanim
- What we hear
- A full three-year period, about 36 months of siege.
- What they heard
- Parts of three regnal years counted inclusively, from Hoshea's 7th to his 9th year (2 Kings 18:9–10). The actual siege could have been considerably shorter than 36 months.
-
in v5
came up / went up
vayyaʿal
- What we hear
- Arrived, travelled, or showed up.
- What they heard
- The standard Hebrew term for launching a military attack, made sharper by Samaria's hilltop position and probably answering v.4, where Hoshea failed to 'bring up' tribute.
-
in v6
Israel
yisraʾel
- What we hear
- The Jewish people as a whole, or the modern State of Israel.
- What they heard
- The northern kingdom (often called 'Ephraim' or 'Samaria' by the prophets), politically separate from Judah since about 930 BC. Judah and Jerusalem are not included here and survived for another 135 years.
-
in v7
feared other gods (KJV, WEB, YLT)
vayyir'u 'elohim 'acherim
- What we hear
- They were afraid of other gods, frightened of their power.
- What they heard
- They gave other gods the reverence, worship and loyalty owed to Yahweh. 'Fear' with a god as object is the language of devotion and allegiance, though awe of the god's power is part of it.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v6
The 'lost ten tribes' didn't all vanish here
- What's often taught
- This verse records the moment the ten northern tribes were carried off wholesale to Assyria and disappeared from history, becoming the 'lost ten tribes' whose descendants must be searched for among distant peoples.
- What the text supports
The verse uses the national name Israel (yisraʾel) for the northern kingdom and says the Assyrian king deported (galah) and resettled (hoshiv) them in named provinces: Halah, Gozan on the Habor, and Media. Kings does frame the event in sweeping theological terms (17:18, 23), and the deportation was devastating. But the Bible itself shows northerners still in the land afterward. Hezekiah invites the remnant of Ephraim, Manasseh, Asher and Zebulun to Passover (2 Chr 30:1–11). Josiah's reforms reach the towns of Samaria (2 Kgs 23:15–20; 2 Chr 34:9). In the NT, Anna is 'of the tribe of Asher' (Luke 2:36). Sargon II's own records give about 27,290 deportees, out of a population usually estimated in the hundreds of thousands. Many northerners also seem to have fled south into Judah. Those deported were resettled in identifiable Assyrian provinces, where Assyrian documents later show people with Yahwistic names. The deportation was real and catastrophic, but it was not the disappearance of the whole population.
- Where the English feeds it
- 'Carried Israel away into Assyria' (KJV) can sound like the entire nation was packed up and removed. Readers who don't know that 'Israel' here is a political name for the northern kingdom easily take it as every member of ten tribes.
Every word
-
עָלָיו
ʿālāyw · H5921A
upon, against · v3, v5
"Against him." With a verb of going up, ʿal marks a hostile target. It comes first in the Hebrew sentence, so the spotlight falls on Hoshea as the one under attack.
-
עָלָה
ʿālāh · H5927G
go up, ascend · v3, v4, v5, v7
"Came up." Here it is the normal military idiom for marching out against a city or land, not a polite visit. The same root comes back in v. 4, where Hoshea fails to "bring up" (heʿelah) tribute.
-
שַׁלְמַנְאֶסֶר
shalmanʾeser · H8022
Shalmaneser · v3
Shalmaneser V of Assyria (reigned 727–722 BC), son and successor of Tiglath-pileser III. In Akkadian his name is Šulmānu-ašarēd, "the god Shulmanu is foremost."
-
מֶלֶךְ
melekh · H4428G
king · v3, v4, v5, v6, v7
"King of." It is a title in a possessive phrase ("king of Assyria"). The phrase "king of Assyria" comes up again and again in this chapter, and it stands for the empire's overwhelming power.
-
אַשּׁוּר
ʾashshur · H0804G
Assyria · v3, v4, v5, v6
The Mesopotamian empire whose heartland lay on the upper Tigris. In the 8th century BC it was the dominant power of the Near East and had already stripped Israel of most of its territory.
-
וַיְהִי
wayhi · H1961
be, become · v3, v7
"And (he) became / was." This is the normal Hebrew verb form for the next step in a story, so it presents Hoshea's submission as the direct result of the invasion.
-
לוֹ
lo · H9033
to him · v3
"To him," meaning Shalmaneser. With "be," the preposition marks belonging: Hoshea became Shalmaneser's servant, his political property.
-
הוֹשֵׁעַ
hoshēaʿ · H1954G
Hoshea · v3, v4, v6
The last king of the northern kingdom of Israel (c. 732–722 BC). The name means "(the LORD) saves" or "salvation" and is the same name the prophet Hosea bore. It is ironic that the king named "salvation" presides over the kingdom's end, though the text does not comment on it.
-
עֶבֶד
ʿeved · H5650
servant, slave, subject · v3
"Servant" in the language of treaties: a vassal king bound by oath to an overlord. It does not mean personal domestic service. It describes a political status that carried duties of loyalty and payment.
-
וַיָּשֶׁב
wayyāshev · H7725K
turn back; (causative) bring back, render, pay · v3
"And he rendered." This is the causative form of "return," so literally "he caused to go back": he handed over what was owed. The same idiom is used for Mesha of Moab paying tribute to Israel (2 Kgs 3:4). It implies a payment that was due, and probably a recurring one.
-
מִנְחָה
minḥāh · H4503I
gift, tribute, offering · v3, v4
"Tribute." This is the payment a subordinate owes a superior: silver, goods and produce, sent every year. The word can mean a gift or a grain offering elsewhere, but here it is the compulsory payment of a vassal.
-
וַיִּמְצָא
wayyimtsa · H4672
and he found · v4
'Found' in the sense of found out or detected. With 'in' plus a person it is the language of finding a fault in someone, as in 1 Samuel 29:3 ('I have found no fault in him'). It works almost like a verdict.
-
קֶ֗שֶׁר
qesher · H7195
conspiracy, treason · v4
From a root meaning 'to tie, bind together.' Here it means a vassal breaking his sworn loyalty: rebellion against the overlord, which amounts to treason.
-
אֲשֶׁר
asher · H0834A
which, in that · v4
Introduces what the conspiracy consisted of: 'in that he had sent…'. It explains rather than restricts.
-
שָׁלַח
shalach · H7971G
he sent · v4
The tense looks back to an earlier act: he had already sent the envoys before Assyria found out.
-
מַלְאָכִים
malakhim · H4397G
messengers, envoys · v4
Human diplomatic envoys carrying a message from one king to another. In other contexts the same word is used for angels as God's messengers, but nothing of that is in view here.
-
אֶל־
el · H0413
to · v4
Marks who the embassy went to.
-
ס֣וֹא
so · H5471
So · v4
An Egyptian ruler mentioned only here. Who he was is disputed (see debates). The most common view is Osorkon IV of Tanis, in the eastern Nile Delta.
-
מִצְרַ֔יִם
mitsrayim · H4714G
Egypt · v4, v7
The traditional rival power to the southwest. Kings of the Levant looked to it as a counterweight to Mesopotamian empires.
-
וְלֹא־
welo · H3808
and not · v4
Negates the next verb. The second charge is that he failed to pay.
-
כְּשָׁנָ֣ה
keshanah · H8141
as a year · v4, v5, v6
First half of the idiom 'as year by year.'
-
וַֽיַּעַצְרֵ֙הוּ֙
wayyaatsrehu · H6113
and he restrained him · v4
'Held him back, shut him up, detained him.' It describes taking Hoshea into custody. How and when this happened is debated.
-
וַיַּאַסְרֵ֖הוּ
wayyaasrehu · H0631
and he bound him · v4
'Tied, bound, imprisoned.' It can mean physical fetters and was the usual way of saying someone was put in custody. The man who had 'bound together' a conspiracy (qesher) is himself bound.
-
בֵּ֥ית
beit · H1004B
house of · v4
'House' in the sense of a building or place set apart for a purpose.
-
כֶּֽלֶא׃
kele · H3608
confinement, prison · v4
From a root meaning 'to shut in, hold back.' A 'house of confinement' is a place of detention, not a prison sentence in the modern sense. Jehoiachin's 'prison clothes' at the end of Kings (2 Kings 25:29) come from the same root.
-
בְּכָל־
bekhol- · H3605
all, the whole of · v5
"Into / throughout all." With the little word 'in' attached, it pictures the army moving through and over the whole territory, not only heading for one city.
-
הָאָ֑רֶץ
haʾarets · H0776
land, country, earth · v5, v7
"The land." This means the country of Israel. By 725 BC that was only the rump of the northern kingdom: the hill country around Samaria. Galilee, Gilead and the coast had already been made Assyrian provinces in 733–732 BC.
-
שֹׁמְר֔וֹן
shomron · H8111
Samaria · v5, v6
Samaria, the royal capital Omri had founded about 150 years earlier (1 Kings 16:24). Here it is the city itself, the last stronghold of the kingdom. Elsewhere the name can stand for the whole northern kingdom.
-
וַיָּ֥צַר
vayyatsar · H6696
bind, confine, besiege · v5
"And he besieged." The root idea is to shut in or hem in: to surround a city, cut off its food and water, and press it until it gives up or its walls are breached.
-
שָׁלֹ֥שׁ
shalosh · H7969
three · v5
"Three." By ancient counting this probably means parts of three calendar or regnal years, not a full 36 months (compare 18:9–10).
-
הַתְּשִׁיעִ֜ית
hattəshiʿit · H8671
the ninth · v6
Hoshea's ninth year, about 723/722 BC. The parallel account in 18:9–10 says the siege began in his seventh year and ended in his ninth, counting the first and last years in full.
-
לָכַ֤ד
lakhad · H3920
he captured · v6
To seize or take, as a city is taken after a siege. The same verb is used for trapping animals. Here it closes the three-year siege of 17:5.
-
אֶת־
ʾet- · H0853
[object marker] · v6, v7
An untranslatable particle that marks 'Samaria' as the definite object of the verb.
-
וַיֶּ֥גֶל
wayyegel · H1540K
and he exiled / deported · v6
A causative form of the verb 'uncover, go into exile': 'he made them go into exile'. This is the standard Hebrew term for forced deportation, and the root of golah/galut, the later words for 'the exile' and 'the diaspora'.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל
yisraʾel · H3478
Israel · v6, v7
Here this means the northern kingdom and its people, as opposed to Judah in the south. The national name stands for the population as a whole, but the Assyrian figures show that the deportation was large without being total.
-
וַיֹּ֨שֶׁב
wayyoshev · H3427
and he settled · v6
A causative form of 'sit/dwell': 'he made them dwell'. It describes planned resettlement, the second half of Assyrian deportation policy, and not imprisonment.
-
בַּחְלַ֧ח
baḥlaḥ · H2477
in Halah · v6
Probably Assyrian Ḫalaḫḫu, a district northeast of Nineveh in the Assyrian heartland.
-
וּבְחָב֛וֹר
uvḥavor · H2249
and on the Habor · v6
The Khabur River, a tributary of the Euphrates in what is now northeastern Syria. In Hebrew the preposition here means 'on' or 'by' a river.
-
נְהַ֥ר
nəhar · H5104H
river of · v6
It stands beside 'Habor' to explain it: the Habor is 'the river of Gozan'. So the river is the Habor, and Gozan is the city or district on it.
-
גּוֹזָ֖ן
gozan · H1470
Gozan · v6
Assyrian Guzana, the modern Tell Halaf. It was a provincial capital on the upper Khabur.
-
וְעָרֵ֥י
wəʿarê · H5892B
and cities of · v6
Towns or settlements. In context it probably means Assyrian-controlled centres in the newly conquered Median territory.
-
מָדָֽי׃
madai · H4074I
Media · v6
The land of the Medes in the Zagros mountains of western Iran. Sargon II conquered parts of it from about 716 BC, so settlement there probably came some years after Samaria fell. It lay at the far eastern edge of the empire, about 1,000 km from Samaria.
-
כִּֽי־
ki · H3588A
because, that, when · v7
Gives the cause: what happened in v. 6 happened because of what follows. It opens a long string of charges that runs on through the next verses.
-
חָטְא֤וּ
chat'u · H2398
to sin, to miss, to offend · v7
'They sinned / did wrong.' With 'against YHWH', it means offending a specific person you have a relationship with. It is a wrong done to someone, not only a broken rule.
-
בְנֵֽי־
venei · H1121G
sons, descendants · v7
'Sons of' Israel: the people seen as one family descended from the ancestor Jacob/Israel. They are guilty together, as a people.
-
לַיהוָ֣ה
la-YHWH · H3068G
to/against the LORD (Yahweh) · v7
The one they wronged is named by his personal name. The wrong is against him in person.
-
אֱלֹהֵיהֶ֔ם
'eloheihem · H0430G
their God · v7
'Their God': a God who belongs to them and they to him. That bond is what makes the wrong a betrayal.
-
מִתַּ֕חַת
mi-tachat · H8478K
from under · v7
'From under': being held down beneath someone's power. It is a picture of the people underneath and the ruler on top.
-
יַ֖ד
yad · H3027W
hand; power, control · v7
'Hand' is the usual Hebrew picture for power and control. 'Under the hand of Pharaoh' means under his rule.
-
פַּרְעֹ֣ה
Par'oh · H6547J
Pharaoh · v7
A title for Egypt's king, not a personal name. The oppressor is left unnamed.
-
וַיִּֽירְא֖וּ
vayyir'u · H3372H
and they feared, revered · v7
'And they feared' other gods, meaning they gave them the reverence, worship and loyalty that belonged to Yahweh. This same verb keeps coming back through the rest of the chapter (vv. 25, 28, 32–41).
-
אֲחֵרִֽים׃
'acherim · H0312
other, another · v7
'Other': gods besides Yahweh. This is the wording of the first commandment and of Deuteronomy, and it marks the charge as breaking the very first demand of the covenant.
The world behind it
Israel's last years under Assyria. By the time of this verse, the northern kingdom of Israel had already been cut down to a small state around the capital, Samaria. In 734–732 BC Tiglath-pileser III of Assyria had annexed Galilee, Gilead and the coastal plain and deported part of their population (2 Kgs 15:29). Hoshea came to power by assassinating King Pekah (2 Kgs 15:30). Tiglath-pileser's own inscriptions claim that he set Hoshea on the throne and took tribute from him. From the start, Hoshea was Assyria's man.
Change of emperor, test of loyalty. Tiglath-pileser died in 727 BC and his son Shalmaneser V succeeded him. In the ancient Near East a vassal's oath was sworn to a particular king, so the death of an overlord was a dangerous moment. Subject kings were expected to renew their submission, and many tested whether the new ruler was strong enough to enforce it. This verse records an Assyrian campaign against Hoshea and Hoshea's submission. That fits either a show of force early in Shalmaneser's reign or a response to wavering on Hoshea's part.
How vassalage worked. Assyria bound subject kings with treaties (Akkadian adê) sworn before the gods of both sides. The vassal kept his throne and some internal freedom. In return he paid annual tribute, supplied troops or provisions when demanded, and made no independent foreign alliances. Assyria typically dealt with a subject state in stages: first tribute-paying vassalage, then a reduced puppet kingdom after any rebellion, and finally annexation as a province with its population deported and replaced. Israel went through all three stages within about twenty years, and this verse shows the last vassal stage just before the final break.
What happens next. Verse 4 explains why this arrangement collapsed. Hoshea sent envoys to "So, king of Egypt," looking for an alliance against Assyria, and stopped the yearly tribute. Under treaty law that was rebellion. Shalmaneser imprisoned Hoshea, besieged Samaria for three years (vv. 5–6; 18:9–10), and the city fell in 722/721 BC. The Babylonian Chronicle credits Shalmaneser with destroying a city usually identified as Samaria. His successor Sargon II also claimed the conquest and the deportation of 27,290 people.
From the study of 2 Kings 17:3.
Where scholars differ
in v3
Does v. 3 describe a separate, earlier campaign from the siege in vv. 5–6, or is it a summary of the same events?
-
Two distinct episodes: an early campaign or show of force (c. 727–725 BC) that made Hoshea submit again, followed later by rebellion and the siege of Samaria.
The narrative sequence: v. 3 submission and tribute, v. 4 tribute paid "year by year" and then withheld, v. 5 invasion and three-year siege. The yearly payments in v. 4 require time between the two. Changes of overlord commonly triggered campaigns to reassert vassal oaths.
-
Vv. 3–6 compress one sequence of events (or combine two sources), and v. 3 summarises Hoshea's existing vassal status rather than a separate campaign.
Assyrian sources for Shalmaneser V's short reign are scant and record no early western campaign against Israel. Hoshea was already a tributary under Tiglath-pileser III. The parallel account in 18:9–10 mentions only the siege.
in v3
Who actually captured Samaria: Shalmaneser V or Sargon II?
-
Shalmaneser V took the city shortly before his death in 722 BC.
2 Kgs 17:5–6 and 18:9–10 name Shalmaneser as the besieger. The Babylonian Chronicle says he "ravaged Šamara'in," usually identified with Samaria.
-
Sargon II completed the conquest or reconquered the city (c. 720 BC) and carried out the mass deportation.
Sargon's inscriptions claim the conquest of Samaria and the deportation of 27,290 people. The vague "they captured it" in 18:10 and the unnamed "king of Assyria" in 17:6 leave room for a change of ruler.
in v4
Who was 'So, king of Egypt'?
-
Osorkon IV of Tanis (22nd Dynasty), with 'So' as a shortened form of (O)so(rkon).
His reign fits the dates (c. 730–715) and his location in the eastern Delta was the nearest to Israel. Sargon II's records mention a 'Shilkanni (Osorkon), king of Egypt' sending gifts about 716. K. A. Kitchen favoured this view, and it is widely accepted.
-
Tefnakht of Sais (24th Dynasty), reading 'So' as the city name Sais.
Tefnakht was the most dynamic Delta ruler in the 720s. Goedicke and others take סוא as a place name ('to Sais, the king of Egypt'). Weaknesses: it requires assuming a scribal error, and Sais was farther from Israel.
-
An Egyptian commander once read 'Sib'e' in Sargon's annals.
An older identification based on similar sounds. Most scholars now read the Assyrian name as Re'e, which undercuts it.
-
A Nubian ruler (Piye, or later Shabaka).
Piye was campaigning in Egypt around 728. Shabaka's reign is generally dated too late (c. 721/716 onward) for an embassy before Samaria's fall. Few hold this view today.
in v4
When and how was Hoshea arrested, given the three-year siege that follows?
-
Hoshea was seized before the siege, perhaps when he came to the Assyrian king to submit or explain himself, and Samaria held out without its king.
The plain order of verses 4–5. Vassals were often summoned to the overlord, and a summoned rebel could be detained. Commentators such as Cogan and Tadmor consider this scenario.
-
Verse 4 summarises the outcome and verses 5–6 go back to narrate the siege. Hoshea was taken when Samaria fell.
Hebrew narrative often gives the result first and then the details. Verse 6 dates the capture to 'the ninth year of Hoshea,' assuming he was still counted as king.
-
'Restrained him' means Hoshea was hemmed in or blockaded in his capital, not literally jailed at first.
Atsar can mean 'shut in, restrain'. But 'bound him in a house of confinement' points more naturally to actual custody, so this view is a minority one.
in v5
Which Assyrian king actually captured Samaria: Shalmaneser V or Sargon II?
-
Shalmaneser V besieged and took the city (about 722 BC), as Kings implies.
2 Kings 17:3–6 and 18:9–10 name Shalmaneser as the besieger and imply he took the city. The Babylonian Chronicle (Chronicle 1) says Shalmaneser 'ravaged Šamara'in', which most scholars, following H. Tadmor, identify with Samaria.
-
Sargon II captured it, or recaptured it after a revolt, around 720 BC.
Sargon's inscriptions (the Nimrud Prism and the Khorsabad texts) claim the conquest of Samaria, the deportation of 27,290 (or 27,280) people, and its reorganisation as a province. Many scholars (e.g. Tadmor, Becking) reconstruct two events: Shalmaneser took the city in 722 BC, then Samaria joined a western revolt in 720 BC and Sargon put it down. Others think Sargon claimed his predecessor's victory for himself, which Assyrian royal propaganda sometimes did.
in v5
How could Hoshea be imprisoned (v.4) before the siege of his capital (v.5)?
-
Hoshea was arrested first, and Samaria fought on without its king.
Read in order, v.4 has Hoshea seized and imprisoned. He may have gone out to meet Shalmaneser to make peace or pay a late tribute and been detained, a known Assyrian practice. The city then resisted on its own.
-
Verse 4 is a summary of Hoshea's fate, and his capture actually came at or after the fall of the city.
Hebrew narrative often gives a summary or outcome first and then tells the events (vv.5–6). The words for 'arrested' and 'imprisoned' could describe the end result rather than an earlier step.
in v6
Which Assyrian king captured Samaria, and when?
-
Shalmaneser V took the city in 722 BC, shortly before he died.
2 Kgs 17:3–5 and 18:9 name Shalmaneser as the one who besieged it. The Babylonian Chronicle says Shalmaneser 'ravaged Shamaraʾin', and Sargon's earliest inscriptions do not mention Samaria.
-
Sargon II took it in 720 BC, and his later claims are accurate.
Sargon's inscriptions repeatedly claim the capture and the deportation of about 27,290 people, and later the rebuilding of the city. The unnamed 'king of Assyria' in 17:6 and the plural 'they captured' in 18:10 leave room for a different king from the one named in 17:3.
-
There were two stages: Shalmaneser captured it in 722, and Sargon put down a renewed revolt in 720 and carried out most of the deportation.
Sargon records a western coalition, including Samaria, rebelling against him in 720 BC. This view, argued by Tadmor and refined by Becking and Younger, fits both the biblical and the Assyrian sources and is widely held.
in v6
How complete was the deportation?
-
It was severe and transformed the region, as the biblical framing suggests.
2 Kgs 17:18, 23 speak of Israel removed 'out of his sight' with only Judah left. Foreign groups were brought in to replace them (17:24). Surveys suggest rural settlement in parts of the Samaria hills declined.
-
It was large but partial, aimed mainly at the capital, the elite and the military.
Sargon's own figure (about 27,000) is a fraction of the estimated northern population. Chronicles shows a remnant of Ephraim and Manasseh still in the land under Hezekiah and Josiah (2 Chr 30:1–11; 34:9; compare 2 Kgs 23:15–20). Archaeologists also point to refugees swelling Jerusalem in the late 8th century.
in v7
How does 'And it was, because...' fit grammatically: does v. 7 explain v. 6, or begin a long sentence whose main point comes later?
-
It explains v. 6: 'This (the exile) happened because Israel sinned...'
Most English versions read it this way (BSB 'All this happened because'). The verse comes right after the deportation report, and the opening phrase can work as a summary statement of cause.
-
It opens a long 'when/because' clause running through vv. 7–17, and the main clause comes in v. 18 ('the LORD was very angry with Israel and removed them').
The run of 'and they did...' verbs continues the 'because' clause, and v. 18 opens with a fresh statement of Yahweh's response. Some commentators (e.g. Cogan & Tadmor, Anchor Bible) discuss this as a possible structure. Either way, the overall meaning is the same.
in v7
Is vv. 7–23 a single composition, or layered?
-
It contains layers: an earlier core explaining the north's fall, expanded during the exile to include Judah (vv. 19–20) and general covenant themes.
Verse 19 on Judah looks like an insertion. There are shifts between charges specific to Israel (Jeroboam's calves, vv. 21–23) and general Deuteronomic charges (vv. 7–17). Scholars who see multiple editions of the book of Kings (e.g. Cross, Nelson) point to these seams.
-
It is largely a single, deliberate theological reflection by one Deuteronomic writer.
The vocabulary is consistent, and there is a clear rhetorical progression from the Exodus (v. 7) to exile (v. 23). Some commentators read the Judah reference as part of the writer's intended warning rather than a later addition.
Sources
- BDB s.v. עָלָה, עֶבֶד, מִנְחָה, שׁוּב
- HALOT s.v. מִנְחָה; עֶבֶד
- Tiglath-pileser III, Summary Inscriptions (appointment of Hoshea; tribute), in COS 2.117
- Babylonian Chronicle 1 (ABC 1), reign of Shalmaneser V
- Sargon II, Nimrud Prism and Khorsabad Annals (Samaria)
- M. Cogan & H. Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible), on 17:1–6
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Kings 17:3–6
- S. Parpola & K. Watanabe, Neo-Assyrian Treaties and Loyalty Oaths (SAA 2)
- HALOT s.v. קֶשֶׁר, מִנְחָה, עצר, אסר, כֶּלֶא
- BDB s.v. קֶשֶׁר; מִנְחָה; סוֹא
- M. Cogan and H. Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible 11), on 2 Kings 17:1–6
- K. A. Kitchen, The Third Intermediate Period in Egypt (1100–650 BC), on So and Osorkon IV
- H. Goedicke, 'The End of "So, King of Egypt"', BASOR 171 (1963)
- Tiglath-pileser III summary inscriptions (installation of Hoshea), in COS / ANET
- Babylonian Chronicle 1 (Shalmaneser V and Samaria)
- Sargon II, Annals and Nimrud Prism (fall of Samaria; Osorkon/Shilkanni)
- Sefire treaty inscriptions (8th-century Aramaic vassal treaties)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Kings 17
- BDB and HALOT s.v. עָלָה, צוּר, שֹׁמְרוֹן
- M. Cogan and H. Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible 11), notes on 17:3–6 and 18:9–12
- H. Tadmor, 'The Campaigns of Sargon II of Assur', Journal of Cuneiform Studies 12 (1958)
- B. Becking, The Fall of Samaria: An Historical and Archaeological Study (1992)
- A. K. Grayson, Assyrian and Babylonian Chronicles, Chronicle 1 i 28
- K. L. Younger Jr., 'The Deportations of the Israelites', JBL 117 (1998)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 4 Kingdoms 17:5; Vulgate, 4 Regum 17:5
- HALOT s.v. גלה; BDB s.v. גָּלָה
- BDB s.v. לָכַד; s.v. יָשַׁב (Hiphil)
- M. Cogan & H. Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible), on 17:3–6 and 18:9–11
- K. L. Younger Jr., 'The Deportations of the Israelites', Journal of Biblical Literature 117 (1998)
- B. Oded, Mass Deportations and Deportees in the Neo-Assyrian Empire (1979)
- Sargon II, Great Display Inscription (Khorsabad) and Nimrud Prism
- Babylonian Chronicle 1 (ABC 1), i 28 on Shalmaneser V and Shamaraʾin
- S. Dalley, 'Foreign Chariotry and Cavalry in the Armies of Tiglath-pileser III and Sargon II', Iraq 47 (1985)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. חָטָא, עָלָה (Hiphil), יָד, תַּחַת, יָרֵא
- M. Cogan & H. Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible), on 2 Kgs 17:7–23
- W. L. Moran, 'The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy,' CBQ 25 (1963)
- K. Baltzer / D. J. McCarthy on treaty form and historical prologue
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) 4 Kingdoms 17:7
- Esarhaddon's Succession Treaty (SAA 2), loyalty vocabulary
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, 2 Kings 17
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).